Light pollution affects invasive and native plant traits important to plant competition and herbivorous insects

Biological Invasions - Invasions in urban settings have been understudied in terms of how invasions are impacted by uniquely urban stressors, such as streetlights. Plant physiology and phenology...     

The mechanisms of plant photosynthetic acclimation to elevated CO2 concentration]

When measured at a same CO(2) concentration, net photosynthetic rate is often significantly lower in long-term high CO(2)-grown plants than the ambient CO(2)-grown ones. This phenomenon is termed photosynthetic acclimation or down-regulation. Although there have been many reports and reviews, the mechanism(s) of the photosynthetic acclimation is not very clear. Combining the work of the authors' group, this paper briefly reviews the progress in studies on the mechanism(s) of the photosynthetic acclimation to elevated CO(2). It is suggested that besides the possible effects of respiration enhancement and excessive photosynthate accumulation, RuBP carboxylation limitation and RuBP regeneration limitation are probably the main factors leading to the photosynthetic acclimation.     

Contrasting acclimation responses to elevated CO2 and warming between an evergreen and a deciduous boreal conifer

Rising atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO₂) concentrations may warm northern latitudes up to 8°C by the end of the century. Boreal forests play a large role in the global carbon cycle, and the responses of northern trees to climate change will thus impact the trajectory of future CO₂ increases. We grew two North American boreal tree species at a range of future climate conditions to assess how growth and carbon fluxes were altered by high CO₂ and warming. Black spruce (Picea mariana, an evergreen conifer) and tamarack (Larix laricina, a deciduous conifer) were grown under ambient (407 ppm) or elevated CO₂ (750 ppm) and either ambient temperatures, a 4°C warming, or an 8°C warming. In both species, the thermal optimum of net photosynthesis (T_optA) increased and maximum photosynthetic rates declined in warm‐grown seedlings, but the strength of these changes varied between species. Photosynthetic capacity (maximum rates of Rubisco carboxylation, V_cmax, and of electron transport, J_max) was reduced in warm‐grown seedlings, correlating with reductions in leaf N and chlorophyll concentrations. Warming increased the activation energy for V_cmax and J_max (E_aV and E_aJ, respectively) and the thermal optimum for J_max. In both species, the T_optA was positively correlated with both E_aV and E_aJ, but negatively correlated with the ratio of J_max/V_cmax. Respiration acclimated to elevated temperatures, but there were no treatment effects on the Q₁₀ of respiration (the increase in respiration for a 10°C increase in leaf temperature). A warming of 4°C increased biomass in tamarack, while warming reduced biomass in spruce. We show that climate change is likely to negatively affect photosynthesis and growth in black spruce more than in tamarack, and that parameters used to model photosynthesis in dynamic global vegetation models (E_aV and E_aJ) show no response to elevated CO₂.     

Genotypic variation in source and sink traits affects the response of photosynthesis and growth to elevated atmospheric CO2

This study aimed to understand the response of photosynthesis and growth to e-CO₂ conditions (800 vs. 400 μmol mol⁻¹) of rice genotypes differing in source–sink relationships. A proxy trait called local C source–sink ratio was defined as the ratio of flag leaf area to the number of spikelets on the corresponding panicle, and five genotypes differing in this ratio were grown in a controlled greenhouse. Differential CO₂ resources were applied either during the 2 weeks following heading (EXP1) or during the whole growth cycle (EXP2). Under e-CO₂, low source–sink ratio cultivars (LSS) had greater gains in photosynthesis, and they accumulated less nonstructural carbohydrate in the flag leaf than high source–sink ratio cultivars (HSS). In EXP2, grain yield and biomass gain was also greater in LSS probably caused by their strong sink. Photosynthetic capacity response to e-CO₂ was negatively correlated across genotypes with local C source–sink ratio, a trait highly conserved across environments. HSS were sink-limited under e-CO₂, probably associated with low triose phosphate utilization (TPU) capacity. We suggest that the local C source–sink ratio is a potential target for selecting more CO₂-responsive cultivars, pending validation for a broader genotypic spectrum and for field conditions.     

