False-negative results in cervical cytologic studies

The appropriate interval between cervical cytologic screening studies is a matter of considerable controversy, with a major consideration being the problem of false-negative results. To determine the rate of false-negative cervical cytologic results in our laboratory and to determine how these failures occur, tissue-proven cases of carcinoma in situ, invasive squamous-cell carcinoma, endocervical adenocarcinoma and lymphoid malignancy involving the cervix with negative Papanicolaou smears obtained within one year prior to the tissue diagnosis were reviewed. Over the four-year period from 1980 through 1983, 339 patients had tissue-proven cervical malignancies. Of these, 66 had false-negative Papanicolaou smears, representing a 20% overall false-negative rate. These false-negative smears were rescreened. For all types of cervical malignancy, the majority of errors were due to sampling. No malignancy was missed disproportionately by either cytotechnologists or cytopathologists. We plan to utilize these data for quality control purposes and for continued review of future performance.     

Imprint cytology of sentinel lymph nodes in breast cancer. Experience with rapid, intraoperative diagnosis and primary screening by cytotechnologists

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the intraoperative imprint diagnoses of smears from sentinel lymph nodes that had been primary screened by cytotechnologists and to assess the most important causes of false negative (FN) imprint diagnoses. STUDY DESIGN: Material consisted of 429 imprints from sentinel lymph nodes in 211 breast cancer patients that were sent for frozen section examination over 13 months. RESULTS: The mean number of imprints/lymph nodes per patient was 2.02. The mean screening time per imprint was 3.6 minutes. Sixty-six sentinel nodes (16%) from 51 women (24%) were metastatic. Imprints and/or frozen sections were positive in 54 nodes (82%). Imprints were positive in 38 nodes, representing 70% of intraoperative positive nodes and 58% of the total number of positive nodes. Twenty-six of 28 (93%) FN imprints were due to suboptimal sampling. Four of 9 FN macrometastases did not contain diagnostic or suspicious cells/cell groups even on rescreening, whereas a few, and then only 1 diagnostic group were identified in 2/9. There were no false positives. CONCLUSION: Primary screening by experienced cytotechnologists is both rapid and reliable and enabled the diagnosing pathologist to concentrate on the frozen section. The major cause of false negative imprints is sampling, even in macrometastases.     

Characteristics of high grade dyskaryotic cervical smears likely to be missed on rapid rescreening

OBJECTIVE: To determine if there is a type of high grade dyskaryotic cervical smear that is likely to be missed on rapid rescreening. STUDY DESIGN: Fifty high grade dyskaryotic smears that had originally been incorrectly reported as negative (FN) were admixed with 100 true negative smears. Each smear in the set was rapidly reviewed at least 40 times. The FN smears that were picked out on > 50% of screenings were compared with those that were passed as unremarkable on > 50% of screenings for features of the dyskaryotic cell population. RESULTS: Significant differences between the two types of FN smear were present in five aspects of the dyskaryotic cell population. A FN smear is more likely to be missed on rapid rescreening than to be selected for review if it has few dyskaryotic cells; if the dyskaryotic cells are small, with pale nuclei; and if they are scattered singly rather than in groups or syncytia. CONCLUSION: A type of severely dyskaryotic smear is likely to evade rapid rescreening as well as routine screening. This suggests that even when rapid rescreening is used as a quality assurance measure, the "zero-error standard" is unlikely to be attained.     

Potentially difficult smears of women with squamous cell carcinoma pose fewer problems when PAPNET is used for primary screening

The diagnosis of squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) on a cervical smear is often far from easy. This study reports the analysis of 40 true-positive SCC smears detected in primary PAPNET screening and eight false-negative (FN) conventionally screened smears. All FN cases contained sparse abnormal material (< 10% of the slide). In these potentially difficult cases the diagnosis on the PAPNET images was not hard. Statistical analysis of the quantitative data indicated that the PAPNET images of the FN cases and the true-positive cases differed in some aspects. PAPNET highlighted the importance of background information (old blood, fibrin and necrosis). In addition, all FN smears contained cancer cells in the PAPNET images, allowing a correct diagnosis.     

