A peripheral mechanism preserves self-tolerance to a secreted protein in transgenic mice

We have examined mechanisms of tolerance to circulating self-proteins in mice that are transgenic for human insulin. Normal, nontransgenic mice develop serum antibody responses when injected with human insulin in CFA; syngeneic transgenic mice do not. B cell responsiveness was assessed by immunizing with human insulin coupled to a T-independent Ag, Brucella abortus. No differences were found in the numbers of insulin-specific splenic plaque-forming cells between transgenic and nontransgenic mice suggesting that insulin-specific B cells are not tolerant in transgenic mice. Similarly, APC from transgenic and nontransgenic mice display no differences in their ability to process and present human insulin to human insulin-specific T cells in vitro. However, marked differences were detected between transgenic and nontransgenic T cells. Lymph node T cells from transgenic mice primed with human insulin provided no detectable helper activity for secondary antibody responses to human insulin whereas, lymph node T cells from nontransgenic mice did. Nevertheless, lymph node T cells from transgenic mice developed significant proliferative responses to human insulin. Lymph node T cells obtained from transgenic and nontransgenic mice were fused to BW5147 and human insulin-specific T cell hybridomas were generated. The fact that human insulin-specific T cell hybridomas were obtained from the transgenic mice suggests that these T cells were not clonally deleted. In addition, APC from transgenic mice did not stimulate human insulin-specific hybridomas from normal mice in the absence of exogenous insulin. We suggest that T cells specific for human insulin are not deleted in the thymus of transgenic mice because APC in the thymus do not bear the requisite levels of endogenous human insulin/Ia complexes. Therefore, we conclude that tolerance in the transgenic mice is preserved by peripheral mechanisms.     

Ir gene control of the immune response to insulins. I. Pork insulin stimulates T cell activity in nonresponder mice

Immune responses by mice to heterologous insulins are controlled by H-2-linked Ir genes. In studies to determine the mechanism(s) of nonresponsiveness, we found that although pork insulin fails to stimulate antibody or proliferative responses in H-2b mice, it does stimulate enhanced responses to subsequent challenge with an immunogenic species of insulin, such as beef insulin. Experiments described in this communication analyze the cell type primed in H-2b mice by pork insulin using an adoptive transfer protocol. The results demonstrate that pork insulin primes T cells that can express helper activity when recipient mice are challenged with beef but not pork insulin. This helper T cell activity is insulin specific in both elicitation and effect but is dependent upon stimulation by beef insulin for expression. Our interpretation of these results is that 2 antigen-specific T cell subpopulations are required for the generation of insulin-specific antibody responses and that the Ir gene defect in this case is expressed as a failure of specific interaction of these 2 T cell populations.     

Bovine insulin and porcine or human insulin prime distinct CD4(+) T cell subsets in C57BL/6 mice.

H-2(b) mice produce insulin-specific antibody when injected with bovine but not porcine or human insulin. Nevertheless, CD4(+) T cells have been cloned from C57BL/6 mice primed with porcine, human, and bovine insulin. Here we tested the hypothesis that CD4(+) T cells from C57BL/6 mice primed with porcine or human insulin are functionally distinct from those primed with bovine insulin. Our results show that variants of insulin that stimulate antibody responses induced Th2 clones, whereas variants of insulin that fail to stimulate antibody induced Th0 clones. Th0 clones triggered delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) in adoptive recipients, whereas Th2 clones did not. Insulin variants that primed Th0 clones also directly primed for DTH responses, while variants that activated Th2 clones did not. Thus, induction of Th2 clones correlated with the ability of mice to make antibody responses to insulin while development of Th0 clones correlated with DTH responses and the failure to produce antibody.     

Ir gene control of immune responses to insulins. II. Phenotypic differences in T cell activity among nonresponder strains of mice

Immune responses by mice to heterologous insulins are controlled by H-2 linked Ir genes. In studies to determine the mechanisms responsible for nonresponsiveness, we found that although pork insulin failed to stimulate antibody or proliferative responses in H-2b mice, it did prime T cells that can express helper activity in adoptive recipient mice. This helper activity was insulin-specific in both elicitation and expression. In studies presented in this paper, we have extended this analysis to the response patterns of helper T cells stimulated by sheep, horse, and rat insulins in mice bearing different H-2 haplotypes. The results demonstrate that nonresponder forms of insulin, including rat insulin, prime T cells in H-2b and H-2d, but not H-2k, mice. These results suggest that regulation of nonresponsiveness to insulin appears to be through different pathways in mice bearing different H-2 haplotypes.     

