A comparison between the acetylene reduction method,the isotope dilution method and the total nitrogen difference method for measuring nitrogen fixation in lucerne (Medicago sativa L.)

Summary In view of the increasing need for the exact estimation of the input of nitrogen in agroecosystems, an application of the acetylene-reduction technique was developed. The technique, consisting of a plastic bag incubation system, using propane as an internal standard of the apparent volume, made it possible to carry out repeated incubations on the same plant system. The evaluated technique included studies of the diffusion of ethylene and propane in a soil column, as well as studies of the optimal substrate concentration and grade of purity of the substrate. In addition, the conversion factor between amounts of reduced acetylene as compared wtih reduced dinitrogen was determined by¹⁵N₂ incubations to be 4.41. The developedin situ acetylene-reduction technique was compared with an isotope dilution method and a total nitrogen difference method. By comparing the derived total nitrogen fixation values from each with the value derived from the acetylene-reduction method; it was shown that the values differed significantly. The acetylene-reduction method gave the highest nitrogen fixation values, the isotope dilution the lowest values and the total nitrogen difference method was intermediate. No statistical significant difference existed between the two different reference crops used in the isotope dilution method.     

Field evaluation of symbiotic nitrogen fixation by rhizobial strains using15N methodology

Summary Small differences in N₂ fixation by nodulated soybeans (Glycine max. (L.) Merr.), inoculated with various strains ofRhizobium japonicum, were assessed in field experiments using¹⁵N methodology, and compared with yields of plant dry matter and total N. Percentage of plant-N derived from atmospheric N₂ and from fertilizer, and values of %¹⁵N atom excess had lower coefficients of variation than did total N and dry matter yield. Nevertheless the precision of estimates of kg N/ha fixed were sufficient to differentiate only the extremes of the range of strains tested, and there were discrepancies between ranking of strains based on % N derived from fertilizer and on total N yield.     

A non-destructive field assay for soybean nitrogen fixation by acetylene reduction

Summary A system for employing open-ended root chambers to measurein situ acetylene reduction rates under field conditions is described. Gas mixtures containing about 2 mbar acetylene were continuously flowed through the chambers providing a continuous record of acetylene reduction. These chambers have been used to measure acetylene reduction rates of soybeans during three growing seasons. The system has proved to be reliable with a high degree of precision. The large amount of plant-to-plant variability observed in N₂ fixation research has been confirmed by the data collected with this system. However, such variability in physiological studies can be reduced by using a non-destructive system to compare the response of an individual plant with its rates before treatment.     

Heterotrophic nitrogen fixation (acetylene reduction) associated to flooded rice: A modified measurement technique in the field

A modifiedin situ technique for measuring heterotrophic nitrogen fixing (acetylene reducing) activity associated to rice is proposed. Ethylene evolution rates measured in opaque cylinders covering the stems of rice plants which have been cut 10 cm over the water level were found independent of the diurnal cycle. Cutting of the leaves resulted in decreased variation between plants and suppression of the acceleration of ethylene evolution rate after 12 h incubation as compared to intact plants. In both systems ethylene evolved was swept by a current of methane and the molar ratio between methane and ethylene was stabilized after 12 h. Methane evolution rates remained stable during 12 h and more than 24 h in whole plants and cut plants respectively. It is suggested that alteration in the active gas transport system after 12 h incubation under 10% acetylene may lead to erroneous evaluation of the actual ethylene production in the root's environment. The average values of ethylene evolution rates by cut plants between 12 and 24 h of incubation may be used for comparative studies of nitrogen fixing activity associated to flooded rice.     

