Intrachanges as part of complex chromosome-type exchange aberrations

The chromosome-type exchange aberrations induced by ionizing radiation during the G(0)/G(1) phase of the cell cycle are believed to be the result of illegitimate rejoining of chromosome breaks. From numerous studies using chromosome painting, it has emerged that even after a moderate dose of radiation, a substantial fraction of these exchanges is complex. Most of them are derived from the free interaction between the ends of three or more breaks. Other studies have demonstrated that chromosomes occupy distinct territories in the interphase nucleus. Since breaks that are in close proximity have an enhanced interaction probability, it seems likely that after ionizing radiation many of the interacting breaks will be present within one chromosome or chromosome arm. Unfortunately, the majority of these intrachanges remain undetected, even when sophisticated molecular cytogenetic detection methods (i.e. mFISH) are applied to paint all chromosome pairs in distinct colors. In the present paper, we evaluate the limitations of full-color painting for the detection of complex exchanges and the correct interpretations of break interactions.     

Equal induction and persistence of chromosome aberrations involving chromosomes 1, 4 and 10 in thyroid cancer patients treated with radioactive iodine

A number of in vitro studies have questioned the assumption of random distribution of breaks in radiation-induced chromosome aberrations. The therapeutic application of radioactive 131I in thyroid cancer patients offers a good opportunity to study the induction and persistence of cytogenetic damage involving different chromosomes in vivo. Using whole-chromosome painting probes and triple colour painting by fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH), we have analysed the frequency of chromosomal aberrations (CAs) involving chromosomes 1, 4 and 10 in peripheral blood lymphocytes of 10 thyroid cancer patients sampled before and 1 week, 1 year and 3.5 years after therapeutic application of radioactive iodine in a self-controlled, longitudinal study. A highly significant 3.4-fold increase in the frequency of chromosome breaks was observed 1 week after treatment with a similar representation of all chromosomes analysed. Although a significant decrease in dicentrics was observed during the first year after treatment, the frequency of chromosome aberrations remained over control levels until the last sampling time, 41-47 months post-treatment. The same behaviour, in terms of induction and persistence, was observed for all three chromosomes, confirming our previous results in vitro and rejecting the reported suggestion that chromosome 10 is radiosensitive in vivo. Our finding that the dynamics of radiation-induced CA in vivo is independent on the chromosome of choice suggests that this variable is not important in retrospective studies.     

Truly incomplete and complex exchanges in prematurely condensed chromosomes of human fibroblasts exposed in vitro to energetic heavy ions

Confluent human fibroblast cells (AG1522) were irradiated with gamma rays, 490 MeV/nucleon silicon ions, or iron ions at either 200 or 500 MeV/nucleon. The cells were allowed to repair at 37 degrees C for 24 h after exposure, and a chemically induced premature chromosome condensation (PCC) technique was used to condense chromosomes in the G2 phase of the cell cycle. Incomplete and complex exchanges were analyzed in the irradiated samples. To verify that chromosomal breaks were truly unrejoined, chromosome aberrations were analyzed using a combination of whole-chromosome specific probes and probes specific for the telomere region of the chromosome. Results showed that the frequency of unrejoined chromosome breaks was higher after irradiation with the heavy ions of high LET, and consequently the ratio of incomplete to complete exchanges increased steadily with LET up to 440 keV/microm, the highest LET included in the present study. For samples exposed to 200 MeV/nucleon iron ions, chromosome aberrations were analyzed using the multicolor FISH (mFISH) technique, which allows identification of both complex and truly incomplete exchanges. Results of the mFISH study showed that 0.7 and 3 Gy iron ions produced similar ratios of complex to simple exchanges and incomplete to complete exchanges; these ratios were higher than those obtained after exposure to 6 Gy gamma rays. After 0.7 Gy of iron ions, most complex aberrations were found to involve three or four chromosomes, which is a likely indication of the maximum number of chromosome domains traversed by a single iron-ion track.     

