Estimation of Plasmid Loss Rates in Bacterial Populations with a Reference to the Reproducibility of Stability Experiments

Two methods for estimation of plasmid loss rates were tested on data obtained from traditional (serial transfer) stability experiments. The first method was based on the assumption that the plasmid does not inhibit the growth of its host, whereas the second method takes differences in the interdivision time of plasmid-free and plasmid-carrying cells into account. In the cases where the loss rate is high and the plasmid does not exert strong growth inhibition, the estimates appear very reliable. When the plasmid loss rate is small and the plasmid exerts inhibition of growth to its host, the experimental design becomes unreliable.     

Transmission rates and phenotypic effects of mitochondrial plasmids and cytotypes in Silene vulgaris

We investigated the transmission properties and the phenotypic effects of two mitochondrial plasmids in a population of the bladder campion, Silene vulgaris. In reciprocal crosses between plasmid-free and plasmid-carrying plants, no cases of paternal transmission or loss during maternal transmission were recorded. Neither was any transmission via pollen observed when plasmid-carrying plants of S. vulgaris were used to pollinate plasmid-free plants of the closely related species Silene uniflora. The phenotypic effects of the plasmids were investigated by comparing germination rate, early growth properties, and the gender of plants grown from seeds with and without plasmids. A significant association between plasmid status, on the one hand, and germination propensity and offspring gender, on the other, was found. However, because all plants carrying plasmids in the experiment shared the same cytoplasmic background, the exact contribution of the plasmid to the phenotypic variation could not be determined. Taken together, our experiments show that in S. vulgaris the mt-plasmids are not currently involved in any strong genetic conflict, but that they evolve in close association with their mitochondrial host.     

A novel feeding strategy for enhanced plasmid stability and protein production in recombinant yeast fedbatch fermentation

A novel feeding strategy in fedbatch recombinant yeast fermentation was developed to achieve high plasmid stability and protein productivity for fermentation using low-cost rich (non-selective) media. In batch fermentations with a recombinant yeast, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, which carried the plasmid pSXR125 for the production of beta-galactosidase, it was found that the fraction of plasmid-carrying cells decreased during the exponential growth phase but increased during the stationary phase. This fraction increase in the stationary phase was attributed to the death rate difference between the plasmid-free and plasmid-carrying cells caused by glucose starvation in the stationary phase. Plasmid-free cells grew faster than plasmid-carrying cells when there were plenty of growth substrate, but they also lysed or died faster upon the depletion of the growth substrate. Thus, pulse additions of the growth substrate (glucose) at appropriate time intervals allowing for significant starvation period between two consecutive feedings during fedbatch fermentation should have positive effects on stabilizing plasmid and enhancing protein production. A selective medium was used to grow cells in the initial batch fermentation, which was then followed with pulse feeding of concentrated non-selective media in fedbatch fermentation. Both experimental data and model simulation show that the periodic glucose starvation feeding strategy can maintain a stable plasmid-carrying cell fraction and a stable specific productivity of the recombinant protein, even with a non-selective medium feed for a long operation period. On the contrary, without glucose starvation, the fraction of plasmid-carrying cells and the specific productivity continue to drop during the fedbatch fermentation, which would greatly reduce the product yield and limit the duration that the fermentation can be effectively operated. The new feeding strategy would allow the economic use of a rich, non-selective medium in high cell density recombinant fedbatch fermentation. This new feeding strategy can be easily implemented with a simple IBM-PC based control system, which monitors either glucose or cell concentration in the fermentation broth.     

An operational strategy for unstable recombinant DNA cultures

A simple operational strategy is shown to offer a viable means of enhancing plasmid stability in chemostat systems where plasmid loss is a common problem. Feedback control can be used to stabilize coexistence states, which are naturally unstable in the system investigated, and thus gurantee retention of the plasmid-carrying strain. The strategy exploits the normally undesirable characteristics of substrate inhibited growth kinetics, and is illustrated with specific reference to methanolutilizing organisms. Since the methodology may be easily implemented in practice, it offers an alternative to costly environmental methods such as antibiotic addition.     

