Phagocytosis of apoptotic cells and the resolution of inflammation

Clearance of apoptotic cells by phagocytic cells plays a significant role in the resolution of inflammation, protecting tissue from harmful exposure to the inflammatory and immunogenic contents of dying cells. Apoptosis induces cell surface changes that are important for recognition and engulfment of cells by phagocytes. These changes include alterations in surface sugars, externalization of phosphatidylserine and qualitative changes in the adhesion molecule ICAM-3. Several studies have contributed to clarify the role of the receptors on the surface of phagocytes that are involved in apoptotic cell clearance. The phagocytic removal of apoptotic cells does not elicit pro-inflammatory responses; in contrast, apoptotic cell engulfment appears to activate signals that suppress release of pro-inflammatory cytokines. Therefore, clearance of apoptotic leucocytes is implicated in the resolution of inflammation and mounting evidence suggests that defective clearance of apoptotic cells contributes to inflammatory and autoimmune diseases. Defining the ligands on apoptotic cells and the corresponding receptors on phagocytes with which they engage, is likely to lead to the development of novel anti-inflammatory pro-resolution drugs. In this article, we will review the recognition and signaling mechanisms involved in the phagocytosis of apoptotic cells as well as the role of endogenous compounds that play a relevant role in the modulation of inflammation. We will also discuss what is currently known about diseases that may reflect impaired phagocytosis and the consequences on inflammation and immune responses.     

Clearance of apoptotic and necrotic cells and its immunological consequences

The ultimate and most favorable fate of almost all dying cells is engulfment by neighboring or specialized cells. Efficient clearance of cells undergoing apoptotic death is crucial for normal tissue homeostasis and for the modulation of immune responses. Engulfment of apoptotic cells is finely regulated by a highly redundant system of receptors and bridging molecules on phagocytic cells that detect molecules specific for dying cells. Recognition of necrotic cells by phagocytes is less well understood than recognition of apoptotic cells, but an increasing number of recent studies, which are discussed here, are highlighting its importance. New observations indicate that the interaction of macrophages with dying cells initiates internalization of the apoptotic or necrotic targets, and that internalization can be preceded by “zipper”-like and macropinocytotic mechanisms, respectively. We emphasize that clearance of dying cells is an important fundamental process serving multiple functions in the regulation of normal tissue turnover and homeostasis, and is not just simple anti- or pro-inflammatory responses. Here we review recent findings on genetic pathways participating in apoptotic cell clearance, mechanisms of internalization, and molecules involved in engulfment of apoptotic versus necrotic cells, as well as their immunological consequences and relationships to disease pathogenesis. Katharina D’Herde and Peter Vandenabeele share senior authorship. This study was supported by Ghent University GOA grant No. 12050502, IUAP-V/12-12.0C14.02, FWO-Vlaanderen 3G.0218.06, and Flanders Interuniversity Institute for Biotechnology (VIB).     

From regulation of dying cell engulfment to development of anti-cancer therapy

Cell death and efficient engulfment of dying cells ensure tissue homeostasis and is involved in pathogenesis. Clearance of dying cells is a complex and dynamic process coordinated by interplay between ligands on dying cell, bridging molecules, and receptors on engulfing cells. In this review, we will discuss recent advances and significance of molecular changes on the surface of dying cells implicated in their recognition and clearance as well as factors released by dying cells that attract macrophages to the site of cell death. It is now becoming apparent that phagocytes use a specific set of mechanisms to discriminate between live and dead cells, and this phenomenon will be illustrated here. Next, we will discuss potential mechanisms by which removal of dying cells could modulate immune responses of phagocytes, in particular of macrophages. Finally, we will address possible strategies for manipulating the immunogenicity of dying cells in experimental cancer therapies.     