Immunopotentiation by SGP and Quil A. II. Identification of responding cell populations

The adjuvants SGP (a starch-acrylamide polymer) and Quil A (purified saponin) were shown to markedly augment antibody responses to T-independent (TI) antigens, suggesting that their adjuvant effects may be at least partially mediated through B cells. The ability of both adjuvants to augment primary responses to trinitrophenyl (TNP)-Ficoll (TI-2 antigen) in athymic nude mice further suggested these adjuvants affect B cells. SGP, however, did not induce a response to the T-dependent (TD) antigen dinitrophenyl-keyhole limpet hemocyanin (DNP-KLH) in athymic nude mice, indicating it was unable to replace the requirement for T-helper cells for responses to TD antigens. Responses to TNP-lipopolysaccharide (LPS) were augmented by SGP in CBA/N X Balb/c immune defective (xid) mice. However, SGP was unable to induce a response to TNP-Ficoll in xid mice. The SGP and Quil A augmented responses to TNP-Ficoll were completely inhibited by the mitotic inhibitor, Velban, indicating that SGP and Quil A increased the plaque-forming cell (PFC) response primarily by stimulating cell proliferation, and not by recruitment of antigen-reactive cells. The effects of the adjuvants on secondary responses were investigated using adoptive transfer experiments. SGP and A1(OH)3 both increased the induction of hapten-specific memory B cells in mice primed with DNP-KLH. SGP, Quil A, and A1(OH)3 also increased priming of carrier specific T cells. Priming of memory B cells with DNP-KLH and either A1(OH)3 or SGP was prevented when T cells were depleted with anti-lymphocyte serum (ALS) at the time of antigen priming, indicating that the augmentation of memory B-cell priming by SGP and A1(OH)3 was dependent on the presence of functional T cells. SGP and Quil A were both unable to augment memory cell induction to the TI antigen, TNP-Ficoll, even though both adjuvants markedly augmented primary IgM and IgG responses to this antigen. Based on these results, it is suggested that SGP and Quil A can mediate their adjuvant effects primarily by a direct or indirect effect on B cells although the adjuvants may also affect T cells to some extent.     

Comparison of the T cell receptors on insulin-specific hybridomas from insulin transgenic and nontransgenic mice. Loss of a subpopulation of self-reactive clones.

Transgenic mice expressing the human insulin gene do not produce insulin-specific antibody after injection of human insulin. Nevertheless, they have some peripheral T cells that proliferate to human insulin in vitro. To investigate the nature of these T cells, human insulin-specific T cell hybridomas were produced from transgenic and nontransgenic mice. Transgenic hybridomas required more insulin to achieve maximum responses and they produced lower levels of lymphokines than nontransgenic hybridomas. The majority of nontransgenic hybridomas recognized only human and pork insulin whereas transgenic hybridomas recognized beef, sheep, and/or horse insulin in addition to human and pork insulin. The TCR expressed by transgenic and nontransgenic hybridomas were determined by Northern analysis. Both types of hybridomas used several different V alpha and V beta gene families and no favored association between V alpha and V beta gene usage was detected in either type. V beta 1 was used by 7 of 16 nontransgenic hybridomas but only by 1 of 16 transgenic hybridomas. V beta 6 receptors were predominantly expressed by the transgenic hybridomas and all V beta 6-bearing hybridomas recognized beef as well as human insulin. The differences in Ag reactivity and TCR gene usage suggest that V beta 1-bearing human insulin-reactive T cells were clonally deleted or inactivated in the transgenic animal. Other clones, representing a minor subpopulation in nontransgenic mice, were recovered from transgenic mice.     

