A commentary on the interpretation of in vitro biochemical measures of brown adipose tissue thermogenesis

In this article we comment on the various in vitro biochemical measurements employed to assess the thermogenic activity and capacity of brown adipose tissue. The meaning and significance of changes in tissue weight, protein content, cell number, and mitochondrial mass are each summarized. In addition, various indices of the proton conductance pathway-mitochondrial swelling, proton conductance, uncoupling protein concentration, and GDP binding studies--are discussed. The issue of unmasking and masking of GDP binding sites is reviewed; recent reports have clearly demonstrated unmasking and masking, and it is concluded that GDP binding studies are an index of the activity of uncoupling protein, rather than a measure of its concentration. It is suggested that tissue mass, mitochondrial content, mitochondrial GDP binding, and uncoupling protein concentration represent core measurements for the biochemical assessment of the thermogenic activity and capacity of brown adipose tissue. Auxiliary measurements include Scatchard analysis of GDP binding data to distinguish changes in the number of binding sites from potential changes in Kd, and mitochondrial swelling studies, as an additional index of proton permeability. The distinction between thermogenic activity (GDP binding, proton permeability) and capacity (uncoupling protein content), both on a per unit of mitochondrial protein and per tissue basis, is emphasized.     

Acute effects of a beta-adrenoceptor agonist (BRL 26830A) on rat brown-adipose-tissue mitochondria. Increased GDP binding and GDP-sensitive proton conductance without changes in the concentration of uncoupling protein.

GDP binding, proton conductance and the specific concentration of uncoupling protein were measured in brown-adipose-tissue mitochondria of rats treated acutely with the novel beta-agonist, BRL 26830A. At 1 h after dosing with BRL 26830A, mitochondrial GDP binding was increased more than 2-fold. The increase in binding resulted from an increase in the number of binding sites. An iterative analysis of Scatchard binding data suggested that there is only one high-affinity GDP-binding site (Kd 0.3 microM) in brown-adipose-tissue mitochondria. The acute increase in GDP binding produced by treatment with BRL 26830A occurred without any alteration in the specific mitochondrial concentration of uncoupling protein, as determined by radioimmunoassay. Treatment with the beta-agonist did, however, lead to a small increase in the GDP-sensitive component of mitochondrial proton conductance. These results indicate that GDP-binding sites on uncoupling protein can be rapidly unmasked after treatment with a brown-fat-specific beta-agonist, and that the increase in binding reflects an increase in the activity of the mitochondrial proton-conductance pathway.     

An immunological study of the uncoupling protein of brown adipose tissue mitochondria

1. Ewes were injected with purified 32,000-Mr uncoupling protein from mitochondria of brown adipose tissue of cold-adapted rats in order to raise antibodies. 2. The existence of antibodies in the plasma of ewes and the cross-reactivity of plasmas were demonstrated and studied by 125I-labelled antigen-antibody reaction, double immunodiffusion, the inhibition of GDP binding to the 32,000 Mr protein and by immunohistochemistry. 3. The antibodies raised against the homogeneous protein yielded a single immunoprecipitation band with detergent-solubilized mitochondrial membranes of brown adipose tissue from rat, hamster, guinea-pig, rabbit and with the purified uncoupling protein of these animals. No immunoprecipitation was obtained with the protein purified from brown adipose tissue of term lamb foetus. 4. The GDP-binding activity of the uncoupling protein (isolated or in solubilized membranes) was largely inhibited by the antiserum. 5. The anti-(rat uncoupling protein) could not cross-react with solubilized membranes from liver or muscle, nor with the purified beef heart or rat liver ADP/ATP translocator.     

Increased GDP binding and thermogenic activity in brown adipose tissue mitochondria during arousal of the hibernating garden dormouse (Eliomys quercinus L.).

