Selective degradation of oxidatively modified protein substrates by the proteasome

Oxidative stress in mammalian cells is an inevitable consequence of their aerobic metabolism. Oxidants produce modifications to proteins leading to loss of function (or gain of undesirable function) and very often to an enhanced degradation of the oxidized proteins. For several years it has been known that the proteasome is involved in the degradation of oxidized proteins. This review summarizes our knowledge about the recognition of oxidized protein substrates by the proteasome in in vitro systems and its applicability to living cells. The majority of studies in the field agree that the degradation of mildly oxidized proteins is an important function of the proteasomal system. The major recognition motif of the substrates seems to be hydrophobic surface patches that are recognized by the 20S 'core' proteasome. Such hydrophobic surface patches are formed by partial unfolding and exposure of hydrophobic amino acid residues during oxidation. Oxidized proteins appear to be relatively poor substrates for ubiquitination, and the ubiquitination system does not seem to be involved in the recognition or targeting of oxidized proteins. Heavily oxidized proteins appear to first aggregate (new hydrophobic and ionic bonds) and then to form covalent cross-links that make them highly resistant to proteolysis. The inability to degrade extensively oxidized proteins may contribute to the accumulation of protein aggregates during diseases and the aging process.     

Intracellular distribution of oxidized proteins and proteasome in HT22 cells during oxidative stress

The production of free radicals and the resulting oxidative damage of cellular structures are always connected with the formation of oxidized proteins. The 20S proteasome is responsible for recognition and degradation of oxidatively damaged proteins. No detailed studies on the intracellular distribution of oxidized proteins during oxidative stress and on the distribution of the proteasome have been performed until now. Therefore, we used immunocytochemical methods to measure protein carbonyls, a form of protein oxidation products, and proteasome distribution within cells. Both immunocytochemical methods of measurement are semiquantitative and the load of oxidized proteins is increased after various oxidative stresses explored, with the highest increase in the perinuclear region of the cell. Distribution of the proteasome and the total protein content revealed the highest concentration of both in the nucleus. No redistribution of the proteasome during oxidative stress occurs. The normalized ratio of protein carbonyls to protein content was formed, indicating the highest concentration of oxidized proteins in the cytosolic region near the cell membrane. By forming the protein oxidation-to-proteasome ratio it was concluded that the highest load of oxidized proteins to the proteasome takes place in the cytosol, independent of the oxidant explored.     

Age-related differences in oxidative protein-damage in young and senescent fibroblasts

Aging is accompanied by an accumulation of oxidized proteins and cross-linked modified protein material. The intracellular formation and accumulation of highly oxidized and cross-linked proteins, the so-called lipofuscin, is a typical sign of senescence. However, little is known whether the lipofuscin accumulation during aging is related to environmental conditions, as oxidative stress, and whether the accumulation of oxidized proteins and lipofuscin is preferentially taking place in the cytosol or the nucleus and finally, what is the role of lysosomes in this process.Therefore, we investigated human skin fibroblasts in an early stage of proliferation (“young cells”) and in a late stage (“senescent cells”). Such cells were compared for the amount of protein carbonyls and lipofuscin and their distribution within the cytosol and the nucleus. Furthermore, cells were exposed to single and repeated doses of hydrogen peroxide and paraquat, measuring the same set of parameters. In addition to that the role of the proteasome to degrade oxidized proteins in young and senescent cells was tested. Furthermore, detailed microscopic analysis was performed testing the intracellular distribution of lipofuscin. The results clearly demonstrated that repeated/chronic oxidative stress induces a senescence-like phenotype of the distribution of oxidized proteins as well as of lipofuscin. It could be demonstrated that most of the lipofuscin is located in lysosomes and that senescent cells contain less lysosomes not lipofuscin-laden in comparison to young cells.     

