Binding of ethidium bromide to fractionated chromatin

The binding of ethidium bromide (EB) to different chromatin preparations was tested. Scatchard plots showed that the slowly sedimenting fraction of sheared chromatin is enriched in dye-binding sites. Limited nuclease digestion of rat liver nuclei, which has been shown to preserve the subunit structure of chromatin, reduces the number of binding sites available for intercalation of the dye.     

Binding of ethidium to the nucleosome core particle. 2. Internal and external binding modes

We have previously reported that the binding of ethidium bromide to the nucleosome core particle results in a stepwise dissociation of the structure which involves the initial release of one copy each of H2A and H2B (McMurray & van Holde, 1986). In this report, we have examined the absorbance and fluorescence properties of intercalated and outside bound forms of ethidium bromide. From these properties, we have measured the extent of external, electrostatic binding of the dye versus internal, intercalation binding to the core particle, free from contribution by linker DNA. We have established that dissociation is induced by the intercalation mode of binding to DNA within the core particle DNA, and not by binding to the histones or by nonintercalative binding to DNA. The covalent binding of [3H]-8-azidoethidium to the core particle clearly shows that less than 1.0 adduct is formed per histone octamer over a wide range of input ratios. Simultaneously, analyses of steady-state fluorescence enhancement and fluorescence lifetime data from bound ethidium complexes demonstrate extensive intercalation binding. Combined analyses from steady-state fluorescence intensity with equilibrium dialysis or fluorescence lifetime data revealed that dissociation began when approximately 14 ethidium molecules are bound by intercalation to each core particle and less than 1.0 nonintercalated ion pair was formed per core particle.     

Monoazido analog of ethidium as a chromatin probe: Binding to DNA

Two photoaffinity analogs of ethidium, 8-azido-3-amino, and 3-azido-8-amino-5-ethyl-6-phenylphenanthridinium chloride, have been used to probe the structure of mammalian chromatin and its interactions with the ethidium moiety. The monoazido analogs were established as suitable probes by comparing their interactions with chromatin and pure DNA prepared from chromatin to those of the parent ethidium bromide. Scatchard analysis of the binding data determined from spectrophotometric titrations showed that the analogs interacted with both nucleic acids in a manner similar to the parent compound. The effect of chromatin proteins on the interaction of the ethidium moiety with intact chromatin was investigated directly. By exposing the noncovalent complex to visible light, the monoazido analog was attached covalently in its interaction sites within chromatin, and the amount of drug bound covalently to DNA was determined for both protein-free DNA and chromatin. Using saturating concentrations of drug, DNA within intact chromatin was found to be associated with only half as much drug as DNA extracted from its protein prior to drug exposure. The distribution of drug bound within chromatin was determined following the attachment of the monoazido analog (by photoactivation) to chromatin that had undergone limited nuclease digestion. Several distinct populations isolated by size fractionation and quantitative measurements revealed that (1) both the core particles and the spacer-containing particles contained bound drug, reflecting high-affinity binding sites; and (2) chromatin particles containing 150 DNA base pairs (putatively nucleosome core structures) contained less total bound drug at high drug concentrations than those particles having intact spacer DNA.     

Interaction of intercalating and non-intercalating agents with DNA: use of hydroxyapatite chromatography and S1 nuclease

We have used hydroxyapatite (HA) chromatography and S1 nuclease hydrolysis to study the modification in the secondary structure of DNA caused by certain intercalating and non-intercalating ligands. The principal conclusions of HA experiments were as follows: (1) when native DNA, complexed with drugs believed to bind to DNA by intercalation (ethidium bromide, acridine orange, actinomycin D and acriflavin), is chromatographed on HA a lower affinity of DNA for HA is observed; also, the DNA elutes from HA columns as a drug-DNA complex; (ii) ligands that are known to interact with DNA by surface interactions do not show these effects; (iii) it may be possible to quantitate the binding of the intercalating drug to DNA and to determine its degree of binding by HA chromatography. Possibly, intercalation causes a change in the configuration of the sugarphosphate backbone of DNA, resulting in an altered steric orientation or 'burial' of phosphate groups with reduced availability for surface interactions with HA. S1 nuclease was used to determine the thermal melting profiles of DNA complexed with ethidium bromide and acridine orange. The melting profile in both cases was found to be biphasic with considerably reduced denaturation even at 95 degrees C. This is accounted for by the property of intercalating agents of stabilizing the secondary structure of DNA and the reported preference in binding to G-C base pairs.     

