Tissue specific differences in fibrillin microfibrils analysed using single particle image analysis

Fibrillin microfibrils endow mammalian connective tissues with elasticity and play a fundamental role in the deposition of elastin. The microfibrils are 57 nm periodic supramolecular protein polymers with a mass of 2.5 MDa per repeat. The organisation of molecules within a microfibril is still open to debate and structural studies are only just starting to unravel this issue. The contribution of microfibril associated proteins to microfibril ultrastructure and whether there are any tissue specific differences in microfibril structure is still unknown. Therefore, we have used low dose electron microscopy, single particle image analysis and atomic force microscopy to study the structure of fibrillin microfibrils from different tissues. EM images of microfibrils from aorta, ciliary zonules and vitreous humor were collected and more than 500 microfibril repeats from each sample were subjected to averaging. Averages from each sample were analysed using axial stain exclusion patterns and difference images to detect any variations between them. The overall morphology of fibrillin microfibrils was conserved between tissues and there were only very minor differences in the bead and shoulder region of microfibrils. These data suggest that the structure of isolated microfibrils represents the fibrillin scaffold, and either microfibril associated molecules are lost on purification or play only a minor role in microfibril structure.     

Evidence for the intramolecular pleating model of fibrillin microfibril organisation from single particle image analysis

Fibrillin microfibrils endow mammalian connective tissues with elasticity and are fundamental for the deposition of elastin. The microfibrils are 57nm periodic supramolecular protein polymers with a mass of 2.4MDa per repeat. The detailed structure and organisation of most matrix assemblies is poorly understood due to their large size and complexity and it has proved a major challenge to define their structural organisation. Therefore, we have used low dose electron microscopy and single particle image analysis to study the structure of fibrillin microfibrils. Three novel features were detected: a globular feature that bridges the "arm" region, a double band of density crossing the microfibril and stain penetrating holes present in the interbead region, possibly produced by the removal of microfibril associated proteins in the purification procedure. Fine filaments of approximately 2.4nm diameter are resolved in the interbead region, which correspond to the reported diameter of the fibrillin molecule. Comparison of the stain exclusion pattern of microfibrils with the theoretical stain exclusion pattern of fibrillin packing models indicates that the intramolecular pleating model, where each fibrillin molecule is pleated within one microfibril period allowing extensibility by unpleating, has the best fit to the data.     

Progress in understanding the role of microtubules in plant cells

Microtubules have long been known to play a key role in plant cell morphogenesis, but just how they fulfill this function is unclear. Transverse microtubules have been thought to constrain the movement of cellulose synthase complexes in order to generate transverse microfibrils that are essential for elongation growth. Surprisingly, some recent studies demonstrate that organized cortical microtubules are not essential for maintaining or re-establishing transversely oriented cellulose microfibrils in expanding cells. At the same time, however, there is strong evidence that microtubules are intimately associated with cellulose synthesis activity, especially during secondary wall deposition. These apparently conflicting results provide important clues as to what microtubules do at the interface between the cell and its wall. I hypothesize that cellulose microfibril length is an important parameter of wall mechanics and suggest ways in which microtubule organization may influence microfibril length. This concept is in line with current evidence that links cellulose synthesis levels and microfibril orientation. Furthermore, in light of new evidence showing that a wide variety of proteins bind to microtubules, I raise the broader question of whether a major function of plant microtubules is in modulating signaling pathways as plants respond to sensory inputs from the environment.     

Tracing cellulose microfibril orientation in inner primary cell walls

Summary By quantitative analysis of cellulose microfibril orientation at different levels in the primary cell wall of a number of cell types, the development of wall texture was studied. Meristematic, isodiametric and cylindrical parenchyma cells and cells of a suspension culture were used. Within the newly deposited microfibril population, various orientations were recognized on the micrographs. Within subpopulations the orientation of undercrossing and overcrossing microfibrils were measured. These measurements showed a gradual shift in cellulose microfibril orientation in the different levels. Microfibrils showed predominant orientations at particular levels but microfibrils of intermediate orientation also occurred, although at a much lower density. As cellulose microfibrils of intermediate orientation were not closely packed, lamellae were not formed. Interwoven microfibrils were occasionally present, indicating that differently orientated microfibrils are occasionally deposited simultaneously. Also gradual changes in orientation over the entire inner cell wall surface were observed. From these observations it was inferred that microfibril deposition occurs with a small but regular and progressive change in orientation, the rotational motion, related to that of a helicoidal system.Dedicated to Professor Dr. M. M. A. Sassen on the occasion of his 65th birthday     