Cervical false negative cases detected by neural network-based technology. Critical review of cytologic errors

OBJECTIVE: To analyze the cytological errors made in the manual screening of cervical smears and to evaluate the usefulness of neural network-based technology (nnbt) in the detection of different kinds of errors. STUDY DESIGN: We reviewed 1,981 cervical smears by nnbt. Twelve false negatives (FNs) were detected and selected for study. The number of cell images showing atypical keratosis or atypical cells was evaluated on the monitor. The cellular features of the atypical cells (cellularity, cell type, nuclear and cytoplasmic changes, cellular arrangement and location on the slide) were analyzed by optic microscopy. Considering these qualitative and quantitative cytologic parameters and the diagnosis made by manual screening, we classified the errors into two groups: screening and interpretation related. RESULTS: Four FNs were screening errors. Five FNs were classified as errors of interpretation. In three cases the cause of the cytologic errors could not be ascertained. CONCLUSION: Our results confirm previous studies demonstrating that nnbt is useful for detecting screening errors. We also showed that it might be an adjunctive tool in the interpretation of abnormal cells, reducing the number of false negatives.     

Retroviral expression of alternatively spliced forms of rat fibronectin

We describe the construction in retroviral vectors and the expression of recombinant rat fibronectin (FN) cDNAs corresponding with the various alternatively spliced forms of FN. In NIH 3T3 cells, the exogenous rat FN subunits are efficiently secreted as heterodimers with endogenous mouse subunits. In contrast, in lymphoid WEHI231 cells, there is no endogenous FN synthesis and the recombinant FNs are secreted and can be purified as homogeneous proteins. We show that the purified recombinant FNs are biochemically and biologically functional. In basic assays for adhesion, spreading, cytoskeletal organization, and migration using various established adherent cell lines, different forms of FNs containing the different alternatively spliced segments show no marked differences in activity. We have used these recombinant FNs to investigate three systems in which earlier results had suggested potential differences between different forms of FN. First, all forms tested appear equally active in restoring normal morphology to a transformed cell line. Second, we detect minor differences in their ability to assemble into preexisting extracellular matrices. Finally, we report that only those forms of FN that contain the V segment will promote the spreading of a lymphoid cell line indicating that this segment confers additional biological functions for some cell types, a result that confirms and extends earlier data. These homogeneous, biologically active recombinant FNs will allow further studies of the role of the alternatively spliced segments of FN.     

A processing strategy for automated Papanicolaou smear screening.

A multilayer processing strategy was developed for the automatic screening of conventionally prepared Papanicolaou smears. The processing stages include image segmentation, feature extraction, object classification and slide classification. Mathematical morphology functions were implemented in hardware with custom-built gate array processors for image segmentation. There were 68 features used for classifier training. In object classification we combined the evidential supports of a binary decision tree classifier and a multilayer perceptron classifier to achieve an integrated decision. In this feasibility study, 449 conventionally prepared cervical Papanicolaou smears were tested in a prototype research system between January and May 1991. The 95% confidence interval for the slide false-negative rate was 1-9%, and the 95% confidence interval for the slide sort rate was 45-55%. The estimated sort rate for clearly normal slides is within the range required for a cost-efficient screening system, and the estimated false-negative rate for premalignant and malignant smears is an improvement over published false-negative rates for human performance. Several performance improvement efforts are still under way. We expect that they will result in a vastly reduced slide false-negative rate.     

Sensitivity of Seescan TV image analysis in discriminating between normal, dysplastic and malignant oral smears

OBJECTIVE: Smears from premalignant and malignant lesions may contain large proportions of normal cells together with atypical cells; that could reduce the sensitivity of cytologic diagnosis. The present study assessed the performance of the Seescan TV image analysis system (TVIAS) in distinguishing between normal, premalignant and malignant oral smears. The sensitivity of Seescan TVIAS was tested using both white and monochromatic light. STUDY DESIGN: Nuclear area (NA) and corrected integrated optical density (IOD) of 50 Feulgen-stained nuclei were measured in smears collected from normal oral mucosa (n = 6), lesions displaying epithelial dysplasia (n = 5) and invasive squamous cell carcinoma (n = 5) using a Seescan TVIAS with both white and monochromatic light. RESULTS: There was a significant increase (P < .001) in mean IOD for nuclei in smears from dysplastic lesions and carcinomas as compared with normal smears. For smears from carcinomas, the mean NA was significantly elevated as compared with dysplastic (P < .001) and normal smears (P < .01). Mean NA for dysplastic smears was significantly reduced as compared with normal smears. While all smears from premalignant and malignant lesions contained mostly normal nuclei, a significant proportion of abnormal nuclei was identified in each smear. CONCLUSION: Although oral smears contain large amounts of normal cells, the Seescan TVIAS could successfully identify dysplastic and malignant cells on the basis of both IOD and NA values with or without the use of a monochromatic filter.     

