Two-dimensional Blue native/SDS gel electrophoresis of multi-protein complexes from whole cellular lysates: a proteomics approach

Identification and characterization of multi-protein complexes is an important step toward an integrative view of protein-protein interaction networks that determine protein function and cell behavior. The limiting factor for identifying protein complexes is the method for their separation. Blue native PAGE (BN-PAGE) permits a high-resolution separation of multi-protein complexes under native conditions. To date, BN-PAGE has only been applicable to purified material. Here, we show that dialysis permits the analysis of multi-protein complexes of whole cellular lysates by BN-PAGE. We visualized different multi-protein complexes by immunoblotting including forms of the eukaryotic proteasome. Complex dynamics after gamma interferon stimulation of cells was studied, and an antibody shift assay was used to detect protein-protein interactions in BN-PAGE. Furthermore, we identified defined protein complexes of various proteins including the tumor suppressor p53 and c-Myc. Finally, we identified multi-protein complexes via mass spectrometry, showing that the method has a wide potential for functional proteomics.     

Blue native PAGE

Blue native PAGE (BN-PAGE) can be used for one-step isolation of protein complexes from biological membranes and total cell and tissue homogenates. It can also be used to determine native protein masses and oligomeric states and to identify physiological protein-protein interactions. Native complexes are recovered from gels by electroelution or diffusion and are used for 2D crystallization and electron microscopy or analyzed by in-gel activity assays or by native electroblotting and immunodetection. In this protocol, we describe methodology to perform BN-PAGE followed by (i) native extraction or native electroblotting of separated proteins, or (ii) a second dimension of tricine-SDS-PAGE or modified BN-PAGE, or (iii) a second dimension of isoelectric focusing (IEF) followed by a third dimension of tricine-SDS-PAGE for the separation of subunits of complexes. These protocols for 2D and 3D PAGE can be completed in 2 and 3 days.     

Identification of cytoplasmic and membrane-associated complexes in human embryonic stem cells using blue native PAGE

Human embryonic stem cells (hESCs) have great potential for use in developmental biology studies, functional genomics applications, drug screening, and regenerative medicine. A detailed understanding of the molecular mechanisms that are responsible for maintaining the undifferentiated and pluripotent nature of hESCs is essential for their effective therapeutic application. It has become evident that many complex cellular processes are carried out by assemblies of protein molecules (protein complexes). Blue native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (BN-PAGE) has been used to separate protein complexes from whole cell lysates. Using BN-PAGE, we resolved cytoplasmic and membrane-associated complexes from hESCs and characterised their composition, stoichiometry, and dynamics by denaturing SDS-PAGE. The reliability of the fractionation was examined by western blot analysis of membrane and cytosolic markers. MALDI TOF/TOF mass spectrometry identified 119 cytosolic and 69 membrane proteins from the BN-PAGE proteome maps. Potential protein complexes were validated by computational prediction of possible protein-protein interactions using the Search Tool for the Retrieval of Interacting Genes/Proteins (STRING) database. Based on BN-PAGE gels and validation by databases, 82 heteromultimeric and 47 homomultimeric protein complexes have been found in hESCs. Resolving some of the protein complexes provided insight into the function of previously uncharacterised complexes in hESCs.     

Advantages and limitations of clear-native PAGE

Clear-native PAGE (CN-PAGE) separates acidic water-soluble and membrane proteins (pI < 7) in an acrylamide gradient gel, and usually has lower resolution than blue-native PAGE (BN-PAGE). The migration distance depends on the protein intrinsic charge, and on the pore size of the gradient gel. This complicates estimation of native masses and oligomerization states when compared to BN-PAGE, which uses negatively charged protein-bound Coomassie-dye to impose a charge shift on the proteins. Therefore, BN-PAGE rather than CN-PAGE is commonly used for standard analyses. However, CN-PAGE offers advantages whenever Coomassie-dye interferes with techniques required to further analyze the native complexes, e.g., determination of catalytic activities, as shown here for mitochondrial ATP synthase, or efficient microscale separation of membrane protein complexes for fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) analyses. CN-PAGE is milder than BN-PAGE. Especially the combination of digitonin and CN-PAGE can retain labile supramolecular assemblies of membrane protein complexes that are dissociated under the conditions of BN-PAGE. Enzymatically active oligomeric states of mitochondrial ATP synthase previously not detected using BN-PAGE were identified by CN-PAGE.     

