Evaluation of π-acid chiral stationary phases deriving from tyrosine and related amino acids for the chromatographic resolution of racemates: Specific requirements for enantiorecognition ability

Chromatographic applications of three novel chiral stationary phases (CSPs) deriving from (S)-(N)-(3,5-dinitrobenzoyl)tyrosine are reported, under liquid chromatographic (LC) and subscritical fluid chromatographic (SubFC) conditions. Two grafting modes of the chiral moiety have been experimented starting either from γ-mercaptopropyl-silanized (type 1) or γ-aminopropyl-silanized (type 2) silica gels. For type 2 CSPs an evaluation of the stability of the amide linkage was achieved by means of SubFC; the relative contriution of ionic and covalent bindings to the ciral recognitio aility was then outlined. The chromatographic properties of these CSPs were compared with those of the corresponding CSPs deriving from phenylglycine, p-hydroxyphenylglycine, and phenylalanine for the resolution of some tertiary phosphine oxide, naphthoyl amide, and α-methylene γ-lactam enantiomers. Some simple requirements regarding the solute and CSP structures for chiral recognition ability can be inferred from these results. In addition, the resolutio of π-acid α-N-(3,5-dinitrobenzoyl)amino esters was investigated on these π-acid CSPs. An example of preparative scale chromatography is also presented.     

Comparison of the chiral separation of amino-acid derivatives by a teicoplanin and RN-beta-CD CSPs using waterless mobile phases: Factors that enhance resolution

A variety of compounds containing amines (i.e., amino acids, amino alcohols, etc.) were chemically derivatized with a variety of electrophilic tagging reagents to elucidate the chiral recognition sites on a teicoplanin-bonded chiral stationary phase (CSP) and on R-naphthylethylcarbamate-beta-cyclodextrin (RN-beta-CD)-bonded CSP. Solutes were separated under optimum chromatographic conditions on teicoplanin and RN-beta-CD CSPs for comparison using an acetonitrile-based mobile phase. It was noted that the size of the analyte or tagging reagent exerted a greater influence on compounds separated on teicoplanin than on RN-beta-CD when using the polar organic mode. This suggests that chiral recognition on teicoplanin CSP is more sensitive to size and indicates that the hydrophobic pocket of teicoplanin plays a significant role in chiral recognition in this mode. However, the type of functional groups had a greater impact than the size of analyte on separations obtained from RN-beta-CD phase in the polar-organic mode. Specifically, the pi-pi interaction was enhanced by derivatizing the aromatic ring of the tagging reagent with electron-withdrawing groups and thus altered the resolution substantially. For both phases, chiral recognition is most pronounced when the stereogenic center of the analyte is near the tagging moiety and surrounded by functional groups (e.g., carboxylic, etc.) which are favorable for hydrogen bonding.     

Novel chiral stationary phases based on 3,5-dimethyl phenylcarbamoylated β-cyclodextrin combining cinchona alkaloid moiety

Novel chiral selectors based on 3,5-dimethyl phenylcarbamoylated β-cyclodextrin connecting quinine (QN) or quinidine (QD) moiety were synthesized and immobilized on silica gel. Their chromatographic performances were investigated by comparing to the 3,5-dimethyl phenylcarbamoylated β-cyclodextrin (β-CD) chiral stationary phase (CSP) and 9-O-(tert-butylcarbamoyl)-QN-based CSP (QN-AX). Fmoc-protected amino acids, chiral drug cloprostenol (which has been successfully employed in veterinary medicine), and neutral chiral analytes were evaluated on CSPs, and the results showed that the novel CSPs characterized as both enantioseparation capabilities of CD-based CSP and QN/QD-based CSPs have broader application range than β-CD-based CSP or QN/QD-based CSPs. It was found that QN/QD moieties play a dominant role in the overall enantioseparation process of Fmoc-amino acids accompanied by the synergistic effect of β-CD moiety, which lead to the different enantioseparation of β-CD-QN-based CSP and β-CD-QD-based CSP. Furthermore, new CSPs retain extraordinary enantioseparation of cyclodextrin-based CSP for some neutral analytes on normal phase and even exhibit better enantioseparation than the corresponding β-CD-based CSP for certain samples.     

