Regulation of bacterial RecA protein function

The RecA protein is a recombinase functioning in recombinational DNA repair in bacteria. RecA is regulated at many levels. The expression of the recA gene is regulated within the SOS response. The activity of the RecA protein itself is autoregulated by its own C-terminus. RecA is also regulated by the action of other proteins. To date, these include the RecF, RecO, RecR, DinI, RecX, RdgC, PsiB, and UvrD proteins. The SSB protein also indirectly affects RecA function by competing for ssDNA binding sites. The RecO and RecR, and possibly the RecF proteins, all facilitate RecA loading onto SSB-coated ssDNA. The RecX protein blocks RecA filament extension, and may have other effects on RecA activity. The DinI protein stabilizes RecA filaments. The RdgC protein binds to dsDNA and blocks RecA access to dsDNA. The PsiB protein, encoded by F plasmids, is uncharacterized, but may inhibit RecA in some manner. The UvrD helicase removes RecA filaments from RecA. All of these proteins function in a network that determines where and how RecA functions. Additional regulatory proteins may remain to be discovered. The elaborate regulatory pattern is likely to be reprised for RecA homologues in archaeans and eukaryotes.     

Regulation of Bacterial RecA Protein Function

ABSTRACT

The RecA protein is a recombinase functioning in recombinational DNA repair in bacteria. RecA is regulated at many levels. The expression of the recA gene is regulated within the SOS response. The activity of the RecA protein itself is autoregulated by its own C-terminus. RecA is also regulated by the action of other proteins. To date, these include the RecF, RecO, RecR, DinI, RecX, RdgC, PsiB, and UvrD proteins. The SSB protein also indirectly affects RecA function by competing for ssDNA binding sites. The RecO and RecR, and possibly the RecF proteins, all facilitate RecA loading onto SSB-coated ssDNA. The RecX protein blocks RecA filament extension, and may have other effects on RecA activity. The DinI protein stabilizes RecA filaments. The RdgC protein binds to dsDNA and blocks RecA access to dsDNA. The PsiB protein, encoded by F plasmids, is uncharacterized, but may inhibit RecA in some manner. The UvrD helicase removes RecA filaments from RecA. All of these proteins function in a network that determines where and how RecA functions. Additional regulatory proteins may remain to be discovered. The elaborate regulatory pattern is likely to be reprised for RecA homologues in archaeans and eukaryotes.     

The DinI and RecX proteins are competing modulators of RecA function

The DinI and RecX proteins of Escherichia coli both modulate the function of RecA protein, but have very different effects. DinI protein stabilizes RecA filaments, preventing disassembly but permitting assembly. RecX protein blocks RecA filament extension, which can lead to net filament disassembly. We demonstrate that both proteins can interact with the RecA filament, and propose that each can replace the other. The DinI/RecX displacement reactions are slow, requiring multiple minutes even when a large excess of the challenging protein is present. The effects of RecX protein on RecA filaments are manifest at lower modulator concentrations than the effects of DinI protein. Together, the DinI and RecX proteins constitute a new regulatory network. The two proteins compete directly as mainly positive (DinI) and negative (RecX) modulators of RecA function.     

RecA K72R filament formation defects reveal an oligomeric RecA species involved in filament extension

Using an ensemble approach, we demonstrate that an oligomeric RecA species is required for the extension phase of RecA filament formation. The RecA K72R mutant protein can bind but not hydrolyze ATP or dATP. When mixed with other RecA variants, RecA K72R causes a drop in the rate of ATP hydrolysis and has been used to study disassembly of hydrolysis-proficient RecA protein filaments. RecA K72R filaments do not form in the presence of ATP but do so when dATP is provided. We demonstrate that in the presence of ATP, RecA K72R is defective for extension of RecA filaments on DNA. This defect is partially rescued when the mutant protein is mixed with sufficient levels of wild type RecA protein. Functional extension complexes form most readily when wild type RecA is in excess of RecA K72R. Thus, RecA K72R inhibits hydrolysis-proficient RecA proteins by interacting with them in solution and preventing the extension phase of filament assembly.     

