Heterogeneity of Equilibrium Molten Globule State of Cytochrome c Induced by Weak Salt Denaturants under Physiological Condition

While many proteins are recognized to undergo folding via intermediate(s), the heterogeneity of equilibrium folding intermediate(s) along the folding pathway is less understood. In our present study, FTIR spectroscopy, far- and near-UV circular dichroism (CD), ANS and tryptophan fluorescence, near IR absorbance spectroscopy and dynamic light scattering (DLS) were used to study the structural and thermodynamic characteristics of the native (N), denatured (D) and intermediate state (X) of goat cytochorme c (cyt-c) induced by weak salt denaturants (LiBr, LiCl and LiClO₄) at pH 6.0 and 25°C. The LiBr-induced denaturation of cyt-c measured by Soret absorption (Δε ₄₀₀) and CD ([θ]₄₀₉), is a three-step process, N ↔ X ↔ D. It is observed that the X state obtained along the denaturation pathway of cyt-c possesses common structural and thermodynamic characteristics of the molten globule (MG) state. The MG state of cyt-c induced by LiBr is compared for its structural and thermodynamic parameters with those found in other solvent conditions such as LiCl, LiClO₄ and acidic pH. Our observations suggest: (1) that the LiBr-induced MG state of cyt-c retains the native Met80-Fe(III) axial bond and Trp59-propionate interactions; (2) that LiBr-induced MG state of cyt-c is more compact retaining the hydrophobic interactions in comparison to the MG states induced by LiCl, LiClO₄ and 0.5 M NaCl at pH 2.0; and (3) that there exists heterogeneity of equilibrium intermediates along the unfolding pathway of cyt-c as highly ordered (X1), classical (X2) and disordered (X3), i.e., D ↔ X3 ↔ X2 ↔ X1 ↔ N.     

Structural Changes and Proapoptotic Peroxidase Activity of Cardiolipin-Bound Mitochondrial Cytochrome c

The cellular process of intrinsic apoptosis relies on the peroxidation of mitochondrial lipids as a critical molecular signal. Lipid peroxidation is connected to increases in mitochondrial reactive oxygen species, but there is also a required role for mitochondrial cytochrome c (cyt-c). In apoptotic mitochondria, cyt-c gains a new function as a lipid peroxidase that catalyzes the reactive oxygen species-mediated chemical modification of the mitochondrial lipid cardiolipin (CL). This peroxidase activity is caused by a conformational change in the protein, resulting from interactions between cyt-c and CL. The nature of the conformational change and how it causes this gain-of-function remain uncertain. Via a combination of functional, structural, and biophysical experiments we investigate the structure and peroxidase activity of cyt-c in its membrane-bound state. We reconstituted cyt-c with CL-containing lipid vesicles, and determined the increase in peroxidase activity resulting from membrane binding. We combined these assays of CL-induced proapoptotic activity with structural and dynamic studies of the membrane-bound protein via solid-state NMR and optical spectroscopy. Multidimensional magic angle spinning (MAS) solid-state NMR of uniformly ¹³C,¹⁵N-labeled protein was used to detect site-specific conformational changes in oxidized and reduced horse heart cyt-c bound to CL-containing lipid bilayers. MAS NMR and Fourier transform infrared measurements show that the peripherally membrane-bound cyt-c experiences significant dynamics, but also retains most or all of its secondary structure. Moreover, in two-dimensional and three-dimensional MAS NMR spectra the CL-bound cyt-c displays a spectral resolution, and thus structural homogeneity, that is inconsistent with extensive membrane-induced unfolding. Cyt-c is found to interact primarily with the membrane interface, without significantly disrupting the lipid bilayer. Thus, membrane binding results in cyt-c gaining the increased peroxidase activity that represents its pivotal proapoptotic function, but we do not observe evidence for large-scale unfolding or penetration into the membrane core.     