THE SIZE OF THE CELLULOSE MICROFIBRIL

Recently the lateral width of the cellulose microfibril has been estimated as 30 A rather than about 150 to 200 A, by extrapolation of data from model shadowing experiments. The difference was attributed to a layer of metal deposited during shadowing. However, direct photographs of the same microfibrils parallel and perpendicular to the direction of shadowing, of unshadowed portions of microfibrils compared with shadowed portions of the same microfibrils, of silver-stained unshadowed microfibrils, and of unshadowed, unstained segments of microfibrils give no evidence of a layer of metal of this thickness in material shadowed under normal conditions. Furthermore, the evidence for microfibril strands of about 35 A in width from negative-staining experiments is subject to a bias from the form of the filaments and from variable positive adsorption of phosphotungstic acid by cellulose. Consequently, the conclusion that the true lateral width of native cellulose microfibrils is about one-fifth of the presently accepted value is not yet justified by unequivocal direct experimental evidence.     

Cellulose microfibril alignment recovers from DCB-induced disruption despite microtubule disorganization

Cellulose microfibril deposition patterns define the direction of plant cell expansion. To better understand how microfibril alignment is controlled, we examined microfibril orientation during cortical microtubule disruption using the temperature-sensitive mutant of Arabidopsis thaliana, mor1-1. In a previous study, it was shown that at restrictive temperature for mor1-1, cortical microtubules lose transverse orientation and cells lose growth anisotropy without any change in the parallel arrangement of cellulose microfibrils. In this study, we investigated whether a pre-existing template of well-ordered microfibrils or the presence of well-organized cortical microtubules was essential for the cell to resume deposition of parallel microfibrils. We first transiently disrupted the parallel order of microfibrils in mor1-1 using a brief treatment with the cellulose synthesis inhibitor 2,6-dichlorobenzonitrile (DCB). We then analysed the alignment of recently deposited cellulose microfibrils (by field emission scanning electron microscopy) as cellulose synthesis recovered and microtubules remained disrupted at the mor1-1 mutant's non-permissive culture temperature. Despite the disordered cortical microtubules and an initially randomized wall texture, new cellulose microfibrils were deposited with parallel, transverse orientation. These results show that transverse cellulose microfibril deposition requires neither accurately transverse cortical microtubules nor a pre-existing template of well-ordered microfibrils. We also demonstrated that DCB treatments reduced the ability of cortical microtubules to form transverse arrays, supporting a role for cellulose microfibrils in influencing cortical microtubule organization.     

Chemical genetic screening identifies a novel inhibitor of parallel alignment of cortical microtubules and cellulose microfibrils

It is a well-known hypothesis that cortical microtubules control the direction of cellulose microfibril deposition, and that the parallel cellulose microfibrils determine anisotropic cell expansion and plant cell morphogenesis. However, the molecular mechanism by which cortical microtubules regulate the orientation of cellulose microfibrils is still unclear. To investigate this mechanism, chemical genetic screening was performed. From this screening, 'SS compounds' were identified that induced a spherical swelling phenotype in tobacco BY-2 cells. The SS compounds could be categorized into three classes: those that disrupted the cortical microtubules; those that reduced cellulose microfibril content; and thirdly those that had neither of these effects. In the last class, a chemical designated 'cobtorin' was found to induce the spherical swelling phenotype at the lowest concentration, suggesting strong binding activity to the putative target. Examining cellulose microfibril regeneration using taxol-treated protoplasts revealed that the cobtorin compound perturbed the parallel alignment of pre-existing cortical microtubules and nascent cellulose microfibrils. Thus, cobtorin could be a novel inhibitor and an attractive tool for further investigation of the mechanism that enables cortical microtubules to guide the parallel deposition of cellulose microfibrils.     

