Phylogenetic comparative mutational analysis of the base-pairing between RNase P RNA and its substrate.

We have studied the base-pairing between the 3'-terminal CCA motif of a tRNA precursor and RNase P RNA by a phylogenetic mutational comparative approach. Thus, various derivatives of the Escherichia coli tRNA(Ser)Su1 precursor harboring all possible substitutions at either the first or the second C of the 3'-terminal CCA motif were generated. Cleavage site selection on these precursors was studied using mutant variants of M1 RNA, the catalytic subunit of E. coli RNase P, carrying changes at positions 292 or 293, which are involved in the interaction with the 3'-terminal CCA motif. From our data we conclude that these two C's in the substrate interact with the well-conserved G292 and G293 through canonical Watson-Crick base-pairing. Cleavage performed using reconstituted holoenzyme complexes suggests that this interaction also occurs in the presence of the C5 protein. Furthermore, we studied the interaction using various derivatives of RNase P RNAs from Mycoplasma hyopneumoniae and Mycobacterium tuberculosis. Our results suggest that the base-pairing between the 3'-terminal CCA motif and RNase P is present also in other bacterial RNase P-substrate complexes and is not limited to a particular bacterial species.     

Phylogenetic comparative analysis and the secondary structure of ribonuclease P RNA--a review

The most incisive a priori approach to inferring the higher order structure of large RNAs has proven to be the use of phylogenetic comparisons. This article provides guidelines to the method, using as an illustration the elucidation of the secondary structure of the catalytic RNA subunit of ribonuclease P (RNase P). The resultant structure is compared to the possibilities that are predicted thermodynamically for the RNase P RNA sequences of nine eubacteria.     

Comparative structure analysis of vertebrate ribonuclease P RNA.

Ribonuclease P cleaves 5'-precursor sequences from pre-tRNAs. All cellular RNase P holoenzymes contain homologous RNA elements; the eucaryal RNase P RNA, in contrast to the bacterial RNA, is catalytically inactive in the absence of the protein component(s). To understand the function of eucaryal RNase P RNA, knowledge of its structure is needed. Considerable effort has been devoted to comparative studies of the structure of this RNA from diverse organisms, including eucaryotes, primarily fungi, but also a limited set of vertebrates. The substantial differences in the sequences and structures of the vertebrate RNAs from those of other organisms have made it difficult to align the vertebrate sequences, thus limiting comparative studies. To expand our understanding of the structure of diverse RNase P RNAs, we have isolated by PCR and sequenced 13 partial RNase P RNA genes from 11 additional vertebrate taxa representing most extant major vertebrate lineages. Based on a recently proposed structure of the core elements of RNase P RNA, we aligned the sequences and propose a minimum consensus secondary structure for the vertebrate RNase P RNA.     

Phylogenetic-comparative analysis of the eukaryal ribonuclease P RNA

Ribonuclease P (RNase P) is the ribonucleoprotein enzyme that cleaves 5'-leader sequences from precursor-tRNAs. Bacterial and eukaryal RNase P RNAs differ fundamentally in that the former, but not the latter, are capable of catalyzing pre-tRNA maturation in vitro in the absence of proteins. An explanation of these functional differences will be assisted by a detailed comparison of bacterial and eukaryal RNase P RNA structures. However, the structures of eukaryal RNase P RNAs remain poorly characterized, compared to their bacterial and archaeal homologs. Hence, we have taken a phylogenetic-comparative approach to refine the secondary structures of eukaryal RNase P RNAs. To this end, 20 new RNase P RNA sequences have been determined from species of ascomycetous fungi representative of the genera Arxiozyma, Clavispora, Kluyveromyces, Pichia, Saccharomyces, Saccharomycopsis, Torulaspora, Wickerhamia, and Zygosaccharomyces. Phylogenetic-comparative analysis of these and other sequences refines previous eukaryal RNase P RNA secondary structure models. Patterns of sequence conservation and length variation refine the minimum-consensus model of the core eukaryal RNA structure. In comparison to bacterial RNase P RNAs, the eukaryal homologs lack RNA structural elements thought to be critical for both substrate binding and catalysis. Nonetheless, the eukaryal RNA retains the main features of the catalytic core of the bacterial RNase P. This indicates that the eukaryal RNA remains intrinsically a ribozyme.     

Bacterial ribonuclease P holoenzyme crosslinking analysis reveals protein interaction sites on the RNA subunit

The structure of the Escherichia coli ribonuclease P (RNase P) holoenzyme was investigated by site-directed attachment of an aryl azide crosslink reagent to specific sites in the protein subunit of the enzyme. The sites of crosslinking to the RNase P RNA subunit were mapped by primer extension to several conserved residues and structural features throughout the RNA. The results suggest rearrangement of current tertiary models of the RNA subunit, particularly in regions poorly constrained by earlier data. Crosslinks to the substrate precursor-tRNA were also detected, consistent with previous crosslinking results in the Bacillus subtilis RNase P holoenzyme.     