1. The thermogenic activity of brown adipose tissue in hibernating garden dormice during hypothermic torpor and at different states of arousal were studied. High levels of GDP binding were observed on isolated brown fat mitochondria, indicating that the thermogenic proton conductance pathway is very active in brown fat during arousal. 2. In order to investigate this phenomenon, the uncoupling protein was assessed by immunological assay and the mRNA for UCP was analysed. 3. Animals during arousal exhibited neither increase in UCPmRNA nor an increase in UCP. 4. Our results suggest that during the rewarming of garden dormice there is an acute unmasking of GDP binding sites on the protein.     

Immunochemical detection and quantitation of brown adipose tissue uncoupling protein

A polyclonal antisera against rat brown adipose tissue mitochondrial uncoupling protein was used to examine mitochondrial samples from liver and white and brown adipose tissue from several mammalian species. A sodium dodecyl sulfate--polyacrylamide gel electrophoretic separation of proteins combined with an immunochemical method allowed for visualization of antigen--antibody complexes on nitrocellulose blots. Hamster, cavy, monkey, and mouse brown adipose tissue mitochondrial samples cross-reacted with the antisera. Mitochondria prepared from white fat obtained from young swine and sheep contained two closely migrating, antigenically active proteins. Hepatic mitochondria samples did not contain antigenically active protein. Reflectance densitometry was used for quantitation of the uncoupling protein in various mitochondrial samples. In rats fed diets low in protein, there appears to be a dissociation between the concentration of uncoupling protein and the number of nucleotide binding sites as given by the [3H]GDP binding assay. These results are indicative of a physiological activation of the uncoupling protein.     

Evidence for unmasking of rat brown-adipose-tissue mitochondrial GDP-binding sites in response to acute cold exposure. Effects of washing with albumin on GDP binding.

Rats, previously acclimated to 29 degrees C, were moved into the cold (4 degrees C) for 2 h. Scatchard analysis of GDP binding to the brown-adipose-tissue mitochondria of these animals showed a 2.3-fold increase in the number of high-affinity sites and a 1.5-fold increase in the number of low-affinity sites compared with binding in animals maintained at 29 degrees C. Immunochemical determination showed no increase in the amount of mitochondrial uncoupling protein during this period. This strongly suggests an unmasking of existing GDP-binding sites before a detectable increase in synthesis of uncoupling protein can occur. Washing with albumin increased the number of GDP-binding sites of brown-adipose-tissue mitochondria from both warm-housed and cold-exposed animals to the same extent. This indicates that the effects of washing with albumin and cold exposure are independent and additive.     

Evidence that fasting can induce a selective loss of uncoupling protein from brown adipose tissue mitochondria of mice

The effects of fasting and refeeding on the concentration of uncoupling protein in brown adipose tissue mitochondria have been investigated in mice. Fasting mice for 48 h led to a large decrease in the total cytochrome oxidase activity of the interscapular brown fat pad. Mitochondrial GDP binding and the specific mitochondrial concentration of uncoupling protein also fell on fasting. After 24 h refeeding both GDP binding and the mitochondrial concentration of uncoupling protein were normalized, but there was no alteration in the total tissue cytochrome oxidase activity. Fasting appears to induce a selective loss of uncoupling protein from brown adipose tissue mitochondria, which is rapidly reversible on refeeding.     

Unmasking of GDP binding sites on hamster brown adipose tissue mitochondria and uncoupling protein.

1. A rapid unmasking of GDP binding sites on brown adipose tissue (BAT) mitochondria was observed when hamsters acclimatized to 28 degrees C were exposed to a temperature of 4 degrees C for 2 hr. 2. No rapid unmasking of GDP binding sites was observed when hamsters housed at 22 degrees C were briefly exposed to 4 degrees C. 3. The amount of GDP bound to BAT mitochondria from hamsters increased during 2 weeks of exposure to 4 degrees C, but did not change between 2 weeks and 30 days of cold exposure. 4. Incubation of mitochondria with 10 mM Mg2+ prior to the GDP binding assay increased the subsequent GDP binding to BAT mitochondria from hamsters housed at 28, 22 or 4 degrees C, albeit to different degrees. 5. The amount of GDP bound to uncoupling proteins isolated from untreated and Mg(2+)-treated mitochondria of hamsters and rats was measured. Scatchard analyses of the binding of GDP to purified uncoupling protein indicate that increases in the number of binding sites due to Mg2+ treatment of mitochondria do not change the affinity of the protein for GDP.     