Ubiquitin-proteasome pathway and cellular responses to oxidative stress

The ubiquitin-proteasome pathway (UPP) is the primary cytosolic proteolytic machinery for the selective degradation of various forms of damaged proteins. Thus, the UPP is an important protein quality control mechanism. In the canonical UPP, both ubiquitin and the 26S proteasome are involved. Substrate proteins of the canonical UPP are first tagged by multiple ubiquitin molecules and then degraded by the 26S proteasome. However, in noncanonical UPP, proteins can be degraded by the 26S or the 20S proteasome without being ubiquitinated. It is clear that a proteasome is responsible for selective degradation of oxidized proteins, but the extent to which ubiquitination is involved in this process remains a subject of debate. Whereas many publications suggest that the 20S proteasome degrades oxidized proteins independent of ubiquitin, there is also solid evidence indicating that ubiquitin and ubiquitination are involved in degradation of some forms of oxidized proteins. A fully functional UPP is required for cells to cope with oxidative stress and the activity of the UPP is also modulated by cellular redox status. Mild or transient oxidative stress up-regulates the ubiquitination system and proteasome activity in cells and tissues and transiently enhances intracellular proteolysis. Severe or sustained oxidative stress impairs the function of the UPP and decreases intracellular proteolysis. Both the ubiquitin-conjugating enzymes and the proteasome can be inactivated by sustained oxidative stress, especially the 26S proteasome. Differential susceptibilities of the ubiquitin-conjugating enzymes and the 26S proteasome to oxidative damage lead to an accumulation of ubiquitin conjugates in cells in response to mild oxidative stress. Thus, increased levels of ubiquitin conjugates in cells seem to be an indicator of mild oxidative stress.     

Proteins bearing oxidation-induced carbonyl groups are not preferentially ubiquitinated

A substantial part of soluble, oxidized proteins are degraded by the proteasome. However, it is still under debate whether these oxidized proteins are degraded by the 26S proteasome in an ubiquitin-dependent way or in an ubiquitin-independent way by the 20S proteasome. Therefore, we treated cells with H₂O₂ and UV-A irradiation and detected protein carbonyls and ubiquitination by immunoblotting. Separation of ubiquitinated proteins from non-ubiquitinated reveals that most oxidized proteins are not ubiquitinated.     

20S proteasome and accumulation of oxidized and ubiquitinated proteins in maize leaves subjected to cadmium stress

In order to examine the possible involvement of the 20S proteasome in degradation of oxidized proteins, the effects of different cadmium concentrations on its activities, protein abundance and oxidation level were studied using maize (Zea mays L.) leaf segments. The accumulation of carbonylated and ubiquitinated proteins was also investigated. Treatment with 50 microM CdCl(2) increased both trypsin- and PGPH-like activities of the 20S proteasome. The incremental changes in 20S proteasome activities were probably caused by an increased level of 20S proteasome oxidation, with this being responsible for degradation of the oxidized proteins. When leaf segments were treated with 100 microM CdCl(2), the chymotrysin- and trypsin-like activities of the 20S proteasome also decreased, with a concomitant increase in accumulation of carbonylated and ubiquitinated proteins. With both Cd(2+) concentrations, the abundance of the 20S proteasome protein remained similar to the control experiments. These results provide evidence for the involvement of this proteolytic system in cadmium-stressed plants.     

Age-dependent declines in proteasome activity in the heart.

The proteasome is a major intracellular proteolytic system involved in the removal of oxidized and ubiquitinated protein and the induction of certain stress response pathways. In this study, age-dependent alterations in proteasome function were investigated to gain insight into potential factors which contribute to increased susceptibility to various forms of heart disease during aging. Proteasome activity in cellular extracts prepared from Fisher 344 rat hearts was found to decrease with age. These declines in activity were associated with a decreased 20S proteasome content and loss of specific activities. As determined by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis of purified 20S proteasome, the distribution and silver staining intensities of enzyme subunits were found to vary with age, suggesting that alterations in proteasome subunit composition and/or structure are involved in age-related declines in proteasome activity. In addition, age-dependent increases in the levels of oxidized and ubiquitinated proteins, known substrates of the proteasome, were observed. Thus, loss in proteasome function may impair the ability of myocytes to mount an appropriate response to stress, thereby enhancing the susceptibility of the aging heart to cardiovascular disease.     