Comparative analysis of ribonuclease P RNA structure in Archaea.

Although the structure of the catalytic RNA component of ribonuclease P has been well characterized in Bacteria, it has been little studied in other organisms, such as the Archaea. We have determined the sequences encoding RNase P RNA in eight euryarchaeal species: Halococcus morrhuae, Natronobacterium gregoryi, Halobacterium cutirubrum, Halobacteriurn trapanicum, Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum strains deltaH and Marburg, Methanothermus fervidus and Thermococcus celer strain AL-1. On the basis of these and previously available sequences from Sulfolobus acidocaldarius, Haloferax volcanii and Methanosarcina barkeri the secondary structure of RNase P RNA in Archaea has been analyzed by phylogenetic comparative analysis. The archaeal RNAs are similar in both primary and secondary structure to bacterial RNase P RNAs, but unlike their bacterial counterparts these archaeal RNase P RNAs are not by themselves catalytically proficient in vitro.     

Phylogenetic analysis and evolution of RNase P RNA in proteobacteria.

The secondary structures of the eubacterial RNase P RNAs are being elucidated by a phylogenetic comparative approach. Sequences of genes encoding RNase P RNA from each of the recognized subgroups (alpha, beta, gamma, and delta) of the proteobacteria have now been determined. These sequences allow the refinement, to nearly the base pair level, of the phylogenetic model for RNase P RNA secondary structure. Evolutionary change among the RNase P RNAs was found to occur primarily in four discrete structural domains that are peripheral to a highly conserved core structure. The new sequences were used to examine critically the proposed similarity (C. Guerrier-Takada, N. Lumelsky, and S. Altman, Science 246:1578-1584, 1989) between a portion of RNase P RNA and the "exit site" of the 23S rRNA of Escherichia coli. Phylogenetic comparisons indicate that these sequences are not homologous and that any similarity in the structures is, at best, tenuous.     

Structure and evolution of ribonuclease P RNA.

Eubacterial RNase P contains a catalytic RNA that cleaves 5' leader sequences from precursor tRNAs. We review the current understanding of RNase P RNA structure and evolution, from the perspective of phylogenetic comparative analysis.     

Phylogenetic comparative analysis of RNA structure on Macintosh computers

A Macintosh Hypertalk program (Hypercard ‘stack’)for use in phylogenetic comparative analysis of RNA structureis described. The program identifies covariations and compensatorychanges in RNA sequence alignments, for use in the constructionof secondary structure models or the identification of tertiaryinteractions. The results of an analysis are presented eitheras a list of positions in the alignment which covary, or asa 2-dimensional matrix in which potential helices in the secondarystructure appear as diagonal patterns. Received on January 7, 1991; accepted on March 19, 1991     

Human tyrosine tRNA is also internally cleavable by E. coli ribonuclease P RNA ribozyme in vitro

Transfer RNA is an essential molecule for biological system, and each tRNA molecule commonly has a cloverleaf structure. Previously, we experimentally showed that some Drosophila tRNA (tRNA(Ala), tRNA(His), and tRNA(iMet)) molecules fit to form another, non-cloverleaf, structure in which the 3'-half of the tRNA molecules forms an alternative hairpin, and that the tRNA molecules are internally cleaved by the catalytic RNA of bacterial ribonuclease P (RNase P). Until now, the hyperprocessing reaction of tRNA has only been reported with Drosophila tRNAs. This time, we applied the hyperprocessing reaction to one of human tRNAs, human tyrosine tRNA, and we showed that this tRNA was also hyperprocessed by E. coli RNase P RNA. This tRNA is the first example for hyperprocessed non-Drosophila tRNAs. The results suggest that the hyperprocessing reaction can be a useful tool detect destablized tRNA molecules from any species.     

Functional domains of the RNA component of ribonuclease P revealed by chemical probing of mutant RNAs.

The higher-order structure of the RNA component of ribonuclease P from Escherichia coli was analyzed using chemical probes. The secondary structure model which had been constructed from the comparative sequence analysis of the RNA was refined using the experimental data. In a mutant RNA (A89 RNA), which contains a G----A substitution at nucleotide 89, we detected a number of conformational alterations clustered between nucleotides 90 and 239. In view of the fact that A89 RNA is as catalytically active as wild-type RNA, but defective in association with the protein component, it is clear that the catalytic function of the RNA component resides on the structure which is not disrupted by the A89 mutation and that the structures altered by the mutation represent the region(s) interacting with the protein component. Another mutant (A329 RNA), which has a G----A substitution at nucleotide 329 and is defective in catalytic function, showed no detectable change in higher-order structure.     