Exposure of a specific pleioform of multifunctional glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate dehydrogenase initiates CD14-dependent clearance of apoptotic cells

Rapid clearance of apoptotic cells by phagocytes is crucial for organogenesis, tissue homeostasis, and resolution of inflammation. This process is initiated by surface exposure of various ‘eat me’ ligands. Though phosphatidylserine (PS) is the best recognized general recognition ligand till date, recent studies have shown that PS by itself is not sufficient for clearance of apoptotic cells. In this study, we have identified a specific pleioform of GAPDH (Glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate dehydrogenase) that functions as an ‘eat me’ signal on apoptotic cell surface. This specific form of GAPDH which is exposed on surface of apoptotic cells was found to interact with CD14 present on plasma membrane of phagocytes leading to their engulfment. This is the first study demonstrating the novel interaction between multifunctional GAPDH and the phagocytic receptor CD14 resulting in apoptotic cell clearance (efferocytosis).Subject terms: Cell biology, Apoptosis     

Friendly fire against neutrophils: proteolytic enzymes confuse the recognition of apoptotic cells by macrophages

Physiologically the only acceptable fate for almost all damaged or unwanted cells is their apoptotic death, followed by engulfment of the corpses by healthy neighbors or professional phagocytes. Efficient clearance of cells that have succumbed to apoptosis is crucial for normal tissue homeostasis, and for the modulation of immune responses. The disposal of apoptotic cells is finely regulated by a highly redundant system of receptors, bridging molecules and 'eat me' signals. The complexity of the system is reflected by the term: 'engulfment synapse', used to describe the interaction between a phagocytic cell and its target. In healthy humans, dying neutrophils are the most abundant and important targets for such recognition and engulfment. In inflammation the scope and importance of this complicated task is further increased. Paradoxically, despite growing evidence highlighting the priority of neutrophils clearance, the recognition of these cells by phagocytes is not as well understood as the recognition of other apoptotic cell types. New findings indicate that the interaction of phosphatidylserine (PS) on apoptotic neutrophils with its receptor on macrophages is not as critical for the specific clearance of neutrophil corpses it was previously believed. In this review we focus on recent findings regarding alternative, PS-independent "eat me" signals expressed on neutrophils during cell death and activation. Based on our own research, we emphasize the clearance of dying neutrophils, especially at the focus of bacterial infection; and the associated inflammatory reaction, which occurs in a highly proteolytic milieu containing both host and bacteria-derived proteinases. In these environments, eat-me signals expressed by neutrophils are drastically modified; arguing against the phospholipid-based detection of apoptotic cells, but supporting the importance of proteinaceous ligand(s) for the recognition of neutrophils by macrophages. In this context we discuss the effect of the gingipain R (Rgp) proteinases from Porphyromonas gingivalis on neutrophils interactions with macrophages. Since the recognition of apoptotic neutrophils is an important fundamental process, serving multiple functions in the regulation of immunity and homeostasis, we hypothesize that many pathogenic bacteria may have developed similar strategies to confuse macrophage-neutrophil interaction as a common pathogenic strategy.     

Engulfment and clearance of apoptotic cells based on a GlcNAc-binding lectin-like property of surface vimentin

The clearance of apoptotic cells is important to maintain tissue homeostasis. The engulfment of apoptotic cells is performed by professional phagocytes, such as macrophages, and also by non-professional phagocytes, such as mesenchymal cells. Here, we show that vimentin, a cytoskeletal protein, functions as an engulfment receptor on neighboring phagocytes, which recognize O-linked β-N-acetylglucosamine (O-GlcNAc)-modified proteins from apoptotic cells as "eat me" ligands. Previously, we reported that vimentin possesses a GlcNAc-binding lectin-like property on cell surface. However, the physiological relevance of the surface localization and GlcNAc-binding property of vimentin remained unclear. In the present study, we observed that O-GlcNAc proteins from apoptotic cells interacted with the surface vimentin of neighboring phagocytes and that this interaction induced serine 71-phosphorylation and recruitment of vimentin to the cell surface of the neighboring phagocytes. Moreover, tetrameric vimentin that was disassembled by serine 71-phosphorylation possessed a GlcNAc-binding activity and was localized to the cell surface. We demonstrated our findings in vimentin-expressing common cell lines such as HeLa cells. Furthermore, during normal developmental processes, the phagocytic engulfment and clearance of apoptotic footplate cells in mouse embryos was mediated by the interaction of surface vimentin with O-GlcNAc proteins. Our results suggest a common mechanism for the clearance of apoptotic cells, through the interaction of surface vimentin with O-GlcNAc-modified proteins.     

