Antigen modulation of the secondary immune response. VI. Contribution of cells recruited from precursor pool to expression of memory.

The adoptive transfer system has been used extensively to study the ability of antigen triggered memory cells to become antibody forming cells and/or to proliferate and expand the memory cell population. Selective antigen triggering of the memory cells for low and high affinity antibody formation has also been studied in this way. One of the main counter-arguments to the interpretation of these data is that the presence of antigen in the adoptive host may lead to recruitment of new memory cells from either a host or donor precursor population. In this paper we examined the contribution of both host and donor precursor cells to the total antibody response in adoptive secondary recipients. The following donor-host combinations were used in which the recipients were given 1 mg fluid antigen intravenously: (A) normal (non-immune) donors to normal irradiated recipients; (B) normal donors to carrier primed irradiated recipients; (C) carrier primed donors to normal irradiated recipients; (D) normal donors to carrier primed recipients with challenge and subsequent transfer to additional carrier primed recipients; (E) carrier primed donor to normal recipients to carrier primed recipients; (F) repeat of B and C above with multiple antigen administration; (G) purified immune (DNP-BGG) donor T cells mixed with normal B cells transferred to normal irradiated recipients. In most cases recruitment was seen but this represented less than 4% of the responses seen with immune cells. Thus we conclude that this level of recruitment does not compromise the use of the adoptive transfer system for studying selective antigen triggering of memory cells.     

Immunological discrimination between self and non-self by precursor depletion and memory accumulation

We study processes by which T-lymphocytes "learn" to discriminate "self" from "non-self". We show that intrinsic features of the T cell activation and proliferation process are sufficient to tolerize (self) reactive T-lymphocyte clones. Self vs non-self discrimination therefore develops without any down-regulatory (e.g. suppressive) interactions. T-lymphocyte clones will expand by proliferation only if the IL2 concentration is high enough to induce a proliferation rate larger than the rate of cell decay. This concentration is the proliferation threshold. Because effector T cells are short-lived the proliferation threshold must be quite high. Such high numbers of cells producing IL2 are achieved only when sufficient (memory) precursors are activated. Self and non-self antigens differ with respect the number of (memory) precursor cells they accumulate, as a result of two processes, i.e. precursor depletion and memory accumulation, and can thus be discriminated. Precursor depletion: the dynamics of long-lived precursors can cause tolerization. In neonatal circumstances precursor influx is still low, newborn cells reacting with self antigens are immediately activated, generating (few), i.e. fewer than the proliferation threshold, effectors that decay rapidly. Thus total lymphocyte numbers remain low, yielding self tolerance. Conversely, large doses of similar antigens introduced in mature systems push "their" lymphocyte clone over the proliferation threshold because a large (accumulated) precursor population is rapidly activated. Small doses are however low zone tolerized. Memory accumulation: peripheral T-lymphocyte populations in fact consist of a mixture of virgin precursors and memory cells. If the formation process of (long-lived) memory cells is taken into account and virgin precursors are made short-lived, the proliferation threshold again accounts for self non-self discrimination. Memory cells accumulate when antigenic restimulation is low; it is low when the antigen concentration and/or the antigen affinity is low. Therefore self antigens, which are present in relatively high concentrations, fail to accumulate high affinity memory cells, and are hence tolerated. Memory cells crossreacting to self antigens with low affinity, however accumulate neonatally, pushing those clones over the proliferation threshold whenever "their" high affinity antigen enters the immune system. Thus the model generates differences in the antigenicity (i.e. memory precursor frequency) of self and non-self.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

The extent of affinity maturation differs between the memory and antibody-forming cell compartments in the primary immune response.

Immunization with protein-containing antigens results in two types of antigen-specific B cell: antibody forming cells (AFCs) producing antibody of progressively higher affinity and memory lymphocytes capable of producing high affinity antibody upon re-exposure to antigen. The issue of the inter-relationship between affinity maturation of memory B cells and AFCs was addressed through analysis of single, antigen-specific B cells from the memory and AFC compartments during the primary response to a model antigen. Only 65% of splenic memory B cells were found capable of producing high affinity antibody, meaning that low affinity cells persist into this compartment. In contrast, by 28 days after immunization all AFCs produced high affinity antibody. We identified a unique, persistent sub-population of bone marrow AFCs containing few somatic mutations, suggesting they arose early in the response, yet highly enriched for an identical affinity-enhancing amino acid exchange, suggesting strong selection. Our results imply that affinity maturation of a primary immune response occurs by the early selective differentiation of high affinity variants into AFCs which subsequently persist in the bone marrow. In contrast, the memory B-cell population contains few, if any, cells from the early response and is less stringently selected.     

