Effective gene silencing activity of prodrug-type 2′-O-methyldithiomethyl siRNA compared with non-prodrug-type 2′-O-methyl siRNA

Small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) are an active agent to induce gene silencing and they have been studied for becoming a biological and therapeutic tool. Various 2′-O-modified RNAs have been extensively studied to improve the nuclease resistance. However, the 2′-O-modified siRNA activities were often decreased by modification, since the bulky 2′-O-modifications inhibit to form a RNA-induced silencing complex (RISC). We developed novel prodrug-type 2′-O-methyldithiomethyl (MDTM) siRNA, which is converted into natural siRNA in an intracellular reducing environment. Prodrug-type 2′-O-MDTM siRNAs modified at the 5′-end side including 5′-end nucleotide and the seed region of the antisense strand exhibited much stronger gene silencing effect than non-prodrug-type 2′-O-methyl (2′-O-Me) siRNAs. Furthermore, the resistances for nuclease digestion of siRNAs were actually enhanced by 2′-O-MDTM modifications. Our results indicate that 2′-O-MDTM modifications improve the stability of siRNA in serum and they are able to be introduced at any positions of siRNA.     

RNA interference tolerates 2'-fluoro modifications at the Argonaute2 cleavage site

Short interfering RNA (siRNA) molecules with good gene-silencing properties are needed for drug development based on RNA interference (RNAi). An initial step in RNAi is the activation of the RNA-induced silencing complex RISC, which requires degradation of the sense strand of the siRNA duplex. Although various chemical modifications have been introduced to the antisense strand, modifications to the Argonaute2 (Ago2) cleavage site in the sense strand have, so far, not been described in detail. In this work, novel 2'-F-purine modifications were introduced to siRNAs, and their biological efficacies were tested in cells stably expressing human tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase (TRACP). A validated siRNA that contains both purine and pyrimidine nucleotides at the putative Ago2 cleavage site was chemically modified to contain all possible combinations of 2'-fluorinated 2'-deoxypurines and/or 2'-deoxypyrimidines in the antisense and/or sense strands. The capacity of 2'-F-modified siRNAs to knock down their target mRNA and protein was studied, together with monitoring siRNA toxicity. All 2'-F-modified siRNAs resulted in target knockdown at nanomolar concentrations, despite their high thermal stability. These experiments provide the first evidence that RISC activation not only allows 2'-F modifications at the sense-strand cleavage site, but also increase the biological efficacy of modified siRNAs in vitro.     

Improvements in siRNA properties mediated by 2'-deoxy-2'-fluoro-beta-D-arabinonucleic acid (FANA)

RNA interference (RNAi) has emerged recently as an efficient mechanism for specific gene silencing. Short double-stranded small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) are now widely used for cellular or drug target validation; however, their use for silencing clinically relevant genes in a therapeutic setting remains problematic because of their unfavourable metabolic stability and pharmacokinetic properties. To address some of these concerns, we have investigated the properties of siRNA modified with 2'-deoxy-2'-fluoro-beta-d-arabinonucleotide units (araF-N or FANA units). Here we provide evidence that these modified siRNAs are compatible with the intracellular RNAi machinery and can mediate specific degradation of target mRNA. We also show that the incorporation of FANA units into siRNA duplexes increases activity and substantially enhances serum stability of the siRNA. A fully modified sense 2'-deoxy-2'-fluoro-beta-D-arabinonucleic acid (FANA) strand when hybridized to an antisense RNA (i.e. FANA/RNA hybrid) was shown to be 4-fold more potent and had longer half-life in serum (approximately 6 h) compared with an unmodified siRNA (<15 min). While incorporation of FANA units is well tolerated throughout the sense strand of the duplex, modifications can also be included at the 5' or 3' ends of the antisense strand, in striking contrast to other commonly used chemical modifications. Taken together, these results offer preliminary evidence of the therapeutic potential of FANA modified siRNAs.     

