Single base mismatches in DNA. Long- and short-range structure probed by analysis of axis trajectory and local chemical reactivity

We have devised a procedure to generate any single base mismatch in a constant sequence context, and have studied these from two points of view. (1) We have examined electrophoretic mobility of 458 base-pair fragments containing approximately centrally located single mismatches, in polyacrylamide gels, compared to fully matched DNA fragments. We found that no single mismatch caused a significant perturbation of gel mobility, and we conclude that all the mismatches may be accommodated within a helical geometry such that there is no alteration of the path of the helix axis in a straight DNA molecule. (2) We have studied all the single mismatches with respect to reactivity to a number of chemical probes. We found that: (a) No mispaired adenine bases are reactive to diethyl pyrocarbonate and are therefore not simply unpaired such that N-7 is exposed. (b) A number of mispaired thymine bases are reactive to osmium tetroxide, and cytosine bases to hydroxylamine. (c) Where crystal or nuclear magnetic resonance structures are available, the reactivity correlates with exposure of the pyrimidine 5,6 double bonds to attack in the major groove as a result of wobble base-pair formation. This is particularly clear for G.T and I.T base-pairs. (d) Reactivity of bases in mismatched pairs can be dependent on sequence context. (e) Reactivity of the C.C mismatch to hydroxylamine is suppressed at low pH, suggesting that a rearrangement of base-pairing occurs on protonation. The results overall are consistent with the formation of stacked intrahelical base-pairs wherever possible, resulting in no global distortion of the DNA structure, but specific enhancement of chemical reactivity in some cases.     

Two-dimensional conformation-dependent electrophoresis (2D-CDE) to separate DNA fragments containing unmatched bulge from complex DNA samples

DNA fragments containing mispaired and modified bases, bulges, lesions and specific sequences have altered conformation. Methods for separating complex samples of DNA fragments based on conformation but independent of length have many applications, including (i) separation of mismatched or unmatched DNA fragments from those perfectly matched; (ii) simultaneous, diagnostic, mismatch scanning of multiple fragments; (iii) isolation of damaged DNA fragments from undamaged fragments; and (iv) estimation of reannealing efficiency of complex DNA samples. We developed a two-dimensional conformation-dependent electrophoresis (2D-CDE) method for separating DNA fragments based on length and conformation in the first dimension and only on length in the second dimension. Differences in migration velocity due to conformation were minimized during second dimension electrophoresis by introducing an intercalator. To test the method, we constructed 298 bp DNA fragments containing cytosine bulges ranging from 1 to 5 nt. Bulge-containing DNA fragments had reduced migration velocity in the first dimension due to altered conformation. After 2D-CDE, bulge-containing DNA fragments had migrated in front of an arc comprising heterogeneous fragments with regular conformation. This simple and robust method could be used in both analytical and preparative applications involving complex DNA samples.     

The thermal stability of DNA fragments with tandem mismatches at a d(CXYG).d(CY'X'G) site.

Temperature-Gradient Gel Electrophoresis (TGGE) was employed to determine the thermal stabilities of 28 DNA fragments, 373 bp long, with two adjacent mismatched base pairs, and eight DNAs with Watson-Crick base pairs at the same positions. Heteroduplex DNAs containing two adjacent mismatches were formed by melting and reannealing pairs of homologous 373 bp DNA fragments differing by two adjacent base pairs. Product DNAs were separated based on their thermal stability by parallel and perpendicular TGGE. The polyacrylamide gel contained 3.36 M urea and 19.2 % formamide to lower the DNA melting temperatures. The order of stability was determined in the sequence context d(CXYG).d(CY'X'G) where X.X' and Y.Y" represent the mismatched or Watson-Crick base pairs. The identity of the mismatched bases and their stacking interactions influence DNA stability. Mobility transition melting temperatures (T u) of the DNAs with adjacent mismatches were 1.0-3.6 degrees C (+/-0.2 degree C) lower than the homoduplex DNA with the d(CCAG).d(CTGG) sequence. Two adjacent G.A pairs, d(CGAG).d(CGAG), created a more stable DNA than DNAs with Watson-Crick A.T pairs at the same sites. The d(GA).d(GA) sequence is estimated to be 0.4 (+/-30%) kcal/mol more stable in free energy than d(AA).d(TT) base pairs. This result confirms the unusual stability of the d(GA).d(GA) sequence previously observed in DNA oligomers. All other DNAs with adjacent mismatched base pairs were less stable than Watson-Crick homoduplex DNAs. Their relative stabilities followed an order expected from previous results on single mismatches. Two homoduplex DNAs with identical nearest neighbor sequences but different next-nearest neighbor sequences had a small but reproducible difference in T u value. This result indicates that sequence dependent next neighbor stacking interactions influence DNA stability.     