ATP-mediated changes in cross-subunit interactions in the RecA protein

RecA protein undergoes ATP- and DNA-induced conformational changes that result in different helical parameters for free protein filaments versus RecA/ATP/DNA nucleoprotein filaments. Previous mutational studies of a particular region of the RecA oligomeric interface suggested that cross-subunit contacts made by residues K6 and R28 were more important for stabilization of free protein oligomers than nucleoprotein filaments [Eldin, S., et al. (2000) J. Mol. Biol. 299, 91-101]. Using mutant proteins with specifically engineered Cys substitutions, we show here that the efficiency of cross-subunit disulfide bond formation at certain positions in this region changes in the presence of ATP or ATP/DNA. Our results support the idea that specific cross-subunit interactions that occur within this region of the subunit interface are different in free RecA protein versus RecA/ATP/DNA nucleoprotein filaments.     

A RecA filament capping mechanism for RecX protein

The RecX protein is a potent inhibitor of RecA protein activities. RecX functions by specifically blocking the extension of RecA filaments. In vitro, this leads to a net disassembly of RecA protein from circular single-stranded DNA. Based on multiple observations, we propose that RecX has a RecA filament capping activity. This activity has predictable effects on the formation and disassembly of RecA filaments. In vivo, the RecX protein may limit the length of RecA filaments formed during recombinational DNA repair and other activities. RecX protein interacts directly with RecA protein, but appears to interact in a functionally significant manner only with RecA filaments bound to DNA.     

Right or left turn? RecA family protein filaments promote homologous recombination through clockwise axial rotation

The RecA family proteins mediate homologous recombination, a ubiquitous mechanism for repairing DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) and stalled replication forks. Members of this family include bacterial RecA, archaeal RadA and Rad51, and eukaryotic Rad51 and Dmc1. These proteins bind to single-stranded DNA at a DSB site to form a presynaptic nucleoprotein filament, align this presynaptic filament with homologous sequences in another double-stranded DNA segment, promote DNA strand exchange and then dissociate. It was generally accepted that RecA family proteins function throughout their catalytic cycles as right-handed helical filaments with six protomers per helical turn. However, we recently reported that archaeal RadA proteins can also form an extended right-handed filament with three monomers per helical turn and a left-handed protein filament with four monomers per helical turn. Subsequent structural and functional analyses suggest that RecA family protein filaments, similar to the F1-ATPase rotary motor, perform ATP-dependent clockwise axial rotation during their catalytic cycles. This new hypothesis has opened a new avenue for understanding the molecular mechanism of RecA family proteins in homologous recombination.     

RNA-DNA hybridization promoted by E. coli RecA protein.

RecA protein of E. coli plays a central regulatory role that is induced by damage to DNA and results in the inactivation of LexA repressor. In vitro, RecA protein binds preferentially to single-stranded DNA to form a nucleoprotein filament that can recognize homology in naked duplex DNA and promote extensive strand exchange. Although RecA protein shows little tendency at neutral pH to bind to RNA, we found that it nonetheless catalyzed at 37 degrees C the hybridization of complementary RNA and single-stranded DNA sequences. Hybrids made by RecA protein at 37 degrees C appeared indistinguishable from ones prepared by thermal annealing. RNA-DNA hybridization by RecA protein at neutral pH required, as does RecA-promoted homologous pairing, optimal conditions for the formation of RecA nucleoprotein filaments. The cosedimentation of RNA with those filaments further paralleled observations made on the formation of networks of nucleoprotein filaments with double-stranded DNA, an instrumental intermediate in homologous pairing in vitro. These similarities with the pairing reaction support the view that RecA protein acts specifically in the hybridization reaction.     

Visualization of recA protein and its association with DNA: a priming effect of single-strand-binding protein

A stoichiometric interaction of RecA protein with single-stranded DNA promotes homologous pairing of the single strand with duplex DNA and subsequent polar formation of a heteroduplex joint. Escherichia coli single-strand-binding (SSB) protein augments these reactions. Electron microscopic observations suggest structural bases for these interactions. Without triphosphates or DNA, RecA protein forms short linear filaments. With added circular single-stranded DNA, it forms extended circular filaments as well as collapsed and aggregated complexes of protein and DNA. The extended circular filaments are stiff and regular in appearance, contrasting with the convoluted structure formed by SSB protein and single-stranded DNA. Together, these two proteins form mixed filaments, which mostly resemble the extended structures containing RecA protein; moreover, SSB protein accelerates formation of extended filaments more than 50-fold, increasing the yield of these structures at the expense of heterogeneous aggregates. Other observations further define the interactions of RecA protein with partially single-stranded DNA, and the effects of ATP gamma S on the tendency of RecA protein to form polymeric structures even in the absence of DNA.     