Genetics of insulin-specific helper and suppressor T cells in nonresponder mice

The role of insulin-specific helper and suppressor T cells in the H-2-linked genetic control of antibody responses to heterologous insulins was examined in vitro. These data demonstrate that pork insulin stimulates both primed helper T cells and dominant suppressor T cells in all nonresponder strains tested. Thus, the nonresponder phenotype is attributed to the activation of specific suppressor T cells rather than to an absence of helper T cell activity. Examination of the antigenic cross-reactivity patterns of pork insulin-primed helper and suppressor T cells in various strains demonstrates that fine specificity of the helper T cells differs from that of the suppressor T cells and that the patterns of antigenic cross-reactivity of these subpopulations are controlled by the H-2 gene complex. Furthermore, in a given strain of mice variants of insulin that stimulate helper T cells that cross-react with mouse insulin also stimulate dominant suppressor T cells that cross-react with mouse insulin. Such variants of insulin are perceived as nonimmunogenic. These observations raise the possibility that nonresponsiveness that is controlled by H-2 linked genes results from the activation of regulatory mechanisms involved in maintaining self-tolerance.     

LPS regulation of the immune response: suppression of immune responses to orally administered T-independent antigen

The regulation of immune responses to gastrically administered TI antigens has been investigated, and the characterization of a regulatory cell population has been performed. Intragastric administration of TNP-haptenated homologous erythrocytes (TNP-MRBC) induced splenic IgM anti-TNP PFC responses in LPS nonresponsive C3H/HeJ mice that were higher than those in LPS-responsive C3H/HeN mice and similar to those noted in athymic (nu/nu) C3H/HeN animals. The simultaneous intragastric administration of LPS with TNP-MRBC augmented immune responses in a manner similar to that previously reported for parenterally administered LPS and antigen. Further, LPS-induced augmentation of TNP-MRBC responses was greater in athymic mice. These findings were substantiated using in vitro spleen cultures. Intragastric challenge with a 2nd TI antigen, TNP-LPS, induced approximately 8-fold higher splenic anti-TNP PFC responses in athymic C3H/HeN mice compared with those in euthymic littermates. By admixture of B and T cell populations, it was demonstrated that the host responsiveness to TNP-LPS was negatively regulated by suppressor cells. Suppressive activity resided in a Thy 1.2-bearing, irradiation-resistant, nylon wool-nonadherent cell population. These cells could be demonstrated in spleen and Peyer's patches from young or old LPS-responsive C3H/HeN mice, but not in tissues from LPS nonresponsive C3H/HeJ mice. The specificity of the regulator cells was not limited to TNP-LPS responses, since immune responsiveness to another TI antigen, TNP-dextran, was also under the control of this cell population. These studies confirm the TI nature of TNP-MRBC and indicate that immune responses to gastrically administered antigens such as TNP-LPS, TNP-dextran, and possibly TNP-MRBC are negatively regulated by a suppressor T cell population. A role for endogenous LPS in the generation of regulator cells and the effect of these cells on host responses to gut-derived antigens is discussed.     

Bovine and human insulin activate CD8+-autoreactive CTL expressing both type 1 and type 2 cytokines in C57BL/6 mice

CD8+ T cells down-regulate a variety of immune responses. For example, porcine and human insulin do not stimulate Abs in C57BL/6 mice because CD8+ T cells inhibit CD4+ helper T cells. By contrast, bovine insulin induces Ab in C57BL/6 mice, and removal of CD8+ T cells does not alter this response. This raises the question of whether porcine, but not bovine, insulin activates CD8+ T cells or whether both insulins activate CD8+ T cells but CD4+ helper T cells are differentially inhibited by them. In this study, we show that insulin-specific CD8+ CTL can be cultured from C57BL/6 mice primed with either bovine or human insulin in CFA. Thus, exogenous Ags, besides OVA, induce CD8+ CTL when administered in an adjuvant, suggesting this is a typical response. These CTL are H-2Kb restricted and produce IL-5, IL-10, IFN-gamma, and small amounts of IL-4, which is distinct from IFN-gamma and TNF-alpha that are typically secreted by virus-specific CTL. Moreover, the CTL primed with either bovine or human insulin recognize an A-chain peptide that is identical to the mouse insulin sequence. That foreign proteins, which are closely related to self-proteins, activated autoreactive, CD8+ T cells in vivo is a novel finding. It raises the possibility that self-reactive CTL may be activated by cross-reacting Ags and once activated they might participate in autoimmunity. These results also suggest that down-regulation of insulin-specific responses by autoreactive CD8+ T cells is most likely due to the differential sensitivity of bovine and human insulin-specific CD4+ T cells.     

