The requirement for DIF for prestalk and stalk cell formation in Dictyostelium discoideum: a comparison of in vivo and in vitro differentiation conditions

In Dictyostelium discoideum stalk cell formation is induced by cyclic AMP and differentiation-inducing factor (DIF) when cells are plated in in vitro monolayers (Kay et al., 1979, Differentiation 13: 7-14). The in vivo developmental stages at which cells became independent of these factors were determined. Independence was defined as the stage at which dispersed cells no longer required the factors for stalk cell formation in low density monolayers. Cyclic AMP independent cells were first detected at around 12 hr of development, a time that corresponds to the transition between the tipped aggregate and the first finger stages. In contrast cells did not become independent of DIF until late culmination. The prestalk cell-specific isozyme acid phosphatase II and a stalk cell-specific 41,000 Mr antigen (ST 41) were expressed during differentiation in low density monolayers in the presence of both cyclic AMP and DIF, but neither component was expressed in the presence of cyclic AMP alone. This result implies that DIF is essential for both prestalk and stalk cell formation. The two components were expressed within 2 hr of each other during differentiation in vitro, whereas during development in vivo acid phosphatase II was first detected at the first finger stage and ST 41 was first detected during late culmination, 8-12 hr later. These contrasting results suggest that the conversion of prestalk cells to stalk cells is unrestrained in monolayers, following directly after prestalk cell induction, but restrained in vivo until the culmination stage. This interpretation is consistent with the finding that cells become independent of DIF early during in vitro differentiation (A. Sobolewski, N. Neave, and G. Weeks, 1983, Differentiation 25, 93-100), but do not become independent of DIF until the culmination stage when differentiating in vivo.     

Studies on the accumulation of the differentiation-inducing factor (DIF) in high-cell-density monolayers of Dictyostelium discoideum

A number of factors that have been shown to influence cell type determination in Dictyostelium discoideum were assessed for their effects on the accumulation of the stalk cell differentiation-inducing factor (DIF) in high-cell-density monolayers of strain V12-M2. DIF accumulation is markedly enhanced by low pH, butyrate, and the proton pump inhibitor diethylstilbestrol (DES), conditions that induce stalk cell formation in low-cell-density monolayers in the absence of added DIF. These results are discussed in relation to a model for cell type determination recently proposed by (J.D. Gross, M.J. Peacey, and R. Pogge Von Strandmann (1988, Differentiation, 38: 91-98). DIF accumulates in high-cell-density monolayers after the cells have become independent of cyclic AMP for stalk cell formation. This accumulation is greatly enhanced by the addition of cyclic AMP. This result may explain why cyclic AMP stimulates stalk cell formation in low-density monolayers in the presence of suboptimal levels of DIF, following preincubation in the presence of saturating levels of cyclic AMP (L. Kwong, A. Sobolewski, and G. Weeks, 1988, Differentiation 37, 1-6). Adenosine has no effect on DIF accumulation in high-cell-density monolayers.     

Developmental regulation of a stalk cell differentiation-inducing factor in Dictyostelium discoideum

Previous work has shown that cells developing at high density release a low-molecular-weight factor that can induce isolated Dictyostelium discoideum amoebae of strain V12M2 to differentiate into stalk cells in the presence of cyclic AMP. We now show that this differentiation-inducing factor, called DIF, can be extracted from cells during normal development and that its production is strongly developmentally regulated. DIF is not detectable in vegetative cells but rises dramatically after aggregation to reach a peak during slug migration. DIF levels are very low in two mutants defective in aggregation. The postaggregative synthesis of DIF is stimulated by the addition of extracellular cyclic AMP. We propose that DIF is a morphogen controlling prestalk cell differentiation.     

