Controlled introgression to wheat of genes from rye chromosome arm 1RS by induction of allosyndesis

Summary Chromosome pairing between rye chromosome arm 1RS, present in two wheat-rye translocation stocks, and its wheat homoeologues was induced by introducing the translocations into either a ph1bph1b or a nullisomic 5B background. This rye arm carries a gene conferring resistance to wheat stem rust, but lines carrying the translocation produce a poor quality dough unsuitable for breadmaking. Storage protein markers were utilised along with stem rust reaction to screen for allosyndetic recombinants. From a 1DL-1RS translocation, three lines involving wheat-rye recombination were recovered, along with thirteen lines derived from wheat-wheat homoeologous recombination. From a 1BL-1RS translocation, an additional three allosyndetic recombinants were recovered. Nullisomy for chromosome 5B was as efficacious as the ph1b mutant for induction of allosyndesis, and the former stock is easier to manipulate due to the presence of a 5BL-encoded endosperm protein. The novel wheat-rye chromosomes present in the recombinant lines may enable the rye disease resistance to be exploited without the associated dough quality defect.     

Comparative analysis of the meiotic effects of wheat ph1b and ph2b mutations in wheat×rye hybrids

 Wheat-wheat and wheat-rye homoeologous pairing at metaphase I and wheat-rye recombination at anaphase I were examined by genomic in situ hybridization (GISH) in wild-type (Ph1Ph2) and mutant ph1b and ph2b wheat×rye hybrids. The metaphase-I analysis revealed that the relative contribution of wheat-rye chromosome associations in ph2b wheat×rye was similar to that of the wild-type hybrid genotype but differed from the effect of the ph1b mutation. The greater pairing promotion effect of the ph1b mutation appears to be relatively more on distant homoeologous partner metaphase-I associations, whereas the lower promoting effect of ph2b is evenly distributed among all types of homoeologous associations. This finding reveals that distinct mechanisms are involved in the control of wheat homoeologous pairing by the two Ph genes. The frequency of wheat-rye recombination calculated from anaphase-I analysis was lower than expected from the metaphase-I data. A greater discrepancy was found in ph2b than in ph1b wheat×rye hybrids, which may suggest a more distal chiasma localization in the former hybrid genotype. Received: 20 June 1997 / Accepted: 9 December 1997     

Detection of wheat-alien recombinant chromosomes using co-dominant DNA markers**

A study of homoeologous recombination along almost the complete genetic length of two homoeologous chromosomes in the Triticeae was conducted. Sears' phlb mutant was used to induce homoeologous pairing between chromosomes 7A of common wheat and 7Ai–l of Agropyron intermedium. 390 ph1b ph1b homozygous F₃ progeny were screened using six co-dominant DNA markers (RFLP loci). 63 of the progeny (16%) were putative recombinants, showing dissociation of RFLP markers within the arm(s). Progeny tests of self-fertile putative recombinants confirmed the dissociation phenotypes observed in the F₃ progeny. No recombination could be confirmed in 117 F₃ progeny plants having the Ph1– allele (control population). Frequencies and distribution of chiasmata along the chromosome arm 7AS were analysed using additional RFLP markers. The patterns of recombination between the two homoeologous chromosomes were found similar to those reported for homologous recombination between the same markers on short arms of group 7 chromosomes of Triticeae.     

Homoeology of rye chromosome arms to wheat

Summary Cytological markers such as diagnostic C-bands, telocentrics, and translocations were used to identify the arms of rye chromosomes associated with wheat chromosomes at metaphase I in ph1b mutant wheat × rye hybrids. Arm homoeologies of rye chromosomes to wheat were established from the results of metaphase I pairing combined with available data on the chromosomal location of homoeoloci series in wheat and rye. Only arms 1RS, 1RL, 2RL, 3RS, and 5RS showed normal homoeologous relationships to wheat. The remaining arms of rye appeared to be involved in chromosome rearrangements that occurred during the evolution of the genus Secale. We conclude that a pericentric inversion in chromosome 4R, a reciprocal translocation between 3RL and 6RL, and a multiple translocation involving 4RL, 5RL, 6RS, and 7RS are present in rye relative to wheat.     

