Troponin T isoforms and posttranscriptional modifications: Evolution, regulation and function

Troponin-mediated Ca²⁺-regulation governs the actin-activated myosin motor function which powers striated (skeletal and cardiac) muscle contraction. This review focuses on the structure–function relationship of troponin T, one of the three protein subunits of the troponin complex. Molecular evolution, gene regulation, alternative RNA splicing, and posttranslational modifications of troponin T isoforms in skeletal and cardiac muscles are summarized with emphases on recent research progresses. The physiological and pathophysiological significances of the structural diversity and regulation of troponin T are discussed for impacts on striated muscle function and adaptation in health and diseases.     

Preserved Close Linkage Between the Genes Encoding Troponin I and Troponin T, Reflecting an Evolution of Adapter Proteins Coupling the Ca2+ Signaling of Contractility

Ca²⁺-regulated motility is essential to numerous cellular functions, including muscle contraction. Systems with troponin C, myosin light chain, or calmodulin as the Ca²⁺ receptor have evolved in striated muscle and other types of cells to transduce the cytoplasm Ca²⁺ signals into allosteric conformational changes of contractile proteins. While these Ca²⁺ receptors are homologous proteins, their coupling to the responding elements is quite different in various cell types. The Ca²⁺ regulatory system in vertebrate striated muscle represents a highly specialized such signal transduction pathway consisting of the troponin complex and tropomyosin associated with the actin filament. To understand the molecular mechanism in the Ca²⁺ regulation of muscle contraction and cell motility, we have revealed a preserved ancestral close linkage between the genes encoding two of the troponin subunits, troponin I and troponin T, in the genome of mouse. The data suggest that the troponin I and troponin T genes may have originated from a single locus and evolved in parallel to encode a striated muscle-specific adapter to couple the Ca²⁺ receptor, troponin C, to the actin–myosin contractile machinery. This hypothesis views the three troponin subunits as two structure–function domains: the Ca²⁺ receptor and the signal transducing adapter. This model may help to further our understanding of the Ca²⁺ regulation of muscle contraction and the structure–function relationship of other potential adapter proteins which are converged to constitute the Ca²⁺ signal transduction pathways governing nonmuscle cell motility. Received: 15 April 1999 / Accepted: 15 July 1999     

Structure–function relationships of molluscan troponin T revealed by limited proteolysis

Molluscan troponin regulates muscle contraction through a novel Ca²⁺-dependent activating mechanism associated with Ca²⁺-binding to the C-terminal domain of troponin C. To elucidate the further details of this regulation, we performed limited chymotryptic digestion of the troponin complex from akazara scallop striated muscle. The results indicated that troponin T is very susceptible to the protease, compared to troponin C or troponin I. The cleavage occurred at the C-terminal extension, producing an N-terminal 33-kDa fragment and a C-terminal 6-kDa fragment. This extension is conserved in various invertebrate troponin T proteins, but not in vertebrate troponin T. A ternary complex composed of the 33-kDa fragment of troponin T, troponin I, and troponin C could be separated from the 6-kDa troponin T fragment by gel filtration. This complex did not show any Ca²⁺-dependent activation of the Mg-ATPase activity of rabbit-actomyosin–scallop-tropomyosin. In addition, the actin–tropomyosin-binding affinity of this complex was significantly decreased with increasing Ca²⁺ concentration. These results indicate that the C-terminal extension of molluscan troponin T plays a role in anchoring the troponin complex to actin–tropomyosin filaments and is essential for regulation.     

Calcium-regulated conformational change in the C-terminal end segment of troponin I and its binding to tropomyosin

The troponin complex plays an essential role in the thin filament regulation of striated muscle contraction. Of the three subunits of troponin, troponin I (TnI) is the actomyosin ATPase inhibitory subunit and its effect is released upon Ca(2+) binding to troponin C. The exon-8-encoded C-terminal end segment represented by the last 24 amino acids of cardiac TnI is highly conserved and is critical to the inhibitory function of troponin. Here, we investigated the function and calcium regulation of the C-terminal end segment of TnI. A TnI model molecule was labeled with Alexa Fluor 532 at a Cys engineered at the C-terminal end and used to reconstitute the tertiary troponin complex. A Ca(2+) -regulated conformational change in the C-terminus of TnI was shown by a sigmoid-shape fluorescence intensity titration curve similar to that of the CD calcium titration curve of troponin C. Such corresponding Ca(2+) responses are consistent with the function of troponin as a coordinated molecular switch. Reconstituted troponin complex containing a mini-troponin T lacking its two tropomyosin-binding sites showed a saturable binding to tropomyosin at pCa 9 but not at pCa 4. This Ca(2+) -regulated binding was diminished when the C-terminal 19 amino acids of cardiac TnI were removed. These results provided novel evidence for suggesting that the C-terminal end segment of TnI participates in the Ca(2+) regulation of muscle thin filament through interaction with tropomyosin.     

