Nonhomologous DNA end rejoining in chromosomal aberration formation

The role of recombination of nonhomologous DNA ends in chromosomal aberration formation was investigated in Chinese hamster ovary cells. Restriction enzymes that produce blunt, 3′ overhanging, or 5′ overhanging DNA double-strand breaks were electroporated into cells in various combinations, and chromosomal aberrations were analyzed at metaphase. For all enzyme combinations tested, there was a significant increase in the frequency of aberrations whose formation requires two breaks in the DNA over the sum obtained when each of the enzymes was tested separately and the aberration frequencies were totaled. No such pattern existed for terminal deletions, which presumably require only one DNA break. The extent of interaction did not depend on the homology in the overhanging sequences or on the combination of ends used, although the largest effect was seen with a combination of two blunt ends. This study shows that nonhomologous DNA double-strand breaks can interact to increase chromosomal aberration formation significantly.     

Cell electroporation is a highly efficient method for introducing restriction endonucleases into cells

Restriction endonucleases that make either blunt- or cohesive-end DNA double-strand breaks can induce chromosome aberrations. We have used cell electroporation with great success to permeabilize Chinese hamster ovary cells for the introduction of restriction enzymes. The introduction of restriction enzymes by this method resulted in extremely high frequencies (greater than 90%) of aberrant metaphase cells and also a dramatic decrease in cell survival, as measured by subsequent colony formation. Cell electroporation by itself caused no increase in aberrant chromosomes and had only a slight effect on cell survival.     

Potentiation of DNA damage by inhibition of poly(ADP-ribosyl)ation: a test of the hypothesis for random nuclease action.

Poly(ADP-ribosyl)ation is a cellular response to DNA strand breaks by which a large array of proteins becomes covalently modified for a brief period during the lifetime of the DNA breaks. Inhibition of poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase by 3-aminobenzamide after many types of DNA damage leads to a marked increase in DNA strand breakage, repair replication, cytogenetic damage, mutagenesis, and cell killing. It has been hypothesized that poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase may modify potentially degradative endogenous nucleases that can reduce cellular viability. Thus, in the presence of DNA strand breakage, the polymer would bind these enzymes to inhibit their activity. When synthesis of the polymerase is inhibited, the enzymes would act randomly to produce nonspecific damage in the DNA. We tested this hypothesis by electroporating restriction enzymes into human cells containing the shuttle vector pHAZE. Restriction enzymes cleave at specific recognition sequences in the lacZ target gene of pHAZE, and mutations result from rejoining errors at the cleavage sites. If the hypothesis were correct, enzyme-treated cells cultured with 3-aminobenzamide to inhibit synthesis of poly(ADP-ribose) polymers would result in a significant increase in mutations outside the restriction enzyme sites. The spectrum of mutations observed after electroporation of PvuII (which produces blunt-end double-strand breaks) or PvuI (which produces cohesive-end double-strand breaks) was similar in untreated and 3-aminobenzamide-treated cells. Thus, our results do not support the hypothesis that the increase in damage observed when poly(ADP-ribosyl)ation is inhibited is due to a chaotic, nonspecific attack on DNA by endogenous cellular nucleases.     

Enzymatic restriction of mammalian cell DNA using Pvu II and Bam H1: evidence for the double-strand break origin of chromosomal aberrations