Some characteristics of crossing over in induced recombination between chromosomes of wheat and rye

Allopolyploid wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) carries three pairs of homoeologous genomes but its meiotic pairing is diploid-like. This is the effect of the Ph (pairing homoeologous) system which restricts chromosome pairing to strictly homologous. Ph1 is the locus with the strongest effect. Disabling Ph1 permits pairing between homoeologues and is routinely used in chromosome engineering to introgress alien variation into breeding stocks. Whereas the efficiency of Ph1 and the general pattern of homoeologous crossovers in its absence are quite well known from numerous studies, other characteristics of such crossovers remain unknown. This study analyzed the crossover points in four sets of the ph1b-induced recombinants between wheat homologues as well as between three wheat and rye (Secale cereale) homoeologous chromosome arms, and compared them to crossovers between homologues in a reference wheat population. The results show the Ph1 locus also controls crossing over of homologues, and the general patterns of homologous (with Ph1) and homoeologous (with ph1b) crossing over are the same. In all intervals analyzed, homoeologous crossovers fell within the range of frequency distribution of homologous crossovers among individual families of the reference population. No specific DNA sequence characteristics were identified that could be recognized by the Ph1 locus; the only difference between homologous and homoeologous crossing over appears to be in frequency. It is concluded that the Ph1 locus likely recognizes DNA sequence similarity; crossing over is permitted between very similar sequences. In the absence of Ph1 dissimilarities are ignored, in proportion to the level of the sequence divergence.     

Physical distribution of translocation breakpoints in homoeologous recombinants induced by the absence of the Ph1 gene in wheat and triticale

The physical distribution of translocation breakpoints was analyzed in homoeologous recombinants involving chromosomes 1A, 1B, 1D of wheat and 1R of rye, and the long arms of chromosome 7S of Aegilops speltoides and 7A of wheat. Recombination between homoeologues was induced by removal of the Ph1 gene. In all instances, translocation breakpoints were concentrated in the distal ends of the chromosome arms and were absent in the proximal halves of the arms. The relationship between the relative distance from the centromere and the relative homoeologous recombination frequency was best explained by the function f(x)=0.0091e^0.0592x. The pattern of recombination in homoeologous chromosomes was essentially the same as in homologues except that there were practically no double exchanges. Among 313 recombinant chromosomes, only one resulted from a double crossing-over. The distribution of translocation breakpoints in translocated arms indicated that positive chiasma interference operated in homoeologous recombination. This implies that the reduction of the length of alien chromosome segments present in translocations with wheat chromosomes may be more difficult than the production of the original recombinants.     

Isolation and characterization of wheat-rye recombinants involving chromosome arm 1DS of wheat

Summary The introgression of genetic material from alien species is assuming increased importance in wheat breeding programs. One example is the translocation of the short arm of rye chromosome 1 (1RS) onto homoeologous wheat chromosomes, which confers disease resistance and increased yield on wheat. However, this translocation is also associated with dough quality defects. To break the linkage between the desirable agronomic traits and poor dough quality, recombination has been induced between 1RS and the homoeologous wheat arm IDS. Seven new recombinants were isolated, with five being similar to those reported earlier and two havina new type of structure. All available recombinantsw ere characterized with DNA probes for the loci Nor-R1, 5SDna-R1, and Tel-R1. Also, the amount of rye chromatin present was quantified with a dispersed rye-specific repetitive DNA sequence in quantitative dot blots. Furthermore, the wheat-rye recombinants were used as a mapping tool to assign two RFLP markers to specific regions on chromosome arms 1DS and 1RS of wheat and rye, respectively.     