Insulin-specific suppressor T cell factors

Murine antibody responses to heterologous insulins are controlled by MHC-linked immune response genes. Although nonresponder mice fail to make antibody when injected with nonimmunogenic variants of insulin, we have recently shown that nonimmunogenic variants stimulate radioresistant, Lyt- 1+2- helper T cells that support secondary antibody responses. However, the helper activity can not be detected unless dominant, radiosensitive Lyt-1-2+, I-J+ suppressor T cells are removed. In this paper we report that extracts of primed Lyt-2+ suppressor T cells contain insulin-specific suppressor factors (TsF) that are capable of replacing the activity of suppressor T cells in vitro. The activity of these factors is restricted by MHC-linked genes that map to the I-J region, and immunoadsorption studies indicated that they bind antigen and bear I-J-encoded determinants. Insulin-specific TsF consists of at least two chains, one-bearing I-J and the other the antigen-binding site. Furthermore, mixing of isolated chains from different strains of mice indicates that the antigenic specificity is determined by the antigen-binding chain and the MHC restriction by the H-2 haplotype of the source of the non-antigen-binding, I-J+ chain. Moreover, mixtures containing antigen-binding chain from allogeneic cell donors and I-J+ chain from responder cell donors have activity in cultures containing responder lymphocytes. This suggests that preferential activation of suppressor T cells, rather than differential sensitivity to suppression, results in the nonresponder phenotype to insulin.     

Age-associated decline in responses of na?ve T cells to in vitro immunization reflects shift in glucocorticoid sensitivity.

Na?ve T lymphocytes from young mice can be immunized to protein antigens in vitro if the initial exposure to antigen is followed by a brief period of clonal expansion in the presence of both the glucocorticoid dexamethasone (at 10(-8) M) and antibodies to Interleukin-10 (IL-10). These cultures produce cell lines that respond to antigen rechallenge by proliferation and cytokine secretion. T cells from older mice, however, do not respond under these conditions unless the dexamethasone concentration is raised to levels (10(-7) M) that are inhibitory for T cells of young mice. Suitably timed exposure to dexamethasone can also increase proliferative responses to polyclonal activation via the CD3 component of the T cell receptor, and again optimal responses are obtained from old mice only at steroid concentrations that are super-optimal for young T cells. Diminished sensitivity to glucocorticoid effects may contribute to the poor responses of aged mice to novel immunogens.     

The suppression of insulin-specific immune responses by the administration of insulin-derivatized syngeneic cells and soluble lysates from these cells

The results of this study demonstrated that the i.v. administration of insulin, in the form of a conjugate with either syngeneic spleen cells (SC) or peritoneal exudate cells (PEC), markedly reduced the capacity of recipient mice to develop insulin-specific immune responses, as manifested by diminished in vivo IgE antibody production and by depressed in vitro, lymph node cell proliferation responses, respectively. Furthermore, it was shown that i.v. injection of insulin-PEC conjugates induced the activation of suppressor cells that had the capacity to downregulate insulin-specific IgG plaque-forming cell (PFC) responses. Finally, it was also determined that freezing and thawing of the insulin-PEC conjugates resulted in the release of a soluble tolerogenic molecule and/or membrane preparation that could also markedly depress insulin-specific IgG antibody production.     

Cutting edge: germinal centers can be induced in the absence of T cells.

Immunization of mice containing mutations that inactivate the TCR Cbeta and Cdelta genes with the T cell-independent (TI) type 2 Ag (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl-Ficoll induces clusters of peanut agglutinin-binding B cells in the spleen. These clusters are histologically indistinguishable from germinal centers (GCs) typical of T cell-dependent immune responses. They are located in follicles, and contain mature follicular dendritic cells, immune complex deposits, and B cells that display the phenotypic qualities of conventional GC B cells. However, the kinetics of this TI GC response differ from T cell-dependent GC responses in being rapidly induced and of short duration. Moreover, the Ab V genes expressed in TI GCs have not undergone somatic hypermutation. Therefore, T cells may be required for B cell differentiation processes associated with the intermediate and latter stages of the GC reaction, but they are dispensable for the induction and initial development of this response.     

