Hydrophobic mismatch between helices and lipid bilayers

alpha-Helical transmembrane peptides, named WALP, with a hydrophobic sequence of leucine and alanine of varying length bordered at both ends by two tryptophans as membrane anchors, were synthesized to study the effect of hydrophobic matching in lipid bilayers. WALPs of 13-, 16-, and 19-residues were incorporated into 1,2-dilauroyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (12C), 1,2-tridecanoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (13C), and 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (14C) bilayers in the form of oriented multilayers. Oriented circular dichroism spectra and x-ray diffraction patterns showed that the peptides were homogenously distributed in the lipid bilayers with the helical axes oriented approximately normal to the plane of bilayers. But in all cases, x-ray diffraction showed that the peptides did not alter the thickness of the bilayer. This is contrary to the case of gramicidin where 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine and 1,2-dilauroyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine clearly thinned and thickened, respectively, to approach the hydrophobic thickness of the gramicidin channels. The result seems to indicate that the packing of lipid chains around a single helix is fundamentally different from the way the chains pack against a large protein surface.     

Structure of gramicidin A.

Gramicidin A, a hydrophobic linear polypeptide, forms channels in phospholipid membranes that are specific for monovalent cations. Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) spectroscopy provided the first direct physical evidence that the channel conformation in membranes is an amino terminal-to-amino terminal helical dimer, and circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy has shown the sensitivity of its conformation to different environments and the structural consequences of ion binding. The three-dimensional structure of a gramicidin/cesium complex has been determined by x-ray diffraction of single crystals using single wavelength anomalous scattering for phasing. The left-handed double helix in this crystal form corresponds to one of the intermediates in the process of folding and insertion into membranes. Co-crystals of gramicidin and lipid that appear to have gramicidin in their membrane channel conformation have also been formed and are presently under investigation. Hence, we have used a combination of spectroscopic and diffraction techniques to examine the conformation and functionally-related structural features of gramicidin A.     

On the helix sense of gramicidin A single channels.

In order to resolve whether gramicidin A channels are formed by right- or left-handed beta-helices, we synthesized an optically reversed (or mirror image) analogue of gramicidin A, called gramicidin A-, to test whether it forms channels that have the same handedness as channels formed by gramicidin M- (F. Heitz et al., Biophys. J. 40:87-89, 1982). In gramicidin M- the four tryptophan residues have been replaced with phenylalanine, and the circular dichroism (CD) spectrum therefore reflects almost exclusively contributions from the polypeptide backbone. The CD spectrum of gramicidin M- in dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine vesicles is consistent with a left-handed helical backbone folding motif (F. Heitz et al., Biophys. Chem. 24:149-160, 1986), and the CD spectra of gramicidins A and A- are essentially mirror images of each other. Based on hybrid channel experiments, gramicidin A- and M- channels are structurally equivalent, while gramicidin A and A- channels are nonequivalent, being of opposite helix sense. Gramicidin A- channels are therefore left-handed, and natural gramicidin A channels in phospholipid bilayers are right-handed beta 6.3-helical dimers.     

The effects of bilayer thickness and tension on gramicidin single-channel lifetime

Measurements have been made of gramicidin single-channel lifetimes in monoacylglycerol bilayers chosen so that their thickness ranged from above to below the length of the gramicidin channel. Contact angles, electrical capacities and bulk-phase interfacial tensions have also been determined for these systems. The mean channel lifetime decreased with the hydrocarbon thickness of the membrane until the latter reached 2.2 nm, after which the lifetime was relatively constant. A theoretical model has been proposed which relates the mean channel lifetime (or dissociation constant) to both the thickness and the tension of the bilayers. The analysis of the present results and of those of previous studies has led to the idea that aggregates of water molecules may play an important r?le in the dissociation of the gramicidin channel.     

Gramicidin conformational studies with mixed-chain unsaturated phospholipid bilayer systems.