Ethidium bromide binding to core particle: comparison with native chromatin.

Ethidium bromide intercalation into DNA of nuclease digested erythrocyte chromatin and core particle, was followed at low ionic strength by fluorescence measurements, equilibrium dialysis using 14C labelled dye, circular dichroism and electron microscopy. High affinity binding sites in the chromatin are no more present in the core particle, i.e. when the linker is removed. In the case of core particle, a cooperative process occurs, accompanied by a partial stripping of the DNA from the core histone. Finally two populations of core particles can be detected by electron microscopy as far as their binding properties are concerned.     

A study of the interaction between ethidium bromide and rye chromatin: comparison with calf thymus chromatin.

We studied the interaction of ethidium bromide with rye and calf thymus chromatin. Both types of chromatin have the same dye accessibility, which is about 50% of that of DNA. From this result we conclude that the molecular structure of these two chromatins is similar. For rye, the extraction of H1 produces no change in the binding of ethidium bromide. The subsequent extraction of H2A and H2B produces a 14% increase in the binding, and the removal of H3 and H4, another 54% increase. At this stage, the number of binding sites is still less than that of DNA. This is presumably due to the presence of some tightly bound non-histones. Thus, the arginine-rich histones and the tightly bound non-histones are most responsible for limiting the binding of ethidium bromide to rye chromatin.     

Ethidium bromide (EB) binding to nucleosomal DNA : Effects on DNA cleavage patterns

Binding of ethidium bromide (EB) to chromatin DNA induces structural changes in nucleosomes. The characteristic cleavage patterns of nucleosomal DNA after digestion with either micrococcal nuclease or pancreatic deoxyribonuclease are altered in the presence of the intercalating dye. Instead, apparently random digestion occurs. Polylysine reduces the amount of EB-binding sites in nucleosomal DNA. Since the intercalation of EB is known to proceed from the minor groove of DNA, polylysine supposedly occupies the same site of the nucleosomal DNA moiety.     

Structural transitions of chromatin at low salt concentrations: a flow linear dichroism study

We have studied the structure of nuclease-solubilized chromatin from Ehrlich ascites cells by flow linear dichroism (LD) using the anisotropic absorption of the DNA bases and of two intercalated dyes, ethidium bromide and methylene blue. It is confirmed that intercalation occurs preferentially in the linker part of the chromatin fiber, at binding ratios (dye/base) below 0.020. Using this information, we determined the orientation of the linker in relation to the average DNA organization in chromatin. The LD measurements indicate that the conformation of chromatin is considerably changed in the ionic strength interval 0.1-10 mM NaCl: with increasing salt concentration, the LD of the intrinsic DNA base absorption changes signs, from negative to positive, at approximately 2.5 mM NaCl. The LD of the intercalated dyes also changes signs, however, at a somewhat higher salt concentration. The results are analyzed in terms of possible allowed combinations of tilt angles of nucleosomes and pitch or tilt angles of linker DNA sections relative to the fiber axis, at different salt concentrations in the interval 0.1-10 mM NaCl. Two models for the salt-induced structural change of chromatin are discussed.     

Characterization of monoclonal antibodies to histone 2B. Localization of epitopes and analysis of binding to chromatin

Two mouse monoclonal IgM antibodies have been isolated which bind to histone 2B (H2B), as shown by protein blotting and immunostaining and by solid-phase radioimmunoassay (RIA). One of these (HBC-7) was specific for H2B by both techniques whereas the other (2F8) cross-reacted with histone H1 by RIA. Both antibodies failed to recognize H2B limit peptides from trypsin-digested chromatin and did not bind to Drosophila H2B, which differs extensively from vertebrate H2B only in the N-terminal region. These findings indicate that both antibodies recognize epitopes within the trypsin-sensitive, N-terminal region comprising residues 1-20. Binding of antibody HBC-7 was inhibited by in vitro ADP-ribosylation of H2B at glutamic acid residue 2. This strongly suggests that the epitope recognized by HBC-7 is located at the N-terminus of H2B, probably between residues 1 and 8. We have used solid-phase radioimmunoassay to investigate factors which influence the accessibility of this epitope in chromatin. Removal of H1 ('stripping') from high-molecular-mass chromatin had no effect on HBC-7 binding, nor was any difference observed between binding to stripped chromatin and to 146-base-pair (bp) core particles derived from it by nuclease digestion. These results suggest that accessibility of the N-terminal region of H2B is not influenced by H1 itself or by the size or conformation of linker DNA. In contrast, binding of antibody HBC-7 to 146-bp core particles derived from unstripped chromatin was reduced by up to 70%. Binding was restored by exposure of these core particles to the conditions used for stripping. Analysis of the protein content of core particle preparations from stripped and unstripped chromatin suggests that these findings may be attributable to redistribution of non-histone proteins during nuclease digestion. Pre-treatment of high-molecular-mass chromatin or 146-bp core particles with the intercalating dye ethidium bromide resulted in a severalfold increase in binding of HBC-7. The major changes in nucleosome morphology induced by ethidium are therefore accompanied by an increase in accessibility of the N-terminal region of H2B, possibly as a direct result of changes in the spatial relationship between H2B and core DNA.     