Immune activation by siRNA/liposome complexes in mice is sequence- independent: lack of a role for Toll-like receptor 3 signaling

Improvement in the pharmacokinetic properties of short interfering RNAs (siRNAs) is a prerequisite for the therapeutic application of RNA interference technology. When injected into mice as unmodified siRNAs complexed to DOTAP/Chol-based cationic liposomes, all 12 tested siRNA duplexes caused a strong induction of cytokines including interferon alpha, indicating that the immune activation by siRNA duplexes is independent of sequence context. When modified by various combinations of 2'-OMe, 2'-F, and phosphorothioate substitutions, introduction of as little as three 2'-OMe substitutions into the sense strand was sufficient to suppress immune activation by siRNA duplexes, whereas the same modifications were much less efficient at inhibiting the immune response of single stranded siRNAs. It is unlikely that Toll-like receptor 3 (TLR3) signaling is involved in immune stimulation by siRNA/liposome complexes since potent immune activation by ds siRNAs was induced in TLR3 knockout mice. Together, our results indicate that chemical modification of siRNA provides an effective means to avoid unwanted immune activation by therapeutic siRNAs. This improvement in the in vivo properties of siRNAs should greatly facilitate successful development of siRNA therapeutics.     

Improved serum stability and biophysical properties of siRNAs following chemical modifications

Small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) which mediate sequence-specific gene silencing through RNA interference have been harnessed for therapeutic applications. Here, we found combinations of modest 2′-ribose siRNA modifications that permit effective gene silencing and improve siRNA stability in human serum. Introduction of as few as two different or identical 2′-ribose modifications at a specific position of either strand, which has been previously suggested to suppress unintended off-target effects, enhances the thermal and thermodynamic stability of siRNA duplexes, and does not alter the overall A-form helical geometry that is required for silencing activity. Our results provide a useful template for the design for therapeutic siRNAs. Ik Sang Cho and Jung Kim contributed equally to this work.     

2'-O-methyl-modified anti-MDR1 fork-siRNA duplexes exhibiting high nuclease resistance and prolonged silencing activity

The thermodynamic asymmetry of siRNA duplexes determines their silencing activity. Favorable asymmetry can be achieved by incorporation of mismatches into the 3' part of the sense strand, providing fork-siRNAs, which exhibit higher silencing activity and higher sensitivity to nucleases. Recently, we found that selective 2'-O-methyl modifications of the nuclease-sensitive sites of siRNA significantly improve its nuclease resistance without substantial loss of silencing activity. Here, we examined the impact of nucleotide mismatches and the number and location of 2'-O-methyl modifications on the silencing activity and nuclease resistance of anti-MDR1 siRNAs. We found that both nonmodified and selectively modified fork-siRNAs with 4 mismatches at the 3' end of the sense strand suppress the expression of target gene at lower effective concentrations than the parent siRNAs with classical duplex design. The selective modification of nuclease-sensitive sites significantly improved the stability of fork-siRNAs in the presence of serum. The selectively modified fork-siRNA duplexes provided inhibitory effect over a period of 12 days posttransfection, whereas the gene silencing activity of the nonmodified analogs expired within 6 days. Thus, selective chemical modifications and structural alteration of siRNA duplexes improve their silencing properties and significantly prolong the duration of their silencing effect.     

Off-target effects by siRNA can induce toxic phenotype

Although recent microarray studies have provided evidence of RNA interference (RNAi)-mediated off-target gene modulation, little is known about whether these changes induce observable phenotypic outcomes. Here we show that a fraction of randomly selected small inhibitory RNAs (siRNAs) can induce changes in cell viability in a target-independent fashion. The observed toxicity requires an intact RNAi pathway and can be eliminated by the addition of chemical modifications that reduce off-target effects. Furthermore, an analysis of toxic and nontoxic duplexes identifies a strong correlation between the toxicity and the presence of a 4-base-pair motif (UGGC) in the RISC-entering strand of toxic siRNA. This article provides further evidence of siRNA-induced off-target effects generating a measurable phenotype and also provides an example of how such undesirable phenotypes can be mitigated by addition of chemical modifications to the siRNA.     