The regulation mechanism of the C-terminus of RecA proteins during DNA strand-exchange process

The C-terminus of Escherichia coli RecA protein can affect the DNA binding affinity, interact with accessory proteins, and regulate the RecA activity. A substantial upward shift in the pH-reaction profile of RecA-mediated DNA strand-exchange reactions was observed for C-terminal-truncated E. coli ΔC17 RecA, Deinococcus radiodurans RecA, and Deinococcus ficus RecA. Here, the process of RecA-mediated strand exchange from the beginning to the end was investigated with florescence resonance energy transfer and tethered particle motion experiments to determine the detailed regulation mechanism. RecA proteins with a shorter C-terminus possess more stable nuclei, higher DNA binding affinities, and lower protonation requirements for the formation of nucleoprotein filaments. Moreover, more stable synaptic complexes in the homologous sequence searching process were also observed for RecA proteins with a shorter C-terminus. Our results suggest that the C-terminus of RecA proteins regulates not only the formation of RecA nucleoprotein filaments but also the entrance of secondary DNA into RecA nucleoprotein filaments.     

Mutations in the N-terminal region of RecA that disrupt the stability of free protein oligomers but not RecA-DNA complexes

We have introduced targeted mutations in two areas that make up part of the RecA subunit interface. In the RecA crystal structure, cross-subunit interactions are observed between the Lys6 and Asp139 side-chains, and between the Arg28 and Asn113 side-chains. Unexpectedly, we find that mutations at Lys6 and Arg28 impose sever defects on the oligomeric stability of free RecA protein, whereas mutations at Asn113 or Asp139 do not. However, Lys6 and Arg28 mutant proteins showed an apparent normal formation of RecA-DNA complexes. These results suggest that cross-subunit contacts in this region of the protein are different for free RecA protein filaments versus RecA-DNA nucleoprotein filaments. Mutant proteins with substitutions at either Lys6 or Arg28 show partial inhibition of DNA strand exchange activity, yet the mechanistic reasons for this inhibition appear to be distinct. Although Lys6 and Arg28 appear to be more important to the stability of free RecA protein, as opposed to the stability of the catalytically active nucleoprotein filament, our results support the idea that the cross-subunit interactions made by each residue play an important role in optimizing the catalytic organization of the active RecA oligomer.     

The RecF protein antagonizes RecX function via direct interaction

The RecX protein inhibits RecA filament extension, leading to net filament disassembly. The RecF protein physically interacts with the RecX protein and protects RecA from the inhibitory effects of RecX. In vitro, efficient RecA filament formation onto single-stranded DNA binding protein (SSB)-coated circular single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) in the presence of RecX occurs only when all of the RecFOR proteins are present. The RecOR proteins contribute only to RecA filament nucleation onto SSB-coated single-stranded DNA and are unable to counter the inhibitory effects of RecX on RecA filaments. RecF protein uniquely supports substantial RecA filament extension in the presence of RecX. In vivo, RecF protein counters a RecX-mediated inhibition of plasmid recombination. Thus, a significant positive contribution of RecF to RecA filament assembly is to antagonize the effects of the negative modulator RecX, specifically during the extension phase.     

Comparison of bacteriophage T4 UvsX and human Rad51 filaments suggests that RecA-like polymers may have evolved independently

The UvsX protein from bacteriophage T4 is a member of the RecA/Rad51/RadA family of recombinases active in homologous genetic recombination. Like RecA, Rad51 and RadA, UvsX forms helical filaments on DNA. We have used electron microscopy and a novel method for image analysis of helical filaments to show that UvsX-DNA filaments exist in two different conformations: an ADP state and an ATP state. As with RecA protein, these two states have a large difference in pitch. Remarkably, even though UvsX is only weakly homologous to RecA, both UvsX filament states are more similar to the RecA crystal structure than are RecA-DNA filaments. We use this similarity to fit the RecA crystal structure into the UvsX filament, and show that two of the three previously described blocks of similarity between UvsX and RecA are involved in the subunit-subunit interface in both the UvsX filament and the RecA crystal filament. Conversely, we show that human Rad51-DNA filaments have a different subunit-subunit interface than is present in the RecA crystal, and this interface involves two blocks of sequence similarity between Rad51 and RecA that do not overlap with those found between UvsX and RecA. This suggests that helical filaments in the RecA/Rad51/RadA family may have arisen from convergent evolution, with a conserved core structure that has assembled into multimeric filaments in a number of different ways.     