Phagocytosis of cells dying through autophagy evokes a pro-inflammatory response in macrophages

Autophagy as a natural part of cellular homeostasis usually takes place unnoticed by neighboring cells. However, its co-occurrence with cell death may contribute to the clearance of these dying cells by recruited phagocytes. Autophagy associated with programmed cell death has recently been reported to be essential for presentation of phoshatidylserine (PS) on the cell surface (Qu et al. 2007) that has a key role in the clearance of apoptotic cells. Recently, we have demonstrated that upon triggering cell death by autophagy in MCF-7 cells, the corpses were efficiently phagocytosed by both human macrophages and non-dying MCF-7 cells. Death as well as engulfment could be prevented by inhibiting autophagy. Based on our data, two molecular mechanisms have been proposed for the uptake of cells which die through autophagy: a PS-dependent pathway which was exclusively used by the living MCF-7 cells acting as non-professional phagocytes, and a PS-independent uptake mechanism that was active in macrophages acting as professional phagocytes. Several lines of evidence suggest that macrophages utilize calreticulin-mediated recognition, tethering, tickling and engulfment processes. Phagocytic uptake of cells dying through autophagy by macrophages leads to a pro-inflammatory response characterized by the induction and secretion of IL-6, TNFalpha, IL-8 and IL-10.     

吞噬凋亡细胞的机制

被吞噬细胞吞噬是多数凋亡细胞的命运.凋亡细胞表面膜磷脂酰丝氨酸的暴露、膜碳水化合物的改变及表面糖蛋白的重新分布和聚集导致被吞噬细胞识别与摄取.吞噬细胞的多种受体参与吞噬过程,有些受体参与栓系凋亡细胞,有些激发巨吞饮的摄取机制.吞噬的摄取过程因吞噬细胞和凋亡细胞的类型差异而不同.至少有7种线虫吞噬基因及其哺乳动物同源物组成两条部分重叠而又平行的摄取信息传导通路.吞噬基因的突变可以改变凋亡细胞的进程.吞噬功能的缺陷将影响机体正常的免疫应答.     

Engulfment of apoptotic cells: signals for a good meal

The clearance of apoptotic cells by phagocytes is an integral component of normal life, and defects in this process can have significant implications for self tolerance and autoimmunity. Recent studies have provided new insights into the engulfment process, including how phagocytes seek apoptotic cells, how they recognize and ingest these targets and how they maintain cellular homeostasis after the 'meal'. Several new factors that regulate engulfment have been identified, whereas the roles of some of the older players require revision. This Review focuses on these recent developments and attempts to highlight some of the important questions in this field.     

Microenvironmental influences of apoptosis in vivo and in vitro

The apoptosis program of physiological cell death elicits a range of non-phlogistic homeostatic mechanisms—“recognition, response and removal”—that regulate the microenvironments of normal and diseased tissues via multiple modalities operating over short and long distances. The molecular mechanisms mediate intercellular signaling through direct contact with neighboring cells, release of soluble factors and production of membrane-delimited fragments (apoptotic bodies, blebs and microparticles) that allow for interaction with host cells over long distances. These processes effect the selective recruitment of mononuclear phagocytes and the specific activation of both phagocytic and non-phagocytic cells. While much evidence is available concerning the mechanisms underlying the recognition and responses of phagocytes that culminate in the engulfment and removal of apoptotic cell bodies, relatively little is yet known about the non-phagocytic cellular responses to the apoptosis program. These responses regulate inflammatory and immune cell activation as well as cell fate decisions of proliferation, differentiation and death. Here, we review current knowledge of these processes, considering especially how apoptotic cells condition the microenvironments of normal and malignant tissues. We also discuss how apoptotic cells that persist in the absence of phagocytic clearance exert inhibitory effects over their viable neighbors, paying particular attention to the specific case of cell cultures and highlighting how new cell-corpse-clearance devices—Dead-Cert^® Nanoparticles—can significantly improve the efficacy of cell cultures through effective removal of non-viable cells in the absence of phagocytes in vitro.     

