Allosteric regulation and catalysis emerge via a common route

Allosteric regulation of protein function is a mechanism by which an event in one place of a protein structure causes an effect at another site, much like the behavior of a telecommunications network in which a collection of transmitters, receivers and transceivers communicate with each other across long distances. For example, ligand binding or an amino acid mutation at an allosteric site can alter enzymatic activity or binding affinity in a distal region such as the active site or a second binding site. The mechanism of this site-to-site communication is of great interest, especially since allosteric effects must be considered in drug design and protein engineering. In this review, conformational mobility as the common route between allosteric regulation and catalysis is discussed. We summarize recent experimental data and the resulting insights into allostery within proteins, and we discuss the nature of future studies and the new applications that may result from increased understanding of this regulatory mechanism.     

Emerging maps of allosteric regulation in cellular networks

Allosteric regulation is classically defined as action at a distance, where a perturbation outside of a protein active site affects function. While this definition has motivated many studies of allosteric mechanisms at the level of protein structure, translating these insights to the allosteric regulation of entire cellular processes – and their crosstalk – has received less attention, despite the broad importance of allostery for cellular regulation foreseen by Jacob and Monod. Here, we revisit an evolutionary model for the widespread emergence of allosteric regulation in colocalized proteins, describe supporting evidence, and discuss emerging advances in mapping allostery in cellular networks that link precise and often allosteric perturbations at the molecular level to functional changes at the pathway and systems levels.     

Allostery in pharmacology: thermodynamics, evolution and design

This review focuses on basic models of allostery, the ambiguous application of the allosteric term in pharmacology illustrated by receptors, the role of thermodynamics in allosteric mechanisms, evolution and design of allostery. The initial step of ligand activation is closure of the agonist-binding cavity. Large entropy increases accompany the agonist-elicited conformational changes of pentameric ligand-gated ion channels due to cavity closure and rearrangement of transmembrane helices. The effects of point mutations on thermodynamic parameters of binding and function can reveal energetic coupling of neighbouring (and distant) amino acid residues in activation. High-order double-mutant cycle analysis and rate-equilibrium linear free-energy relationships can identify the trajectory and conformational spread of activation.Protein assembly and allostery can be deduced from colocalization and physicochemical principles. Molecular evolution has led from homooligomerization of protomers to heterotropic cooperativity and to allosteric regulation. Examples are discussed such as similar paths of protein (dis)assembly and evolution, irreversible evolution, statistical analysis of sequence homology revealing coevolution, different impacts of adaptation and evolution on hemoglobin, and the flagellar motor switch of bacteria. The driving force of dynamic allostery is associated with funnel-like free energy landscapes of protein binding and shifts in conformational fluctuations upon binding. Allostery can be designed based on our increasing knowledge of natural allosteric mechanisms and evolution. The allosteric principle has been applied for various bio/macro/molecular and signal transduction systems as well as in cognitive sciences.     

Correlating allostery with rigidity

Allosteric proteins demonstrate the phenomenon of a ligand binding to a protein at a regulatory or effector site and thereby changing the chemical affinity of the catalytic site. As such, allostery is extremely important biologically as a regulatory mechanism for molecular concentrations in many cellular processes. One particularly interesting feature of allostery is that often the catalytic and effector sites are separated by a large distance. Structural comparisons of allosteric proteins resolved in both inactive and active states indicate that a variety of structural rearrangement and changes in motions may contribute to general allosteric behavior. In general it is expected that the coupling of catalytic and regulatory sites is responsible for allosteric behavior. We utilize a novel examination of allostery using rigidity analysis of the underlying graph of the protein structures. Our results indicate a general global change in rigidity associated with allosteric transitions where the R state is more rigid than the T state. A set of allosteric proteins with heterotropic interactions is used to test the hypothesis that catalytic and effector sites are structurally coupled. Observation of a rigid path connecting the effector and catalytic sites in 68.75% of the structures points to rigidity as a means by which the distal sites communicate with each other and so contribute to allosteric regulation. Thus structural rigidity is shown to be a fundamental underlying property that promotes cooperativity and non-locality seen in allostery.     