Structure of helical RecA-DNA complexes. Complexes formed in the presence of ATP-gamma-S or ATP

Electron micrographs of RecA-DNA filaments, formed under several different conditions, have been analyzed and the filament images reconstructed in three dimensions. In the presence of ATP and a non-hydrolyzable ATP analog. ATP-gamma-S, the RecA protein forms with DNA a right-handed helical complex with a pitch of approximately 95 A. The most detailed view of the filament was obtained from analysis of RecA filaments on double-stranded DNA in the presence of ATP-gamma-S. There are approximately six subunits of RecA per turn of the helix, but both this number and the pitch are variable. From the examination of single filaments and filament-filament interactions, a picture of an extremely flexible protein structure emerges. The subunits of RecA protein are seen to be arranged in such a manner that the bound DNA must be partially exposed and able to come into contact with external DNA molecules. The RecA structure determined in the presence of ATP-gamma-S appears to be the same as the "pre-synaptic" state that occurs with ATP, in which there is recognition and pairing between homologous DNA molecules.     

Structural polymorphism of the RecA protein from the thermophilic bacterium Thermus aquaticus.

The Escherichia coli RecA protein has served as a model for understanding protein-catalyzed homologous recombination, both in vitro and in vivo. Although RecA proteins have now been sequenced from over 60 different bacteria, almost all of our structural knowledge about RecA has come from studies of the E. coli protein. We have used electron microscopy and image analysis to examine three different structures formed by the RecA protein from the thermophilic bacterium Thermus aquaticus. This protein has previously been shown to catalyze an in vitro strand exchange reaction at an optimal temperature of about 60 degrees C. We show that the active filament formed by the T. aquaticus RecA on DNA in the presence of a nucleotide cofactor is extremely similar to the filament formed by the E. coli protein, including the extension of DNA to a 5.1-A rise per base pair within this filament. This parameter appears highly conserved through evolution, as it has been observed for the eukaryotic RecA analogs as well. We have also characterized bundles of filaments formed by the T. aquaticus RecA in the absence of both DNA and nucleotide cofactor, as well as hexameric rings of the protein formed under all conditions examined. The bundles display a very large plasticity of mass within the RecA filament, as well as showing a polymorphism in filament-filament contacts that may be important to understanding mutations that affect surface residues on the RecA filament.     

Complementation of one RecA protein point mutation by another. Evidence for trans catalysis of ATP hydrolysis

The RecA residues Lys248 and Glu96 are closely opposed across the RecA subunit-subunit interface in some recent models of the RecA nucleoprotein filament. The K248R and E96D single mutant proteins of the Escherichia coli RecA protein each bind to DNA and form nucleoprotein filaments but do not hydrolyze ATP or dATP. A mixture of K248R and E96D single mutant proteins restores dATP hydrolysis to 25% of the wild type rate, with maximum restoration seen when the proteins are present in a 1:1 ratio. The K248R/E96D double mutant RecA protein also hydrolyzes ATP and dATP at rates up to 10-fold higher than either single mutant, although at a reduced rate compared with the wild type protein. Thus, the K248R mutation partially complements the inactive E96D mutation and vice versa. The complementation is not sufficient to allow DNA strand exchange. The K248R and E96D mutations originate from opposite sides of the subunit-subunit interface. The functional complementation suggests that Lys248 plays a significant role in ATP hydrolysis in trans across the subunit-subunit interface in the RecA nucleoprotein filament. This could be part of a mechanism for the long range coordination of hydrolytic cycles between subunits within the RecA filament.     

A key presynaptic role in transformation for a widespread bacterial protein: DprA conveys incoming ssDNA to RecA

Natural transformation is a mechanism for genetic exchange in many bacterial genera. It proceeds through the uptake of exogenous DNA and subsequent homology-dependent integration into the genome. In Streptococcus pneumoniae, this integration requires the ubiquitous recombinase, RecA, and DprA, a protein of unknown function widely conserved in bacteria. To unravel the role of DprA, we have studied the properties of the purified S. pneumoniae protein and its Bacillus subtilis ortholog (Smf). We report that DprA and Smf bind cooperatively to single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) and that these proteins both self-interact and interact with RecA. We demonstrate that DprA-RecA-ssDNA filaments are produced and that these filaments catalyze the homology-dependent formation of joint molecules. Finally, we show that while the Escherichia coli ssDNA-binding protein SSB limits access of RecA to ssDNA, DprA lowers this barrier. We propose that DprA is a new member of the recombination-mediator protein family, dedicated to natural bacterial transformation.     

