A relationship between membrane properties forms the basis of a selectivity mechanism for vesicle self-reproduction

Self-reproduction and the ability to regulate their composition are two essential properties of terrestrial biotic systems. The identification of non-living systems that possess these properties can therefore contribute not only to our understanding of their functioning but also hint at possible prebiotic processes that led to the emergence of life. Growing lipid vesicles have been previously established as having the capacity to self-reproduce. Here it is demonstrated that vesicle self-reproduction can occur only at selected values of vesicle properties. We treat as an example a simple vesicle with membrane elastic properties defined by a membrane bending modulus and spontaneous curvature C₀, whose volume variation depends on the membrane hydraulic permeability L_p and whose membrane area doubles in time T_d. Vesicle self-reproduction is described as a process in which a growing vesicle first transforms its shape from a sphere into a budded shape of two spheres connected by a narrow neck, and then splits into two spherical daughter vesicles. We show that budded vesicle shapes can be reached only under the condition that T_dL_pC₀⁴1.85. Thus, in a growing vesicle population containing vesicles of different composition, only the vesicles for which this condition is fulfilled can increase their number in a self-reproducing manner. The obtained results also suggest that at times much longer than T_d the number of vesicles with their properties near the edge in the system parameter space defined by the minimum value of the product T_dL_pC₀⁴, will greatly exceed the number of any other vesicles.     

Question 7: Construction of a Semi-Synthetic Minimal Cell: A Model for Early Living Cells

Using a Synthetic Biology approach we are building a semi-synthetic minimal cell. This represents an exercise to shape a minimal-cell model system recalling the simplicity of early living cells in early evolution. We have recently introduced into liposome compartments a minimal set of enzymes named “Puresystem” (PS) synthesizing EGFP proteins. To establish reproduction of the shell compartment with a minimal set of genes we have cloned the genes for the Fatty Acid Synthase (FAS) type I enzymes. These FAS genes introduced into liposomes, translated into FAS enzymes by PS and in the presence of precursors produce fatty acids. The resulting release of fatty acid molecules within liposome vesicles should promote vesicle growth and reproduction. The core reproduction of a minimal cell corresponding to the replication of the minimal genome will require a few genes for the DNA replication and the PS, and a minimum set of genes for the synthesis of t-RNAs. In future the reconstruction of a minimal ribosome will bring the number of genes for ribosomal proteins from 54 of an existing minimal genome down to 30–20 genes. A Synthetic Biology approach could bring the number of essential genes for a minimal cell down to 100 or less. International School of Complexity–4th Course: Basic Questions on the Origins of Life; “Ettore Majorana” Foundation and Centre for Scientific Culture, Erice, Italy, 1–6 October 2006.     

Synthetic biology of minimal living cells: primitive cell models and semi-synthetic cells

This article summarizes a contribution presented at the ESF 2009 Synthetic Biology focused on the concept of the minimal requirement for life and on the issue of constructive (synthetic) approaches in biological research. The attempts to define minimal life within the framework of autopoietic theory are firstly described, and a short report on the development of autopoietic chemical systems based on fatty acid vesicles, which are relevant as primitive cell models is given. These studies can be used as a starting point for the construction of more complex systems, firstly being inspired by possible origins of life scenarioes (and therefore by considering primitive functions), then by considering an approach based on modern biomacromolecular-encoded functions. At this aim, semi-synthetic minimal cells are defined as those man-made vesicle-based systems that are composed of the minimal number of genes, proteins, biomolecules and which can be defined as living. Recent achievements on minimal sized semi-synthetic cells are then discussed, and the kind of information obtained is recognized as being distinctively derived by a constructive approach. Synthetic biology is therefore a fundamental tool for gaining basic knowledge about biosystems, and it should not be confined at all to the engineering side.     

Mathematical modeling of a minimal protocell with coordinated growth and division

Self-replication is an essential attribute of life but the molecular-level mechanisms involved are not well understood. Cellular self-replication requires not only duplicating all cellular components and doubling volume and membrane area, but also replicating cellular geometry. A whole-cell modeling framework is presented in which an assumed reaction network determines both concentration changes of cellular components and cell geometry. Cell shape is calculated by minimizing membrane-bending energy. Using this framework, simultaneous doubling of volume, surface area, and all components was found to be insufficient to provide mid-cell “pinching” of the parental cell to form two daughter cells. This prompted the design of a minimal protocell that includes a growing shell, a cell-cycle engine, and a contractile ring to enforce cytokinesis. Kinetic parameters were found such that the system exhibited periodic behavior with fundamental aspects of self-replication. This involved simultaneous doubling of all cellular components during a cell cycle, doubling cell volume and membrane area, achieving periodic changes in surface/volume ratio, and forming daughter cells that were geometrically equivalent to each other and to the “newborn” parental cell. The results presented here impact the design of laboratory protocells and the development of a modular strategy for constructing a comprehensive in silico whole-cell model.     

