Discriminating antigen and non-antigen using proteome dissimilarity: bacterial antigens

It has been postulated that immunogenicity results from the overall dissimilarity of pathogenic proteins versus the host proteome. We have sought to use this concept to discriminate between antigens and non-antigens of bacterial origin. Sets of 100 known antigenic and nonantigenic peptide sequences from bacteria were compared to human and mouse proteomes. Both antigenic and non-antigenic sequences lacked human or mouse homologues. Observed distributions were compared using the non-parametric Mann-Whitney test. The statistical null hypothesis was accepted, indicating that antigen and non-antigens did not differ significantly. Likewise, we were unable to determine a threshold able to separate meaningfully antigen from non-antigen. Thus, antigens cannot be predicted from pathogen genomes based solely on their dissimilarity to the human genome.     

Discriminating antigen and non-antigen using proteome dissimilarity III: tumour and parasite antigens

Computational genome analysis enables systematic identification of potential immunogenic proteins within a pathogen. Immunogenicity is a system property that arises through the interaction of host and pathogen as mediated through the medium of a immunogenic protein. The overt dissimilarity of pathogenic proteins when compared to the host proteome is conjectured by some to be the determining principal of immunogenicity. Previously, we explored this idea in the context of Bacterial, Viral, and Fungal antigen. In this paper, we broaden and extend our analysis to include complex antigens of eukaryotic origin, arising from tumours and from parasite pathogens. For both types of antigen, known antigenic and non-antigenic protein sequences were compared to human and mouse proteomes. In contrast to our previous results, both visual inspection and statistical evaluation indicate a much wider range of homologues and a significant level of discrimination; but, as before, we could not determine a viable threshold capable of properly separating non-antigen from antigen. In concert with our previous work, we conclude that global proteome dissimilarity is not a useful metric for immunogenicity for presently available antigens arising from Bacteria, viruses, fungi, parasites, and tumours. While we see some signal for certain antigen types, using dissimilarity is not a useful approach to identifying antigenic molecules within pathogen genomes.     

Three cDNA clones encoding mouse transplantation antigens: Homology to immunoglobulin genes

We constructed cDNA libraries from poly(A)⁺ RNA isolated from cell lines of two different inbred strains of mice, and screened the libraries with a cDNA clone encoding a human transplantation antigen. Three cDNA clones were identified, sequenced and found to encode amino acid sequences highly homologous to portions of a known mouse transplantation antigen. Comparison of the cDNA sequences of mouse transplantation antigens with the constant region domains of the mouse immunoglobulin μ gene reveals a striking homology, which suggests that the two genes share a common ancestor. Antibody genes undergo DNA rearrangements during B cell differentiation that are correlated with their expression. In contrast, DNA blots with these cDNA probes suggest that the genes for the transplantation antigens are not rearranged in the genomes of liver or embryo cells, which express these antigens, as compared with sperm cells, which do not express these antigens. In Bam HI-digested liver DNAs from different inbred strains of mice, 10–15 bands of hybridization were found. Accordingly, the genes encoding the transplantation antigens appear to constitute a multigene family with similar gene numbers in different mice.     

Superinfection rescue of an integrated defective polyomavirus genome.

We have characterized the viral sequences integrated in a polyomavirus-transformed mouse cell line, Py-3T3 (clone Py-6), and followed their excision and packaging upon superinfection. The polyomavirus sequences contained in Py-6 cells are present as a single insert of nonidentical tandem copies which includes, in addition to a normal middle T-antigen-coding region, some very rearranged sequences. Infection of Py-6 cells with polyomavirus strains encoding a normal large T antigen leads to the reproducible recovery in the resulting viral stock of specific defective viral genomes. The defective genomes contain a wild-type coding region for middle and small T antigens and intact viral origin and enhancer sequences. The remainder of the viral genome is rearranged or lost, so that there is no capacity to code for large T antigen or viral capsid proteins. The recovered defective sequences are also found integrated in Py-6 genomic DNA. Presumably, in infections of Py-6 cells, large T antigen, provided by the superinfecting virus, amplifies and excises the integrated viral sequences. The superinfecting helper virus must also produce viral capsids for packaging of the defective viral DNA and thus provides a means to shuttle the defective sequences from the mouse cells into other hosts, such as rat cells. In the latter host, the defective sequences are able to induce transformation.     

