FLOW CYTOMETRY AND THE SINGLE CELL IN PHYCOLOGY

Flow cytometers measure light scattering and fluorescence characteristics from individual particles in a fluid stream as they cross one or more light beams at rates of up to thousands of events per second. Flow cytometrically detectable optical signals may arise naturally from algae, reflecting cell size, structure, and endogenous pigmentation, or may be generated by fluorescent stains that report the presence of otherwise undetected cellular constituents. Some flow cytometers can physically sort particles with desired optical characteristics out of the flow stream and collect them for subsequent culture or other analyses. The statistically rigorous, cell‐level perspective provided by flow cytometry has been advantageous in experimental investigations of phycological problems, such as the regulation of cell cycle progression. The capacity of flow cytometry to measure large numbers of cells in large numbers of samples rapidly and quantitatively has been used extensively by biological oceanographers to define the distributions and dynamics of marine picophytoplankton. Recent work has shown that flow cytometry can be used to elucidate relationships between the optical properties of individual cells and the bulk optical properties of the water they live in, and thereby may provide an explicit link between algal physiology and global biogeochemistry. Unfortunately, commercially available flow cytometers that are optimized for biomedical applications have a limited capacity to analyze larger phytoplankton. To circumvent these limitations, many investigators are developing flow cytometers specifically designed for analyzing the broad range of sizes, shapes, and pigments found among algae. These new instruments can perform some novel measurements, including simple fluorescence excitation spectra, detailed angular scattering measurements, and in‐flow digital imaging. The growing accessibility and power of flow cytometers may allow the technology to be applied to a wider array of problems in phycology, including investigations of nonplanktonic and multicellular algae, but also presents new challenges for effectively analyzing the large quantity of multiparameter data produced. Ultimately, the detection of molecular probes by flow cytometry may allow single‐cell taxonomic and physiological information to be garnered for a variety of algae, both in culture and in nature.     

Individual Escherichia coli cells studied from light scattering with the scanning flow cytometer

BACKGROUND: Flow cytometry is a powerful tool for the analysis of individual particles in a flow. Differential light scattering (an indicatrix) was used for many years to obtain morphologic information about microorganisms. The indicatrices play the same role for individual particle recognition as a spectrum for substance characterization. We combined two techniques to analyze the indicatrix of the cells for the purpose of developing a database of light-scattering functions of cells. METHODS: The scanning flow cytometer (SFC) allows the measurement of the entire indicatrix of individual particles at polar angles ranging from 5 degrees to 100 degrees. In this work, light-scattering properties of Escherichia coli have been studied both experimentally and theoretically with the SFC and the T-matrix method, respectively. The T-matrix method was used because of the nonspherical shape of E. coli cells, which were modeled by a prolate spheroid. RESULTS: The indicatrices of E. coli cells were stimulated with T-matrix method at polar angles ranging from 10 degrees to 60 degrees. The absolute cross-section of light scattering of E. coli has been determined comparing the cross section of polystyrene particles modeled by a homogeneous sphere. The E. coli indicatrices were compared for logarithmic and stationary phases of cell growth. CONCLUSIONS: The indicatrices of E. coli were reproducible and could be used for identification of these cells in biologic suspensions. The angular location of the indicatrix minimum can be used in separation of cells in logarithmic and stationary phases. To use effectively the indicatrices for that purpose, the light-scattering properties of other microorganisms have to be studied.     

Characterization of bacteria by multiparameter flow cytometry

An arc-lamp based flow cytometer was used to obtain high resolution measurements of the light scattering characteristics and DNA contents of eight different bacteria. Light scatter profiles of bacteria are a useful first step when flow cytometry is used to characterize organisms. Scanning and transmission electron microscopy of the bacterial samples demonstrate that the structural basis of the light scattering profiles is not always clear, i.e. some organisms appear to have anomalous light scattering characteristics. The use of a third measurement parameter, DNA content, allowed much better discrimination of the organisms. Flow cytometry shows great promise as a method for the rapid discrimination and identification of bacterial populations.     

Characterization of bacteria by multiparameter flow cytometry.

An arc-lamp based flow cytometer was used to obtain high resolution measurements of the light scattering characteristics and DNA contents of eight different bacteria. Light scatter profiles of bacteria are a useful first step when flow cytometry is used to characterize organisms. Scanning and transmission electron microscopy of the bacterial samples demonstrate that the structural basis of the light scattering profiles is not always clear, i.e. some organisms appear to have anomalous light scattering characteristics. The use of a third measurement parameter, DNA content, allowed much better discrimination of the organisms. Flow cytometry shows great promise as a method for the rapid discrimination and identification of bacterial populations.     