Microsecond Barrier-Limited Chain Collapse Observed by Time-Resolved FRET and SAXS

It is generally held that random-coil polypeptide chains undergo a barrier-less continuous collapse when the solvent conditions are changed to favor the fully folded native conformation. We test this hypothesis by probing intramolecular distance distributions during folding in one of the paradigms of folding reactions, that of cytochrome c. The Trp59-to-heme distance was probed by time-resolved Förster resonance energy transfer in the microsecond time range of refolding. Contrary to expectation, a state with a Trp59–heme distance close to that of the guanidinium hydrochloride (GdnHCl) denatured state is present after ~ 27 μs of folding. A concomitant decrease in the population of this state and an increase in the population of a compact high-FRET (Förster resonance energy transfer) state (efficiency > 90%) show that the collapse is barrier limited. Small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) measurements over a similar time range show that the radius of gyration under native favoring conditions is comparable to that of the GdnHCl denatured unfolded state. An independent comprehensive global thermodynamic analysis reveals that marginally stable partially folded structures are also present in the nominally unfolded GdnHCl denatured state. These observations suggest that specifically collapsed intermediate structures with low stability in rapid equilibrium with the unfolded state may contribute to the apparent chain contraction observed in previous fluorescence studies using steady-state detection. In the absence of significant dynamic averaging of marginally stable partially folded states and with the use of probes sensitive to distance distributions, barrier-limited chain contraction is observed upon transfer of the GdnHCl denatured state ensemble to native-like conditions.     

Non-Sequence-Specific Interactions Can Account for the Compaction of Proteins Unfolded under “Native” Conditions

Proteins unfolded by high concentrations of chemical denaturants adopt expanded, largely structure-free ensembles of conformations that are well approximated as random coils. In contrast, globular proteins unfolded under less denaturing conditions (via mutations, or transiently unfolded after a rapid jump to native conditions) and molten globules (arising due to mutations or cosolvents) are often compact. Here we explore the origins of this compaction using a truncated equilibrium-unfolded variant of the 57-residue FynSH3 domain. As monitored by far-UV circular dichroism, NMR spectroscopy, and hydrogen-exchange kinetics, CΔ4 (a 4-residue carboxy-terminal deletion variant of FynSH3) appears to be largely unfolded even in the absence of denaturant. Nevertheless, CΔ4 is quite compact under these conditions, with a hydrodynamic radius only slightly larger than that of the native protein. In order to understand the origins of this molten-globule-like compaction, we have characterized a random sequence polypeptide of identical amino acid composition to CΔ4. Notably, we find that the hydrodynamic radius of this random sequence polypeptide also approaches that of the native protein. Thus, while native-like interactions may contribute to the formation of compact “unfolded” states, it appears that non-sequence-specific monomer-monomer interactions can also account for the dramatic compaction observed for molten globules and the “physiological” unfolded state.     

Structural Characteristic of the Initial Unfolded State on Refolding Determines Catalytic Efficiency of the Folded Protein in Presence of Osmolytes

Osmolytes are low molecular weight organic molecules accumulated by organisms to assist proper protein folding, and to provide protection to the structural integrity of proteins under denaturing stress conditions. It is known that osmolyte-induced protein folding is brought by unfavorable interaction of osmolytes with the denatured/unfolded states. The interaction of osmolyte with the native state does not significantly contribute to the osmolyte-induced protein folding. We have therefore investigated if different denatured states of a protein (generated by different denaturing agents) interact differently with the osmolytes to induce protein folding. We observed that osmolyte-assisted refolding of protein obtained from heat-induced denatured state produces native molecules with higher enzyme activity than those initiated from GdmCl- or urea-induced denatured state indicating that the structural property of the initial denatured state during refolding by osmolytes determines the catalytic efficiency of the folded protein molecule. These conclusions have been reached from the systematic measurements of enzymatic kinetic parameters (K _m and k _cat), thermodynamic stability (T _m and ΔH _m) and secondary and tertiary structures of the folded native proteins obtained from refolding of various denatured states (due to heat-, urea- and GdmCl-induced denaturation) of RNase-A in the presence of various osmolytes.     