Intrachromosomal mapping of crossability genes in wheat (Triticum aestivum)

Summary Intrachromosomal mapping studies were used to locate the positions of the genes Kr1 and Kr2, which control the crossability of wheat with Hordeum bulbosum, on chromosomes 5B and 5A, respectively. The location of Kr1 was established using the telocentric mapping technique and found to be on the long arm of chromosome 5B, distal to the centromere with a mean recombination frequency of 44.8±3.28%. Kr2 was located on the long arm of chromosome 5A by linkage with the major gene markers Vrn1, controlling vernalization requirement, and q, controlling ear morphology. Kr2 is closely linked to Vrn1, with a mean recombination frequency of 4.8±4.66%, and is distal to q with a mean recombination frequency of 38.1±10.60%. The similar locations of Kr1 and Kr2 on homoeologous chromosomes suggest that these two loci are homoeoallelic. Significant correlations between Hordeum bulbosum and rye crossability confirmed that Kr1 and Kr2 control the crossability of wheat with both species.     

A comparison of physical distribution of recombination in chromosome 1R in diploid rye and in hexaploid triticale

Summary Polymorphism for six C-bands on chromosome 1R was used to study the frequency and distribution of recombination along the chromosome in a diploid rye (Secale cereale L.) and in a hexaploid triticale (X Triticosecale Wittmack) derived from it. In rye, the total recombination frequency in five segments of chromosome 1R was 93.7%. Recombination was concentrated in the distal regions of both chromosome arms and was infrequent in the proximal regions. In hexaploid triticale the total recombination frequency in the same chromosome was reduced to 51.7%. In both backgrounds the distal half of the long arm showed similar recombination frequencies, 51.4% and 45.7% for rye and triticale, respectively. The remaining about two-thirds of the chromosome length showed 42.3% recombination in rye but only 6% recombination in triticale. The results demonstrate that the genetic background in which mapping is performed not only affects the total amount of recombination, but also its distribution along the chromosome length.     

Development of wheat–<Emphasis Type="Italic">Lophopyrum elongatum</Emphasis> recombinant lines for enhanced sodium ‘exclusion’ during salinity stress

Lophopyrum elongatum (tall wheatgrass), a wild relative of wheat, can be used as a source of novel genes for improving salt tolerance of bread wheat. Sodium ‘exclusion’ is a major physiological mechanism for salt tolerance in a wheat–tall wheatgrass amphiploid, and a large proportion (~50%) for reduced Na⁺ accumulation in the flag leaf, as compared to wheat, was earlier shown to be contributed by genetic effects from substitution of chromosome 3E from tall wheatgrass for wheat chromosomes 3A and 3D. Homoeologous recombination between 3E and wheat chromosomes 3A and 3D was induced using the ph1b mutant, and putative recombinants were identified as having SSR markers specific for tall wheatgrass loci. As many as 14 recombinants with smaller segments of tall wheatgrass chromatin were identified and low-resolution breakpoint analysis was achieved using wheat SSR loci. Seven recombinants were identified to have leaf Na⁺ concentrations similar to those in 3E(3A) or 3E(3D) substitution lines, when grown in 200 mM NaCl in nutrient solution. Phenotypic analysis identified recombinants with introgressions at the distal end on the long arm of homoeologous group 3 chromosomes being responsible for Na⁺ ‘exclusion’. A total of 55 wheat SSR markers mapped to the long arm of homoeologous group 3 markers by genetic and deletion bin mapping were used for high resolution of wheat–tall wheatgrass chromosomal breakpoints in selected recombinants. Molecular marker analysis and genomic in situ hybridisation confirmed the 524-568 recombinant line as containing the smallest introgression of tall wheatgrass chromatin on the distal end of the long arm of wheat chromosome 3A and identified this line as suitable for developing wheat germplasm with Na⁺ ‘exclusion’.     

Condensation of rye chromatin in somatic interphase nuclei of Ph1 and ph1b wheat

The Ph1 locus in hexaploid wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) enforces diploid-like behavior in the first metaphase of meiosis. To test the hypothesis that this chromosome pairing control is exercised by affecting the degree of chromatin condensation, the dispersion of rye chromatin in interphase nuclei in somatic tissues of wheat-rye chromosome translocations 1RS.1BL, 2RS.2BL, 2BS.2RL, 3RS.3DL and 5RS.5BL was compared in Ph1 and ph1b isogenic backgrounds. No significant differences in rye chromatin condensation that could be attributed to the Ph1 locus were detected. Regardless of the Ph1 status, each rye chromosome arm tested conformed to the general Rabl's orientation and occupied portions of the nuclei proportional to their length. Earlier observations that indicated the involvement of Ph1 locus in rye chromatin condensation in wheat could have been due either to specific loci on the studied 5RL rye arm that control the chromosome condensation process or to damage to the genetic system controlling chromatin condensation in the existing ph1b stocks of wheat. That damage might have been caused by homoeologous recombination and uneven disjunction of chromosomes from multivalents.     

