Regulatory mechanisms in cytotoxic T lymphocyte development. II. Dissociation of in vitro cytotoxic T-lymphocyte and suppressor T-cell activities with L-ornithine

L-ornithine was found to differentially affect the induction of allospecific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) and suppressor T cells (Ts). At a concentration of 10 mM, ornithine inhibited the development of CTL in a mixed-leukocyte culture (MLC). This same population of cells suppressed the generation of CTL when irradiated and cocultured with fresh syngeneic lymphocytes and alloantigen. Suppression was mediated by Lyt-1-2+ cells and was antigen specific. Suppression was abrogated when IL-2 (10 U/ml) was added to the cocultures, but could not be reversed by increasing the antigen dose. Ornithine was not toxic to CTL precursors but rather arrested their development. Cells from MLC plus ornithine developed CTL activity within 2 days of transfer to secondary cultures in the absence of ornithine. Development of CTL effector cells (CTLe) was augmented by but did not require exogenous IL-2. Generation of CTLe from the MLC plus ornithine population was radiation sensitive and could be inhibited by reexposure to ornithine, even in the presence of IL-2. Thus, Lyt-1-2+ T cells allostimulated in vitro in MLC plus ornithine and lacking CTL activity convey radiation-resistant, antigen-specific suppression.     

Inhibition of cytolytic T lymphocyte maturation with ornithine, arginine, and putrescine

L-Ornithine was shown to inhibit the development of cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) in mixed lymphocyte cultures (MLC). Lymphokines were unable to reverse the suppressive effect, and cytotoxic activity was not revealed by coupling ornithine-inhibited MLC cells to target cells with phytohemagglutinin (PHA). If addition of ornithine to MLC were delayed, sensitivity of CTL to inhibition was reduced after 24 hr and lost by 48 hr. Suppression of CTL development was not due to a toxic effect. MLC washed free of ornithine after 3 days produced detectable cytolytic activity within 24 hr of secondary culture, and to the same degree as the uninhibited MLC control within 48 hr. Cytotoxic cells generated in secondary cultures were Lyt-2+, did not kill the natural killer-sensitive YAC-1 cell line, and were shown to be antigen-specific by virtue of the findings that cytolysis and cold target inhibition were observed only with cells carrying the original, inducing H-2 haplotype. Cytolysis of target cells by normal CTL effector cells was not inhibited by L-ornithine. MLC depleted of accessory cells so that CTL activation was dependent upon addition of lymphokines remained susceptible to inhibition by ornithine. Our findings indicate that in the ornithine-inhibited MLC, CTL precursors undergo clonal expansion, but their maturation is arrested at a precytolytic stage. L-Arginine and putrescine also suppressed generation of CTL in primary MLC, and cells recovered from arginine- and putrescine-inhibited MLC developed control levels of CTL within 48 hr of secondary culture. Inhibition by putrescine was observed in tissue culture medium supplemented with human serum but not with fetal calf serum, presumably due to the presence of diamine oxidase activity in fetal calf serum. Similar to ornithine, the suppressive effects of arginine and putrescine on T lymphocytes were apparently selective for CTL because they did not inhibit mitogen activation with concanavalin A or the production of interleukin 2 and interleukin 3. These findings are consistent with a hypothesis that the inhibitory effects of ornithine, arginine, and putrescine are mediated by polyamines, and exerted on the differentiative stage of CTL development.     

Regulation of the cytotoxic activity of alloreactive cytotoxic T lymphocytes by helper cells and lymphokines