Leaf quality and insect herbivory in model tropical plant communities after long-term exposure to elevated atmospheric CO2

Results from laboratory feeding experiments have shown that elevated atmospheric carbon dioxide can affect interactions between plants and insect herbivores, primarily through changes in leaf nutritional quality occurring at elevated CO₂. Very few data are available on insect herbivory in plant communities where insects can choose among species and positions in the canopy in which to feed. Our objectives were to determine the extent to which CO₂-induced changes in plant communities and leaf nutritional quality may affect herbivory at the level of the entire canopy. We introduced equivalent populations of fourth instar Spodoptera eridania, a lepidopteran generalist, to complex model ecosystems containing seven species of moist tropical plants maintained under low mineral nutrient supply. Larvae were allowed to feed freely for 14 days, by which time they had reached the seventh instar. Prior to larval introductions, plant communities had been continuously exposed to either 340 l CO₂ l^–1 or to 610 l CO₂ l^–1 for 1.5 years. No major shifts in leaf nutritional quality [concentrations of N, total non-structural carbohydrates (TNC), sugar, and starch; ratios of: C/N, TNC/N, sugar/N, starch/N; leaf toughness] were observed between CO₂ treatments for any of the species. Furthermore, no correlations were observed between these measures of leaf quality and leaf biomass consumption. Total leaf area and biomass of all plant communities were similar when caterpillars were introduced. However, leaf biomass of some species was slightly greater-and for other species slightly less (e.g. Cecropia peltata)-in communities exposed to elevated CO₂. Larvae showed the strongest preference for C. peltata leaves, the plant species that was least abundant in all communites, and fed relatively little on plants species which were more abundant. Thus, our results indicate that leaf tissue quality, as described by these parameters, is not necessarily affected by elevated CO₂ under relatively low nutrient conditions. Hence, the potential importance of CO₂-induced shifts in leaf nutritional quality, as determinants of herbivory, may be overestimated for many plant communities growing on nutrient-poor sites if estimates are based on traditional laboratory feeding studies. Finally, slight shifts in the abundance of leaf tissue of various species occurring under elevated CO₂ will probably not significantly affect herbivory by generalist insects. However, generalist insect herbivores appear to become more dependent on less-preferred plant species in cases where elevated CO₂ results in reduced availability of leaves of a favoured plant species, and this greater dependency may eventually affect insect populations adversely.     

Contrasting acclimation abilities of two dominant boreal conifers to elevated CO2 and temperature

High latitude forests will experience large changes in temperature and CO₂ concentrations this century. We evaluated the effects of future climate conditions on 2 dominant boreal tree species, Pinus sylvestris L. and Picea abies (L.) H. Karst, exposing seedlings to 3 seasons of ambient (430 ppm) or elevated CO₂ (750 ppm) and ambient temperatures, a + 4 °C warming or a + 8 °C warming. Pinus sylvestris responded positively to warming: seedlings developed a larger canopy, maintained high net CO₂ assimilation rates (A_net), and acclimated dark respiration (R_dark). In contrast, carbon fluxes in Picea abies were negatively impacted by warming: maximum rates of A_net decreased, electron transport was redirected to alternative electron acceptors, and thermal acclimation of R_dark was weak. Elevated CO₂ tended to exacerbate these effects in warm‐grown Picea abies, and by the end of the experiment Picea abies from the +8 °C, high CO₂ treatment produced fewer buds than they had 3 years earlier. Treatments had little effect on leaf and wood anatomy. Our results highlight that species within the same plant functional type may show opposite responses to warming and imply that Picea abies may be particularly vulnerable to warming due to low plasticity in photosynthetic and respiratory metabolism.     

大气CO_2浓度升高对植物-植食性昆虫的作用机制

大气二氧化碳浓度升高及其伴随的全球变暖引起国内外科学家的极大关注。CO2浓度升高主要通过改变植物的初级和次级代谢产物,影响以之为食的昆虫。本文结合作者近年来的研究成果,着重于以CO2浓度升高为作用因子,以植物和植食性昆虫的相互关系为对象,比较了咀嚼式口器昆虫与刺吸式口器昆虫对大气CO2浓度升高的响应特征,分析了不同取食类型昆虫-植物对大气CO2浓度升高的响应机制。     

Tree seedling growth in natural deep shade: functional traits related to interspecific variation in response to elevated CO2