Dynamics and dimension of an amyloidogenic disordered state of human β2-microglobulin

Human β₂-microglobulin (β₂m) aggregation is implicated in dialysis-related amyloidosis. Previously, it has been shown that β₂m adopts an ensemble of partially unfolded states at low pH. Here we provide detailed structural and dynamical insights into the acid unfolded and yet compact state of β₂m at pH 2.5 using a host of fluorescence spectroscopic tools. These tools allowed us to investigate protein conformational dynamics at low micromolar protein concentrations in an amyloid-forming condition. Our equilibrium fluorescence data in combination with circular dichroism data provide support in favor of progressive structural dissolution of β₂m with lowering pH. The acid unfolded intermediate at pH 2.5 has high 8-anilinonaphthalene, 1-sulfonic acid (ANS)-binding affinity and is devoid of significant secondary structural elements. Using fluorescence lifetime measurements, we have been able to monitor the conformational transition during the pH transition from the native to the compact disordered state. Additionally, using time-resolved fluorescence anisotropy measurements, we have been able to distinguish this compact disordered state from the canonical denatured state of the protein by identifying unique dynamic signatures pertaining to the segmental chain mobility. Taken together, our results demonstrate that β₂m at pH 2.5 adopts a compact noncanonical unfolded state resembling a collapsed premolten globule state. Additionally, our stopped-flow fluorescence kinetics results provide mechanistic insights into the formation of a compact disordered state from the native form.     

Thermodynamics and Kinetics of Single-Chain Monellin Folding with Structural Insights into Specific Collapse in the Denatured State Ensemble

Proteins, which behave as random coils in high denaturant concentrations undergo collapse transition similar to polymers on denaturant dilution. We study collapse in the denatured ensemble of single-chain monellin (MNEI) using a coarse-grained protein model and molecular dynamics simulations. The model is validated by quantitatively comparing the computed guanidinium chloride and pH-dependent thermodynamic properties of MNEI folding with the experiments. The computed properties such as the fraction of the protein in the folded state and radius of gyration (R_g) as function of [GuHCl] are in good agreement with the experiments. The folded state of MNEI is destabilized with an increase in pH due to the deprotonation of the residues Glu24 and Cys42. On decreasing [GuHCl], the protein in the unfolded ensemble showed specific compaction. The R_g of the protein decreased steadily with [GuHCl] dilution due to increase in the number of native contacts in all the secondary structural elements present in the protein. MNEI folding kinetics is complex with multiple folding pathways and transiently stable intermediates are populated in these pathways. In strong stabilizing conditions, the protein in the unfolded ensemble showed transition to a more compact unfolded state where R_g decreased by ≈ 17% due to the formation of specific native contacts in the protein. The intermediate populated in the dominant MNEI folding pathway satisfies the structural features of the dry molten globule inferred from experiments.     

Is There or Isn't There? The Case for (and Against) Residual Structure in Chemically Denatured Proteins

ABSTRACT

First raised some 60 years ago, the question of whether chemically denatured proteins are fully unfolded has, in recent years, seen significantly renewed interest. This increased attention has been spurred, in large part, by new spectroscopic and computational approaches that suggest even the most highly denatured polypeptides contain significant residual structure. In contrast, the most recent scattering results uphold the long-standing view that chemically denatured proteins adopt random coil configurations. Here we review the evidence both for and against residual structure in chemically denatured proteins, and attempt to reconcile these seemingly contradictory observations.     

Electrophoretic analysis of the unfolding of proteins by urea.

The unfolding of several proteins by urea has been followed by electrophoresis of a band of protein through a slab gel of polyacrylamide in which there was a gradient of urea concentration perpendicular to the direction of electrophoresis. Unfolding was invariably manifested by a marked reduction of mobility, presumably due to molecular sieving of the expanded polypeptide chain by the polyacrylamide gel. The procedure provides a continuous two-dimensional pattern of the effect of urea on the shape of the protein and is especially sensitive to microheterogeneity of the protein.Experiments with pancreatic trypsin inhibitor, ribonuclease, lysozyme, chymotrypsin, chymotrypsinogen, staphylococcal nuclease, and cytochrome c were consistent with the results of others using orthodox methods and confirm the validity of the method. Where unfolding occurred, it was generally rapidly reversible and the curves were entirely consistent with the presence of only the native and the fully unfolded states. Serum albumin gave more complex curves and a remarkable illustration of micro-heterogeneity. β-Lactoglobulins A and B and ovalbumin refold very slowly and the unfolded molecules appeared to equilibrate preferentially with compact, but non-native, forms at low urea concentrations.     