Lymphokine-induction of memory B-cell differentiation: differential stimulation of large virgin and memory B-cell differentiation

In order to compare and contrast the requirements of virgin and memory B cells for B-cell differentiation factors, a model system was developed in which low-density rat B cells isolated from 4-week primed antigen-draining lymph nodes were cultured in vitro. This large low-density cell population contained B cells which were 90% surface IgM positive and 60% IgD positive and showed moderately elevated Ia staining. When the cell population was stimulated with antigen plus lymphokines or lymphokines alone, antigen-specific IgG antibody was secreted; this was used as a measure of memory cell differentiation. When the cell population was stimulated with mitogen (lipopolysaccharide plus dextran sulfate) plus lymphokines, polyclonal IgG and IgM secretion was seen and was used as a measure of virgin B-cell differentiation. Using this system, we found that lymphokines contained in a Con A-induced rat spleen cell supernatant (CSN) were sufficient to drive both memory and virgin B-cell differentiation. In contrast, lymphokines contained in the supernatant from the murine T-cell hybridoma B151K12 (B151CFS) were able to induce large amounts of polyclonal IgM and IgG secretion but did not support memory B-cell differentiation. When recombinant human IL-2 was added to these cultures, it acted synergistically to augment virgin B-cell differentiation, but this combination of lymphokines was still not able to support memory B-cell differentiation. Furthermore, recombinant rat interferon-gamma and a commercial source of human BCGF, with or without IL-2, were unable to promote significant virgin or memory B-cell differentiation. These data support the hypothesis that memory B cells and virgin B cells differ in their lymphokine requirements for differentiation into antibody-secreting cells.     

Antigen concentration determines helper T cell subset participation in IgE antibody responses.

A recently developed in vitro system for antigen-stimulated primary and secondary murine IgE antibody responses has been used to define (a) the relative participation of the Th1 and Th2 cell-derived lymphokines IFN-gamma and IL-4, respectively, in such responses, and (b) the role of antigen concentration in determining functional helper T cell activity. These studies confirm that IL-4 and IFN-gamma exert regulatory effects on IgE synthesis, but the nature and extent of their respective effects on primary and secondary IgE responses differ. Thus, primary IgE responses are considerably more sensitive to and dependent on IL-4 than are secondary IgE responses since (1) anti-IL-4 monoclonal antibody totally inhibited primary IgE responses, but only partially affected secondary responses; and (2) exogenously added IL-4 could stimulate primary IgE responses to optimal antigen concentrations, but had no effect on secondary IgE production. Likewise, antigen-stimulated primary IgE responses are about eightfold more sensitive than are secondary responses to the inhibitory effects of IFN-gamma. Studying the effect of antigen dose on the quantity of IgE antibody produced revealed that although IFN-gamma could be detected by ELISA in cultures exhibiting high-dose antigen-dependent diminution of IgE production, anti-IFN-gamma monoclonal antibody could not reverse this phenomenon. Thus, IFN-gamma is not solely responsible for decreased IgE synthesis associated with high-dose antigen exposure. IL-4 activity was detected in the fluid from cultures stimulated with low, but not high, levels of antigen. Moreover, addition of exogenous IL-4 restored IgE production to normal levels in cultures exposed to high antigen concentrations. Therefore, it appears that high levels of antigen result in selective stimulation of Th1 cells which produce IFN-gamma, and diminished activation of IL-4-producing Th2 cells. These results help explain observations regarding the influence of antigen dose on the generation of experimental and clinical IgE antibody responses in vivo.     