The siRNA sequence and guide strand overhangs are determinants of in vivo duration of silencing

The use of short interfering RNAs (siRNA) in animals for target validation or as potential therapeutics is hindered by the short physical half-life when delivered as unencapsulated material and in turn the short active half-life of siRNAs in vivo. Here we demonstrate that the character of the two 3′-overhang nucleotides of the guide strand of siRNAs is a determinant of the duration of silencing by siRNAs both in vivo and in tissue culture cells. We demonstrate that deoxyribonucleotides in the guide strand overhang of siRNAs have a negative impact on maintenance of both the in vitro and in vivo activity of siRNAs over time. Overhangs that contain ribonucleotides or 2′-O-methyl modified nucleotides do not demonstrate this same impairment. We also demonstrate that the sequence of an siRNA is a determinant of the duration of silencing of siRNAs directed against the same target even when those siRNAs have equivalent activities in vitro. Our experiments have determined that a measurable duration parameter exists, distinct from both maximum silencing ability and the potency of siRNAs. Our findings provide information on incorporating chemically modified nucleotides into siRNAs for potent, durable therapeutics and also inform on methods used to select siRNAs for therapeutic and research purposes.     

Competition for RISC binding predicts in vitro potency of siRNA

Short interfering RNAs (siRNA) guide degradation of target RNA by the RNA-induced silencing complex (RISC). The use of siRNA in animals is limited partially due to the short half-life of siRNAs in tissues. Chemically modified siRNAs are necessary that maintain mRNA degradation activity, but are more stable to nucleases. In this study, we utilized alternating 2′-O-methyl and 2′-deoxy-2′-fluoro (OMe/F) chemically modified siRNA targeting PTEN and Eg5. OMe/F-modified siRNA consistently reduced mRNA and protein levels with equal or greater potency and efficacy than unmodified siRNA. We showed that modified siRNAs use the RISC mechanism and lead to cleavage of target mRNA at the same position as unmodified siRNA. We further demonstrated that siRNAs can compete with each other, where highly potent siRNAs can compete with less potent siRNAs, thus limiting the ability of siRNAs with lower potency to mediate mRNA degradation. In contrast, a siRNA with low potency cannot compete with a highly efficient siRNA. We established a correlation between siRNA potency and ability to compete with other siRNAs. Thus, siRNAs that are more potent inhibitors for mRNA destruction have the potential to out-compete less potent siRNAs indicating that the amount of a cellular component, perhaps RISC, limits siRNA activity.     

Investigating the pharmacodynamic durability of GalNAc–siRNA conjugates

One hallmark of trivalent N-acetylgalactosamine (GalNAc)-conjugated siRNAs is the remarkable durability of silencing that can persist for months in preclinical species and humans. Here, we investigated the underlying biology supporting this extended duration of pharmacological activity. We found that siRNA accumulation and stability in acidic intracellular compartments is critical for long-term activity. We show that functional siRNA can be liberated from these compartments and loaded into newly generated Argonaute 2 protein complexes weeks after dosing, enabling continuous RNAi activity over time. Identical siRNAs delivered in lipid nanoparticles or as GalNAc conjugates were dose-adjusted to achieve similar knockdown, but only GalNAc–siRNAs supported an extended duration of activity, illustrating the importance of receptor-mediated siRNA trafficking in the process. Taken together, we provide several lines of evidence that acidic intracellular compartments serve as a long-term depot for GalNAc–siRNA conjugates and are the major contributor to the extended duration of activity observed in vivo.     

Genome-wide analysis of single non-templated nucleotides in plant endogenous siRNAs and miRNAs

Plant small RNAs are subject to various modifications. Previous reports revealed widespread 3′ modifications (truncations and non-templated tailing) of plant miRNAs when the 2′-O-methyltransferase HEN1 is absent. However, non-templated nucleotides in plant heterochromatic siRNAs have not been deeply studied, especially in wild-type plants. We systematically studied non-templated nucleotide patterns in plant small RNAs by analyzing small RNA sequencing libraries from Arabidopsis, tomato, Medicago, rice, maize and Physcomitrella. Elevated rates of non-templated nucleotides were observed at the 3′ ends of both miRNAs and endogenous siRNAs from wild-type specimens of all species. ‘Off-sized’ small RNAs, such as 25 and 23 nt siRNAs arising from loci dominated by 24 nt siRNAs, often had very high rates of 3′-non-templated nucleotides. The same pattern was observed in all species that we studied. Further analysis of 24 nt siRNA clusters in Arabidopsis revealed distinct patterns of 3′-non-templated nucleotides of 23 nt siRNAs arising from heterochromatic siRNA loci. This pattern of non-templated 3′ nucleotides on 23 nt siRNAs is not affected by loss of known small RNA 3′-end modifying enzymes, and may result from modifications added to longer heterochromatic siRNA precursors.     

