Methylobacterium Genome Sequences: A Reference Blueprint to Investigate Microbial Metabolism of C1 Compounds from Natural and Industrial Sources

Background

Methylotrophy describes the ability of organisms to grow on reduced organic compounds without carbon-carbon bonds. The genomes of two pink-pigmented facultative methylotrophic bacteria of the Alpha-proteobacterial genus Methylobacterium, the reference species Methylobacterium extorquens strain AM1 and the dichloromethane-degrading strain DM4, were compared.

Methodology/Principal Findings

The 6.88 Mb genome of strain AM1 comprises a 5.51 Mb chromosome, a 1.26 Mb megaplasmid and three plasmids, while the 6.12 Mb genome of strain DM4 features a 5.94 Mb chromosome and two plasmids. The chromosomes are highly syntenic and share a large majority of genes, while plasmids are mostly strain-specific, with the exception of a 130 kb region of the strain AM1 megaplasmid which is syntenic to a chromosomal region of strain DM4. Both genomes contain large sets of insertion elements, many of them strain-specific, suggesting an important potential for genomic plasticity. Most of the genomic determinants associated with methylotrophy are nearly identical, with two exceptions that illustrate the metabolic and genomic versatility of Methylobacterium. A 126 kb dichloromethane utilization (dcm) gene cluster is essential for the ability of strain DM4 to use DCM as the sole carbon and energy source for growth and is unique to strain DM4. The methylamine utilization (mau) gene cluster is only found in strain AM1, indicating that strain DM4 employs an alternative system for growth with methylamine. The dcm and mau clusters represent two of the chromosomal genomic islands (AM1: 28; DM4: 17) that were defined. The mau cluster is flanked by mobile elements, but the dcm cluster disrupts a gene annotated as chelatase and for which we propose the name “island integration determinant” (iid).

Conclusion/Significance

These two genome sequences provide a platform for intra- and interspecies genomic comparisons in the genus Methylobacterium, and for investigations of the adaptive mechanisms which allow bacterial lineages to acquire methylotrophic lifestyles.     

Effects of Bacterial Host and Dichloromethane Dehalogenase on the Competitiveness of Methylotrophic Bacteria Growing with Dichloromethane

Methylobacterium sp. strain DM4 and Methylophilus sp. strain DM11 can grow with dichloromethane (DCM) as the sole source of carbon and energy by virtue of homologous glutathione-dependent DCM dehalogenases with markedly different kinetic properties (the k_cat values of the enzymes of these strains are 0.6 and 3.3 s⁻¹, respectively, and the K_m values are 9 and 59 μM, respectively). These strains, as well as transconjugant bacteria expressing the DCM dehalogenase gene (dcmA) from DM11 or DM4 on a broad-host-range plasmid in the background of dcmA mutant DM4-2cr, were investigated by growing them under growth-limiting conditions and in the presence of an excess of DCM. The maximal growth rates and maximal levels of dehalogenase for chemostat-adapted bacteria were higher than the maximal growth rates and maximal levels of dehalogenase for batch-grown bacteria. The substrate saturation constant of strain DM4 was much lower than the K_m of its associated dehalogenase, suggesting that this strain is adapted to scavenge low concentrations of DCM. Strains and transconjugants expressing the DCM dehalogenase from strain DM11, on the other hand, had higher growth rates than bacteria expressing the homologous dehalogenase from strain DM4. Competition experiments performed with pairs of DCM-degrading strains revealed that a strain expressing the dehalogenase from DM4 had a selective advantage in continuous culture under substrate-limiting conditions, while strains expressing the DM11 dehalogenase were superior in batch culture when there was an excess of substrate. Only DCM-degrading bacteria with a dcmA gene similar to that from strain DM4, however, were obtained in batch enrichment cultures prepared with activated sludge from sewage treatment plants.     