Cyclic AMP is an inhibitor of stalk cell differentiation in Dictyostelium discoideum

Cyclic AMP and DIF-1 (1-(3,5-dichloro-2,6-dihydroxy-4-methoxyphenyl)-1-hexanone) together induce stalk cell differentiation in vitro in Dictyostelium discoideum strain V12M2. The induction can proceed in two stages: in the first, cyclic AMP brings cells to a DIF-responsive state; in the second, DIF-1 alone can induce stalk cell formation. We report here that during the DIF-1-dependent stage, cyclic AMP is a potent inhibitor of stalk cell differentiation. Addition of cyclic AMP at this stage to V12M2 cells appreciably delays, but does not prevent, stalk cell formation. In contrast, stalk cell differentiation in the more common strain NC4 is completely suppressed by the continued presence of cyclic AMP. This fact explains earlier failures to induce stalk cells in vitro in NC4. We now consistently obtain efficient stalk cell induction in NC4 by removing cyclic AMP in the DIF-1-dependent stage. Cyclic AMP also inhibits the production of a stalk-specific protein (ST310) in both NC4 and a V12M2 derivative. Adenosine, a known antagonist of cyclic AMP action, does not relieve this inhibition by cyclic AMP and does not itself promote stalk cell formation. Finally, stalk cell differentiation of NC4 cells at low density appears to require factors in addition to cyclic AMP and DIF-1, but their nature is not yet known. The inhibition of stalk cell differentiation by cyclic AMP may be important in establishing the prestalk/prespore pattern during normal development, and in preventing the maturation of prestalk into stalk cells until culmination.     

Stalk cell formation in monolayers of Dictyostelium discoideum V12-M2

Stalk cell formation in low-cell-density monolayers of Dictyostelium discoideum, strain V12-M2, occurs following the sequential addition of cyclic AMP and the differentiation-inducing factor (DIF). Both cyclic AMP and DIF are essential for the appearance of the prestalk-specific isozyme alkaline phosphatase-II, which suggests that both factors are necessary for prestalk cell formation. The available evidence suggests that the cyclic AMP requirement for stalk cell formation is mediated through the cell surface cyclic AMP receptor. However, stalk cell formation is inhibited by caffeine and this inhibition is reversed by the cell-permeable analogue 8-Br-cyclic AMP, which suggests in addition a possible involvement for elevated intracellular cyclic AMP concentrations in stalk cell formation. During in vivo development cells first become independent of cyclic AMP at the tipped aggregate stage, but the acquisition of cyclic AMP independence is advanced by several hours when cells are incubated in the presence of cyclic AMP for 2 hours. Cells do not become independent of DIF until the culmination stage of development, which suggests the possibility that DIF is required for the conversion of prestalk cells to stalk cells. There is an absolute requirement for DIF for stalk cell formation in low-density monolayers of prestalk cells but only part of population exhibits a requirement for cyclic AMP, which suggests that the prestalk cell population consists of two distinct cell types. Stalk cell formation from prespore cells is totally dependent on both cyclic AMP and DIF.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Stalk cell formation in monolayers from isolated prestalk and prespore cells of Dictyostelium discoideum: evidence for two populations of prestalk cells

Cells from the pseudoplasmodial stage of Dictyostelium discoideum differentiation were dispersed and separated on Percoll gradients into prestalk and prespore cells. The requirements for stalk cell formation in low-density monolayers from the two cell types were determined. The isolated prespore cells required both the Differentiation Inducing Factor (DIF) and cyclic AMP for stalk cell formation. In contrast, only part of the isolated prestalk cell population required both cyclic AMP and DIF, the remainder requiring DIF alone, suggesting the possibility that there were two populations of prestalk cells, one independent of cyclic AMP and one dependent on cyclic AMP for stalk cell formation. The finding that part of the prestalk cell population required only a brief incubation in the presence of DIF to induce stalk cell formation, whilst the remainder required a considerably longer incubation in the presence of both DIF and cyclic AMP was consistent with this idea. In addition, stalk cell formation from cyclic-AMP-dependent prestalk cells was relatively more sensitive to caffeine inhibition than stalk cell formation from cyclic-AMP-independent prestalk cells. The latter cells were enriched in the most anterior portion of the migrating pseudoplasmodium, indicating that there is spatial segregation of the two prestalk cell populations. The conversion of prespore cells to stalk cells took longer and was more sensitive to caffeine when compared to stalk cell formation from cyclic-AMP-dependent prestalk cells.     