Effects of deoxycoformycin in mice. I. Suppression and enhancement of in vivo antibody responses to thymus-dependent and -independent antigens

The effect of 2'-deoxycoformycin (DCF) on the PFC responses of AKR mice to SE, TNP-Ficoll, and TNP-B. abortus was examined. Subcutaneous injection of DCF 4 days before antigen caused suppression of all three responses by 70 to 78%. In contrast, injection of DCF 1 day after antigen caused enhancement of both the anti-SE and the anti-TNP-Ficoll responses. Although a single high dose of cortisone acetate injected 4 days before antigen caused a similar suppression, the effect of DCF was not mediated via a steroid release, inasmuch as DCF also suppressed the immune response in adrenalectomized mice. The response of BALB/c mice to TNP-Ficoll was also inhibited by DCF pretreatment and enhanced by injection of DCF after antigen. In contrast, in athymic mice DCF caused suppression of the anti-TNP-Ficoll PFC response, whether injected before or after antigen. These results are interpreted as suggesting that DCF causes suppression primarily via an effect on B cells. The enhancement seen in normal but not in athymic mice may possibly be ascribed to an effect on suppressor T cells. Apparently the enhancement of both TD and TI responses caused by DCF injected 1 day after antigen in normal mice is the net result of these two opposing effects. The results imply that helper T cells are resistant to DCF.     

Immune response to phosphorylcholine. VII. Functional evidence for three separate B cell subpopulations responding to TI and TD PC-antigens

A T-independent PC antigen, the C-polysaccharide, was used to induce a primary response to PC in splenic foci containing precursors taken from normal, unprimed BALB/c mice. The precursor frequency for the TI response was compared with the frequency for a T-dependent PC antigen, PPC-TGG-Hy. Idiotype analysis of the precursors for TD and TI responses indicate that the TD responses are more diverse with respect to clonal dominance of idiotype, TEPC-15, than that of TI responses. If splenic fragments were doubly immunized with both TI and TD antigens, the combined PC-specific precursor frequency was superadditive. TD-antigen-induced responses were found resistant to tolerogen and anti-idiotype suppression, whereas TI responses were extremely sensitive to both manipulations. Since under limiting dilution conditions precursors sort out independently, the superadditive response seen in dual immunized fragments can only be interpreted as evidence for an additional subpopulation of B cells that responds to the combined signals of TD and TI antigens. This postulated third B cell population is also extremely sensitive to tolerogen and anti-idiotype suppression.     

Functions of accessory cells in B cell responses to thymus-independent antigens

The functions of adherent accessory (A) cells in thymus-independent (TI) B cell activation were investigated using homogeneous A cell lines with distinct cell surface and functional characteristics, as well as inhibitors of antigen processing and interleukin 1 (IL 1) secretion. B cell responses to both type 1 and type 2 TI antigens were found to be strictly A cell dependent. Only A cells capable of IL 1 secretion could restore responsiveness in A cell-depleted spleen cells, regardless of Ia expression or antigen-processing capability. Moreover, recombinant IL 1 completely replaced A cell function in B cell responses to both TI 1 and TI 2 antigens. Finally, T cell depletion did not diminish the reconstitution by IL 1. Thus in contrast to T cell activation, IL 1 secretion is the only A cell function required in TI B cell activation, and the data are consistent with a direct role for IL 1 in B cell activation.     