Bacterial Plasmids in Antarctic Natural Microbial Assemblages

Samples of psychrophilic and psychrotrophic bacteria were collected from sea ice, seawater, sediments, and benthic or ice-associated animals in McMurdo Sound, Antarctica. A total of 155 strains were isolated and tested for the presence of plasmids by DNA agarose gel electrophoresis. Thirty-one percent of the isolates carried at least one kind of plasmid. Bacterial isolates taken from sediments showed the highest plasmid incidence (42%), and isolates from seawater showed the lowest plasmid incidence (20%). Plasmids were significantly more frequent in the strains which had been first isolated from low-nutrient media (46%) than in the strains which had been isolated from high-nutrient media (25%). Multiple forms of plasmids were observed in two-thirds of the plasmid-carrying strains. A majority of the plasmids detected were estimated to have a mass of 10 megadaltons or less. Among 48 plasmid-carrying strains, 7 showed antibiotic resistance. It is concluded that bacterial plasmids are ubiquitous in natural microbial assemblages of the pristine marine ecosystem of Antarctica.     

Stability of recombinant plasmids on the continuous culture of Bifidobacterium animalis ATCC 27536

Bifidobacterium animalis ATCC 27536 represents among bifidobacteria a host-model for cloning experiments. The segregational and structural stabilities of a family of cloning vectors with different molecular weights but sharing a common core were studied in continuous fermentation of the hosting B. animalis without selective pressure. The rate of plasmid loss (R) and the specific growth rate difference (delta mu) between plasmid-free and plasmid-carrying cells were calculated for each plasmid and their relationship with plasmid size was studied. It was observed that both R and the numerical value of delta mu increased exponentially with plasmid size. The exponential functions correlating the specific growth rate difference and the rate of plasmid loss with the plasmid molecular weight were determined. Furthermore, the smallest of the plasmids studied, pLAV (4.3-kb) was thoroughly characterized by means of its complete nucleotide sequence. It was found that it contained an extra DNA fragment, the first bifidobacterial insertion sequence characterised, named IS 1999.     

Plasmid stability and kinetics of continuous production of glucoamylase by recombinant <Emphasis Type="Italic">Saccharomyces cerevisiae</Emphasis> in an airlift bioreactor

Production of glucoamylase by recombinant Saccharomyces cerevisiae C468/pGAC9 (ATCC 20690) in a continuous stirred tank bioreactor was studied at different dilution rates. Plasmid stability was found to be growth (dilution rate) dependent; it increased with the dilution rate. Bioreactor productivity and specific productivity also increased with the dilution rate. A kinetic equation was used to model the plasmid stability kinetics. The growth rate ratio between plasmid-carrying and plasmid-free cells decreased from 1.397 to 1.215, and segregational instability or probability of plasmid loss from each cell division decreased from 0.059 to 0.020 as the dilution rate increased from 0.10 to 0.37 1/h. The specific growth rates increased with dilution rate, while the growth rate difference between plasmid-carrying and plasmid-free cell populations was negligible. This was attributed to the low copy number of the hybrid plasmid pGAC9. Thus, the growth rate had no significant effect on plasmid instability. The proposed kinetics was consistent with experimental results, and the model simulated the experimental data well.     

Rapid determination of plasmid-carrying yeast cells by using an imaging sensor system

A novel imaging sensor system for the determination of plasmid carrying yeast cells was developed. The sensor system consisted of an Silicon Intensifier Target (SIT) video camera, a fluorescent microscope, and a personal computer system equipped with an image memory board. This system was based on the fact that the membrane integrity of only plasmid-carrying cells is lost following cell growth in 5-fluoro-orotic acid (5-FOA) containing medium, and consequently these target cell can be stained with fluorescent probes and detected. In this study, plasmid-carrying cells were detected and their fraction determined in a mixture of both plasmid-carring and plasmid-free cells. A good correlation was observed between the values determined by this sensor system and the conventional method in the 30%-80% range, and one assay was possible within 4 h. This sensor system could be used for the monitoring of plasmid-carrying fraction in recombinant yeast cells during cultivation.     

The effect of a plasmid on growth and survival of E. coli

We studied the growth characteristics of a pair of Escherichia coli strains, isogenic apart from the possession of a nonconjugative plasmid. There was no difference between the two strains when they were grown separately. In mixed culture, a second slow phase of growth that normally occurred following the end of rapid exponential growth, was absent from the plasmid-carrying strain. This resulted in a considerable decrease in the proportion of the cells that carried the plasmid after overnight incubation. The effect of different conditions of growth is reported. The plasmid-carrying strain survived extended incubation (150 days at 37°C) as well as did the plasmid free strain separately. In a mixture, the proportion of plasmid-carrying cells declined rapidly, and none was detected after 100 days.     