A specific DIF binding protein in Dictyostelium

Differentiation Inducing Factor (DIF-1), a small chlorinated organic molecule which is produced during Dictyostelium development, is believed to be the morphogen that controls the stalk-specific pathway of differentiation. We describe the identification and characterization of a protease-sensitive activity from cell lysates which binds tritiated DIF-1 with the properties expected of a DIF receptor. Scatchard and linear subtraction plots show a single class of binding sites, of high affinity (Kd = 1.8 nM) and low abundance (1100 sites/cell). The activity elutes from heparin-agarose as a single peak. Various DIF-1 analogues compete for binding in proportion to their activities in a stalk cell differentiation bioassay. The amount of binding activity is developmentally regulated, peaking shortly before the appearance of the prestalk-prespore pattern and before the developmental rise in DIF concentration; the rise occurs at the same time that prestalk-specific genes become DIF inducible. Addition of cyclic AMP to aggregated cells, which induces post-aggregative gene expression in general, also induces the binding activity.     

Morphogenesis and differentiation of Dictyostelium cells interacting with immobilized glucosides: dependence on DIF production

Previous work has shown that multicellular morphogenesis of submerged Dictyostelium cells is inhibited when they bind to glucosides covalently linked to polyacrylamide gels. The amoebae aggregate normally, but then the aggregates repeatedly disperse and reaggregate, whereas control cells go on to form tight aggregates. We have investigated the role of the stalk cell differentiation inducing factors (DIFs) in this process. In the presence of cyclic AMP, amoebae submerged at high cell density accumulate DIF and differentiate into stalk cells. We find that stalk cell differentiation is inhibited by interaction of the cells with glucoside gels in these conditions, but can be restored by the addition of exogenous DIF-1. Since the responsiveness of cells to DIF-1 is not altered, it appears likely that the effect of the glucoside gel is to block DIF-1 production. Further, the addition of DIF-1 or DIF-2 stimulates the formation of tight aggregates by cells developing on glucoside gels in the absence of cyclic AMP, thus preventing the rounds of aggregation and disaggregation otherwise seen. This suggests a role for DIF in morphogenesis as well as in controlling cell differentiation. We propose a model in which immobilized glucosides activate a specific receptor ("food sensor") which drives the amoebae toward the vegetative state and inhibits DIF accumulation. DIF, on the other hand, induces tight aggregate formation and so locks the amoebae into the developmental program.     

The effects of presumptive morphogens on prestalk and prespore cell gene expression in monolayers of Dictyostelium discoideum

Abstract. The expression of three prestalk cell-specific genes ( ecm A, ecm B and pDd26) was examined during in vitro differentiation in cell monolayers, in an attempt to explain the spatial heterogeneity of the prestalk region of migrating Dictyostelium pseudoplasmodia. Under these conditions ecm A, ecm B and pDd26 mRNAs were expressed sequentially in response to the addition of differentiation inducing factor-1 (DIF)-1, a temporal sequence similar to that observed during normal development. ecm A and ecm B mRNAs reached a maximum level 2–4 h after DIF-1 supplementation and then declined, whereas pDd26 mRNA levels increased more slowly but remained high 24 h after DIF addition. The increases in expression in response to increasing concentrations of either DIF-1 or DIF-2 were identical for the three genes, suggesting that neither alteration in DIF concentration nor species was an important determinant of spatial heterogeneity. Ammonia had the same inhibitory effect on the expression of all three prestalk cell-specific genes and stimulated the expression of the prespore cell-specific gene, D19. These results indicate that ammonia is also not responsible for the spatial heterogeneity of the prestalk cell region. In contrast, cyclic AMP had a differential effect on the expression of the prestalk cell specific genes: ecm A expression was variably stimulated, pDd26 expression was inhibited and ecm B expression was sometimes stimulated and sometimes inhibited. These results are difficult to explain in terms of a gradient of cyclic AMP in the prestalk region. We postulate that temporal responses are more important than spatial responses to cyclic AMP in regulating stalk cell differentiation.     

Signals controlling cell differentiation and pattern formation in Dictyostelium

The major inducers of cell differentiation in Dictyostelium appear to be cyclic AMP and DIF-1. Recently we have chemically identified DIF-1, together with the closely related DIF-2 and -3. They represent a new chemical class of potent effector molecules, based on a phenyl alkanone with chloro, hydroxy, and methoxy substitution of the benzene ring. Previous work has shown that DIF-1 can induce prestalk-specific gene expression within 15 min, whereas it suppresses prespore differentiation. Hence, DIF-1 can control the choice of pathway of cell differentiation in Dictyostelium and is therefore likely to be involved in establishing the prestalk/prespore pattern in the aggregate. In support of this, we show that DIF treatment of slugs results in an enlarged prestalk zone. Cyclic AMP seems less likely to have such a pathway-specific role, but later in development it becomes inhibitory to stalk cell differentiation. This inhibition may be important in suppressing terminal stalk cell differentiation until culmination. Spore differentiation can be induced efficiently by high levels of Br-cyclic AMP, a permeant analogue of cyclic AMP. In this, it phenocopies certain spore-maturation mutants, and we propose that during normal development spore differentiation is triggered by an elevation in intracellular cyclic AMP levels. How this elevation in cyclic AMP levels is brought about is not known. The experiments with Br-cyclic AMP also provide the first direct evidence that elevated levels of intracellular cyclic AMP induce differentiation in Dictyostelium.     