Pairing and recombination between individual chromosomes of wheat and rye in hybrids carrying the ph1b mutation

Wheat-rye chromosome associations at metaphase I studied by Naranjo and Fernández-Rueda (1991) in ph1b ABDR hybrids have been reanalysed to establish the frequency of pairing between individual chromosomes of wheat and rye. Wheat chromosomes, except for 2A and 2D, and their arms were identified by C-banding. Diagnostic C-bands and other cytological markers such as telocentrics or translocations were used to identify each one of the rye chromosomes and their arms. Both the amount of telomeric C-heterochromatin and the structure of the rye chromosomes relative to wheat affected the level of wheatrye pairing. The degree to which rye chromosomes paired with their wheat homoeologues varied with each of the three wheat genomes; in most groups, the B-R association was more frequent than the A-R or D-R associations. Recombination between arms 1RL and 2RL and their homoeologues of wheat possessing a different telomeric C-banding pattern was detected and quantified at anaphase I. The frequency of recombinant chromosomes obtained supports the premise that recombination between wheat and rye chromosomes may be estimated from wheat-rye pairing.     

Comparison of homoeologous chromosome pairing between hybrids of wheat genotypes Chinese Spring ph1b and Kaixian-luohanmai with rye

The ph-like genes in the Chinese common wheat landrace Kaixian-luohanmai (KL) induce homoeologous pairing in hybrids with alien species. In the present study, meiotic phenotypic differences on homoeologous chromosome pairing at metaphase I between hybrids of wheat genotypes Chinese Spring ph1b (CSph1b) and KL with rye were studied by genomic in situ hybridization (GISH). The frequency of wheat-wheat associations was higher in CSph1b×rye than in KL×rye. However, frequencies of wheat-rye and rye-rye associations were higher in KL×rye than in CSph1b×rye. These differences may be the result of different mechanisms of control between the ph-like gene(s) controlling homoeologous chromosome pairing in KL and CSph1b. Wheat-wheat associations were much more frequent than wheat-rye pairing in both hybriods. This may be caused by lower overall affinity, or homoeology, between wheat and rye chromosomes than between wheat chromosomes.     

Genetic and physical mapping of homoeologous recombination points involving wheat chromosome 2B and rye chromosome 2R.

Wide hybrids have been used in generating genetic maps of many plant species. In this study, genetic and physical mapping was performed on ph1b-induced recombinants of rye chromosome 2R in wheat (Triticum aestivum L.). All recombinants were single breakpoint translocations. Recombination 2RS-2BS was absent from the terminal and the pericentric regions and was distributed randomly along an intercalary segment covering approximately 65% of the arm's length. Such a distribution probably resulted from structural differences at the telomeres of 2RS and wheat 2BS arm that disrupted telomeric initiation of pairing. Recombination 2RL-2BL was confined to the terminal 25% of the arm's length. A genetic map of homoeologous recombination 2R-2B was generated using relative recombination frequencies and aligned with maps of chromosomes 2B and 2R based on homologous recombination. The alignment of the short arms showed a shift of homoeologous recombination toward the centromere. On the long arms, the distribution of homoeologous recombination was the same as that of homologous recombination in the distal halves of the maps, but the absence of multiple crossovers in homoeologous recombination eliminated the proximal half of the map. The results confirm that homoeologous recombination in wheat is based on single exchanges per arm, indicate that the distribution of these single homoeologous exchanges is similar to the distribution of the first (distal) crossovers in homologues, and suggest that successive crossovers in an arm generate specific portions of genetic maps. A difference in the distribution of recombination between the short and long arms indicates that the distal crossover localization in wheat is not dictated by a restricted distribution of DNA sequences capable of recombination but by the pattern of pairing initiation, and that can be affected by structural differences. Restriction of homoeologous recombination to single crossovers in the distal part of the genetic map complicates chromosome engineering efforts targeting genes in the proximal map regions.     