Sequence‐dependent cleavage of mismatched DNA by Ban I restriction endonuclease

Restriction enzymes have previously shown the ability to cleave DNA substrates with mismatched base(s) in recognition sequences; in this study, Ban I endonuclease demonstrated this same ability. Single base substitutions were introduced, and fragments containing various types of unpaired base(s) (heteroduplex fragments) within the Ban I endonuclease recognition sequence, 5′‐G|GPyPuCC‐3′, were generated. Each of the heteroduplex fragments was treated with Ban I endonuclease and analyzed by denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis. Our results showed that heteroduplex fragments containing mismatched bases at either the first or third position of the Ban I recognition sequence or, because of the symmetrical structure of the sequence, the sixth or fourth position on the opposite strand were cleaved by the enzyme. Furthermore, these cleaved fragments contained at least one strand corresponding to the original Ban I recognition sequence. Fragments with mismatches formed by an A (noncanonical , nc ) opposite a purine (canonical , ca ) or a T (nc ) opposite a pyrimidine (ca ) were cleaved more efficiently than other types of mismatched bases. These results may help elucidate the mechanisms by which DNA and protein interact during the process of DNA cleavage by Ban I endonuclease.     

Influence of nearest neighbor sequence on the stability of base pair mismatches in long DNA; determination by temperature-gradient gel electrophoresis.

Temperature-gradient gel electrophoresis (TGGE) was employed to determine the thermal stabilities of 48 DNA fragments that differ by single base pair mismatches. The approach provides a rapid way for studying how specific base mismatches effect the stability of a long DNA fragment. Homologous 373 bp DNA fragments differing by single base pair substitutions in their first melting domain were employed. Heteroduplexes were formed by melting and reannealing pairs of DNAs, one of which was 32P-labeled on its 5'-end. Product DNAs were separated based on their thermal stability by parallel and perpendicular temperature-gradient gel electrophoresis. The order of stability was determined for all common base pairs and mismatched bases in four different nearest neighbor environments; d(GXT).d(AYC), d(GXG).d(CYC), d(CXA).d(TYG), and d(TXT).d(AYA) with X,Y = A, T, C, or G. DNA fragments containing a single mismatch were destabilized by 1 to 5 degrees C with respect to homologous DNAs with complete Watson-Crick base pairing. Both the bases at the mismatch site and neighboring stacking interactions influence the destabilization caused by a mismatch. G.T, G.G and G.A mismatches were always among the most stable mismatches for all nearest neighbor environments examined. Purine.purine mismatches were generally more stable than pyrimidine.pyrimidine mispairs. Our results are in very good agreement with data where available from solution studies of short DNA oligomers.     

Cleavage of substrates with mismatched nucleotides by Flap endonuclease-1. Implications for mammalian Okazaki fragment processing.