DNA damage processing and aberration formation in plants

Various types of DNA damage, induced by endo- and exogenous genotoxic impacts, may become processed into structural chromosome changes such as sister chromatid exchanges (SCEs) and chromosomal aberrations. Chromosomal aberrations occur preferentially within heterochromatic regions composed mainly of repetitive sequences. Most of the preclastogenic damage is correctly repaired by different repair mechanisms. For instance, after N-methyl-N-nitrosourea treatment one SCE is formed per >40,000 and one chromatid-type aberration per approximately 25 million primarily induced O6-methylguanine residues in Vicia faba. Double-strand breaks (DSBs) apparently represent the critical lesions for the generation of chromosome structural changes by erroneous reciprocal recombination repair. Usually two DSBs have to interact in cis or trans to form a chromosomal aberration. Indirect evidence is at hand for plants indicating that chromatid-type aberrations mediated by S phase-dependent mutagens are generated by post-replication (mis)repair of DSBs resulting from (rare) interference of repair and replication processes at the sites of lesions, mainly within repetitive sequences of heterochromatic regions. The proportion of DSBs yielding structural changes via misrepair has still to be established when DSBs, induced at predetermined positions, can be quantified and related to the number of SCEs and chromosomal aberrations that appear at these loci after DSB induction. Recording the degree of association of homologous chromosome territories (by chromosome painting) and of punctual homologous pairing frequency along these territories during and after mutagen treatment of wild-type versus hyperrecombination mutants of Arabidopsis thaliana, it will be elucidated as to what extent the interphase arrangement of chromosome territories becomes modified by critical lesions and contributes to homologous reciprocal recombination. This paper reviews the state of the art with respect to DNA damage processing in the course of aberration formation and the interphase arrangement of homologous chromosome territories as a structural prerequisite for homologous rearrangements in plants.     

Influence of dose rate on the induction of simple and complex chromosome exchanges by gamma rays

Single-color painting of whole chromosomes, or protocols in which only a few chromosomes are distinctively painted, will always fail to detect a proportion of complex exchanges because they frequently produce pseudosimple painting patterns that are indistinguishable from those produced by bona fide simple exchanges. When 24-color multi-fluor FISH (mFISH) was employed for the purpose of distinguishing (truly) simple from pseudosimple exchanges, it was confirmed that the acute low-LET radiation dose-response relationship for simple exchanges lacked significant upward curvature. This result has been interpreted to indicate that the formation of simple exchanges requires only one chromosome locus be damaged (e.g. broken) by radiation to initiate an exchange-not two, as classical cytogenetic theory maintains. Because a one-lesion mechanism implies single-track action, it follows that the production of simple exchanges should not be influenced by changes in dose rate. To examine this prediction, we irradiated noncycling primary human fibroblasts with graded doses of (137)Cs gamma rays at an acute dose rate of 1.10 Gy/min and compared, using mFISH, the yield of simple exchanges to that observed after exposure to the same radiation delivered at a chronic dose rate of 0.08 cGy/min. The shape of the dose response was found to be quasi-linear for both dose rates, but, counter to providing support for a one-lesion mechanism, the yield of simple aberrations was greatly reduced by protracted exposure. Although chronic doses were delivered at rates low enough to produce damage exclusively by single-track action, this did not altogether eliminate the formation of complex aberrations, an analysis of which leads to the conclusion that a single track of low-LET radiation is capable of inducing complex exchanges requiring up to four proximate breaks for their formation. For acute exposures, the ratio of simple reciprocal translocations to simple dicentrics was near unity.     