The cytotoxic activity of alloreactive cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) was maintained and augmented by transferring cells from a 5-day mixed lymphocyte culture MLC into a host culture (HC) containing indomethacin, freshly explanted normal spleen cells, and peritoneal cells which were syngeneic to the MLC cells. The MLC cells used in the transfer experiments were generated by culturing untreated H-2b splenic responders with irradiated H-2d stimulators, or were generated by culturing Lyt-2-depleted H-2b splenic responders with irradiated H-2d stimulators. The allo-CTL were found to be derived from the donor MLC (first culture) when unfractionated MLC cells were transferred into a host (second) culture and incubated for 5 days. In contrast, the allo-CTL were derived from host culture cells when Lyt-2-depleted MLC cells were transferred and the combined cultures incubated for 5 days. In the former case, the augmentation of MLC-derived cytotoxicity did not result from nonspecific expansion of all donor T cells; instead it was mediated by lymphokine(s), distinct from IL-2, produced by helper T cells generated in host culture, which appeared to selectively expand the antigen-specific CTL or to increase the cytotoxic activity of these CTL. The helper T cells were Thy-1+, L3T4+, and Lyt-2-. These findings indicate that antigen-nonspecific help was provided by helper cells or helper factors (lymphokines) generated in the host culture, which maintained and augmented the cytotoxic activity of the fully generated allo-CTL. This helper effect was also seen in the induction of primary allo-CTL responses which could be generated with fewer stimulating cells and with a stronger cytotoxic response at different R/S ratios tested. The generation of allo-CTL in second culture following transfer of Lyt-2-depleted MLC cells to host cultures appears to have involved antigen carryover from the MLC; however, antigen carryover alone was not sufficient. It appears that in the absence of Lyt-2+ suppressor T cells, antigen-specific help might be generated in donor cultures (Lyt-2-depleted MLC) which promoted or recruited the generation of antigen-specific CTL in host culture.     

Dissociation of differentiation and proliferation in the primary induction of cytolytic T lymphocytes by alloantigens

The requirement for DNA synthesis in the induction of cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) by alloantigens has been investigated. C57BL/6 splenic T cells purified by passage on nylon wool columns were stimulated in vitro in mixed leukocyte culture (MLC) and assayed for cytotoxicity against 51Cr-labeled target cells. With this system, CTL activity was detectable after 24 hr of MLC and reached high levels after 48 hr. Addition of cytosine arabinoside (ARA-C) or hydroxyurea to such cultures at concentrations that were sufficient to inhibit DNA synthesis by greater than 98% did not reduce CTL activity measured after 24 hr; however, the increase in activity that occurred between 24 and 48 hr in control cultures was strongly reduced (or abolished) by these drugs. Velocity sedimentation analysis of MLC cells activated for 48 hr in the presence of ARA-C further revealed that CTL precursor lymphocytes had enlarged into medium- to large-sized CTL under these conditions. These studies provide direct evidence that the primary induction of CTL by alloantigens can be dissociated into a differentiation step, which occurs within 24 hr in the absence of DNA synthesis and is accompanied by blast transformation, and a subsequent proliferation.     

Generation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes in vitro. VI. Effect of cell density on response in mixed leukocyte cultures.

Reexposure of day 14 murine mixed leukocyte culture (MLC) populations to the original irradiated allogeneic stimulating spleen cells has previously been found to result in the ratpid generation of cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) associated with a net increase in cultured cell number. Under the experimental conditions used, day 5 MLC cells appeared unable to respond to the allogeneic stimulus. In order to characterize further the development of the potential for anamnestic reactivity during the course of MLC, C57BL/6 spleen cells were incubated with irradiated (1000 rads) DBA/2 spleen cells (primary MLC) for up to 3 weeks. At various time intervals after the onset of the primary MLC, the surviving cells were collected and reexposed, at varying cell concentrations, to irradiated DBA/2 spleen cells (secondary MLC). At daily intervals thereafter, CTL activity was assessed using a quantitative 51Cr-release assay system. A paradoxic effect of responding cell concentration on generation of CTL activity was observed; relatively greater increase in CTL activity was observed as the concentration of responding cells was decreased over a 100-fold range. This effect was more pronounced with responding cells reexposed to antigen after primary MLC for 20 days, but was observed even with normal cells. The apparent unresponsiveness of day 5 MLC cells to alloantigen restimulation could be overcome by simple dilution of responding cells. Cytotoxic activity at the time of restimulation with antigen seems to be a major factor determining the magnitude of the secondary response. Since intact cells bearing alloantigens are required for the generation of CTL in MLC, residual cytotoxic cells reduce the effective antigenic stimulus by destroying stimulating cells. This effect of concentration of responding cells on generation of CTL in MLC complicates interpretation of experiments investigating the role of "inhibitor" and "helper" cell in cell-mediated immune responses occurring in vitro. Under optimal conditions, the highest CTL activity and the largest increase in total cell number was observed 4 days after restimulation of day 10 MLC cells. On a per cell basis, the lytic activity was up to 4 times greater than that observed at the peak of a primary response, and the number of viable cells recovered was nearly 20 times higher than that at the onset. Such secondary MLC are thus a convenient source of lymphoid cells selected primarily on the basis of proliferation induced by alloantigens.     

