The mechanism of inhibition of antibody-based inhibitors of membrane-type serine protease 1 (MT-SP1)

The mechanisms of inhibition of two novel scFv antibody inhibitors of the serine protease MT-SP1/matriptase reveal the basis of their potency and specificity. Kinetic experiments characterize the inhibitors as extremely potent inhibitors with K(I) values in the low picomolar range that compete with substrate binding in the S1 site. Alanine scanning of the loops surrounding the protease active site provides a rationale for inhibitor specificity. Each antibody binds to a number of residues flanking the active site, forming a unique three-dimensional binding epitope. Interestingly, one inhibitor binds in the active site cleft in a substrate-like manner, can be processed by MT-SP1 at low pH, and is a standard mechanism inhibitor of the protease. The mechanisms of inhibition provide a rationale for the effectiveness of these inhibitors, and suggest that the development of specific antibody-based inhibitors against individual members of closely related enzyme families is feasible, and an effective way to develop tools to tease apart complex biological processes.     

Noncovalent inhibitors of human leukocyte elastase based on the 4-imidazolidinone scaffold

A central problem associated with the design of enzyme inhibitors in general, and serine protease inhibitors in particular, is the identification of templates capable of binding to the active site of an enzyme in a predictable and substrate-like fashion, orienting appended recognition elements in a correct spatial relationship so that favorable binding interactions with multiple sites are achieved. Described herein for the first time is the design of noncovalent inhibitors of human leukocyte elastase that employs a functionalized 4-imidazolidinone scaffold.     

A reverse binding motif that contributes to specific protease inhibition by antibodies

The type II transmembrane serine protease family consists of 18 closely related serine proteases that are implicated in multiple functions. To identify selective, inhibitory antibodies against one particular type II transmembrane serine protease, matriptase [MT-SP1 (membrane-type serine protease 1)], a phage display library was created with a natural repertoire of Fabs [fragment antigen binding (Fab)] from human naïve B cells. Fab A11 was identified with a 720 pM inhibition constant and high specificity for matriptase over other trypsin-fold serine proteases. A Trichoderma reesei system expressed A11 with a yield of ～ 200 mg/L. The crystal structure of A11 in complex with matriptase has been determined and compared to the crystal structure of another antibody inhibitor (S4) in complex with matriptase. Previously discovered from a synthetic single-chain variable fragment library, S4 is also a highly selective and potent matriptase inhibitor. The crystal structures of the A11/matriptase and S4/matriptase complexes were solved to 2.1 Å and 1.5 Å, respectively. Although these antibodies, discovered from separate libraries, interact differently with the protease surface loops for their specificity, the structures reveal a similar novel mechanism of protease inhibition. Through the insertion of the H3 variable loop in a reverse orientation at the substrate-binding pocket, these antibodies bury a large surface area for potent inhibition and avoid proteolytic inactivation. This discovery highlights the critical role that the antibody scaffold plays in positioning loops to bind and inhibit protease function in a highly selective manner. Additionally, Fab A11 is a fully human antibody that specifically inhibits matriptase over other closely related proteases, suggesting that this approach could be useful for clinical applications.     

Fungal β-trefoil trypsin inhibitors cnispin and cospin demonstrate the plasticity of the β-trefoil fold

The recently identified fungal protease inhibitors cnispin, from Clitocybe nebularis, and cospin, from Coprinopsis cinerea, are both β-trefoil proteins highly specific for trypsin. The reactive site residue of cospin, Arg27, is located on the β2–β3 loop. We show here, that the reactive site residue in cnispin is Lys127, located on the β11–β12 loop. Cnispin is a substrate-like inhibitor and the β11–β12 loop is yet another β-trefoil fold loop recruited for serine protease inhibition. By site-directed mutagenesis of the P1 residues in the β2–β3 and β11–β12 loops in cospin and cnispin, protease inhibitors with different specificities for trypsin and chymotrypsin inhibition have been engineered. Double headed inhibitors of trypsin or trypsin and chymotrypsin were prepared by introducing a second specific site residue into the β2–β3 loop in cnispin and into the β11–β12 loop in cospin. These results show that β-trefoil protease inhibitors from mushrooms exhibit broad plasticity of loop utilization in protease inhibition.     