Structure and dynamics of the C-domain of human cardiac troponin C in complex with the inhibitory region of human cardiac troponin I

Cardiac troponin C is the Ca2+-dependent switch for heart muscle contraction. Troponin C is associated with various other proteins including troponin I and troponin T. The interaction between the subunits within the troponin complex is of critical importance in understanding contractility. Following a Ca2+ signal to begin contraction, the inhibitory region of troponin I comprising residues Thr128-Arg147 relocates from its binding surface on actin to troponin C, triggering movement of troponin-tropomyosin within the thin filament and thereby freeing actin-binding site(s) for interactions with the myosin ATPase of the thick filament to generate the power stroke. The structure of calcium-saturated cardiac troponin C (C-domain) in complex with the inhibitory region of troponin I was determined using multinuclear and multidimensional nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. The structure of this complex reveals that the inhibitory region adopts a helical conformation spanning residues Leu134-Lys139, with a novel orientation between the E- and H-helices of troponin C, which is largely stabilized by electrostatic interactions. By using isotope labeling, we have studied the dynamics of the protein and peptide in the binary complex. The structure of this inhibited complex provides a framework for understanding into interactions within the troponin complex upon heart contraction.     

Exon skipping in cardiac troponin T of turkeys with inherited dilated cardiomyopathy

Troponin T is a central component of the thin filament-associated troponin-tropomyosin system and plays an essential role in the Ca(2+) regulation of striated muscle contraction. The importance of the structure and function of troponin T is evident in the regulated isoform expression during development and the point mutations resulting in familial hypertrophic and dilated cardiomyopathies. We report here that turkeys with inherited dilated cardiomyopathy and heart failure express an unusual low molecular weight cardiac troponin T missing 11 amino acids due to the splice out of the normally conserved exon 8-encoded segment. The deletion of a 9-bp segment from intron 7 of the turkey cardiac troponin T gene may be responsible for the weakened splicing of the downstream exon 8 during mRNA processing. The exclusion of the exon 8-encoded segment results in conformational changes in cardiac troponin T, an altered binding affinity for troponin I and tropomyosin, and an increased calcium sensitivity of the actomyosin ATPase. Expression of the exon 8-deleted cardiac troponin T prior to the development of cardiomyopathy in turkeys indicates a novel RNA splicing disease and provides evidence for the role of troponin T structure-function variation in myocardial pathogenesis and heart failure.     

Interaction of cardiac troponin with cardiotonic drugs: a structural perspective

Over the 40 years since its discovery, many studies have focused on understanding the role of troponin as a myofilament based molecular switch in regulating the Ca²⁺-dependent activation of striated muscle contraction. Recently, studies have explored the role of cardiac troponin as a target for cardiotonic agents. These drugs are clinically useful for treating heart failure, a condition in which the heart is no longer able to pump enough blood to other organs. These agents act via a mechanism that modulates the Ca²⁺-sensitivity of troponin; such a mode of action is therapeutically desirable because intracellular Ca²⁺ concentration is not perturbed, preserving the regulation of other Ca²⁺-based signaling pathways. This review describes molecular details of the interaction of cardiac troponin with a variety of cardiotonic drugs. We present recent structural work that has identified the docking sites of several cardiotonic drugs in the troponin C-troponin I interface and discuss their relevance in the design of troponin based drugs for the treatment of heart disease.     