Corpse disposal after apoptosis

The termination of the apoptotic program occurs in most cases via recognition and clearance by phagocytes. Engulfed cells do not simply disappear from the midst of living tissues. Constituents of the corpse indeed survive the intracellular processing and are recycled to the membrane of the phagocyte. The presentation of yielded antigens to T cells is a central event in the induction and the maintenance of peripheral tolerance. Conversely, errors in this pathway contribute to the pathogenesis of systemic and organ specific autoimmune diseases. Here we discuss the available information on the events that follow active engulfment of dying cells, with attention to the events involved in vitro and in vivo in apoptotic cell processing. The outcome of the processing is the cross-priming or the functional inactivation of T cells that specifically recognise antigens contained in the cell corpse.     

Immunopathological consequences of the loss of engulfment genes: the case of ABCA1

Programmed cell death plays a crucial role in the maintenance of cell homeostasis. An initial, effector phase leads to the generation of apoptotic corpses and is closely followed by a swift clearance by professional or amateur phagocytes. Several aspects distinguish this latter process of engulfment of dying cells from the classical forms of phagocytosis. They concern all aspects of the process from the recognition of the prey to the final outcome, i.e. immunological silence. The engulfment of dead cells is a process highly conserved through evolution and it has been studied in parallel in two systems, mammalian cells and the nematode C. elegans. ABCA1 and its ortholog CED-7 in the nematode are key players of engulfment. Their mode of action is somehow original in the panorama of engulfment receptors since they act as lipid transporters. While in the worm the loss of CED-7 has phenotypic consequences exclusively on engulfment, in the mouse the deletion of ABCA1 by homologous recombination has highlighted broad consequences on macrophage biology. Among those we will discuss here the aberrant responses of ABCA1-/- mice to Plasmodium berghei ANKA infection, concerning in particular the development of cerebral malaria (CM), a cytokine-induced immunopathology. This syndrome involves a central role of monocytes and, as shown recently, high levels of circulating microparticles. It was found that ABCA1 loss completely protects against CM and its associated mortality. This observation, together with the demonstration of quantitative and functional modifications of microparticles, suggests that microparticles may be involved in CM pathogenesis. The ABCA1 transporter thus appears to control susceptibility to CM, thereby providing new insights in its pathophysiological mechanisms and potential new therapeutic avenues.     

Clearing the Dead: Apoptotic Cell Sensing,Recognition, Engulfment,and Digestion

Clearance of apoptotic cells is the final stage of programmed cell death. Uncleared corpses can become secondarily necrotic, promoting inflammation and autoimmunity. Remarkably, even in tissues with high cellular turnover, apoptotic cells are rarely seen because of efficient clearance mechanisms in healthy individuals. Recently, significant progress has been made in understanding the steps involved in prompt cell clearance in vivo. These include the sensing of corpses via “find me” signals, the recognition of corpses via “eat me” signals and their cognate receptors, the signaling pathways that regulate cytoskeletal rearrangement necessary for engulfment, and the responses of the phagocyte that keep cell clearance events “immunologically silent.” This study focuses on our understanding of these steps.Multicellular organisms execute the majority of unwanted cell populations in a regulated fashion via the process of apoptosis (Henson and Hume 2006; Nagata et al. 2010). Examples of unwanted cells include excess cells generated during development, cells infected with intracellular bacteria or viruses, transformed or malignant cells capable of tumorigenesis, and cells irreparably damaged by cytotoxic agents. Swift removal of these cells is necessary for maintenance of overall health and homeostasis and prevention of autoimmunity, pathogen burden, or cancer. Quick removal of dying cells is a key final step, if not the ultimate goal of the apoptotic program.The term “phagocytosis” refers to an internalization process by which larger particles, such as bacteria and dead/dying cells, are engulfed and processed within a membrane-bound vesicle called the phagosome (Ravichandran and Lorenz 2007). A phagocyte is any cell that is capable of engulfment, including “professional” phagocytes such as macrophages, immature dendritic cells, and neutrophils. Metazoa have multiple mechanisms for clearing apoptotic cells, often depending on the tissue and apoptotic cell type (Gregory 2009). Macrophages and immature dendritic cells readily engulf dead or dying cells in tissues such as bone marrow (where a large number of new hematopoietic cells are generated), spleen (during or after an immune response), and the thymus (in young animals during T-lymphocyte development). In other tissues, neighboring “nonprofessional” phagocytes can also mediate the clearance of apoptotic targets. For example, in the mammary epithelium, viable mammary epithelial cells engulf apoptotic mammary epithelial cells after cessation of lactation (Monks et al. 2005, 2008). What distinguishes the phagocytosis of apoptotic cells from the phagocytosis of most bacteria or necrotic cells is the lack of a pro-inflammatory immune response (Henson 2005). This article discusses apoptotic cell engulfment, specifically the recruitment of phagocytes, through “find me” signals, the recognition of apoptotic cells by phagocytes via “eat me” signals, the internalization process and signaling pathways used for cytoskeletal rearrangement, and finally the digestion of apoptotic cells and phagocytic response to this process (Fig. 1).Open in a separate windowFigure 1.The steps of efficient apoptotic cell clearance. First, “find me” signals released by apoptotic cells are recognized via their cognate receptors on the surface of phagocytes. This is the sensing stage and stimulates phagocyte migration to the location of apoptotic cells. Second, phagocytes recognize exposed “eat me” signals on the surface of apoptotic cells via their phagocytic receptors, which leads to downstream signaling events culminating in Rac activation. Finally, further signaling events within the phagocyte regulate the digestion and processing of the apoptotic cell meal and the secretion of anti-inflammatory cytokines.     