Permeabilized Chinese hamster cells were treated with the restriction enzymes Pvu II and Bam H1 which generate blunt-ended with cohesive-ended double-strand breaks in the DNA respectively. Cells were then allowed to progress to the first mitosis, where chromosomal aberrations were scored. It was found that blunt-ended double-strand breaks induced both chromosome and chromatid aberrations of exchange and deletion types, including a high frequency of tri-radials. The total aberration frequency at high enzyme concentrations was more than ten times the control background frequency. Treatment with Bam H1 on the other hand did not induce aberrations above the background rate. This may indicate that the cohesive ends generated by this enzyme may be easily repaired by the cell due to the stabilization of the hydrogen bonding at the site of the double-strand break. Measurements using the unwinding method showed that the enzymes caused strand breaks in the DNA of permeabilized cells, and an approximate X-ray dose equivalent of the restriction-enzyme-induced breaks could be calculated. This indicated that restriction-induced blunt-ended double-strand breaks are relatively inefficient in causing chromosomal aberrations. This may be because of the presence of 'clean ends' at the site of a double-strand break, which may be repaired by ligation. The method of introducing restriction enzymes into cells opens up a new model approach for the study of the conversion of double-strand breaks into chromosome aberrations.     

Modulation of restriction enzyme-induced damage by chemicals that interfere with cellular responses to DNA damage: a cytogenetic and pulsed-field gel analysis

The electroporation of restriction enzymes into mammalian cells results in DNA double-strand breaks that can lead to chromosome aberrations. Four chemicals known to interfere with cellular responses to DNA damage were investigated for their effects on chromosome aberrations induced by AluI and Sau3AI; in addition, the number of DNA double-strand breaks at various times after enzyme treatment was determined by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE). The poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase inhibitor 3-aminobenzamide (3AB) dramatically increased the yield of exchanges and deletions and caused a small but transitory increase in the yield of double-strand breaks induced by the enzymes. 1-beta-D-Arabinofuranosylcytosine, which can inhibit DNA repair either by direct action on DNA polymerases alpha and delta or by incorporation into DNA, potentiated aberration induction but to a lesser extent than 3AB and did not affect the amount of DNA double-strand breakage. Aphidicolin, which inhibits polymerases alpha and delta, had no effect on AluI-induced aberrations but did increase the aberration yield induced by Sau3AI. The postreplication repair inhibitor caffeine had no effect on aberration yields induced by either enzyme. Neither aphidicolin nor caffeine modulated the amount of DNA double-strand breakage as measured by PFGE. These data implicate poly(ADP-ribosyl)ation and polymerases alpha and delta as important components of the cellular processes required for the normal repair of DNA double-strand breaks with blunt or cohesive ends. Comparison of these data with the effect of inhibitors on the frequency of X-ray-induced aberrations leads us to the conclusion that X-ray-induced aberrations can result from the misjoining or nonrejoining of double-strand breaks, particularly breaks with cohesive ends, but that this process accounts for only a portion of the induced aberrations.     

Induction of chromosome damage by restriction enzymes during mitosis.

Once electroporated into the nucleus of eukaryotic cells, restriction enzymes will bind at specific DNA sequences and cleave DNA to make double-strand breaks. These induced breaks can lead to chromosome aberrations and consequently offer one approach to determining the mechanism(s) of aberration formation. Because the higher-order structure of DNA in eukaryotic cells might influence the ability of restriction enzymes to locate their recognition sequence, bind, and cleave DNA, we have investigated whether enzymes will cut DNA during metaphase when the chromosomes are most condensed. Chinese hamster ovary cells synchronized in mitosis and treated with either AluI or Sau3AI showed few chromosome aberrations when held in mitosis for 1, 2, or 3 h after enzyme treatment. However, some disruption of chromosome morphology was seen, especially after exposure to Sau3AI. When cells were allowed to complete one cell cycle after enzyme treatment in the preceding mitosis, there was extensive chromosome damage, with the most abundant type of lesion being the interstitial deletion. It appears that restriction enzymes will cleave the highly condensed DNA in mitotic cells but that decondensation, DNA replication, and recondensation are required before the aberrations are manifested.     

Illegitimate recombination induced by DNA double-strand breaks in a mammalian chromosome.