Systems and synthetic biology approaches to cell division

Cells proliferate by division into similar daughter cells, a process that lies at the heart of cell biology. Extensive research on cell division has led to the identification of the many components and control elements of the molecular machinery underlying cellular division. Here we provide a brief review of prokaryotic and eukaryotic cell division and emphasize how new approaches such as systems and synthetic biology can provide valuable new insight.     

A hydrothermally precipitated catalytic iron sulphide membrane as a first step toward life

We propose that life emerged from growing aggregates of iron sulphide bubbles containing alkaline and highly reduced hydrothermal solution. These bubbles were inflated hydrostatically at sulphidic submarine hot springs sited some distance from oceanic spreading centers four billion years ago. The membrane enclosing the bubbles was precipitated in response to contact between the spring waters and the mildly oxidized, acidic and iron-bearing Hadean ocean water. As the gelatinous sulphide bubbles aged and were inflated beyond their strength they budded, producing contiguous daughter bubbles by the precipitation of new membrane. [Fe₂S₂]^+/0 or [Fe₄S₄]^2+/+ clusters, possibly bonded by hydrothermal thiolate ligands as proferredoxins, could have catalyzed oxidation of thiolates to disulphides, thereby modifying membrane properties.We envisage the earliest iron sulphide bubbles (pro botryoids) first growing by hydrostatic inflation with hydrothermal fluid, but evolving to grow mainly by osmosis (the protocellular stage), driven by (1) catabolism of hydrothermal abiogenic organics trapped on the inner walls of the membrane, catalyzed by the iron sulphide clusters; and (2) cleavage of hydrophobic compounds dissolved in the membrane to hydrophilic moieties which were translocated, by the proton motive force inherent in the acidic Hadean ocean, to the alkaline interior of the protocell. The organics were generated first within the hydrothermal convective system feeding the hot springs operating in the oceanic crust and later in the pyritizing mound developing on the sea floor, as a consequence of the reduction of CO, CO₂, and formaldehyde by Fe²⁺- and S^2–-bearing minerals.We imagine the physicochemical interactions in and on the membrane to have been sufficiently complex to have engendered auto- and cross-catalytic replication. The membrane may have been constructed in such a way that a successful parent could have informed the daughters of membrane characteristics functional for the then-current level of evolution.Correspondence to: M. J. RussellGlossary: Hollow pyrite botryoids: hollow hemispheres of cryptocrystalline pyrite (FeS₂) 0.1–1 mm across. Fischer-Tropsch syntheses: the highly exothermic catalytic hydrogenation of CO to hydrocarbons and aliphatic oxygenated compounds using finely divided iron. Greigite (Fe₃S₄): metastable iron sulphide precipitated from aqueous solution in a gel at 100°C and containing two-thirds of its iron as the high-spin ferric ion. Haber-Bosch process: the exothermic catalytic hydrogenation of nitrogen to yield ammonia. Probotryoid: a hydrostatically inflated colloidal iron monosulphide bubble; precursor to hollow botryoids and the progenitor to protocells. Proferredoxins: [Fe₂S₂] and [Fe₃MS₄] clusters (M = Fe, Mo, W, Ni, etc.) ligated by abiogenic thiols and thiolates. Protocell: a cell comprised mainly of abiogenic organics including thiols with subordinate iron sulphides, partly as proferredoxins; growth results from catabolism and osmotic pressure     

A synthetic biology approach to the construction of membrane proteins in semi-synthetic minimal cells

Synthetic biology is an emerging field that aims at constructing artificial biological systems by combining engineering and molecular biology approaches. One of the most ambitious research line concerns the so-called semi-synthetic minimal cells, which are liposome-based system capable of synthesizing the lipids within the liposome surface. This goal can be reached by reconstituting membrane proteins within liposomes and allow them to synthesize lipids. This approach, that can be defined as biochemical, was already reported by us (Schmidli et al. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 113, 8127-8130, 1991). In more advanced models, however, a full reconstruction of the biochemical pathway requires (1) the synthesis of functional membrane enzymes inside liposomes, and (2) the local synthesis of lipids as catalyzed by the in situ synthesized enzymes. Here we show the synthesis and the activity - inside liposomes - of two membrane proteins involved in phospholipids biosynthesis pathway. The proteins, sn-glycerol-3-phosphate acyltransferase (GPAT) and lysophosphatidic acid acyltransferase (LPAAT), have been synthesized by using a totally reconstructed cell-free system (PURE system) encapsulated in liposomes. The activities of internally synthesized GPAT and LPAAT were confirmed by detecting the produced lysophosphatidic acid and phosphatidic acid, respectively. Through this procedure, we have implemented the first phase of a design aimed at synthesizing phospholipid membrane from liposome within from within — which corresponds to the autopoietic growth mechanism.     