The transition of gramicidin from a nonchannel to a channel form was investigated using mixed-chain phosphatidylcholine lipid bilayers. Gramicidin and phospholipids were codispersed, after removal of the solvents chloroform/methanol or trifluoroethanol which resulted in nonchannel and channel conformations, respectively, as confirmed using circular dichroism (CD). The fluorescence emission maxima of the nonchannel form were shifted toward shorter wavelengths by heating at 60 degrees C (for 0-12 h), which converted it to a channel form, again as confirmed by CD. The channel form did not respond to heat treatment. Heat treatment also increased the fluorescence anisotropy of the nonchannel gramicidin tryptophans. The rate of transition from the nonchannel to channel conformation was found to be faster if phosphatidylethanolamine was present in combination with phosphatidylcholine compared to phosphatidylcholine alone. Also, gramicidin in bilayers of the polyunsaturated 1-palmitoyl-2-docosahexaenoyl-phosphatidylcholine converted more rapidly compared to 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoylphosphatidylcholine. Using the fluorescence anisotropy of the membrane lipid probe 1,6-diphenyl-1,3,5-hexatriene, it was also shown that the motional properties of the surrounding lipid acyl chains differed for the channel and nonchannel gramicidin conformations. The possibility that lipids tending to favor the hexagonal phase (HII) would enhance the rate of the nonchannel to channel transition was supported by 31P NMR which revealed the presence of some HII lipids in the channel preparations. The results of this study suggest that gramicidin may serve as a useful model for similar conformational transitions in other more complex membrane proteins.     

The effect of gramicidin A on phospholipid bilayers

The helical polypeptide, gramicidin A has been widely studied as a model for the interactions of hydrophobic proteins with lipid bilayer membranes. Many reports are now available of the physical effects of mixing gramicidin A with phospholipid membranes, however, the interpretation of these data remains unclear. The purpose of this communication is to examine the controversial claim that high concentrations of gramicidin A cause disorder within the L phase of phosphatidylcholine-water dispersions. Solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), density gradient and X-ray diffraction techniques are used to confirm the existence of such an effect and mechanisms are discussed which account for the known effects of gramicidin A on lipid bilayers.     

Proton conduction in gramicidin A and in its dioxolane-linked dimer in different lipid bilayers.

Gramicidin A (gA) molecules were covalently linked with a dioxolane ring. Dioxolane-linked gA dimers formed ion channels, selective for monovalent cations, in planar lipid bilayers. The main goal of this study was to compare the functional single ion channel properties of natural gA and its covalently linked dimer in two different lipid bilayers and HCl concentrations (10-8000 mM). Two ion channels with different gating and conductance properties were identified in bilayers from the product of dimerization reaction. The most commonly observed and most stable gramicidin A dimer is the main object of this study. This gramicidin dimer remained in the open state most of the time, with brief closing flickers (tau(closed) approximately 30 micros). The frequency of closing flickers increased with transmembrane potential, making the mean open time moderately voltage dependent (tau(open) changed approximately 1.43-fold/100 mV). Such gating behavior is markedly different from what is seen in natural gA channels. In PEPC (phosphatidylethanolamine-phosphatidylcholine) bilayers, single-channel current-voltage relationships had an ohmic behavior at low voltages, and a marked sublinearity at relatively higher voltages. This behavior contrasts with what was previously described in GMO (glycerylmonooleate) bilayers. In PEPC bilayers, the linear conductance of single-channel proton currents at different proton concentrations was essentially the same for both natural and gA dimers. g(max) and K(D), obtained from fitting experimental points to a Langmuir adsorption isotherm, were approximately 1500 pS and 300 mM, respectively, for both the natural gA and its dimer. In GMO bilayers, however, proton affinities of gA and the dioxolane-dimer were significantly lower (K(D) of approximately 1 and 1.5 M, respectively), and the g(max) higher (approximately 1750 and 2150 pS, respectively) than in PEPC bilayers. Furthermore, the relationship between single-channel conductance and proton concentration was linear at low bulk concentrations of H+ (0.01-2 M) and saturated at concentrations of more than 3 M. It is concluded that 1) The mobility of protons in gramicidin A channels in different lipid bilayers is remarkably similar to proton mobilities in aqueous solutions. In particular, at high concentrations of HCl, proton mobilities in gramicidin A channel and in solution differ by only 25%. 2) Differences between proton conductances in gramicidin A channels in GMO and PEPC cannot be explained by surface charge effects on PEPC membranes. It is proposed that protonated phospholipids adjacent to the mouth of the pore act as an additional source of protons for conduction through gA channels in relation to GMO bilayers. 3) Some experimental results cannot be reconciled with simple alterations in access resistance to proton flow in gA channels. Said differences could be explained if the structure and/or dynamics of water molecules inside gramicidin A channels is modulated by the lipid environment and by modifications in the structure of gA channels. 4) The dioxolane ring is probably responsible for the closing flickers seen in the dimer channel. However, other factors can also influence closing flickers.     