Direct enantiomeric separation of beta-blockers on ChyRoSine-A by supercritical fluid chromatography: supercritical carbon dioxide as transient in situ derivatizing agent.

The direct enantiomeric separation of a series of beta-blockers has been carried out on two chiral stationary phases (CSPs) derived from 3,5-dinitrobenzoyl tyrosine: the commercially available ChyRoSine-A and a recent improved version of this CSP. Using supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC), facile separations are achieved (1.1 less than Rs less than 7) within short analysis times. The parameters affecting the enantioselectivity (temperature, pressure, mobile phase nature, solute structure) have been investigated. The optimal mobile phase consists in a mixture of carbon dioxide-methanol-propylamine at 25 degrees C. The solute structure has a great influence on the enantioselectivity. For instance, both amine and hydroxyl protons are necessary for chiral discrimination to occur. Furthermore, the steroselectivity value is directly connected to the amine substituent steric bulkiness. Surprisingly, these solutes are poorly resolved using normal phase liquid chromatography (NPLC). Accordingly, the specific influence of carbon dioxide on the enantiomeric separation of 1,2-amino-alcohols have been investigated using various techniques such as nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) or molecular modelisation. It has been shown that carbon dioxide acts as a complexing agent toward the amino-alcohol by setting up of a bridge with the hydroxyl and the amine protons of the solute. In that way, the resulting complex possesses lower acido-basic properties and a higher conformational rigidity, responsible for chiral discrimination.     

The comparison in enantioseparation ability of the chiral stationary phases with single and mixed selector--the selectors derived from two D-tartrates

(2S,3S)-2,3-Bis(3,5-dimethylphenylcarbonyloxy)-3-(benzyloxycarbonyl)-propanoic acid and (2S,3S)-2,3-bis(1-naphthalenecarbonyloxy)-3-(benzyloxycarbonyl)-propanoic acid were synthesized from D-tartaric acid. These two compounds were chlorinated to afford two chiral selectors for chiral stationary phases (CSPs). The selectors were separately immobilized on aminated silica gel to give two single selector CSPs; and were simultaneously immobilized to obtain a mixed selector CSP. Comparing to the single selector CSPs, the mixed selector CSP bears the enhanced enantioseparation ability, suggesting that the two selectors in the mixed selector CSP are consistent for chiral recognition in most mobile phase conditions.     

HPLC enantioseparation on cellulose tris(3,5-dimethylphenylcarbamate) as a chiral stationary phase: Influences of pore size of silica gel,coating amount,coating solvent,and column temperature on chiral discrimination

Cellulose tris(3,5-dimethylphenylcarbamate) (CDMPC) was coated on large-pore silica gels and used as a chiral stationary phase (CSP) for high-performance liquid chromatographic separation of enantiomers. The influences of pore size of silica gel, coating amount of CDMPC, coating solvent, and column temperature on chiral discrimination were investigated. CSPs prepared with a large-pore silica gel having a small surface area showed higher chiral recognition. The amount of CDMPC adsorbed on the silica gel influenced the chiral recognition of some racemates. Loading capacity of racemates increased with an increase of the amount of CDMPC supported on the silica gel, and a CSP coated with 45% CDMPC by weight can be used for both analytical and semi-preparative scale separations. The CDMPC, coated using acetone as the coating solvent, exhibited, in many cases, higher enantioselectivity than that obtained with tetrahydrofuran F as the coating solvent. © 1996 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Liquid chromatographic resolution of 3-amino-1,4-benzodiazepin-2-ones on crown ether-based chiral stationary phases