Inhibition of alloantigen-induced cytolytic T lymphocytes in vitro with (2R,5R)-6-heptyne-2,5-diamine, an irreversible inhibitor of ornithine decarboxylase

The objective of the present investigation was to examine the effect of a new potent irreversible inhibitor of ornithine decarboxylase, (2R,5R)-6-heptyne-2,5-diamine (MAP) (MDL 72,175), on the induction of functionally reactive T-cell populations in vitro. We examined alloantigen-activated cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) and T-helper (TH) lymphocytes generated during a one-way mixed-leukocyte culture (MLC). The addition of MAP (1 mM) at the initiation of cell culture reduced intracellular putrescine, spermidine, and spermine levels by 81.9, 82.4, and 55.8% respectively. MAP reduced CTL induction 93.8, 78.4, and 37.5% when added at 0, 24, or 48 hr of culture, respectively. A dose-dependent inhibition of CTL induction and polyamine levels was observed following MAP treatment. In direct comparison with another ODC inhibitor, alpha-difluoromethylornithine (DFMO), MAP was five- to sixfold more potent in reducing CTL induction. CTL generation is dependent upon the endogenous production of the TH-cell product interleukin 2 (IL-2). MAP treatment reduced detectable IL-2 activity in a MLC by 54.8%. These results indicate that MAP is a potent inhibitor of alloantigen-activated CTL in vitro and deserves further investigation as a potential immunosuppressive agent.     

Heterogeneity of immunologic memory T cells specific for H-2 antigens and detection of their receptors

The in-vivo-induced memory T cells (MC) of mice, specific to H-2 antigens, are assayed by the generation of the secondary cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) in mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) activated by heat-killed stimulator cells. The MC are shown to adhere selectively to the corresponding target monolayer that gives rise to both the loss of MC activity in the population of non-adherent lymphocytes and gain in MC activity in the population adherent and eluted from the same monolayer. In addition to the revealing of MC H-2 antigen-binding receptors, the absorption-elution technique allows the separation of the MC into two categories: secondary CTL precursors bearing these receptors, and secondary amplifier cells non-adherent to the monolayer and assayed by promotion of the CTL generation from the primary precursors activated in MLC by heated stimulators. The difference in the receptor properties between the primary and secondary CTL precursors raises the possibility that the MC are generated not only in the amplifier cell population but also in the independent CTL precursor population.     

Increased cytolytic T lymphocyte activity induced by 2-mercaptoethanol in mixed leukocyte cultures: kinetics and possible mechanisms of action.

The 20- to 50-fold increase in cytolytic T lymphocyte (CTL) activity caused by the addition of 50 muM 2-mercaptoethanol (2-ME) at the onset of a one-way murine mixed leukocyte culture (MLC) between C57BL/6 and DBA/2 splenic lymphocytes appears to be unrelated to early events in the culture: if 2-ME was present for the first 24 hr of culture only, there was no increase on day 4, but if addition of 2-ME was delayed until the last 24 hr of culture, the CTL activity was almost as high as that of cultures that were exposed to 2-ME for the entire 4-day culture period. The increase of CTL activity caused by delayed addition of 2-ME ("2-ME rescue") was used to investigate the mechanism by which the thiol induces differentiation of CTL from precursor cells. 2-ME rescue was mimicked by two other thiols, dithiothreitol and cysteamine phosphate, but at higher concentrations. Because the latter compound has no free sulhydryl group until it diffuses into cells and is enzymatically dephosphorylated, we conclude that thiols may increase the differentiation of CTL from precursor cells by an intracellular process involving free sulphydryl groups rather than by interaction with membrane sulfhydryls or destruction of inhibitor cells or their products. Cell separation experiments indicated that 2-ME rescue was independent of the presence of B lymphocytes and of adherent cells (macrophages) and was restricted to a subpopulation of T lymphocytes that developed into large lymphoid precursor cells during the first 3 days in culture even without 2-ME. The development of this subpopulation required DNA synthesis between 24 nad 72 hr after the onset of MLC. When 2-ME was added to day-3 MLC, CTL activity increased slightly as early as 4 hr later, but the major increase occurred during the second half of the 24 hr "rescue"period. Because this increase was inhibited by cytosine arabinoside (ARA-C), it seems likely that DNA synthesis is associated with and may be required for the differentiation of large precursor lymphoid cells into CTL after the addition of 2-ME.     

