Radiation damage in macromolecular cryocrystallography

X-ray radiation damage to cryocooled ( approximately 100 K) macromolecular crystals has emerged as a general problem, especially since the advent of third generation synchrotron undulator sources. Interest in understanding the physical and chemical phenomena behind the observed effects is growing rapidly. The specific structural damage seen in electron density maps has to be accounted for when studying intermediates, and can sometimes be related to biological function. Radiation damage induces non-isomorphism, thus hampering traditional phasing methods. However, specific damage can also be used to obtain phases. With an increased knowledge of expected crystal lifetime, beamline characteristics and types of damage, macromolecular crystallographers might soon be able to account for radiation damage in data collection, processing and phasing.     

Doses for experiments with microbeams and microcrystals: Monte Carlo simulations in RADDOSE‐3D

Increasingly, microbeams and microcrystals are being used for macromolecular crystallography (MX) experiments at synchrotrons. However, radiation damage remains a major concern since it is a fundamental limiting factor affecting the success of macromolecular structure determination. The rate of radiation damage at cryotemperatures is known to be proportional to the absorbed dose, so to optimize experimental outcomes, accurate dose calculations are required which take into account the physics of the interactions of the crystal constituents. The program RADDOSE‐3D estimates the dose absorbed by samples during MX data collection at synchrotron sources, allowing direct comparison of radiation damage between experiments carried out with different samples and beam parameters. This has aided the study of MX radiation damage and enabled prediction of approximately when it will manifest in diffraction patterns so it can potentially be avoided. However, the probability of photoelectron escape from the sample and entry from the surrounding material has not previously been included in RADDOSE‐3D, leading to potentially inaccurate does estimates for experiments using microbeams or microcrystals. We present an extension to RADDOSE‐3D which performs Monte Carlo simulations of a rotating crystal during MX data collection, taking into account the redistribution of photoelectrons produced both in the sample and the material surrounding the crystal. As well as providing more accurate dose estimates, the Monte Carlo simulations highlight the importance of the size and composition of the surrounding material on the dose and thus the rate of radiation damage to the sample. Minimizing irradiation of the surrounding material or removing it almost completely will be key to extending the lifetime of microcrystals and enhancing the potential benefits of using higher incident X‐ray energies.     

Single particle macromolecular structure determination via electron microscopy

Three-dimensional structure determination of macromolecules and macromolecular complexes is an integral part of understanding biological functions. For large protein and macromolecular complexes structure determination is often performed using electron cryomicroscopy where projection images of individual macromolecular complexes are combined to produce a three-dimensional reconstruction. Single particle methods have been devised to perform this structure determination for macromolecular complexes with little or no underlying symmetry. These computational methods generally involve an iterative process of aligning unique views of the macromolecular images followed by determination of the angular components that define those views. In this review, this structure determination process is described with the aim of clarifying a seemingly complex structural method.     

How to avoid premature decay of your macromolecular crystal: a quick soak for long life

Radiation damage to biological samples is currently one of the major limiting factors in macromolecular X-ray crystallography, since it severely and irreversibly affects the quality of the data that can be obtained from a diffraction experiment. However, radiation damage can effectively be reduced by utilizing the electron and radical scavenging potential of certain small-molecule compounds. We propose an approach to protect macromolecular crystals prior to data collection by quick soaking with scavengers. This, in favorable cases, can more than double crystal lifetime in the X-ray beam. The approach has the potential to yield diffraction data of superior quality and hence to increase the amount of high-quality diffraction data and of structural information attainable from a single crystal.     

When X-rays modify the protein structure: radiation damage at work

The majority of 3D structures of macromolecules are currently determined by macromolecular crystallography, which employs the diffraction of X-rays on single crystals. However, during diffraction experiments, the X-rays can damage the protein crystals by ionization processes, especially when powerful X-ray sources at synchrotron facilities are used. This process of radiation damage generates photo-electrons that can get trapped in protein moieties. The 3D structure derived from such experiments can differ remarkably from the structure of the native molecule. Recently, the crystal structures of different oxidation states of horseradish peroxidase and nickel-containing superoxide dismutase were determined using crystallographic redox titration performed during the exposure of the crystals to the incident X-ray beam. Previous crystallographic analyses have not shown the distinct structures of the active sites associated with the redox state of the structural features of these enzymes. These new studies show that, for protein moieties that are susceptible to radiation damage and prone to reduction by photo-electrons, care is required in both the design of the diffraction experiment and the analysis and interpretation.     