Chromosome pairing relationships among the A,B, and D genomes of bread wheat

Summary Chromosome pairing and chiasma frequency were studied in bread wheat euhaploids (2n = 3x = 21; ABD genomes) with and without the major pairing regulatorPh1. This constitutes the first report of chromosome pairing relationships among the A, B, and D genomes of wheat without the influence of an alien genome. AllPh1 euhaploids had very little pairing, with 0.62–1.05 rod bivalents per cell; ring bivalents were virtually absent and mean arm-binding frequency (c) values ranged from 0.050 to 0.086. In contrast, theph1b euhaploids had extensive homoeologous pairing, with chiasma frequency 7.5–11.6 times higher than that in thePh1 euhaploids. They had 0.53–1.16 trivalents, 1.53–1.74 ring bivalents, and 2.90–3.57 rod bivalents, withc from 0.580 to 0.629. N-banding of meiotic chromosomes showed strongly preferential pairing between chromosomes of the A and D genomes; 80% of the pairing was between these genomes, especially in the presence of theph1b allele. The application of mathematical models to unmarked chromosomes also supported a 21 genomic structure of theph1b euhaploids. Numerical modeling suggested that about 80% of the metaphase I association was between the two most related genomes in the presence ofph1b, but that pairing under Ph1 was considerably more random. The data demonstrate that the A and D genomes are much more closely related to each other than either is to B. These results may have phylogenetic significance and hence breeding implications.This paper is dedicated to the memory of the late Ernest R. SearsCooperative investigations of the USDA-Agricultural Research Service and the Utah Agricultural Experiment Station, Logan, UT 84322, USA. Approved as Journal Paper No. 3986     

Meiotic homoeologous recombination-based mapping of wheat chromosome 2B and its homoeologues in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Aegilops speltoides</Emphasis> and <Emphasis Type="Italic">Thinopyrum elongatum</Emphasis>

Key message

We physically dissected and mapped wheat chromosome 2B and its homoeologues in Aegilops speltoides and Thinopyrum elongatum based on meiotic homoeologous recombination, providing a unique physical framework for genome studies.

Abstract

Common wheat has a large and complex genome with narrow genetic diversity and various degrees of recombination between the A, B, and D subgenomes. This has limited the homologous recombination-based genome studies in wheat. Here, we exploited meiotic homoeologous recombination for molecular mapping of wheat chromosome 2B and its homoeologue 2S from Aegilops speltoides and 2E from Thinopyrum elongatum. The 2B–2S and 2B–2E recombination was induced by the ph1b mutant, and recovered using molecular markers and fluorescent genomic in situ hybridization (FGISH). A total of 112 2B–2S and 87 2B–2E recombinants involving different chromosome regions were developed and physically delineated by FGISH. The 2B–2S and 2B–2E recombination hotspots mapped to the subterminal regions on both arms. Recombination hotspots with the highest recombination rates mapped to the short arms. Eighty-three 2B–2S and 67 2B–2E recombinants were genotyped using the wheat 90 K SNP arrays. Based on the genotyping results and FGISH patterns of the recombinants, chromosomes 2B, 2S, and 2E were partitioned into 93, 66, and 46 bins, respectively. In total, 1037 SNPs physically mapped onto distinct bins of these three homoeologous chromosomes. A homoeologous recombination-based bin map was constructed for chromosome 2B, providing a unique physical framework for genome studies in wheat and its relatives. Meiotic homoeologous recombination also facilitates gene introgression to diversify the wheat genome for germplasm development. Therefore, homoeologous recombination-based studies enhance understanding of the wheat genome and its homoeologous counterparts from wild grasses, and expand the genetic variability of the wheat genome.