Prediction of Protein Allosteric Signalling Pathways and Functional Residues Through Paths of Optimised Propensity

Allostery commonly refers to the mechanism that regulates protein activity through the binding of a molecule at a different, usually distal, site from the orthosteric site. The omnipresence of allosteric regulation in nature and its potential for drug design and screening render the study of allostery invaluable. Nevertheless, challenges remain as few computational methods are available to effectively predict allosteric sites, identify signalling pathways involved in allostery, or to aid with the design of suitable molecules targeting such sites. Recently, bond-to-bond propensity analysis has been shown successful at identifying allosteric sites for a large and diverse group of proteins from knowledge of the orthosteric sites and its ligands alone by using network analysis applied to energy-weighted atomistic protein graphs. To address the identification of signalling pathways, we propose here a method to compute and score paths of optimised propensity that link the orthosteric site with the identified allosteric sites, and identifies crucial residues that contribute to those paths. We showcase the approach with three well-studied allosteric proteins: h-Ras, caspase-1, and 3-phosphoinositide-dependent kinase-1 (PDK1). Key residues in both orthosteric and allosteric sites were identified and showed agreement with experimental results, and pivotal signalling residues along the pathway were also revealed, thus providing alternative targets for drug design. By using the computed path scores, we were also able to differentiate the activity of different allosteric modulators.     

Allostery: an illustrated definition for the 'second secret of life'

Although allosteric regulation is the 'second secret of life', the molecular mechanisms that give rise to allostery currently elude understanding. In my opinion, experimental progress is hampered by a commonly used but misleading definition of allostery as protein structural changes that are elicited by the binding of a single ligand. Allostery is more strictly defined in functional terms as a comparison of how one ligand binds in the absence, versus the presence, of a second ligand. Therefore, as each of the two binding events involves two protein complexes, a study of allostery must consider four complexes and not just two. Such a comparison can distinguish allosteric from non-allosteric protein changes, the importance of which is frequently overlooked. When a study of all four complexes is not feasible, an alternative, albeit limited, strategy can identify subsets of allosteric-specific changes.     

The Role of Protein-Ligand Contacts in Allosteric Regulation of the Escherichia coli Catabolite Activator Protein

Allostery is a fundamental process by which ligand binding to a protein alters its activity at a distant site. Both experimental and theoretical evidence demonstrate that allostery can be communicated through altered slow relaxation protein dynamics without conformational change. The catabolite activator protein (CAP) of Escherichia coli is an exemplar for the analysis of such entropically driven allostery. Negative allostery in CAP occurs between identical cAMP binding sites. Changes to the cAMP-binding pocket can therefore impact the allosteric properties of CAP. Here we demonstrate, through a combination of coarse-grained modeling, isothermal calorimetry, and structural analysis, that decreasing the affinity of CAP for cAMP enhances negative cooperativity through an entropic penalty for ligand binding. The use of variant cAMP ligands indicates the data are not explained by structural heterogeneity between protein mutants. We observe computationally that altered interaction strength between CAP and cAMP variously modifies the change in allosteric cooperativity due to second site CAP mutations. As the degree of correlated motion between the cAMP-contacting site and a second site on CAP increases, there is a tendency for computed double mutations at these sites to drive CAP toward noncooperativity. Naturally occurring pairs of covarying residues in CAP do not display this tendency, suggesting a selection pressure to fine tune allostery on changes to the CAP ligand-binding pocket without a drive to a noncooperative state. In general, we hypothesize an evolutionary selection pressure to retain slow relaxation dynamics-induced allostery in proteins in which evolution of the ligand-binding site is occurring.     

Structure-Based Statistical Mechanical Model Accounts for the Causality and Energetics of Allosteric Communication

Allostery is one of the pervasive mechanisms through which proteins in living systems carry out enzymatic activity, cell signaling, and metabolism control. Effective modeling of the protein function regulation requires a synthesis of the thermodynamic and structural views of allostery. We present here a structure-based statistical mechanical model of allostery, allowing one to observe causality of communication between regulatory and functional sites, and to estimate per residue free energy changes. Based on the consideration of ligand free and ligand bound systems in the context of a harmonic model, corresponding sets of characteristic normal modes are obtained and used as inputs for an allosteric potential. This potential quantifies the mean work exerted on a residue due to the local motion of its neighbors. Subsequently, in a statistical mechanical framework the entropic contribution to allosteric free energy of a residue is directly calculated from the comparison of conformational ensembles in the ligand free and ligand bound systems. As a result, this method provides a systematic approach for analyzing the energetics of allosteric communication based on a single structure. The feasibility of the approach was tested on a variety of allosteric proteins, heterogeneous in terms of size, topology and degree of oligomerization. The allosteric free energy calculations show the diversity of ways and complexity of scenarios existing in the phenomenology of allosteric causality and communication. The presented model is a step forward in developing the computational techniques aimed at detecting allosteric sites and obtaining the discriminative power between agonistic and antagonistic effectors, which are among the major goals in allosteric drug design.     