3-Amino-5-phenyl (or 5-methyl)-1,4-benzodiazepin-2-ones, which are chiral precursors of anti-respiratory syncytial virus active agents, were resolved on three different chiral stationary phases (CSPs) based on (+)-(18-crown-6)-2,3,11,12-tetracarboxylic acid or (3,3'-diphenyl-1,1'-binaphthyl)-20-crown-6. Among the three CSPs, the CSP that is based on (3,3'-diphenyl-1,1'-binaphthyl)-20-crown-6 and containing residual silanol group-protecting n-octyl groups on the silica surface was found to be most effective with the use of 80% ethanol in water containing perchloric acid (10 mM) and ammonium acetate (1.0 mM) as a mobile phase. The separation factors (α) and resolutions (R(S) ) were in the range of 1.90-3.21 and 2.79-5.96, respectively. From the relationship between the analyte structure and the chromatographic resolution behavior, the chiral recognition mechanism on the CSP based on (+)-(18-crown-6)-2,3,11,12-tetracarboxylic acid was proposed to be different from that on the CSP based on (3,3'-diphenyl-1,1'-binaphthyl)-20-crown-6. In addition, the chromatographic resolution behavior of the most effective CSP was investigated as a function of the composition of aqueous mobile phase containing organic and acidic modifier and ammonium acetate.     

Enantioresolution of Chiral Derivatives of Xanthones on (S,S)‐Whelk‐O1 and l‐Phenylglycine Stationary Phases and Chiral Recognition Mechanism by Docking Approach for (S,S)‐Whelk‐O1

The resolution of seven enantiomeric pairs of chiral derivatives of xanthones (CDXs) on (S,S)‐Whelk‐O1 and l ‐phenylglycine chiral stationary phases (CSPs) was systematically investigated using multimodal elution conditions (normal‐phase, polar‐organic, and reversed‐phase). The (S,S)‐Whelk‐O1 CSP, under polar‐organic conditions, demonstrated a very good power of resolution for the CDXs possessing an aromatic moiety linked to the stereogenic center with separation factor and resolution factor ranging from 1.91 to 7.55 and from 6.71 to 24.16, respectively. The chiral recognition mechanisms were also investigated for (S,S)‐Whelk‐O1 CSP by molecular docking technique. Data regarding the CSP–CDX molecular conformations and interactions were retrieved. These results were in accordance with the experimental chromatographic parameters regarding enantioselectivity and enantiomer elution order. The results of the present study fulfilled the initial objectives of enantioselective studies of CDXs and elucidation of intermolecular CSP–CDX interactions. Chirality 25:89–100, 2013. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Synthesis and evaluation of two novel “mixed” chiral stationary phases deriving from tyrosine: Csps designed for the resolution of either π-acid or π-basic racemates

The synthesis and chromatographic evaluation of two novel chiral stationary phases (CSPs) deriving from (S)-tyrosine are reported. The chiral graft has been designed in order to bear both π-acid and π-basic sites, each one being connected to a distinct asymmetric centre. An intramolecular π-π interaction may take place within these CSPs, leading to an energetically favoured conformation of the chiral selector (CS). The enantiorecognition ability of these CSPs was investigated for various classes of either π-acid or π-basic racemates. It is shown that these CSPs are able to separate simultaneously π-acid and π-basic racemates. Finally, chiral recognition mechanisms and mobile phase optimization are discussed.     