Cost analysis of PAPNET-assisted vs. conventional Pap smear evaluation in primary screening of cervical smears

OBJECTIVE: To assess the difference in costs between PAPNET-assisted and conventional microscopy of cervical smears when used as a primary screening tool. STUDY DESIGN: We performed time measurements of the initial screening of smears by four cytotechnologists in one laboratory. Time was measured in 816 conventionally screened smears and in 614 smears with PAPNET-assisted screening. Data were collected on the components of initial screening, clerical activities and other activities in the total work time of cytotechnologists in the routine situation and on resource requirements for both techniques. RESULTS: PAPNET saved an average of 22% on initial screening time per smear. Due to costs of processing and additional equipment, the costs of PAPNET-assisted screening were estimated to be $2.85 (and at least $1.79) higher per smear than conventional microscopy. The difference in costs is sensitive to the rate of time saving, the possibility of saving on quality control procedures and the component of the initial screening time in the total work time of cytotechnologists. CONCLUSION: Although PAPNET is time saving as compared with conventional microscopy, the associated reduction in personnel costs is outweighed by the costs of scanning the slides and additional equipment. This conclusion holds under a variety of assumptions. Using PAPNET instead of conventional microscopy as a primary screening tool will make cervical cancer screening less cost-effective unless the costs of PAPNET are considerably reduced and its sensitivity and/or specificity are considerably improved.     

Abrasive bronchial brushing cytology. A preliminary study of 200 specimens for the diagnosis of neoplastic and nonneoplastic bronchopulmonary lesions

Two hundred subjects with chronic respiratory symptoms with a suspicion of malignancy were selected for bronchial brushing cytology. Prior sputum examination had shown malignant squamous cells in two cases only. The cytologic appearances of the brushing smears were divided into five categories: 41 (20.5%) smears with positively malignant cells; 20 (10%) smears predominantly showing chronic inflammatory features; 31 (15.5%) smears with mainly acute inflammatory changes; 60 (30%) smears with normal cytologic features; and 48 (24%) smears unsatisfactory for cytologic interpretation. Thirteen patients with a positive cytology had a positive tissue biopsy for malignancy. Among the group with chronic inflammatory changes, acid-fast bacilli were identified in nine cases, and one smear showed frank tuberculous granuloma. In the unsatisfactory group, two cases showed malignant cells in the postbrushing sputum. There was one false-negative report for malignancy in the entire study. This study confirms the sensitivity and accuracy of bronchial brushing cytology in the diagnosis of various bronchopulmonary lesions, especially malignancy and pulmonary tuberculosis, in India.     

Quality assurance in cervical smears: 100% rapid rescreening vs. 10% random rescreening

OBJECTIVE: To compare 100% rapid rescreening of cervical smears with 10% random rescreening as a method of quality assurance. STUDY DESIGN: A total of 5215 smears, randomly selected from smears reported as negative by cytotechnologists during routine screening, underwent 100% rapid rescreening by senior cytotechnologists. Ten percent of these smears, selected at random, were rescreened by other senior cytotechnologists. The gold standard was defined by cytopathologists, who rescreened all 5215 smears. After excluding unsatisfactory smears detected by cytopathologists, 4271 were included in the analysis. RESULTS: The 100% rapid rescreening method identified 69.9%, 95.7% and 100%, respectively, of atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance, low grade squamous intraepithelial lesion and high grade squamous intraepithelial lesion cases reported by the cytopathologists. The 100% rapid rescreening method showed a sensitivity of 73.5% and specificity of 98.6%. The 10% rescreening method showed sensitivity of 40.9% and specificity of 98.8%. CONCLUSION: One hundred percent rapid rescreening is an efficient method of internal quality assurance in cervical smear diagnosis. It can reduce the false negative rate and therefore can provide greater certainty to women who have received negative results. Well-trained cytotechnologists are able to identify abnormal smears in 1-minute rapid rescreening.     