Differential effect of sodium butyrate on cyclic AMP phosphodiesterase activities in butyrate sensitive and resistant mastocytoma cells

The effect of sodium butyrate on the intracellular cyclic AMP levels and the activities of cyclic AMP-regulating enzymes were examined in two types of mastocytoma p-815 cells in culture: one type (S cell) was sensitive and the other (R cell) was resistant to the induction of differentiation by sodium butyrate. In the presence of sodium butyrate, adenylate cyclase activity increased in both S and R cells to the same degree, whereas the level of cyclic AMP was elevated only in S cells. Cyclic AMP phosphodiesterase activity increased in R cells but not in S cells. Cyclic AMP phosphodiesterase activities of two cell populations differed in their response to sodium butyrate and they seem to have an important role in regulating cellular level of cyclic AMP that might be an important factor in controlling cell differentiation.     

The effect of ammonia on stalk cell formation in submerged monolayers of Dictyostelium discoideum

It has been shown that ammonia inhibits stalk cell formation in monolayers of V12M2, and it was suggested that this inhibition was due to an antagonism of the differentiation-inducing factor (DIF) (Gross, J.D. et al., Nature, 303, 244-246, 1983). However, the results presented here indicate that ammonia inhibition is independent of DIF concentration, and that it occurs well in advance of the period of DIF requirement. Ammonia completely inhibits DIF accumulation and inhibits stalk cell differentiation, but there is no inhibition of prespore cell formation. These results imply the existence of an early ammonia-sensitive event that influences terminal cell type differentiation.     

The effect of cAMP on differentiation inducing factor (DIF)-mediated formation of stalk cells in low-cell-density monolayers of Dictyostelium discoideum

Abstract. The requirement for cyclic AMP (cAMP) for stalk-cell formation in low-density monolayers of Dictyoste-lium discoideum , is mediated through the cell-surface cAMP receptor. Stalk-cell formation is markedly inhibited by the cAMP relay inhibitor, caffeine. This inhibition is reversed by high concentrations of 8-Br-cAMP, a highly cell-perme-abie analog of cAMP. These results suggest that elevated intracellular concentrations of cAMP are necessary for stalk-cell formation. The induction of stalk-cell formation in monolayers can be divided into a cAMP-dependent period and a differentiation inducing factor (DIF)-dependent period [21]. Despite this clearcut separation of the cAMP and DIF induction periods, cAMP enhanced the effects of DIF at low DIF concentrations. Evidence is presented that this was not a direct cooperative effect. The effect of caffeine was inhibitory during both periods and was not reversed by a combination of DIF and cAMP. Ammonia inhibited stalk-cell formation at all stages of the differentiation process, but the inhibition engendered during the initial cAMP-induction period was reversed by a combination of DIF and cAMP.     

Dictyostelium mutants lacking DIF,a putative morphogen

DIF is an endogenous extracellular signal that may control differentiation of D. discoideum cells. It is a dialyzable, lipid-like factor that induces stalk cell formation among isolated amebae incubated in vitro with cAMP. To examine the consequences of DIF deprivation, we have isolated several mutant strains that are impaired in DIF accumulation, and whose inability to make stalk cells in vitro and during normal development on agar can be corrected by the addition of exogenous DIF. Little DIF is made by the mutants, and morphological development on agar stops after the cells have aggregated, but before a slug forms. In these DIF-deprived conditions, prespore cells can differentiate, but prestalk cells cannot.     

Cyclic AMP induces the synthesis of developmentally regulated plasma membrane proteins in Dictyostelium.