Human and murine cytotoxic T cells specific to respiratory syncytial virus recognize the viral nucleoprotein (N), but not the major glycoprotein (G), expressed by vaccinia virus recombinants

The viral antigens recognized by cytotoxic T cells (CTL) have not been defined in most viruses infecting mouse or man. Natural or artificial virus recombinants can be used to determine the antigen specificity of CTL directed against viruses with segmented genomes, such as influenza, but this technique is more difficult to apply to the study of unsegmented viruses. We describe here the use of recombinant vaccinia viruses, containing cDNA corresponding to either the nucleoprotein (N) gene or the major surface glycoprotein (G) gene of human respiratory syncytial virus (RSV), to examine the antigen specificity of anti-RSV cytotoxic T cells from humans and mice. The results demonstrate that the RSV N protein is one of the target antigens for CTL in man and mouse, whereas the G protein was not recognized and can at best represent a minor target antigen for CTL.     

Serological relationship of woodchuck hepatitis virus to human hepatitis B virus.

Two antigenic systems of the woodchuck hepatitis virus have been identified. The relationship between viral antigens of the woodchuck hepatitis virus and the human hepatitis B virus was determined by using immunoprecipitation, hemagglutination, and immune electron microscopy techniques. Antigens found on the cores of the two viruses were cross-reactive. Lack of cross-reactivity between the surface antigens of the two viruses in immunodiffusion experiments suggested that the major antigenic determinants of the viral surfaces are different; however, results of passive hemagglutination tests indicated that there are common minor determinants. Nucleic acid homology, as measured by liquid hybridization, was found to be 3 to 5% of the viral genomes. The results of this study provide further evidence that woodchuck hepatitis virus is the second member of a new class of viruses represented by human hepatitis B virus. Since virus-infected woodchucks may acquire chronic hepatitis and hepatocellular carcinoma, these antigens and their respective antibodies will be useful markers for following the course of virus infection in investigations of the oncogenic potential of this class of viruses. The nucleocapsid antigen described may be a class-specific antigen of these viruses and, thus, may be useful in discovering new members of the group.     

Paracoccidioides brasiliensis antigen batches from the same isolate show immunological and biochemical differences

We investigated the occurrence of antigenic and biochemical variability among Paracoccidioides brasiliensis antigen batches prepared according to the same protocol. Initially (experiment #1), we analyzed two antigen lots of two human isolates (Bt1 & Bt2), cultured in two media (PYG: bactopeptone, yeast extract, glucose; MMM: McVeigh & Morton medium) in SDS-PAGE and in two immunological tests (imunodiffusion-ID and footpad swelling test-FPT). Afterwards (experiment #2), we compared the antigenic profile of three antigen batches from three human isolates (Bt1, Bt2 & Bt3) by two-dimensional immunoelectrophoresis (2 D-IEP) against a reference system for P. brasiliensis antigens. In experiment #1, there were important intra- and inter-strain antigenic differences between batches of the fungal isolates cultured on both media. The block titration of the antigen batches for the immunological tests revealed correlation between protein concentration and biological activity in ID and no correlation in FPT. In experiment #2, the reference system for P. brasiliensis showed 26 antigen peaks. There were important differences between batches prepared from the same isolate and between batches from different isolates. Our data suggested the occurrence of instability in the synthesis of antigenic components by a same P. brasiliensis isolate, under controlled incubation conditions.     

Human and mouse introns are linked to the same processes and functions through each genome's most frequent non-conserved motifs

We identified the most frequent, variable-length DNA sequence motifs in the human and mouse genomes and sub-selected those with multiple recurrences in the intergenic and intronic regions and at least one additional exonic instance in the corresponding genome. We discovered that these motifs have virtually no overlap with intronic sequences that are conserved between human and mouse, and thus are genome-specific. Moreover, we found that these motifs span a substantial fraction of previously uncharacterized human and mouse intronic space. Surprisingly, we found that these genome-specific motifs are over-represented in the introns of genes belonging to the same biological processes and molecular functions in both the human and mouse genomes even though the underlying sequences are not conserved between the two genomes. In fact, the processes and functions that are linked to these genome-specific sequence-motifs are distinct from the processes and functions which are associated with intronic regions that are conserved between human and mouse. The findings show that intronic regions from different genomes are linked to the same processes and functions in the absence of underlying sequence conservation. We highlight the ramifications of this observation with a concrete example that involves the microsatellite instability gene MLH1.     

Rat sequences of the Kirsten and Harvey murine sarcoma virus genomes: nature, origin, and expression in rat tumor RNA.