We examined DNA double-strand-break-induced mutations in the endogenous adenine phosphoribosyl-transferase (APRT) gene in cultured Chinese hamster ovary cells after exposure to restriction endonucleases. PvuII, EcoRV, and StuI, all of which produce blunt-end DNA double-strand breaks, were electroporated into CHO-AT3-2 cells hemizygous at the APRT locus. Colonies of viable cells containing mutations at APRT were expanded, and the mutations that occurred during break repair were analyzed at the DNA sequence level. Restriction enzyme-induced mutations consisted of small deletions of 1 to 36 bp, insertions, and combinations of insertions and deletions at the cleavage sites. Most of the small deletions involved overlaps of one to four complementary bases at the recombination junctions. Southern blot analysis revealed more complex mutations, suggesting translocation, inversion, or insertion of larger chromosomal fragments. These results indicate that blunt-end DNA double-strand breaks can induce illegitimate (nonhomologous) recombination in mammalian chromosomes and that they play an important role in mutagenesis.     

Restriction endonucleases do not induce sister-chromatid exchanges in Chinese hamster ovary cells

Bacterial restriction enzymes offer the unique opportunity to determine the biological and cytogenetic consequences of DNA double-strand breakage. To examine the role of various types of breaks in sister-chromatid exchange (SCE) formation, we used restriction enzymes with different recognition sequences and different cutting frequencies to generate DNA double-strand breaks in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. The restriction enzymes were introduced by electroporation into exponentially growing cells during the second replication cycle in bromodeoxyuridine, and SCEs were analyzed at mitosis. Contrary to results reported by others, we found no increase in SCE frequency in cells exposed to restriction enzymes despite the presence of numerous cells with chromatid aberrations. These data suggest that DNA double-strand breaks do not lead to SCE formation.     

The induction of chromosome aberrations by restriction endonucleases that produce blunt-end or cohesive-end double-strand breaks

Restriction endonucleases have been used to study the involvement of specific types of DNA damages in the production of chromosome aberrations. In this study restriction endonucleases were introduced into viable CHO cells using osmolytic shock of pinocytic vesicles. We compared two cohesive-end cutters, Msp I (CCGG-2-base overlap) and Sau3A I (GATC-4-base overlap) with two blunt-end cutters, Alu I (AGCT) and Rsa I (GTAC). All 4 enzymes were effective at inducing aberrations. The 4-base overlap cohesive-end cutter Sau3A I was approximately as effective as the blunt-end cutter Alu I. We present evidence that cutting frequency rather than cut end-structure is important in determining efficiency of aberration induction. There is over-dispersion of the distribution of dicentrics and rings among cells, and the data could be fitted to a Neyman Type A distribution, a modified Poisson, that indicates that there is a probability distribution both for the entry of the enzyme into a cell nucleus and for the induction of aberrations once the enzyme has entered a cell nucleus. In addition, we used Alu I to determine the sensitivity of cells to aberration induction in the different stages of the cell cycle. Alu I induced aberrations in all stages of the cycle, chromatid-type in S/G2 and chromosome-type in G1. In agreement with data of others, there were variations in sensitivity with cycle stage, and changes in the proportions of the different aberration classes for chromatid-type aberrations.     

Differences in accumulation of blunt- and cohesive-ended double-strand breaks generated by restriction endonucleases in electroporated CHO cells.

Restriction endonucleases (RE) have been used in cytogenetic studies to mimic the DNA double-strand break (dsb)-inducing action of radiation. In the experiments presented here, we have treated electroporated CHO cells with RE and have measured the resulting dsb using the filter elution technique under non-denaturing conditions (pH 9.6). PvuII, which generates blunt-ended dsb, gave rise to a significant number of measurable dsb. The frequency of the dsb induced by PvuII is shown to increase over a 3-12-h post-treatment incubation period, which implies that the RE is active in the cell for a considerable length of time. We postulate that the accumulation of dsb reflects a competition between enzymatic incision and repair of the DNA. The presence of araA, a known inhibitor of DNA synthesis, did not affect the frequency of PvuII-induced breaks indicating a lack of an inhibitory effect of araA on the repair of RE-induced dsb. Two RE which cause cohesive-ended dsb, namely BamHI and EcoRI, were found to be ineffective in giving rise to measurable dsb. Our interpretation of this is that for cohesive-ended dsb (caused by BamHI and EcoRI) the rate at which these breaks are rejoined matches or exceeds the rate of enzymatic incision and hence no dsb were observed. In the case of PvuII, the possibly slower rate of repair of blunt-ended termini would on this hypothesis result in the observed net accumulation of dsb.     