The concentration of uncoupling protein correlates with Mg2+ activated mitochondrial binding of GDP

Rats were housed at 4 degrees C for periods of up to 26 days. As little as 2 h of cold exposure caused an increase in the binding of [3H]GDP to mitochondria from brown adipose tissue. Incubation of mitochondria in vitro with 10 mM Mg2+ caused a marked increase in the subsequent binding of GDP to mitochondria from rats housed at 28 degrees C and a smaller increase in that from rats exposed to 4 degrees C for 2 h. Chronic exposure to cold led to an even greater increase in the amount of GDP bound to mitochondria incubated with Mg2+. The time course for the increase in the concentration of uncoupling protein was compared with that for GDP binding to mitochondria with and without Mg2+ treatment. The concentration of uncoupling protein appears to be correlated with the GDP-binding values for mitochondria treated with Mg2+ (r = 0.70) but not with the GDP binding to untreated mitochondria (r = 0.36). Therefore, the binding of GDP to untreated mitochondria may represent thermogenic activity at the time of death, whereas that after treatment with Mg2+ may more closely reflect total thermogenic capacity of the mitochondrion.     

Uncoupling protein in human brown adipose tissue mitochondria. Isolation and detection by specific antiserum

A protein of Mr 32 000 has been isolated from human infant brown adipose tissue mitochondria following the procedure used to purify the uncoupling protein from rat brown adipose tissue mitochondria. A specific antiserum has been raised against the human 32 kDa protein, and used to detect it by probing mitochondrial proteins separated by SDS-PAGE. The protein is present in large amounts in brown adipose tissue but is undetectable in human liver, heart or white adipose tissue. It has strong immunological cross-reactivity with rat brown adipose tissue uncoupling protein.     

Role of neural input in photoperiod-induced changes in hamster brown adipose tissue

Repeated injections of 6-hydroxydopamine in Syrian hamster neonates maintained under long-day (16L:8D) photoperiod for 30 days retarded body growth and cellular proliferation in brown adipose tissue but did not affect the cellular content of mitochondrial proteins. Sympathectomy reduced GDP binding to isolated mitochondria without affecting the organelle uncoupling protein (UCP) content. Unilateral surgical denervation of the brown fat pad of 30-day-old hamsters caused loss of tissue protein and succinate dehydrogenase as well as reductions in GDP binding and UCP content of isolated mitochondria but did not prevent an increase in GDP binding observed after 1 month exposure to a short-day photoperiod. The increased GDP binding was not due to increased UCP content. These results indicate that an adrenergic neural input may not be essential for UCP expression in Syrian hamsters and that changes in GDP binding observed in a short-day photoperiod environment can be observed in denervated tissue in the absence of changes in mitochondrial UCP content.     

Functional atrophy of brown adipose tissue during lactation in mice. Effects of lactation and weaning on mitochondrial GDP binding and uncoupling protein.

The thermogenic activity and capacity of brown adipose tissue were determined in mice during lactation and after weaning. There was a marked fall during lactation in the mitochondrial content of the tissue, and in GDP binding and the specific mitochondrial concentration of uncoupling protein. The lactation-induced functional atrophy of brown adipose tissue was fully reversible after weaning; mitochondrial content and the mitochondrial concentration of uncoupling protein were both restored, although GDP binding was not normalized.     

Molecular approach to thermogenesis in brown adipose tissue. Cell-free translation of mRNA and characterization of the mitochondrial uncoupling protein

In order to develop a molecular approach of the thermogenesis mechanism in brown adipose tissue, cell-free translation was performed with mRNA obtained from control or thermoactive brown adipose tissue. Alterations were observed on analysis of the newly synthesized proteins and in particular at the 32,000 dalton level. Experiments using antibodies against the purified characteristic 32,000-dalton uncoupling protein of brown fat mitochondria were carried out. They indicated that the uncoupling protein was synthesized in the reticulocyte lysate with the same apparent molecular weight as the mature form. It is suggested that the development of the thermogenic capacity of brown fat cells is accompanied by an increase in specific mRNA coding for the uncoupling mitochondrial protein and that such a system could be an interesting one for study of mitochondrial membrane biogenesis.     