Suppression of HIV-1 protease inhibitor resistance by phosphonate-mediated solvent anchoring

The introduction of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) protease inhibitors (PIs) markedly improved the clinical outcome and control of HIV-1 infection. However, cross-resistance among PIs due to a wide spectrum of mutations in viral protease is a major factor limiting their broader clinical use. Here we report on the suppression of PI resistance using a covalent attachment of a phosphonic acid motif to a peptidomimetic inhibitor scaffold. The resulting phosphonate analogs maintain high binding affinity to HIV-1 protease, potent antiretroviral activity, and unlike the parent molecules, display no loss of potency against a panel of clinically important PI-resistant HIV-1 strains. As shown by crystallographic analysis, the phosphonate moiety is highly exposed to solvent with no discernable interactions with any of the enzyme active site or surface residues. We term this effect "solvent anchoring" and demonstrate that it is driven by a favorable change in the inhibitor binding entropy upon the interaction with mutant enzymes. This type of thermodynamic behavior, which was not found with the parent scaffold fully buried in the enzyme active site, is a result of the increased degeneracy of inhibitor binding states, allowing effective molecular adaptation to the expanded cavity volume of mutant proteases. This strategy, which is applicable to various PI scaffolds, should facilitate the design of novel PIs and potentially other antiviral therapeutics.     

Crystal structure of the thrombin-hirudin complex: a novel mode of serine protease inhibition.

Thrombin is a serine protease that plays a central role in blood coagulation. It is inhibited by hirudin, a polypeptide of 65 amino acids, through the formation of a tight, noncovalent complex. Tetragonal crystals of the complex formed between human alpha-thrombin and recombinant hirudin (variant 1) have been grown and the crystal structure of this complex has been determined to a resolution of 2.95 A. This structure shows that hirudin inhibits thrombin by a previously unobserved mechanism. In contrast to other inhibitors of serine proteases, the specificity of hirudin is not due to interaction with the primary specificity pocket of thrombin, but rather through binding at sites both close to and distant from the active site. The carboxyl tail of hirudin (residues 48-65) wraps around thrombin along the putative fibrinogen secondary binding site. This long groove extends from the active site cleft and is flanked by the thrombin loops 35-39 and 70-80. Hirudin makes a number of ionic and hydrophobic interactions with thrombin in this area. Furthermore hirudin binds with its N-terminal three residues Val, Val, Tyr to the thrombin active site cleft. Val1 occupies the position P2 and Tyr3 approximately the position P3 of the synthetic inhibitor D-Phe-Pro-ArgCH2Cl. Thus the hirudin polypeptide chain runs in a direction opposite to that expected for fibrinogen and that observed for the substrate-like inhibitor D-Phe-Pro-ArgCH2Cl.     

Structural basis of trypsin inhibition and entomotoxicity of cospin, serine protease inhibitor involved in defense of Coprinopsis cinerea fruiting bodies

Cospin (PIC1) from Coprinopsis cinerea is a serine protease inhibitor with biochemical properties similar to those of the previously characterized fungal serine protease inhibitors, cnispin from Clitocybe nebularis and LeSPI from Lentinus edodes, classified in the family I66 of the MEROPS protease inhibitor classification. In particular, it exhibits a highly specific inhibitory profile as a very strong inhibitor of trypsin with K(i) in the picomolar range. Determination of the crystal structure revealed that the protein has a β-trefoil fold. Site-directed mutagenesis and mass spectrometry results have confirmed Arg-27 as the reactive binding site for trypsin inhibition. The loop containing Arg-27 is positioned between the β2 and β3 strands, distinguishing cospin from other β-trefoil-fold serine protease inhibitors in which β4-β5 or β5-β6 loops are involved in protease inhibition. Biotoxicity assays of cospin on various model organisms revealed a strong and specific entomotoxic activity against Drosophila melanogaster. The inhibitory inactive R27N mutant was not entomotoxic, associating toxicity with inhibitory activity. Along with the abundance of cospin in fruiting bodies of C. cinerea and the lack of trypsin-like proteases in the C. cinerea genome, these results suggest that cospin and its homologs are effectors of a fungal defense mechanism against fungivorous insects that function by specific inhibition of serine proteases in the insect gut.     