Inducible expression and cytogenetic effects of the EcoRI restriction endonuclease in Chinese hamster ovary cells.

The cytogenetic endpoints sister chromatid exchange (SCE) and chromosome aberrations are widely used as indicators of DNA damage induced by mutagenic carcinogens. Chromosome aberrations appear to result directly from DNA double-strand breaks, but the lesion(s) giving rise to SCE formation remains unknown. Most compounds that induce SCEs induce a spectrum of lesions in DNA. To investigate the role of double-strand breakage in SCE formation, we constructed a plasmid that gives rise to one specific lesion, a staggered-end ("cohesive") DNA double-strand break. This plasmid, designated pMENs, contains a selectable marker, neo, which is a bacterial gene for neomycin resistance, and the coding sequence for the bacterial restriction endonuclease EcoRI attached to the mouse metallothionein gene promoter. EcoRI recognizes G decreases AATTC sequences in DNA and makes DNA double-strand breaks with four nucleotides overhanging as staggered ends. Cells transfected with pMENS were resistant to the antibiotic G418 and contained an integrated copy of the EcoRI gene, detectable by DNA filter hybridization. The addition of the heavy metal CdSO4 resulted in the intracellular production of EcoRI, as measured by an anti-EcoRI antibody. Cytogenetic analysis after the addition of CdSO4 indicated a dramatic increase in the frequency of chromosome aberrations but very little effect on SCE frequency. Although there was some intercellular heterogeneity, these results confirm that DNA double-strand breaks do result in chromosome aberrations but that these breaks are not sufficient to give rise to SCE formation.     

Effect of linear energy transfer (LET) on the complexity of alpha-particle-induced chromosome aberrations in human CD34+ cells

The aim of this study was to assess the relative influence of the linear energy transfer (LET) of alpha particles on the complexity of chromosome aberrations in the absence of significant other differences in track structure. To do this, we irradiated human hemopoietic stem cells (CD34+) with alpha particles of various incident LETs (110-152 keV/microm, with mean LETs through the cell of 119-182 keV/microm) at an equi-fluence of approximately one particle/cell and assayed for chromosome aberrations by mFISH. Based on a single harvest time to collect early-division mitotic cells, complex aberrations were observed at comparable frequencies irrespective of incident LET; however, when expressed as a proportion of the total exchanges detected, their occurrence was seen to increase with increasing LET. Cycle analysis to predict theoretical DNA double-strand break rejoining cycles was also carried out on all complex chromosome aberrations detected. By doing this we found that the majority of complex aberrations are formed in single non-reducible cycles that involve just two or three different chromosomes and three or four different breaks. Each non-reducible cycle is suggested to represent "an area" of finite size within the nucleus where double-strand break repair occurs. We suggest that the local density of damage induced and the proximity of independent repair areas within the interphase nucleus determine the complexity of aberrations resolved in metaphase. Overall, the most likely outcome of a single nuclear traversal of a single alpha particle in CD34+ cells is a single chromosome aberration per damaged cell. As the incident LET of the alpha particle increases, the likelihood of this aberration being classed as complex is greater.     