Lyt-2+ suppressor T cells are resistant to anti-Lyt-2 antibody blocking

Lyt-2 molecules play a role in antigen recognition by cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL). In an attempt to determine whether Lyt-2 molecules play a similar role in suppressor T cell (Ts) functions, the effect of anti-Lyt-2 antibodies on Ts generation and effector activity was studied. Allospecific Ts were induced in allogeneic mixed lymphocyte cultures (MLC). Anti-Lyt-2 antibodies added to MLC in the absence of complement abolished CTL generation, but had no effect on concomitant induction of Ts. In a different experimental system, allospecific Ts were induced in cultures treated with pyrilamine, which blocks generation of CTL but allows differentiation of Ts. The addition of anti-Lyt-2 antibodies to pyrilamine-treated MLC resulted in unaffected induction of Ts. It was further demonstrated that the effector activity of Ts was as resistant to anti-Lyt-2 antibodies as their induction, in contrast to the cytolytic activity of CTL, which was inhibited by the same antibodies. Ts in the present experimental system were Lyt-2+ antigen-specific cells. It therefore appears that Lyt-2 molecules, although expressed on both CTL and Ts, are involved in CTL activity, but do not play an essential role in Ts function.     

Three different signals are required for the induction of cytolytic T lymphocytes from resting precursors

The requirement for the signals in induction of cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) has been investigated. C57BL/6 X CBA/T6 F1 spleen cells stimulated with the lectin leukoagglutinin (L-A) failed to show CTL activity in a PHA-facilitated assay, although L-A-activated splenic T cells were able to respond to T cell growth factor (TCGF). Concanavalin A (Con A) on the other hand was able to induce cytolytic activity from CTL-P, as well as to render splenic T cells responsive to TCGF. Furthermore, L-A-activated splenic T cells could generate cytolytic activity upon subsequent culture in secondary mixed leukocyte culture supernatant (2 degrees MLC SN). In contrast, EL-4-derived SN (EL-4 SN) was unable to induce cytolytic activity from L-A-activated spleen cells. In addition, proliferation of L-A-activated spleen cells cultured in EL-4 SN was similar to those cultured in 2 degrees MLC SN. Nonactivated spleen cells were totally unresponsive to both SN in proliferation and generation of CTL. Analysis of T cell clones for the production of a factor necessary for induction of cytolytic activity revealed that both cytolytic and noncytolytic T cell clones were able to produce a factor(s) for the generation of cytolytic activity from L-A-activated T cells. On the other hand, SN from certain antigen-stimulated T cell clones produced factors capable of inducing cytocytic activity by L-A-activated T cells only in the presence of EL-4 SN. Neither EL-4 SN nor cloned T cell SN alone had such a capacity. The nature of the necessary lymphokines in the SN from the clone cells or from the EL-4 is unknown. In the case of the EL-4 SN, it is not known whether the presence of TCGF plays a role or whether that role is perhaps more differentiative than proliferative. This study provides evidence that the induction of CTL from CTL-P can be dissociated into activation, which is required to render T cells responsive to second signals, and differentiation, which is mediated by two different factors.     

Regulation of primary cytotoxic T lymphocyte responses generated during mixed leukocyte culture with H-2d identical Qa-1-disparate cells