Study of population dynamic for a recombinant bacterium during continuous cultures: application of data filtering and smoothing

A numerical method to process experimental data concerning plasmid stability of a recombinant bacteria during continuous cultures with nonselective media is proposed here. This method differs from previous ones in that it uses the derivatve form of the state equation of the Imanaka-Aiba model for recombinant cultures. The methodology proposed here allows one to estimate values for the two model parameters without forcing them to be constant. Until now, this could not be done using classical analytical techniques because these parameters have been considered invariable because of the integration used in the evaluation of the model. These parameters are (1) the difference in the specific growth rates between plasmid-carrying cells and plasmid-free cells (deltamu), and (2) the probability of plasmid loss by plasmid-containing cells (rho(r) mu(+)). The derivative technique used here is completed by mathematical treatments involving data filtering and smoothing. The values of the two parameters are in agreement with those already publised. The current technique does not impose preconditions and permit us to further study related phenomena.     

Data analysis of plasmid maintenance in a CSTR

A simple procedure is developed to process experimental data from plasmid maintenance studies of recombinant cells in a chemostat with nonselective medium. This procedure, based on the model proposed by Imanaka and Aiba, provides quantitative information on the rate of plasmid loss and the difference in the specific growth rate between the plasmid-carrying and plasmid-free cells. The performance of the proposed method is evaluated through simulation studies. In addition, the method is applied to a set of previously reported experimental data. The two-parameter model, together with the estimated parameter values, provides an excellent fit to the experimental data.     

Dynamics of plasmid maintenance in a CSTR upon square-wave perturbations in the dilution rate

The effects of forced oscillations in the dilution rate on a population of Escherichia coli K12 harboring the plasmid pBR322 in a chemostat with a nonselective medium were studied. In the constant dilution rate control experiments, the percentage of plasmid-containing cells decreased after a long lag time. Eventually, the culture approached a population consisting of 100% plasmid-free ells. However, under forced perturbations of the dilution rate, the culture maintained a mixed population of plasmid-free and plasmid-carrying cells for a longer period of ime. An unstructured model was developed to describe the above observations. Our results indicate that transient conditions created by dilution-rate perturbations provide a favorable environment for the plasmid-carrying population. In addition, experiments with different cycling frequencies suggest that adaptation by the culture to these transient conditions will reduce or totally eliminate such an advantage.     

Stability of pBR322-derived plasmids

The stability of pBR322-derived plasmids was studied during growth of their Escherichia coli host in the absence of antibiotics. Plasmid pBR322, as well as its delta rom and delta bla derivatives, were lost from their host within 60 generations, but a number of delta tet derivatives were quite stable under the same conditions. An evaluation of the data indicated that primary plasmid loss due to random partitioning corresponds to the generation of a plasmid-free cell about every 10(4) divisions (probability P0; = "intrinsic" instability). Secondary loss of plasmid-carrying cells resulted from a growth advantage of the plasmid-free cells when bacteria die, perhaps due to unrepaired lethal damage in the DNA, under conditions of stationary incubation (= "apparent" instability). This cell death also occurred in the absence of plasmids but was accelerated by the presence of extra plasmid DNA in the cell and further accelerated by a functional tet gene. This was the reason for the differential apparent stabilities of delta bla and delta tet plasmids. There was no indication that an accumulation of plasmid multimers contributed to the plasmid instability, as has been suggested in the literature. The value of P0 = 10(-4) is 14 orders of magnitude greater than expected under the assumption of a random (Poisson) distribution of plasmid copy numbers in a population of cells.     

Twenty-Six Chromosomal Genes Needed to Maintain the Killer Double-Stranded RNA Plasmid of SACCHAROMYCES CEREVISIAE

The double-stranded RNA killer plasmid gives yeast strains carrying it both the ability to secret a protein toxin and immunity to that toxin. This report describes a new series of mutants in chromsomal genes needed for killer plasmid maintenance (mak genes). These mutants comprise 12 complementation groups. There are a total of at least 26 mak genes. Each mak gene product is needed for plasmid maintenance in diploids as well as in haploids. None of these mak mutations prevent the killer plasmid from entering the mak- spores in the process of meiotic sporulation. Complementation between mak mutants can be performed by mating meitoic spores from a makx/+ plasmid-carrying diploid with a maky haploid. If x = y, about half the diploid clones formed lose the killer plasmid. If x not equal to y, complementation occurs, and all of the diploid clones are killers.     