Codon Usage Methods for Horizontal Gene Transfer Detection Generate an Abundance of False Positive and False Negative Results

Bacteria acquire new DNA in a process known as horizontal gene transfer (HGT). To investigate the evolutionary impact of this transfer of DNA, various methods have been developed to detect past HGT events. For example, codon usage-based methods detect the presence of transferred genes by identifying atypical patterns of codon usage. However, some inherited genes exhibit atypical codon usage and some transferred genes have codon usage patterns similar to those of the inherited genes. In this study, we used a comparative phylogenetic approach with Methylobacterium and Caulobacter species to demonstrate that even well-designed codon usage methods fail to detect many HGT events and generate a high rate of false positives (60–75 %) and false negatives (23–61 %). Therefore, we recommend caution when employing codon usage methods to identify transferred genes and suggest that the rapidly increasing availability of bacterial genome sequences makes the phylogenetic approach the method of choice.     

Real time expression of ACC oxidase and PR-protein genes mediated by Methylobacterium spp. in tomato plants challenged with Xanthomonas campestris pv. vesicatoria

Biotic stress like pathogenic infection increases ethylene biosynthesis in plants and ethylene inhibitors are known to alleviate the severity of plant disease incidence. This study aimed to reduce the bacterial spot disease incidence in tomato plants caused by Xanthomonas campestris pv. vesicatoria (XCV) by modulating stress ethylene with 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylate (ACC) deaminase activity of Methylobacterium strains. Under greenhouse condition, Methylobacterium strains inoculated and pathogen challenged tomato plants had low ethylene emission compared to pathogen infected ones. ACC accumulation and ACC oxidase (ACO) activity with ACO related gene expression increased in XCV infected tomato plants over Methylobacterium strains inoculated plants. Among the Methylobacterium spp., CBMB12 resulted lowest ACO related gene expression (1.46 Normalized Fold Expression), whereas CBMB20 had high gene expression (3.42 Normalized Fold Expression) in pathogen challenged tomato. But a significant increase in ACO gene expression (7.09 Normalized Fold Expression) was observed in the bacterial pathogen infected plants. In contrast, Methylobacterium strains enhanced β-1,3-glucanase and phenylalanine ammonia-lyase (PAL) enzyme activities in pathogen challenged tomato plants. The respective increase in β-1,3-glucanase related gene expressions due to CBMB12, CBMB15, and CBMB20 strains were 66.3, 25.5 and 10.4% higher over pathogen infected plants. Similarly, PAL gene expression was high with 0.67 and 0.30 Normalized Fold Expression, in pathogen challenged tomato plants inoculated with CBMB12 and CBMB15 strains. The results suggest that ethylene is a crucial factor in bacterial spot disease incidence and that methylobacteria with ACC deaminase activity can reduce the disease severity with ultimate pathogenesis-related protein increase in tomato.     

Role of Intraspecies Recombination in the Spread of Pathogenicity Islands within the Escherichia coli Species

Horizontal gene transfer is a key step in the evolution of bacterial pathogens. Besides phages and plasmids, pathogenicity islands (PAIs) are subjected to horizontal transfer. The transfer mechanisms of PAIs within a certain bacterial species or between different species are still not well understood. This study is focused on the High-Pathogenicity Island (HPI), which is a PAI widely spread among extraintestinal pathogenic Escherichia coli and serves as a model for horizontal transfer of PAIs in general. We applied a phylogenetic approach using multilocus sequence typing on HPI-positive and -negative natural E. coli isolates representative of the species diversity to infer the mechanism of horizontal HPI transfer within the E. coli species. In each strain, the partial nucleotide sequences of 6 HPI–encoded genes and 6 housekeeping genes of the genomic backbone, as well as DNA fragments immediately upstream and downstream of the HPI were compared. This revealed that the HPI is not solely vertically transmitted, but that recombination of large DNA fragments beyond the HPI plays a major role in the spread of the HPI within E. coli species. In support of the results of the phylogenetic analyses, we experimentally demonstrated that HPI can be transferred between different E. coli strains by F-plasmid mediated mobilization. Sequencing of the chromosomal DNA regions immediately upstream and downstream of the HPI in the recipient strain indicated that the HPI was transferred and integrated together with HPI–flanking DNA regions of the donor strain. The results of this study demonstrate for the first time that conjugative transfer and homologous DNA recombination play a major role in horizontal transfer of a pathogenicity island within the species E. coli.     