Ligand binding and allostery can emerge simultaneously

A heterotropic allosteric effect involves an effector molecule that is distinct from the substrate or ligand of the protein. How heterotropic allostery originates is an unanswered question. We have previously created several heterotropic allosteric enzymes by recombining the genes for TEM1 beta-lactamase (BLA) and maltose binding protein (MBP) to create BLAs that are positively or negatively regulated by maltose. We show here that one of these engineered enzymes has approximately 10(6) M(-1) affinity for Zn(2+), a property that neither of the parental proteins possesses. Furthermore, Zn(2+) is a negative effector that noncompetitively switches off beta-lactam hydrolysis activity. Mutagenesis experiments indicate that the Zn(2+)-binding site does not involve a histidine or a cysteine, which is atypical of natural Zn(2+)-binding sites. These studies also implicate helices 1 and 12 of the BLA domain in allosteric signal propagation. These results support a model for the evolution of heterotropic allostery in which effector affinity and allosteric signaling emerge simultaneously.     

Allosteric Effect of Adenosine Triphosphate on Peptide Recognition by 3′5′-Cyclic Adenosine Monophosphate Dependent Protein Kinase Catalytic Subunits

The allosteric influence of adenosine triphosphate (ATP) on the binding effectiveness of a series of peptide inhibitors with the catalytic subunit of 3′5′-cyclic adenosine monophosphate dependent protein kinase was investigated, and the dependence of this effect on peptide structure was analyzed. The allosteric effect was calculated as ratio of peptide binding effectiveness with the enzyme-ATP complex and with the free enzyme, quantified by the competitive inhibition of the enzyme in the presence of ATP excess, and by the enzyme-peptide complex denaturation assay, respectively It was found that the principle “better binding—stronger allostery” holds for interactions of the studied peptides with the enzyme, indicating that allostery and peptide binding with the free enzyme are governed by the same specificity pattern. This means that the allosteric regulation does not include new ligand–protein interactions, but changes the intensity (strength) of the interatomic forces that govern the complex formation in the case of each individual ligand. We propose that the allosteric regulation can be explained by the alteration of the intrinsic dynamics of the protein by ligand binding, and that this phenomenon, in turn, modulates the ligand off-rate from its binding site as well as the binding affinity. The positive allostery could therefore be induced by a reduction in the enzyme’s overall intrinsic dynamics.     

Hinge Twists and Population Shifts Deliver Regulated Catalysis for ATP-PRT in Histidine Biosynthesis

Allosteric regulation plays an important role in the control of metabolic flux in biosynthetic pathways. In microorganisms, many enzymes in these pathways adopt different strategies of allostery to allow the tuning of their activities in response to metabolic demand. Thus, it is important to uncover the mechanism of allosteric signal transmission to fully comprehend the complex control of enzyme function and its evolution. ATP-phosphoribosyltransferase (ATP-PRT), as the first enzyme in the histidine biosynthetic pathway, is allosterically regulated by histidine and offers a good platform for the study of allostery. Two forms of ATP-PRT, namely long and short forms, were discovered that show different arrangements of their regulatory machinery. Crystal structures of the long-form ATP-PRT have revealed overall conformational changes in the inhibited state, but the observed changes in the active state are quite subtle, making the elucidation of its allosteric mechanism difficult. Here, we combine computational methods (ligand docking, quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics optimization, and molecular dynamic simulations) with experimental studies to probe the signal transmission between remote allosteric and active sites. Our results reveal that distinct conformational ensembles of the catalytic domain with different dynamic properties exist in the ligand-free and histidine-bound enzymes. These ensembles display different capabilities in supporting the catalytic and allosteric function of ATP-PRT. The findings give insight into the underlying mechanism of allostery and allow us to propose that the hinge twisting within the catalytic domain is the key for both enhancement of catalysis and provision of regulation in ATP-PRT enzymes.     

Emerging computational approaches for the study of protein allostery

Allosteric regulation of protein function is key in controlling cellular processes so its underlying mechanisms are of primary concern to research in areas spanning protein engineering and drug design. However, due to the complex nature of allosteric mechanisms, a clear and predictive understanding of the relationship between protein structure and allosteric function remains elusive. Well established experimental approaches are available to offer a limited degree of characterization of mechanical properties within proteins, but the analytical capabilities of computational methods are evolving rapidly in their ability to accurately define the subtle and concerted structural dynamics that comprise allostery. This review includes a brief overview of allostery in proteins and an exploration of relevant experimental methods. An explanation of the transition from experimental toward computational methods for allostery is discussed, followed by a review of existing and emerging methods.     