Detection and discrimination of individual viruses by flow cytometry.

A new flow cytometer with a very small observation volume has been developed to detect individual viruses with good resolution, and has been used to discriminate between two types of viral particles based on differences in their light scattering. Measurements of light scattering and fluorescence made with such an instrument can provide a basis for quantitative analysis and sorting of viruses and other particles in the micron and submicron size range.     

DIEL VARIATIONS IN OPTICAL PROPERTIES OF MICROMONAS PUSILLA (PRASINOPHYCEAE)1

Micromonas pusilla (Butcher) Manton et Parke, a marine prasinophyte, was used to investigate how cell growth and division affect optical properties of phytoplankton over the light:dark cycle. Measurements were made of cell size and concentration, attenuation and absorption coefficients, flow cytometric forward and side light scattering and chl fluorescence, and chl and carbon content. The refractive index was derived from observations and Mie scattering theory. Diel variations occurred, with cells increasing in size, light scattering, and carbon content during daytime photosynthesis and decreasing during nighttime division. Cells averaged 1.6 μm in diameter and exhibited phased division, with 1.3 divisions per day. Scattering changes resulted primarily from changes in cell size and not refractive index; absorption changes were consistent with a negligible package effect. Measurements over the diel cycle suggest that in M. pusilla carbon‐specific attenuation varies with cell size, and this relationship appears to extend to other phytoplankton species. Because M. pusilla is one of the smallest eukaryotic phytoplankton and belongs to a common marine genus, these results will be useful for interpreting in situ light scattering variation. The relationship between forward light scattering (FLS) and volume over the diel cycle for M. pusilla was similar to that determined for a variety of phytoplankton species over a large size range. We propose a method to estimate cellular carbon content directly from FLS, which will improve our estimates of the contribution of different phytoplankton groups to productivity and total carbon content in the oceans.     

Design and first results of CytoBuoy: a wireless flow cytometer for in situ analysis of marine and fresh waters.

BACKGROUND:The high costs of microscopical determination and counting of phytoplankton often limit sampling frequencies below an acceptable level for the monitoring of dynamic ecosystems. Although having a limited discrimination power, flow cytometry allows the analysis of large numbers of samples to a level that is sufficient for many basic monitoring jobs. For this purpose, flow cytometers should not be restricted to research laboratories. We report here on the development of an in situ flow cytometer for autonomous operation inside a small moored buoy or on other platforms. METHODS AND RESULTS: Operational specifications served a wide range of applications in the aquatic field. Specific conditions had to be met with respect to the operation platform and autonomy. A small, battery-operated flow cytometer resulted, requiring no external sheath fluid supply. Because it was designed to operate in a buoy, we call it CytoBuoy. Sampling, analysis, and radio transmission of the data proceed automatically at user-defined intervals. A powerful feature is the acquisition and radio transmission of full detector pulse shapes of each particle. This provides valuable morphological information for particles larger than the 5-microm laser focus. CONCLUSIONS:CytoBuoy allows on-line in situ particle analysis, estimation of phytoplankton biomass, and discrimination between different phytoplankton groups. This will increase the applicability of flow cytometry in the field of environmental monitoring.     

UV‐EXCITED BLUE AUTOFLUORESCENCE OF PSEUDO‐NITZSCHIA MULTISERIES (BACILLARIOPHYCEAE)1

A flow cytometer coupled to a scanning monochromator and a fluorescence microscope were used to characterize the fluorescence spectrum of Pseudo‐nitzschia multiseries (Hasle) Hasle, a pennate diatom that produces the neurotoxin domoic acid, a lethal amnesic. In this research, we characterize the fluorescence spectrum of P. multiseries in vivo over the wavelength range of 360 to 850 nm and show that this diatom autofluoresces blue when excited with UV light (350–365 nm). The autofluorescence characterization of Pseudo‐nitzschia may provide new methods for rapid in situ monitoring of diatom populations and reiterates the usefulness of flow cytometry in the analysis and study of marine phytoplankton.     