Stability of an ion channel in lipid bilayers: implicit solvent model calculations with gramicidin

Gramicidin is a helical peptide, 15 residues in length, which dimerizes to form ion-conducting channels in lipid bilayers. Here we report calculations of its free energy of transfer from the aqueous phase into bilayers of different widths. The electrostatic and nonpolar contributions to the desolvation free energy were calculated using implicit solvent models, in which gramicidin was described in atomic detail and the hydrocarbon region of the membrane was described as a slab of hydrophobic medium embedded in water. The free energy penalties from the lipid perturbation and membrane deformation effects, and the entropy loss associated with gramicidin immobilization in the bilayer, were estimated from a statistical thermodynamic model of the bilayer. The calculations were carried out using two classes of experimentally observed conformations: a head-to-head dimer of two single-stranded (SS) beta-helices and a double-stranded (DS) intertwined double helix. The calculations showed that gramicidin is likely to partition into the bilayer in all of these conformations. However, the SS conformation was found to be significantly more stable than the DS in the bilayer, in agreement with most of the experimental data. We tested numerous transmembrane and surface orientations of gramicidin in bilayers of various widths. Our calculations indicate that the most favorable orientation is transmembrane, which is indeed to be expected from a channel-forming peptide. The calculations demonstrate that gramicidin insertion into the membrane is likely to involve a significant deformation of the bilayer to match the hydrophobic width of the peptide (22 A), again in good agreement with experimental data. Interestingly, deformation of the bilayer was induced by all of the gramicidin conformations.     

Water permeation through gramicidin A: desformylation and the double helix: a molecular dynamics study

Multinanosecond molecular dynamics simulations of gramicidin A embedded in a dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine bilayer show a remarkable structural stability for both experimentally determined conformations: the head-to-head helical dimer and the double helix. Water permeability was found to be much higher in the double helical conformation, which is explained by lower hydrogen bond-mediated enthalpic barriers at the channel entrance and its larger pore size. Free-energy perturbation calculations show that the double helical structure is stabilized by the positive charges at the N termini introduced by the desformylation, whereas the helical dimer is destabilized. Together with the recent experimental observation that desformyl gramicidin conducts water hundredfold better than gramicidin, this suggests that desformyl gramicidin A predominantly occurs in the double helical conformation.     

Extraction of K<Superscript>+</Superscript> Selective Channels from Excitable Tissue

ALTHOUGH the existence of ion conductance channels in excitable tissues is strongly suspected¹, there has been no way of measuring the occurrence of such channels in extracts of nerve or brain until the advent of lipid bilayer techniques², improved to the extent of allowing detection of a few channels³. The observation⁴ of ion channel formation in lipid bilayers by gramicidin A and its elucidation as a helical peptide structure^5,6 has prompted the search for substances of similar properties in extracts of nervous tissue. This is made more plausible by the fact that the channel conductance Δ(Na⁺) for the alkyldiamide derivatives of gramicidin is close to the value of 2 × 10^?10, which was estimated for nerve on pharmacological grounds⁷.     