The Calcium-Saturated cTnI/cTnC Complex: Structure of the Inhibitory Region of cTnI

The contiguous inhibitory and regulatory regions of troponin I in the heterotrimeric troponin complex play a critical role in Ca²⁺ activation of striated muscle. Knowledge of the structure of this critical region within the complex will enhance efforts toward understanding regulatory mechanisms. Toward this goal, we have used simulated annealing to study the structure of the inhibitory and regulatory regions of cardiac muscle troponin I in the calcium-saturated complex formed between cardiac troponin C and cardiac troponin I. We have incorporated distances determined experimentally by Förster resonance energy transfer in the full-length complex, rather than using peptides derived from cTnI. For these models, we assume a helix-loop-helix conformation for the inhibitory region. We have found several structures that satisfy the experimental constraints fairly well. Although it is not possible to eliminate any of these models at this time, future studies with additional experimental restraints will yield insights on the mechanisms of calcium regulation in cardiac muscle.     

Structure-function relationships of molluscan troponin T revealed by limited proteolysis

Molluscan troponin regulates muscle contraction through a novel Ca(2+)-dependent activating mechanism associated with Ca(2+)-binding to the C-terminal domain of troponin C. To elucidate the further details of this regulation, we performed limited chymotryptic digestion of the troponin complex from akazara scallop striated muscle. The results indicated that troponin T is very susceptible to the protease, compared to troponin C or troponin I. The cleavage occurred at the C-terminal extension, producing an N-terminal 33-kDa fragment and a C-terminal 6-kDa fragment. This extension is conserved in various invertebrate troponin T proteins, but not in vertebrate troponin T. A ternary complex composed of the 33-kDa fragment of troponin T, troponin I, and troponin C could be separated from the 6-kDa troponin T fragment by gel filtration. This complex did not show any Ca(2+)-dependent activation of the Mg-ATPase activity of rabbit-actomyosin-scallop-tropomyosin. In addition, the actin-tropomyosin-binding affinity of this complex was significantly decreased with increasing Ca(2+) concentration. These results indicate that the C-terminal extension of molluscan troponin T plays a role in anchoring the troponin complex to actin-tropomyosin filaments and is essential for regulation.     

Role of regulatory proteins (troponin-tropomyosin) in pathologic states

In vertebrate striated muscle, troponon-tropomyosin is responsible, in part, not only for transducing the effect of calcium on contractile protein activation, but also for inhibiting actin and myosin interaction when calcium is absent. The regulatory troponin (Tn) complex displays several molecular and calcium binding variations in cardiac muscles of different species and undergoes genetic changes with development and in various pathologic states.Extensive reviews on the role of tropomyosin (Tm) and Tn in the regulation of striated muscle contraction have been published describing the molecular mechanisms involved in contractile protein regulation. In our studies, we have found an increase in Mg²⁺ ATPase activity in cardiac myofibrils from dystrophic hamsters and in rats with chronic coronary artery narrowing. The abnormalities in myofibrillar ATPase activity from cardiomyopathic hamsters were largely corrected by recombining the preparations with a TnTm, complex isolated from normal hamsters indicating that the TnTm, may play a major role in altered myocardial function. We have also observed down regulation of Ca²⁺ Mg²⁺ ATPase of myofibrils from hypertrophic guinea pig hearts, myocardial infarcted rats and diabetic-hypertensive rat hearts. In myosin from diabetic rats, this abnormality was substantially corrected by adding troponin-tropomyosin complex from control hearts. All of these disease models are associated with decreased ATPase activities of pure myosin and in the case of rat and hamster models, shifts of myosin, heavy chain from alpha to beta predominate.In summary, there are three main troponin subunit components which might alter myofibrillar function however, very few direct links of molecular alterations in the regulatory proteins to physiologic and pathologic function have been demonstrated so far.     

Role of troponin I isoform switching in determining the pH sensitivity of Ca(2+) regulation in developing rabbit cardiac muscle

Skinned muscle fibers prepared from fetal rabbit heart (28 days of gestation) showed a marked resistance to acidic pH in the Ca(2+) regulation of force generation, compared to the fibers prepared from adult heart. SDS-PAGE and immunoblot analysis showed that the slow skeletal troponin I was predominantly expressed in the fetal cardiac muscle, while the cardiac isoform was predominantly expressed in the adult cardiac muscle. Direct exchange of purified slow skeletal and cardiac troponin I isoforms into these skinned muscle fibers revealed that cardiac troponin I made the Ca(2+) regulation of contraction sensitive to acidic pH just as in the adult fibers, whereas slow skeletal troponin I made the Ca(2+) regulation of contraction resistant to acidic pH just as in the fetal fibers. These results demonstrate that the troponin I isoform switching accounts fully for the change in the pH dependence of Ca(2+) regulation of contraction in developmental cardiac muscle.     

