Sites of auxin action: regulation of geotropism, growth, and ethylene production by inhibitors of auxin transport

The inhibitors of auxin transport-NPA (N-1-naphthylphthalamic acid), DPX1840 (3,3a-dihydro-2-(p-methoxyphenyl)-8H-pyrazolo[5,1-a] isoindol-8-one), and TIBA (2,3,5-triiodobenzoic acid)-inhibited geotropism in roots of intact Pisum sativum L. seedlings. NPA and DPX1840 also caused cellular swelling in the roots. The swelling was due to a greater inhibition of elongation than increase in weight and looked identical to the one caused by ethylene. However, ethylene did not act as an intermediate in the action of auxin transport inhibitors because all three failed to stimulate ethylene production and some of their growth-inhibiting effect was retained in the presence of saturating levels of ethylene. In the presence of 10 mum indoleacetic acid the growth-inhibiting effect of auxin transport inhibitors was lost after 18 hours. On the other hand, auxin transport inhibitors did not interfere with the ability of auxin to promote ethylene production. Growth inhibition caused by auxin transport inhibitors was reversible. Pea root sections resumed normal growth following flushing of treated sections with inhibitor-free solutions. Experiments with (14)C-2, 4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid revealed that the herbicide and auxin transport inhibitors may have the same binding site. It was concluded that a class of structurally dissimilar compounds may share a similar physiological role since they all appear to compete with endogenous auxin for certain binding sites and they all have similar growth-regulating activities.     

Strigolactone Can Promote or Inhibit Shoot Branching by Triggering Rapid Depletion of the Auxin Efflux Protein PIN1 from the Plasma Membrane

Plants continuously extend their root and shoot systems through the action of meristems at their growing tips. By regulating which meristems are active, plants adjust their body plans to suit local environmental conditions. The transport network of the phytohormone auxin has been proposed to mediate this systemic growth coordination, due to its self-organising, environmentally sensitive properties. In particular, a positive feedback mechanism termed auxin transport canalization, which establishes auxin flow from active shoot meristems (auxin sources) to the roots (auxin sinks), has been proposed to mediate competition between shoot meristems and to balance shoot and root growth. Here we provide strong support for this hypothesis by demonstrating that a second hormone, strigolactone, regulates growth redistribution in the shoot by rapidly modulating auxin transport. A computational model in which strigolactone action is represented as an increase in the rate of removal of the auxin export protein, PIN1, from the plasma membrane can reproduce both the auxin transport and shoot branching phenotypes observed in various mutant combinations and strigolactone treatments, including the counterintuitive ability of strigolactones either to promote or inhibit shoot branching, depending on the auxin transport status of the plant. Consistent with this predicted mode of action, strigolactone signalling was found to trigger PIN1 depletion from the plasma membrane of xylem parenchyma cells in the stem. This effect could be detected within 10 minutes of strigolactone treatment and was independent of protein synthesis but dependent on clathrin-mediated membrane trafficking. Together these results support the hypothesis that growth across the plant shoot system is balanced by competition between shoot apices for a common auxin transport path to the root and that strigolactones regulate shoot branching by modulating this competition.     

Genetic Analysis of the Effects of Polar Auxin Transport Inhibitors on Root Growth in Arabidopsis thaliana

Polar auxin transport inhibitors, including N-1-naphthylphthalamicacid (NPA) and 2,3,5-triiodobenzoic acid (TIBA), have variouseffects on physiological and developmental events, such as theelongation and tropism of roots and stems, in higher plants.We isolated NPA-resistant mutants of Arabidopsis thaliana, withmutations designated pir1 and pir2, that were also resistantto TIBA. The mutations specifically affected the root-elongationprocess, and they were shown ultimately to be allelic to aux1and ein2, respectively, which are known as mutations that affectresponses to phytohormones. The mechanism of action of auxintransport inhibitors was investigated with these mutants, inrelation to the effects of ethylene, auxin, and the polar transportof auxin. With respect to the inhibition of root elongationin A. thaliana, we demonstrated that (1) the background levelof ethylene intensifies the effects of auxin transport inhibitors,(2) auxin transport inhibitors might act also via an inhibitorypathway that does not involve ethylene, auxin, or the polartransport of auxin, (3) the hypothesis that the inhibitory effectof NPA on root elongation is due to high-level accumulationof auxin as a result of blockage of auxin transport is not applicableto A. thaliana, and (4) in contrast to NPA, TIBA itself hasa weak auxin-like inhibitory effect. (Received April 12, 1996; Accepted September 2, 1996)     