The response of field grownPhaseolus vulgaris to Rhizobium inoculation and the quantification of N2 fixation using15N

Summary A field experiment was performed to assess the effects of Rhizobium inoculation and nitrogen fertilizer (100 kg N ha^–1) on four cultivars of Phaseolus beans; Carioca, Negro Argel, Venezuela 350 and Rio Tibagi. In the inoculated treatment 2.5 kg N ha^–1 of¹⁵N labelled fertilizer was added in order to apply the isotope dilution technique to quantify the contribution of N₂ fixation to the nutrition of these cultivars.Nodulation of all cultivars in the uninoculated treatments was poor, but the cultivars Carioca and Negro Argel were well nodulated when inoculated. Even when inoculated, nodulation of the cultivars Venezuela 350 and Rio Tibagi was poor and these cultivars showed little response to inoculation in terms of nitrogen accumulation or grain yield. The estimates of the contribution of N₂ fixation estimated using the isotope dilution technique, for the Carioca and Negro Argel cultivars, amounted to 31.7 and 18.4 kg N ha^–1 respectively. These two cultivars produced 991 and 883 kg ha^–1 of grain, respectively, when inoculated and 663 and 620 kg ha^–1 with the addition of 100 kg N ha^–1 of N fertilizer. The response to nitrogen was particularly poor due to high leaching losses in the very sandy soil at the experimental site.The Venezuela 350 and Rio Tibagi cultivars only responded to N fertilizer and not to inoculation with Rhizobium which stresses the great importance of selecting plant cultivars for nitrogen fixation in the field.     

Estimation of biological nitrogen fixation associated withBrachiaria andPaspalum grasses using15N labelled organic matter and fertilizer

Summary Six pasture grasses,Paspalum notatum cv batatais,P. notatum cv pensacola,Brachiaria radicans, B. ruziziensis, B. decumbens andB. humidicola, were grown in concrete cylinders (60 cm diameter) in the field for 31 months. The soil was amended with either a single addition of¹⁵N labelled organic matter or frequent small (2 kg N. ha^–1) additions of¹⁵N enriched (NH₄)₂SO₄. In the labelled fertilizer treatment soil analysis revealed that there was a very drastic change in¹⁵N enrichment in plant-available nitrogen (NO ₃ ^– +NH ₄ ⁺ ) with depth. The different grass cultivars recovered different quantities of applied labelled N, and evidence was obtained to suggest that the roots exploited the soil to different depths thus obtaining different¹⁵N enrichments in soil derived N. This invalidated the application of the isotope dilution technique to estimate the contribution of nitrogen fixation to the grass cultivars in this treatment. In the labelled organic matter treatment the¹⁵N label in the plant-available N declined at a decreasing rate during the experiment until in the last 12 months the decrease was only from 0.274 to 0.222 atom % excess. There was little change in¹⁵N enrichment of available N with depth, hence it was concluded that although the grasses recovered different quantities of labelled N, they all obtained virtually the same¹⁵N enrichment in soil derived N. Data from the final harvests of this treatment indicated thatB. humidicola andB. decumbens obtained 30 and 40% respectively of their nitrogen from N₂ fixation amounting to an input of 30 and 45 kg N.ha^–1 year^–1 respectively.     

Effect of plant genotype and nitrogen fertilizer on symbiotic nitrogen fixation by soybean cultivars

Summary Isotopic as well as non-isotopic methods were used to assess symbiotic nitrogen fixation within eight soybean [Glycine max (L.) Merr.] cultivars grown at 20 and 100 kg N/ha levels of nitrogen fertilizer under field conditions.The¹⁵N methodology revealed large differences between soybean cultivars in their abilities to support nitrogen fixation. In almost all cases, the application of 100 kg N/ha resulted in lower N₂ fixed in soybean than at 20 kg N/ha in the first year of the study. However, N₂ fixed in one cultivar, Dunadja, was not significantly affected by the higher rate of N fertilizer application. These results were confirmed by measurements of acetylene reduction activity, nodule dry weight and N₂ fixed as measured by the difference method. Further proof of differences in N₂ fixed within soybean cultivars and the ability of Dunadja to fix similar amounts of N₂ at 20 and 100 kg N/ha was obtained during a second year experiment. Dunadja yield was affected by N fertilizer and produced larger yield at 100 kg N/ha than at 20 kg N/ha. This type of cultivar could be particularly useful in situations where soil N levels are high or where there is need to apply high amounts of N fertilizer.The present study reveals the great variability between legume germplasms in the ability to fix N₂ at different inorganic N levels, and also the potential that exists in breeding for nitrogen fixation associative traits. The¹⁵N methodology offers a unique tool to evaluate germplasms directly in the field for their N₂ fixation abilities at different N fertilizer levels.     