Two murine sarcoma viruses, the Kirsten and the Harvey, were isolated by passage of mouse type C leukemia viruses through rats. These sarcoma viruses have genomes containing portions of their parental type C mouse leukemia virus genomes, in stable association with specific rat cellular sequences that we find to be quite likely not those of a rat type C leukemia virus. To determine if these murine sarcoma viruses provide a model relevant to the events occurring in spontaneous tumors, we have hybridized DNA and RNA prepared from rat tumors and normal rat tissues to [3H]DNA prepared from the Kirsten murine sarcoma virus. We have also hybridized these rat tissue nucleic acids to [3H]DNA prepared from a respresentative endogenous rat type C leukemia virus, the WFU (Wistar-Furth). Sarcoma-viral rat cellular sequences and endogenous rat leukemia viral sequences were detected in the DNA of both tumor and normal tissues, with no evidence of either gene amplification or additional sequences being present in tumor DNA. Sarcoma-viral rat cellular sequences and endogenous rat leukemia viral sequences were detected at elevated concentrations in the RNA of many rat tumors and in specific groups of normal tissues.     

Murine embryonic antigen (SSEA-1) is expressed on human cells and structurally related human blood group antigen I is expressed on mouse embryos

The stage-specific embryonic antigen (SSEA-1), present on embryonal carcinoma cells and on murine preimplantation embryos, is defined by a monoclonal antibody. The antigenic determinant of SSEA-1 is a carbohydrate structurally related to the human blood group antigen I. Since it has been suggested that the I antigen might represent a precursor or SSEA-1, we used antibodies to SSEA-1 and to I to analyze their expression on mouse preimplantation embryos. Both are expressed on mouse embryos; moreover, I is expressed on earlier embryos than SSEA-1. The I antigen is defined by its expression on human erythrocytes; accordingly, we examined expression of I and SSEA-1 on human peripheral blood elements. We find SSEA-1 to be expressed exclusively on human granulocytes while I is found only on erythrocytes. These results suggest that these closely related antigens can be independently expressed. Analysis of the expression of I and SSEA-1 was then extended to a series of mouse and human cell lines; some express both, some express only one, and some express neither of these antigens. The activation of specific glycosyltransferases and/or glycosidases during development and differentiation appears to be the biochemical mechanism regulating expression of these antigens.     

Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 genomic RNA sequences in the female genital tract and blood: compartmentalization and intrapatient recombination

Investigation of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) in the genital tract of women is crucial to the development of vaccines and therapies. Previous analyses of HIV-1 in various anatomic sites have documented compartmentalization, with viral sequences from each location that were distinct yet phylogenetically related. Full-length RNA genomes derived from different compartments in the same individual, however, have not yet been studied. Furthermore, although there is evidence that intrapatient recombination may occur frequently, recombinants comprising viruses from different sites within one individual have rarely been documented. We compared full-length HIV-1 RNA sequences in the plasma and female genital tract, focusing on a woman with high HIV-1 RNA loads in each compartment who had been infected heterosexually and then transmitted HIV-1 by the same route. We cloned and sequenced 10 full-length HIV-1 RNA genomes from her genital tract and 10 from her plasma. We also compared viral genomes from the genital tract and plasma of four additional heterosexually infected women, sequencing 164 env and gag clones obtained from the two sites. Four of five women, including the one whose complete viral sequences were determined, displayed compartmentalized HIV-1 genomes. Analyses of full-length, compartmentalized sequences made it possible to document complex intrapatient HIV-1 recombinants that were composed of alternating viral sequences characteristic of each site. These findings demonstrate that the genital tract and blood harbor genetically distinct populations of replicating HIV-1 and provide evidence that recombination between strains from the two compartments contributes to rapid evolution of viral sequence variation in infected individuals.     

Biological properties and viral surface antigens of Burkitt lymphoma- and mononucleosis- derived strains of Epstein-Barr virus released from transformed marmoset cells.