How do expansins control plant growth? A model for cell wall loosening via defect migration in cellulose microfibrils

Expansins are plant cell wall-loosening proteins that promote cell growth and are essential for many critical developmental processes and stress responses. The molecular basis for expansin action is uncertain. Recently, it has been proposed that expansins loosen the wall by means of the generation of mobile conformational defects at the surface of cellulose microfibrils. The present work addresses this hypothesis by elaborating three assumptions: (1) microfibril–matrix interfaces cause steep stress gradients on the microfibril surface, (2) stress gradients drive the motion of conformational defects along the microfibril surface toward the microfibril–matrix interfaces, and (3) the approach of the defects to the microfibril–matrix interfaces facilitates the dissociation of matrix polysaccharides from cellulose microfibrils.     

New techniques enable comparative analysis of microtubule orientation, wall texture, and growth rate in intact roots of Arabidopsis

This article explores root epidermal cell elongation and its dependence on two structural elements of cells, cortical microtubules and cellulose microfibrils. The recent identification of Arabidopsis morphology mutants with putative cell wall or cytoskeletal defects demands a procedure for examining and comparing wall architecture and microtubule organization patterns in this species. We developed methods to examine cellulose microfibrils by field emission scanning electron microscopy and microtubules by immunofluorescence in essentially intact roots. We were able to compare cellulose microfibril and microtubule alignment patterns at equivalent stages of cell expansion. Field emission scanning electron microscopy revealed that Arabidopsis root epidermal cells have typical dicot primary cell wall structure with prominent transverse cellulose microfibrils embedded in pectic substances. Our analysis showed that microtubules and microfibrils have similar orientation only during the initial phase of elongation growth. Microtubule patterns deviate from a predominantly transverse orientation while cells are still expanding, whereas cellulose microfibrils remain transverse until well after expansion finishes. We also observed microtubule-microfibril alignment discord before cells enter their elongation phase. This study and the new technology it presents provide a starting point for further investigations on the physical properties of cell walls and their mechanisms of assembly.     

Alteration of oriented deposition of cellulose microfibrils by mutation of a katanin-like microtubule-severing protein

It has long been hypothesized that cortical microtubules (MTs) control the orientation of cellulose microfibril deposition, but no mutants with alterations of MT orientation have been shown to affect this process. We have shown previously that in Arabidopsis, the fra2 mutation causes aberrant cortical MT orientation and reduced cell elongation, and the gene responsible for the fra2 mutation encodes a katanin-like protein. In this study, using field emission scanning electron microscopy, we found that the fra2 mutation altered the normal orientation of cellulose microfibrils in walls of expanding cells. Although cellulose microfibrils in walls of wild-type cells were oriented transversely along the elongation axis, cellulose microfibrils in walls of fra2 cells often formed bands and ran in different directions. The fra2 mutation also caused aberrant deposition of cellulose microfibrils in secondary walls of fiber cells. The aberrant orientation of cellulose microfibrils was shown to be correlated with disorganized cortical MTs in several cell types examined. In addition, the thickness of both primary and secondary cell walls was reduced significantly in the fra2 mutant. These results indicate that the katanin-like protein is essential for oriented cellulose microfibril deposition and normal cell wall biosynthesis. We further demonstrated that the Arabidopsis katanin-like protein possessed MT-severing activity in vitro; thus, it is an ortholog of animal katanin. We propose that the aberrant MT orientation caused by the mutation of katanin results in the distorted deposition of cellulose microfibrils, which in turn leads to a defect in cell elongation. These findings strongly support the hypothesis that cortical MTs regulate the oriented deposition of cellulose microfibrils that determines the direction of cell elongation.     