Cryo-cooling in macromolecular crystallography: advantages, disadvantages and optimization

The flash-cooling of crystals in macromolecular crystallography has become commonplace. The procedure makes it possible to collect data from much smaller specimens than was the case in the past Also, flash-cooled crystals are much less prone to radiation damage than their room-temperature counterparts, allowing data to be accumulated over extended periods of time. Notwithstanding the attractiveness of the technique, it does have potential disadvantages. First, better methods need to be developed to prevent damage to crystals on freezing. There is also a risk that structures determined at low temperature may suggest conclusions based on aspects of the structure that are not necessarily relevant at room temperature.     

Observation of decreased radiation damage at higher dose rates in room temperature protein crystallography

Radiation damage can be a problem when utilizing ionizing X-radiation in macromolecular crystallography. The dose dependence of radiation damage to eight lysozyme crystals at room temperature (292 K) was investigated in order to provide an accurate comparison with cryotemperature (100 K) results and to allow researchers to calculate expected maximum room-temperature-crystal lifetimes prior to data collection. Results of intensity-loss analysis unexpectedly showed that the dose tolerated by a crystal is dependent on the dose rate according to a positive linear relationship (99% correlation coefficient); a 60% increase in dose rate gave a 4-fold increase in crystal lifetime over the range studied. Alternative metrics of damage were also assessed from room temperature data. In the dose-rate range tested (6 Gy s(-1) to 10 Gy s(-1)), data collection at 100 K appears to offer a 26-113 times increase in the lifetime of the crystal.     

Macromolecular cryocrystallography--methods for cooling and mounting protein crystals at cryogenic temperatures

Cryocrystallography is routinely used in macromolecular crystallography laboratories. The main advantage of X-ray diffraction data collection near 100K is that crystals display much less radiation damage than seen at room temperature. Techniques and tools are described to facilitate cryoprotecting and flash-cooling crystals for data collection.     

FASTDXL: a generalized screen to trap disulfide-stabilized complexes for use in structural studies

Structural studies of macromolecular complexes have produced extraordinary insights into a wide variety of biological processes. Unfortunately, as structural biologists pursue larger and more challenging assemblies, weakly stable and/or nonspecific interactions can become significant roadblocks to structure determination. We have developed a rapid and effective pool-based screen, termed FASTDXL (focused array screening technique for disulfide X-linking), to produce and identify disulfide-stabilized protein-nucleic acid assemblies. A significant strength of FASTDXL is that it can take advantage of prior structural knowledge about molecular interactions, but does not necessarily rely upon it. A detailed application of the approach to the difficult problem of trapping a bacterial primase-ssDNA complex is described, validating the method as a route toward obtaining diffracting crystals suitable for structure determination.     

'Cool' crystals: macromolecular cryocrystallography and radiation damage

Macromolecular crystals commonly suffer rapid radiation damage during room temperature X-ray data collection. Therefore, data are now routinely collected with the sample held at around 100K, significantly reducing secondary radiation damage, and usually resulting in higher resolution and better quality data. At synchrotron sources, the frequent observation of radiation damage even at cryotemperatures has prompted the development of exciting new experiments aimed at characterising and reducing this damage, and using it for structure determination and enzymatic studies. Current research into cryotechniques seeks to understand the basic physical and chemical processes involved in flash-cooling and radiation damage, which should eventually enable the rational optimisation of cryoprotocols.     