Polyclonal activation of primed rat B cells

In recent years, murine and human virgin B lymphocytes have been used to examine the steps necessary for polyclonal activation. In these models mitogens are used in conjunction with lymphokines to determine which signals are responsible for regulating B-cell triggering, proliferation, and differentiation. While progress has been made in understanding these events as they occur in virgin B cells, very little evidence exists to suggest whether these models of activation also apply to the memory B-cell population. In this report we have described an antigen-specific, secondary in vitro immune response using cells isolated from lymph nodes draining the site of antigen injection. Unfractionated cells, B cells, and size-fractionated cells from dinitrophenyl-keyhole limpet hemocyanin (DNP-KLH)-primed rats were challenged in vitro with DNP-KLH, lipopolysaccharide plus dextran sulfate (LPS/DxS), and T-cell factors. We have consistently found, under all these conditions, that antigen challenge of primed cells results in the production of DNP-specific IgG antibody while stimulation with LPS/DxS plus T-cell factors results only in the polyclonal activation of virgin B cells; no antigen-specific IgG secretion is seen. This suggests that acquisition of memory status is associated with a loss in responsiveness to LPS/DxS-induced differentiation.     

Transfer of memory cells into antigen-pretreated hosts. I. Functional detection of migration sites for antigen-specific B cells.

The distribution of functionally active hapten-specific B memory cells was investigated. Using antigen-pretreated lethally irradiated recipients, a marked accumulation of adoptively transferred B memory cells was demonstrated in lymph nodes containing specific antigen, but not in lymph nodes containing non-cross-reacting hapten conjugates. This difference in responsiveness between lymph nodes containing specific versus those containing nonspecific antigen developed over a period 3–5 days after memory cell transfer. The localization of antigen specific cells was T-cell independent; both carrier-primed T helper cells and specific antigenic challenge, however, were required to trigger the localized B memory cells into antibody production. Specific B memory cell accumulation did not result from an expansion of the antigen-specific cell population due to local proliferation induced by antigen depots in the lymph nodes to challenge. Rather, the results indicated that recirculating B memory cells had progressively accumulated through retention by antigen in the lymph node. These findings suggest that, in the absence of T-cell help and specific antigenic challenge, B memory cells accumulate in lymphoid tissue (follicles) without responding and provide persistent local memory for the humoral immune response.     

Studies on the mechanism of suppression by T cells in an adoptive secondary response.

Suppression of antibody synthesis by lymphocytes was studied using an adoptive secondary response model in which human serum albumin (HSA)-primed lymphocytes (memory cells) from the thoracic ducts of inbred rats were inhibited in irradiated recipients by nonimmune lymphocytes after mixed cell transfer. This investigation extended earlier work and formally showed that the suppressor cells were peripheral thymus-derived lymphocytes, which could rapidly recirculate from the blood to lymph, were present in spleen but not in bone marrow, and that primed T cells lacked this property to inhibit. The suppressive effect was independent of antigen dose but was markedly influenced by the form of antigen used for challenge in that suppression was significantly abrogated with aggregated HSA or with soluble HSA in the presence of specific antibody. Suppressor cells were found to exert their effect maximally at the time of antigen injection, but became ineffective by 40 hr following challenge. The results are considered within a larger framework of cellular regulation of antibody synthesis.     

Structural requirements for in vivo and in vitro immunogenicity in hapten-specific delayed hypersensitivity

Affinity changes of hapten-specific IgM antibodies were analysed by plaque inhibition assays and by inhibition with varying quantities of monovalent inhibitor. The resulting data were used for cell population studies, based on the affinity of plaque-forming antibody. Maturation of IgM plaque-forming cell populations was time- and antigen dose-dependent. Maturation was characterized by a consistent increase in the proportions of high affinity and medium affinity cells and a decrease in the proportion of low affinity cell populations. Thus progressive selection of high affinity cells occurred over the entire dose range of immunization. The hapten concentration at which 20% of cells was inhibited decreased with time at all administered antigen concentrations. The inhibitory hapten concentration at which 50 or 70% of cells was inhibited did not change after administration of very large immunizing doses. Thus recruitment of this type of plaque-forming cell depended on dose. In the secondary response, high affinity cells appeared initially but very transiently, and the subsequent rate of population changes was faster than that observed in the primary response. The short productive life of IgM plaque-forming populations may be responsible for the time restriction in IgM as compared to IgG maturation.     