The temperature dependence of gramicidin conformational States in octanol

In lipid bilayers and organic solvents, the hydrophobic polypeptide gramicidin adopts a number of different conformations, some of which are capable of conducting monovalent cations across phospholipid membranes. The equilibria between conformations have been shown to be influenced by factors such as lipid chain length, solvent, concentration and salt. In this study, the temperature dependence of the equilibrium mixture of double helical ion-free gramicidin in octanol was examined using circular dichroism spectroscopy.     

Sterol specific inactivation of gramicidin A induced membrane cation permeability.

Channel inactivation, a time-dependent decrease of the high-cationic permeability induced by gramicidin A, has been found both in cholesterol containing red blood cell membranes and lipid bilayers (Schagina et al., (1989) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 978, 145-150). The rate of channel inactivation strongly depends on the phospholipid to cholesterol molar ratio of the membrane. The channel inactivation is suggested to be the result of an interaction between gramicidin and cholesterol in a stoichiometry of 1:5. Cholesterol dependent inactivation is shown also for gramicidin A analogs: tryptophan-N-formylated gramicidin A, o-pyromellitilgramicidin and malonylbisdesformylgramicidin. When cholesterol in the membrane is substituted by sitosterol, the inactivation of gramicidin-induced cation permeability is preserved, while in the presence of either ergosterol or 7-dehydrocholesterol no indication of the channel inactivation is observed. Thus, the structure of the 'B', ring, not the apolar tail of the sterol molecule, appears to be important in the inactivation process.     

Deuterium NMR of Val1...(2-2H)Ala3...gramicidin A in oriented DMPC bilayers.

Deuterium NMR is used to study the selectively labeled Val1...(2-2H)Ala3...gramicidin A molecule to investigate the structure and dynamics of the C alpha-2H bond in the Ala3 residue of gramicidin. Val1...(2-2H)Ala3...gramicidin A is synthesized, purified, and characterized and then incorporated into oriented bilayers of dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine sandwiched between glass coverslips. Phosphorus NMR line shapes obtained from this sample are consistent with the presence of the bilayer phase and indicate that no nonbilayer phases are present in significant amounts. Deuterium NMR line shapes obtained from this sample indicate that the motional axis of the gramicidin Ala3 residue is parallel to the coverslip normal, that the distribution of motional axis orientations has a width of 2 degrees, and that only one major conformational and dynamical state of the Ala3 C alpha-2H bond is observed on the NMR time scale. Furthermore, the Ala3 C alpha-2H bond angle relative to the motional axis is 19-20 degrees if fast axial rotation is assumed to be the only motion present but is less than or equal to 19-20 degrees in the absence of such an assumption. This result indicates that various double-stranded, helical dimer models are very unlikely to represent the structure of gramicidin in the sample studied but that the single-stranded, beta 6.3 helical dimer models are consistent with the experimental data. However, a definitive distinction between the left-handed, single-stranded, beta 6.3 helical dimer model and the right-handed, single-stranded, beta 6.3 helical dimer model cannot be made on the basis of the experimental data obtained in this study.     

Structural Polymorphism of Gramicidin A Channels: Ion Conductivity and Spectral Studies

The relation between the various spatial structures of the gramicidin A channels and their ionic conductance has been studied. For this aim, various conformations of the peptide were pre-formed in liposomal bilayer and after subsequent fusion of liposomes with planar lipid bilayer the measured channel conductance was correlated with gramicidin structures established in liposomes. To form the single-stranded π6.3π 6.3 helix the peptide and lipid were co-dissolved in TFE prior to liposome preparation. THF and other solvents were used to form parallel (↑ ↑ π π) and antiparallel (↑ ↓ π π) double helices. Conformation of gramicidin in liposomes made by various phosphatidylcholines was monitored by CD spectroscopy, and computer analysis of the spectra obtained was performed. After fusion of gramicidin containing liposomes with planar bilayer membranes from asolectin, the histograms of single-channel conductance were obtained. The histograms had one or three distinct peaks depending on the liposome preparation. Assignment of the structure of the channel to conductance levels was made by correlation of CD data with conductance histograms. The channel-forming analogue, des(Trp-Leu)₂-gramicidin A, has been studied by the same protocol. The channel conductances of gramicidin A and the shortened analogue increase in the following order: ↑ ↓ π π 2 ↑ ↑ π π < π 6.3π6.3. Single-channels formed by double helices have higher dispersity of conductance than the π6.3π6.3 helical channel. Lifetimes of the double helical and the π6.3π6.3 helical channels are very close to each other. The data obtained were compared with theoretically predicted properties of double helices [1].     