Elucidation of direct competition and allosteric modulation of small‐molecular‐weight protein ligands using surface plasmon resonance methods

The present work introduces a surface plasmon resonance‐based method for the discrimination of direct competition and allosteric effects that occur in ternary systems comprising a receptor protein and two small‐molecular‐weight ligands that bind to it. Fatty acid binding protein 4, fructose‐1,6‐bisphosphatase and human serum albumin were used as model receptor molecules to demonstrate the performance of the method. For each of the receptor molecules, pairs of ligand molecules were selected for which either direct competition or an allosteric effect had already been determined by other methods. The method of discrimination introduced here is based on the surface plasmon resonance responses observed at equilibrium when an immobilized receptor protein is brought into contact with binary mixtures of interacting ligands. These experimentally determined responses are compared with the responses calculated using a theoretical model that considers both direct competition and allosteric ligand interaction modes. This study demonstrates that the allosteric ternary complex model, which enables calculation of the fractional occupancy of the protein by each ligand in such ternary systems, is well suited for the theoretical calculation of these types of responses. For all of the ternary systems considered in this work, the experimental and calculated responses in the chosen concentration ratio range were identical within a five‐σ confidence interval when the calculations considered the correct interaction mode of the ligands (direct competition or different types of allosteric regulation), and in case of allosteric modulation, also the correct strength of this effect. This study also demonstrates that the allosteric ternary complex model‐based calculations are well suited to predict the ideal concentration ratio range or even single concentration ratios that can serve as hot spots for discrimination, and such hot spots can drastically reduce the numbers of measurements needed for discrimination between direct competition and distinct modulation modes (neutral, positive or negative allostery). Copyright © 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Contrasting roles of dynamics in protein allostery: NMR and structural studies of CheY and the third PDZ domain from PSD-95

Allosteric regulation is a ubiquitous phenomenon exploited in biological processes to control cells in a myriad of ways. It is also of emerging interest in the design of functional proteins and therapeutics. Even though allostery was proposed over 50 years ago and has been studied intensively from a structural perspective, many key details of allosteric mechanisms remain mysterious. Over the last decade significant attention has been paid to the “dynamic component” of allostery, as opposed to the analysis of rigid structures. Nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy and its ability to detect conformationally dynamic processes at atomic resolution have played an important role in expanding our understanding of allosteric mechanisms and opening up new questions. This article focuses on work that highlights how protein dynamics can factor into allosteric processes in distinct ways. Two cases are contrasted. The first considers the “traditionally allosteric” protein CheY, which undergoes a conformational change as a key element of its allostery. The second considers the more rarely observed “dynamic allostery” in a PDZ domain, in which allosteric behavior arises from changes in internal structural dynamics. Interestingly, the dynamic processes in these two contrasting examples occur on different timescales. In the case of the PDZ domain, subsequent experimental and computational work is reviewed to reveal a more complete picture of this interesting case of allostery.     

Differentiating a ligand's chemical requirements for allosteric interactions from those for protein binding. Phenylalanine inhibition of pyruvate kinase

The isoform of pyruvate kinase from brain and muscle of mammals (M(1)-PYK) is allosterically inhibited by phenylalanine. Initial observations in this model allosteric system indicate that Ala binds competitively with Phe, but elicits a minimal allosteric response. Thus, the allosteric ligand of this system must have requirements for eliciting an allosteric response in addition to the requirements for binding. Phe analogues have been used to dissect what chemical properties of Phe are responsible for eliciting the allosteric response. We first demonstrate that the l-2-aminopropanaldehyde substructure of the amino acid ligand is primarily responsible for binding to M(1)-PYK. Since the allosteric response to Ala is minimal and linear addition of methyl groups beyond the beta-carbon increase the magnitude of the allosteric response, we conclude that moieties beyond the beta-carbon are primarily responsible for allostery. Instead of an all-or-none mechanism of allostery, these findings support the idea that the bulk of the hydrophobic side chain, but not the aromatic nature, is the primary determinant of the magnitude of the observed allosteric inhibition. The use of these results to direct structural studies has resulted in a 1.65 A structure of M(1)-PYK with Ala bound. The coordination of Ala in the allosteric amino acid binding site confirms the binding role of the l-2-aminopropanaldehyde substructure of the ligand. Collectively, this study confirms that a ligand can have chemical regions specific for eliciting the allosteric signal in addition to the chemical regions necessary for binding.