The mechanisms for species-specific growth responses to changes in atmospheric CO₂ concentration within narrow ecological groups of species, such as shade-tolerant, late-successional trees, have rarely been addressed and are not well understood. In this study the underlying functional traits for interspecific variation in the biomass response to elevated CO₂ were explored for seedlings of five late-successional temperate forest tree species (Fagus sylvatica, Acer pseudoplatanus, Quercus robur, Taxus baccata, Abies alba). The seedlings were grown in the natural forest understorey in very low and low light microsites (an average of 1.3% and 3.4% full sun in this experiment), and were exposed to either current ambient CO₂ concentrations, 500, or 660 µl CO₂ l^-1 in 36 open-top chambers (OTC) over two growing seasons. Even across the narrow range of successional status and shade tolerance, the study species varied greatly in photosynthesis, light compensation point, leaf dark respiration (R_d), leaf nitrogen concentration, specific leaf area (SLA), leaf area ratio (LAR), and biomass allocation among different plant parts, and showed distinct responses to CO₂ in these traits. No single species combined all characteristics traditionally considered as adaptive to low light conditions. At very low light, the CO₂ stimulation of seedling biomass was related to increased LAR and decreased R_d, responses that were observed only in Fagus and Taxus. At slightly higher light levels, interspecific differences in the biomass response to elevated CO₂ were reversed and correlated best with leaf photosynthesis. The data provided here contribute to a mechanistic process-based understanding of distinct response patterns in co-occurring tree species to elevated CO₂ in natural deep shade. I conclude that the high variation in physiological and morphological traits among late-successional species, and the consequences for their responses to slight changes in resource availability, have previously been underestimated. The commonly used broad definitions of functional groups of species may not be sufficient for the understanding of recruitment success and dynamic changes in species composition of old-growth forests in response to rising concentrations of atmospheric CO₂.     

Growth and senescence in plant communities exposed to elevated CO2 concentrations on an estuarine marsh

Summary Three high marsh communities on the Chesapeake Bay were exposed to a doubling in ambient CO₂ concentration for one growing season. Open-top chambers were used to raise CO₂ concentrations ca. 340 ppm above ambient over monospecific communities of Scirpus olneyi (C₃) and Spartina patens (C₄), and a mixed community of S. olneyi, S. patens, and Distichlis spicata (C₄). Plant growth and senescence were monitored by serial, nondestructive censuses. Elevated CO₂ resulted in increased shoot densities and delayed sensecence in the C₃ species. This resulted in an increase in primary productivity in S. olneyi growing in both the pure and mixed communities. There was no effect of CO₂ on growth in the C₄ species. These results demonstrate that elevated atmospheric CO₂ can cause increased aboveground production in a mature, unmanaged ecosystem.     

Tidal marsh plant responses to elevated CO2, nitrogen fertilization,and sea level rise

Elevated CO₂ and nitrogen (N) addition directly affect plant productivity and the mechanisms that allow tidal marshes to maintain a constant elevation relative to sea level, but it remains unknown how these global change drivers modify marsh plant response to sea level rise. Here we manipulated factorial combinations of CO₂ concentration (two levels), N availability (two levels) and relative sea level (six levels) using in situ mesocosms containing a tidal marsh community composed of a sedge, Schoenoplectus americanus, and a grass, Spartina patens. Our objective is to determine, if elevated CO₂ and N alter the growth and persistence of these plants in coastal ecosystems facing rising sea levels. After two growing seasons, we found that N addition enhanced plant growth particularly at sea levels where plants were most stressed by flooding (114% stimulation in the + 10 cm treatment), and N effects were generally larger in combination with elevated CO₂ (288% stimulation). N fertilization shifted the optimal productivity of S. patens to a higher sea level, but did not confer S. patens an enhanced ability to tolerate sea level rise. S. americanus responded strongly to N only in the higher sea level treatments that excluded S. patens. Interestingly, addition of N, which has been suggested to accelerate marsh loss, may afford some marsh plants, such as the widespread sedge, S. americanus, the enhanced ability to tolerate inundation. However, if chronic N pollution reduces the availability of propagules of S. americanus or other flood‐tolerant species on the landscape scale, this shift in species dominance could render tidal marshes more susceptible to marsh collapse.     