Flavonoids act as negative regulators of auxin transport in vivo in arabidopsis

Polar transport of the plant hormone auxin controls many aspects of plant growth and development. A number of synthetic compounds have been shown to block the process of auxin transport by inhibition of the auxin efflux carrier complex. These synthetic auxin transport inhibitors may act by mimicking endogenous molecules. Flavonoids, a class of secondary plant metabolic compounds, have been suggested to be auxin transport inhibitors based on their in vitro activity. The hypothesis that flavonoids regulate auxin transport in vivo was tested in Arabidopsis by comparing wild-type (WT) and transparent testa (tt4) plants with a mutation in the gene encoding the first enzyme in flavonoid biosynthesis, chalcone synthase. In a comparison between tt4 and WT plants, phenotypic differences were observed, including three times as many secondary inflorescence stems, reduced plant height, decreased stem diameter, and increased secondary root development. Growth of WT Arabidopsis plants on naringenin, a biosynthetic precursor to those flavonoids with auxin transport inhibitor activity in vitro, leads to a reduction in root growth and gravitropism, similar to the effects of synthetic auxin transport inhibitors. Analyses of auxin transport in the inflorescence and hypocotyl of independent tt4 alleles indicate that auxin transport is elevated in plants with a tt4 mutation. In hypocotyls of tt4, this elevated transport is reversed when flavonoids are synthesized by growth of plants on the flavonoid precursor, naringenin. These results are consistent with a role for flavonoids as endogenous regulators of auxin transport.     

Novel auxin transport inhibitors phenocopy the auxin influx carrier mutation aux1

The hormone auxin is transported in plants through the combined actions of diffusion and specific auxin influx and efflux carriers. In contrast to auxin efflux, for which there are well documented inhibitors, understanding the developmental roles of carrier-mediated auxin influx has been hampered by the absence of specific competitive inhibitors. However, several molecules that inhibit auxin influx in cultured cells have been described recently. The physiological effects of two of these novel influx carrier inhibitors, 1-naphthoxyacetic acid (1-NOA) and 3-chloro-4-hydroxyphenylacetic acid (CHPAA), have been investigated in intact seedlings and tissue segments using classical and new auxin transport bioassays. Both molecules do disrupt root gravitropism, which is a developmental process requiring rapid auxin redistribution. Furthermore, the auxin-insensitive and agravitropic root-growth characteristics of aux1 plants were phenocopied by 1-NOA and CHPAA. Similarly, the agravitropic phenotype of inhibitor-treated seedlings was rescued by the auxin 1-naphthaleneacetic acid, but not by 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid, again resembling the relative abilities of these two auxins to rescue the phenotype of aux1. Further investigations have shown that none of these compounds block polar auxin transport, and that CHPAA exhibits some auxin-like activity at high concentrations. Whilst results indicate that 1-NOA and CHPAA represent useful tools for physiological studies addressing the role of auxin influx in planta, 1-NOA is likely to prove the more useful of the two compounds.     

Aryl-Substituted alpha-Aminooxycarboxylic Acids: A New Class of Auxin Transport Inhibitors

Certain herbicidal aminooxyisovalerate analogs were noted in whole plant phytotoxicity bioassays to cause disoriented roots. Since this symptom is often characteristic of interference with the transport of the plant hormone auxin, the ability of several of these compounds to compete for the N-1-naphthylphthalamic acid (NPA) binding site in corn (Zea mays L.) coleoptile membranes was measured. Significant NPA binding activity was found, expecially for the 2,4-dichlorophenyl analog. Application of structure-activity principles from traditional auxin transport inhibitors to this new class of molecules led to the synthesis of the naphthyl analogue. This molecule was extremely active in competing for NPA binding and in eliciting whole plant growth regulator effects. Possible relationships between these molecules and the mode of auxin transport are discussed.     