Flap endonuclease-1 (FEN1) is proposed to participate in removal of the initiator RNA of mammalian Okazaki fragments by two pathways. In one pathway, RNase HI removes most of the RNA, leaving a single ribonucleotide adjacent to the DNA. FEN1 removes this ribonucleotide exonucleolytically. In the other pathway, FEN1 removes the entire primer endonucleolytically after displacement of the 5'-end region of the Okazaki fragment. Cleavage would occur beyond the RNA, a short distance into the DNA. The initiator RNA and an adjacent short region of DNA are synthesized by DNA polymerase alpha/primase. Because the fidelity of DNA polymerase alpha is lower than that of the DNA polymerases that complete DNA extension, mismatches occur relatively frequently near the 5'-ends of Okazaki fragments. We have examined the ability of FEN1 to repair such errors. Results show that mismatched bases up to 15 nucleotides from the 5'-end of an annealed DNA strand change the pattern of FEN1 cleavage. Instead of removing terminal nucleotides sequentially, FEN1 appears to cleave a portion of the mismatched strand endonucleolytically. We propose that a mismatch destabilizes the helical structure over a nearby area. This allows FEN1 to cleave more efficiently, facilitating removal of the mismatch. If mismatches were not introduced during synthesis of the Okazaki fragment, helical disruption would not occur, nor would unnecessary degradation of the 5'-end of the fragment.     

Chemical reactivity of matched cytosine and thymine bases near mismatched and unmatched bases in a heteroduplex between DNA strands with multiple differences.

The chemical reactivity of matched T and C bases to osmium tetroxide and hydroxylamine near mismatched and unmatched bases in a heteroduplex between two strands of DNA with multiple differences was examined. Data was available for matched bases one or two positions away from 24 mismatches. Reactive bases were found near 16 of the mismatches and were usually one or two bases away. This reactivity is consistent with structural studies indicating perturbation of the duplex around mismatches and will allow another mode of study of the effect of mismatches. The reactivity of these bases was found not to be strongly correlated with mismatch type or GC basepair content of the basepairs around the mismatches. Extra reactivity may have been promoted by the presence of either T or C in the mismatch allowing increased reactivity of nearby T or C. The utility of the phenomenon for the detection of mutations is discussed. Unmatched bases in the heteroduplex also gives rise to reactive matched bases nearby.     

ssDNA Pairing Accuracy Increases When Abasic Sites Divide Nucleotides into Small Groups

Accurate sequence dependent pairing of single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) molecules plays an important role in gene chips, DNA origami, and polymerase chain reactions. In many assays accurate pairing depends on mismatched sequences melting at lower temperatures than matched sequences; however, for sequences longer than ~10 nucleotides, single mismatches and correct matches have melting temperature differences of less than 3°C. We demonstrate that appropriately grouping of 35 bases in ssDNA using abasic sites increases the difference between the melting temperature of correct bases and the melting temperature of mismatched base pairings. Importantly, in the presence of appropriately spaced abasic sites mismatches near one end of a long dsDNA destabilize the annealing at the other end much more effectively than in systems without the abasic sites, suggesting that the dsDNA melts more uniformly in the presence of appropriately spaced abasic sites. In sum, the presence of appropriately spaced abasic sites allows temperature to more accurately discriminate correct base pairings from incorrect ones.     

The SV40 termination region exhibits an altered helical DNA conformation.

The DNA structure of a fragment containing the SV40 termination sequences was examined using gel mobility assays. The region is shown to contain a DNA bend as evidenced by an abnormal mobility that is progressively accentuated as the temperature is lowered. This represents the strongest example of DNA bending among the collection of SV40 fragments studied. The same fragment was shown previously to uniquely support hyper-stable nucleosome formation in vitro, suggesting a possible relationship between DNA bending and nucleosome stability.     

Detection of 100% of mutations in 124 individuals using a standard UV/Vis microplate reader: a novel concept for mutation scanning

We report the development of a simple and inexpensive assay for the detection of DNA polymorphisms and mutations that is based on the modification of mismatched bases by potassium permanganate. Unlike the chemical cleavage of mismatch assay, which also exploits the reactivity of potassium permanganate to detect genomic variants, the assay we describe here does not require a cleavage manipulation and therefore does not require expensive or toxic chemicals or a separation step, as mismatches are detected using direct optical methods in a microplate format. Studies with individual deoxynucleotides demonstrated that the reactivity with potassium permanganate resulted in a specific colour change. Furthermore, studies with synthetic oligonucleotide heteroduplexes demonstrated that this colour change phenomenon could be applied to detect mismatched bases spectrophotometrically. A collection of plasmids carrying single point mutations in the mouse β-globin promoter region was used as a model system to develop a functional mutation detection assay. Finally, the assay was validated as 100% effective in detecting mismatches in a blinded manner using DNA from patients previously screened for mutations using established techniques, such as sequencing, SSCP and denaturing high-performance liquid chromatography (DHPLC) analysis in DNA fragments up to 300 bp in length.     