Cytotoxic lymphocyte (CTL) responses are not usually generated during primary mixed leukocyte culture (MLC) with H-2 identical cells. Thus NZB mice are unusual in that their spleen cells do mount CTL responses during primary MLC with H-2d identical stimulator cells; the predominant target antigen for these NZB responses is Qa-1b. Considering the numerous immunoregulatory defects in NZB mice, we postulated that these NZB anti-Qa-1 primary CTL responses were due to an abnormality in T suppressor cell activity. Cellular interactions capable of suppressing NZB anti-Qa-1 primary CTL responses were investigated by using one-way and two-way MLC with spleen cells from NZB mice and other H-2d strains. Although H-2d identical one-way MLC with the use of NZB responders resulted in substantial CTL responses, only minimal CTL responses were detected from two-way MLC with the use of NZB spleen cells plus nonirradiated spleen cells from other H-2d mice. Thus the presence of non-NZB spleen cells in the two-way H-2d identical MLC prevented the generation of NZB CTL. Noncytotoxic mechanisms were implicated in the suppression of the NZB CTL responses during two-way MLC, because only minimal CTL activity was generated when NZB spleen cells were cultured with semiallogeneic, H-2d identical (e.g., NZB X BALB) F1 spleen cells. The observed suppression could be abrogated with as little as 100 rad gamma-irradiation to the non-NZB spleen cells. The phenotype of these highly radiosensitive spleen cells was Thy-1+, Lyt-1+, Lyt-2-, L3T4+. The functional presence of these cells in the spleens of semiallogeneic, H-2d identical F1 mice indicated that their deficiency in NZB mice was a recessive trait. These data suggest that NZB mice lack an L3T4+ cell present in the spleens of normal mice that is capable of suppressing primary anti-Qa-1 CTL responses. This model system should facilitate additional investigations of the cellular interactions and immunoregulatory mechanisms responsible for controlling primary CTL responses against non-H-2K/D class I alloantigens. The model may also provide insight into the immunoregulatory defects of autoimmune NZB mice.     

Effect of synthetic beta-carotene on the formation of cytolytic T-lymphocytes

The effect of intraperitoneal injection of beta-carotene in different doses on the formation of cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) in a one-way mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) of allogeneic mice was studied. The maximal cytotoxic activity of lymphocytes was attained in the MLC with splenocytes of mice which received 10 mg/kg beta-carotene 6 days before experimentation. The correlation was studied between the beta-carotene ability to stimulate CTL formation and antineoplastic activity. It was discovered that injection of beta-carotene in doses and times provoking maximal CTL induction had no effect on the animals' lifespan and the size of transplanted sarcoma 180.     

FCS-activated blast T cells inhibit the in vitro response of memory CTL precursors to alloantigens by removal of factor(s) from MLC supernatant

The inhibitory effect of spleen cells, precultured in the presence of FCS, was assayed on the memory cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) response to alloantigens. For this, we have used in vitro conditions in which both particulate alloantigen and MLC SN are required to allow the generation of CTL. It was shown that the CTL response was totally inhibited in the presence of 5 to 7 days precultured spleen cells. This inhibitory effect was partly due to removal, by those precultured cells, of relevant factor(s) contained in the MLC SN. After velocity sedimentation at unit gravity, it was shown that the T cells able to inhibit the cytolytic response and to remove MLC SN factor(s) are found in the fractions containing the large proliferating cells. It was further demonstrated that in the presence of inhibiting cells, a significant CTL response may be obtained after addition of concentrated MLC SN. However, in this way, this inhibitory effect was not totally circumvented, which suggests that the memory CTL response is also impaired by other mechanisms.     

Immunoregulation by mouse T-cell clones. I. Suppression and amplification of cytotoxic responses by cloned H-Y-specific cytolytic T lymphocytes

H-Y-specific and H-2Db-restricted, Lyt-1-2+ T-cell clones ( CTLL ) with graded specific cytotoxic activities on male C57BL/6 (B6) target cells ( 1E3 , ; 2C5 , ++; 2A5 , +, 3E6 , +/-) were tested for their capacity to inhibit the generation of H-Y-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) in vitro. Addition of irradiated lymphocytes of CTLL 1E3 and CTLL 3E6 but not those of CTLL 2A5 or CTLL 2C5 abolished the generation of CTL from in vivo primed H-Y-specific precursor cells (CTLP) when added to fresh mixed-lymphocyte cultures (MLC). Exogenous sources of T-cell growth factors (TCGF) did not overcome suppression. Rather the presence of TCGF resulted in a further enhancement of suppressive activities in CTLL 1E3 and 3E6 and the induction of similar activities in cells from CTLL 2A5 and 2C5 , which by themselves were not inhibitory. Moreover when added to similar MLC on Day 1 instead of Day 0, only irradiated cells of CTLL 3E6 but not those of the other three CTLL were suppressive. Induction of suppressive activities in H-Y-specific CTLL was independent of the appropriate male stimulator cells since it was also observed in MLC induced by irrelevant antigens (H-2, trinitrophenol). Furthermore at low cell numbers, irradiated lymphocytes from any of the CTLL consistently enhanced CTL activities generated from H-Y-specific CTLP. This augmenting activity, which was not TCGF, could be transferred by soluble mediators present in antigen-sensitized CTLL cultures. Thus, these data indicate (i) that cytotoxic effector cells can function as suppressor cells in the generation of CTL, (ii) that the cytotoxic activity of cloned CTL does not correlate with their capacity to suppress CTL responses, (iii) that the inhibition of CTL responses by CTLL is not due to simple consumption of T-cell growth factors produced in MLC, and (iv) that different CTL clones may interfere with the generation of CTL at different stages of their maturation. Moreover, the experiments suggest an antigen-independent enhancement of suppression by the interaction of CTL with lymphokines. Together with the augmenting activity evoked by cloned CTL the data provide strong evidence for the expression of multiple immunological functions by one particular subset of T cells and suggest that cytotoxic effector cells can differentially regulate the maturation and/or clonal expression of their precursor cells.     