Novel role of ICAM3 and LFA-1 in the clearance of apoptotic neutrophils by human macrophages

Apoptotic cells express eat-me signals which are recognized by several receptors mainly on professional phagocytes of the mononuclear phagocyte system. This “engulfment synapse” can define a safe and effective clearance of apoptotic cells in order to maintain tissue homeostasis in the entire body. We show that the expression of four genes related to apoptotic cell clearance is strongly up-regulated in human macrophages 30 min after administration of apoptotic neutrophils. Out of these the significant role of the up-regulated intercellular adhesion molecule 3 (ICAM3) in phagocytosis of apoptotic neutrophils could be demonstrated in macrophages by gene silencing as well as treatment with blocking antibodies. Blocking ICAM3 on the surface of apoptotic neutrophils also resulted in their decreased uptake which confirmed its role as an eat-me signal expressed by apoptotic cells. In macrophages but not in neutrophils silencing and blocking integrin alphaL and beta2 components of lymphocyte function-associated antigen 1 (LFA-1), which can strongly bind ICAM3, resulted in a decreased phagocytosis of apoptotic cells indicating its possible role to recognize ICAM3 on the surface of apoptotic neutrophils. Finally, we report that engulfing portals formed in macrophages during phagocytosis are characterized by accumulation of ICAM3, integrin alphaL and beta2 which show co-localization on the surface of phagocytes. Furthermore, their simultaneous knock-down in macrophages resulted in a marked deficiency in phagocytosis and a slight decrease in the anti-inflammatory effect of apoptotic neutrophils. We propose that ICAM3 and LFA-1 act as recognition receptors in the phagocytosis portals of macrophages for engulfment of apoptotic neutrophils.     

Clearance of apoptotic cells in Caenorhabditis elegans

Programmed cell death, or apoptosis, is a genetically controlled process of cell suicide that is a common fate during an animal's life. In metazoans, apoptotic cells are rapidly removed from the body through the process of phagocytosis. Genetic analyses probing the mechanisms controlling the engulfment of apoptotic cells were pioneered in the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans. So far, at least seven genes have been identified that are required for the recognition and engulfment of apoptotic cells and have been shown to function in two partially redundant signaling pathways. Molecular characterization of their gene products has lead to the finding that similar genes act to control the same processes in other organisms, including mammals. In this paper, we review these exciting findings in C. elegans and discuss their implications in understanding the clearance of apoptotic cells in mammals.     