A comparative approach towards thylakoid membrane proteome analysis of unicellular green alga Scenedesmus obliquus

The chlorophyll (Chl)-containing membrane protein complexes from the green alga Scenedesmus obliquus have been isolated from the thylakoid membranes by solubilization with dodecyl-beta-maltoside and fractionation using a sucrose density gradient. The Chl-containing protein fractions were characterized by absorption spectroscopy, tricine SDS PAGE, BN-PAGE, and dynamic light scattering (DLS). BN-PAGE showed the presence of seven protein complexes with molecular weights in the range of 68, 118, 157, 320, 494, 828 and 955 kDa, respectively. Furthermore, light scattering reveals the simultaneous presence of particles of different sizes in the 3-4 nm and 6.0-7.5 nm range, respectively. The smaller size is related to the hydrodynamic radius of the trimer Light Harvesting Complex (LHCII), whereas the larger size is associated with the presence of photosystem I and photosystem II reaction centers. Additionally, functional information regarding protein-protein interactions was deconvoluted using coupling 2-D BN-PAGE, MALDI-TOF MS and a detailed mapping of S. obliquus photosynthetic proteome of the solubilized thylakoid membranes is therefore presented.     

Low-SDS Blue native PAGE

SDS normally is strictly avoided during Blue native (BN) PAGE because it leads to disassembly of protein complexes and unfolding of proteins. Here, we report a modified BN-PAGE procedure, which is based on low-SDS treatment of biological samples prior to native gel electrophoresis. Using mitochondrial OXPHOS complexes from Arabidopsis as a model system, low SDS concentrations are shown to partially dissect protein complexes in a very defined and reproducible way. If combined with 2-D BN/SDS-PAGE, generated subcomplexes and their subunits can be systematically investigated, allowing insights into the internal architecture of protein complexes. Furthermore, a 3-D BN/low-SDS BN/SDS-PAGE system is introduced to facilitate structural analysis of individual protein complexes without their previous purification.     

Blue Native electrophoresis to study mitochondrial and other protein complexes

The biogenesis and maintenance of mitochondria relies on a sizable number of proteins. Many of these proteins are organized into complexes, which are located in the mitochondrial inner membrane. Blue Native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (BN-PAGE) is a method for the isolation of intact protein complexes. Although it was initially used to study mitochondrial respiratory chain enzymes, it can also be applied to other protein complexes. The use of BN-PAGE has increased exponentially over the past few years and new applications have been developed. Here we review how to set up the basic system and outline modifications that can be applied to address specific research questions. Increasing the upper mass limit of complexes that can be separated by BN-PAGE can be achieved by using agarose instead of acrylamide. BN-PAGE can also be used to study assembly of mitochondrial protein complexes. Other applications include in-gel measurements of enzyme activity by histochemical staining and preparative native electrophoresis to isolate a protein complex. Finally, new ways of identifying protein spots in Blue Native gels using mass spectrometry are briefly discussed.     

A comparative approach towards thylakoid membrane proteome analysis of unicellular green alga Scenedesmus obliquus

The chlorophyll (Chl)-containing membrane protein complexes from the green alga Scenedesmus obliquus have been isolated from the thylakoid membranes by solubilization with dodecyl-β-maltoside and fractionation using a sucrose density gradient. The Chl-containing protein fractions were characterized by absorption spectroscopy, tricine SDS PAGE, BN-PAGE, and dynamic light scattering (DLS). BN-PAGE showed the presence of seven protein complexes with molecular weights in the range of 68, 118, 157, 320, 494, 828 and 955 kDa, respectively. Furthermore, light scattering reveals the simultaneous presence of particles of different sizes in the 3-4 nm and 6.0-7.5 nm range, respectively. The smaller size is related to the hydrodynamic radius of the trimer Light Harvesting Complex (LHCII), whereas the larger size is associated with the presence of photosystem I and photosystem II reaction centers. Additionally, functional information regarding protein-protein interactions was deconvoluted using coupling 2-D BN-PAGE, MALDI-TOF MS and a detailed mapping of S. obliquus photosynthetic proteome of the solubilized thylakoid membranes is therefore presented.     