Progress in computation and amide hydrogen exchange for prediction of protein-protein complexes

The macromolecular docking problem that must be solved for experimental biologists is prediction of the structures of complexes for which the components are known or reliably modeled in the unbound state, but the structure of the complex is unknown. The current state of the art in macromolecular docking is such that solving this problem usually requires supplementary experimental chemical and/or biological information to evaluate computational predictions. Amide (1)H/(2)H exchange measured by mass spectroscopy is a promising approach for obtaining such information, because it can reveal interfacial regions of each member of the complex and identify regions of conformational flexibility in the structure. In a previous article (Anand et al., Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 2003;100:13264-13269), we used (1)H/(2)H exchange data to predict the structure of a complex between regulatory and catalytic subunits of protein kinase A. Comparison of the prediction with a recent crystal structure determination (Kim et al., Science 2005;307:690-696) showed large conformational change in the regulatory subunit on formation of the complex. Analysis of the prediction, previous CAPRI results, novel data processing methods for the (1)H/(2)H exchange data, and new fragment docking computations give grounds for cautious optimism that this method can be useful even in cases of substantial conformational change.     

Liquid sample delivery techniques for serial femtosecond crystallography

X-ray free-electron lasers overcome the problem of radiation damage in protein crystallography and allow structure determination from micro- and nanocrystals at room temperature. To ensure that consecutive X-ray pulses do not probe previously exposed crystals, the sample needs to be replaced with the X-ray repetition rate, which ranges from 120 Hz at warm linac-based free-electron lasers to 1 MHz at superconducting linacs. Liquid injectors are therefore an essential part of a serial femtosecond crystallography experiment at an X-ray free-electron laser. Here, we compare different techniques of injecting microcrystals in solution into the pulsed X-ray beam in vacuum. Sample waste due to mismatch of the liquid flow rate to the X-ray repetition rate can be addressed through various techniques.     

Biological horizons in molecular microscopy.

The purpose envisaged in this report is not to provide a comprehensive monography but rather to give a survey, especially for biologists, of the state of the art and of current research trends in molecular microscopy. Following a brief discussion of the obvious discrepancy between instrumental capabilities and the limits of biologically significant information, a definition of the diversifying field is attempted. Four main topics are discussed. First, recent progress in the field of "low noise" specimen supports is reviewed. It is emphasized that a minimum background structure is an important but not the sole criterion for a satisfactory support. It is the ability to adsorb molecules in a predeterminable and orderly fashion which will attract wider attention in the future; positional and orientational order figure as crucial points in the strategem of low dose microscopy. Second, the problem of achieving adequate contrast without the expense of an unfaithful representation of molecular structures is discussed. Contrast is a problem of optimum imaging modes as well as of preparatory techniques. The third topic of discussion is specimen dehydration. Several avenues to circumvent or at least to alleviate dehydration artifacts are outlined. The last chapter focusses on the most fundamental problem in molecular microscopy:radiation damage. A brief synopsis of the physical and physico-chemical processes involved in damaging interactions is given and an attempt is made to tesselate the true picture of radiation damage to lipids and proteins. This might serve as a guidance in assessing the degree of structural fidelity to be expected for a given electron dose. Possibilities to overcome the radiation damage problem are adumbrated.     

Monitoring and validating active site redox states in protein crystals

High resolution protein crystallography using synchrotron radiation is one of the most powerful tools in modern biology. Improvements in resolution have arisen from the use of X-ray beamlines with higher brightness and flux and the development of advanced detectors. However, it is increasingly recognised that the benefits brought by these advances have an associated cost, namely deleterious effects of X-ray radiation on the sample (radiation damage). In particular, X-ray induced reduction and damage to redox centres has been shown to occur much more rapidly than other radiation damage effects, such as loss of resolution or damage to disulphide bridges. Selection of an appropriate combination of in-situ single crystal spectroscopies during crystallographic experiments, such as UV-visible absorption and X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAFS), allows for effective monitoring of redox states in protein crystals in parallel with structure determination. Such approaches are also essential in cases where catalytic intermediate species are generated by exposure to the X-ray beam. In this article, we provide a number of examples in which multiple single crystal spectroscopies have been key to understanding the redox status of Fe and Cu centres in crystal structures. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Protein Structure and Function in the Crystalline State.     