Structural evidence for co-evolution of the regulation of contraction and energy production in skeletal muscle

Skeletal muscle phosphorylase kinase (PhK) is a Ca²⁺-dependent enzyme complex, (αβγδ)₄, with the δ subunit being tightly bound endogenous calmodulin (CaM). The Ca²⁺-dependent activation of glycogen phosphorylase by PhK couples muscle contraction with glycogen breakdown in the “excitation-contraction-energy production triad.” Although the Ca²⁺-dependent protein-protein interactions among the relevant contractile components of muscle are well characterized, such interactions have not been previously examined in the intact PhK complex. Here we show that zero-length cross-linking of the PhK complex produces a covalent dimer of its catalytic γ and CaM subunits. Utilizing mass spectrometry, we determined the residues cross-linked to be in an EF hand of CaM and in a region of the γ subunit sharing high sequence similarity with the Ca²⁺-sensitive molecular switch of troponin I that is known to bind actin and troponin C, a homolog of CaM. Our findings represent an unusual binding of CaM to a target protein and supply an explanation for the low Ca²⁺ stoichiometry of PhK that has been reported. They also provide direct structural evidence supporting co-evolution of the coordinate regulation by Ca²⁺ of contraction and energy production in muscle through the sharing of a common structural motif in troponin I and the catalytic subunit of PhK for their respective interactions with the homologous Ca²⁺-binding proteins troponin C and CaM.     

Troponin: regulatory function and disorders

Study of the molecular biology of the calcium regulation of muscle contraction was initiated by Professor Ebashi’s discovery of a protein factor that sensitized actomyosin to calcium ions. This protein factor was separated into two proteins: tropomyosin and a novel protein named troponin. Troponin is a Ca²⁺-receptive protein for the Ca²⁺-regulation of muscle contraction and, in association with tropomyosin, sensitizes actomyosin to Ca²⁺. Troponin forms an ordered regulatory complex with tropomyosin in the thin filament. Several regulatory properties of troponin, which is composed of three different components, troponins C, I, and T, are discussed in this article. Genetic studies have revealed that many mutations of genes for troponin components, especially troponins T and I, are involved in the three types of inherited cardiomyopathy. Results of functional analyses indicate that changes in the Ca²⁺-sensitivity caused by troponin mutations are the critical functional consequences leading to these disorders. Recent results of this pathophysiological aspect of troponin are also discussed.     

A pH-sensitive interaction of troponin I with troponin C coupled with strongly binding cross-bridges in cardiac myofilament activation

Slow skeletal muscle troponin I (ssTnI) expressed predominantly in perinatal heart confers a marked resistance to acidic pH on Ca(2+) regulation of cardiac muscle contraction. To explore the molecular mechanism underlying this phenomenon, we investigated the roles of TnI isoforms (ssTnI and cardiac TnI (cTnI)) in the thin filament activation by strongly binding cross-bridges, by exchanging troponin subunits in cardiac permeabilized muscle fibers. Fetal cardiac muscle showed a marked resistance to acidic pH in activation of the thin filament by strongly binding cross-bridges compared to adult muscle. Exchanging ssTnI into adult fibers altered the pH sensitivity from adult to fetal type, indicating that ssTnI also confers a marked resistance to acidic pH on the cross-bridge-induced thin filament activation. However, the adult fibers containing ssTnI or cTnI but lacking TnC showed no pH sensitivity. These findings provide the first evidence for the coupling between strongly binding cross-bridges and a pH-sensitive interaction of TnI with TnC in cardiac muscle contraction, as a molecular basis of the mechanism conferring the differential pH sensitivity on Ca(2+) regulation.     

Interaction of calmodulin with troponin I and the troponin-tropomyosin-actin complex. Effect of Ca2+ and Sr2+ ions.