Domains in folding of model proteins.

By means of Monte Carlo simulation, we investigated the equilibrium between folded and unfolded states of lattice model proteins. The amino acid sequences were designed to have pronounced energy minimum target conformations of different length and shape. For short fully compact (36-mer) proteins, the all-or-none transition from the unfolded state to the native state was observed. This was not always the case for longer proteins. Among 12 designed sequences with the native structure of a fully compact 48-mer, a simple all-or-none transition was observed in only three cases. For the other nine sequences, three states of behavior-the native, denatured, and intermediate states-were found. The contiguous part of the native structure (domain) was conserved in the intermediate state, whereas the remaining part was completely unfolded and structureless. These parts melted separately from each other.     

Thermodynamically stable aggregation-resistant antibody domains through directed evolution

Protein aggregates are usually formed by interactions between unfolded or partially unfolded species, and often occur when a protein is denatured by, for example, heat or low pH. In earlier work, we used a Darwinian selection strategy to create human antibody variable domains that resisted heat aggregation. The repertoires of domains were displayed on filamentous phage and denatured (at 80 °C in pH 7.4), and folded domains were selected by binding to a generic ligand after cooling. This process appeared to select for domains with denatured states that resisted aggregation, but the domains only had low free energies of folding (ΔG_N-D^o = 15-20 kJ/mol at 25 °C in pH 7.4). Here, using the same phage repertoire, we have extended the method to the selection of domains resistant to acid aggregation. In this case, however, the thermodynamic stabilities of selected domains were higher than those selected by thermal denaturation (under both neutral and acidic conditions; ΔG_N-D^o = 26-47 kJ/mol at 25 °C in pH 7.4, or ΔG_N-D^o = 27-34 kJ/mol in pH 3.2). Furthermore, we identified a key determinant (Arg28) that increased the aggregation resistance of the denatured states of the domains at low pH without compromising their thermodynamic stabilities. Thus, the selection process yielded domains that combined thermodynamic stability and aggregation-resistant unfolded states. We suggest that changes to these properties are controlled by the extent to which the folding equilibrium is displaced during the process of selection.     

Cation-induced toroidal condensation of DNA studies with Co3+(NH3)6

The unfolding and refolding of Staphylococcus aureus penicillinase have been followed by urea-gradient electrophoresis. Unfolding of the native state proceeds by an all-or-none transition to fully unfolded protein, with no detectable accumulation of partially unfolded states. In contrast, refolding is complex and proceeds by very rapid, reversible formation of a partially folded state, H, which had been detected and characterized previously, as it is the most stable conformation at intermediate denaturant concentrations. At very low urea concentrations, a more compact conformational state was observed as a transient intermediate in refolding. There was little kinetic heterogeneity of the unfolded protein, as is normally observed with proteins containing proline residues.     

The cold denatured state is compact but expands at low temperatures: hydrodynamic properties of the cold denatured state of the C-terminal domain of L9

A point mutation of a small globular protein, the C-terminal domain of L9 destabilizes the protein and leads to observable cold-denaturation at temperatures above zero. The cold denatured state is in slow exchange with the native state on the NMR time scale, and this allows the hydrodynamic properties of the cold unfolded state and the native state to be measured under identical conditions using pulsed-field gradient NMR diffusion measurements. This provides the first experimental measurement of the hydrodynamic properties of a cold unfolded protein and its folded form under identical conditions. Hydrodynamic radii of the cold-induced unfolded states were measured for a set of temperatures ranging from 2 °C to 25 °C at pD 6.6 in the absence of denaturant. The cold unfolded state is compact compared to the urea or acid unfolded state and a trend of increasing radii of hydration is observed as the temperature is lowered. These observations are confirmed by experiments on the same protein at pD 8.0, where it is more stable, in the presence of a modest concentration of urea. The expansion of the cold-denatured state at lower temperatures is consistent with the temperature dependence of hydrophobic interactions.     

