Covalent cross-linking of the NC1 domain of collagen type IX to collagen type II in cartilage

From a study to understand the mechanism of covalent interaction between collagen types II and IX, we present experimental evidence for a previously unrecognized molecular site of cross-linking. The location relative to previously defined cross-linking sites predicts a specific manner of interaction and folding of collagen IX on the surface of nascent collagen II fibrils. The initial evidence came from Western blot analysis of type IX collagen extracted by pepsin from fetal human cartilage, which showed a molecular species that had properties indicating an adduct between the alpha1(II) chain and the C-terminal domain (COL1) of type IX collagen. A similar component was isolated from bovine cartilage in sufficient quantity to confirm this identity by N-terminal sequence analysis. Using an antibody that recognized the putative cross-linking sequence at the C terminus of the alpha1(IX) chain, cross-linked peptides were isolated by immunoaffinity chromatography from proteolytic digests of human cartilage collagen. They were characterized by immunochemistry, N-terminal sequence analysis, and mass spectrometry. The results establish a link between a lysine near the C terminus (in the NC1 domain) of alpha1(IX) and the known cross-linking lysine at residue 930 of the alpha1(II) triple helix. This cross-link is speculated to form early in the process of interaction between collagen IX molecules and collagen II polymers. A model of molecular folding and further cross-linking is predicted that can spatially accommodate the formation of all six known cross-linking interactions to the collagen IX molecule on a fibril surface. Of particular biological significance, this model can accommodate potential interfibrillar as well as intrafibrillar links between the collagen IX molecules themselves, so providing a mechanism whereby collagen IX could stabilize a collagen fibril network.     

Identification of cross-linking sites in bovine cartilage type IX collagen reveals an antiparallel type II-type IX molecular relationship and type IX to type IX bonding.

Type IX collagen functions in covalent cross-linkage to type II collagen in cartilage (Eyre, D. R., Apone, S., Wu, J. J., Ericsson, L. H., and Walsh, K. A. (1987) FEBS Lett. 220, 337-341). To understand this molecular relationship better, an analysis of all cross-linking sites labeled by [3H]borohydride was undertaken using the protein prepared from fetal bovine cartilage. Sequence analysis of tryptic peptides containing the 3H-labeled cross-links showed that each of the chains of type IX collagen, alpha 1(IX), alpha 2(IX), and alpha 3(IX), contained a site of cross-linking at the amino terminus of the COL2 triple-helix to which the alpha 1(II)N-telopeptide could bond. The alpha 3(IX)COL2 domain alone also had an attachment site for the alpha 1(II)C-telopeptide. The distance between the alpha 1(II)N-telopeptide and alpha 1(II)C-telopeptide interaction sites, 137 residues, is equal to the length of the hole zone (0.6D) in a type II collagen fibril. This implies an antiparallel type II to type IX cross-linking relationship. Peptide analysis also revealed an unknown amino acid sequence linked to the COL2 cross-linking domains in both the alpha 1(IX) and alpha 3(IX) chains. Using antibodies to this novel peptide, its origin in the collagen alpha 3(IX)NC1 domain was established. In summary, the results confirm extensive covalent cross-linking between type IX and type II collagen molecules and reveal the existence of type IX-type IX bonding. These data provide a molecular basis for the proposed function of type IX collagen as a critical contributor to the mechanical stability and resistance to swelling of the collagen type II fibril framework of cartilage.     

Sites of stromelysin cleavage in collagen types II, IX, X, and XI of cartilage

Human recombinant stromelysin-1 was shown to cleave four types of collagen (types II, IX, X, and XI) prepared from bovine and rat cartilages at specific sites. Stromelysin-1 cleaved salt-soluble native molecules of type IX collagen into two main triple-helical fragments, COL1 and COL2,3. Protein microsequencing identified the exact cleavage sites in the NC2 domain of all three chains, alpha 1(IX), alpha 2(IX), and alpha 3(IX). Stromelysin-1 also acted as a "telopeptidase," in that it efficiently clipped intact molecules of types II and XI collagens at sites just inside their terminal cross-linking hydroxylysine residues. Native molecules of type X collagen were cleaved by stromelysin-1 within their triple helical domains at a COOH-terminal site that reduced the alpha 1(X) chain size by 10 kDa. These findings suggest an important role for stromelysin in the turnover and remodeling of the collagenous matrix of cartilage both normally and in degenerative joint disease.     

Differences in Chain Usage and Cross-linking Specificities of Cartilage Type V/XI Collagen Isoforms with Age and Tissue