Mastering the canonical loop of serine protease inhibitors: enhancing potency by optimising the internal hydrogen bond network

Background

Canonical serine protease inhibitors commonly bind to their targets through a rigid loop stabilised by an internal hydrogen bond network and disulfide bond(s). The smallest of these is sunflower trypsin inhibitor (SFTI-1), a potent and broad-range protease inhibitor. Recently, we re-engineered the contact β-sheet of SFTI-1 to produce a selective inhibitor of kallikrein-related peptidase 4 (KLK4), a protease associated with prostate cancer progression. However, modifications in the binding loop to achieve specificity may compromise structural rigidity and prevent re-engineered inhibitors from reaching optimal binding affinity.

Methodology/Principal Findings

In this study, the effect of amino acid substitutions on the internal hydrogen bonding network of SFTI were investigated using an in silico screen of inhibitor variants in complex with KLK4 or trypsin. Substitutions favouring internal hydrogen bond formation directly correlated with increased potency of inhibition in vitro. This produced a second generation inhibitor (SFTI-FCQR Asn₁₄) which displayed both a 125-fold increased capacity to inhibit KLK4 (K _i = 0.0386±0.0060 nM) and enhanced selectivity over off-target serine proteases. Further, SFTI-FCQR Asn₁₄ was stable in cell culture and bioavailable in mice when administered by intraperitoneal perfusion.

Conclusion/Significance

These findings highlight the importance of conserving structural rigidity of the binding loop in addition to optimising protease/inhibitor contacts when re-engineering canonical serine protease inhibitors.     

1,2,5-Thiadiazolidin-3-one 1,1 dioxide: a powerful scaffold for probing the S' subsites of (chymo)trypsin-like serine proteases

The 1,2,5-thiadiazolidin-3-one 1,1 dioxide scaffold (I) embodies a motif that allows it to dock to the active site of (chymo)trypsin-like proteases in a predictable and substrate-like fashion. Consequently, inhibitors derived from this heterocyclic scaffold interact with both the S and S' subsites of an enzyme. Exploitation of binding interactions with both the S and S' subsites of a target enzyme may lead to compounds with greatly enhanced enzyme selectivity and inhibitory potency. This preliminary report describes the use of a series of compounds having the heterocyclic scaffold linked to various amino acids to probe the S' subsites of human leukocyte elastase (HLE), proteinase 3 (PR 3), and cathepsin G (Cat G). For comparative purposes, a series of compounds derived from a related scaffold, isothiazolidin-3-one 1,1 dioxide (II), was also generated. Several of the compounds were found to be highly potent and selective time-dependent inhibitors of HLE, PR 3, and Cat G.     

Protein inhibitors of serine proteinases

Serine proteinases and their natural protein inhibitors belong to the most intensively studied models of protein-protein recognition. Protein inhibitors do not form a single group but can be divided into about 20 different families. Global structures of proteins representing different inhibitor families are completely different and comprise alpha-helical proteins, beta-sheet proteins, alpha/beta-proteins and different folds of small disulfide-rich proteins. Three different types of inhibitors can be distinguished: canonical (standard mechanism) inhibitors, non-canonical inhibitors, and serpins. The canonical inhibitor binds to the enzyme through the exposed and convex binding loop, which is complementary to the active site of the enzyme. The mechanism of inhibition in this group is consistently very similar and resembles that of an ideal substrate. Non-canonical inhibitors, originating from blood sucking organisms, specifically block enzymes of the blood clotting cascade. The interaction is mediated through inhibitor N-terminus which binds to the proteinase forming a parallel beta-sheet. There are also extensive secondary interactions which provide an additional buried area and contribute significantly to the strength and specificity of recognition. Serpins are major proteinase inhibitors occurring in plasma. Similarly to canonical inhibitors, serpins interact with their target proteinases in a substrate-like manner. However, in the case of serpins, cleavage of a single peptide bond in a flexible and exposed binding loop leads to dramatic structural changes.     

Structural basis of the endoproteinase-protein inhibitor interaction

Proteolytic enzymes are potentially hazardous to their protein environment, so that their activity must be carefully controlled. Living organisms use protein inhibitors as a major tool to regulate the proteolytic activity of proteinases. Most of the inhibitors for which 3D structures are available are directed towards serine proteinases, interacting with the active sites in a 'canonical' i.e. substrate-like manner via an exposed reactive site loop of conserved conformation. More recently, some non-canonically binding serine proteinase inhibitors directed against coagulation factors, in particular thrombin, a few cysteine proteinase inhibitors inhibitory towards papain-like proteinases, and three zinc endopeptidase inhibitors directed against metzincins and thermolysin have been characterised in the free and complexed state, displaying novel mechanisms of inhibition with their target proteinases. These different interaction modes are presented and briefly discussed with respect to the different strategies applied by nature.     