The xyloglucan-cellulose assembly at the atomic scale

The assembly of cell wall components, cellulose and xyloglucan (XG), was investigated at the atomistic scale using molecular dynamics simulations. A molecular model of a cellulose crystal corresponding to the allomorph Ibeta and exhibiting a flexible complex external morphology was employed to mimic the cellulose microfibril. The xyloglucan molecules considered were the three typical basic repeat units, differing only in the size of one of the lateral chain. All the investigated XG fragments adsorb nonspecifically onto cellulose fiber; multiple arrangements are equally probable, and every cellulose surface was capable of binding the short XG molecules. The following structural effects emerged: XG molecules that do not have any long side chains tended to adapt themselves nicely to the topology of the microfibril, forming a flat, outstretched conformation with all the sugar residues interacting with the surface. In contrast, the XG molecules, which have long side chains, were not able to adopt a flat conformation that would enable the interaction of all the XG residues with the surface. In addition to revealing the fundamental atomistic details of the XG adsorption on cellulose, the present calculations give a comprehensive understanding of the way the XG molecules can unsorb from cellulose to create a network that forms the cell wall. Our revisited view of the adsorption features of XG on cellulose microfibrils is consistent with experimental data, and a model of the network is proposed.     

On the alignment of cellulose microfibrils by cortical microtubules: A review and a model

Summary The hypothesis that microtubules align microfibrils, termed the alignment hypothesis, states that there is a causal link between the orientation of cortical microtubules and the orientation of nascent microfibrils. I have assessed the generality of this hypothesis by reviewing what is known about the relation between microtubules and microfibrils in a wide group of examples: in algae of the family Characeae,Closterium acerosum, Oocystis solitaria, and certain genera of green coenocytes and in land plant tip-growing cells, xylem, diffusely growing cells, and protoplasts. The salient features about microfibril alignment to emerge are as follows. Cellulose microfibrils can be aligned by cortical microtubules, thus supporting the alignment hypothesis. Alignment of microfibrils can occur independently of microtubules, showing that an alternative to the alignment hypothesis must exist. Microfibril organization is often random, suggesting that self-assembly is insufficient. Microfibril organization differs on different faces of the same cell, suggesting that microfibrils are aligned locally, not with respect to the entire cell. Nascent microfibrils appear to associate tightly with the plasma membrane. To account for these observations, I present a model that posits alignment to be mediated through binding the nascent microfibril. The model, termed templated incorporation, postulates that the nascent microfibril is incorporated into the cell wall by binding to a scaffold that is oriented; further, the scaffold is built and oriented around either already incorporated microfibrils or plasma membrane proteins, or both. The role of cortical microtubules is to bind and orient components of the scaffold at the plasma membrane. In this way, spatial information to align the microfibrils may come from either the cell wall or the cell interior, and microfibril alignment with and without microtubules are subsets of a single mechanism.Dedicated to Professor Brian E. S. Gunning on the occasion of his 65th birthday     

A kinesin-like protein is essential for oriented deposition of cellulose microfibrils and cell wall strength

Cortical microtubules have long been hypothesized to regulate the oriented deposition of cellulose microfibrils. However, the molecular mechanisms of how microtubules direct the orientation of cellulose microfibril deposition are not known. We have used fibers in the inflorescence stems of Arabidopsis to study secondary wall deposition and cell wall strength and found a fragile fiber (fra1) mutant with a dramatic reduction in the mechanical strength of fibers. The fra1 mutation did not cause any defects in cell wall composition, secondary wall thickening, or cortical microtubule organization in fiber cells. An apparent alteration was found in the orientation of cellulose microfibrils in fra1 fiber walls, indicating that the reduced mechanical strength of fra1 fibers probably was attributable to altered cellulose microfibril deposition. The FRA1 gene was cloned and found to encode a kinesin-like protein with an N-terminal microtubule binding motor domain. The FRA1 protein was shown to be concentrated around the periphery of the cytoplasm but absent in the nucleus. Based on these findings, we propose that the FRA1 kinesin-like protein is involved in the microtubule control of cellulose microfibril order.     