Rapid rescreening of cervical smears as a quality control method in a high-risk population

OBJECTIVE: Cancer of the cervix is one of the commonest cancers in South Africa. Accurate cytological diagnosis is one of the prerequisites for an effective cervical screening programme and requires the implementation of appropriate quality assurance modalities. This study was undertaken to determine if rapid review of reportedly negative cervical smears is a useful internal quality assurance modality in an unscreened population with very high rates of cervical carcinoma. METHOD: Approximately 26% of all cervical smears received at the study institution between 1 January 1998 and 31 December 2003, and initially reported as negative or inadequate, underwent rapid review. RESULTS: A total of 62,866 (26%) cervical smears out of 241,796 reportedly negative or inadequate cervical smears underwent rapid review. An amended report was sent out in 373 (0.59%) of these 62,866 cervical smears. This included 101 cases of high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesion (HSIL) and high-grade atypical squamous cells (ASC-H), 143 low-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions, 54 atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance (ASC-US) and 33 atypical glandular cells that were not reported initially. The false-negative proportion for HSIL and ASC-H (combined) in this study was 5.76%. No squamous cell carcinomas were diagnosed on rapid review but one patient with HSIL/ASC-H on review had squamous cell carcinoma on biopsy. Three cytotechnologists had a lower sensitivity of primary screening and required retraining. CONCLUSIONS: Rapid review is beneficial as an internal quality assurance modality in an unscreened high-risk population and increases the detection of women with significant cervical lesions requiring treatment. The relatively low cost of rapid review compared with other rescreening modalities makes this an attractive option in low resource settings.     

Immunohistochemical studies with monoclonal antibodies B72.3 and MA5 on histologic and cytologic specimens from benign and malignant breast lesions

Monoclonal antibodies B72.3 and MA5 were tested by the avidin-biotin immunoperoxidase method in histologic sections of 38 benign, 22 precancerous and 22 cancerous breast lesions, as well as in fine needle aspiration (FNA) smears and cell blocks of 25 breast carcinomas. Neither B72.3 nor MA5 was specific for breast cancer cells: both also reacted with cells from benign and precancerous conditions. B72.3 as a "detector" of malignant cells or their precursors was superior to MA5, however: it was not reactive to cells in most benign breast lesions (mammary duct ectasia, fibroadenoma and ductal hyperplasia, with and without atypia). Cancerous cells had heterogeneous immunostaining with B72.3, which may lead to false-negative results in relatively hypocellular FNA samples. FNA samples prepared as both smears and cell blocks provided the most abundant cellular samples and the lowest false-negative immunostaining reaction of cancerous cells with B72.3.     

The use of the PAPNET automated cytological screening system for the diagnosis of oral squamous carcinoma

levine t. s., njemenze v., cowpe j. g. and coleman d. v. (1998) Cytopathology 9, 398–405
The use of the PAPNET automated cytological screening system for the diagnosis of oral squamous carcinoma
The automated PAPNET screening system has been developed to recognize abnormal cells in cervical smears. Given that the oral mucosa sheds cells resembling superficial and intermediate cells of the cervix, the aim of this study was to assess whether the PAPNET system could be used to detect dysplastic cells in oral mucosal smears. Sixty-two oral smears from 27 patients were examined by both light microscopy and using the PAPNET system from clinically abnormal and normal areas by two pathologists. The clinically abnormal sites were also biopsied for histological analysis. There was 100% correlation between the manual and PAPNET screening results. Cytological interpretation of oral smears by both manual and PAPNET screening methods correctly diagnosed squamous cell carcinoma in 14/23 (61%) of patients who had all been confirmed by biopsy. The nine patients with false-negative cases could be attributed to poor smear technique and preparation. The PAPNET system can be used to identify abnormal cells in oral smears and, as such, may have an application for screening those populations at high risk of oral cancer—provided that adequate tuition is given in smear technique.     