Three strains of Epstein-Barr virus (EBV), two from Burkitt lymphoma (BL) and one from infectious mononucleosis (IM) were used to transform separate cultures of the same batch of primary marmoset leukocytes, and the viruses released from the transformants were compared. The three viruses shared properties of the transforming biotype of EBV, namely, stimulation of DNA synthesis and immortalization of cord blood leukocytes, and failure to induce "early antigen" in lymphoblast lines. All viruses produced more virus in transformed marmoset cells than in transformed human cells, as measured by the number of EBV genomes detected by complementary RNA/DNA hybridization, by virus capsid antigen expression, or by released virions and biologically active virus. Reference human sera and sera from primary EBV infections were used to compare the three virus strains in a virus neutralization test based on inhibition of stimulation of DNA synthesis. Specimens taken late in convalescence from patients with mononucleosis and sera from marmosets experimentally infected with virus from a patient with mononucleosis neutralized the homologous virus, as well as the two virus strains isolated from patients with BL. This finding indicates that viral antigens that elicit neutralizing antibodies are shared among the strains. However, in certain sera the neutralizing-antibody titer against one strain was consistently higher than against another strain. Furthermore, sera taken early after onset of IM contained low levels of neutralizing antibody against IM-derived virus, but failed to neutralize BL-derived virus. These latter findings suggest the existence of heterogeneity among surface antigens of EBVs. The results emphasize the biological and antigenic similarity of EBV isolates from BL and IM and do not suggest major subtype variations. It remains to be determined whether antigenic diversity such as described or virus genome variation detectable by other means is epidemiologically significant.     

Relationship Among Tau Antigens Isolated from Various Lines of Simian Virus 40-Transformed Cells

In addition to the virus-specified tumor antigens, simian virus 40-transformed cells contain at least one other protein which can be immunoprecipitated with serum from animals bearing simian virus 40-induced tumors. This protein, which is designated Tau antigen, has an apparent molecular weight of 56,000 as determined by electrophoresis on acrylamide gels. The relationship among Tau antigens isolated from different lines of simian virus 40-transformed cells was examined by comparing the methionine-labeled tryptic peptides of these proteins by two-dimensional fingerprinting on thin-layer cellulose plates. In this fashion, we initially determined that the Tau antigens isolated from three different lines of transformed mouse cells were very similar. Second, we found that Tau antigen isolated from a line of rat transformants was closely related, but not identical, to the mouse cell Tau antigens. Approximately 70% of their methionine peptides comigrated in two dimensions. Finally, we showed that Tau antigen isolated from a line of transformed human cells was only partially related to the mouse and rat proteins. About 40% of the methionine peptides of the human protein were also contained in the Tau antigens from the other two species. These results strongly indicate that the Tau antigens isolated from these various simian virus 40-transformed cell lines contain common amino acid sequences.     

Characterization of flat revertant cells isolated from simian virus 40-transformed mouse and rat cells which contain multiple copies of viral genomes.

Eight clones of flat revertants were isolated by negative selection from simian virus 40 (SV40)-transformed mouse and rat cell lines in which two and six viral genome equivalents per cell were integrated, respectively. These revertants showed either a normal cell phenotype or a phenotype intermediate between normal and transformed cells as to cellular morphology and saturation density and were unable to grow in soft agar medium. One revertant derived from SV40-transformed mouse cells was T antigen positive, whereas the other seven revertants were T antigen negative. SV40 could be rescued only from the T-antigen-positive revertant by fusion with permissive monkey cells. The susceptibility of the revertants to retransformation by wild-type SV40 was variable among these revertants. T-antigen-negative revertants from SV40-transformed mouse cells were retransformed at a frequency of 3 to 10 times higher than their grandparental untransformed cells. In contrast, T-antigen-negative revertants from SV40-transformed rat cells could not be retransformed. The arrangement of viral genomes was analyzed by digestion of cellular DNA with restriction enzymes of different specificity, followed by detection of DNA fragments containing a viral sequence and rat cells were serially arranged within the length of about 30 kilobases, with at least two intervening cellular sequences. A head-to-tail tandem array of unit length viral genomes was present in at least one insertion site in the transformed rat cells. All of the revertants had undergone a deletion(s), and only a part of the viral genome was retained in T-antigen-negative revertants. A relatively high frequency of reversion in the transformed rat cells suggests that reversion occurs by homologous recombination between the integrated viral genomes.     

Characterization of K virus and its comparison with polyoma virus.