Restoration of phenotype in Escherichia coli auxotrophs by pULB113-mediated mobilisation from methylotrophic bacteria

The plasmid pULB113 has been transferred to the facultative methylotrophs, Methylobacterium AM1 and Methylobacterium extorquens and to the obligate methanotroph Methylosinus trichosporium OB3b. Subsequent transfer from the methanotroph to the facultative methylotrophs and from the methanotroph and the facultative methylotrophs to Escherichia coli K-12 strains has been observed. In crosses from M. extorquens to restriction-deficient recombination-impaired E. coli strains, restoration of phenotype to auxotrophs was demonstrated and R-primes isolated from these recipients could transform auxotrophic strains to prototrophy.     

Aggregation of selected plant growth promoting Methylobacterium strains: role of cell surface components and hydrophobicity

The bacterial cell surface plays a major role in the bacterial aggregation that in turn plays a positive role in affecting the bacterial dispersion and survival in soil and their ability to adhere to plant surfaces. Plant growth–promoting Methylobacterium strains, Methylobacterium goesingense CBMB5, Methylobacterium sp. CBMB12, Methylobacterium oryzae CBMB20, Methylobacterium fujisawaense CBMB37, M. oryzae CBMB110 and Methylobacterium suomiense CBMB120 were evaluated for aggregation efficiency. Aggregation occurred in all test strains under high C/N growth conditions, and the strain CBMB12 showed the highest aggregation of 53.4 % at 72 h. Disaggregation compound treatment studies revealed the role of protein–protein interaction in Methylobacterium strains except CBMB110 and CBMB120 strains, where a possible carbohydrate–protein interaction is suspected. Surface layer protein extraction by LiCl followed by SDS-PAGE analysis showed the presence of proteins at molecular weights ranging from 41 to 49 kDa. Methylobacterium strains under aggregated conditions showed increased hydrophobicity compared to the cells under standard grown conditions. A relatively higher hydrophobicity of 50.1 % as evident by the adhesion with xylene was observed with strain CBMB12 under aggregated condition. This study reports the aggregation ability in plant growth–promoting Methylobacterium strains and the possible involvement of cellular components and hydrophobicity in this phenomenon.     

H-NS Facilitates Sequence Diversification of Horizontally Transferred DNAs during Their Integration in Host Chromosomes

Bacteria can acquire new traits through horizontal gene transfer. Inappropriate expression of transferred genes, however, can disrupt the physiology of the host bacteria. To reduce this risk, Escherichia coli expresses the nucleoid-associated protein, H-NS, which preferentially binds to horizontally transferred genes to control their expression. Once expression is optimized, the horizontally transferred genes may actually contribute to E. coli survival in new habitats. Therefore, we investigated whether and how H-NS contributes to this optimization process. A comparison of H-NS binding profiles on common chromosomal segments of three E. coli strains belonging to different phylogenetic groups indicated that the positions of H-NS-bound regions have been conserved in E. coli strains. The sequences of the H-NS-bound regions appear to have diverged more so than H-NS-unbound regions only when H-NS-bound regions are located upstream or in coding regions of genes. Because these regions generally contain regulatory elements for gene expression, sequence divergence in these regions may be associated with alteration of gene expression. Indeed, nucleotide substitutions in H-NS-bound regions of the ybdO promoter and coding regions have diversified the potential for H-NS-independent negative regulation among E. coli strains. The ybdO expression in these strains was still negatively regulated by H-NS, which reduced the effect of H-NS-independent regulation under normal growth conditions. Hence, we propose that, during E. coli evolution, the conservation of H-NS binding sites resulted in the diversification of the regulation of horizontally transferred genes, which may have facilitated E. coli adaptation to new ecological niches.     

Analysis of the key functional genes in new aerobic degraders of dichloromethane

The genes of dichloromethane (CH₂C1₂, DCM) degradation have been characterized in the aerobic degraders “Gottschalkia methylica” DM15, “Ancylobacter dichloromethanicus” DM16, and Methylobac- terium extorquens DM17, isolated from different regions of Russia. The sequencing of the structural gene dcmA of DCM dehalogenase, followed by phylogenetic analysis, showed that the new degraders possess A-type dehalogenases. The DcmAs of the strains DM15 and DM17 were identical to the known orthologous proteins of Methylorhabdus multivorans DM 13 and Methylobacterium dichloromethanicum DM4, respectively. DcmA of the degrader DM16 differed by three amino acid substitutions from DcmA of strain DM4. In agreement with the organization of the cluster of DCM degradation genes in M. dichloromethanicum DM4, the regulatory gene dcmR and the open reading frame orf353, flanking dcmA, were identified in the new degraders. The similarity of DCM degradation genes in aerobic degraders of different taxonomic position and geographical origin suggests their distribution among methylotrophic bacteria by means of horizontal transfer.     