A protocol for designing siRNAs with high functionality and specificity

Effective gene silencing by the RNA interference (RNAi) pathway requires a comprehensive understanding of the elements that influence small interfering RNA (siRNA) functionality and specificity. These include (i) sequence space restrictions that define the boundaries of siRNA targeting, (ii) structural and sequence features required for efficient siRNA performance, (iii) mechanisms that underlie nonspecific gene modulation and (iv) additional features specific to the intended use (i.e., inclusion of native sugar or base chemical modifications for increased stability or specificity, vector design, etc.). Attention to each of these factors enhances siRNA performance and heightens overall confidence in the output of RNAi-mediated functional genomic studies. Here, we provide a detailed protocol explaining the methodologies used for manual and web-based design of siRNAs.     

Analysis of acyclic nucleoside modifications in siRNAs finds sensitivity at position 1 that is restored by 5′-terminal phosphorylation both in vitro and in vivo

Small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) are short, double-stranded RNAs that use the endogenous RNAi pathway to mediate gene silencing. Phosphorylation facilitates loading of a siRNA into the Ago2 complex and subsequent cleavage of the target mRNA. In this study, 2′, 3′ seco nucleoside modifications, which contain an acylic ribose ring and are commonly called unlocked nucleic acids (UNAs), were evaluated at all positions along the guide strand of a siRNA targeting apolipoprotein B (ApoB). UNA modifications at positions 1, 2 and 3 were detrimental to siRNA activity. UNAs at positions 1 and 2 prevented phosphorylation by Clp1 kinase, abrogated binding to Ago2, and impaired Ago2-mediated cleavage of the mRNA target. The addition of a 5′-terminal phosphate to siRNA containing a position 1 UNA restored ApoB mRNA silencing, Ago2 binding, and Ago2 mediated cleavage activity. Position 1 UNA modified siRNA containing a 5′-terminal phosphate exhibited a partial restoration of siRNA silencing activity in vivo. These data reveal the complexity of interpreting the effects of chemical modification on siRNA activity, and exemplify the importance of using multiple biochemical, cell-based and in vivo assays to rationally design chemically modified siRNA destined for therapeutic use.     

siRNA function in RNAi: a chemical modification analysis

Various chemical modifications were created in short-interfering RNAs (siRNAs) to determine the biochemical properties required for RNA interference (RNAi). Remarkably, modifications at the 2'-position of pentose sugars in siRNAs showed the 2'-OHs were not required for RNAi, indicating that RNAi machinery does not require the 2'-OH for recognition of siRNAs and catalytic ribonuclease activity of RNA-induced silencing complexes (RISCs) does not involve the 2'-OH of guide antisense RNA. In addition, 2' modifications predicted to stabilize siRNA increased the persistence of RNAi as compared with wild-type siRNAs. RNAi was also induced with chemical modifications that stabilized interactions between A-U base pairs, demonstrating that these types of modifications may enhance mRNA targeting efficiency in allele-specific RNAi. Modifications altering the structure of the A-form major groove of antisense siRNA-mRNA duplexes abolished RNAi, suggesting that the major groove of these duplexes was required for recognition by activated RISC*. Comparative analysis of the stability and RNAi activities of chemically modified single-stranded antisense RNA and duplex siRNA suggested that some catalytic mechanism(s) other than siRNA stability were linked to RNAi efficiency. Modified or mismatched ribonucleotides incorporated at internal positions in the 5' or 3' half of the siRNA duplex, as defined by the antisense strand, indicated that the integrity of the 5' and not the 3' half of the siRNA structure was important for RNAi, highlighting the asymmetric nature of siRNA recognition for initiation of unwinding. Collectively, this study defines the mechanisms of RNAi in human cells and provides new rules for designing effective and stable siRNAs for RNAi-mediated gene-silencing applications.     