Metal mediated protease inhibition: design and synthesis of inhibitors of the human cytomegalovirus (hCMV) protease

A versatile synthetic route to a novel series of bis-imidazolemethanes designed to inhibit the hCMV protease has been developed and a series of potential metal binding inhibitors has been identified. In selectivity assays, the compounds were highly specific for CMV protease and showed no inhibition (IC50 > 100 microM) of other prototypical serine proteases such as trypsin, elastase, and chymotrypsin. Although the presence of free zinc ions was found to be an absolute requirement for the in vitro biological activity of this class of inhibitor, the potency of the inhibitors could not be improved beyond the micromolar level.     

A structural and thermodynamic escape mechanism from a drug resistant mutation of the HIV-1 protease

The efficacy of HIV-1 protease inhibition therapies is often compromised by the appearance of mutations in the protease molecule that lower the binding affinity of inhibitors while maintaining viable catalytic activity and substrate affinity. The V82F/I84V double mutation is located within the binding site cavity and affects all protease inhibitors in clinical use. KNI-764, a second-generation inhibitor currently under development, maintains significant potency against this mutation by entropically compensating for enthalpic losses, thus minimizing the loss in binding affinity. KNI-577 differs from KNI-764 by a single functional group critical to the inhibitor response to the protease mutation. This single difference changes the response of the two inhibitors to the mutation by one order of magnitude. Accordingly, a structural understanding of the inhibitor response will provide important guidelines for the design of inhibitors that are less susceptible to mutations conveying drug resistance. The structures of the two compounds bound to the wild type and V82F/I84V HIV-1 protease have been determined by X-ray crystallography at 2.0 A resolution. The presence of two asymmetric functional groups, linked by rotatable bonds to the inhibitor scaffold, allows KNI-764 to adapt to the mutated binding site cavity more readily than KNI-577, with a single asymmetric group. Both inhibitors lose about 2.5 kcal/mol in binding enthalpy when facing the drug-resistant mutant protease; however KNI-764 gains binding entropy while KNI-577 loses binding entropy. The gain in binding entropy by KNI-764 accounts for its low susceptibility to the drug-resistant mutation. The heat capacity change associated with binding becomes more negative when KNI-764 binds to the mutant protease, consistent with increased desolvation. With KNI-577, the opposite effect is observed. Structurally, the crystallographic B factors increase for KNI-764 when it is bound to the drug-resistant mutant. The opposite is observed for KNI-577. Consistent with these observations, it appears that KNI-764 is able to gain binding entropy by a two-fold mechanism: it gains solvation entropy by burying itself deeper within the binding pocket and gains conformational entropy by losing interaction with the protease.     

Crystallographic determination of the structures of human alpha-thrombin complexed with BMS-186282 and BMS-189090.

The crystallographic structures of the ternary complexes of human alpha-thrombin with hirugen (a sulfated hirudin fragment) and the small-molecule active site thrombin inhibitors BMS-186282 and BMS-189090 have been determined at 2.6 and 2.8 A. In both cases, the inhibitors, which adopt very similar bound conformations, bind in an antiparallel beta-strand arrangement relative to the thrombin main chain in a manner like that reported for PPACK, D-Phe-Pro-Arg-CH2Cl. They do, however, exhibit differences in the binding of the alkyl guanidine moiety in the specificity pocket. Numerous hydrophilic and hydrophobic interactions serve to stabilize the inhibitors in the binding pocket. Although PPACK forms covalent bonds to both serine and the histidine of the catalytic triad of thrombin, neither BMS-186282 nor BMS-189090 bind covalently and only BMS-186282 forms a hydrogen bond to the serine of the catalytic triad. Both inhibitors bind with high affinity (Ki = 79 nM and 3.6 nM, respectively) and are highly selective for thrombin over trypsin and other serine proteases.     