Tryptophan contributions to the empirical free-energy profile in gramicidin A/M heterodimer channels

Gramicidin A/gramicidin M heterodimer conductances were measured in planar lipid bilayers and found to form two distinguishable populations about halfway between the gramicidin A and gramicidin M homodimer conductances. This implies that the principle difference in the gramicidin A and gramicidin M transport free-energy profiles occurs at the channel center, where it would produce similar effects on the rate-limiting barrier for the two heterodimers. Kinetic analysis based on this and nearly all previously published homodimer conductance data for both gramicidin A and gramicidin M channels confirms this conclusion, indicating that the translocation step is approximately 100-fold slower in gramicidin M homodimers than in gramicidin A homodimers and that first- and second-ion exit-rate constants are higher by factors of 24 and 10, respectively. Assuming that the ratios of rate constants are related to the free-energy difference between gramicidin A and gramicidin M, we construct an effective ion-Trp free-energy interaction profile that has a minimum at the channel center.     

Ion channels formed by chemical analogs of gramicidin A.

Channel-forming peptides such as gramicidin A offer the opportunity to study the relationship between chemical structure and transport properties of an ion channel. This article summarizes a number of recent experiments with chemical analogs and derivatives of gramicidin A using artificial lipid bilayer membranes. The introduction of negative charges near the channel mouth leads to an increase in the cation transport rate. Hybrid channels consisting of a neutral and a negatively charged or of a positively and a negatively charged half-channel may be formed. The current-voltage characteristic of these hybrid channels exhibits a pronounced asymmetry.Experiments with charged derivatives of gramicidin A have been used in order to distinguish between different structural models of the dimeric channel; these studies strongly support Urry's model of a single-stranded, head-to-head associated helical dimer. In a further set of experiments gramicidin analogs with modified amino acid sequence were studied. It was found that a single substitution (tryptophan replaced by phenylalanine) leads to marked changes in the conductance of the channel. Analogs with a simplified amino acid sequence such as (L-Trp-D-Leu)7-L-Trp or L-Trp-Gly-(L-Trp-D-Leu)6-L-Trp are able to form cation permeable channels with similar properties as gramicidin A.     

Gramicidin channels that have no tryptophan residues.

In order to understand how aromatic residues modulate the function of membrane-spanning proteins, we examined the role of the four tryptophans in gramicidin A (gA) in determining the average duration and permeability characteristics of membrane-spanning gramicidin channels; the tryptophan residues were replaced by tyrosine (gramicidin T, gT), tyrosine O-benzyl ether [gramicidin T(Bzl), gT(Bzl)], naphthylalanine (gramicidin N, gN), and phenylalanine (gramicidin M enantiomer, gM-). These analogues form channels with durations and conductances that differ some 10- and 16-fold, respectively. The single-channel conductance was invariably decreased by the Trp----Yyy replacement, and the relative conductance alterations were similar in phosphatidylcholine (DPhPC) and monoglyceride (GMO) bilayers. The duration variations exhibited a more complex pattern, which was quite different in the two membrane environments: in DPhPC bilayers, gN channels have an average duration that is approximately 2-fold longer than that of gA channels; in GMO bilayers, the average duration of gN channels is about one-tenth that of gA channels. The sequence-dependent alterations in channel function do not result from alterations in the channels' peptide backbone structure, because heterodimers can form between the different analogues and gramicidine A, and there is no energetic cost associated with heterodimer formation [cf. Durkin, J. T., Koeppe, R. E., II, & Andersen, O. S. (1990) J. Mol. Biol. 211, 221]. The alterations in permeability properties are consistent with the notion that Trp residues alter the energy profile for ion permeation through long-range electrostatic interactions.     