Selective immunodepression

A variety of experimental conditions have been described which can selectively depress various aspects of the normal immune response. Treatment with cytotoxic drugs or variations in the route of administration or physical state of the antigen can selectively depress one immunoglobulin class while allowing normal synthesis of other immunoglobulin classes. Injection of excessive or subimmunogenic doses of antigen, or injection of antigen in a nonimmunogenic form will specifically depress antibody body syntheis to that antigen. Depending upon the antigen dose and other factors discussed above such tolerance can be selectively induced in either the B- or the T-lymphocyte population. Finally, antibody is highly heterogeneous with respect to its affinity for the antigenic determinant. As a consequence of the selective pressure of decreasing antigen concentration there is generally a progressive shift towards the production of high affinity antibodies. Various experimental maneuvers can selectively depress specific subpopulations of antibody forming cells. B-cell tolerance preferentially occurs in high affinity antibody forming cells with a decrease in the average affinity of the residual antibody formed. Passively injected antibody specifically depresses antibody synthesis to concomitantly injected antigen. This antibody mediated immune suppression selectively depresses low affinity antibody synthesis. Thus, a variety of experimental procedures have been discussed which will modify the immune response in highly selected ways.It is clearly important in describing the immune response to specify not merely the amount of antibody formed, but also its class and subclass. In addition, to fully describe the immune response it is necessary to specify the affinity and heterogeneity of the antibody. As discussed above the factors controlling the affinity of serum antibody and the mechanism of antibody mediated immune suppression are reasonably well understood. Much data are available regarding factors determining tolerance induction, however, the detailed cellular mechanisms involved remain obscure. With regard to the mechanisms determining which immunoglobulin classes are formed, and in what proportion, relatively little information is available.     

Differences in antibody repertoires for (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl (NP) in splenic vs immature bone marrow precursor cells

To evaluate the contribution of environmental regulatory mechanisms in fashioning the primary B cell repertoire, we have compared the repertoire of (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl (NP)-specific primary splenic B cells with that of precursor cells present as surface immunoglobulin-negative (sIg-) cells in adult bone marrow of C.B20 (Ighb) mice. Previous analyses using a variety of antigens have led to the conclusion that the antibody repertoire expressed in the spleen is similar to that expressed in newly generated B cell precursors with respect to both repertoire diversity and the representation of various predominant clonotypes. However, in the response to NP of C.B20 precursor cells, two marked disparities have been identified between the repertoire of sIg- bone marrow cells vs splenic precursor cells. The first concerns precursor cells that give rise to lambda-bearing NP-specific antibodies with heteroclitic fine specificity. Such antibodies normally dominate the primary response of Ighb mice; however, the representation of precursor cells giving rise to lambda-bearing antibodies is disproportionately low in the sIg- bone marrow cell population of C.B20 mice. Thus, during the maturation of these cells, post-sIg receptor expression, there is an apparent increase in the proportionate representation of lambda-bearing NP-specific cells. The second disparity concerns precursor cells whose antibody products bear kappa-light chains and exhibit high affinity and homoclitic binding for the NP haptenic determinant. Such precursor cells are poorly represented in the spleen, but represent a sizeable proportion of the sIg- NP-specific precursor cell population. Thus, there seems to be a selective elimination of high affinity, kappa-homoclitic anti-NP antibody-bearing cells as they acquire their sIg receptors. The elimination of this cell population could partially account for the dominance of lambda-heteroclitic antibodies in the serum responses to NP of C.B20 mice.     

Cells en route to apoptosis are characterized by the upregulation of c-fos,c-myc,c-jun,cdc2, and RB phosphorylation,resembling events of early cell-cycle traverse

Apoptosis is an important mechanism enabling the selection of the non-self-reactive T cell repertoire and for maintaining homeostasis in the immune system after it has expanded to combat infections. Highly activated, proliferating T cells become susceptible to apoptosis driven by a number of stimuli, and T cells activated during a viral infection become susceptible to “activation induced cell death” after repeated stimulation through the T cell receptor (TcR). This is a major mechanism for the immune deficiencies observed during many viral infections. During infections with a high antigen load this can lead to a selective deletion of virus-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) and to the establishment of persistent infection. More commonly, the CTL control the infection first, and high levels of apoptosis in the expanded lymphocyte population occur after antigen and growth factors become limiting. This cell death does not seem to depend on TcR specificity, as the residual population contains a remarkably stable population of memory CTL precursors that approximate the frequency per CD8 cell of that seen during the peak of the acute infection. Subsequent infections with heterologous viruses result in an expansion and then an apoptotic elimination of T cells, with the consequence being a reduction in precursor CTL specific for the first virus. Thus, apoptosis shapes the quality and quantity of T cell memory. © 1995 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Selective survival and expression of B-lymphocyte memory cells during long-term serial transplantation