Mouse chromosome-specific painting probes generated from microdissected chromosomes

Using degenerate primer amplification of chromosomes microdissected from banded cytogenetic preparations, we constructed both whole chromosome painting probes for mouse Chromosomes (Chrs) 1, 2, 3, and 11 and a centromere probe that strongly paints most mouse centromeres. We also amplified a Robertsonian translocation chromosome microdissected from unstained preparations to construct a painting probe for Chrs 9 and 19. The chromosomes probes uniformly painted the respective chromosomes of origin. We demonstrated the utility of the Chr 11 probe in aberration analysis by staining mutants that we had previously identified as containing a Chr 11 translocation, and in some mutant cell lines we observed chromosome rearrangements not previously detected in stained cytogenetic preparations. The technology of microdissection and amplification applies to all mouse chromosomes or to specific subchromosomal regions and will be useful in mouse genetics, in aberration analysis, and for chromosome identification.     

Computational model of chromosome aberration yield induced by high- and low-LET radiation exposures

We present a computational model for calculating the yield of radiation-induced chromosomal aberrations in human cells based on a stochastic Monte Carlo approach and calibrated using the relative frequencies and distributions of chromosomal aberrations reported in the literature. A previously developed DNA-fragmentation model for high- and low-LET radiation called the NASARadiationTrackImage model was enhanced to simulate a stochastic process of the formation of chromosomal aberrations from DNA fragments. The current version of the model gives predictions of the yields and sizes of translocations, dicentrics, rings, and more complex-type aberrations formed in the G(0)/G(1) cell cycle phase during the first cell division after irradiation. As the model can predict smaller-sized deletions and rings (<3 Mbp) that are below the resolution limits of current cytogenetic analysis techniques, we present predictions of hypothesized small deletions that may be produced as a byproduct of properly repaired DNA double-strand breaks (DSB) by nonhomologous end-joining. Additionally, the model was used to scale chromosomal exchanges in two or three chromosomes that were obtained from whole-chromosome FISH painting analysis techniques to whole-genome equivalent values.     

PCR in situ followed by microdissection allows whole chromosome painting probes to be made from single microdissected chromosomes

Whole-chromosome painting probes (WCPs) and chromosome-arm painting probes (CAPs) are an integral part of the cytogenetic analysis of chromosome abnormalities. While these are routinely made by chromosome microdissection, multiple copies of the dissected region have been necessary to achieve a library sufficiently complex to provide adequate painting. Performing multiple dissections of chromosomes or chromosome regions is time consuming and occasionally impossible, such as when working with species whose banded karyotype is not well defined. We have developed a method whereby chromosome paints can be reliably generated by dissecting single chromosomes. The technique consists of performing degenerate oligonucleotide-primed polymerase chain reaction (DOP-PCR) in situ on the chromosomes, prior to dissection. Enough amplification occurs to enable a single dissected chromosome to be used to create a painting probe sufficiently complex for use in fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH). The amplification products remain localized on the chromosomes; this allows region-specific chromosome paints to be made. We detail this novel technique and show whole-chromosome, arm-specific, and contiguous region-specific probes for human and rat, each created from single dissected fragments of chromatin. Received: 14 January 1999 / Accepted: 28 January 1999     

Further observations on the nature of radiation-induced chromosomal interchanges recovered from Drosophila sperm

The induction and analysis of numerous translocations (identified genetically and characterized cytologically) between chromosomes 2 and 3 of Drosophila melanogaster have allowed us to reexamine three issues concerning the nature of radiation-induced interchanges in spermatozoa. First, our results support the idea that, relative to their mitotic metaphase length, all major chromosomal regions are similar in their breakability, whether euchromatic (proximal or distal) or heterochromatic. Second, analysis of all our reciprocal exchanges between the two chromosomes shows a statistically significant dependence of the position of the chromosome 2 breakpoint on that of the chromosome 3 breakpoint. Thirdly, our combined cytological and genetic approach strengthens the results of previous analyses, which suggested a strong tendency for chromosomal interchanges to be of the reciprocal type in multiple-break rearrangements. This indicates that if radiation induces chromosome breaks, then the resulting broken ends tend to rejoin in pairs rather than independently.     