Relationship between resolution and analysis time in chiral subcritical fluid chromatography

A model is presented that predicts a defined relationship between chiral SubFC resolution and analysis time. This model is based upon ideal chromatographic behavior and requires column efficiency and selectivity to be independent of mobile phase modifier level and flow rate. The validity of these assumptions was found to be imperfect but acceptable for two model compounds on two commonly used chiral columns. A major implication of the model is that the maximum resolution obtainable with a particular column and mobile phase modifier may be predicted from one injection. The retention time required to obtain a desired resolution is also calculable. This information enables the practitioner to discern quickly the futility of method development efforts. Insufficient maximum resolution predicted from the first injection would require an increase in selectivity to achieve a useful separation. Selectivity may then be altered by temperature, modifier, or stationary phase. The increased column efficiency of SubFC at typical flow rates rescues separations that fail by HPLC, thus shrinking the practitioner's required library of chiral columns. This work demonstrates that SubFC also allows the practitioner to skim through that library very quickly. © 1996 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Direct high-performance liquid chromatographic enantioseparation of beta-lactam stereoisomers

High-performance liquid chromatographic methods were developed for the separation of the enantiomers of 12 beta-lactams. Direct separations were performed on chiral stationary phases (CSPs) containing cellulose-tris-3,5-dimethylphenyl carbamate (Chiralcel OD-RH and OD-H columns), the macrocyclic glycopeptide antibiotic teicoplanin (Chirobiotic T column), or teicoplanin aglycone (Chirobiotic TAG column) as the chiral selector. It was clearly established that, with teicoplanin-based columns, the teicoplanin aglycone was most often responsible for the enantioseparation of the beta-lactams. The difference in enantioselective free energy between the aglycone CSP and the teicoplanin CSP was in the range between 0.02 and 0.97 kJ mol(-1) for these beta-lactam stereoisomer separations. The separations were carried out with high selectivity and resolution, and the method was therefore suitable for monitoring of the enantiomeric excess after chiral synthesis. The Chirobiotic and Chiralcel columns appear to be highly complementary to one another. The best separation of this class of beta-lactam compound could be obtained using the Chirobiotic TAG in the polar-organic mode plus the Chiralcel OD-H in the normal-phase mode. The elution sequence was also determined.     

Use of a new pirkle-type chiral stationary phase in analytical and preparative subcritical fluid chromatography of pharmaceutical compounds

Good results have been obtained with use of the new bonded chiral stationary phase Whelk-O 1 in analytical and preparative subcritical fluid chromatography. A wide variety of enantiomeric pairs of compounds with different functional groups that are of pharmaceutical and biological interest have been resolved. This Pirkle-concept CSP appears to be more rugged than cellulosic phases (e.g., Chiralcel) with regards to solvents and pressure. In comparing the usefulness of the column for SFC versus HPLC chiral analysis, we have observed a clear superiority of SFC in terms of higher speed and efficiency of analysis, and faster method development. This is consistent with our experience with Chiralcel CSPs. With the Whelk-O 1 we have shown that the effects of temperature and modifier on SFC separations are similar to what has been reported for most other CSPs. We also observed a unique selectivity advantage of SFC for verapamil. We had good success with using a 1-in. diameter column packed with Whelk-O 1 to perform preparative SFC separations of a number of enantiomeric mixtures. The advantages of preparative SFC over preparative HPLC will be discussed. The feasibility of preparative SFC is dependent on how well we meet the practical challenges such as sample introduction issues, special hardware requirements due to the high pressure, and fraction collection issues. © 1994 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Chiral separation based on immobilized intact and fragmented cellobiohydrolase II (CBH II): A comparison with cellobiohydrolase I (CBH I)

Intact and fragmented cellobiohydrolase II (CBH II) were immobilized to silica and used as chiral stationary phases (CSPs) for liquid chromatographic separations of enantiomers. Both acidic and basic chiral compounds could be resolved into their enantiomers on these phases. The enantioselectivities obtained on intact CBH II and its core were almost equivalent. Comparisons were also made with CBH I silica. It was found that the new materials show quite different chiral and chromatographic properties. The enzymatic activity of the CBH II in free solution was influenced by alprenolol and mexiletine, both separated on the corresponding CSP. It indicates that the sites for catalysis and for chiral recognition overlap. © 1995 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Comparative HPLC Enantioseparation of Thirty‐Six Aromatic Compounds on Four Columns of the Lux® Series: Impact of Substituents,Shapes and Electronic Properties