Substrate-dependent morphology of supramolecular assemblies: fibrillin and type-VI collagen microfibrils

Substrate hydrophobicity/hydrophilicity has previously been shown to affect the morphology and biological function of isolated proteins. We have employed atomic force microscopy to investigate substrate dependent morphologies of two biochemically distinct native supramolecular assemblies: fibrillin and type-VI collagen microfibrils. These morphologically heterogeneous microfibrillar systems are found in many vertebrate tissues where they perform structural and cell-signaling roles. Fibrillin microfibrils adsorbed to a hydrophilic mica substrate adopted a diffuse morphology. Fibrillin microfibrils adsorbed to mica coated with poly-L-lysine or to borosilicate glass substrates had a more compact morphology and a directional asymmetry to the bead, which was not present on mica alone. Intermediate morphologies were observed along a substrate gradient. The classical double-beaded appearance of type-VI collagen microfibrils was evident on mica coated with poly-L-lysine and on glass. On hydrophilic mica, morphology was severely disrupted and there was a major conformational reorganization along the whole collagen microfibril repeat. These observations of substrate dependent conformation have important implications for the interpretation of data from in vitro protein interaction assays and cellular signaling studies. Furthermore, conformational changes may be induced by local charge environments in vivo, revealing or hiding binding sites.     

Spatial organization of cellulose microfibrils and matrix polysaccharides in primary plant cell walls as imaged by multichannel atomic force microscopy

We used atomic force microscopy (AFM), complemented with electron microscopy, to characterize the nanoscale and mesoscale structure of the outer (periclinal) cell wall of onion scale epidermis – a model system for relating wall structure to cell wall mechanics. The epidermal wall contains ~100 lamellae, each ~40 nm thick, containing 3.5‐nm wide cellulose microfibrils oriented in a common direction within a lamella but varying by ~30 to 90° between adjacent lamellae. The wall thus has a crossed polylamellate, not helicoidal, wall structure. Montages of high‐resolution AFM images of the newly deposited wall surface showed that single microfibrils merge into and out of short regions of microfibril bundles, thereby forming a reticulated network. Microfibril direction within a lamella did not change gradually or abruptly across the whole face of the cell, indicating continuity of the lamella across the outer wall. A layer of pectin at the wall surface obscured the underlying cellulose microfibrils when imaged by FESEM, but not by AFM. The AFM thus preferentially detects cellulose microfibrils by probing through the soft matrix in these hydrated walls. AFM‐based nanomechanical maps revealed significant heterogeneity in cell wall stiffness and adhesiveness at the nm scale. By color coding and merging these maps, the spatial distribution of soft and rigid matrix polymers could be visualized in the context of the stiffer microfibrils. Without chemical extraction and dehydration, our results provide multiscale structural details of the primary cell wall in its near‐native state, with implications for microfibrils motions in different lamellae during uniaxial and biaxial extensions.     

beta-tubulin affects cellulose microfibril orientation in plant secondary fibre cell walls

Cellulose microfibrils are the major structural component of plant secondary cell walls. Their arrangement in plant primary cell walls, and its consequent influence on cell expansion and cellular morphology, is directed by cortical microtubules; cylindrical protein filaments composed of heterodimers of alpha- and beta-tubulin. In secondary cell walls of woody plant stems the orientation of cellulose microfibrils influences the strength and flexibility of wood, providing the physical support that has been instrumental in vascular plant colonization of the troposphere. Here we show that a Eucalyptus grandisbeta-tubulin gene (EgrTUB1) is involved in determining the orientation of cellulose microfibrils in plant secondary fibre cell walls. This finding is based on RNA expression studies in mature trees, where we identified and isolated EgrTUB1 as a candidate for association with wood-fibre formation, and on the analysis of somatically derived transgenic wood sectors in Eucalyptus. We show that cellulose microfibril angle (MFA) is correlated with EgrTUB1 expression, and that MFA was significantly altered as a consequence of stable transformation with EgrTUB1. Our findings present an important step towards the production of fibres with altered tensile strength, stiffness and elastic properties, and shed light on one of the molecular mechanisms that has enabled trees to dominate terrestrial ecosystems.     