The expression of individual clonal products during long-term in vivo culture was investigated using a rabbit model system of bone marrow transplantation. RLA (MHC) matched rabbits were deliberately mismatched for kappa light chain immunoglobulin allotype to facilitate identification of antibodies as being of donor or recipient origin. Recipients of cells from antigen-primed donors responded to antigen stimulation with antibody of donor origin, showing that cells were effectively triggered for antibody production in the recipient. Isoelectric focusing followed by affinity immunoblotting of the expressed antibodies showed that the responding B-cell clonotype repertoire remained virtually unchanged throughout the extensive cell transfer protocol used. These results suggest that B-memory-cell stimulation, rather than stem cell differentiation, was responsible for the observed response patterns. There was no detectable increase in the heterogeneity of the donor-derived antibody response with time and no new clonotypes appeared which were not present in the cell donor. Unlike previous studies, early stimulation with antigen was not required for successful engraftment and memory cell establishment. However, our data suggest that the timing of antigenic challenge may determine which of the donor-derived clones will dominate a response after antigen challenge of the recipient.     

In vivo obtained antigen presented by germinal center B cells to T cells in vitro

Shortly after secondary immunization germinal center (GC) B cells obtain antigen from follicular dendritic cells (FDC) in the form of immune complexes. This antigen appears to be degraded by the GC B cells and may be processed for presentation to T cells. The present study was undertaken to determine whether GC B cells can process and present antigen obtained from FDC in vivo to appropriate T cells in vitro. GC B cells were isolated from immune mice with the use of Percoll density separation followed by a panning procedure which utilizes the ability of the plant lectin, peanut agglutinin (PNA), to selectively bind to GC B cells. The enriched GC B cells were approximately 80% highly positive for PNA, 97% positive for Ia and surface IgM, but less than 0.01% positive for Thy-1.2 or esterase. In some experiments, this population was further purified to near 100% highly PNA-positive cells with the use of fluoresceinated PNA and a fluorescence-activated cell sorter. Cell sorting analysis indicated that the antigen (125I-labeled ovalbumin (OVA)) was restricted to the highly PNA-positive cell fraction. The capacity of these highly PNA-positive B cells to present antigen was assessed by monitoring interleukin 2 (IL-2) production by the OVA-specific T cell hybridoma, 3DO-54.8. GC B cells obtained from mice 3 wk or more after secondary immunization did not elicit IL-2 production in the absence of added OVA. However, GC B cells isolated as early as 1 day and for over 1 wk after a challenge with OVA, were able to stimulate high levels of IL-2 production, in the absence of adding OVA to the cell cultures. This response was maximal on day 5 and corresponded precisely with the kinetics of the ultrastructural studies which document the uptake of antigen by GC B cells in vivo. The FDC-derived antigen was remarkably immunogenic when compared with exogenous antigen. These findings demonstrated that antigen obtained in vivo by GC B cells could be processed and presented to T cells. In vivo, GC B cells may induce the T cell help needed for the germinal center reaction, generate B memory cells, and help induce the high titers of antibody associated with the secondary antibody response.     

Verification of immune response optimality through cybernetic modeling

An immune response cascade that is T cell independent begins with the stimulation of virgin lymphocytes by antigen to differentiate into large lymphocytes. These immune cells can either replicate themselves or differentiate into plasma cells or memory cells. Plasma cells produce antibody at a specific rate up to two orders of magnitude greater than large lymphocytes. However, plasma cells have short life-spans and cannot replicate. Memory cells produce only surface antibody, but in the event of a subsequent infection by the same antigen, memory cells revert rapidly to large lymphocytes. Immunologic memory is maintained throughout the organism's lifetime. Many immunologists believe that the optimal response strategy calls for large lymphocytes to replicate first, then differentiate into plasma cells and when the antigen has been nearly eliminated, they form memory cells. A mathematical model incorporating the concept of cybernetics has been developed to study the optimality of the immune response. Derived from the matching law of microeconomics, cybernetic variables control the allocation of large lymphocytes to maximize the instantaneous antibody production rate at any time during the response in order to most efficiently inactivate the antigen. A mouse is selected as the model organism and bacteria as the replicating antigen. In addition to verifying the optimal switching strategy, results showing how the immune response is affected by antigen growth rate, initial antigen concentration, and the number of antibodies required to eliminate an antigen are included.     