High throughput two-dimensional blue-native electrophoresis: a tool for functional proteomics of cytoplasmatic protein complexes from Chlorobium tepidum

Chl. tepidum is a Gram-negative green-sulfur bacterium, which is strict by anaerobic and grows by utilizing sulfide or thiosulfate as an electron source. Blue native-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (BN-PAGE) is widely used for the analysis of oligomeric state and molecular mass non-dissociated protein complexes. In this study, a number of proteomic techniques were used to investigate the oligomeric state enzymes. In particular, the Chl. tepidum-soluble proteome was monitored under native condition by using BN-PAGE. The BN-PAGE protein complexes map was analyzed by MALDI-TOF MS after trypsin treatment and from 42 BN proteins bands, 62 different proteins were identified. Additionally, functional information regarding protein–protein interactions was assembled, by coupling 2-D BN-PAGE with MALDI-TOF MS. One-hundred and seventy gel bands were spotted, out of which 187 different proteins were identified. The identified proteins belong to various functional categories like energy metabolism, protein synthesis, amino acid biosynthesis, central intermediate metabolism, and biosynthesis of cofactors indicating the potential of the method for elucidation of functional proteomes.     

An alternative strategy for the membrane proteome analysis of the green sulfur bacterium Chlorobium tepidum using blue native PAGE and 2-D PAGE on purified membranes

To avoid the specific problems concerning intrinsic membrane proteins in proteome analysis, an alternative strategy is described that is complementary to previous investigations using 2-D polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) techniques. The strategy involves (a) obtaining purified preparations of the membranes from Chlorobium tepidum by washing with 2 M NaBr, which removed membrane-associated soluble proteins and membrane-associated organelles; (b) separation of membrane protein complexes using 1-D Blue-native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (BN-PAGE) after solubilization with n-dodecyl-beta-d-maltoside (DDM); (c) combination of the BN with Tricine-SDS-PAGE; (d) high-throughput mass spectrometric analysis after gel band excision, in-gel digestion, and MALDI target spotting; and (e) protein identification from mixtures of tryptic peptides by peptide mass fingerprinting. Using this approach, we identified 143 different proteins, 70 of which have not been previously reported using 2-D PAGE techniques. Membrane proteins with up to 14 transmembrane helices were found, and this procedure proved to be efficient with proteins within a wide pI range (4.4-11.6). About 54% of the identified membrane proteins belong to various functional categories like energy metabolism, transport, signal transduction, and protein translocation, while for the others, a function is not yet known, indicating the potential of the method for the elucidation of the membrane proteomes in general.     

Application of "blue native" electrophoresis in the studies of mitochondrial respiratory chain complexes in physiology and pathology

"Blue Native" polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (BN-PAGE), originally described by Sch?gger and von Jagow in 1991, is an elegant method to study protein complexes from mitochondrial membranes. BN-PAGE, commonly used in molecular biology to study composition of protein complexes and protein-protein interactions, enables separation of respiratory chain complexes keeping their properties and enzymatic activities unchanged. BN-PAGE, supplemented by other methods, e.g. in gel activity assay, SDS-PAGE (as a first or second dimension) can be successfully adapted for diagnosis of mitochondrial diseases connected with abnormalities of the respiratory chain. Therefore, to make a correct diagnosis of the deficiency of respiratory chain complexes, other methods, as histochemical colorimetric reactions allowing evaluation of the OXPHOS catalytic activity in individual cells and spectrophotometric technique should be used simultaneously with BN-PAGE.     

Gas chromatographic determination and mechanism of formation of D-amino acids occurring in fermented and roasted cocoa beans, cocoa powder, chocolate and cocoa shell

Summary. Pseudomonas sp. strain phDV1, being a phenol degrading bacterium, has been found to utilize phenol as sole carbon source via the meta pathway. Blue native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (BN-PAGE) is widely used for the analysis of oligomeric state and molecular mass non-dissociated protein complexes. In this study, a number of proteomic techniques were used to investigate the oligomeric state enzymes involved in the aromatic degradation pathway. In particular, the Pseudomonas sp. strain phDV1 proteome was monitored under two different growth substrate conditions, using glucose or phenol as sole carbon source. The protein complexes map was compared by BN-PAGE after fractionation by sucrose density centrifugation of the cell extracts. Multiple differences were detected. Further, analysis and identification of the subunit composition of these complexes was carried out using MALDI-TOF MS, allowing the identification of 49 proteins. Additionally, functional information regarding protein–protein interactions was assembled, by coupling 2-D BN-PAGE with MALDI-TOF MS. Application of this functional proteomics method resulted in an higher number of the identified proteins.     