Beta-2-glycoprotein 1-dependent macrophage uptake of apoptotic cells. Binding to lipoprotein receptor-related protein receptor family members

The recognition and removal of apoptotic cells is critical to development, tissue homeostasis, and the resolution of inflammation. Many studies have shown that phagocytosis is regulated by signaling mechanisms that involve distinct ligand-receptor interactions that drive the engulfment of apoptotic cells. Studies from our laboratory have shown that the plasma protein beta-2-glycoprotein 1 (beta2GP1), a member of the short consensus repeat superfamily, binds phosphatidylserine-containing vesicles and apoptotic cells and promotes their bridging and subsequent engulfment by phagocytes. The phagocyte receptor for the protein/apoptotic cell complex, however, is unknown. Here we report that a member of the low density lipoprotein receptor-related protein family on phagocytes binds and facilitates engulfment of beta2GP1-phosphatidylserine and beta2GP1-apoptotic cell complexes. Using recombinant beta2GP1, we also show that beta2GP1-dependent uptake is mediated by bridging of the target cell to the phagocyte through the protein C- and N-terminal domains, respectively.     

If phosphatidylserine is the death knell, a new phosphatidylserine-specific receptor is the bellringer

Recognition of phosphatidylserine (PtdSer) is essential for engulfment of apoptotic cells by mammalian phagocytes. Engagement of a new phosphatidylserine-specific receptor (PtdSerR) appears to be necessary for uptake of apoptotic cells. Many other mammalian receptors have been described to function in the clearance of apoptotic cells. The emerging picture is that many of these receptors may provide the strong adhesion needed to increase the likelihood of contact between the PtdSerR and its phospholipid ligand, which is required for uptake. Furthermore, stimulation of this receptor on different types of phagocytes by apoptotic cells, PtdSer-containing liposomes or an IgM monoclonal anti-PtdSer antibody initiates release of TGFbeta, known to be involved in the anti-inflammatory effects of apoptotic cells. Although highly homologous genes exist in C. elegans and Drosophila melanogaster, their role in engulfment of apoptotic cells remains to be determined.     

Phagocytosis of Cells Dying through Autophagy Evokes a Pro-Inflammatory Response in Macrophages

Autophagy as a natural part of cellular homeostasis usually takes place unnoticed by neighboring cells. However, its co-occurrence with cell death may contribute to the clearance of these dying cells by recruited phagocytes. Autophagy associated with programmed cell death has recently been reported to be essential for presentation of phoshatidylserine (PS) on the cell surface (Qu et al. 2007) that has a key role in the clearance of apoptotic cells. Recently, we have demonstrated that upon triggering cell death by autophagy in MCF-7 cells, the corpses were efficiently phagocytosed by both human macrophages and non-dying MCF-7 cells. Death as well as engulfment could be prevented by inhibiting autophagy. Based on our data, two molecular mechanisms have been proposed for the uptake of cells which die through autophagy: a PS-dependent pathway which was exclusively used by the living MCF-7 cells acting as non-professional phagocytes, and a PS-independent uptake mechanism that was active in macrophages acting as professional phagocytes. Several lines of evidence suggest that macrophages utilize calreticulin-mediated recognition, tethering, tickling and engulfment processes. Phagocytic uptake of cells dying through autophagy by macrophages leads to a pro-inflammatory response characterized by the induction and secretion of IL-6, TNFα, IL-8 and IL-10.

Addendum to:Clearance of Dying Autophagic Cells of Different Origin by Professional and Non-Professional Phagocytes

G. Petrovski, G. Zahuczky, K. Katona, G. Vereb, W. Martinet, Z. Nemes, W. Bursch and L. Fésüs

Cell Death Differ 2007;14:1117-28     

Clearance of apoptotic corpses

Apoptotic corpses can be engulfed and cleared by many other cell types in addition to ‘professional’ phagocytes such as macrophage. Studies of several organisms have contributed to the understanding of apoptotic corpse engulfment. Two partially redundant engulfment pathways have been characterized that act even in non-professional phagocytes to promote corpse engulfment. This review summarizes some recent progress in signaling by these pathways, including the exposure of eat-me-signals on apoptotic cells, and insights from Drosophila on the roles of the bridging receptor Six Microns Under, the non-receptor tyrosine kinase Shark, and store-operated calcium release in the Draper/Ced-1 pathway of corpse recognition and internalization. The mechanism of apoptotic phagosome maturation is outlined, and possible connections between corpse engulfment and proliferation, cell competition, and immunity are discussed.