In Planta Horizontal Transfer of a Major Pathogenicity Effector Gene

Xanthomonas citri pv. citri is a clonal group of strains that causes citrus canker disease and appears to have originated in Asia. A phylogenetically distinct clonal group that causes identical disease symptoms on susceptible citrus, X. citri pv. aurantifolii, arose more recently in South America. Genomes of X. citri pv. aurantifolii strains carry two DNA fragments that hybridize to pthA, an X. citri pv. citri gene which encodes a major type III pathogenicity effector protein that is absolutely required to cause citrus canker. Marker interruption mutagenesis and complementation revealed that X. citri pv. aurantifolii strain B69 carried one functional pthA homolog, designated pthB, that was required to cause cankers on citrus. Gene pthB was found among 38 open reading frames on a 37,106-bp plasmid, designated pXcB, which was sequenced and annotated. No additional pathogenicity effectors were found on pXcB, but 11 out of 38 open reading frames appeared to encode a type IV transfer system. pXcB transferred horizontally in planta, without added selection, from B69 to a nonpathogenic X. citri pv. citri (pthA::Tn5) mutant strain, fully restoring canker. In planta transfer efficiencies were very high (>0.1%/recipient) and equivalent to those observed for agar medium with antibiotic selection, indicating that pthB conferred a strong selective advantage to the recipient strain. A single pathogenicity effector that can confer a distinct selective advantage in planta may both facilitate plasmid survival following horizontal gene transfer and account for the origination of phylogenetically distinct groups of strains causing identical disease symptoms.     

Multiple Pathways of Plasmid DNA Transfer in Helicobacter pylori

Many Helicobacter pylori (Hp) strains carry cryptic plasmids of different size and gene content, the function of which is not well understood. A subgroup of these plasmids (e.g. pHel4, pHel12), contain a mobilisation region, but no cognate type IV secretion system (T4SS) for conjugative transfer. Instead, certain H. pylori strains (e.g. strain P12 carrying plasmid pHel12) can harbour up to four T4SSs in their genome (cag-T4SS, comB, tfs3, tfs4). Here, we show that such indigenous plasmids can be efficiently transferred between H. pylori strains, even in the presence of extracellular DNaseI eliminating natural transformation. Knockout of a plasmid-encoded mobA relaxase gene significantly reduced plasmid DNA transfer in the presence of DNaseI, suggesting a DNA conjugation or mobilisation process. To identify the T4SS involved in this conjugative DNA transfer, each individual T4SS was consecutively deleted from the bacterial chromosome. Using a marker-free counterselectable gene deletion procedure (rpsL counterselection method), a P12 mutant strain was finally obtained with no single T4SS (P12ΔT4SS). Mating experiments using these mutants identified the comB T4SS in the recipient strain as the major mediator of plasmid DNA transfer between H. pylori strains, both in a DNaseI-sensitive (natural transformation) as well as a DNaseI-resistant manner (conjugative transfer). However, transfer of a pHel12::cat plasmid from a P12ΔT4SS donor strain into a P12ΔT4SS recipient strain provided evidence for the existence of a third, T4SS-independent mechanism of DNA transfer. This novel type of plasmid DNA transfer, designated as alternate DNaseI-Resistant (ADR) mechanism, is observed at a rather low frequency under in vitro conditions. Taken together, our study describes for the first time the existence of three distinct pathways of plasmid DNA transfer between H. pylori underscoring the importance of horizontal gene transfer for this species.     