Autophagy as a cell-repair mechanism: activation of chaperone-mediated autophagy during oxidative stress

Proper removal of oxidized proteins is an important determinant of success when evaluating the ability of cells to handle oxidative stress. The ubiquitin/proteasome system has been considered the main responsible mechanism for the removal of oxidized proteins, as it can discriminate between normal and altered proteins, and selectively target the latter ones for degradation. A possible role for lysosomes, the other major intracellular proteolytic system, in the removal of oxidized proteins has been often refused, mostly on the basis of the lack of selectivity of this system. Although most of the degradation of intracellular components in lysosomes (autophagy) takes place through “in bulk” sequestration of complete cytosolic regions, selective targeting of proteins to lysosomes for their degradation is also possible via what is known as chaperone-mediated autophagy (CMA). In this work, we review recent evidence supporting the participation of CMA in the clearance of oxidized proteins in the forefront of the cellular response to oxidative stress. The consequences of an impairment in CMA activity, observed during aging and in some age-related disorders, are also discussed.     

Coordination of oxidized protein hydrolase and the proteasome in the clearance of cytotoxic denatured proteins

Intracellular accumulation of denatured proteins impairs cellular function. The proteasome is recognized as an enzyme responsible for the effective clearance of those cytotoxic denatured proteins. As another enzyme that participates in the destruction of damaged proteins, we have identified oxidized protein hydrolase (OPH) and found that OPH confers cellular resistance to various kinds of oxidative stress. In this study, we demonstrate the roles of the proteasome and OPH in the clearance of denatured proteins. The inhibition of proteasome activity results in the elevation of protein carbonyls in cells under oxidative stress. On the other hand, cells overexpressing OPH retain higher resistance to oxidative stress, even though the proteasome activity is inhibited. Furthermore, upon inhibition of the proteasome activity, OPH is recruited to a novel organelle termed the aggresome where misfolded or denatured proteins are processed. Thus, OPH and the proteasome coordinately contribute to the clearance of cytotoxic denatured proteins.     

Hydrogen peroxide-mediated protein oxidation in young and old human MRC-5 fibroblasts

It is suggested that the aging process is dependent on the action of free radicals. One of the highlights of age-related changes of cellular metabolism is the accumulation of oxidized proteins. The present investigation was undertaken to reveal the proliferation-related changes in the protein oxidation and proteasome activity during and after an acute oxidative stress. It could be demonstrated that the activity of the cytosolic proteasomal system declines during proliferative senescence of human MRC-5 fibroblasts and is not able to remove oxidized proteins in old cells efficiently. Whereas in young cells removal of oxidized proteins was accompanied by an increase in the overall protein turnover, this increase in protein turnover could not be seen in old MRC-5 fibroblasts. Therefore, our studies demonstrate that old fibroblasts are much more vulnerable to the accumulation of oxidized proteins after oxidative stress and are not able to remove these oxidized proteins as efficiently as young fibroblasts.     

Spg5 Protein Regulates the Proteasome in Quiescence

The ubiquitin-proteasome system is the major pathway for selective protein degradation in eukaryotes. Despite extensive study of this system, the mechanisms by which proteasome function and cell growth are coordinated remain unclear. Here, we identify Spg5 as a novel component of the ubiquitin-proteasome system. Spg5 binds the regulatory particle of the proteasome and the base subassembly in particular, but it is excluded from mature proteasomes. The SPG5 gene is strongly induced in the stationary phase of budding yeast, and spg5Δ mutants show a progressive loss of viability under these conditions. Accordingly, during logarithmic growth, Spg5 appears largely dispensable for proteasome function, but during stationary phase the proteasomes of spg5Δ mutants show both structural and functional defects. This loss of proteasome function is reflected in the accumulation of oxidized proteins preferentially in stationary phase in spg5Δ mutants. Thus, Spg5 is a positive regulator of the proteasome that is critical for survival of cells that have ceased to proliferate due to nutrient limitation.     