Porphyrins and porphines bind strongly and specifically to tRNA, precursor tRNA and to M1 RNA and inhibit the ribonuclease P ribozyme reaction

Porphyrins and porphines strongly inhibit the action of the RNA subunit of the Escherichia coli ribonuclease P (M1 RNA). Meso-tetrakis(N-methyl-pyridyl)porphine followed linear competitive kinetics with pre-tRNA(Gly1) from E. coli as variable substrate (Ki 0.960 microM). Protoporphyrin IX showed linear competitive inhibition versus pre-tRNA(Gly1) from E. coli (Ki 1.90 microM). Inhibition by meso-tetrakis[4-(trimethylammonio)phenyl]porphine versus pre-tRNA(Gly1) from E. coli followed non-competitive kinetics (Ki 4.1 microM). The porphyrins bound directly to E. coli tRNAVal, E. coli pre-tRNAGly1 and M1 RNA and dissociation constants for the 1:1 complexes were determined using fluorescence spectroscopy. Dissociation constants (microM) against E. coli tRNAVal and E. coli pre-tRNAGly were: meso-tetrakis(N-methyl-pyridyl)porphine 1.21 and 0.170; meso-tetrakis[4-(trimethylammonio)phenyl]porphine, 0.107 and 0.293; protoporphyrin IX, 0.138 and 0.0819. For M1 RNA, dissociation constants were 32.8 nM for meso-tetrakis(N-methyl-pyridyl)porphine and 59.8 nM for meso-tetrakis[4-(trimethylammonio)phenyl]porphine and excitation and emission spectra indicate a binding mode with strong pi-stacking of the porphine nucleus and base pairs in a rigid low-polarity environment. Part of the inhibition of ribonuclease P is from interaction with the pre-tRNA substrate, resulting from porphyrin binding to the D-loop/T-loop region which interfaces with M1 RNA during catalysis, and part from the porphyrin binding to the M1 RNA component.     

Structure and evolution of ribonuclease P RNA in Gram-positive bacteria.

The sequences and structures of RNase P RNAs of some Gram-positive bacteria, e.g. Bacillus subtilis, are very different than those of other bacteria. In order to expand our understanding of the structure and evolution of RNase P RNA in Gram-positive bacteria, gene sequences encoding RNase P RNAs from 10 additional species from this evolutionary group have been determined, doubling the number of sequences available for comparative analysis. The enlarged data set allows refinement of the secondary structure model of these unusual RNase P RNAs and the identification of potential tertiary interactions between P10.1 and L12, and between L5.1 and L15.1. The newly-obtained sequences suggest that RNase P RNA underwent an abrupt, dramatic restructuring in the ancestry of the low-G+C Gram-positive bacteria after the divergence of the branches leading to the 'Clostridia and relatives' and the remaining low-G+C Gram-positive species. The unusual structures of the RNase P RNAs of Mycoplasma hyopneumoniae and M.floccularre are apparently derived from RNAs with Bacillus-like structure rather than from intermediate, partially restructured ancestral RNAs. The structure of the RNase P RNA from the photosynthetic Heliobacillus mobilis supports the relationship of this specie with Bacillus and Staphylococcus rather than the 'Clostridia and relatives' as suggested by the sequences of their small-subunit ribosomal RNAs.     

Purine N7 groups that are crucial to the interaction of Escherichia coli rnase P RNA with tRNA.

We have detected by nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) purine N7 functional groups in Escherichia coli RNase P RNA that are important for tRNA binding under moderate salt conditions (0.1 M Mg2+, 0.1 M NH4+). The majority of identified positions represent highly or universally conserved nucleotides. Our assay system allowed us, for the first time, to identify c7-deaza interference effects at two G residues (G292, G306). Several c7-deazaadenine interference effects (A62, A65, A136, A249, A334, A351) have also been identified in other studies performed at very different salt concentrations, either selecting for substrate binding in the presence of 0.025 M Ca2+ and 1 M NH4+ or self-cleavage of a ptRNA-RNase P RNA conjugate in the presence of 3 M NH4+ or Na+. This indicates that these N7 functional groups play a key role in the structural organization of ribozyme-substrate and -product complexes. We further observed that a c7-deaza modification at A76 of tRNA interferes with tRNA binding to and ptRNA processing by E. coli RNase P RNA. This finding combined with the strong c7-deaza interference at G292 of RNase P RNA supports a model in which substrate and product binding to E. coli RNase P RNA involves the formation of intermolecular base triples (A258-G292-C75 and G291-G259-A76).     

Cleavage of tRNA precursors by the RNA subunit of E. coli ribonuclease P (M1 RNA) is influenced by 3''-proximal CCA in the substrates

tRNA precursor molecules that contain the CCA sequence found at the 3' termini of all mature tRNAs are cleaved in vitro more readily by M1 RNA, the catalytic subunit of E. coli RNAase P, than precursors that lack this sequence. The sensitivity to the CCA sequence is not apparent when precursors are cleaved by the reconstituted RNAase P holoenzyme that contains both M1 RNA and the protein subunit. These results have been obtained with monomeric precursor molecules encoded by the E. coli and human chromosomes and with three dimeric precursor molecules encoded by the bacteriophage T4 genome. The data are in agreement with previous results concerning T4 tRNA biosynthesis in vivo and show that the CCA sequence is important for the processing of precursors to tRNAs.