Binding of ethidium to the nucleosome core particle. 1. Binding and dissociation reactions

We have examined binding properties of and dissociation induced by the intercalating dye ethidium bromide when it interacts with the nucleosome core particle under low ionic strength conditions. Ethidium binding to the core particle results in a reversible dissociation which requires the critical binding of 14 ethidium molecules. Under low ionic strength conditions, dissociation is about 90% completed in 5 h. The observed ethidium binding isotherm was corrected for the presence of free DNA due to particle dissociation. The corrected curve reveals that the binding of ethidium to the core particle itself is a highly cooperative process characterized by a low intrinsic binding constant of KA = 2.4 X 10(4) M-1 and a cooperativity parameter of omega = approximately 140. The number of base pairs excluded to another dye molecule by each bound dye molecule (n) is 4.5. Through the use of a chemical probe, methidiumpropyl-EDTA (MPE), we have localized the initial binding sites of ethidium in the core particle to consist of an average of 27 +/- 4 bp of DNA that are distributed near both ends of the DNA termini. MPE footprint analysis has also revealed that, prior to dissociation, the fractional population of core particles which bind the dye (f) may be as low as 50%. Comparison of the binding and dissociation data showed that the cooperative maximum of the binding curve occurred at or near the critical value, i.e., at the point where dissociation began. The data were used to generate a detailed model for the association of ethidium with chromatin at the level of the nucleosome.     

Properties of activated chromatin from rat liver shortly after partial hepatectomy

The properties of rat liver chromatin 1, 2 and 6 hours after partial hepatectomy have been studied by means of cytochemical and biochemical methods. An increase in the accessibility of DNA to low molecular weight ligands, RNA--polymerase and RNAse I and also of the distances between nucleosomes and their heterogeneity in length on electron -- microscopic photographs has been found. Analysis of the isotherms of adsorption has revealed an increase in the number of binding sites for ethidium bromide on DNA and accordingly a decrease in the extent of the filling of the template with protein in activated chromatin. Two hours after partial hepatectomy rat liver chromatin does not differ in all parameters studied from control chromatin. Limited digestion of chromatin with DNAse I almost fully eliminates the difference between the fractions of activated and control chromatin in the number of binding sites for the ligands to the fractions resistent in these conditions to nuclease. A suggestion that the changes in the properties of chromatin upon activation are due to the change in the character of chromatin proteins interaction with DNA are discussed.     

cis-diamminedichloroplatinum (II) modified chromatin and nucleosomal core particle

The influence of cis-diamminedichloroplatinum (II) (cis-DDP) binding to chromatin in chicken erythrocyte nuclei and the nucleosomal core particle is investigated. The cis-DDP modifications alter DNA-protein interactions associated with the higher order structure of chromatin to significantly inhibit the rate of micrococcal nuclease digestion and alter the digestion profile. However, cis-DDP modification of core particle has little effect on the digestion rate and the relative distribution of DNA fragments produced by microccocal nuclease digestion. Analysis of the monomer DNA fragments derived from the digestion of modified nuclei suggests that cis-DDP binding does not significantly disrupt the DNA structure within the core particle, with its major influence being on the internucleosomal DNA. Together these findings suggest that cis-DDP may preferentially bind to the internucleosomal region and/or that the formation of the intrastrand cross-link involving adjacent guanines exhibits a preference for the linker region. Sucrose gradient profiles of the modified nucleoprotein complexes further confirm that the digestion profile for micrococcal nuclease is altered by cis-DDP binding and that the greatest changes occur at the initial stages of digestion. The covalent cross-links within bulk chromatin fix a sub-population of subnucleosomal and nucleosomal products, which are released only after reversal by NaCN treatment. Coupled with our previous findings, it appears that this cis-DDP mediated cross-linking network is primarily associated with protein-protein crosslinks of the low mobility group (LMG) proteins.     