Induction of conductance heterogeneity in gramicidin channels

In previous work from our laboratory, 5-10% of the channels formed by [Val1]gramicidin A have conductances that fall outside the narrow range that conventionally has defined the standard gramicidin channel [e.g., see Russell et al. (1986) Biophys. J. 49, 673]. Reports from other laboratories, however, show that up to 50% of [Val1]gramicidin channels have conductances that fall outside the range for standard channels [e.g., see Prasad et al. (1986) Biochemistry 25, 456]. This laboratory-to-laboratory variation in the distribution of gramicidin single-channel conductances suggests that the conductance variants are induced by some environmental factor(s) [Busath et al. (1987) Biophys. J. 51, 79]. In order to test whether extrinsic agents can induce such conductance heterogeneity, we examined the effects of nonionic or zwitterionic detergents upon gramicidin channel behavior. In phospholipid bilayers, detergent addition induces many changes in gramicidin channel behavior: all detergents tested increase the channel appearance rate and average duration; most detergents decrease the conductance of the standard channel; and all but one of the detergents increase the conductance heterogeneity. These results show that the conductance heterogeneity can result from environmental perturbations, thus providing a possible explanation for the laboratory-to-laboratory variation in the heterogeneity of gramicidin channels. In addition, the differential detergent effects suggest possible mechanisms by which detergents can induce the conformational perturbations that result in gramicidin single-channel conductance variations.     

Membrane-thinning effect of curcumin

Interaction of curcumin with lipid bilayers is not well understood. A recent experiment showed that curcumin significantly affected the single-channel lifetime of gramicidin in a 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DOPC) bilayer without affecting its single-channel conductance. We performed two experiments to understand this result. By isothermal titration calorimetry, we measured the partition coefficient of curcumin binding to DOPC bilayers. By x-ray lamellar diffraction, we measured the thickness change of DOPC bilayers as a function of the curcumin/lipid ratio. A nonlinear membrane-thinning effect by curcumin was discovered. The gramicidin data were qualitatively interpreted by the combination of isothermal titration calorimetry and x-ray results. We show that not only does curcumin thin the lipid bilayer, it might also weaken its elasticity moduli. The result implies that curcumin may affect the function of membrane proteins by modifying the properties of the host membrane.     

Ultraviolet flash photolysis of gramicidin-doped lipid bilayers

We have examined the rate of gramicidin channel conductance inactivation by ultraviolet photolysis using 0.1 millisecond light flashes. The lower limit on the channel photolysis reaction rate has been reduced by four orders of magnitude over previous observations. Monoolein/hexadecane bilayers formed in 1.0 M KCl were doped with (1-3) x 10(6) gramicidin A' channels and exposed to a broad-spectrum light flash. The flash reduced membrane conductance abruptly by approx. 16%. Following the flash, a further slow reduction of approx. 3% was observed followed by a slow recovery of approx. 4%. The post-flash decay and recovery may be due to slow chemical reactions, conformational relaxations, or changes in the equilibrium between aqueous, lipid-bound, and channel-forming dimerized gramicidin. Under our experimental conditions, gramicidin M was insensitive to light flashes compared to gramicidin A', demonstrating that for gramicidin A' the photolysis mechanism depends specifically on the tryptophan side-chain. Flash photolysis of a membrane containing a small population of channels (approx. 30) indicated that the decay is due to the sudden inactivation of several channels. The recovery appears to result from insertion of normal channels into the membrane. Flash photolysis of single-channel membranes showed that the flash causes abrupt, complete channel inactivation.