Mechanisms for chromosomal aberrations in mammalian cells

Experimental evidence is presented for the involvement of DNA double-strand breaks in the formation of radiation-induced chromosomal aberrations. When X-irradiated cells were post-treated with single-strand specific Neurospora crassa endonuclease (NE), the frequencies of all classes of aberration increased by about a factor 2. Under these conditions, the frequencies of DNA double-strand breaks induced by X-rays (as determined by neutral sucrose-gradient centrifugation), also increased by a factor of 2. The frequency of chromosomal aberrations induced by fast neutrons (which predominantly induce DNA double-strand breaks) was not influenced by post-treatment with NE. Inhibition of poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase, an enzyme that uses DNA with double-strand breaks as an optimal template, by 3-aminobenzamide also increased the frequencies of X-ray-induced chromosomal aberrations, which supports the idea that DNA double-strand breaks are important lesions for the production of chromosomal aberrations induced by ionizing radiation.     

Cytogenetic alterations in field workers routinely exposed to pesticides in Bogota flowers farms

Frequency of cytogenetic alterations (micronuclei and chromosome aberrations), DNA repair deficiencies and acetylcholinesterase activity was determined for field workers in Bogotá, Colombia. These workers were regularly exposed to organophosphate and carbamate insecticides while employed on farms for flower growing. Interviews were conducted with 31 workers associated with occupational risk of pesticides exposure and 30 without exposure. A standard cytogenetic assay was used to determine chromosome aberrations and micronuclei frequencies. In addition, a challenge assay assessed response to gamma-rays as an indication of DNA repair deficiencies--cells were exposed to gamma-rays in vitro and the frequencies of chromosome aberrations in post-irradiation metaphase cells were quantified. The data were evaluated for percentage of aberrant cells, cells with chromosome aberrations and frequencies of chromatid breaks per 100 metaphase cells in each worker. The exposed group had a significantly higher frequency of cells with chromosome aberrations and micronuclei as compared with the non-exposed group (p = 0.02). However, the challenge assay did not indicate a significant difference (p > 0.1). These findings require confirmation by further analytical studies involving larger sample. Cytogenetic and toxicological studies, in conjunction with thorough clinical examination are recommended.     

Induction of chromosomal aberrations in the CHO mutant EM9 and its parental line AA8 by EcoRI restriction endonuclease: electroporation experiments

EcoRI restriction endonuclease (RE), which produces cohesive-ended double-strand breaks (dsb) in DNA, was tested in the ethyl methanesulfonate- and X-ray-sensitive CHO mutant EM9 and its parental cell strain AA8 for its chromosomal aberration-inducing effect. The RE was efficiently introduced by electroporation into AA8 cells, while the mutant cells showed a very high sensitivity to electroporation, which consistently resulted in cell death. Nevertheless, the incubation of EM9 cells in the presence of EcoRI, without electroporation, was sufficient to induce about three times the chromosome damage observed in the electroporated parental cell line AA8 for any given dose of the RE.     

Increased chromosomal radiosensitivity of a Chinese hamster ovary cell line that inducibly expresses the Eco RI restriction endonuclease

We have transfected a Chinese hamster ovary cell line (CHO 6) with a plasmid that inducibly expresses the Eco RI restriction endonuclease gene in the presence of cadmium sulfate (CdSO4). Expression of Eco RI results in DNA double-strand breaks, which can lead to chromosome aberrations. The new line, designated CHO 10, also has a low level of constitutive expression of Eco RI in the absence of CdSO4 without any cytogenetic effect. This suggested that these cells may be efficient at repairing low levels of DNA double-strand breaks. To test this, both cell lines were exposed to ionizing radiation, and aberration yields were analyzed with or without induction of Eco RI. CHO 10 cells showed increased radiosensitivity after G1 irradiation, but after G2 exposure, only doses greater than or equal to 0.4 Gy caused more damage in CHO 10 cells. We conclude that CHO 10 cells can tolerate constitutive expression of Eco RI, but that when the cells are subjected to additional stress, in this case ionizing radiation, they become very sensitive to DNA double-strand breaks.     