IL-6/BSF-2 functions as a killer helper factor in the in vitro induction of cytotoxic T cells

rIL-6/B cell stimulatory factor 2 was found to augment CTL generation from mature as well as immature human T cells stimulated with UV-treated allogeneic cells. rIL-6 also acted on peanut agglutinin-positive murine thymocytes and Lyt-2-positive splenic T cells to give rise to CTL. rIL-6 alone could not induce CTL generation, the presence of IL-2 during the early phase of culture period was found to be essential for the IL-6 activity in the induction of CTL. The effect of rIL-6 was not mediated by the induction of IL-2 inasmuch as rIL-6 did not augment IL-2 production in MLC and anti-IL-2 antibody could not neutralize IL-6 activity. rIL-6 augmented CTL generation even when added 72 h after the initiation of cultures. The enhancing activity of rIL-6 could be neutralized with anti-IL-6 antibodies even when added 72 h after the initiation of cultures. The present data indicate that IL-6 acts in the late phase of CTL generation.     

Characterization of effector lymphocytes associated with immunity to murine sarcoma virus (MSV) induced tumors. I. Physical properties of cytolytic T lymphocytes generated in vitro and of their immediate progenitors.

Cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) were generated in secondary mixed leukocyte-tumor cell cultures (MLTC) with syngeneic RB1-5 tumor cells as stimulating cells and with responding spleen cells from regressor mice that had rejected a murine sarcoma virus (MSV)-induced tumor. CTL precursor cells were found to be exclusively of thymic origin and non-T cells were apparently not required for CTL generation. When the size variations of CTL from syngeneic MLTC were analyzed by velocity sedimentation it appeared that a transition from small precursor cells to larger effector cells occurred during the first 5 days in culture; this change in cell size was then followed by a shift toward small-sized cells. Furthermore, the CTL generated in syngeneic MLTC in the MSV tumor immune system were compared with those CTL obtained in allogeneic mixed leukocyte cultures (MLC) and were shown to exhibit fundamental similarities.     

Human cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) induced by phytohemagglutinin: conditions for CTL generation and effect of interferon

The present study demonstrates that human peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PMC) can be stimulated in vitro to become cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) by PHA. A significant cytotoxic activity of PMC was detected 48 hr after the culture initiation in the presence of 5 micrograms/ml of PHA and the peak level of the activity was obtained by culturing PMC for 72 hr. The cytotoxic cells require the presence of PHA as a cell agglutinin for the expression of their cytotoxic activity. The effector cells mediating the activity were identified as T lymphocytes by E-rosette fractionation of PMC. In this system, removal of carbonyl iron phagocytosed or attached cells from PMC did not abrogate CTL generation of PMC. In addition, human alpha-interferon did not augment CTL generation or expression of their activity. Although the target cells employed were sensitive to natural killer (NK) cells, the effector cells induced by PHA did not seem to have any relation to the NK cells. The present study may provide a useful tool to analyze for precursors of killer T cells.     