Effect of nitrogen fertilization and cropping system of the reference crop on estimation of N2 fixation by vetch using15N methodology

This study was conducted to examine the effects of varying N rates and cropping systems (mixedversus pure stand) on the suitability of oats (Avena sativa L.) for estimating N₂ fixed in sequentially harvested vetch (Vicia sativa L.) over two growing seasons (1984–85 and 1985–86). The N rates were, 20 and 100 kg N ha^–1 in 1984–85 and 15 and 60 kg N ha^–1 in 1985–86. In the 1984–85 season, vetch at maturity derived 76 and 63% N from fixation at the high and low N rates respectively. The corresponding values for the second season were 66 and 42%. Except in the 1985–86 season when some significantly higher values of % N₂ fixed were estimated by using the reference crop grown at the higher (A-value approach) than at the lower N rate (isotope-dilution approach), both approaches resulted in similar measurements of N₂ fixed. In the 1984–85 season, similar values of N₂ fixed were obtained using either the pure or mixed stand oats reference crops. Although in the 1985–86 season, the mixed reference crop occasionally estimated lower % N₂ fixed than pure oats, total N₂ fixed estimates were always similar (P<0.05). Thus, in general, N fertilization and cropping system of the reference crop did not significantly influence estimates of N₂ fixation.     

Absence of nitrogen fixation (acetylene reduction) by procaryotes in nectar of Banksias

Summary An earlier hypothesis that blue-green algae in the nectar ofBanksia telmatiaea contribute to the nitrogen economy of the host by fixing N₂ was tested. Field and laboratory experiments failed to demonstrate C₂H₄ production in C₂H₂-treated containers over extended periods. Soil N was not higher at the end of the flowering season and plants in which flower heads were removed prior to nectar production did not contain less N than the controls.     

Estimation of symbiotic N2 fixation in an Amazon floodplain forest

Sustainable management for existing Amazonian forests requires an extensive knowledge about the limits of ecosystem nutrient cycles. Therefore, symbiotic nitrogen (N₂) fixation of legumes was investigated in a periodically flooded forest of the central Amazon floodplain (Várzea) over two hydrological cycles (20 months) using the ¹⁵N natural abundance method. No seasonal variation in ¹⁵N abundance (δ ¹⁵N values) in trees which would suggest differences in N₂ fixation rates between the terrestrial and the aquatic phase was found. Estimations of the percentage of N derived from atmosphere (%Ndfa) for the nodulated legumes with Neptunia oleracea on the one side and Teramnus volubilis on the other resulted in mean %Ndfa values between 9 and 66%, respectively. More than half of the nodulated legume species had %Ndfa values above 45%. These relatively high N gains are important for the nodulated legumes during the whole hydrological cycle. With a %Ndfa of 4–5% for the entire Várzea forest, N₂ fixation is important for the ecosystem and therefore, has to be taken into consideration for new sustainable land-use strategies in this area.     

A field evaluation using the 15N isotope dilution method of lines of Phaseolus vulgaris L. bred for increased nitrogen fixation