Chromosome-type exchange aberrations are induced by inhibiting repair of UVC-induced DNA lesions in quiescent human lymphocytes

Human lymphocytes in the quiescent stage were UVC-irradiated and then incubated for 90 min in the presence of the DNA-repair inhibitor ara-C. The cells were then cultured and analyzed for chromosome aberrations. A single treatment with UVC or ara-C gives rise to a very low yield of dicentrics, whereas the combined treatment can induce a high frequency of these chromosome-type aberrations. The yield in the combined treatment is approximately proportional to the square of the UVC fluence in the range 1-3 J/m2. In addition, the experiments demonstrate that synergistic effects arise when cells are treated with UVC + ara-C and then exposed to X-rays. The results can be explained on the assumption that the UVC + ara-C treatment induces DNA double-strand breaks which, to the first approximation, are randomly distributed over the chromosomes. These breaks are able to interact with each other as well as with X-ray-induced DNA double-strand breaks to form a chromosome-type exchange aberration.     

Induction of chromosome damage by Neurospora endonuclease in repair-inhibited quiescent normal human fibroblasts

The purpose of these experiments was to determine the role of double-strand breaks in chromosome aberration formations. Quiescent normal human fibroblasts were treated with 3 μM nitrogen mustard and then allowed to repair their DNA damage for 24 h prior to cell fusion and induction of premature chromosome condensation. The extent of chromosome damage was determined in the G1 prematurely condensed chromosomes (G1 PCC). The presence of cytosine arabinoside and hydroxyurea during the repair period in order to accumulate single-strand DNA breaks resulted in an increase in the chromosome-break frequency. Treatment of these repair-inhibited cells with single-strand-specific neurospora endonuclease during fusion to change single-strand lesions into double-strand breajs resulted in a doubling of the aberration frequency. These results support the notion that double-strand breaks are important in chromosome-aberration formation.     

Radiation-induced chromosome aberrations in Saccharomyces cerevisiae: influence of DNA repair pathways.

Radiation-induced chromosome aberrations, particularly exchange-type aberrations, are thought to result from misrepair of DNA double-strand breaks. The relationship between individual pathways of break repair and aberration formation is not clear. By electrophoretic karyotyping of single-cell clones derived from irradiated cells, we have analyzed the induction of stable aberrations in haploid yeast cells mutated for the RAD52 gene, the RAD54 gene, the HDF1(= YKU70) gene, or combinations thereof. We found low and comparable frequencies of aberrational events in wildtype and hdf1 mutants, and assume that in these strains most of the survivors descended from cells that were in G2 phase during irradiation and therefore able to repair breaks by homologous recombination between sister chromatids. In the rad52 and the rad54 strains, enhanced formation of aberrations, mostly exchange-type aberrations, was detected, demonstrating the misrepair activity of a rejoining mechanism other than homologous recombination. No aberration was found in the rad52 hdf1 double mutant, and the frequency in the rad54 hdf1 mutant was very low. Hence, misrepair resulting in exchange-type aberrations depends largely on the presence of Hdf1, a component of the nonhomologous end-joining pathway in yeast.     

Influence of polyethylene glycol on the ligation reaction with calf thymus DNA ligases I and II

High concentrations of the nonspecific macromolecule polyethylene glycol 6000 (PEG 6000) enabled DNA ligases I and II from calf thymus to catalyze intermolecular blunt-end ligation of duplex DNA. Intermolecular cohesive-end ligation with these enzymes was markedly stimulated in the presence of 10-16% (w/v) PEG 6000. The effect of PEG 6000 (4-16%) on the sealing of single-stranded breaks in duplex DNA with DNA ligases I and II was not appreciably stimulatory but rather inhibitory. PEG 6000 (15%) enhanced more twofold the rate of DNA ligase II-AMP complex formation, but moderately suppressed the rate of formation of DNA ligase 1-AMP complex. Polyamines and KCl inhibited blunt-end and cohesive-end ligations with DNA ligases I and II in the presence of PEG 6000.