Cross-crystal averaging with search models to improve molecular replacement phases

The application of molecular replacement (MR) in macromolecular crystallography can be limited by the "model bias" problem. Here we propose a strategy to reduce model bias when only part of a new structure is known: after the MR search, structure determination of the unknown part of the new structure can be facilitated by cross-crystal averaging of the known part of the new structure with the search model. This strategy dramatically improves electron density in the unknown part of the new structure. It has enabled us to determine the structures of two coronavirus receptor-binding domains each complexed with their receptor at moderate resolutions. In a test case, it also enabled automated model building when >50% of an antigen-antibody complex was absent. These results suggest that this averaging strategy can be routinely used after MR to enhance the interpretability of electron density associated with missing model.     

Defining and solving the essential protein-protein interactions in HIV infection

The structure determination of macromolecular complexes is entering a new era. The methods of optical microscopy, electron microscopy, X-ray crystallography, and nuclear magnetic resonance increasingly are being combined in hybrid method approaches to achieve an integrated view of macromolecular complexes that span from cellular context to atomic detail. A particularly important application of these hybrid method approaches is the structural analysis of the Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) proteins with their cellular binding partners. High resolution structure determination of essential HIV - host cell protein complexes and correlative analysis of these complexes in the live cell can serve as critical guides in the design of a broad, new class of therapeutics that function by disrupting such complexes. Here, with the hope of stimulating some discussion, we will briefly review some of the literature in the context of what could be done to further apply structural methods to HIV research. We have chosen to focus our attention on certain aspects of the HIV replication cycle where we think that structural information would contribute substantially to the development of new therapeutic and vaccine targets for HIV.     

Recent developments in software for the automation of crystallographic macromolecular structure determination

The automation of macromolecular structure determination by X-ray crystallography has long been a goal for many researchers. Recently, there have been improvements in the underlying algorithms, some of which have been implemented in software packages that deal with multiple stages of the structure determination process. These first steps towards complete automation have made X-ray crystallography more efficient.     

Radiation-induced autophagy: mechanisms and consequences

Autophagy is an evolutionary conserved, indispensable, lysosome-mediated degradation process, which helps in maintaining homeostasis during various cellular traumas. During stress, a context-dependent role of autophagy has been observed which drives the cell towards survival or death depending upon the type, time, and extent of the damage. The process of autophagy is stimulated during various cellular insults, e.g. oxidative stress, endoplasmic reticulum stress, imbalances in calcium homeostasis, and altered mitochondrial potential. Ionizing radiation causes ROS-dependent as well as ROS-independent damage in cells that involve macromolecular (mainly DNA) damage, as well as ER stress induction, both capable of inducing autophagy. This review summarizes the current understanding on the roles of oxidative stress, ER stress, DNA damage, altered mitochondrial potential, and calcium imbalance in radiation-induced autophagy as well as the merits and limitations of targeting autophagy as an approach for radioprotection and radiosensitization.     

A three dimensional visualisation approach to protein heavy-atom structure reconstruction

Background

A commonly recurring problem in structural protein studies, is the determination of all heavy atom positions from the knowledge of the central α-carbon coordinates.

Results

We employ advances in virtual reality to address the problem. The outcome is a 3D visualisation based technique where all the heavy backbone and side chain atoms are treated on equal footing, in terms of the C_α coordinates. Each heavy atom is visualised on the surfaces of a different two-sphere, that is centered at another heavy backbone and side chain atoms. In particular, the rotamers are visible as clusters, that display a clear and strong dependence on the underlying backbone secondary structure.

Conclusions

We demonstrate that there is a clear interdependence between rotameric states and secondary structure. Our method easily detects those atoms in a crystallographic protein structure which are either outliers or have been likely misplaced, possibly due to radiation damage. Our approach forms a basis for the development of a new generation, visualization based side chain construction, validation and refinement tools. The heavy atom positions are identified in a manner which accounts for the secondary structure environment, leading to improved accuracy.