Studies on the mechanism of suppression of primary cytotoxic responses by cloned cytotoxic T lymphocytes

We have shown in the accompanying companion paper that cloned cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) can serve as veto cells in vitro, suppressing primary cytotoxic activity directed against antigens expressed by those cloned CTL but not against third party antigens. We now explore the mechanism of this antigen-specific suppression by cloned CTL, using as a model system the ability of G4, a BALB.B anti-H-2Dd CTL clone, to specifically suppress a primary in vitro anti-H-2b CTL response. G4 cells do not constitutively secrete a suppressor factor, because suppression cannot be mediated by supernatants removed from G4 cells at a time when they are routinely used as veto cells. Furthermore, medium removed from cultures suppressed by G4 will not suppress, indicating that the veto cell function of G4 is not mediated by soluble factors. Full suppression of primary anti-H-2b CTL responses requires that G4 be present throughout the 5-day mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC). Removal of G4 during the first 3 days of MLC results in a drastic reduction in the level of antigen-specific suppression, with a slight but reproducible loss of suppression after veto cell removal on day 4. The addition of G4 during the course of an ongoing MLC reveals that maximal suppression requires the presence of veto cells during the first 24 to 48 hr of culture. Thus, G4 cells must be present both early and late in an MLC to exert maximal veto cell suppression. Several experiments suggest that G4-induced veto cell activity is unlikely to be due to cytolysis of CTL precursors which are capable of recognizing G4. G4 cannot specifically recognize these CTL precursors, and G4 cells are inefficient at lectin-mediated lysis of non-tumor cell targets. Furthermore, we show that G4 cells cannot lyse CTL which recognize them. Finally, dilutions of anti-clonotypic antibodies which completely block both lectin-mediated and specific cytolysis by G4 do not block (and in fact enhance) G4-mediated veto cell activity.     

Suppression of lymphocyte alloreactivity by early gestational human decidua. II. Characterization of the suppressor mechanisms

We have earlier shown that first trimester human decidual cells (typical decidual cells and decidual macrophages) suppress lymphocyte alloreactivity (MLR and CTL generation) in vitro in an MHC-unrestricted manner and that this suppression is mediated by PGE2. The present study explored the mechanisms underlying this suppression by noting the effects of decidual cells (+/- indomethacin or anti-PGE2 antibody) or chemically pure PGE2 on numerous T lymphocyte activation events following allogeneic stimulation in mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) or polyclonal activation with Con A. The results revealed that this suppression was the net result of an action of PGE2 on at least two events during lymphocyte activation: (i) a down-regulation of IL-2 receptor development on lymphocytes, quantitated with a radioimmunoassay and radioautography; this was noted in MLC or Con A-stimulated lymphocyte cultures in the presence of decidual cells (reversible in the presence of indomethacin or anti-PGE2 antibody), or PGE2, but not PGF2 alpha; (ii) an inhibition of IL-2 production in the MLC, measured with a bioassay using an IL-2-dependent T cell line (CTLL-2) and a recombinant IL-2 standard. These effects blocked cell proliferation and eventual generation of killer cells in the MLC. Decidual cells or PGE2 did not interfere with IL-2-dependent proliferation of CTLL-2 cells, which require an interaction between IL-2 receptors on these cells and IL-2. Finally, neither agent interfered with the lytic function of CTL, once generated. These results indicate that the PGE2-mediated immunosuppressor function of early gestational human decidual cells is accomplished by an afferent blockade of the early events in T lymphocyte activation.     

Veto cell H-2 antigens: veto cell activity is restricted by determinants encoded by K, D, and I MHC regions

Responder cells from primary syngeneic and allogeneic one-way mixed-lymphocyte cultures (MLC) specifically inhibit the development of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) directed against the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) antigens of the MLC responder cells. This special kind of suppressor activity is known as veto suppression. Ia+ cells with veto activity obtained from H-2 recombinant mouse strains were shown to downregulate alloantigen (class II)-specific helper activity for class I-specific CTL development in a primary MLC provided that the veto cells expressed the same I-E alpha subregion as the MLC stimulator cells. The veto-induced suppression of allo-help was prevented by the addition of supernatant from concanavalin A-stimulated spleen cells (Con A-SN) and was inhibited considerably by very high amounts of recombinant interleukin-2 (IL-2). In the presence of Con A-SN, CTL precursors recognizing either the K end or the D end of the veto cell MHC were found to be inactivated. Thus, our results indicate that MLC responder cells include active veto cells expressing Ia region-encoded restriction elements for allospecific T helper cells, as well as K- or D-encoded restriction elements for allospecific T cytotoxic cells.