In vivo immune response to TNP hapten coupled to thymus-independent carrier lipopolysaccharide

Lipopolysaccharide has been utilized as a carrier for the TNP hapten, producing an antigen which induces an in vivo thymus-independent antibody response to TNP as determined using athymic nude mice and their normal littermates. The immune response to TNP-LPS was investigated at both the antibody-forming cell and the serum antibody levels.The primary response to an optimal dose of TNP-LPS (1.0 μg) exhibited unusual kinetics reaching a sharp peak on day 3 of 58,000 anti-TNP PFC/spleen. Serum antibody to TNP was first detected on day 3 and reached a maximum log₂ titer of 17.5 on day 5, an uncommonly high level for hapten-carrier conjugates and most carriers. Both the anti-TNP serum antibody and PFCs were exclusively IgM. No IgG antibody was detected in the primary response through 28 days postimmunization, nor was any detected in any experiment described in this paper. The primary PFC response to 1.0 μg of TNP-LPS was specific for TNP, producing no evidence of polyclonal antibody synthesis. The relative affinities of PFC-secreted antibody were investigated using hapten inhibition. The hapten inhibition curves for TNP-LPS and TNP-SRBC were very similar, indicating that relatively high affinity antibody was elicited by TNP-LPS. The secondary response to this dose following priming with TNP-SRBC or TNP-LPS was similar to the primary response, though the peak was less sharp in both cases. The response to the homologous secondary challenge shifted somewhat, reaching a peak on days 3–4. The effect of various doses in priming or challenging for the secondary response to TNP-LPS was investigated. Using an increased PFC response as a criterion, no dose was optimal for priming or immunological memory to TNP-LPS. While the adoptive primary response to TNP-LPS reached a low level peak on day 7, the adoptive secondary attained a maximum on day 6. This shift in kinetics in intact mice and in adoptive hosts in comparing primary to secondary responses indicated that a state of B cell priming may be induced. However, its full expression may be suppressed by endogenous factors at the time of priming, such as the high level of circulating anti-TNP antibody or residual antigen. Adoptive transfer would remove the cells from these influences, allowing such B cell priming to manifest itself fully.     

Inhibition of adoptive secondary responses by lymphoid cell populations

The ability of normal and tolerant lymphoid cells to inhibit the adoptive secondary response was investigated in order to delineate the influence which the host can exert on a memory cell population as the host recovers from the effects of irradiation. LBN rats were irradiated with 500R whole body X-irradiation, reconstituted with either normal or tolerant lymphoid cells, then they were given immune spleen cells and challenged with soluble antigen (DNP-BGG). Cells capable of suppressing the adoptive secondary responses were shown to possess the following characteristics: 1) in nonimmune donors they were found in the greatest concentration in lymph nodes, followed by spleen and bone marrow and were practically absent in the thymus; 2) their numbers were not increased in donors rendered tolerant by long term treatment with deaggregated DNP-BGG plus cyclophosphamide nor in donors given large doses of DNP-BGG 48 to 72 hr before sacrifice; 3) in animals rendered tolerant by long term antigen treatment alone some enhancement of suppressor function was seen; 4) the suppressor cells could be shown among both glass wool adherent and nonadherent cells and 5) the nonantigen specific suppressor cells did not affect the kinetics of antibody formation nor the affinity of the antibody which was produced. These results are discussed in terms of the nature and source of the suppressor cell populations and their relevance to the control of secondary responses in intact animals.     

Class, amounts, and affinities of anti-dinitrophenyl antibodies in chickens. II. Production of a restricted population of high affinity 7S antibodies by injection of antigen emulsified in adjuvant.