Phytoplankton monitoring by flow cytometry

The application of flow cytometry to the monitoring of phytoplanktonis demonstrated. A comparison is made with conventional approachesto phytoplankton monitoring: light microscopy for the determinationof species abundance, and chlorophyll a determination and insitu chlorophyll a measurement by fluorescence for the determinationof the biomass. Flow cytometric measurements correlate wellwith these conventional types of measurements, as has been shownby comparing a full year of monitoring data obtained at a fixedmonitoring location 10 km off the Dutch coast. Flow cytometrybridges the gap between labour-intensive, but highly informative,microscopic observations and simple biomass measurements withless information content: via flow cytometry optical data areobtained at high speed for individual particles, which can betranslated into biomass information. On the basis of the flowcytometric measurements, rough discrimination of phytoplanktonspecies groups is possible, particularly for the abundant species.Of crucial importance is careful calibration of the flow cytometer,to ensure quantitative and comparable measurements over a longperiod of time. Calibration and quality assurance aspects arecovered in detail. ³Present address: Akzo Nobel Central Research Laboratories Arnhem,Department CRL, PO Box 9300, NL-6800 SB Arnhem, The Netherlands     

DAPI staining improved for quantitative cytofluorometry

DNA-DAPI complexes emit strong bluish white fluorescence when excited by ultraviolet light so that even very small amounts of DNA such as those in mitochondria, chloroplasts, and virus particles can be visualized. Moreover, the staining procedure with DAPI is very simple and requires no hydrolysis. However, DAPI staining was considered unsuitable for quantitative purpose; nonspecific cytoplasmic fluorescence, scattering of strong emission light, and fading of the fluorescence under UV excitation were major problems of DAPI staining in quantitative cytofluorometry. We found that (1) nonspecific cytoplasmic fluorescence could be eliminated by reducing the DAPI concentration to 50 ng/ml, (2) fluorescence decay was markedly decreased by adding electron donors and molecules containing SH radicals in the mounting media, and (3) light scattering became negligible after reducing the intensity of the excitation light. Thus satisfactory precision could be obtained in DNA quantification by epifluorescent cytophotometry on DAPI stained specimens.     

Lorenz-Mie light scattering in cellular biology.

The Lorenz-Mie light scattering is discussed as a tool allowing living cell characterization. The scattered light carries information about the size, shape, internal structure and refractive index of the cell. The advantages of light scattering methods consist in high speed, nondestructive, sensitive and relatively easy measurements. Light scattering methods are compatible with other methods. In light scattering in both static and flow systems. For sphere-like cells reliable size and refractive index information can be extracted. On the empirical basis, light scattering pattern can be used for the cell identification and separation purposes. The full utilization of the light scattering information is limited due to the lack of theoretical knowledge about the complex scatterer properties and efficient inversion schemes. The rapid progress in computer technique and in single-particle scattering experiments may significantly improve the interpretation of light scattering patterns of the biological particles.     

Flow cytometer based on triggered supercontinuum laser illumination

Multiple wavelength operation in a flow cytometer is an exciting way for cell analysis based on both fluorescence and optical scattering processing. For example, this multiparametric technique is currently used to differentiate blood cells subpopulations. The choice of excitation wavelengths matching fluorochrome spectra (it is currently the opposite) and the use of a broader range of fluorochromes can be made by taking advantage of a filtered supercontinuum white light source. In this study, we first wished to validate the use of a specific triggered supercontinuum laser in a flow cytometer based on white light scattering and electric sizing on human blood cells. Subsequently, to show the various advantages of this attractive system, using scattering effect, electrical detections, and fluorescence analysis, we realized cells sorting based on DNA/RNA stained by thiazole orange. Discrimination of white blood cells is efficiently demonstrated by using a triggered supercontinuum-based flow cytometer operating in a "one cell-one shot" configuration. The discriminated leukocyte populations are monocytes, lymphocytes, granulocytes, immature granulocytes, and cells having a high RNA content (monoblasts, lymphoblasts, and plasma cells). To the best of our knowledge, these results constitute the first practical demonstration of flow cytometry based on triggered supercontinuum illumination. This study is the starting point of a series of new experiments fully exploiting the spectral features of such a laser source. For example, the large flexibility in the choice of the excitation wavelength allows to use a larger number of fluorochromes and to excite them more efficiently. Moreover, this work opens up new research directions in the biophotonics field, such as the combination of coherent Raman spectroscopy and flow cytometry techniques.     

Fluorescence as an alternative to light-scatter gating strategies to identify frozen–thawed cells with flow cytometry

Flow cytometry is a key instrument in biological studies, used to identify and analyze cells in suspension. The identification of cells from debris is commonly based on light scatter properties as it has been shown that there is a relationship between forward scattered light and cell volume and this has become common practice in flow cytometry. Cryobiological conditions induce changes in cells that alter their light scatter properties. Cells with membrane damage from freeze–thaw stress produce lower forward scatter signals and may fall below standard forward scatter thresholds. In contrast to light scatter properties that cannot identify damaged cells from debris, fluorescent dyes used in membrane integrity and mitochondrial polarization assays are capable of labeling and discriminating all cells in suspension. Under cryobiological conditions, isolating cell populations is more effectively accomplished by gating on fluorescence rather than light scatter properties. This study shows the limitations of using forward scatter thresholds in flow cytometry to identify and gate cells after exposure to a freeze–thaw protocol and demonstrates the use of fluorescence as an alternative means of identifying and analyzing cells.     