Insulin-specific tolerance induction. II. Tolerant helper T cells can be rescued by insulin complexed to Brucella abortus

Murine antibody responses to heterologous insulins are under H-2-linked immune response (Ir) gene control. We previously demonstrated that the immune response to insulin in Freund's complete adjuvant (CFA) can be specifically inhibited by prior injection of soluble insulin i.v. Unresponsiveness requires at least 4 days after i.v. injection to develop, and once induced, it lasts 4 wk or more. Unresponsiveness is caused by T cell, but not B cell, tolerance; furthermore, we have been unable to demonstrate any role for suppressor T cells in this unresponsiveness. The following experiments examine the nature of the T cell tolerance induced by i.v. injection of insulin, and the data suggest that helper T cells were not clonally deleted by this procedure. The functional activity of the tolerized T cells can be rescued by stimulation with insulin covalently complexed to the type 1 T-independent (TI-1) antigen, Brucella abortus. This observation suggests that tolerance induced by soluble insulin is due to clonal anergy rather than clonal deletion of helper T cells; thus, this system could provide a model for determining the cellular events involved in tolerance induction and reversal in helper T cells.     

Regulation of antibody response in different immunoglobulin classes. II. Induction of in vitro IgE antibody response in murine spleen cells and demonstration of a possible involvement of distinct T-helper cells in IgE and IgG antibody responses.

In vitro induction of anti-DNP IgE as well as IgG1, IgG2a antibody responses was shown in murine spleen cell culture. Spleen cells primed three times with 1 mug of DNP-OA or DNP-Asc produced significant amounts of anti-DNP IgE as well as IgG antibodies by the in vitro stimulation with DNP-OA or DNP-Asc, respectively. Collaboration between DNP-primed B cells and carrier-primed T cells was required for the induction of both IgE and IgG antibodies with DNP-coupled T-dependent antigen. Carrier-specific T cells induced with a low dose of Asc (0.01 mug) showed helper function only on IgE antibody response, whereas T cells primed with a higher dose of Asc (10 mug) cooperated only with IgG-B cells. T cells primed with Asc in CFA showed helper function mainly on IgG antibody response but not on IgE antibody response. The result indicated the presence of a distinct population of T helper cells for IgE and IgG antibody responses. T-independent antigen (DNP-Ficoll) induced both anti-DNP IgE and IgG antibody responses in DNP-primed spleen cell population without the requirement of the collaboration of helper T cells.     

The role of CD40-CD154 interaction in antiviral T cell-independent IgG responses

Polyomavirus (PyV) infection elicits protective T cell-independent (TI) IgG responses in T cell-deficient mice. The question addressed in this report is whether CD40 signaling plays a role in this TI antiviral IgG response. Because CD40 ligand (CD40L) can be expressed on numerous cell types in addition to activated T cells, it is possible that cells other than T cells provide CD40L to signal through CD40 on B cells and hence positively influence the antiviral TI IgG responses. In this study we show, by blocking CD40-CD40L interactions in vivo with anti-CD40L Ab treatment in TCR betaxdelta-/- mice and by using SCID mice reconstituted with CD40-/- B cells, that the lack of CD40 signaling in B cells results in a 50% decrease in TI IgG secreted in response to PyV. SCID mice reconstituted with CD40L-/- B cells also responded to PyV infection with diminished IgG secretion compared with that of SCID mice reconstituted with wild-type B cells. This finding suggests that B cells may provide the CD40L for CD40 signaling in the absence of T cell help during acute virus infection. Our studies demonstrate that, although about half of the TI IgG responses to PyV are independent of CD40-CD40L interactions, these interactions occur in T cell-deficient mice and enhance antiviral TI Ab responses.     

Selective effect of irradiation on responses to thymus-independent antigen

Low doses of ionizing radiation have a selective immunosuppressive effect on in vivo B cell responses to thymus-independent (TI) antigens. The B cell response, assayed as direct anti-trinitrophenyl (TNP)-specific plaque-forming cells (PFC), induced by type 2, TI antigens (TNP-Ficoll or TNP-Dextran), was reduced, on the average, by 10-fold in animals exposed to 200 rad of ionizing radiation 24 hr before antigen challenge. In contrast, PFC responses to type 1, TI antigens (TNP-lipopolysaccharide or TNP-Brucella abortus) are unaffected in mice exposed to the same dose of radiation. Adoptive transfers showed that this selective immunosuppression is a result of the specific inactivation of the B cell subpopulation responding to type 2, TI antigens. These experiments suggest that physiologic differences exist in the B cell subpopulations of normal mice which respond to type 1, or type 2, TI antigens.