Cellular tumorigenicity in nude mice. Test of associations among loss of cell-surface fibronectin, anchorage independence, and tumor-forming ability

Fibronectin (FN; also called large external transformation-sensitive [LETS] protein or cell-surface protein [CSP]) is a large cell-surface glycoprotein that is frequently observed to be either absent or greatly reduced on the surfaces of malignant cells grown in vitro. Because FN may be a useful molecular marker of cellular malignancy, we have carried out an extensive screening to test the specific association among the degree of expression of FN, anchorage-independent growth, and tumorigenicity in the athymic nude mouse. A variety of diploid cell strains and established cell lines were tested for the expression of surface FN by indirect immunofluorescence using rabbit antisera against human cold insoluble globulin, rodent plasma FN, or chicken cell- surface FN. Concomitantly, the cells were assayed for tumor formation in nude mice and for the ability to form colonies in methylcellulose. Tumorigenic cells often showed very low surface fluorescence, confirming earlier reports. However, many highly tumorigenic fibroblast lines from several species stained strongly with all three antisera. In contrast, the anchorage-independent phenotype was nearly always associated with tumorigenicity in approximately 35 cell lines examined in this study. In another series of experiments, FN-positive but anchorage-independent cells were grown as tumors in nude mice and then reintroduced into culture. In five of the six tumor-derived cell lines, cell-surface FN was not significantly reduced; one such cell line showed very little surface FN. Our data thus indicate that the loss of cell-surface FN is not a necessary step in the process of malignant transformation and that the growth of FN-positive cells as tumors does not require a prior selection in vivo for FN-negative subpopulations.     

Rapid cervicovaginal smear screening: method of quality control and assessing individual cytotechnologist performance

AIM: To validate the method of rapid screening (RS) in the detection of cervical lesions and false-negative results as well as in quality control of cytotechnologist performance. MATERIAL AND METHODS: The RS method was validated on Papanicolaou-stained and initially conventionally analysed vaginal, cervical and endocervical (VCE) smears collected in an opportunistic programme for the detection of cervical carcinoma. The study included 3680 VCE smears from the Department of Gynaecologic Cytology, University Department of Gynaecology and Obstetrics, Zagreb University Hospital Center, Zagreb and from the Department of Clinical Cytology, Osijek University Hospital, Osijek. Histologically verified abnormal findings accounted for 10% of the study samples. Thirteen cytotechnologists, with no previous experience in RS, performed the test. Each slide was examined using the 'step' technique for 1.5 minutes, the findings were classified as negative or abnormal, and the abnormal ones were also classified according to differential cytological diagnosis. The results were compared with those obtained on initial screening. Abnormal findings from a group of initially negative findings were reanalysed using conventional methods to make definitive cytological diagnosis. RESULTS: RS yielded a sensitivity of 83.7%, specificity of 93.7%, positive predictive value of 62.4%, negative predictive value of 97.9% and diagnostic accuracy of 92.6%. Relative to the initial abnormal differential cytological diagnosis, the diagnostic value of RS increased with lesion severity [54.8%, 68.0% and 91.3% for cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) I, CIN II and CIN III respectively]. RS detected 38 additional positive findings; 94.2% of these were atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance (ASCUS)/abnormal glandular cells undetermined significance (AGUS) and CIN I. The rate of additional positive findings was 1.14% (38/3135). The false-negative rate of initial screening was 9.4% (38/406), and individual cytotechnologist sensitivity was 60.0-100.0%. CONCLUSION: RS could be introduced as an efficient method of quality control to improve the sensitivity of cytological screening as well as for quality control of cytotechnologist performance.     

Probing molecular polymorphism of fibronectins with antibodies directed to the alternatively spliced peptide segments

Molecular heterogeneity of fibronectins (FNs) isolated from plasma, cultured fibroblasts, and placenta was studied with site-specific antibodies recognizing alternatively spliced peptide segments, termed ED-A and IIICS/delta 2. The antibodies were raised in rabbits by immunization with synthetic peptides. Neither the ED-A nor the IIICS/delta 2 extra peptide segment was present in the major subunits of plasma FN, although a minor subunit contained the latter extra segment. Cellular FN consisted of at least four subunits differing in size of the fragments generated by cleavage of the C-terminal region with cathepsin D. These fragments were distinct from each other in the reactivity with anti-ED-A and anti-IIICS/delta 2 antibodies, suggesting that all combinations of the presence or absence of the extra segments were produced by cultured fibroblasts. Placental FN was more heterogeneous than plasma and cellular FNs, consisting of five, or probably more, subunits. Among these, the two smaller subunits appeared to be closely similar to the major subunits of plasma FN, whereas the other subunits were more related to those of cellular FN in the size of cathepsin D cleaved C-terminal fragments and in the reactivity with anti-peptide antibodies. These results, taken together, indicate that the FNs produced by different tissues or cell types are distinct from each other in the number and types of subunits, which are partly, if not all, defined by alternative splicing at the ED-A and IIICS regions.     