The Effects of Calcium Channel Blocker Benidipine and Calmodulin Antagonist W7 on GDP-Binding Capacity of Brown Adipose Tissue in Mice

It has been suggested that increased dietary calcium intake can attenuate obesity. Calcium antagonists, such as benidipine, also have been shown to have an anti-obesity effect. However, the mechanism for calcium-related anti-obesity effect has not yet been established. A defective brown adipose tissue thermogenesis has been shown in obese rodents. This study was designed to examine the direct effects of calcium channel blocker benidipine and calmodulin antagonist W7 administration on the adaptive thermogenesis in brown adipose tissue taken from the genetically obese mice and their lean controls. The GDP binding to brown-fat cell mitochondria was used as a brown adipose tissue thermogenic index. The results show that benidipine treatment had no marked effect on brown-fat cell GDP-binding capacities in both obese and lean mice. However, GDP-binding capacities were significantly reduced in both obese and lean mice after the W7 administration. The results of this study support the previous finding that benidipine did not have direct thermogenic effect on brown adipose tissue and suggest that the change in intracellular calmodulin availability might contribute to the adaptive thermogenesis in brown adipose tissue.     

Sequential changes in brown adipose tissue composition, cytochrome oxidase activity and GDP binding throughout pregnancy and lactation in the rat

The sequential appearance of changes in interscapular brown adipose tissue composition, cytochrome oxidase activity and GDP binding was studied throughout pregnancy and lactation in the rat. Brown adipose tissue was hypertrophied during pregnancy because of progressive lipid accumulation, whereas its mitochondrial component and GDP binding to brown fat mitochondria were unchanged. In early lactation (day 5) there was a decrease in the overall GDP binding to brown fat only because of the lower mitochondrial protein content. In late stages of lactation (days 10 and 15), the amount of tissue and its mitochondrial protein content were minimal and the GDP binding per mitochondrial protein decreased substantially. Scatchard analysis in day-15-lactating rats indicated a large decrease in GDP binding sites without any changes in affinity. It is concluded that the diminished thermogenic activity of brown fat in lactation is attained through changes at different structural levels of the tissue occurring in a characteristic sequential trend; first a reduction in its mitochondrial component, and only later, at mid-lactation, a decrease in the specific mitochondrial proton conductance pathway activity.     

Uncoupling Protein 1 Decreases Superoxide Production in Brown Adipose Tissue Mitochondria

In thermogenic brown adipose tissue, uncoupling protein 1 (UCP1) catalyzes the dissipation of mitochondrial proton motive force as heat. In a cellular environment of high oxidative capacity such as brown adipose tissue (BAT), mitochondrial uncoupling could also reduce deleterious reactive oxygen species, but the specific involvement of UCP1 in this process is disputed. By comparing brown adipose tissue mitochondria of wild type mice and UCP1-ablated litter mates, we show that UCP1 potently reduces mitochondrial superoxide production after cold acclimation and during fatty acid oxidation. We address the sites of superoxide production and suggest diminished probability of “reverse electron transport” facilitated by uncoupled respiration as the underlying mechanism of reactive oxygen species suppression in BAT. Furthermore, ablation of UCP1 represses the cold-stimulated increase of substrate oxidation normally seen in active BAT, resulting in lower superoxide production, presumably avoiding deleterious oxidative damage. We conclude that UCP1 allows high oxidative capacity without promoting oxidative damage by simultaneously lowering superoxide production.     