Low-Frequency Horizontal Transfer of an Element Containing the Chlorocatechol Degradation Genes from Pseudomonas sp. Strain B13 to Pseudomonas putida F1 and to Indigenous Bacteria in Laboratory-Scale Activated-Sludge Microcosms

The possibilities for low-frequency horizontal transfer of the self-transmissible chlorocatechol degradative genes (clc) from Pseudomonas sp. strain B13 were investigated in activated-sludge microcosms. When the clc genes were transferred into an appropriate recipient bacterium such as Pseudomonas putida F1, a new metabolic pathway for chlorobenzene degradation was formed by complementation which could be selected for by the addition of mono- or 1,4-dichlorobenzene (CB). Under optimized conditions with direct donor-recipient filter matings, very low transfer frequencies were observed (approximately 3.5 × 10⁻⁸ per donor per 24 h). In contrast, in matings on agar plate surfaces, transconjugants started to appear after 8 to 10 days, and their numbers then increased during prolonged continuous incubation with CB. In activated-sludge microcosms, CB-degrading (CB⁺) transconjugants of strain F1 which had acquired the clc genes were detected but only when strain B13 cell densities of more than 10⁵ CFU/ml could be maintained by the addition of its specific growth substrate, 3-chlorobenzoate (3CBA). The CB⁺ transconjugants reached final cell densities of between 10² and 10³ CFU/ml. When strain B13 was inoculated separately (without the designated recipient strain F1) into an activated-sludge microcosm, CB⁺ transconjugants could not be detected. However, in this case a new 3CBA-degrading strain appeared which had acquired the clc genes from strain B13. The effects of selective substrates on the survival and growth of and gene transfer between bacteria degrading aromatic pollutants in a wastewater ecosystem are discussed.     

Genetic and enzymatic analysis of a gene controlling UV sensitivity in Neurospora crassa

The upr-I gene controlling UV sensitivity in Neurospora crassa has been transferred from a microconidial strain into a macroconidial strain. The properties of the strain with respect to UV sensitivity and photoreactivation (PR) have been modified in the macroconidial background leading to an enhancement of resistance to UV by a factor of about 2 and some suggestion of enzymatic PR. The upr-I gene confers sensitivity to nitrous acid to about the same degree as that for UV. However, inactivation of strains carrying the upr-I gene by white light in the presence of photosensitizing dyes is equivalent to that of strains exhibiting normal sensitivity to UV.     

Evolution in Quantum Leaps: Multiple Combinatorial Transfers of HPI and Other Genetic Modules in Enterobacteriaceae

Horizontal gene transfer is a key step in the evolution of Enterobacteriaceae. By acquiring virulence determinants of foreign origin, commensals can evolve into pathogens. In Enterobacteriaceae, horizontal transfer of these virulence determinants is largely dependent on transfer by plasmids, phages, genomic islands (GIs) and genomic modules (GMs). The High Pathogenicity Island (HPI) is a GI encoding virulence genes that can be transferred between different Enterobacteriaceae. We investigated the HPI because it was present in an Enterobacter hormaechei outbreak strain (EHOS). Genome sequence analysis showed that the EHOS contained an integration site for mobile elements and harbored two GIs and three putative GMs, including a new variant of the HPI (HPI-ICEEh1). We demonstrate, for the first time, that combinatorial transfers of GIs and GMs between Enterobacter cloacae complex isolates must have occurred. Furthermore, the excision and circularization of several combinations of the GIs and GMs was demonstrated. Because of its flexibility, the multiple integration site of mobile DNA can be considered an integration hotspot (IHS) that increases the genomic plasticity of the bacterium. Multiple combinatorial transfers of diverse combinations of the HPI and other genomic elements among Enterobacteriaceae may accelerate the generation of new pathogenic strains.     

Regulation of Bacterial Cell Division: Genetic and Phenotypic Analysis of Temperature-Sensitive, Multinucleate, Filament-Forming Mutants of Escherichia coli

Three mutants of Escherichia coli K-12 which form filaments during 42 C incubation have been characterized. The mutant strains AX621, AX629, and AX655 continued to grow and to synthesize deoxyribonucleic acid at 42 C for 150 to 180 min, after which time growth ceased. When cultures of the mutants were transferred from 42 to 28 C, septation of the filaments began after a 25- to 30-min period and continued at a greater than normal rate until no filaments remained. Addition of chloramphenicol at the time of transfer from 42 to 28 C prevented cell division in strain AX655 and caused lysis of strains AX621 and AX629. The temperature sensitivity mutation in each strain mapped near leu. For strain AX621, the mutation was specifically located between leu and nadC by P1 transduction. Properties of these strains are compared with those of other cell division mutants.     