Chromosomes are predominantly located randomly with respect to each other in interphase human cells

To test quantitatively whether there are systematic chromosome-chromosome associations within human interphase nuclei, interchanges between all possible heterologous pairs of chromosomes were measured with 24-color whole-chromosome painting (multiplex FISH), after damage to interphase lymphocytes by sparsely ionizing radiation in vitro. An excess of interchanges for a specific chromosome pair would indicate spatial proximity between the chromosomes comprising that pair. The experimental design was such that quite small deviations from randomness (extra pairwise interchanges within a group of chromosomes) would be detectable. The only statistically significant chromosome cluster was a group of five chromosomes previously observed to be preferentially located near the center of the nucleus. However, quantitatively, the overall deviation from randomness within the whole genome was small. Thus, whereas some chromosome-chromosome associations are clearly present, at the whole-chromosomal level, the predominant overall pattern appears to be spatially random.     

Reflections and meditations upon complex chromosomal exchanges

The application of FISH chromosome painting techniques, especially the recent mFISH (and its equivalents) where all 23 human chromosome pairs can be distinguished, has demonstrated that many chromosome-type structural exchanges are much more complicated (involving more "break-rejoins" and arms) than has hitherto been assumed. It is clear that we have been greatly under-estimating the damage produced in chromatin by such agents as ionising radiation. This article gives a brief historical summary of observations leading up to this conclusion, and after outlining some of the problems surrounding the formation of complex chromosomes exchanges, speculates about possible solutions currently being proposed.     

Complex chromosome exchanges induced by gamma rays in human lymphocytes: an mFISH study

Loucas, B. D. and Cornforth, M. N. Complex Chromosome Exchanges Induced by Gamma Rays in Human Lymphocytes: An mFISH Study. Radiat. Res. 155, 660-671 (2001). Combinatorial multi-fluor fluorescence in situ hybridization (mFISH) allows the simultaneous painting of each pair of homologous chromosomes, thereby eliminating many of the difficulties previously associated with the analysis of complex rearrangements. We employed mFISH to visualize exchanges in human lymphocytes and found significant frequencies of these aberrations after gamma-ray doses of 2 and 4 Gy. At 4 Gy, roughly half of the cells contained at least one complex exchange that required anywhere from 3 to 11 initial chromosome breaks. At this dose, more than 40% of gross cytogenetic damage, as measured by the total number of exchange breakpoints, was complex in origin. Both simple and complex exchanges were found to have nonlinear dose responses, although the latter showed significantly more upward curvature. In many cases, it could be deduced that the initial breaks leading to a particular complex exchange were proximate, meaning that the resulting broken chromosome ends all must have been capable of interacting freely during the exchange process. For other complex exchanges, the rearrangement could just as well have resulted from two or more simpler exchanges that occurred sequentially. The results demonstrate the utility of mFISH in visualizing intricacies of the exchange process, but also highlight the various sources of ambiguity concerning cytogenetic analysis that remain despite the power of this approach.     

Modulation of restriction enzyme-induced damage by chemicals that interfere with cellular responses to DNA damage: a cytogenetic and pulsed-field gel analysis

The electroporation of restriction enzymes into mammalian cells results in DNA double-strand breaks that can lead to chromosome aberrations. Four chemicals known to interfere with cellular responses to DNA damage were investigated for their effects on chromosome aberrations induced by AluI and Sau3AI; in addition, the number of DNA double-strand breaks at various times after enzyme treatment was determined by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE). The poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase inhibitor 3-aminobenzamide (3AB) dramatically increased the yield of exchanges and deletions and caused a small but transitory increase in the yield of double-strand breaks induced by the enzymes. 1-beta-D-Arabinofuranosylcytosine, which can inhibit DNA repair either by direct action on DNA polymerases alpha and delta or by incorporation into DNA, potentiated aberration induction but to a lesser extent than 3AB and did not affect the amount of DNA double-strand breakage. Aphidicolin, which inhibits polymerases alpha and delta, had no effect on AluI-induced aberrations but did increase the aberration yield induced by Sau3AI. The postreplication repair inhibitor caffeine had no effect on aberration yields induced by either enzyme. Neither aphidicolin nor caffeine modulated the amount of DNA double-strand breakage as measured by PFGE. These data implicate poly(ADP-ribosyl)ation and polymerases alpha and delta as important components of the cellular processes required for the normal repair of DNA double-strand breaks with blunt or cohesive ends. Comparison of these data with the effect of inhibitors on the frequency of X-ray-induced aberrations leads us to the conclusion that X-ray-induced aberrations can result from the misjoining or nonrejoining of double-strand breaks, particularly breaks with cohesive ends, but that this process accounts for only a portion of the induced aberrations.     