In an effort to elucidate the mechanism of calmodulin regulation of muscle contraction, we investigated the interaction between calmodulin and troponin components in the presence of Ca2+ or Sr2+ by the use of ultracentrifugation methods and polyacrylamide-gel electrophoresis. Skeletal-muscle troponin C bound to troponin I and dissociated it from the tropomyosin-actin complex in the presence of Ca2+ or Sr2+. When troponin T was absent, calmodulin bound to troponin I and dissociated it from the tropomyosin-actin complex in the presence of Ca2+ or Sr2+. When troponin T was present, calmodulin hardly bound to troponin I even in the presence of bivalent cations. Trifluoperazine, a calmodulin antagonist, inhibited the bivalent-cation-dependent interaction between calmodulin and troponin I. Calmodulin migrated more slowly in the presence of Sr2+ than it did in the presence of EGTA but faster than it did in the presence of Ca2+ on polyacrylamide-gel electrophoresis under non-denaturing conditions. It is concluded that troponin T is not required in the calmodulin regulation of muscle contraction because troponin T inhibits the bivalent-cation-dependent interaction between calmodulin and troponin I and because calmodulin binds to troponin I and dissociates it from the tropomyosin-actin complex in a bivalent-cation-dependent manner. Sr2+-induced exposure of the hydrophobic region enables calmodulin to bind to troponin I, as is the case with Ca2+.     

Site-directed mutation of the trigger calcium-binding sites in cardiac troponin C

The trigger Ca2+-binding sites in troponin C, those which initiate muscle contraction, are thought to be the first two of four potential sites (sites I-IV). In cardiac troponin C, the first Ca2+-binding site is inactive, and initiation of contraction in cardiac muscle appears to involve only the second site. To study this phenomenon and associated Ca2+-dependent protein conformational changes in cardiac troponin C, the cDNA for the chicken protein was incorporated into a bacterial expression plasmid to allow site-specific mutagenesis. Ca2+-binding site I was activated by deletion of Val-28 and conversion of amino acids 29-32 to those found at the first four positions in the active site I of fast skeletal troponin C. In a series of proteins, Ca2+-binding site II was inactivated by mutation of amino acids Asp-65, Asp-67, and Gly-70. All mutated proteins exhibited the predicted calcium-binding characteristics. The single mutation of converting Asp-65 to Ala was sufficient to inactivate site II. Ca2+-dependent conformational changes in the normal and mutated proteins were monitored by labeling with a sulfhydryl-specific fluorescent dye. Activation of Ca2+-binding site I or inactivation of site II, eliminated the large Ca2+-dependent increase in fluorescence seen in the wild type protein and there was, instead, a Ca2+-dependent decrease in fluorescence. All mutant proteins could associate with troponin I and troponin T to form a troponin complex. Activation of Ca2+-binding site I changed the characteristics of contraction in skinned slow skeletal muscle fibers such that the response to Ca2+ was more cooperative. Inactivation of Ca2+-binding site II abolished Ca2+-dependent contraction in skinned muscle fibers. The data provide a direct demonstration that Ca2+-binding site II in cardiac troponin C is essential for triggering muscle contraction and support the hypothesis that site I functions to modify the characteristics of contraction.     

Functional consequences of a carboxyl terminal missense mutation Arg278Cys in human cardiac troponin T.

A carboxyl terminal missense mutant Arg278Cys of human cardiac troponin T that causes familial hypertrophic cardiomyopathy was expressed in Escherichia coli, purified, and exchanged into rabbit cardiac skinned muscle fibers using a troponin exchange technique. Compared to the fibers exchanged with human cardiac wild-type troponin T, the fibers exchanged with the mutant Arg278Cys developed less maximum force with a decreased cooperativity and a slightly increased Ca(2+) sensitivity, resulting in a significant elevation of sub-half-maximal force. Since intact cardiac muscle is thought to never be activated beyond the half-maximum level, the results suggest that an enhanced myofilament response to Ca(2+) may be responsible for the pathogenesis of hypertrophic cardiomyopathy associated with this mutation. The results also provide the first evidence that the carboxyl terminal region of cardiac troponin T plays an important role probably through its interaction with tropomyosin in allowing troponin complex to inhibit the muscle contraction at low Ca(2+), in agreement with the hypothesis deduced from the previous studies on fast skeletal troponin T.     