Small interfering RNAs containing full 2'-O-methylribonucleotide-modified sense strands display Argonaute2/eIF2C2-dependent activity

RNA interference (RNAi) is a process by which short interfering RNAs (siRNAs) direct the degradation of complementary single-strand RNAs. In this study, we investigated the effects of full-strand phosphorothioate (PS) backbone and 2'-O-methyl (2'-OMe) sugar modifications on RNAi-mediated silencing. In contrast to previous reports, we have identified active siRNA duplexes containing full 2'-OMe-modified sense strands that display comparable activity to the unmodified analog of similar sequence. The structure of these modified siRNAs is the predominant determinant of their activity, with sequence and backbone composition being secondary. We further show, by using biotin-tagged siRNAs and affinity-tagged hAgo2/eIF2C2, that activity of siRNA duplexes containing full 2'-OMe substitutions in the sense strand is mediated by the RNA-induced silencing complex (RISC) and that strand-specific loading (or binding) to hAgo2 may be modulated through selective incorporation of these modifications.     

Designing highly active siRNAs for therapeutic applications

The discovery of RNA interference (RNAi) generated considerable interest in developing short interfering RNAs (siRNAs) for understanding basic biology and as the active agents in a new variety of therapeutics. Early studies showed that selecting an active siRNA was not as straightforward as simply picking a sequence on the target mRNA and synthesizing the siRNA complementary to that sequence. As interest in applying RNAi has increased, the methods for identifying active siRNA sequences have evolved from focusing on the simplicity of synthesis and purification, to identifying preferred target sequences and secondary structures, to predicting the thermodynamic stability of the siRNA. As more specific details of the RNAi mechanism have been defined, these have been incorporated into more complex siRNA selection algorithms, increasing the reliability of selecting active siRNAs against a single target. Ultimately, design of the best siRNA therapeutics will require design of the siRNA itself, in addition to design of the vehicle and other components necessary for it to function in vivo. In this minireview, we summarize the evolution of siRNA selection techniques with a particular focus on one issue of current importance to the field, how best to identify those siRNA sequences likely to have high activity. Approaches to designing active siRNAs through chemical and structural modifications will also be highlighted. As the understanding of how to control the activity and specificity of siRNAs improves, the potential utility of siRNAs as human therapeutics will concomitantly grow.     

Chemical modification resolves the asymmetry of siRNA strand degradation in human blood serum

Small interfering (si)RNAs have recently been used to therapeutically silence genes in vivo after intravenous systemic delivery. Further progress in the development of siRNA therapeutics will in part rely on tailoring site-specific chemical modifications of siRNAs to optimize their pharmacokinetic properties. Advances are particularly needed to improve the nucleolytic stability of these double-stranded RNA drugs in vivo and suppress adverse off-target gene silencing effects. Here we demonstrate that specific chemical 2'-O-methylation, which has already been shown to ameliorate the omnipresent off-target toxicity of siRNAs, selectively protects the particularly vulnerable 5'-end of the guide strand against exonucleolytic degradation in human blood serum. Specific chemical modification thus resolves the asymmetric degradation of the guide and passenger strands, which is inherent to the thermodynamic asymmetry of the siRNA termini as required for proper utilization of the guide strand in RNA interference.     

Solid-phase synthesis of modified RNAs containing amide-linked oligoribonucleosides at their 3'-end and their application to siRNA

siRNAs against luciferase mRNA were modified with amide-linked oligoribonucleosides (amide-linked RNA) at their 3 '-overhangs. Tm values of the modified siRNAs increased compared with that of the unmodified siRNA. These results indicate that the modified overhangs increase the thermodynamic stability of the siRNAs. The modified overhangs improved stability of siRNAs against degradation by nuclease S1 and 50% mouse plasma. Furthermore the modified siRNAs reduced the target gene expression in a similar manner to the unmodified siRNA in cultured cells. These results suggest that the overhang modifications are tolerated for the siRNA activity.