A link between plant diversity, elevated CO2 and soil nitrate

Interactive effects of reductions in plant species diversity and increases in atmospheric CO₂ were investigated in a long-term study in nutrient-poor calcareous grassland. Throughout the experiment, soil nitrate was persistently increased at low plant species diversity, and CO₂ enrichment reduced soil [NO₃^-] at all levels of plant species diversity. In our study, soil [NO₃^-] was unrelated to root length density, microbial biomass N, community legume contents, and experimental plant communities differed only little in total N pools. However, potential nitrification revealed exactly the same treatment effects as soil [NO₃^-], providing circumstantial evidence that nitrification rates drove the observed changes in [NO₃^-]. One possible explanation for plant diversity effects on nitrification lies in spatial and temporal interspecific differences in plant N uptake, which would more often allow accumulation of NH₄⁺ in part of the soil profile at low diversity than in more species-rich plant communities. Consequently, nitrification rates and soil [NO₃^-] would increase. Elevated CO₂ increased soil water contents, which may have improved NO₃^- diffusion to the root surface thereby reducing soil [NO₃^-]. Higher soil moisture at elevated CO₂ might also reduce nitrification rates due to less aerobic conditions. The accordance of the diversity effect on soil [NO₃^-] with previous experiments suggests that increased soil [NO₃^-] at low species diversity is a fairly general phenomenon, although the mechanisms causing high [NO₃^-] may vary. In contrast, experimental evidence for effects of CO₂ enrichment on soil [NO₃^-] is ambiguous, and the antagonistic interaction of plant species reductions and elevated CO₂ we have observed is thus probably less universal.     

Plant nutrient mobilization in temperate heathland responds to elevated CO2, temperature and drought

Temperate terrestrial ecosystems are currently exposed to increased atmospheric CO₂ and progressive climatic changes with increased temperature and periodical drought. We here present results from a field experiment, where the effects of these three main climate change related factors are investigated solely and in all combinations at a temperate heathland. Significant responses were found in the top soils below the two dominant species (Calluna vulgaris and Deschampsia flexuosa). During winter incubation, microbial immobilization of N and ammonification rate decreased in response to warming in Deschampsia soil, and microbial immobilization of N and P decreased in warmed Calluna soil. Warming tended to increase microbial N and P in Calluna but not in Deschampsia soil in fall, and more microbial C was accumulated under drought in Calluna soil. The effects of warming were often counteracted or erased when combined with CO₂ and drought. Below Deschampsia, the net nitrification rate decreased in response to drought and, while phosphorus availability and microbial P immobilization decreased, but nitrification increased in response to elevated CO₂. Furthermore, leaf litter decomposition of both species decreased in response to drought. These complex changes in availability and release of nutrients from soil organic matter turnover and mineralization in response to elevated CO₂ and climate change may influence the future plant carbon sequestration and species composition at temperate heathlands.     

Responses of an old-field plant community to interacting factors of elevated [CO2], warming, and soil moisture

Aims: The direct effects of atmospheric and climatic change factors—atmospheric[CO₂], air temperature and changes in precipitation—canshape plant community composition and alter ecosystem function.It is essential to understand how these factors interact tomake better predictions about how ecosystems may respond tochange. We investigated the direct and interactive effects of[CO₂], warming and altered soil moisture in open-top chambers(OTCs) enclosing a constructed old-field community to test howthese factors shape plant communities. Materials and methods: The experimental facility in Oak Ridge, TN, USA, made use of4-m diameter OTCs and rain shelters to manipulate [CO₂] (ambient,ambient + 300 ppm), air temperature (ambient, ambient + 3.5°C)and soil moisture (wet, dry). The plant communities within thechambers comprised seven common old-field species, includinggrasses, forbs and legumes. We tracked foliar cover for eachspecies and calculated community richness, evenness and diversityfrom 2003 to 2005. Important findings: This work resulted in three main findings: (1) warming had species-specificeffects on foliar cover that varied through time and were alteredby soil moisture treatments; (2) [CO₂] had little effect onindividual species or the community; (3) diversity, evennessand richness were influenced most by soil moisture, primarilyreflecting the response of one dominant species. We concludethat individualistic species responses to atmospheric and climaticchange can alter community composition and that plant populationsand communities should be considered as part of analyses ofterrestrial ecosystem response to climate change. However, predictionof plant community responses may be difficult given interactionsbetween factors and changes in response through time.     