Inhibition of auxin transport by isoquinolinedione herbicides

2-(p-carbethoxyphenyl)-1,3(2H,4H)-isoquinolinedione (CEPIQ), an experimental herbicide, caused effects on geotropism, which are often indicative of an effect on auxin transport, in a whole plant herbicidal screen. However, it showed little or no activity in an in vitro binding assay in corn coleoptiles for the auxin-transport inhibitor,N-1-naphthylphthalamic acid (NPA). Other active isoquinolinedione analogues of this compound did, however, exhibit significant in vitro activity. Direct measurements of auxin transport in corn coleoptiles were undertaken in an attempt to resolve the apparent discrepancy between herbicidal and binding activities. In all cases examined, compounds that were highly active on whole plants were good inhibitors of auxin transport, and compounds that were weak as herbicides showed little or no effect on auxin transport. Therefore, it is concluded that the mode of action of these isoquinolinedione herbicides is the inhibition of auxin transport. Ring-opened analogues of several isoquinolinediones were synthesized and assayed in both the transport and binding assays, in order to test whether compounds in this class express their herbicidal activity by undergoing ring-opening in vivo, yielding products that are more straightforward analogues of NPA with free carboxyl groups. The homophthalamic acids had little or no activity in both assays. On the other hand, thep-ethyl- andp-ethoxy-phenyl phthalamic acids showed auxin transport inhibition comparable to the parent isoquinolinediones, but with markedly increased binding activity. These results support the possible role of ring-opening in the generation of biological activity. However, thep-carbethoxyphenyl phthalamic acid, analogous to CEPIQ, was very weak in both assays. Thus, ring-opening in vivo cannot alone account for the biological activity of this class of compounds.     

Auxin transport at cellular level: new insights supported by mathematical modelling

The molecular basis of cellular auxin transport is still not fully understood. Although a number of carriers have been identified and proved to be involved in auxin transport, their regulation and possible activity of as yet unknown transporters remain unclear. Nevertheless, using single-cell-based systems it is possible to track the course of auxin accumulation inside cells and to specify and quantify some auxin transport parameters. The synthetic auxins 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D) and naphthalene-1-acetic acid (NAA) are generally considered to be suitable tools for auxin transport studies because they are transported specifically via either auxin influx or efflux carriers, respectively. Our results indicate that NAA can be metabolized rapidly in tobacco BY-2 cells. The predominant metabolite has been identified as NAA glucosyl ester and it is shown that all NAA metabolites were retained inside the cells. This implies that the transport efficiency of auxin efflux transporters is higher than previously assumed. By contrast, the metabolism of 2,4-D remained fairly weak. Moreover, using data on the accumulation of 2,4-D measured in the presence of auxin transport inhibitors, it is shown that 2,4-D is also transported by efflux carriers. These results suggest that 2,4-D is a promising tool for determining both auxin influx and efflux activities. Based on the accumulation data, a mathematical model of 2,4-D transport at a single-cell level is proposed. Optimization of the model provides estimates of crucial transport parameters and, together with its validation by successfully predicting the course of 2,4-D accumulation, it confirms the consistency of the present concept of cellular auxin transport.     

Inhibition of auxin transport by isoquinolinedione herbicides

2-(p-carbethoxyphenyl)-1,3(2H,4H)-isoquinolinedione (CEPIQ), an experimental herbicide, caused effects on geotropism, which are often indicative of an effect on auxin transport, in a whole plant herbicidal screen. However, it showed little or no activity in an in vitro binding assay in corn coleoptiles for the auxin-transport inhibitor,N-1-naphthylphthalamic acid (NPA). Other active isoquinolinedione analogues of this compound did, however, exhibit significant in vitro activity. Direct measurements of auxin transport in corn coleoptiles were undertaken in an attempt to resolve the apparent discrepancy between herbicidal and binding activities. In all cases examined, compounds that were highly active on whole plants were good inhibitors of auxin transport, and compounds that were weak as herbicides showed little or no effect on auxin transport. Therefore, it is concluded that the mode of action of these isoquinolinedione herbicides is the inhibition of auxin transport. Ring-opened analogues of several isoquinolinediones were synthesized and assayed in both the transport and binding assays, in order to test whether compounds in this class express their herbicidal activity by undergoing ring-opening in vivo, yielding products that are more straightforward analogues of NPA with free carboxyl groups. The homophthalamic acids had little or no activity in both assays. On the other hand, thep-ethyl- andp-ethoxy-phenyl phthalamic acids showed auxin transport inhibition comparable to the parent isoquinolinediones, but with markedly increased binding activity. These results support the possible role of ring-opening in the generation of biological activity. However, thep-carbethoxyphenyl phthalamic acid, analogous to CEPIQ, was very weak in both assays. Thus, ring-opening in vivo cannot alone account for the biological activity of this class of compounds.     