Uncoupling protein and its mRNA in brown adipose tissue of newborn rabbits

Guanosine diphosphate binding to the uncoupling protein of isolated mitochondria of brown adipose tissue in newborn rabbits was measured as an index of thermogenic activity. The binding was 0.281 +/- 0.022 nmol GDP/mg mitochondrial protein at 1 day of age, 0.214 +/- 0.017 at 3 days, 0.428 +/- 0.038 at 5 days, and 0.208 +/- 0.016 at 7 days. The increase in binding between 3 and 7 days of age suggests that the brown fat has an increased thermogenic capacity at that age. In addition, the potential for synthesis of the uncoupling protein was investigated in 1- to 5-day-old newborn rabbits by probing the total cellular ribonucleic acid for the messenger that codes for uncoupling protein. The amount of uncoupling protein messenger was highest at 1 day of age and declined at least until 5 days of age. Because the amount of uncoupling protein messenger decreased as the GDP binding increased, the results suggest that either the initially translated uncoupling protein was unmasked at about 5 days of age or there was a delay in the incorporation of uncoupling protein into the mitochondrial inner membrane, or both.     

Rapid quantitation of uncoupling protein in brown adipose tissue mitochondria by a dot immunobinding ("dot blot") procedure: application to the measurement of uncoupling protein in Richardson's ground squirrel, rats, and mice

A dot immunobinding ("dot blot") method for measuring uncoupling protein in brown adipose tissue mitochondria is described. Mitochondrial proteins were solubilized in sodium dodecyl sulfate and applied directly to a nitrocellulose membrane housed in a 96-well microfiltration manifold. Spare binding sites on the nitrocellulose membrane were blocked with bovine serum albumin and then anti-(uncoupling protein) serum was applied. The antigen-antibody complex was detected by the addition of 125I-labelled protein A. Each nitrocellulose "dot" was cut out and its radioactivity was counted. A calibration curve was constructed from purified uncoupling protein standards, taken through the entire procedure. The dot immunobinding method is sensitive (nanogram quantities of uncoupling protein), and in contrast to conventional radioimmunoassay and enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay procedures, it is also rapid and appears to be very robust. The method has been successfully applied to the measurement of uncoupling protein in brown adipose tissue mitochondria of Richardson's ground squirrel, rats, and mice.     

The role of UCP 1 in production of reactive oxygen species by mitochondria isolated from brown adipose tissue

We provide evidence that ablation or inhibition of, uncoupling protein 1 increases the rate of reactive oxygen containing species production by mitochondria from brown adipose tissue, no matter what electron transport chain substrate is used (succinate, glycerol-3-phosphate or pyruvate/malate). Consistent with these data are our observations that (a) the mitochondrial membrane potential is maximal when uncoupling protein 1 is ablated or inhibited and (b) oxygen consumption rates in mitochondria from uncoupling protein 1 knock-out mice, are significantly lower than those from wild-type mice, but equivalent to those from wild-type mice in the presence of GDP. In summary, we show that uncoupling protein 1 can affect reactive oxygen containing species production by isolated mitochondria from brown adipose tissue.     

Postnatal appearance of uncoupling protein and formation of thermogenic mitochondria in hamster brown adipose tissue

Brown adipose tissue of developing hamster was characterized by western blotting, enzyme activity measurements and immunoelectron microscopy. During the first postnatal week the tissue contained significant amounts of differentiating mitochondria and comparable quantities of active cytochrome oxidase and ATP synthase. The uncoupling protein appeared on the 7/8th day and its specific content increased 80-times between day 8 and day 17. In parallel, the specific content and activity of cytochrome oxidase increased 3-times but ATP synthase decreased 2-times. The total content of uncoupling protein and of cytochrome oxidase in interscapular brown adipose tissue increased 360- and 11-times, respectively. Analysis of isolated mitochondria showed that the observed differences result mainly from changes of the enzymic equipment of the mitochondrial membrane. During the same interval, propylthiouracil-insensitive "type II' thyroxine 5'-deiodinase activity in brown adipose tissue increased 10-times. It was concluded that the thermogenic function of the hamster brown adipose tissue develops after the first postnatal week due to highly differentiated synthesis of mitochondrial proteins leading to replacement of preexisting, uncoupling protein-lacking nonthermogenic mitochondria by thermogenic ones, similarly as shown in brown adipose tissue of the embryonic mouse and rat (Houst?k, J., et al. (1988) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 935, 19-25).