Vocabulary of Definitions of Life Suggests a Definition

Abstract

Analysis of the vocabulary of 123 tabulated definitions of life reveals nine groups of defining terms (definientia) of which the groups (self-)reproduction and evolution (variation) appear as the minimal set for a concise and inclusive definition: Life is self-reproduction with variations.     

Genetic requirements for cell division in a genomically minimal cell

1. Download : Download high-res image (233KB)
2. Download : Download full-size image

     

A genomically/chemically complete module for synthesis of lipid membrane in a minimal cell

A minimal cell is a hypothetical cell defined by the essential functions required for life. We have developed a module for the synthesis of membrane precursors for a mathematical minimal cell model. This module describes, with chemical and genomic detail the production of the constituents required to build a cell membrane and identifies the corresponding essential genes. Membranes allow selective nutrient passage, harmful substance exclusion, and energy generation. Bacterial membrane components range from lipids to fatty acids with embedded proteins and are structurally similar to eukaryotic cell membranes. Membranes are dynamic structures and experimental analyses show great variations in bacterial membrane composition. The flexibility of the model is such that different membrane compositions could be obtained in response to simulated changes in culture conditions. The model's predictions are in close agreement with the observed biological trends. The model's predictions correspond well with the experimental values of total lipid content in cells grown in chemostat culture, but less well with data from batch growth. Cell shape and size results agree especially well for data for growth rate relative to maximum growth rate larger than 0.5; and DNA, RNA, and protein predictions are consistent with experimental observations. A better understanding of the simplest bacterial membrane should lead to insights on the more complex behavior of membranes of higher species as well as identification of potential targets for antimicrobials.     

Toward the assembly of a minimal divisome

The construction of an irreducible minimal cell having all essential attributes of a living system is one of the biggest challenges facing synthetic biology. One ubiquitous task accomplished by any living systems is the division of the cell envelope. Hence, the assembly of an elementary, albeit sufficient, molecular machinery that supports compartment division, is a crucial step towards the realization of self-reproducing artificial cells. Looking backward to the molecular nature of possible ancestral, supposedly more rudimentary, cell division systems may help to identify a minimal divisome. In light of a possible evolutionary pathway of division mechanisms from simple lipid vesicles toward modern life, we define two approaches for recapitulating division in primitive cells: the membrane deforming protein route and the lipid biosynthesis route. Having identified possible proteins and working mechanisms participating in membrane shape alteration, we then discuss how they could be integrated into the construction framework of a programmable minimal cell relying on gene expression inside liposomes. The protein synthesis using recombinant elements (PURE) system, a reconstituted minimal gene expression system, is conceivably the most versatile synthesis platform. As a first step towards the de novo synthesis of a divisome, we showed that the N-BAR domain protein produced from its gene could assemble onto the outer surface of liposomes and sculpt the membrane into tubular structures. We finally discuss the remaining challenges for building up a self-reproducing minimal cell, in particular the coupling of the division machinery with volume expansion and genome replication.     

The vesicle cluster as a major organizer of synaptic composition in the short-term and long-term

For decades, the synaptic vesicle cluster has been thought of as a storage space for synaptic vesicles, whose obvious function is to provide vesicles for the depolarization-induced release of neurotransmitters; however, reports over the last few years indicate that the synaptic vesicle cluster probably plays a much broader and more fundamental role in synaptic biology. Various experiments suggest that the cluster is able to regulate protein distribution and mobility in the synapse; moreover, it probably regulates cytoskeleton architecture, mediates the selective removal of synaptic components from the bouton, and controls the responses of the presynapse to plasticity. Here we discuss these features of the vesicle cluster and conclude that it serves as a key organizer of synaptic composition and dynamics.     