Methylobacterium pseudosasae sp. nov., a pink-pigmented, facultatively methylotrophic bacterium isolated from the bamboo phyllosphere

A pink-pigmented, Gram negative, aerobic, facultatively methylotrophic bacterium, strain BL44^T, was isolated from bamboo leaves and identified as a member of the genus Methylobacterium. Phylogenetic analysis based on 16S rRNA gene sequences showed similarity values of 98.7–97.0 % with closely related type strains and showed highest similarity to Methylobacterium zatmanii DSM 5688^T (98.7 %) and Methylobacterium thiocyanatum DSM 11490^T (98.7 %). Methylotrophic metabolism in this strain was confirmed by PCR amplification and sequencing of the mxaF gene coding for the α-subunit of methanol dehydrogenase. Strain BL44^T produced three known quorum sensing signal molecules with similar retention time to C₈, C₁₀ and C₁₂-HSLs when characterized by GC–MS. The fatty acid profiles contained major amounts of C_18:1 ω7c, iso-3OH C_17:0 and summed feature 3 (C_16:1 ω7c and/or iso-C_15:0 2-OH), which supported the grouping of the isolate in the genus Methylobacterium. The DNA G+C content was 66.9 mol%. DNA relatedness of the strain BL44^T to its most closely related strains ranged from 12–43.3 %. On the basis of the phenotypic, phylogenetic and DNA–DNA hybridization data, strain BL44^T is assigned to a novel species of the genus Methylobacterium for which the name Methylobacterium pseudosasae sp. nov. is proposed (type strain BL44^T = NBRC 105205^T = ICMP 17622^T).     

Transfer of plasmids pBC 16 and pC 194 into Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. israelensis

A lysozyme sensitive strain of B. thuringiensis (strain O 016) was isolated and shown to be effectively transformed with plasmids pC 194 and pHV 33 using the protoplast transformation technique. The plasmid pC 194 from one successful transformant, strain O 016–194, was subsequently transferred to B. thuringiensis subsp. israelensis by a “conjugation-like” process. The plasmid pBC 16 from B. cereus could also be transferred to B. thuringiensis subsp. israelensis with high frequency using the conjugation-like process. Further, both plasmids, pC 194 and pBC 16, were transferred between strains of B. thuringiensis subsp. israelensis to yield transcipient strains that harbored and expressed properties of both plasmids. This work constitutes effective gene transfer system in B. thuringiensis subsp. israelensis.     

Transfer and Expression of Lithoautotrophy and Denitrification in a Host Lacking These Metabolic Activities

The conjugative 450-kilobase-pair megaplasmid pHG1 from Alcaligenes eutrophus H16 was transferred to the herbicide-degrading soil bacterium A. eutrophus JMP134. This transfer was achieved by means of RP4 mobilization and a Tn5-Mob insertion provided in trans on the megaplasmid replicon. Although kanamycin-resistant transconjugants also occurred with other gram-negative species such as Rhizobium, Agrobacterium, and thiobacteria, A. eutrophus JMP134 was the only recipient which stably maintained the megaplasmid. pHG1-containing transconjugants derived from JMP134 expressed all metabolic functions associated with the plasmid: the ability to oxidize hydrogen through catalysis of two hydrogenases, to assimilate carbon dioxide via the Calvin cycle pathway, and to grow with nitrate anaerobically. All of these metabolic activities were absent in the original strain JMP134.     

Ecotype Diversity and Conversion in Photobacterium profundum Strains

Photobacterium profundum is a cosmopolitan marine bacterium capable of growth at low temperature and high hydrostatic pressure. Multiple strains of P. profundum have been isolated from different depths of the ocean and display remarkable differences in their physiological responses to pressure. The genome sequence of the deep-sea piezopsychrophilic strain Photobacterium profundum SS9 has provided some clues regarding the genetic features required for growth in the deep sea. The sequenced genome of Photobacterium profundum strain 3TCK, a non-piezophilic strain isolated from a shallow-water environment, is now available and its analysis expands the identification of unique genomic features that correlate to environmental differences and define the Hutchinsonian niche of each strain. These differences range from variations in gene content to specific gene sequences under positive selection. Genome plasticity between Photobacterium bathytypes was investigated when strain 3TCK-specific genes involved in photorepair were introduced to SS9, demonstrating that horizontal gene transfer can provide a mechanism for rapid colonisation of new environments.