Comparing DNA damage-processing pathways by computer analysis of chromosome painting data.

Chromosome aberrations are large-scale illegitimate rearrangements of the genome. They are indicative of DNA damage and informative about damage processing pathways. Despite extensive investigations over many years, the mechanisms underlying aberration formation remain controversial. New experimental assays such as multiplex fluorescent in situ hybridyzation (mFISH) allow combinatorial "painting" of chromosomes and are promising for elucidating aberration formation mechanisms. Recently observed mFISH aberration patterns are so complex that computer and graph-theoretical methods are needed for their full analysis. An important part of the analysis is decomposing a chromosome rearrangement process into "cycles." A cycle of order n, characterized formally by the cyclic graph with 2n vertices, indicates that n chromatin breaks take part in a single irreducible reaction. We here describe algorithms for computing cycle structures from experimentally observed or computer-simulated mFISH aberration patterns. We show that analyzing cycles quantitatively can distinguish between different aberration formation mechanisms. In particular, we show that homology-based mechanisms do not generate the large number of complex aberrations, involving higher-order cycles, observed in irradiated human lymphocytes.     

Association of inter- and intrachromosomal exchanges with the distribution of low- and high-LET radiation-induced breaks in chromosomes

To study the effects of low- and high-linear energy transfer (LET) radiation on break locations within a chromosome, we exposed human epithelial cells in vitro to (137)Cs γ rays at both low and high dose rates, secondary neutrons at a low dose rate, and 600 MeV/u iron ions at a high dose rate. Breakpoints were identified using multicolor banding in situ hybridization (mBAND), which paints chromosome 3 in 23 different colored bands. For all four radiation scenarios, breakpoint distributions were found to be different from the predicted distribution based on band width. Detailed analysis of chromosome fragment ends involved in inter- or intrachromosomal exchanges revealed that the distributions of fragment ends participating in interchromosomal exchanges were similar between the two low-LET radiation dose rates and between the two high-LET radiation types, but the distributions were less similar between low- and high-LET radiations. For fragment ends participating in intrachromosomal exchanges, the distributions for all four radiation scenarios were similar, with clusters of breaks found in three regions. Analysis of the locations of the two fragment ends in chromosome 3 that joined to form an intrachromosomal exchange demonstrated that two breaks with a greater genomic separation can be more likely to rejoin than two closer breaks, indicating that chromatin folding can play an important role in the rejoining of chromosome breaks. Comparison of the breakpoint distributions to the distributions of genes indicated that the gene-rich regions do not necessarily contain more breaks. In general, breakpoint distributions depend on whether a chromosome fragment joins with another fragment in the same chromosome or with a fragment from a different chromosome.     

Molecular targets and mechanisms in formation of chromosomal aberrations: contributions of Soviet scientists

Studies of mechanisms for formation of chromosomal aberrations (CAs) with special emphasis on data from Soviet/Russian investigations are reviewed that argue in favor of a minor fraction of genomic DNA that forms specific molecular targets/contacts for the formation of chromosomal exchanges. This DNA is presumably associated with matrix attachment sites of DNA loops, enriched with AT base pairs and repetitive DNA sequences. It is assumed that there are two main mechanisms in formation of chromosome aberrations: 1) mutually reciprocal recombination, resulting in formation of all kinds of chromosome exchanges; 2) the process of telomere formation, resulting in the generation of true deletions. A significant part of chromosomal breaks and apparently unrejoined ends in incomplete exchanges as seen with cytogenetic techniques reflect decondensation in the discrete units of chromatin organization such as the megabase-size DNA domains. The possible ways for further analysis of alternative theories with emerging technologies are also discussed.     