Chemical aspects of synthetic biology

Synthetic biology as a broad and novel field has also a chemical branch: whereas synthetic biology generally has to do with bioengineering of new forms of life (generally bacteria) which do not exist in nature, 'chemical synthetic biology' is concerned with the synthesis of chemical structures such as proteins, nucleic acids, vesicular forms, and other which do not exist in nature. Three examples of this 'chemical synthetic biology' approach are given in this article. The first example deals with the synthesis of proteins that do not exist in nature, and dubbed as 'the never born proteins' (NBPs). This research is related to the question why and how the protein structures existing in our world have been selected out, with the underlying question whether they have something very particular from the structural or thermodynamic point of view (for example, the folding). The NBPs are produced in the laboratory by the modern molecular biology technique, the phage display, so as to produce a very large library of proteins having no homology with known proteins. The second example of chemical synthetic biology has also to do with the laboratory synthesis of proteins, but, this time, adopting a prebiotic synthetic procedure, the fragment condensation of short peptides, where short means that they have a length that can be obtained by prebiotic methods; for example, from the condensation of N-carboxy anhydrides. The scheme is illustrated and discussed, being based on the fragment condensation catalyzed by peptides endowed with proteolitic activity. Selection during chain growth is determined by solubility under the contingent environmental conditions, i.e., the peptides which result insoluble are eliminated from further growth. The scheme is tested preliminarily with a synthetic chemical fragment-condensation method and brings to the synthesis of a 44-residues-long protein, which has no homology with known proteins, and which has a stable tertiary folding. Finally, the third example, dubbed as 'the minimal cell project'. Here, the aim is to synthesize a cell model having the minimal and sufficient number of components to be defined as living. For this purpose, liposomes are used as shell membranes, and attempts are made to introduce in the interior a minimal genome. Several groups all around the world are active in this field, and significant results have been obtained, which are reviewed in this article. For example, protein expression has been obtained inside liposomes, generally with the green fluorescent protein, GFP. Our last attempts are with a minimal genome consisting of 37 enzymes, a set which is able to express proteins using the ribosomal machinery. These minimal cells are not yet capable of self-reproduction, and this and other shortcomings within the project are critically reviewed.     

Origin of life: Consideration of alternatives to proteins and nucleic acids

Summary Starting with relatively simple, non-hydrolyzable compounds in aqueous solution, entirely spontaneous condensations give rise to polymers that contain purines, pyrimidines, amino acids, coenzymes, lipid components and even phosphate. The presence of certain lipid micelles allows significant product formation at millimolar substrate concentrations. The first step involves formation of a Michael adduct from--unsaturated carbonyl compounds and various nucleophiles. Polymerization of these adducts occurs via sequential Knoevenagel condensations. All reactions take place readily at temperatures below 45°. The polymers can act as macromolecular catalysts as evidenced by hydrolytic activity. The purines and pyrimidines in the polymers appear to be capable of both base pairing and stacking interactions with ribonucleic acids. Specific examples of potential alternatives to base pairing are presented. These results are discussed from the standpoint of the spontaneous development of reproducing molecules. Proteins and nucleic acids may be evolutionary developments which have displaced earlier biopolymers.     

Phenotypic diversity and chaos in a minimal cell model

Gánti's chemoton model (Gánti, T., 2002. On the early evolution of biological periodicity. Cell. Biol. Int. 26, 729) is considered as an iconic example of a minimal protocell including three key subsystems: membrane, metabolism and information. The three subsystems are connected through stoichiometrical coupling which ensures the existence of a replication cycle for the chemoton. Our detailed exploration of a version of this model indicates that it displays a wide range of complex dynamics, from regularity to chaos. Here, we report the presence of a very rich set of dynamical patterns potentially displayed by a protocell as described by this implementation of a chemoton-like model. The implications for early cellular evolution and synthesis of artificial cells are discussed.     

On the road to synthetic life: the minimal cell and genome-scale engineering

Synthetic biology employs rational engineering principles to build biological systems from the libraries of standard, well characterized biological parts. Biological systems designed and built by synthetic biologists fulfill a plethora of useful purposes, ranging from better healthcare and energy production to biomanufacturing. Recent advancements in the synthesis, assembly and “booting-up” of synthetic genomes and in low and high-throughput genome engineering have paved the way for engineering on the genome-wide scale. One of the key goals of genome engineering is the construction of minimal genomes consisting solely of essential genes (genes indispensable for survival of living organisms). Besides serving as a toolbox to understand the universal principles of life, the cell encoded by minimal genome could be used to build a stringently controlled “cell factory” with a desired phenotype. This review provides an update on recent advances in the genome-scale engineering with particular emphasis on the engineering of minimal genomes. Furthermore, it presents an ongoing discussion to the scientific community for better suitability of minimal or robust cells for industrial applications.