Analysis of 953 Human Proteins from a Mitochondrial HEK293 Fraction by Complexome Profiling

Complexome profiling is a novel technique which uses shotgun proteomics to establish protein migration profiles from fractionated blue native electrophoresis gels. Here we present a dataset of blue native electrophoresis migration profiles for 953 proteins by complexome profiling. By analysis of mitochondrial ribosomal complexes we demonstrate its potential to verify putative protein-protein interactions identified by affinity purification – mass spectrometry studies. Protein complexes were extracted in their native state from a HEK293 mitochondrial fraction and separated by blue native gel electrophoresis. Gel lanes were cut into gel slices of even size and analyzed by shotgun proteomics. Subsequently, the acquired protein migration profiles were analyzed for co-migration via hierarchical cluster analysis. This dataset holds great promise as a comprehensive resource for de novo identification of protein-protein interactions or to underpin and prioritize candidate protein interactions from other studies. To demonstrate the potential use of our dataset we focussed on the mitochondrial translation machinery. Our results show that mitoribosomal complexes can be analyzed by blue native gel electrophoresis, as at least four distinct complexes. Analysis of these complexes confirmed that 24 proteins that had previously been reported to co-purify with mitoribosomes indeed co-migrated with subunits of the mitochondrial ribosome. Co-migration of several proteins involved in biogenesis of inner mitochondrial membrane complexes together with mitoribosomal complexes suggested the possibility of co-translational assembly in human cells. Our data also highlighted a putative ribonucleotide complex that potentially contains MRPL10, MRPL12 and MRPL53 together with LRPPRC and SLIRP.     

Phosphoprotein profiling by PA-GeLC-MS/MS

A significant consequence of protein phosphorylation is to alter protein-protein interactions, leading to dynamic regulation of the components of protein complexes that direct many core biological processes. Recent proteomic studies have populated databases with extensive compilations of cellular phosphoproteins and phosphorylation sites and a similarly deep coverage of the subunit compositions and interactions in multiprotein complexes. However, considerably less data are available on the dynamics of phosphorylation, composition of multiprotein complexes or that define their interdependence. We describe a method to identify candidate phosphoprotein complexes by combining phosphoprotein affinity chromatography, separation by size, denaturing gel electrophoresis, protein identification by tandem mass spectrometry, and informatics analysis. Toward developing phosphoproteome profiling, we have isolated native phosphoproteins using a phosphoprotein affinity matrix, Pro-Q Diamond resin (Molecular Probes-Invitrogen). This resin quantitatively retains phosphoproteins and associated proteins from cell extracts. Pro-Q Diamond purification of a yeast whole cell extract followed by 1-D PAGE separation, proteolysis and ESI LC-MS/MS, a method we term PA-GeLC-MS/MS, yielded 108 proteins, a majority of which were known phosphoproteins. To identify proteins that were purified as parts of phosphoprotein complexes, the Pro-Q eluate was separated into two fractions by size, <100 kDa and >100 kDa, before analysis by PAGE and ESI LC-MS/MS and the component proteins queried against databases to identify protein-protein interactions. The <100 kDa fraction was enriched in phosphoproteins indicating the presence of monomeric phosphoproteins. The >100 kDa fraction contained 171 proteins of 20-80 kDa, nearly all of which participate in known protein-protein interactions. Of these 171, few are known phosphoproteins, consistent with their purification by participation in protein complexes. By comparing the results of our phosphoprotein profiling with the informational databases on phosphoproteomics, protein-protein interactions and protein complexes, we have developed an approach to examining the correlation between protein interactions and protein phosphorylation.     

LC‐MS/MS as an alternative for SDS‐PAGE in blue native analysis of protein complexes

Two‐dimensional blue native/SDS‐PAGE is widely applied to investigate native protein–protein interactions, particularly those within membrane multi‐protein complexes. MS has enabled the application of this approach at the proteome scale, typically by analysis of picked protein spots. Here, we investigated the potential of using LC‐MS/MS as an alternative for SDS‐PAGE in blue native (BN) analysis of protein complexes. By subjecting equal slices from BN gel lanes to label‐free semi‐quantitative LC‐MS/MS, we determined an abundance profile for each protein across the BN gel, and used these profiles to identify potentially interacting proteins by protein correlation profiling. We demonstrate the feasibility of this approach by considering the oxidative phosphorylation complexes I–V in the native human embryonic kidney 293 mitochondrial fraction, showing that the method is capable of detecting both the fully assembled complexes as well as assembly/turnover intermediates of complex I (NADH:ubiquinone oxidoreductase). Using protein correlation profiling with a profile for subunits NDUFS2, 3, 7 and 8 we identified multiple proteins possibly involved in the biogenesis of complex I, including the recently implicated chaperone C6ORF66 and a novel candidate, C3ORF60.     