Processing of mispaired and unpaired bases in heteroduplex DNA in E. coli

Bacteriophage lambda and phi X 174 DNAs, carrying sequenced mutations, have been used to construct in vitro defined species of heteroduplex DNA. Such heteroduplex DNAs were introduced by transfection, as single copies, into E. coli host cells. The progeny of individual heteroduplex molecules from each infective center was analyzed. The effect of the presence of GATC sequences (phi X 174 system) and of their methylation (lambda system) was tested. The following conclusions can be drawn: some mismatched base pairs trigger the process of mismatch repair, causing a localized strand-to-strand information transfer in heteroduplex DNA: transition mismatches G:T and A:C are efficiently repaired, whereas the six transversion mismatches are not always readily recognized and/or repaired. The recognition of transversion mismatches appears to depend on the neighbouring nucleotide sequence; single unpaired bases (frameshift mutation "mismatches") are recognized and repaired, some equally efficiently on both strands (longer and shorter), some more efficiently on the shorter (-1) strand; large non-homologies (about 800 bases) are not repaired by the Mut H, L, S, U system, but some other process repairs the non-homology with a relatively low efficiency; full methylation of GATC sequences inhibits mismatch repair on the methylated strand: this is the chemical basis of strand discrimination (old/new) in mismatch correction; unmethylated GATC sequences appear to improve mismatch repair of a G:T mismatch in phi X 174 DNA, but there may be some residual mismatch repair in GATC-free phi X 174, at least for some mismatches.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Chemical determinants of DNA bending at adenine-thymine tracts

DNA fragments having homopolymeric adenine-thymine tracts phased with the helix screw are known to be bent. According to our working model, adenine-thymine tracts adopt a polymorphic structure (H-DNA), and juxtaposition of H-DNA with B-DNA results in bending at the junction between the two structures. We incorporated different base analogues in addition to the four ordinary bases into oligonucleotides; ligated multimers of oligonucleotide duplexes were run on polyacrylamide gels. By comparison of gel mobility data for different sequences, we identified factors both necessary and irrelevant for bending, corresponding to the formation of H-DNA. The 5-methyl group on pyrimidines is not essential, and the 2-amino group on purines interferes with the formation of H-DNA, either because it provides a third H bond between the bases or because it alters water structure in the minor groove. The strong base stacking of A may be an important contributing factor to stabilization of the anomalous DNA structure responsible for bending.     

The poor homology stringency in the heteroduplex allows strand exchange to incorporate desirable mismatches without sacrificing recognition in vivo

RecA family proteins are responsible for homology search and strand exchange. In bacteria, homology search begins after RecA binds an initiating single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) in the primary DNA-binding site, forming the presynaptic filament. Once the filament is formed, it interrogates double-stranded DNA (dsDNA). During the interrogation, bases in the dsDNA attempt to form Watson–Crick bonds with the corresponding bases in the initiating strand. Mismatch dependent instability in the base pairing in the heteroduplex strand exchange product could provide stringent recognition; however, we present experimental and theoretical results suggesting that the heteroduplex stability is insensitive to mismatches. We also present data suggesting that an initial homology test of 8 contiguous bases rejects most interactions containing more than 1/8 mismatches without forming a detectable 20 bp product. We propose that, in vivo, the sparsity of accidental sequence matches allows an initial 8 bp test to rapidly reject almost all non-homologous sequences. We speculate that once the initial test is passed, the mismatch insensitive binding in the heteroduplex allows short mismatched regions to be incorporated in otherwise homologous strand exchange products even though sequences with less homology are eventually rejected.     

Structures of mismatched base pairs in DNA and their recognition by the Escherichia coli mismatch repair system.