With the aim to define a combined computational/chromatographic empirical approach useful for the high‐performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) method development of new chiral compounds, 36 racemic aromatic compounds with different chemical structures were used as test probes on four polysaccharide‐based chiral stationary phases (CSPs) of the Lux series, namely Lux Cellulose‐1, Lux Cellulose‐2, Lux Cellulose‐4, and Lux Amylose‐2, using classical n‐hexane/2‐propanol mixtures as mobile phase. Electrostatic potential surfaces (EPSs) determined using Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations were used to derive size, shape, and electronic properties of each analyte. Then a comparative HPLC screening was carried out in order to evaluate the impact of substituents, shapes, and electronic properties of the analytes on the chromatographic behavior as the column changes. The four CSPs showed good complementary recognition ability. The elution sequence was determined in 30 cases out of 36. The success rate to afford baseline separations (R_s ≥ 1.5) was estimated: 29 compounds out of 36 showed baseline enantioseparation on at least one of the four selected CSPs. The combined computational‐chromatographic screening furnished useful collective structure‐chromatographic behavior relationships and a map of the chiral discrimination abilities of the considered CSPs towards the analytes. On this basis, the chromatographic behavior of new analytes on a set of polysaccharide‐based CSPs can be mapped through the qualitative correlation of chromatographic parameters (k, α, R_s) to computed molecular properties of the analytes. Chirality 25:709–718, 2013. © 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Liquid Chromatographic Resolution of Mexiletine and Its Analogs on Crown Ether‐Based Chiral Stationary Phases

Mexiletine, an effective class IB antiarrhythmic agent, and its analogs were resolved on three different crown ether‐based chiral stationary phases (CSPs), one (CSP 1 ) of which is based on (+)‐(18‐crown‐6)‐2,3,11,12‐tetracarboxylic acid and the other two (CSP 2 and CSP 3 ) are based on (3,3’‐diphenyl‐1,1’‐binaphthyl)‐20‐crown‐6. Mexiletine was resolved with a resolution (R_S) of greater than 1.00 on CSP 1 and CSP 3 containing residual silanol group‐protecting n‐octyl groups on the silica surface, but with a resolution (R_S) of less than 1.00 on CSP 2 . The chromatographic behaviors for the resolution of mexiletine analogs containing a substituted phenyl group at the chiral center on the three CSPs were quite dependent on the phenoxy group of analytes. Namely, mexiletine analogs containing 2,6‐dimethylphenoxy, 3,4‐dimethylphenoxy, 3‐methylphenoxy, 4‐methylphenoxy, and a simple phenoxy group were resolved very well on the three CSPs even though the chiral recognition efficiencies vary with the CSPs. However, mexiletine analogs containing 2‐methylphenoxy group were not resolved at all or only slightly resolved. Among the three CSPs, CSP 3 was found to show the highest chiral recognition efficiencies for the resolution of mexiletine and its analogs, especially in terms of resolution (R_S). Chirality 26:272–278, 2014. © 2014 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Role of the weak interactions in enantiorecognition of racemic dihydropyrimidinones by novel brush-type chiral stationary phases

The chiral discrimination ability of two recently prepared chiral stationary phases (CSP 1 and CSP 2), based on a leucine derived chiral selector, was tested for the enantiomers of dihydropyrimidone (DHPM) derivatives and compared with the commercially available Hyun-leucine CSP 3 and classical Pirkle-leucine CSP 4. By combining all of these CSPs, the enantiomers of all DHPM derivatives used in this study can be properly resolved. Particularly good enantioresolutions were achieved for thioureide derivatives, such as Monastrol. The results presented show that sulfur-aromatic interactions are meritorious for these very good separations.     