Test for cooperativity in the early kinetic intermediate in lysozyme folding

During the folding of many proteins, collapsed globular states are formed prior to the native structure. The role of these states for the folding process has been widely discussed. Comparison with properties of synthetic homo and heteropolymers had suggested that the initial collapse represented a shift of the ensemble of unfolded conformations to more compact states without major energy barriers. We investigated the folding/unfolding transition of a collapsed state, which transiently populates early in lysozyme folding. This state forms within the dead-time of stopped-flow mixing and it has been shown to be significantly more compact and globular than the denaturant-induced unfolded state. We used the GdmCl-dependence of the dead-time signal change to characterize the unfolding transition of the burst phase intermediate. Fluorescence and far-UV CD give identical unfolding curves, arguing for a cooperative two-state folding/unfolding transition between unfolded and collapsed lysozyme. These results show that collapse leads to a distinct state in the folding process, which is separated from the ensemble of unfolded molecules by a significant energy barrier. NMR, fluorescence and small angle X-ray scattering data further show that some local interactions in unfolded lysozyme exist at denaturant concentrations above the coil-collapse transition. These interactions might play a crucial role in the kinetic partitioning between fast and slow folding pathways.     

Direct observation of phosphorylase kinase and phosphorylase b by scanning tunneling microscopy

The molecular structures of phosphorylase b and phosphorylase kinase have been visualized by scanning tunneling microscopy (STM). STM is a near field technique that can resolve structures at the nanometer level and thus can image individual molecules. Phosphorylase b can be seen in dimeric and tetrameric forms as well as linear and globular aggregates. The linear arrays consist of side by side dimers with the long axis of the dimer perpendicular to the aggregated chain. Individual molecules of phosphorylase kinase appear to be planar, bilobate structures with a 2-fold axis of symmetry and a central depression.     

Distribution of molecular size within an unfolded state ensemble using small-angle X-ray scattering and pulse field gradient NMR techniques

The size distribution of molecules within an unfolded state of the N-terminal SH3 domain of drk (drkN SH3) has been studied by small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) and pulsed-field-gradient NMR (PFG-NMR) methods. An empirical model to describe this distribution in the unfolded state ensemble has been proposed based on (i) the ensemble-averaged radius of gyration and hydrodynamic radius derived from the SAXS and PFG-NMR data, respectively, and (ii) a histogram of the size distribution of structures obtained from preliminary analyses of structural parameters recorded on the unfolded state. Results show that this unfolded state, U(exch), which exists in equilibrium with the folded state, F(exch), under non-denaturing conditions, is relatively compact, with the average size of conformers within the unfolded state ensemble only 30-40% larger than the folded state structure. In addition, the model predicts a significant overlap in the size range of structures comprising the U(exch) state with those in a denatured state obtained by addition of 2 M guanidinium chloride.     

Thermodynamics of Loop Formation in the Denatured State of Rhodopseudomonas palustris Cytochrome c′: Scaling Exponents and the Reconciliation Problem

The observation that denatured proteins yield scaling exponents, ν, consistent with random-coil behavior and yet can also have pockets of residual or nonrandom structure has been termed the “reconciliation problem”. To provide greater insight into the denatured state of a foldable sequence, we have measured histidine-heme loop formation equilibria in the denatured state of a class II c-type cytochrome, cytochrome c′ from Rhodopseudomonas palustris. We have prepared a series of variants that provide His-heme loop stabilities, pK_loop(His), for loop sizes ranging from 10 to 111 residues at intervals of 7 to 11 residues along the sequence of the protein. We observe a scaling exponent for loop formation, ν₃, of 2.5 ± 0.3. Theoretical values for ν₃ range from 1.8 to 2.4; thus, the observed ν₃ is consistent with random-coil behavior. However, in contrast to data for loop formation as a function of loop size obtained with peptides of homogeneous sequence, we observe considerable scatter about the linear dependence of loop stability on loop size. Thus, foldable sequences behave very differently from homogeneous peptide sequences. The observed scatter suggests that there is considerable variation in the conformational properties along the backbone of a foldable sequence, consistent with alternating compact and extended regions. With regard to the reconciliation problem, it is evident that a scaling exponent consistent with a random coil is necessary but not sufficient to demonstrate random-coil behavior.     