N₂ fixation in lines of Phaseolus vulgaris was measured by ¹⁵N-isotope dilution to determine whether a programme of crossing and recurrent selection had resulted in enhanced nitrogen fixation. In field experiments on an isohyperthermic Aquic Hapludoll soil the amount of N₂ fixed by the different lines ranged from 18 to 36 kg ha^–1 (32 to 47% of plant N) in 56 days. The quantity of N₂ fixed and the proportion of plant N derived from fixation was not significantly greater in the lines selected for N₂ fixation (RIZ lines) than parental lines. Total shoot N ranged from 53 to 77 kg ha^–1 and partitioning of N to pods differed from 28 to 52% among the lines which all had similar growth habit and duration. Nodulation patterns were also distinct. Nodules formed early (10 to 15 plant^–1 at 13 days) in many lines, and smallest amounts of fixation were observed in those lines which nodulated slowly and did not form substantial nodule mass until after 40 days. The screening criteria used in the selection of the RIZ lines had been largely indirect with other factors such as disease resistance also being included. Progress for increasing N₂ fixation over good-fixing parental lines such as BAT76 was not significant and it is recommended that more attention be paid to early nodulation, to the use of soils with lower available N and to inter-crossing of lines having different good N₂ fixation traits in order to further enhance the potential for N₂ fixation in beans.     

15N2 incorporation and acetylene reduction by Azospirillum isolated from rice roots and soils

Summary Nitrogen fixation by strains of Azospirillum isolated from several rice soils and rice cultivars was investigated by¹⁵N₂ incorporation and C₂H₂ reduction. C₂H₂ reducing ability markedly varied among the strains obtained from soils differing widely in their physico-chemical properties. Large variations in¹⁵N₂ incorporation by Azospirillum isolated from the roots of several rice cultivars were also noticed. The present study reveals that rice cultivars harbour Azospirillum with differential N₂-fixing ability and that plant genotype is of importance for optimal associations.     

Methods for enhancing symbiotic nitrogen fixation

Biological nitrogen fixation of leguminous crops is becoming increasingly important in attempts to develop sustainable agricultural production. However, these crops are quite variable in their effectiveness in fixing nitrogen. By the use of the ¹⁵N isotope dilution method some species have been found to fix large proportions of their nitrogen, while others like common bean have been considered rather inefficient. Methods for increasing N₂ fixation are therefore of great importance in any legume work. Attempts to enhance nitrogen fixation of grain legumes has been mainly the domain of microbiologists who have selected rhizobial strains with superior effectiveness or competitive ability. Few projects have focused on the plant symbiont with the objective of improving N₂ fixation as done in the FAO/IAEA Co-ordinated Research Programme which is being reported in this volume. The objective of the present paper is to discuss some possibilities available for scientists interested in enhancing symbiotic nitrogen fixation in grain legumes. Examples will be presented on work performed using agronomic methods, as well as work on the plant and microbial symbionts. There are several methods available to scientists working on enhancement of N₂ fixation. No one approach is better than the others; rather work on the legume/Rhizobium symbiosis combining experience from various disciplines in inter-disciplinary research programmes should be pursued.     

Developing a breeding strategy to exploit quantitative variation in symbiotic nitrogen fixation

Summary This paper examines evidence which quantifies the relative importance of legume and Rhizobium genotypes as determinants of phenotypic variation in symbiotic nitrogen fixation. It demonstrates potentially large and unpredictable effects of the Rhizobium genotype. The likely importance of such effects on crop yield is considered. The information is then used to assess ways in which legume breeding programmes may be altered to encompass the effects of genetic variation in Rhizobium.     

Acetylene reduction,H2 evolution and 15N2 fixation in the Alnus incana-Frankia symbiosis

Acetylene reduction, ¹⁵N₂ reduction and H₂ evolution were measured in root systems of intact plants of grey alder (Alnus incana (L.) Moench) in symbiosis with Frankia. The ratios of C₂H₂: ¹⁵N₂ were compared with C₂H₂:N₂ ratios calculated from C₂H₂ reduction and H₂ evolution, and with C₂H₂:N₂ ratios calculated from accumulated C₂H₄ production and nitrogen content. It was possible to calculate C₂H₂:N₂ ratios from C₂H₂ reduction and H₂ evolution because this source of Frankia did not show any hydrogenase activity. The ratios obtained using the different methods ranged from 2.72 to 4.42, but these values were not significantly different. It was also shown that enriched ¹⁵N could be detected in the shoot after a 1-h incubation of the root-system. It is concluded that the measurement of H₂ evolution in combination with C₂H₂ reduction represents a nondestructive assay for nitrogen fixation in a Frankia symbiosis which shows no detectable hydrogenase activity.     