Dictyostelium discoideum slugs (pseudoplasmodia) were disaggregated and the resynthesis of developmentally regulated plasma membrane proteins examined. The synthesis of the majority of these proteins was inhibited when cells were overlaid with Cellophane and maintained as a monolayer. However, cell contact and movement did occur under the Cellophane. The inhibition of differentiation may result from the inability of the cells to organize specifically into multicellular aggregates. The addition of cyclic AMP (1--5 mM) induced the synthesis of certain developmentally regulated plasma membrane proteins in cells overlaid with Cellophane. Hence, this confirms other work showing that cyclic AMP is required for at least some post-aggregative gene expression. Specific cell organisation and interactions are apparently required for an increase in or maintenance of intracellular cyclic AMP levels.     

A Dictyostelium morphogen that is essential for stalk cell formation is generated by a subpopulation of prestalk cells

The stalk cell differentiation inducing factor (DIF) has the properties required of a morphogen responsible for pattern regulation during the pseudoplasmodial stage of Dictyostelium development. It induces prestalk cell formation and inhibits prespore cell formation, but there is as yet no strong evidence for a morphogenetic gradient of DIF. We have measured DIF accumulation by monolayers of isolated prestalk and prespore cells in an attempt to provide evidence for such a gradient. DIF is accumulated in the largest quantities by a subpopulation of prestalk cells that specifically express the DIF-inducible genes pDd56 and pDd26. Since it has been shown recently that cells that express pDd56 are localized in the central core of the prestalk cell region of the pseudoplasmodia, our current results suggest a morphogenetic gradient generated by this region.     

Cyclic AMP induces the synthesis of developmentally regulated plasma membrane proteins in Dictyostelium

Dictyostelium discoideum slugs (pseudoplasmodia) were disaggregated and the resynthesis of developmentally regulated plasma membrane proteins examined. The synthesis of the majority of these proteins was inhibited when cells were overlaid with Cellophane and maintained as a monolayer. However, cell contact and movement did occur under the Cellophane. The inhibition of differentiation may result from the inability of the cells to organise specifically into multicellular aggregates. The addition of cyclic AMP (1–5 mM) induced the synthesis of certain developmentally regulated plasma membrane proteins in cells overlaid with Cellophane. Hence, this confirms other work showing that cyclic AMP is required for at least some post-aggregative gene expression. Specific cell organisation and interactions are apparently required for an increase in or maintenance of intracellular cyclic AMP levels.     

Culmination in Dictyostelium is regulated by the cAMP-dependent protein kinase.

We placed a specific inhibitor of cyclic AMP-dependent protein kinase (PKA) under the control of a prestalk-specific promoter. Cells containing this construct form normally patterned slugs, but under environmental conditions that normally trigger immediate culmination, the slugs undergo prolonged migration. Slugs that eventually enter culmination do so normally but arrest as elongated, hairlike structures that contain neither stalk nor spore cells. Mutant cells do not migrate to the stalk entrance when codeveloped with wild-type cells and show greatly reduced inducibility by DIF, the stalk cell morphogen. These results suggest that the activity of PKA is necessary for the altered pattern of movement of prestalk cells at culmination and their differentiation into stalk cells. We propose a model whereby a protein repressor, under the control of PKA, inhibits precocious induction of stalk cell differentiation by DIF and so regulates the choice between slug migration and culmination.     

A possible role for DIF-2 in the formation of stalk cells during Dictyostelium development.

The differentiation inducing factor (DIF) is essential for stalk cell formation in monolayers of Dictyostelium discoideum and is necessary for the expression of several prestalk cell-specific genes. DIF activity has been fractionated into a major species, designated DIF-1, and several minor species, including DIF-2. Although DIF-1 is an excellent inducer of stalk cell formation from vegetative cells, it is a poor inducer of stalk cell formation from prestalk cells. In contrast, DIF-2 is more active for the conversion of prestalk cells into stalk cells, than for the conversion of vegetative cells to stalk cells. The same results were obtained regardless of whether chemically synthesized or naturally occurring components were utilized. In addition, stalk cell formation was three- to fourfold higher when vegetative cells were incubated with DIF-1 for a suboptimal period and then subsequently incubated with DIF-2, than when cells were incubated with DIF-2 first and then subsequently with DIF-1. These results indicate a distinct role for DIF-2 during stalk cell formation and suggest the possibility that DIF-1 and DIF-2 act sequentially.