The extended N-terminus of Mycobacterium smegmatis RecX potentiates its ability to antagonize RecA functions

The members of the RecX family of proteins have a unique capacity to regulate the catalytic activities of RecA/Rad51 proteins in both prokaryotic and eukaryotic organisms. However, our understanding of the functional roles of RecX in pathogenic and non-pathogenic mycobacteria has been limited by insufficient knowledge of the molecular mechanisms of its activity and regulation. Moreover, the significance of a unique 14 amino acid N-terminal extension in Mycobacterium smegmatis RecX (MsRecX) to its function remains unknown. Here, we advance our understanding of the antagonistic roles of mycobacterial RecX proteins and the functional significance of the extended N-terminus of MsRecX. The full-length MsRecX acts as an antagonist of RecA, negatively regulating RecA promoted functions, including DNA strand exchange, LexA cleavage and ATP hydrolysis, but not binding of ATP. The N-terminally truncated MsRecX variants retain the RecA inhibitory activity, albeit with lower efficiencies compared to the full-length protein. Perhaps most importantly, direct visualization of RecA nucleoprotein filaments, which had been incubated with RecX proteins, showed that they promote disassembly of nucleoprotein filaments primarily within the filaments. In addition, interaction of RecX proteins with the RecA nucleoprotein filaments results in the formation of stiff and irregularly shaped nucleoprotein filaments. Thus, these findings add an additional mechanism by which RecX disassembles RecA nucleoprotein filaments. Overall, this study provides strong evidence for the notion that the N-terminal 14 amino acid region of MsRecX plays an important role in the negative regulation of RecA functions and new insights into the molecular mechanism underlying RecX function.     

Crystal structure of the left-handed archaeal RadA helical filament: identification of a functional motif for controlling quaternary structures and enzymatic functions of RecA family proteins

The RecA family of proteins mediates homologous recombination, an evolutionarily conserved pathway that maintains genomic stability by protecting against DNA double strand breaks. RecA proteins are thought to facilitate DNA strand exchange reactions as closed-rings or as right-handed helical filaments. Here, we report the crystal structure of a left-handed Sulfolobus solfataricus RadA helical filament. Each protomer in this left-handed filament is linked to its neighbour via interactions of a β-strand polymerization motif with the neighbouring ATPase domain. Immediately following the polymerization motif, we identified an evolutionarily conserved hinge region (a subunit rotation motif) in which a 360° clockwise axial rotation accompanies stepwise structural transitions from a closed ring to the AMP–PNP right-handed filament, then to an overwound right-handed filament and finally to the left-handed filament. Additional structural and functional analyses of wild-type and mutant proteins confirmed that the subunit rotation motif is crucial for enzymatic functions of RecA family proteins. These observations support the hypothesis that RecA family protein filaments may function as rotary motors.     

A DNA pairing-enhanced conformation of bacterial RecA proteins

The RecA proteins of Escherichia coli (Ec) and Deinococcus radiodurans (Dr) both promote a DNA strand exchange reaction involving two duplex DNAs. The four-strand exchange reaction promoted by the DrRecA protein is similar to that promoted by EcRecA, except that key parts of the reaction are inhibited by Ec single-stranded DNA-binding protein (SSB). In the absence of SSB, the initiation of strand exchange is greatly enhanced by dsDNA-ssDNA junctions at the ends of DNA gaps. This same trend is seen with the EcRecA protein. The results lead to an expansion of published hypotheses for the pathway for RecA-mediated DNA pairing, in which the slow first order step (observed in several studies) involves a structural transition to a state we designate P. The P state is identical to the state found when RecA is bound to double-stranded (ds) DNA. The structural state present when the RecA protein is bound to single-stranded (ss) DNA is designated A. The DNA pairing model in turn facilitates an articulation of three additional conclusions arising from the present work. 1) When a segment of a RecA filament bound to ssDNA is forced into the P state (as RecA bound to the ssDNA immediately adjacent to dsDNA-ssDNA junction), the segment becomes "pairing enhanced." 2) The unusual DNA pairing properties of the D. radiodurans RecA protein can be explained by postulating this protein has a more stringent requirement to initiate DNA strand exchange from the P state. 3) RecA filaments bound to dsDNA (P state) have directly observable structural changes relative to RecA filaments bound to ssDNA (A state), involving the C-terminal domain.