Structure of the complex between lac repressor headpiece and operator DNA from measurements of the orientation relaxation and the electric dichroism.

The complex between lac repressor headpiece and short rodlike DNA fragments containing the lac operator sequence is characterised by measurements of the rotation diffusion. Using the method of electric dichroism we measure the rotation relaxation and determine changes in the length of the DNA upon ligand binding with high accuracy. According to these measurements any change in the length of the operator DNA upon binding of the first two headpiece molecules remains below 1A; the electric dichroism also remains virtually unchanged. At high degrees of (unspecific) binding we observe an increase in the rotation relaxation time, which is attributed to an increase of the apparent mean radius of the complex. As a control of our procedure for the determination of length changes we use the intercalation of ethidium bromide and arrive at an increase of the DNA length per bound ethidium of 3.2A (at 3.4A rise per base pair). The results obtained for the headpiece operator complex are not consistent with models assuming large changes of the DNA structure or intercalation of tyrosine residues.     

Localization of linker histone in chromatosomes by cryo-atomic force microscopy

Linker histones play a fundamental role in determining higher order chromatin structure as a consequence of their association with nucelosomal DNA. Yet the locations and structural consequences of linker histone binding are still enigmatic. Here, using cryo-atomic force microscopy, we show that the linker histone H5 in native chromatin and in chromatosomes reconstituted on the 5S rDNA template is located at the dyad of the nucleosome core particle, within the "stem" structure. Direct measurement also indicates that the length of free linker DNA between chromatosomes in native chromatin is approximately 30 bp, slightly shorter than that estimated from nuclease digestion assays.     

Anticooperative Binding Governs the Mechanics of Ethidium-Complexed DNA

DNA intercalators bind nucleic acids by stacking between adjacent basepairs. This causes a considerable elongation of the DNA backbone as well as untwisting of the double helix. In the past few years, single-molecule mechanical experiments have become a common tool to characterize these deformations and to quantify important parameters of the intercalation process. Parameter extraction typically relies on the neighbor-exclusion model, in which a bound intercalator prevents intercalation into adjacent sites. Here, we challenge the neighbor-exclusion model by carefully quantifying and modeling the force-extension and twisting behavior of single ethidium-complexed DNA molecules. We show that only an anticooperative ethidium binding that allows for a disfavored but nonetheless possible intercalation into nearest-neighbor sites can consistently describe the mechanical behavior of intercalator-bound DNA. At high ethidium concentrations and elevated mechanical stress, this causes an almost complete occupation of nearest-neighbor sites and almost a doubling of the DNA contour length. We furthermore show that intercalation into nearest-neighbor sites needs to be considered when estimating intercalator parameters from zero-stress elongation and twisting data. We think that the proposed anticooperative binding mechanism may also be applicable to other intercalating molecules.     

Generation of a third-order folded structure for chromatin

A model for the initiation of the diffuse-condensed transition of chromatin induced by a change in the conformation of lysine-rich histones is proposed. Three levels of folded structures are discussed. The first-order folded structure refers to the structure of the repeat unit of chromatin, which is called the nucleosome. The nucleosome contains a nuclease resistant region in which 140 base pairs of DNA are wrapped around the surface of a histone aggregated of two copies each of the histones H2A, H2B, H3 and H4. This DNA-histone aggregate is called a core particle. The nuclease accessible region of the nucleosome is approximately 60 base pairs of DNA which link the core particle, hence the terminology “linker DNA.” The lysine-rich histones, (Hl, H5), which are more loosely bound than the core histones, are associated with the linker DNA. The second-order folded structure refers to the conformation of a polynucleosome. Based on neutron scattering and quasielastic light scattering studies the second-order folded structure is assumed to be an extended helix in solution with 5–7 nucleosome units per turn. The third-order folded structure is defined as that structure resulting from the first stage in the condensation process induced by a conformational change in the lysine-rich histones. Generation of the third-order folded structure in the proposed model is effected by an increased affinity of the lysine-rich histones for super-helical DNA in the core particles in adjacent turns of the second-order folded structure. Since the lysine-rich histones preferentially bind to A-T rich regions in DNA, the distribution of these regions would determine the third-order folded structure. The net effect of a non-random distribution of A-T rich regions as in the proposed model is the generation of a helix for the third-order folded structure. The assumption of a non-random distribution of A-T rich regions is indirectly supported by proflavine binding studies reported herein and by the existence of repetitive and non-repetitive DNA regions inferred from renaturation studies. One consequence of the proposed mechanism is that the majority of the A-T rich regions are in the interior of the third-order folded structure. Promoter sites of high A-T content would then be inaccessible to polymerases. The proposed model also suggests a role for spacer DNA in the genome. Higher order folded structures must also be present in the final state of condensed chromatin since the three orders of folded structures considered in this communication accounts for only 2% of that required in the diffuse-condensed transition.     