The crystal structure of guamerin in complex with chymotrypsin and the development of an elastase-specific inhibitor

Guamerin, a canonical serine protease inhibitor from Hirudo nipponia, was identified as an elastase-specific inhibitor and has potential application in various diseases caused by elevated elastase concentration. However, the application of guamerin is limited because it also shows inhibitory activity against other proteases. To improve the selectivity of guamerin as an elastase inhibitor, it is essential to understand the binding mode of the inhibitor to elastase and to other proteases. For this purpose, we determined the crystal structure of guamerin in complex with chymotrypsin at 2.5 Å resolution. The binding mode of guamerin on elastase was explored from the model structure of guamerin/elastase. Guamerin binds to the hydrophobic pocket of the protease in a substrate-like manner using its binding loop. In order to improve the binding selectivity of guamerin to elastase, several residues in the binding loop were mutated and the inhibitory activities of the mutants against elastase and chymotrypsin were monitored. The substitution of the Met36 residue for Ala in the P1 site increased the inhibitory activity against elastase up to 14-fold, while the same mutant showed 7-fold decreased activity against chymotrypsin compared to the wild-type guamerin. Furthermore, the M36A guamerin mutant more effectively protected endothelial cells against cell damage caused by elastase than the wild-type guamerin.     

Think Twice: Understanding the High Potency of Bis(phenyl)methane Inhibitors of Thrombin

Successful design of potent and selective protein inhibitors, in terms of structure-based drug design, strongly relies on the correct understanding of the molecular features determining the ligand binding to the target protein. We present a case study of serine protease inhibitors with a bis(phenyl)methane moiety binding into the S3 pocket. These inhibitors bind with remarkable potency to the active site of thrombin, the blood coagulation factor IIa. A combination of X-ray crystallography and isothermal titration calorimetry provides conclusive insights into the driving forces responsible for the surprisingly high potency of these inhibitors. Analysis of six well-resolved crystal structures (resolution 1.58-2.25 Å) along with the thermodynamic data allows an explanation of the tight binding of the bis(phenyl)methane inhibitors. Interestingly, the two phenyl rings contribute to binding affinity for very different reasons — a fact that can only be elucidated by a structure-based approach. The first phenyl moiety occupies the hydrophobic S3 pocket, resulting in a mainly entropic advantage of binding. This observation is based on the displacement of structural water molecules from the S3 pocket that are observed in complexes with inhibitors that do not bind in the S3 pocket. The same classic hydrophobic effect cannot explain the enhanced binding affinity resulting from the attachment of the second, more solvent-exposed phenyl ring. For the bis(phenyl)methane inhibitors, an observed adaptive rotation of a glutamate residue adjacent to the S3 binding pocket attracted our attention. The rotation of this glutamate into salt-bridging distance with a lysine moiety correlates with an enhanced enthalpic contribution to binding for these highly potent thrombin binders. This explanation for the magnitude of the attractive force is confirmed by data retrieved by a Relibase search of several thrombin-inhibitor complexes deposited in the Protein Data Bank exhibiting similar molecular features.Special attention was attributed to putative changes in the protonation states of the interaction partners. For this purpose, two analogous inhibitors differing mainly in their potential to change the protonation state of a hydrogen-bond donor functionality were compared. Buffer dependencies of the binding enthalpy associated with complex formation could be traced by isothermal titration calorimetry, which revealed, along with analysis of the crystal structures (resolution 1.60 and 1.75 Å), that a virtually compensating proton interchange between enzyme, inhibitor and buffer is responsible for the observed buffer-independent thermodynamic signatures.     