Ectomycorrhizal exudates and pre-exposure to elevated CO2 affects soil bacterial growth and community structure

Ectomycorrhizal fungi produce low molecular weight organic compounds, supporting diverse microbial communities. To link mycorrhizal root exudation directly to bacterial responses, we used Scots pine exudates with (Suillus variegatus and Piloderma fallax) and without mycorrhiza as substrata for forest soil bacteria. Bacterial growth and vitality was monitored, and community composition determined using T-RFLP, cloning and sequencing. We investigated if the amount of organic acids in exudates explained bacterial growth, and whether bacterial communities were influenced by pre-exposure to elevated atmospheric CO₂. We demonstrated functional differences in bacterial growth rates related to CO₂. There was a shift in the bacterial community (e.g. Burkholderia sp. and gamma-proteobacteria) toward organisms better able to rapidly utilize exudates when pine microcosms were pre-exposed to elevated CO₂. Soil bacteria from all treatments tended to grow more abundantly and rapidly in exudates from Piloderma-colonized seedlings, suggesting that the organic acids and/or unidentified compounds present supported greater growth.     

Long-term acclimation to elevated pCO2 alters carbon metabolism and reduces growth in the Antarctic diatom Nitzschia lecointei

Increasing atmospheric CO₂ levels are driving changes in the seawater carbonate system, resulting in higher pCO₂ and reduced pH (ocean acidification). Many studies on marine organisms have focused on short-term physiological responses to increased pCO₂, and few on slow-growing polar organisms with a relative low adaptation potential. In order to recognize the consequences of climate change in biological systems, acclimation and adaptation to new environments are crucial to address. In this study, physiological responses to long-term acclimation (194 days, approx. 60 asexual generations) of three pCO₂ levels (280, 390 and 960 µatm) were investigated in the psychrophilic sea ice diatom Nitzschia lecointei. After 147 days, a small reduction in growth was detected at 960 µatm pCO₂. Previous short-term experiments have failed to detect altered growth in N. lecointei at high pCO₂, which illustrates the importance of experimental duration in studies of climate change. In addition, carbon metabolism was significantly affected by the long-term treatments, resulting in higher cellular release of dissolved organic carbon (DOC). In turn, the release of labile organic carbon stimulated bacterial productivity in this system. We conclude that long-term acclimation to ocean acidification is important for N. lecointei and that carbon overconsumption and DOC exudation may increase in a high-CO₂ world.     

Response of a Sphagnum bog plant community to elevated CO2 and N supply

The factors determining herbaceous canopy architecture are poorlyunderstood, especially in natural and semi-natural plant communities. Inthis study, we tested three main hypotheses: (1) the structure of herbaceouscanopies can be explained by the vertical distribution of functional groupsdefined by leaf width and the presence/absence of leaves on upright stem;(2) the degree of canopy stratification is greater in habitats that experiencelower spatial heterogeneity in the supply of light (i.e., grasslands as opposedto forest herb layers); and (3) there is significant variation among specieswithin a growth-form, with respect to their vertical position in thecanopy. We used plant foliage height distribution data from 14 grassland and 13forest herbaceous communities to test these hypotheses. A general linear mixedmodel was applied to specify the proportions of total variance in the foliageheight, accounted for by the fixed effects of plants' basicgrowth-form properties (growth-form) and community type(forest/grassland), and by the random effects of sampling site, samplingpoint, and individual species. We were also interested in the correlation ofthedegree of the stratification with various community characteristics(productivity, other canopy properties, species richness, variation ofspecies' traits) and light availability. There was some evidence ofoverall canopy stratification according toplant growth-form, since plants with leafy stem were locatedsignificantly higher. However, such a pattern of two more or less distinctlayers (grasses + upright forbs and rosette forbs) occurred withconsistency only in grasslands (greater homogeneity in light). Thebetween-species variation within a growth-form was a highlysignificant predictor of canopy vertical structure in the 27 communities. Theproportion of total observed variance, explainable throughspecies-specific effects, was comparable to that caused bybetween-site differences. The effect of community horizontal pattern wasless obvious, but still significant. The site by site analysis revealed thatthe degree to which horizontalpatchiness explained variation in vertical canopy structure was negativelyrelated to the relative importance of species-specific effects, showingthat small between-species differences lead to a more obviouswithin-community horizontal pattern, and vice versa. The upper bound ofthe degree of foliage stratification, according to growth-form, wasrelated to the variability of species light requirements and to relative (tocommunity pool size) richness, indicating that certain aspects of canopyarchitecture might be explained through community species composition anddiversity pattern.     