Reversible Unfolding of Rhomboid Intramembrane Proteases

Denaturant-induced unfolding of helical membrane proteins provides insights into their mechanism of folding and domain organization, which take place in the chemically heterogeneous, anisotropic environment of a lipid membrane. Rhomboid proteases are intramembrane proteases that play key roles in various diseases. Crystal structures have revealed a compact helical bundle with a buried active site, which requires conformational changes for the cleavage of transmembrane substrates. A dimeric form of the rhomboid protease has been shown to be important for activity. In this study, we examine the mechanism of refolding for two distinct rhomboids to gain insight into their secondary structure-activity relationships. Although helicity is largely abolished in the unfolded states of both proteins, unfolding is completely reversible for HiGlpG but only partially reversible for PsAarA. Refolding of both proteins results in reassociation of the dimer, with a 90% regain of catalytic activity for HiGlpG but only a 70% regain for PsAarA. For both proteins, a broad, gradual transition from the native, folded state to the denatured, partly unfolded state was revealed with the aid of circular dichroism spectroscopy as a function of denaturant concentration, thus arguing against a classical two-state model as found for many globular soluble proteins. Thermal denaturation has irreversible destabilizing effects on both proteins, yet reveals important functional details regarding substrate accessibility to the buried active site. This concerted biophysical and functional analysis demonstrates that HiGlpG, with a simple six-transmembrane-segment organization, is more robust than PsAarA, which has seven predicted transmembrane segments, thus rendering HiGlpG amenable to in vitro studies of membrane-protein folding.     

Identical RNA-Protein Interactions in Vivo and in Vitro and a Scheme of Folding the Newly Synthesized Proteins by Ribosomes

A distinct three-dimensional shape of rRNA inside the ribosome is required for the peptidyl transfer activity of its peptidyltransferase center (PTC). In contrast, even the in vitro transcribed PTC RNA interacts with unfolded protein(s) at about five sites to let them attain their native states. We found that the same set of conserved nucleotides in the PTC interact identically with nascent and chemically unfolded proteins in vivo and in vitro, respectively. The time course of this interaction, difficult to follow in vivo, was observed in vitro. It suggested nucleation of folding of cytosolic globular proteins vectorially from hydrophilic N to hydrophobic C termini, consistent with our discovery of a regular arrangement of cumulative hydrophobic indices of the peptide segments of cytosolic proteins from N to C termini. Based on this observation, we propose a model here for the nucleation of folding of the nascent protein chain by the PTC.     

Peroxidase activity of cytochrome c in its compact state depends on dynamics of the heme region

Cytochrome c (cyt c) is a small globular hemoprotein with the main function as an electron carrier in mitochondrial respiratory chain. Cyt c possesses also peroxidase-like activity in the native state despite its six-coordinated heme iron. In this work, we studied the effect of increasing urea concentration in the range from 0 M to 6 M at pH 7 (pH value of the bulk solvent) and pH 5 (pH value close to negatively charged membrane) on peroxidase-like activity of cyt c. We show that peroxidase-like activity, measured by guaiacol oxidation and the ferrous oxidation in xylenol orange methods, correlates with the accessibility of the heme iron, which was assessed from the association rate constant of cyanide binding to cyt c. Cyt c peroxidase-like activity linearly increases in the pre-denaturational urea concentrations (0–4 M) at both studied pHs without an apparent formation of penta-coordinated state of the heme iron. Our results suggest that dynamic equilibrium among the denaturant-induced non-native coordination states of cyt c, very likely due to reversible unfolding of the least stable foldons, is pre-requisite for enhanced peroxidase-like activity of cyt c in its compact state. Dynamic replacement of the native sixth coordination bond of methionine-80 by lysines (72, 73, and 79) and partially also by histidines (26 and 33) provides an efficient way how to increase peroxidase-like activity of cyt c without significant conformational change at physiological conditions.