Types and frequencies of chromosomal aberrations induced by irradiation of different parts of interphase in Crepis capillaris

Quantitative and qualitative estimates of chromosomal damage in roots of Crepis capillaris were made in metaphase cells at many time intervals after irradiation with 200 or 400 rad of ⁶⁰Co gamma-rays. The results have confirmed the general pattern described for cells of other organisms, and have revealed in addition the following new facts. (1) The formation of aberrations of chromosome and chromatid type is not determined by the time of chromosome duplication alone. (2) The relative frequencies of different types of discontinuity form peaks with the following time succession: single gaps, chromatid breaks, isolocus breaks. (3) The location of peaks does not depend on the radiation dose, and shows no correlation which the time of synthesis. (4) Irradiation of G₂ induces a significant number of chromosome-type exchanges in Crepis. (5) Higher doses of radiation in G₂ favour the formation of chromatid over chromosome exchanges and of isochromatid breaks over chromosome breaks. A new interpretation of the production of certain types of aberration is discussed.     

Effect of linear energy transfer (LET) on the complexity of alpha-particle-induced chromosome aberrations in human CD34+ cells

The aim of this study was to assess the relative influence of the linear energy transfer (LET) of alpha particles on the complexity of chromosome aberrations in the absence of significant other differences in track structure. To do this, we irradiated human hemopoietic stem cells (CD34+) with alpha particles of various incident LETs (110-152 keV/microm, with mean LETs through the cell of 119-182 keV/microm) at an equi-fluence of approximately one particle/cell and assayed for chromosome aberrations by mFISH. Based on a single harvest time to collect early-division mitotic cells, complex aberrations were observed at comparable frequencies irrespective of incident LET; however, when expressed as a proportion of the total exchanges detected, their occurrence was seen to increase with increasing LET. Cycle analysis to predict theoretical DNA double-strand break rejoining cycles was also carried out on all complex chromosome aberrations detected. By doing this we found that the majority of complex aberrations are formed in single non-reducible cycles that involve just two or three different chromosomes and three or four different breaks. Each non-reducible cycle is suggested to represent "an area" of finite size within the nucleus where double-strand break repair occurs. We suggest that the local density of damage induced and the proximity of independent repair areas within the interphase nucleus determine the complexity of aberrations resolved in metaphase. Overall, the most likely outcome of a single nuclear traversal of a single alpha particle in CD34+ cells is a single chromosome aberration per damaged cell. As the incident LET of the alpha particle increases, the likelihood of this aberration being classed as complex is greater.     

cis-diamminedichloroplatinum(II)-induced sister-chromatid exchanges and chromosome aberration formation in cultured human lymphocytes and their inhibition by sodium thiosulfate

cis-Diamminedichloroplatinum(II) (cis-DDP)-induced sister-chromatid exchanges (SCEs) and chromosome aberration formation were studied in human lymphocytes. The mitotic index decreased abruptly at 2 X 10(-6) M cis-DDP and the frequency of SCEs was dose-related; a marked increase was recorded at 10(-6) M cis-DDP. A dose-dependent effect was also found for chromosome aberration formation at concentrations between 10(-11) and 4 X 10(-6) M. The aberrations observed were primarily chromatid breaks and gaps. We also examined the inhibition of these genotoxicities by treating the cells with sodium thiosulfate (STS). Simultaneous treatment with 10(-4)-10(-3) M STS (100-1000-fold molar ratio to cis-DDP) significantly reduced the frequency of SCEs induced by 10(-6) M cis-DDP. Furthermore, a 3-h delay in treating with STS significantly reduced cis-DDP-induced SCEs, but not chromosome aberration formation.