Purification of multisubunit membrane protein complexes: isolation of chloroplast FoF1-ATP synthase, CFo and CF1 by blue native electrophoresis.

The proton-ATP synthase of thylakoid membranes from chloroplasts (CFoF1) is composed of two parts with different structural and functional properties: the membrane-integral, proton-conducting complex CFo and the hydrophilic part, CF1 which catalyze the formation of adenosine-5'-triphosphate (ATP). To date it is difficult to isolate functional CFoF1 from thylakoids in high purity and yield. Blue native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (BN-PAGE) was therefore successfully employed to isolate CFoF1 in a one-step procedure from thylakoid membranes. Using a cathode buffer with low Coomassie Blue G-250 (CBG) concentration (0.002%), CFoF1 remains intact and can be obtained in high purity from solubilized, prepurified ATP synthase. Using BN-PAGE and a cathode buffer with 0.02% CBG, the ATP synthase bifurcates, and we were able to isolate both parts, CFo and CF1, separately. CFoF1, CFo, and CF1, respectively, were electroeluted nearly quantitatively electroeluted from the gel. BN-PAGE is a generally applicable method for the isolation and characterization of multisubunit membrane protein complexes in their native structure. However, the combination of neutral detergents and the negatively charged dye CBG seems to mimic properties of mild ionic detergents. This effect can lead to dissociation of labile subunits and subcomplexes, especially when delipidated membrane protein complexes are applied to BN-PAGE. By variation of the initial electrophoresis conditions, i.e., dye concentration in the cathode buffer, amount of lipid and detergent, BN-PAGE can be used for the isolation of either intact complexes or of subcomplexes.     

Coupling of native liquid phase isoelectrofocusing and blue native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis: a potent tool for native membrane multiprotein complex separation

In this study, a new 3D native electrophoretic protocol is proposed for an exhaustive separation and identification of membrane proteins. It is based on native liquid phase isoelectrofocusing (N-LP-IEF) of protein complexes in the first dimension, followed by blue native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (BN-PAGE) in the second dimension, where both the pI and the molecular masses of protein complexes (2D N-LP-IEF-BN) were used to separate them in their native form. Finally, each single component can be resolved using denaturing electrophoresis (3D N-LP-IEF-BN-SDS-PAGE). The thylakoid membrane of spinach which contains four big protein complexes was chosen as a model for setting up analytical methods suitable for any membrane proteins. The pI-based MicroRotofor has a number of advantages over BN-PAGE: it does not require the addition of any chemicals, and separation of complexes is based on the protein's real physicochemical properties which inevitably change when dye is added. Results were more easily reproduced than with BN, and the pI of each native complex was also determined. Although some fractions still contained comigrating complexes after MicroRotofor, these were subsequently separated by BN for further analysis. Thus, highly hydrophobic complexes, such as ATP-synthetas and Cyt b6/f, were separated in native form as were various complexes of LHCII trimers, which have different pI but similar molecular masses. SDS-PAGE revealed almost all the subunits from the four photosynthetic complexes, indicating that by using 3D N-LP-IEF-BN-SDS-PAGE it is possible to achieve a greater degree of component identification than with 2D BN-SDS-PAGE.     

Rhizobial nod gene-inducing activity in pea nodulation mutants: dissociation of nodulation and flavonoid response

With the characterization of the total genomes of Arabidopsis thaliana and Oryza sativa , several putative plasma membrane components have been identified. However, a lack of knowledge at the protein level, especially for hydrophobic proteins, have hampered analyses of physiological changes. To address whether protein complexes may be present in the native membrane, we subjected plasma membranes isolated from Spinacia oleracea leaves to blue-native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (BN-PAGE). BN-PAGE is well established in the separation of functional membrane protein complexes from mitochondria and chloroplasts, but a resolved protein complex pattern from PM of eukaryotic cells has previously not been reported. Using this method, protein complexes from Spinacia oleracea PM could be efficiently solubilized and separated, including the highly hydrophobic aquaporin (apparent molecular mass 230 kDa), a putative tetramer of H⁺-ATPase, and several less abundant complexes with apparent masses around or above 750 kDa. After denaturation and separation of the complexes into their subunits in a second dimension (SDS-PAGE), several of the complexes were identified as hydrophobic membrane proteins. Large amounts of protein (up to 1 mg) can be resolved in each lane, which suggests that the method could be used to study also low-abundance protein complexes, e.g. under different physiological conditions.