Plasmid-mediated lethality and plasmid multimer formation in an Escherichia coli recBC sbcBC mutant. Involvement of RecF recombination pathway genes

Apparent plasmid instability, i.e. progressive plasmid loss in a bacterial culture growing in the absence of selection for the plasmid, in an Escherichia coli recBC sbcBC mutant was investigated with two different ColE1 derivatives (pMB9 and pBR322) and a mini-F plasmid. The instability was most striking for pMB9 and much less, but still significant, for pBR322 and the mini-F. It was also dependent upon a subset of the genes involved in the RecF recombination pathway: in addition to the previously reported recA, recF and recJ mutations, a recO and a recQ mutation showed a total and a partial suppression, respectively, of the instability. Other recF-family mutations, recN and ruv, were without such an effect. Population analyses of the recBC sbcBC strain carrying pMB9 or the mini-F, as carried out by plating and Coulter counting, revealed marked loss of viability in plasmid-carrying cells, strongly implicating plasmid-mediated cell death in the apparent defect in plasmid maintenance. Analysis of intracellular plasmid DNA by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis combined with the in-agarose cell lysis technique showed that the instability was associated with the formation of plasmid multimers, with a good correlation between the degree of the instability and the amount of the multimers. The multimer formation was also dependent on the same subset of the RecF pathway genes as in the instability phenomenon. These results strongly suggest that the lethality is somehow caused by the multimer formation. Various DNase treatments of cell lysates showed that such multimers of pMB9 DNA comprised molecules of exonuclease-sensitive and exonuclease-resistant types. It was inferred that the former class, which showed electrophoretic mobilities corresponding to plain linear duplexes of approximately 200 x 10(3) to 2200 x 10(3) base-pairs, represented linear multimers possibly carrying circular structures at one end. The latter class, which remained in the origin, was thought to consist of circular multimers and/or linear multimers protected by circular structures at both ends against exonucleolytic attack.     

Expression of the gene for tetracycline resistance of plasmids R6 and RP4 in bacteria of the family Enterobacteriaceae]

It was found that manifestation of the tetracycline resistance gene depended on the type of the plasmid containing the gene. The tetracycline resistance gene was subject to less repression in plasmid R6 than in plasmid RP4. Sensitivity of the initial plasmid-free bacteria varied within lower dose ranges than that of the plasmid-carrying strains. Regulation of the tetracycline resistance gene manifestation in the given plasmid may change in different bacterial hosts, i.e. in different cytoplasmic environment at different gene background.     

Variation and modeling of the probability of plasmid loss as a function of growth rate of plasmid-bearing cells of Escherichia coli during continuous cultures

A large number of models concerning cultures of genetically engineered bacteria have been described. Among them, some are specifically adapted to continuous cultures and lead to the determination of two variables: (i) the difference in the specific growth rates between plasmid-carrying cell and plasmid-free cells (deltamu) and (ii) the frequency of plasmid loss by plasmid-containing cells (p(r)mu(+)). Until now, studies have been performed on the global expression p(r)mu(+) and deltamu, whose value during continuous assays have been supposed approximately constant (mean value) and not on separate values of both terms p(r) and mu(+), respectively, probability of plasmid loss and specific growth rate of the plasmid-carrying cells. So far these studies do not allow examination of the relationship between these two last parameters. Experimental results were obtained with Escherichia coli C600 galk (GAPDH), a genetically engineered strain that synthetizes an elevated quantity of glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GAPDH). From data obtained during continuous cultures, it is shown that during an assay, deltamu, and p(r)mu(+) do not remain constant. An appropriate mathematical analysis of the expression of mu(-) (specific growth rate of the plasmid-free cells) and mu(+) has been built up. This allows the evaluation of the values of mu(+) and mu(-) during the continuous cultures carried out at different dilution rates. Values of p(r) have been calculated from these data. Indeed our results show that p(r) increases with mu(+). A modeling approach which allows correct simulation of this variation is also proposed. This model is derived from the Hill equation regarding cooperative binding of enzymic type reaction. (c) 1993 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Camphor Plasmid-Mediated Chromosomal Transfer in Pseudomonas putida

Camphor-utilizing strains of Pseudomonas putida have been shown to carry the genetic information required for camphor degradation on a plasmid. The plasmid-carrying strains can serve as donors of both plasmid-borne and chromosomal genes. As recipients, plasmid-deleted strains are much superior to those carrying the camphor pathway genes. The transfer frequency of chromosomal, but not plasmid-borne, genes is markedly enhanced if the donor cells are irradiated with ultraviolet light followed by 3-h of growth on a rich medium in the dark. Recombinants selected for prototrophy are stable and most acquire the camphor (CAM) plasmid concomitantly; only a few of the Cam(+) recombinants inherit the donor's ability to transfer chromosomal genes at a high frequency. Transfer-defective mutations occur on the CAM plasmid, affecting both CAM and chromosomal gene transfer.