Role of troponin T in disease

Several striated muscle myopathies have been directly linked to mutations in contractile and associated proteins. Troponin T (TnT) is one of the three subunits that form troponin (Tn) which together with tropomyosin is responsible for the regulation of striated muscle contraction. All three subunits of cardiac Tn as well as tropomyosin have been associated with hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM). However, TnT accounts for most of the mutations that cause HCM in these regulatory proteins. To date 30 mutations have been identified in the cardiac TnT (CTnT) gene that results in familial HCM (FHC). The CTnT gene has also been associated with familial dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM). CTnT deficiency is lethal due to impaired cardiac development. A recessive nonsense mutation in the gene encoding slow skeletal TnT has been associated with an unusual, severe form of nemaline myopathy among the Old Order Amish. How each mutation leads to the diverse clinical symptoms associated with FHC, DCM or nemaline myopathy is unclear. However, the use of animal model systems, in particular transgenic mice, has significantly increased our knowledge of normal and myopathic muscle physiology. In this review, we focus on the role of TnT in muscle physiology and disease. (Mol Cell Biochem 263: 115–129, 2004)     

Mutual Rescues between Two Dominant Negative Mutations in Cardiac Troponin I and Cardiac Troponin T

Troponin T (TnT) and troponin I (TnI) are two evolutionarily and functionally linked subunits of the troponin complex that regulates striated muscle contraction. We previously reported a single amino acid substitution in the highly conserved TnT-binding helix of cardiac TnI (cTnI) in wild turkey hearts in concurrence with an abnormally spliced myopathic cardiac TnT (cTnT) (Biesiadecki, B. J., Schneider, K. L., Yu, Z. B., Chong, S. M., and Jin, J. P. (2004) J. Biol. Chem. 279, 13825–13832). To investigate the functional effect of this cTnI mutation and its potential value in compensating for the cTnT abnormality, we developed transgenic mice expressing the mutant cTnI (K118C) in the heart with or without the deletion of the endogenous cTnI gene to mimic the homozygote and heterozygote of wild turkeys. Double and triple transgenic mice were created by crossing the cTnI-K118C lines with transgenic mice overexpressing the myopathic cTnT (exon 7 deletion). Functional studies of ex vivo working hearts found that cTnI-K118C alone had a dominantly negative effect on diastolic function and blunted the inotropic responses of cardiac muscle to β-adrenergic stimuli without abolishing the protein kinase A-dependent phosphorylation of cTnI. When co-expressed with the cTnT mutation, cTnI-K118C corrected the significant depression of systolic function caused by cTnT exon 7 deletion, and the co-existence of exon 7-deleted cTnT minimized the diastolic abnormality of cTnI-K118C. Characterization of this naturally selected pair of mutually rescuing mutations demonstrated that TnI-TnT interaction is a critical link in the Ca²⁺ signaling and β-adrenergic regulation in cardiac muscle, suggesting a potential target for the treatment of troponin cardiomyopathies and heart failure.     

Targeted disruption of the cardiac troponin T gene causes sarcomere disassembly and defects in heartbeat within the early mouse embryo

Cardiac troponin T (cTnT) is a component of the troponin (Tn) complex in cardiac myocytes, and plays a regulatory role in cardiac muscle contraction by anchoring two other Tn components, troponin I (TnI) and troponin C, to tropomyosin (Tm) on the thin filaments. In order to determine the in vivo function of cTnT, we created a null cTnT allele in the mouse TNNT2 locus. In cTnT-deficient (cTnT^−/−) cardiac myocytes, the thick and thin filaments and α-actinin-positive Z-disk-like structures were not assembled into sarcomere, causing early embryonic lethality due to a lack of heartbeats. TnI was dissociated from Tm in the thin filaments without cTnT. In spite of loss of Tn on the thin filaments, the cTnT^−/− cardiac myocytes showed regular Ca²⁺-transients. These findings indicate that cTnT plays a critical role in sarcomere assembly during myofibrillogenesis in the embryonic heart, and also indicate that the membrane excitation and intracellular Ca²⁺ handling systems develop independently of the contractile system. In contrast, heterozygous cTnT^+/− mice had a normal life span with no structural and functional abnormalities in their hearts, suggesting that haploinsufficiency could not be a potential cause of cardiomyopathies, known to be associated with a variety of mutations in the TNNT2 locus.