The Escherichia coli mismatch repair system does not recognize and/or repair all mismatched base pairs with equal efficiency: whereas transition mismatches (G X T and A X C) are well repaired, the repair of some transversion mismatches (e.g. A X G or C X T) appears to depend on their position in heteroduplex DNA of phage lambda. Undecamers were synthesized and annealed to form heteroduplexes with a single base-pair mismatch in the centre and with the five base pairs flanking each side corresponding to either repaired or unrepaired heteroduplexes of lambda DNA. Nuclear magnetic resonance (n.m.r.) studies show that a G X A mismatch gives rise to an equilibrium between fully helical and a looped-out structure. In the unrepaired G X A mismatch duplex the latter predominates, while the helical structure is predominant in the case of repaired G X A and G X T mismatches. It appears that the E. coli mismatch repair enzymes recognize and repair intrahelical mismatched bases, but not the extrahelical bases in the looped-out structures.     

Reactions at the polymerase active site that contribute to the fidelity of Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I (Klenow fragment).

In order to study the structural principles governing DNA polymerase fidelity we have measured the rates of insertion of incorrect nucleotides and the rates of extension from the resulting mismatched base pairs, catalyzed by the Klenow fragment of DNA polymerase I. Using a combination of semi-quantitative and qualitative approaches, we have studied each of the 12 possible mismatches in a variety of sequence contexts. The results indicate that Klenow fragment discriminates between mismatches largely on the basis of the identity of the mismatch, with the surrounding sequence context playing a significant, but secondary, role. For purine-pyrimidine and pyrimidine-pyrimidine mispairs, the relative ease of mismatch synthesis and extension can be rationalized using a simple geometrical model, with the important criterion being the extent to which the mismatched base pair can conform to normal DNA geometry. Essentially similar conclusions have been reached in studies of other polymerases, suggesting that this aspect of mispair geometry is sensed and responded to in a similar way by all polymerases. Purine-purine mismatches form a less cohesive class, showing more variable behavior from mispair to mispair, and a greater apparent susceptibility to sequence context effects. Comparison of our data with studies of other polymerases also suggests that different polymerases respond to purine-purine mismatches in distinct and characteristic ways. An extensive analysis of each of the four purine-purine mispairs in approximately 100 different sequence contexts suggests that the reaction is influenced both by the local DNA structure and by the ability of the mismatched terminus to undergo slippage.     

Mutation detection by electrocatalysis at DNA-modified electrodes

Detection of mutations and damaged DNA bases is important for the early diagnosis of genetic disease. Here we describe an electrocatalytic method for the detection of single-base mismatches as well as DNA base lesions in fully hybridized duplexes, based on charge transport through DNA films. Gold electrodes modified with preassembled DNA duplexes are used to monitor the electrocatalytic signal of methylene blue, a redox-active DNA intercalator, coupled to [Fe(CN)6]3-. The presence of mismatched or damaged DNA bases substantially diminishes the electrocatalytic signal. Because this assay is not a measure of differential hybridization, all single-base mismatches, including thermodynamically stable GT and GA mismatches, can be detected without stringent hybridization conditions. Furthermore, many common DNA lesions and "hot spot" mutations in the human p53 genome can be distinguished from perfect duplexes. Finally, we have demonstrated the application of this technology in a chip-based format. This system provides a sensitive method for probing the integrity of DNA sequences and a completely new approach to single-base mismatch detection.     

Base pairing geometry in GA mismatches depends entirely on the neighboring sequence.

We have synthesized nine self-complementary DNA oligomers containing different flanking sequences adjacent to a pair of contiguous GA mismatches, and have used high resolution nuclear magnetic resonance (n.m.r.) to investigate the GpA phosphodiester backbone conformation and mismatch pairing schemes in these duplexes. We found dramatic effects of the flanking base pair on the hydrogen bonding and backbone conformation, which appear to be coupled. Thus the Ganti-Aanti base pairing scheme in a NAGATN sequence switches to a more stable sheared GA base pairing scheme in a NCGAGN or NTGAAN context, while no duplex is formed (or only GA bulges occur) when NAGATN is changed to NGGACN. Furthermore, the more stable sheared GA pairing in NPyGAPuN sequences is associated with a BII rather than BI backbone conformation for the phosphodiester between the adjacent mismatched GA pairs. The overall stability of these adjacent GA mismatches as measured by imino proton n.m.r. studies is Py-GA-Pu > A-GA-T > G-GA-C.     