Prime site binding inhibitors of a serine protease: NS3/4A of hepatitis C virus

Serine proteases are the most studied class of proteolytic enzymes and a primary target for drug discovery. Despite the large number of inhibitors developed so far, very few make contact with the prime site of the enzyme, which constitutes an almost untapped opportunity for drug design. In the course of our studies on the serine protease NS3/4A of hepatitis C virus (HCV), we found that this enzyme is an excellent example of both the opportunities and the challenges of such design. We had previously reported on two classes of peptide inhibitors of the enzyme: (a) product inhibitors, which include the P(6)-P(1) region of the substrate and derive much of their binding energy from binding of their C-terminal carboxylate in the active site, and (b) decapeptide inhibitors, which span the S(6)-S(4)' subsites of the enzyme, whose P(2)'-P(4)' tripeptide fragment crucially contributes to potency. Here we report on further work, which combined the key binding elements of the two series and led to the development of inhibitors binding exclusively to the prime site of NS3/4A. We prepared a small combinatorial library of tripeptides, capped with a variety of constrained and unconstrained diacids. The SAR was derived from multiple analogues of the initial micromolar lead. Binding of the inhibitor(s) to the enzyme was further characterized by circular dichroism, site-directed mutagenesis, a probe displacement assay, and NMR to unequivocally prove that, according to our design, the bound inhibitor(s) occupies (occupy) the S' subsite and the active site of the protease. In addition, on the basis of the information collected, the tripeptide series was evolved toward reduced peptide character, reduced molecular weight, and higher potency. Beyond their interest as HCV antivirals, these compounds represent the first example of prime site inhibitors of a serine protease. We further suggest that the design of an inhibitor with an analogous binding mode may be possible for other serine proteases.     

Discovery of inhibitors of the channel-activating protease prostasin (CAP1/PRSS8) utilizing structure-based design

Structure-based design was utilized to guide the early stage optimization of a substrate-like inhibitor to afford potent peptidomimetic inhibitors of the channel-activating protease prostasin. The first X-ray crystal structures of prostasin with small molecule inhibitors bound to the active site are also reported.     

Long-range Electrostatic Complementarity Governs Substrate Recognition by Human Chymotrypsin C,a Key Regulator of Digestive Enzyme Activation

Human chymotrypsin C (CTRC) is a pancreatic serine protease that regulates activation and degradation of trypsinogens and procarboxypeptidases by targeting specific cleavage sites within their zymogen precursors. In cleaving these regulatory sites, which are characterized by multiple flanking acidic residues, CTRC shows substrate specificity that is distinct from that of other isoforms of chymotrypsin and elastase. Here, we report the first crystal structure of active CTRC, determined at 1.9-Å resolution, revealing the structural basis for binding specificity. The structure shows human CTRC bound to the small protein protease inhibitor eglin c, which binds in a substrate-like manner filling the S₆-S₅′ subsites of the substrate binding cleft. Significant binding affinity derives from burial of preferred hydrophobic residues at the P₁, P₄, and P₂′ positions of CTRC, although acidic P₂′ residues can also be accommodated by formation of an interfacial salt bridge. Acidic residues may also be specifically accommodated in the P₆ position. The most unique structural feature of CTRC is a ring of intense positive electrostatic surface potential surrounding the primarily hydrophobic substrate binding site. Our results indicate that long-range electrostatic attraction toward substrates of concentrated negative charge governs substrate discrimination, which explains CTRC selectivity in regulating active digestive enzyme levels.     

Conformational lability in serine protease active sites: structures of hepatocyte growth factor activator (HGFA) alone and with the inhibitory domain from HGFA inhibitor-1B

Hepatocyte growth factor activator (HGFA) is a serine protease that converts hepatocyte growth factor (HGF) into its active form. When activated HGF binds its cognate receptor Met, cellular signals lead to cell growth, differentiation, and migration, activities which promote tissue regeneration in liver, kidney and skin. Intervention in the conversion of HGF to its active form has the potential to provide therapeutic benefit where HGF/Met activity is associated with tumorigenesis. To help identify ways to moderate HGF/Met effects, we have determined the molecular structure of the protease domain of HGFA. The structure we determined, at 2.7 A resolution, with no pseudo-substrate or inhibitor bound is characterized by an unconventional conformation of key residues in the enzyme active site. In order to find whether this apparently non-enzymatically competent arrangement would persist in the presence of a strongly-interacting inhibitor, we also have determined, at 2.6 A resolution, the X-ray structure of HGFA complexed with the first Kunitz domain (KD1) from the physiological inhibitor hepatocyte growth factor activator inhibitor 1B (HAI-1B). In this complex we observe a rearranged substrate binding cleft that closely mirrors the cleft of other serine proteases, suggesting an extreme conformational dynamism. We also characterize the inhibition of 16 serine proteases by KD1, finding that the previously reported enzyme specificity of the intact extracellular region of HAI-1B resides in KD1 alone. We find that HGFA, matriptase, hepsin, plasma kallikrein and trypsin are potently inhibited, and use the complex structure to rationalize the structural basis of these results.