The antigenic relationship between the two murine papovaviruses, K virus and polyoma virus, was examined by serological techniques to determine whether they shared any antigenic components. No cross-reactivity was found associated with the viral (V) antigens by the indirect immunofluorescence, neutralization, or hemagglutination-inhibition tests. The tumor (T) antigens expressed in transformed cells or cells productively infected by either K or polyoma virus did not cross-react by indirect immunofluorescence. An antigenic relationship was detected, however, among the late proteins of K virus, polyoma virus, simian virus 40, and the human papovavirus BKV, when tested with either hyperimmune sera prepared against polyoma virus and simian virus 40 or sera prepared against disrupted virions. The nucleic acids of K and polyoma viruses were compared by agarose gel electrophoresis and restriction endonuclease analysis. No nucleotide sequence homology between the genomes of these two viruses was detectable by DNA-DNA hybridization techniques under stringent conditions. The genome of K virus was found to be slightly smaller than that of polyoma virus, and the cleavage patterns of the viral DNAs with six restriction endonucleases were different. These findings indicate that there is little relationship between these two murine papovaviruses.     

Polymorphism of murine major histocompatibility Class I antigen: assignment of putative allodeterminants to distinct positions of the amino acid sequence within the first external domain of the antigen

Forty-five new monoclonal antibodies reacting with the mouse H-2Dd antigen have been established. The specificities of 34 of these antibodies were mapped into the first external domain (N) of the Dd antigen by testing reactivities with the products of mosaic H-2 genes in which the coding sequences of the first and/or the second external domains of the H-2Dd genes were recombined in vitro with the remaining portion of the H-2Ld gene. These antibodies reacted with at least 13 distinct allodeterminants located in the N domain, composed of 91 amino acids, as judged from panel tests carried out on various H-2 haplotypes. To assign possible positions of antigenic determinants of these and other anti-H-2Dd antibodies, we compared primary sequences of seven H-2 antigens and searched for correspondence between the pattern of amino acid substitutions in the N domain, allowing 15 positions to be assigned for the antigenic sites. These putative antigenic determinants were assessed for possible relationships with several parameters of protein secondary structure postulated according to predictive methods. Many of these sites appear to be associated with greatest local hydrophilicity, known to correlate with sites of antibody binding in various proteins. We therefore propose that some of the correspondences found in this work represent structural correlates of allodeterminants.     

Persistence of the Recombinant Genomes of Woodchuck Hepatitis Virus in the Mouse Model

Hydrodynamic injection (HI) with a replication competent hepatitis B virus (HBV) genome may lead to transient or prolonged HBV replication in mice. However, the prolonged HBV persistence after HI depends on the specific backbone of the vector carrying HBV genome and the genetic background of the mouse strain. We asked whether a genetically closely related hepadnavirus, woodchuck hepatitis virus (WHV), may maintain the gene expression and replication in the mouse liver after HI. Interestingly, we found that HI of pBS-WHV1.3 containing a 1.3 fold overlength WHV genome in BALB/c mouse led to the long presence of WHV DNA and WHV proteins expression in the mouse liver. Thus, we asked whether WHV genome carrying foreign DNA sequences could maintain the long term gene expression and persistence. For this purpose, the coding region of HBV surface antigen (HBsAg) was inserted into the WHV genome to replace the corresponding region. Three recombinant WHV-HBV genomes were constructed with the replacement with HBsAg a-determinant, major HBsAg, and middle HBsAg. Serum HBsAg, viral DNA, hepatic WHV protein expression, and viral replication intermediates were detected in mice after HI with recombinant genomes. Similarly, the recombinant genomes could persist for a prolonged period of time up to 45 weeks in mice. WHV and recombinant WHV-HBV genomes did not trigger effective antibody and T-cell responses to viral proteins. The ability of recombinant WHV constructs to persist in mice is an interesting aspect for the future investigation and may be explored for in vivo gene transfer.     

Rescue of silent integrated polyoma genomes suggests homologous recombination between resident and transfected DNA fragments

Two defective polyoma virus genomes, deleted in the nucleotide sequences coding the N-termini of the tumor antigens, were introduced into Fisher 3T3 rat cells by DNA-mediated gene transfer (transfection). The resulting integrated genomes were incapable of conferring a transformed phenotype to the cells. However, after transfection of these lines with small polyoma fragments overlapping the deleted sequences, transformed clones were isolated. These clones were analyzed by Southern genomic blot hybridization and by isolation in E. coli of plasmids containing viral sequences excised following fusion with mouse polyoma growth-permissive cells. In all cases at least one intact copy of the early region of the polyoma genome was found. Furthermore, restriction sites adjacent to the initial inactive insertion remained unchanged in many of the transformed lines. These results show that functional restoration of the defective polyoma early region involves homologous recombination between the deleted viral genomes integrated in the cellular DNA and the transfecting viral fragments.