Protein oxidation and proteolysis

One of the hallmarks of chronic or severe oxidative stress is the accumulation of oxidized proteins, which tend to form high-molecular-weight aggregates. The major proteolytic system responsible for the removal of oxidized cytosolic and nuclear proteins is the proteasome. This complicated proteolytic system contains a core proteasomal form (20S proteasome) and several regulators. All of these components are affected by oxidative stress to various degrees. The ATP-stimulated 26S proteasome is sensitive to oxidative stress, whereas the 20S form seems to be more resistant. The nuclear proteasome selectively degrades oxidatively damaged histones in the nuclei of mammalian cells, where it is activated and regulated by automodified PARP-1 after oxidative challenge. In this brief review we highlight the proteolysis and its regulatory effects during oxidative stress.     

Protein oxidation and degradation during cellular senescence of human BJ fibroblasts: part I--effects of proliferative senescence.

Oxidized and cross-linked proteins tend to accumulate in aging cells. Declining activity of proteolytic enzymes, particularly the proteasome, has been proposed as a possible explanation for this phenomenon, and direct inhibition of the proteasome by oxidized and cross-linked proteins has been demonstrated in vitro. We have further examined this hypothesis during both proliferative senescence (this paper) and postmitotic senescence (see the accompanying paper, ref 1 ) of human BJ fibroblasts. During proliferative senescence, we found a marked decline in all proteasome activities (trypsin-like activity, chymotrypsin-like activity, and peptidyl-glutamyl-hydrolyzing activity) and in lysosomal cathepsin activity. Despite the loss of proteasome activity, there was no concomitant change in cellular levels of actual proteasome protein (immunoassays) or in the steady-state levels of mRNAs for essential proteasome subunits. The decline in proteasome activities and lysosomal cathepsin activities was accompanied by dramatic increases in the accumulation of oxidized and cross-linked proteins. Furthermore, as proliferation stage increased, cells exhibited a decreasing ability to degrade the oxidatively damaged proteins generated by an acute, experimentally applied oxidative stress. Thus, oxidized and cross-linked proteins accumulated rapidly in cells of higher proliferation stages. Our data are consistent with the hypothesis that proteasome is progressively inhibited by small accumulations of oxidized and cross-linked proteins during proliferative senescence until late proliferation stages, when so much proteasome activity has been lost that oxidized proteins accumulate at ever-increasing rates. Lysosomes attempt to deal with the accumulating oxidized and cross-linked proteins, but declining lysosomal cathepsin activity apparently limits their effectiveness. This hypothesis, which may explain the progressive intracellular accumulation of oxidized and cross-linked proteins in aging, is further explored during postmitotic senescence in the accompanying paper (1).     

The nuclear proteasome and the degradation of oxidatively damaged proteins

Summary. The accumulation of oxidized proteins is known to be linked to some severe neurodegenerative diseases like Alzheimer’s, Parkinson’s and Huntington’s disease. Furthermore, the aging process is also accompanied by an ongoing aggregation of misfolded and damaged proteins. Therefore, mammalian cells have developed potent degradation systems, which selectively degrade damaged and misfolded proteins. The proteasomal system is largely responsible for the removal of oxidatively damaged proteins form the cellular environment. Not only cytosolic proteins are prone to oxidative stress, also nuclear proteins are readily oxidized. The nuclear proteasomal system is responsible for the degradation of these proteins. This review is focused on the specific degradation of oxidized nuclear proteins, the role of the proteasome in this process and the regulation of the nuclear proteasomal system under oxidative conditions.     

Ubiquitin conjugation is not required for the degradation of oxidized proteins by proteasome