The response of chickens given a single intramuscular injection of maximally coupled dinitrophenylated-gamma-bovine beta-globulin in either Freund's complete (FCA) or incomplete (FIA) adjuvants was characterized by an initial synthesis of 7S and 17S antibodies followed by the exclusive and persistent production of 7S antibodies. The 17S antibodies were not detected either 3 to 4 weeks after a single injection or after an intravenous boost 16 months later. Injections of low doses of antigen in FCA induced the synthesis of 7S antibodies of high affinity at least by 4 months. Analyses of the Sips plots generated from equilibrium dialysis data indicated that a shift in the distribution of 7S antibody affinities occurred because of the production of a restricted population of high affinity antibodies. The changes in the binding properties of antibody during the immune response from chickens given antigen in FIA were less apparent, although qualitatively similar, to those found in birds given antigen in FCA. Three possibilities were presented to explain the effect of adjuvant on the class and affinity of the antibody: a) the requirement of a second signal for B cell differentiation, b) the presence of subpopulation of B cells, and c) somatic mutation events.     

Idiotypic regulation of B cell differentiation

We study the equilibrium properties of idiotypically interacting B cell clones in the case where only the differentiation of B cells is affected by idiotypic interactions. Furthermore, we assume that clones may recognize and be stimulated by self antigen in the same fashion as by antiantibodies. For idiotypically interacting pairs of non-autoreactive clones we observe three qualitatively different dynamical regimes. In the first regime, at small antibody production an antibody-free fixed point, the virgin state, is the only attractor of the system. For intermediate antibody production, a symmetric activated state replaces the virgin state as the only attractor of the system. For large antibody production, finally, the symmetric activated state gives way to two asymmetric activated states where one clone suppresses the other clone. If one or both clones in the pair are autoreactive there is no virgin state. However, we still observe the switch from an almost symmetric activated state to two asymmetric activated states. The two asymmetric activated states at high antibody production have profoundly different implications for a self antigen which is recognized by one of the clones of the pair. In the attractor characterized by high autoantibody concentration the self antigen is attacked vigorously by the immune system while in the opposite steady state the tiny amount of autoantibody hardly affects the self antigen. Accordingly, we call the first state the autoimmune state and the second the tolerant state. In the tolerant state the autoreactive clone is down-regulated by its anti-idiotype providing an efficient mechanism to prevent an autoimmune reaction. However, the antibody production required to achieve this anti-idiotypic control of autoantibodies is rather large.     

Human peripheral blood mononuclear cells produce IgA anti-influenza virus antibody in a secondary in vitro antibody response

The function and immunoregulation of human IgA memory B cells producing anti-influenza virus antibody was analyzed in vitro in antigen-stimulated cultures. Peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) from seven of eight normal adult volunteers naturally immunized to influenza virus produced IgA anti-influenza virus antibody when stimulated in vitro with inactivated A/Aichi/68 [H3N2] influenza virus. This IgA antibody response was approximately one-eighth the IgG antibody response. PBMC from each of five patients with selective IgA deficiency failed to produce any measurable IgA antibody. When tonsillar mononuclear cells (TMC) were studied in a similar manner, a relatively higher IgA antibody response was obtained (one-third the IgG antibody) than with PBMC. Additional studies were undertaken to investigate the immunoregulation of this IgA antibody production and the relatively lower amount produced by PBMC than by TMC. Co-cultures of peripheral blood B cells with irradiated peripheral blood T cells (to possibly inactivate a radiosensitive IgA suppressor cell) did not result in a relative increase in IgA antibody production. Also, co-cultures of B cells with increasing numbers of T cells produced parallel increases of IgG and IgA antibody when plotted on a log scale with slopes of approximately 1, suggesting that a single helper T cell was limiting for both isotypes. Finally, pokeweed mitogen-stimulated co-cultures of peripheral blood and tonsillar B and T cells revealed that the B cell population, but not the T cell population, determined the amount of IgA anti-influenza virus antibody produced. Precursor frequency analyses of tonsillar and peripheral blood B cells in antigen-stimulated cultures confirmed that tonsils contained a higher precursor frequency of B cells for IgA anti-influenza virus antibody production (3.95/10(6) B cells) than did peripheral blood B cells (0.65/10(6) B cells). Thus, IgA memory cells are preferentially found in tonsillar tissue as compared with the peripheral blood, consistent with the role of the tonsils as a mucosal immune organ.