     

A simple PCR-based method for scoring the ph1b deletion in wheat

 The amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) technique was used to isolate DNA sequences present in the euploid wheat Chinese Spring but not in the Chinese Spring ph1b mutant (which has a deletion of the Ph1 gene, a suppressor of homoeologous chromosome pairing). The polymorphic DNA fragments identified by AFLP were then cloned, sequenced, and used to design two primer pairs. These primers were used in a PCR-based assay to specifically amplify products from the Chinese Spring euploid but not from the ph1b mutant. This PCR assay can be carried out from extracted genomic DNA or directly from alkaline-treated wheat leaves, and the reaction products can be scored on a plus-minus basis, making the screening amenable to automation. The reliability of the assay was tested using a F₁-derived doubled-haploid population of 55 lines which segregate for the ph1b deletion. This PCR-screening technique is less time and labour consuming, and more accurate and reliable, than cytologically based conventional methods. Received: 4 September 1997 / Accepted: 19 September 1997     

Homoeologous relationships of Triticum sharonense chromosomes to T. aestivum

 Homoeologous pairing at metaphase I was analyzed in standard-type, ph2b, and ph1b hybrids of Triticum aestivum (common, bread or hexaploid wheat) and T. sharonense in order to establish the homoeologus relationships of T. sharonense chromosomes to hexaploid wheat. Chromosomes of both species, and their arms, were identified by C-banding. Normal homoeologous relationships for the seven chromosomes of the S^sh genome, and their arms, were revealed, which implies that no apparent chromosome rearrangement occurred in the evolution of T. sharonense relative to wheat. All three types of hybrids with low-, intermediate-, and high-pairing level showed preferential pairing between A-D and B-S^sh. A close relationship of the S^sh genome to the B genome of bread wheat was confirmed, but the results provide no evidence that the B genome was derived from T. sharonense. Data on the pairing between individual chromosomes of T. aestivum and T. sharonense provide an estimate of interspecific homoeologous recombination. Received: 14 October 1996 / Accepted: 25 October 1996     

A molecular linkage map of rye

A genetic map of six chromosomes of rye, (all of the rye chromosomes except for 2R), was constructed using 77 RFLP and 12 RAPD markers. The map was developed using an F₂ population of 54 plants from a cross between two inbred lines. A rye genomic library was constructed as a source of clones for RFLP mapping. Comparisons were made between the rye map and other rye and wheat maps by including additional probes previously mapped in those species. These comparisons allowed (1) chromosome arm orientation to the linkage groups to be given, (2) the corroboration of several evolutionary translocations between rye chromosomes and homoeologous chromosomes of wheat; (3) an increase in the number of available markers for target regions of rye that show colinearity with wheat. Inconsistencies in the location of markers between the wheat and rye maps were mostly detected by multi-copy probes.     

Rye chromosome translocations in hexaploid wheat: a re-evaluation of the loss of heterochromatin from rye chromosomes

Summary Using in situ hybridization techniques, we have been able to identify the translocated chromosomes resulting from whole arm interchanges between homoeologous chromosomes of wheat and rye. This was possible because radioactive probes are available which recognize specific sites of highly repeated sequence DNA in either rye or wheat chromosomes. The translocated chromosomes analysed in detail were found in plants from a breeding programme designed to substitute chromosome 2R of rye into commercial wheat cultivars. The distribution of rye highly repeated DNA sequences showed modified chromosomes in which (a) most of the telomeric heterochromatin of the short arm and (b) all of the telomeric heterochromatin of the long arm, had disappeared. Subsequent analyses of these chromosomes assaying for wheat highly repeated DNA sequences showed that in type (a), the entire short arm of 2R had been replaced by the short arm of wheat chromosome 2B and in (b), the long arm of 2R had been replaced by the long arm of 2B. The use of these probes has also allowed us to show that rye heterochromatin has little effect on the pairing of the translocated wheat arm to its wheat homologue during meiosis. We have also characterized the chromosomes resulting from a 1B-1R translocation event.From these results, we suggest that the observed loss of telomeric heterochromatin from rye chromosomes in wheat is commonly due to wheat-rye chromosome translocations.