Differential Targeting of Unpaired Bases within Duplex DNA by the Natural Compound Clerocidin: A Valuable Tool to Dissect DNA Secondary Structure

Non-canonical DNA structures have been postulated to mediate protein-nucleic acid interactions and to function as intermediates in the generation of frame-shift mutations when errors in DNA replication occur, which result in a variety of diseases and cancers. Compounds capable of binding to non-canonical DNA conformations may thus have significant diagnostic and therapeutic potential. Clerocidin is a natural diterpenoid which has been shown to selectively react with single-stranded bases without targeting the double helix. Here we performed a comprehensive analysis on several non-canonical DNA secondary structures, namely mismatches, nicks, bulges, hairpins, with sequence variations in both the single-stranded region and the double-stranded flanking segment. By analysis of clerocidin reactivity, we were able to identify the exposed reactive residues which provided information on both the secondary structure and the accessibility of the non-paired sites. Mismatches longer than 1 base were necessary to be reached by clerocidin reactive groups, while 1-base nicks were promptly targeted by clerocidin; in hairpins, clerocidin reactivity increased with the length of the hairpin loop, while, interestingly, reactivity towards bulges reached a maximum in 3-base-long bulges and declined in longer bulges. Electrophoretic mobility shift analysis demonstrated that bulges longer than 3 bases (i.e. 5- and 7-bases) folded or stacked on the duplex region therefore being less accessible by the compound. Clerocidin thus represents a new valuable diagnostic tool to dissect DNA secondary structures.     

Comparative reactivity of mismatched and unpaired bases in relation to their type and surroundings. Chemical cleavage of DNA mismatches in mutation detection analysis

Systematic study of chemical reactivity of non-Watson–Crick base pairs depending on their type and microenvironment was performed on a model system that represents two sets of synthetic DNA duplexes with all types of mismatched and unmatched bases flanked by T·A or G·C pairs. Using comparative cleavage pattern analysis, we identified the main and additional target bases and performed quantitative study of the time course and efficacy of DNA modification caused by potassium permanganate or hydroxylamine. Potassium permanganate in combination with tetraethylammonium chloride was shown to induce DNA cleavage at all mismatched or bulged T residues, as well as at thymines of neighboring canonical pairs. Other mispaired (bulged) bases and thymine residues located on the second position from the mismatch site were not the targets for KMnO₄ attack. In contrast, hydroxylamine cleaved only heteroduplexes containing mismatched or unmatched C residues, and did not modify adjacent cytosines. However when G·C pairs flank bulged C residue, neighboring cytosines are also attacked by hydroxylamine due to defect migration. Chemical reactivity of target bases was shown to correlate strongly with the local disturbance of DNA double helix at mismatch or bulge site. With our model system, we were able to prove the absence of false-negative and false-positive results. Portion of heteroduplex reliably revealed in a mixture with corresponding homoduplex consists of 5% for bulge bases and “open” non-canonical pairs, and 10% for wobble base pairs giving minimal violations in DNA structure. This study provides a complete understanding of the principles of mutation detection methodology based on chemical cleavage of mismatches and clarifies the advantages and limitations of this approach in various biological and conformational studies of DNA.     

G . T base-pairs in a DNA helix: the crystal structure of d(G-G-G-G-T-C-C-C)

The synthetic deoxyoctanucleotide d(G-G-G-G-T-C-C-C) crystallizes as an A-type DNA double helix containing two adjacent G . T base-pair mismatches. The structure has been refined to an R-factor of 14% at 2.1 A resolution with 104 solvent molecules located. The two G . T mismatches adopt the "wobble" form of base-pairing. The mismatched bases are linked by a network of water molecules interacting with the exposed functional groups in both the major and minor grooves. The presence of two mispaired bases in the octamer has surprisingly little effect on the global structure of the helix or the backbone and glycosidic torsional angles. Base stacking around the mismatch is perturbed, but the central G-T step shows particularly good base overlap, which may contribute to the relatively high stability of this oligomer.