THE SITES OF CELLULOSE SYNTHESIS IN ALGAE: DIVERSITY AND EVOLUTION OF CELLULOSE-SYNTHESIZING ENZYME COMPLEXES

Information on the sites of cellulose synthesis and the diversity and evolution of cellulose-synthesizing enzyme complexes (terminal complexes) in algae is reviewed. There is now ample evidence that cellulose synthesis occurs at the plasma membrane-bound cellulose synthase, with the exception of some algae that produce cellulosic scales in the Golgi apparatus. Freeze-fracture studies of the supramolecular organization of the plasma membrane support the view that the rosettes (a six-subunit complex) in higher plants and both the rosettes and the linear terminal complexes (TCs) in algae are the structures that synthesize cellulose and secrete cellulose microfibrils. In the Zygnemataceae, each single rosette forms a 5-nm or 3-nm single “elementary” microfibril (primary wall), whereas rosettes arranged in rows of hexagonal arrays synthesize criss-crossed bands of parallel cellulose microfibrils (secondary wall). In Spirogyra, it is proposed that each of the six subunits of a rosette might synthesize six β-1,4-glucan chains that cocrystallize into a 36-glucan chain “elementary” microfibril, as is the case in higher plants. One typical feature of the linear terminal complexes in red algae is the periodic arrangement of the particle rows transverse to the longitudinal axis of the TCs. In bangiophyte red algae and in Vaucheria hamata, cellulose microfibrils are thin, ribbon-shaped structures, 1–1.5 nm thick and 5–70 nm wide; details of their synthesis are reviewed. Terminal complexes appear to be made in the endoplasmic reticulum and are transferred to Golgi cisternae, where the cellulose synthases are activated and may be transported to the plasma membrane. In algae with linear TCs, deposition follows a precise pattern directed by the movement and the orientation of the TCs (membrane flow). A principal underlying theme is that the architecture of cellulose microfibrils (size, shape, crystallinity, and intramicrofibrillar associations) is directly related to the geometry of TCs. The effects of inhibitors on the structure of cellulose-synthetizing complexes and the relationship between the deposition of the cellulose microfibrils with cortical microtubules and with the membrane-embedded TCs is reviewed In Porphyra yezoensis, the frequency and distribution of TCs reflect polar tip growth in the apical shoot cell.The evolution of TCs in algae is reviewed. The evidence gathered to date illustrates the utility of terminal complex organization in addressing plant phylogenetic relationships.     

Mutation or drug-dependent microtubule disruption causes radial swelling without altering parallel cellulose microfibril deposition in Arabidopsis root cells

As critical determinants of growth anisotropy in plants, cortical microtubules are thought to constrain the movement of cellulose synthase complexes and thus align newly deposited cellulose microfibrils. We tested this cellulose synthase constraint model using the temperature-sensitive mor1-1 mutant of Arabidopsis. Contrary to predictions, the disruption of cortical microtubules in mor1-1 root epidermal cells led to left-handed root twisting and radial swelling but did not alter the transverse orientation of cellulose microfibrils. We also found that drug-dependent disassembly or hyperstabilization of cortical microtubules did not alter the parallel order of cellulose microfibrils. By measuring cellulose content in mor1-1 seedlings, we verified that cellulose synthesis is not reduced at the restrictive temperature. The independence of cortical microtubule organization and cellulose microfibril alignment was supported by the observation that double mutants of mor1-1 and rsw1-1, the cellulose-deficient mutant with misaligned microfibrils, had additive phenotypes. Our results suggest that cortical microtubules regulate growth anisotropy by some mechanism other than cellulose microfibril alignment or synthesis.     

Atomic force microscopy of microfibrils in primary cell walls

Examination of angiosperm primary cell walls by transmission electron microscopy shows that they contain microfibrils that probably consist of cellulose microfibrils surrounded by associated non-cellulosic polysaccharides. Previous studies using solid-state (13)C NMR spectroscopy have shown that the cellulose is all crystalline with crystallites of cross-sectional dimensions of 2-3 nm. However, it is not known if each microfibril contains only one, or more than one crystallite because there is no agreement about the dimensions of the microfibrils. Partially hydrated primary cell walls isolated from onion ( Allium cepa L.) and Arabidopsis thaliana (L.) Heynh. were examined by atomic force microscopy and the microfibril diameters determined. The cell walls of both species contained tightly interwoven microfibrils of uniform diameter: 4.4+/-0.13 nm in the onion and 5.8+/-0.17 nm in A. thaliana. The effect was also examined of extracting the A. thaliana cell walls to remove pectic polysaccharides. The microfibrils in the extracted cell walls of A. thaliana were significantly narrower (3.2+/-0.13 nm) than those in untreated walls. The results are consistent with the microfibrils containing only one cellulose crystallite.