Auxin transport and the interaction of phytotropins: probing the properties of a phytotropin binding protein

We have described the inhibition of polar auxin transport by several phytotropins including 1-N-naphthylphthalamic acid (NPA) and quercetin. Semicarbazones (substituted phenylsemicarbazones of 2-acetylarylcarboxylic acids) are inhibitors consistent with previously predicted general structural requirements for auxin transport inhibitors. The best semicarbazone derivative tested to date, hereafter called SCB-I, binds to the NPA binding protein with high affinity, K_b = 4 nanomolar. Quantification of the binding of various phytotropins allows us to make some general statements concerning the structure/properties of the NPA binding protein. The data suggest that the ligand binding region of this protein is multifaceted, a conclusion supported by the chemical predictions of Katekar and Geissler ([1977] Plant Physiol 60: 826-829). Although the data do not allow us to make specific conclusions on the structure of the binding site, they do show that both NPA and SCB-I could each occupy two regions of the protein. At least one of these binding regions appears to be common for both inhibitors of auxin transport. We suggest that the diversity of the binding site structure reflects the possible existence of more than one type of natural ligand controlling the process of auxin transport.     

Modulation of P-glycoproteins by auxin transport inhibitors is mediated by interaction with immunophilins

The immunophilin-like FKBP42 TWISTED DWARF1 (TWD1) has been shown to control plant development via the positive modulation of ABCB/P-glycoprotein (PGP)-mediated transport of the plant hormone auxin. TWD1 functionally interacts with two closely related proteins, ABCB1/PGP1 and ABCB19/PGP19/MDR1, both of which exhibit the ability to bind to and be inhibited by the synthetic auxin transport inhibitor N-1-naphylphtalamic acid (NPA). They are also inhibited by flavonoid compounds, which are suspected modulators of auxin transport. The mechanisms by which flavonoids and NPA interfere with auxin efflux components are unclear. We report here the specific disruption of PGP1-TWD1 interaction by NPA and flavonoids using bioluminescence resonance energy transfer with flavonoids functioning as a classical established inhibitor of mammalian and plant PGPs. Accordingly, TWD1 was shown to mediate modulation of PGP1 efflux activity by these auxin transport inhibitors. NPA bound to both PGP1 and TWD1 but was excluded from the PGP1-TWD1 complex expressed in yeast, suggesting a transient mode of action in planta. As a consequence, auxin fluxes and gravitropism in twd1 roots are less affected by NPA treatment, whereas TWD1 gain-of-function promotes root bending. Our data support a novel model for the mode of drug-mediated P-glycoprotein regulation mediated via protein-protein interaction with immunophilin-like TWD1.     

Auxin Transport Inhibitors: III. Chemical Requirements of a Class of Auxin Transport Inhibitors

The structural requirements of a proposed class of auxin transport inhibitors have been shown to be very similar to those required to inhibit the cress (Lepidium sativum) root geotropic response. A 2-carboxyphenyl group separated by a conjugated system of atoms from a second aromatic ring appears to be necessary for a molecule to have high activity.     

Effects of the auxin-inhibiting substances raphanusanin and benzoxazolinone on apical dominance of pea seedlings