Oxidatively modified proteins that accumulate in aging and many diseases can form large aggregates because of covalent cross-linking or increased surface hydrophobicity. Unless repaired or removed from cells, these oxidized proteins are often toxic, and threaten cell viability. Most oxidatively damaged proteins appear to undergo selective proteolysis, primarily by the proteasome. Previous work from our laboratory has shown that purified 20 S proteasome degrades oxidized proteins without ATP or ubiquitin in vitro, but there have been no studies to test this mechanism in vivo. The aim of this study was to determine whether ubiquitin conjugation is necessary for the degradation of oxidized proteins in intact cells. We now show that cells with compromised ubiquitin-conjugating activity still preferentially degrade oxidized intracellular proteins, at near normal rates, and this degradation is still inhibited by proteasome inhibitors. We also show that progressive oxidation of proteins such as lysozyme and ferritin does not increase their ubiquitinylation, yet the oxidized forms of both proteins are preferentially degraded by proteasome. Furthermore, rates of oxidized protein degradation by cell lysates are not significantly altered by addition of ATP, excluding the possibility of an energy requirement for this pathway. Contrary to earlier popular belief that most proteasomal degradation is conducted by the 26 S proteasome with ubiquitinylated substrates, our work suggests that oxidized proteins are degraded without ubiquitin conjugation (or ATP hydrolysis) possibly by the 20 S proteasome, or the immunoproteasome, or both.     

Protein turnover by the proteasome in aging and disease

A significant body of evidence supports a key role for free radicals in causing cumulative damage to cellular macromolecules, thereby contributing to senescence/aging, and a number of age-related disorders. Proteins are recognized as major targets for oxidative damage (in addition to DNA and lipids) and the accumulation of oxidized proteins has been reported for many experimental aging models, as measured by several markers for protein oxidation. In young and healthy individuals, moderately oxidized soluble cell proteins are selectively and rapidly degraded by the proteasome. However, severely oxidized, cross-linked proteins are poor substrates for degradation and actually inhibit the proteasome. Considerable evidence now indicates that proteasome activity declines during aging, as the protease is progressively inhibited by binding to ever increasing levels of oxidized and cross-linked protein aggregates. Cellular aging probably involves both an increase in the generation of reactive oxygen species and a progressive decline in proteasome activity, resulting in the progressive accumulation of oxidatively damaged protein aggregates that eventually contribute to cellular dysfunction and senescence.     

Limited degradation of oxidized calmodulin by proteasome: formation of peptides

Oxidized proteins are recognized and degraded preferentially by the proteasome. This is true for numerous proteins including calmodulin (CaM). The degradation of CaM was investigated in a human fibroblast cell line under conditions of oxidative stress. Low molecular CaM fragments or peptides were found under such conditions. In in vitro experiments it was investigated whether this CaM breakdown product formation is induced by protein oxidation or is due to a limited proteolysis-derived degradation by the 20S proteasome. Native unoxidized CaM was not degraded by 20S proteasome, oxidized CaM was degraded in a time- and H₂O₂ concentration-dependent manner. Peptides of similar molecular weight were detected in isolated calmodulin as in oxidatively stressed fibroblasts. The peptides were identified using isolated calmodulin. Therefore, in oxidatively stressed fibroblasts and in vitro CaM is forming oxidation-driven fragments and proteasomal cleavage peptides of approximately 30 amino acids which undergo a slow or no degradation.     

Impairment of proteasome function upon UVA- and UVB-irradiation of human keratinocytes

The major environmental influence for epidermal cells is sun exposure and the harmful effect of UV radiation on skin is related to the generation of reactive oxygen species that are altering cellular components including proteins. It is now well established that the proteasome is responsible for the degradation of oxidized proteins. Therefore, the effects of UV-irradiation on proteasome have been investigated in human keratinocyte cultures. Human keratinocytes were irradiated with 10 J/cm(2) of UVA and 0.05 J/cm(2) of UVB and proteasome peptidase activities were measured in cell lysates using fluorogenic peptides. All three peptidase activities were decreased as early as 1 h and up to 24 h after irradiation of the cells. Increased levels of oxidized and ubiquitinated proteins as well as proteins modified by the lipid peroxidation product 4-hydroxy-2-nonenal were also observed in irradiated cells. However, immunopurified 20S proteasome exhibited no difference in both peptidase specific activities and 2D gel pattern of subunits in irradiated cells, ruling out the possibility that the 20S proteasome could be a target for the UV-induced damage. Finally, extracts from irradiated keratinocytes were able to inhibit degradation by the proteasome, demonstrating the presence of endogeneous inhibitors, including 4-hydroxy-2-nonenal modified proteins, generated upon UV-irradiation.