Effect of mutation of the Sac7d intercalating residues on the temperature dependence of DNA distortion and binding thermodynamics

Sac7d is a small chromatin protein from the hyperthermophile Sulfolobus acidocaldarius which kinks duplex DNA by approximately 66 degrees at a single base pair step with intercalation of V26 and M29 side chains. Site-directed mutagenesis coupled with calorimetric and spectroscopic data has been used to characterize the influence of the intercalating side chains on the structure and thermodynamics of the DNA complex from 5 to 85 degrees C. Two single-alanine substitutions (V26A and M29A) and five double-glycine, -alanine, -leucine, -phenylalanine, and -tryptophan substitutions of the surface residues have been created. NMR and fluorescence titrations indicated that the substitutions had little effect on the structure of the protein or DNA binding site size. Each of the mutant proteins demonstrated a temperature-dependent binding enthalpy which was correlated with a similar temperature dependence in the structure of the complex reflected by changes in fluorescence and circular dichroism. A positive heat capacity change (DeltaC(p)) for DNA binding was observed for only those mutants which also demonstrated a thermotropic structural transition in the complex, and the temperature range for the positive DeltaC(p) coincided with that observed for the structural transition. The thermodynamic data are interpreted using a model in which binding is linked to an endothermic distortion of the DNA in the complex. The results support the proposal that the unfavorable enthalpy of binding of Sac7d at 25 degrees C is due in part to the distortion of DNA.     

Torsional sensing of small-molecule binding using magnetic tweezers

DNA-binding small molecules are widespread in the cell and heavily used in biological applications. Here, we use magnetic tweezers, which control the force and torque applied to single DNAs, to study three small molecules: ethidium bromide (EtBr), a well-known intercalator; netropsin, a minor-groove binding anti-microbial drug; and topotecan, a clinically used anti-tumor drug. In the low-force limit in which biologically relevant torques can be accessed (<10 pN), we show that ethidium intercalation lengthens DNA ∼1.5-fold and decreases the persistence length, from which we extract binding constants. Using our control of supercoiling, we measure the decrease in DNA twist per intercalation to be 27.3 ± 1° and demonstrate that ethidium binding delays the accumulation of torsional stress in DNA, likely via direct reduction of the torsional modulus and torque-dependent binding. Furthermore, we observe that EtBr stabilizes the DNA duplex in regimes where bare DNA undergoes structural transitions. In contrast, minor groove binding by netropsin affects neither the contour nor persistence length significantly, yet increases the twist per base of DNA. Finally, we show that topotecan binding has consequences similar to those of EtBr, providing evidence for an intercalative binding mode. These insights into the torsional consequences of ligand binding can help elucidate the effects of small-molecule drugs in the cellular environment.     

Chromatin organization in Paracentrotus lividus eggs

After purification by buoyant density centrifugation in ethidium bromide - CsCl gradient and electrophoretic fractionation, the DNA fragments isolated from P. lividus egg nuclei incubated with micrococcal nuclease exhibit a typical oligomeric pattern. Analysis of chromatin samples digested to an increasing extent by micrococcal nuclease reveals that the structural organization of egg chromatin is heterogeneous, both in terms of repeat size and degree of sensitivity to nuclease attack. The nucleosomal repeats of P. lividus sperms and embryos up to the mesenchyme blastula stage have also been determined, for comparison.