Forests losing large quantities of nitrogen have elevated 15N:14N ratios

Summary Urea (U) and ammonium nitrate (AN) had been applied to a Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris L.) forest in northern Sweden for 18 consecutive years at four doses resulting in total N applications ranging from 0 to 1980 kg ha^–1. The ¹⁵N abundance ( ¹⁵N) of the grass Deschampsia flexuosa (L.) Trin. increased linearly (from –0.7 to 11.0) with application rate in the case of U. The response to AN was in the same direction but smaller. While others have shown that the initial response of nitrogen-limited systems to additions of N is a change of ¹⁵N abundance towards that of added N, this study shows that further and excessive additions leads to a retention of ¹⁵N. Monitoring ¹⁵N abundance over time in dose-response trials of this type thus opens new possibilities to estimate critical loads of N and the point of nitrogen saturation.     

15N2 measurement of nitrogen fixation by legumes and actinorhizals: theory and practice

A gas-tight chamber has been constructed to calibrate the ¹⁵N isotope dilution method against direct ¹⁵N₂ measurements. The theoretical basis for such estimates is given, and the practical problems associated with the experiments are discussed.     

Measurements of genetic variability for symbiotic dinitrogen fixation in fieldgrwon fababean (Vicia faba L.) using a low level15N-tracer technique

Before starting a breeding program aimed at improving the nitrogen nutrition ofVicia faba, the authors tried an alternative technique to the acetylene reduction assay, to measure some genetic variability in the plant material. The quantity of dinitrogen fixed by several cultivars ofVicia faba was estimated using a low enrichment¹⁵N tracer method and high precision¹⁵N mass spectrometry. The fababeans were cultivated for two years in two different soils. The percentage of fixed dinitrogen in the seed varied between genotypes from 40 to 83% of the total nitrogen and was positively correlated with the total seed nitrogen (r=0.64 to 0.86). A highly significant positive correlation was also found between the total seed nitrogen and the quantity of fixed dinitrogen in the seed (r=0.95 to 0.99). The technique used to measure dinitrogen fixation proved to be useful and reliable enough to discriminate between various genotypes, grown over a period of two years in two different soils. However, several non-fixing control plants showed significant differences in their¹⁵N enrichment and the problem of choosing a good reference plant was raised and discussed.     

The contribution of associative and symbiotic nitrogen fixation to the nitrogen nutrition of non-legumes

During the past 10 years estimates of N₂ fixation associated with sugar cane, forage grasses, cereals and actinorhizal plants grown in soil with and without addition of inoculum have been obtained using the ¹⁵N isotope dilution technique. These experiments are reviewed in this paper with the aim of determining the proportional and absolute contribution of N₂ fixation to the N nutrition of non-legumes, and its role as a source of N in agriculture. The review also identifies deficiencies in both the totality of data which are currently available and the experimental approaches used to quantify N₂ fixation associated with non-legumes.Field data indicate that associative N₂ fixation can potentially contribute agronomically-significant amounts of N (>30–40 kg N ha^-1 y^-1) to the N nutrition of plants of importance in tropical agriculture, including sugar cane (Saccharum sp.) and forage grasses (Panicum maximum, Brachiaria sp. and Leptochloa fusca) when grown in uninoculated, N-deficient soils. Marked variations in proportions of plant N derived from the atmosphere have been measured between species or cultivars within species.Limited pot-culture data indicate that rice can benefit naturally from associative N₂ fixation, and that inoculation responses due to N₂ fixation can occur. Wheat can also respond to inoculation but responses do not appear to be due to associative N₂ fixation. ¹⁵N dilution studies confirm that substantial amounts of N₂ can be fixed by actinorhizal plants.