Genetic variation in plant below-ground response to elevated CO2 and two herbivore species

Aims

It is unclear how changing atmospheric conditions, including rising carbon dioxide concentration, influence interactions between above and below-ground systems and if intraspecific variation exists in this response.

Methods

We assessed interactive effects of atmospheric CO₂ concentration, above-ground herbivory, and plant genotype on root traits and mycorrhizal associations. Plants from five families of Asclepias syriaca, a perennial forb, were grown under ambient and elevated atmospheric CO₂ concentrations. Foliar herbivory by either lepidopteran caterpillars or phloem-feeding aphids was imposed. Mycorrhizal colonization, below-ground biomass, root biomass, and secondary defensive chemistry in roots were quantified.

Results

We observed substantial genetic variation among A. syriaca families in their mycorrhizal colonization levels in response to elevated CO₂ and herbivory treatments. Elevated CO₂ treatment increased root biomass in all genetic families, whereas foliar herbivory tended to decrease root biomass. Root cardenolide concentration and composition varied greatly among plant families, and elevated CO₂ treatment increased root cardenolides in two of the five plant families. Moreover, herbivores differentially affected the composition of cardenolides expressed below ground.

Conclusions

Increased atmospheric CO₂ has the potential to influence interactions among plants, herbivores and mycorrhizal fungi and intraspecific variation suggests that such interactions can evolve.     

Responses of fungal root colonization,plant cover and leaf nutrients to long‐term exposure to elevated atmospheric CO2 and warming in a subarctic birch forest understory

Responses of the mycorrhizal fungal community in terrestrial ecosystems to global change factors are not well understood. However, virtually all land plants form symbiotic associations with mycorrhizal fungi, with approximately 20% of the plants' net primary production transported down to the fungal symbionts. In this study, we investigated how ericoid mycorrhiza (ErM), fine endophytes (FE) and dark septate endophytes (DSE) in roots responded to elevated atmospheric CO₂ concentrations and warming in the dwarf shrub understory of a birch forest in the subarctic region of northern Sweden. To place the belowground results into an ecosystem context we also investigated how plant cover and nutrient concentrations in leaves responded to elevated atmospheric CO₂ concentrations and warming. The ErM colonization in ericaceous dwarf shrubs increased under elevated atmospheric CO₂ concentrations, but did not respond to warming following 6 years of treatment. This suggests that the higher ErM colonization under elevated CO₂ might be due to increased transport of carbon belowground to acquire limiting resources such as N, which was diluted in leaves of ericaceous plants under enhanced CO₂. The elevated CO₂ did not affect total plant cover but the plant cover was increased under warming, which might be due to increased N availability in soil. FE colonization in grass roots decreased under enhanced CO₂ and under warming, which might be due to increased root growth, to which the FE fungi could not keep up, resulting in proportionally lower colonization. However, no responses in aboveground cover of Deschampsia flexuosa were seen. DSE hyphal colonization in grass roots significantly increased under warmer conditions, but did not respond to elevated CO₂. This complex set of responses by mycorrhizal and other root‐associated fungi to global change factors of all the fungal types studied could have broad implications for plant community structure and biogeochemistry of subarctic ecosystems.     

The response of mycorrhizal colonization to elevated CO2 and climate change in Pascopyrum smithii and Bouteloua gracilis

Large intact soil cores of nearly pure stands of Pascopyrum smithii (western wheatgrass, C₃) and Bouteloua gracilis (blue grama, C₄) were extracted from the Central Plains Experimental Range in northeastern Colorado, USA and transferred to controlled environment chambers. Cores were exposed to a variety of water, temperature and CO₂ regimes for a total of four annual growth cycles. Root subsamples were harvested after the completion of the second and fourth growth cycles at a time corresponding to late winter, and were examined microscopically for the presence of mycorrhizae. After two growth cycles in the growth chambers, 54% of the root length was colonized in P. smithii, compared to 35% in blue grama. Field control plants had significantly lower colonization. Elevation of CO₂ increased mycorrhizal colonization in B. gracilis by 46% but had no effect in P. smithii. Temperatures 4° C higher than normal decreased colonization in P. smithii by 15%. Increased annual precipitation decreased colonization in both species. Simulated climate change conditions of elevated CO₂, elevated temperature and lowered precipitation decreased colonization in P. smithii but had less effect on B. gracilis. After four growth cycles in P. smithii, trends of treatments remained similar, but overall colonization rate decreased.