Functionalities tuned enantioselectivity of phenylcarbamate cyclodextrin clicked chiral stationary phases in HPLC

The mixed chloro‐ and methyl‐ functionalities can greatly modulate the enantioselectivities of phenylcarbamate cyclodextrin (CD) clicked chiral stationary phases (CSPs). A comparison study is herein reported for per(4‐chloro‐3‐methyl)phenylcarbamate and per(2‐chloro‐5‐methyl)phenylcarbamate β‐CD clicked CSPs (i.e., CCC4M3‐CSP and CCC2M5‐CSP). The enantioselectivity dependence on column temperature was studied in both normal‐phase and reversed‐phase mode high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). The thermodynamic study revealed that the stronger intermolecular interactions can be formed between CCC4M3‐CSP and chiral solutes to drive the chiral separation. The higher enantioselectivities of CCC4M3‐CSP were further demonstrated with the enantioseparation of 17 model racemates in HPLC.     

Direct high-performance liquid chromatographic separation of the enantiomers of venlafaxine and 11 analogs using amylose-derived chiral stationary phases

A direct liquid chromatographic enantioselective separation of venlafaxine and 11 analogs was obtained in the normal phase mode using Chiralpak AD. For some compounds, a comparison between the enantioseparation using coated and immobilized amylose tris(3,5-dimethylphenylcarbamate) chiral stationary phases (Chiralpak AD and Chiralpak IA, respectively) was made. The best separations were achieved on Chiralpak AD with ethanol as alcoholic modifier in a mobile phase made basic by DEA addition: separation factor ranges between 2.08 and 1.15 and resolution factor between 7.0 and 1.0. Using the same CSP and 2-propanol doped with TFA as acidic modifier, 10 compounds were enantioseparated with separation factor ranging between 1.40 and 1.04 and resolution factor between 3.1 and 0.3. The use of ethanol as alcoholic modifier also has the advantage of better solubility of the compounds in the mobile phase. The nature of the substituent (electron donating or withdrawing) affects in general the separation factor. A memory effect that involves a long equilibration time of the CSP is present when switching from an acidic mobile phase to a basic one.     

Direct HPLC enantioseparation of chiral aptazepine derivatives on coated and immobilized polysaccharide-based chiral stationary phases

The direct HPLC enantioseparation of Mianserin and a series of aptazepine derivatives is accomplished on polysaccharide-based chiral stationary phases (CSPs). The resolutions are performed on the coated-type Chiralcel OD and Chiralpak AD CSPs and on the first commercially available immobilized-type Chiralpak IA CSP, in normal-phase and polar-organic modes. The complete separation of enantiomers of all racemates investigated was successfully achieved under at least one of CSP/eluent combinations employed. Pure alcohols such ethanol or 2-propanol, with a fixed percentage of DEA added, serve as valuable alternatives to the more common n-hexane-based normal-phase eluents in resolution of Mianserin on the AD CSP. In order to study the chiroptical properties of aptazepine derivatives, chromatographic resolutions are carried out at semipreparative scale using Chiralpak AD and Chiralpak IA as CSPs. Nonconventional dichloromethane-based eluents have permitted to expand the chiral resolving ability of the immobilized Chiralpak IA CSP and to perform mg-scale enantioseparations with an analytical-size column. Assignment of the absolute configuration of the separated enantiomers is empirically established by comparing their chiroptical data with those of structurally related Mianserin.     

Separation of the optical isomers of a new 1,4-dihydropyridine calcium channel blocker (LF 2.0254) by liquid and supercritical fluid chromatography

The four optical isomers of a new calcium channel blocker LF 2.0254 (developed by Laboratoires Fournier) are resolved by chromatography using chiral stationary phases. Two methods are proposed: the first one involving two chiral stationary phases [(S)-N-(2-naphthyl)alanine, a Pirkle type CSP and Chiralcel OJ, a cellulose derived CSP] in the liquid chromatographic mode, the second one involving a single CSP (Chiralcel OJ) in the supercritical fluid chromatographic mode. © 1994 Wiley-Liss, Inc.