Shipboard analytical flow cytometry of oceanic ultraphytoplankton

Shipboard analysis of marine ultraphytoplankton by flow cytometry is a powerful method to classify these cells according to in vivo fluorescence characteristics and size. At present, this ataxonomic-allometric approach allows recognition of phycoerythrin-containing cyanobacteria, cryptomonads, very small red-fluorescing cells (presumably prochlorophytes), and eukaryotic algae of various sizes in many open ocean samples. The speed at which flow cytometric analysis can be performed on freshly collected samples permits a high degree of sampling resolution in both space and time. A flow cytometric view is presented of the vertical distribution of ultraphytoplankton at various sites in the north Atlantic and of experiments wherein phytoplankton were incubated in an artificial light gradient and under simulated in situ conditions.     

A new multiparameter flow cytometer: optical and electrical cell analysis in combination with video microscopy in flow

BACKGROUND: Flow cytometers, which are commercially available, do not necessarily meet all demands of actual biomedical research. This is the case for the investigation of mechanisms involved in cell volume regulation, which requires electrical volume measurement and ratiometric multichannel fluorescence analysis for the simultaneous assessment of different physiologic parameters (intracellular pH and the intracellular concentration of calcium ions, etc). METHODS AND RESULTS: We describe the construction of a new nonsorting flow cytometer designed for the simultaneous acquisition of seven parameters including fluorescence signals, forward and perpendicular light scatter, cell volume according to the electrical Coulter principle, and flow cytometric imaging. The instrument is equipped with three different light sources. A tunable argon-ion laser generates efficient excitation of the most standard fluorescent probes in the visible spectral range, and an arc lamp provides the means for ultraviolet excitation at low cost. Because of the spatial filtering by the excitation and detection optics, two independent sets of dual fluorescence measurements can be performed, a prerequisite for flexible ratiometric fluorescence analysis. A flow video microscope integrated into the optical system optionally generates either brightfield or phase images of selected flowing particles. Only particles whose individual datasets meet predefined gating conditions are imaged in real time. To avoid smear effects, the motion of the object to be imaged (speed approximately 8 m/s) is frozen on the target of a CCD camera by flash illumination. For this purpose, a high radiance gas discharge lamp with 25-mJ electric pulse energy provides an illumination time of 18 ns (full width half maximum). Test results obtained from latex spheres and cells are shown. CONCLUSIONS: Test results indicate that our instrument can perform Coulter measurements in combination with flexible optical analysis. Moreover, integration of an adapted video microscope into a flow cytometer is an approach to overcome the gap between flow and image cytometry.     

Possibilities of Optical Monitoring of Phosphorus Starvation in Suspensions of Microalga <Emphasis Type="Italic">Chlorella vulgaris</Emphasis> IPPAS C-1 (Chlorophyceae)

Studies of the impact of inorganic phosphorus (P_i), an important nutrient, on the growth and physiological parameters of single-celled algae are important for investigations of the dynamics of phytoplankton abundance and productivity in natural ecosystems as well as in industrial systems for the cultivation of microalgae. Difficulties in carrying out such studies are associated with the complex kinetics of P_i uptake by cells and the ability of microalgae to store phosphorus in their cells. This situation necessitates efficient methods for express monitoring of microalgal cultures, such as the methods based on the registration of optical properties of cells, in particular absorption and scattering of light and fluorescence of chlorophyll contained in the cells. Here, the results of monitoring the cultures of the chlorophyte Chlorella vulgaris IPPAS C-1 starving for phosphorus are described. It was found that both optical (light absorption in the bands of the key pigments—chlorophylls and carotenoids) and luminescent (variable fluorescence of chlorophyll) parameters closely reflect the culture condition. Registration of optical properties required correction for the contribution of light scattering to the overall extinction of light by microalgal cell suspensions. At the same time, the light scattering signal is an accurate measure of the total number of suspended particles in the suspension. However, it is difficult to monitor cultures containing a significant amount of light-scattering particles lacking photosynthetic pigments (such as heterotrophic bacteria). For such cultures, the use of variable fluorescence- based parameter Fv/Fm reflecting the maximum photochemical efficiency of the photosystem II is advisable.     