Evaluation of the AutoCyte SCREEN system in a clinical cytopathology laboratory

OBJECTIVE: To compare the AutoCyte SCREEN (AutoCyte, Burlington, North Carolina, U.S.A.) system with manual screening by experienced cytotechnologists using thin-layer preparations that had been previously extensively studied and their cytologic abnormalities well defined. STUDY DESIGN: AutoCyte PREP (AutoCyte) samples prepared for a previous split-sample study comparing thin-layer preparations to conventional smears were used. These 1,992 AutoCyte PREP samples were in a cohort the abnormal findings of which had been confirmed via independent review by two sets of pathologists. For the current study, these samples were remasked and evaluated by the AutoCyte SCREEN system in a clinical laboratory. The instrument scanned each slide and selected six overview fields and 120 single objects for storage and display. The computer classified each slide in one of the following categories: abnormal, uncertain, normal or unsatisfactory. Independently for each case, a cytotechnologist evaluated the six fields and 120 objects selected by the instrument as abnormal, normal or unsatisfactory. For those cases classified as uncertain by AutoCyte, the technologist then reexamined the cellular displays and entered a consensus classification. These results were then compared to those of an independent review by cytotechnologists of the identical set of slides using routine manual screening. RESULTS: The AutoCyte SCREEN selected 35% of slides for manual review. Technologist and computer rendered equivalent classifications in 79%. Of the total slides screened by the AutoCyte SCREEN, 57% were classified as "uncertain," and 88% of these were subsequently classified as normal by consensus. Using the well-defined abnormal values of the cellular sample as a basis for calculation, the AutoCyte SCREEN-assisted practice had a diagnostic sensitivity of 85% and diagnostic specificity of 97.6%. Comparable values for manual screening of the identical cellular sample were a diagnostic sensitivity of 80% and specificity of 97.4%. CONCLUSION: The AutoCyte SCREEN achieves comparable or greater sensitivity in detecting cervical abnormalities in comparison with manual screening. When combined with the substantial advantage of thin-layer preparations over conventional smears, the AutoCyte SCREEN provides a screening system of superior sensitivity over conventionally prepared and examined cervical smears.     

Assessment of the cyto- and genotoxic effects of a nanoferromagnetic and a static magnetic field in vivo

The cyto- and genotoxic effects of ferromagnetic nanoparticles (FNs), a static magnetic field (SMF), or their combination were comparatively studied in Ehrlich ascites carcinoma (EAC) cells, bone marrow (BM) erythroid series cells, and peripheral blood lymphocytes at definite time intervals, using the MN test and the DNA-comet assay. The MN test and the DNA-comet assay were used as markers of genotoxic exposure. It has been shown that the limit value of insignificantly expressed changes in the EAC cell architectonics (due to FNs) is an FN concentration of 3 mg/kg. The FN concentration increases in tumor cells, because the expressed blebbing in the cytoplasmic membrane increases the amount of micronuclei and the percentage of DNA in the comet tail in EAC cells, BM erythroid series cells, and peripheral blood lymphocytes. It has also been demonstrated that an SMF alone, as an independent factor, does not produce cytogenotoxic effects on the studied cells. When SMF and FN were used in combination, we could observe the phenomenon of SMF induction by FNs, which manifested itself as an increased total effect of these factors on cells. The MN-test and the DNA-comet assay can be used for assessing the genomic stability of both tumor cells and somatic nonmalignized cells when testing the genotoxic effect of nanomaterials used in the design of vector systems. As was established, the DNA-comet method demonstrated a higher sensitivity in the assessment of the genotoxicity produced by the studied factors.