The effects of the auxin-inhibiting substances raphanusanin ((3R*,6S*)-3-[methoxy (methylthio) methyl]-2-pyrrolidinethione, raphanusanin B)and benzoxazolinone (6-methoxy-2-bezoxazolinone, MBOA) on apical dominance of pea(Pisum sativum L. cv. Alaska) seedlings were studied.Application of raphanusanin B or MBOA to the apical bud, internode, or lateralbud of pea seedlings released apical dominance in either intact orindole-3-acetic acid (IAA )-treated, decapitated plants. These results suggestthat the auxin-inhibiting substances raphanusanin B and MBOA have activity inreleasing apical dominance. Conversely, the auxin transport inhibitors2,3,4-triiodobenzoic acid (TIBA) and 1-naphthylphthalamic acid (NPA) did notstimulate lateral bud growth when they were applied directly to the lateralbud,although application to the apical bud or internode released apical dominance.Therefore, the mode of action of raphanusanin B and MBOA in apical dominance isclearly different from that of auxin transport inhibitors. Raphanusanin B andMBOA may suppress the synthesis of growth-inhibiting factor(s) of the lateralbud induced by endogenous auxin transported from the apical bud or exogenouslyapplied auxin, and/or the action of the factor(s).     

Evidence Against the Involvement of Galactosidase or Glucosidase in Auxin- or Acid-stimulated Growth

Research on the mode of action of auxin in the promotion of growth has shown that auxin treatment leads to hydrogen ion secretion and wall acidification. It has recently been reported that auxin stimulates cell wall β-galactosidase activity in Avena coleoptiles, presumably by causing cell wall acidification, since the pH optimum for the enzyme is about 5.0. It has been suggested that enhancement of β-galactosidase and/or other glycosidase activity mediates growth promotion by auxin or low pH. This hypothesis was tested by examining the effect of inhibitors of β-galactosidase and β-glucosidase. Severe inhibition of measureable β-galactosidase or β-glucosidase activity was found to have no effect on auxin- or acid-promoted growth. It is concluded that neither β-galactosidase nor β-glucosidase plays an important role in short term growth promotion by auxin or acid. The data do not rule out the possibility that some other cell wall glycosidase is involved in auxin or acid action.     

The inter‐kingdom volatile signal indole promotes root development by interfering with auxin signalling

Recently, emission of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) has emerged as a mode of communication between bacteria and plants. Although some bacterial VOCs that promote plant growth have been identified, their underlying mechanism of action is unknown. Here we demonstrate that indole, which was identified using a screen for Arabidopsis growth promotion by VOCs from soil‐borne bacteria, is a potent plant‐growth modulator. Its prominent role in increasing the plant secondary root network is mediated by interfering with the auxin‐signalling machinery. Using auxin reporter lines and classic auxin physiological and transport assays we show that the indole signal invades the plant body, reaches zones of auxin activity and acts in a polar auxin transport‐dependent bimodal mechanism to trigger differential cellular auxin responses. Our results suggest that indole, beyond its importance as a bacterial signal molecule, can serve as a remote messenger to manipulate plant growth and development.     

Species differences in ligand specificity of auxin-controlled elongation and auxin transport: comparing Zea and Vigna

The plant hormone auxin affects cell elongation in both roots and shoots. In roots, the predominant action of auxin is to inhibit cell elongation while in shoots auxin, at normal physiological levels, stimulates elongation. The question of whether the primary receptor for auxin is the same in roots and shoots has not been resolved. In addition to its action on cell elongation in roots and shoots, auxin is transported in a polar fashion in both organs. Although auxin transport is well characterized in both roots and shoots, there is relatively little information on the connection, if any, between auxin transport and its action on elongation. In particular, it is not clear whether the protein mediating polar auxin movement is separate from the protein mediating auxin action on cell elongation or whether these two processes might be mediated by one and the same receptor. We examined the identity of the auxin growth receptor in roots and shoots by comparing the response of roots and shoots of the grass Zea mays L. and the legume Vigna mungo L. to indole-3-acetic acid, 2-naphthoxyacetic acid, 4,6-dichloroindoleacetic acid, and 4,7-dichloroindoleacetic acid. We also studied whether or not a single protein might mediate both auxin transport and auxin action by comparing the polar transport of indole-3-acetic acid and 2-naphthoxyacetic acid through segments from Vigna hypocotyls and maize coleoptiles. For all of the assays performed (root elongation, shoot elongation, and polar transport) the action and transport of the auxin derivatives was much greater in the dicots than in the grass species. The preservation of ligand specificity between roots and shoots and the parallels in ligand specificity between auxin transport and auxin action on growth are consistent with the hypothesis that the auxin receptor is the same in roots and shoots and that this protein may mediate auxin efflux as well as auxin action in both organ types.