Narrow-angle forward light scattering from individual algal cells: implications for size and shape discrimination in flow cytometry

Single-cell forward light scattering patterns have been examinedfor four algal species (one pennate diatom, two green flagellatesand one filamentous cyanobacterium), mounted statically in afocused laser beam. In all cases, the distribution of lightintensity at narrow angles (within the first scattering lobe)is well described by diffraction theory. Narrow-angle forwardscattering measurements can therefore be used in principle todeduce the size and approximate shape of algal cells. The feasibilityof using this technique in flow cytometry has been tested usingan instrument which orientates elongated cells uniformly inthe flow stream, and uses fibre optics to make azimuthally resolvedforward scatter measurements at sub-degree polar angles. Withthis instrument it is possible to discriminate between specieswith similar volume and fluorescence characteristics using forwardlight scattering as a shape-sensitive parameter.     

In vitro isolation of nanobodies for selective Alexandrium minutum recognition: A model for convenient development of dedicated immuno-reagents to study and diagnostic toxic unicellular algae

At the present, the identification of planktonic species in coastal water is still a time intensive process performed by highly trained personnel that relies either on qPCR or on light microscopy observation and in vitro culturing. Furthermore, the increasing danger represented by Harmful Algal Blooms (HABs) inside phytoplankton community and the recent implementation of the legislation on ballast water management to prevent the introduction of HABs and NIS (Non Indigenous Species) urge the development of faster and reliable diagnostic methods. Immuno-based approaches could fulfil this need provided that the costs for antibody selection and production will be reduced.In this work it is demonstrated for the first time the feasibility to recover nanobodies (VHHs) selective for native surface epitopes of Alexandrium minutum by direct whole cell bio-panning using a pre-immune phage display library. The recombinant nature of VHHs enabled their rapid engineering into eGFP fluorescent reagents (fluobodies) that were produced recombinantly in bacteria and are directly suitable for fluorescence microscopy and flow cytometry. Immune-detection identified also cysts and anti-Alexandrium fluobodies showed no cross-reactivity with indigenous not-toxic phytoplankton microalgae belonging to different geni. The fluobodies were able to bind selectively to the target cells in both fixed and fresh samples with minimal processing.     

Phytoplankton monitoring by high performance flow cytometry: a successful approach?

BACKGROUND: Regular phytoplankton monitoring in Dutch coastal waters is performed as an indicator of the ecological state of these waters. The monitoring program is focused on temporal and spatial changes of species composition and abundance. Flow cytometry has been introduced to provide additional information, to improve ecosystem understanding, and to increase the efficiency of analysis and reportage. METHODS: Phytoplankton community abundance and composition were routinely determined by flow cytometry and microscopy at six locations in the North Sea over three annual cycles between 2000 and 2003. Supplementary measurements were also made for fluorescence (chlorophyll-a and other pigments) and, in combination with flow cytometric and microscopic data, were used to determine phytoplankton abundance and composition as a function of their size distribution. Real-time imaging of species was also used to identify species on the basis of their flow cytometric optical characteristics. RESULTS: Flow cytometric analysis took 15 min on average. Analysis including data processing, and Web site reportage took less than 1 h. Phytoplankton concentrations (cells/ml), biomass (fluorescence/ml), and concentration of phycoerythrin- or phycocyanin-containing cells (cells/ml) as a function of their algal size were produced every 2 weeks on average. The phytoplankton integrated annual concentration and biomass were used as ecological indicators for overall phytoplankton status. Real-time imaging of cells in flow enabled the identification of dominant species and was applied as an early warning system for Phaeocystis spp. CONCLUSIONS: The reproducibility and count precision due to the large number of observations of the flow cytometric technique provided reliable data for monitoring long-term trends. Flow cytometrically based analyses extended the lower detection limit (<0.5 microm) of analysis beyond the capabilities of other techniques such as the relation between small and larger phytoplankton, the relation between cell counts and biomass as a function of cell size, but also the ability to monitor and report on blooms of harmful algae. A good correlation was found between concentrations (cells/ml) measured by flow cytometry and microscopy. In practice, flow cytometric analysis of a single marine sample took 15 min on average.     

Flow cytometric characterization of marine microbes

The analysis of marine phytoplankton using flow cytometry has enabled the discovery of new taxa and has contributed new understanding to the dynamics and ecological contributions of phytoplankton to the global carbon cycle. Marine phytoplankton are uniquely suited to analysis by flow cytometry because of their size, pigment content, and ability to remain in suspension. Cytometric analysis of marine populations is not without challenges. Phytoplankton communities span a broad range of sizes. The smallest microbes are a few tenths of a micron, while the largest are a few tenths of a millimeter. The improvement of cytometric measurements of scattered laser light allows one to investigate marine microbes whose sizes span several orders of magnitude. To effectively leverage the advantages that marine microbes possess, cytometers have to be carefully engineered for marine use.