Collagen type V/XI is a minor but essential component of collagen fibrils in vertebrates. We here report on age- and tissue-related variations in isoform usage in cartilages. With maturation of articular cartilage, the α1(V) chain progressively replaced the α2(XI) chain. A mix of the molecular isoforms, α1(XI)α1(V)α3(XI) and α1(XI)α2(XI)α3(XI), best explained this finding. A prominence of α1(V) chains is therefore characteristic and a potential biomarker of mature mammalian articular cartilage. Analysis of cross-linked peptides showed that the α1(V) chains were primarily cross-linked to α1(XI) chains in the tissue and hence an integral component of the V/XI polymer. From nucleus pulposus of the intervertebral disc (in which the bulk collagen monomer is type II as in articular cartilage), type V/XI collagen consisted of a mix of five genetically distinct chains, α1(XI), α2(XI), α3(XI), α1(V), and α2(V). These presumably were derived from several different molecular isoforms, including α1(XI)α2(XI)α3(XI), (α1(XI))₂α2(V), and others. Meniscal fibrocartilage shows yet another V/XI phenotype. The findings support and extend the concept that the clade B subfamily of COL5 and COL11 gene products should be considered members of the same collagen subfamily, from which, in combination with clade A gene products (COL2A1 or COL5A2), a range of molecular isoforms has evolved into tissue-dependent usage. We propose an evolving role for collagen V/XI isoforms as an adaptable polymeric template of fibril macro-architecture.The collagen framework of hyaline cartilages is based on a covalently cross-linked heteropolymeric network of types II, IX, and XI collagens. During development, collagen type IX molecules are covalently linked to the surface of thin, new fibrils of type II collagen polymerized on a template of type XI collagen (1–5). In fetal cartilage, type XI collagen is a heterotrimer of three genetically distinct chains, α1(XI), α2(XI), and α3(XI) in a 1:1:1 ratio (6–9). The α3(XI) chain has the same primary sequence as α1(II), but the chains differ in their post-translational processing and cross-linking properties (7–9). All three collagen subunits, II, IX, and XI, are heavily cross-linked in the same fibril through a lysyl oxidase-mediated mechanism (2, 5, 9). The location of the cross-links determined by sequence analysis of peptides prepared from proteolytically degraded fibrils reveals a high degree of chain specificity (9). Collagen XI molecules are linked to each other in a head-to-tail fashion by N-telopeptide² to helix cross-links and laterally to type II collagen molecules through α1(II) C-telopeptides (9). Isolated from mature articular cartilage, type XI collagen includes a significant pool of α1(V) chains (6), implying the presence of V/XI hybrid molecules. The ratio of type XI collagen to type II collagen is about 1 to 10 in fetal bovine and human epiphyseal cartilage when compared with 1 to 30 in adult articular cartilage. Similarly, the ratio of collagen IX to collagen II falls from about 1 to 10 to 1 to 100 between fetal and adult. In adult articular cartilage, most of the collagen IX is located in the immediate pericellular matrix (10–12).The intervertebral disc has a unique collagen architecture that combines features of ligament and cartilage in its morphology, function, and matrix biochemistry. The lamellar fabric of the outer annulus fibrosus combines collagens I and II fibrils in a complex weave with a radial gradient from mostly type I in the outermost layers and mostly type II in the interior. Nucleus pulposus, the gel-like center of the young intervertebral disc, has a similar collagen molecular phenotype to hyaline cartilage in which types II, IX, and XI collagens are the principal cross-linked fibrillar components (13–16). Collagen IX in the disc has a different protein isoform to that of hyaline cartilages. The α1(IX) chain is expressed as a short form that lacks the amino-terminal NC4 domain (16). One of the aims of the present study was to determine whether a unique pattern of type V/XI hybrid molecules is present in disc tissue when compared with articular cartilage and a more typical fibrocartilage, the knee meniscus.The results show an accumulation of collagen α1(V) chains as articular cartilage matures. A related but distinct complexity in chain usage in the type V/XI collagen of nucleus pulposus is also revealed. Such tissue diversity suggests that the different molecular isoforms produce functional differences in the type V/XI polymeric template on which the bulk fibril architecture of a tissue is built.     

Construction and characterization of cDNA encoding the alpha 2 chain of chicken type IX collagen

We have isolated and characterized a cDNA encoding the carboxy-terminal half of one of the polypeptide subunits of a novel disulfide-bonded collagen found in hyaline cartilage. This collagen has been given the type assignment type IX, and it has several unusual characteristics. First, the polypeptide subunits are shorter than alpha-chains of the fibrillar collagens types I, II, and III. Second, type IX molecules are heterotrimers of three genetically distinct polypeptide subunits. Third, type IX molecules contain three triple-helical collagenous domains interspersed with noncollagenous domains. When chicken cartilage collagens are extracted with pepsin, type IX collagen is cleaved and gives rise to the triple-helical fragments HMW and LMW. The identification of the cDNA reported here is based on a comparison of the amino acid composition of tryptic peptides derived from LMW with the composition of tryptic peptides predicted from the nucleotide sequence of the cDNA. We also show that the amino-terminal sequence of one of the subunits of LMW is identical with the sequence predicted from the nucleotide sequence of the cDNA. Finally, we demonstrate that the amino-terminal amino acid sequence of a tryptic peptide isolated from one of the subunits of HMW is identical with a sequence predicted from the cDNA. We have given the polypeptide chain encoded by the cDNA reported here the name alpha 2(IX), and we show that it is homologous to the alpha 1(IX) chain previously characterized by us.     

Fragmentation of proteins in cartilage treated with interleukin-1: specific cleavage of type IX collagen by matrix metalloproteinase 13 releases the NC4 domain

Degradation of bovine nasal cartilage induced by interleukin-1 (IL-1) was used to study catabolic events in the tissue over 16 days. Culture medium was fractionated by two-dimensional electrophoresis (isoelectric focusing and SDS-PAGE). Identification of components by peptide mass fingerprinting revealed released fragments representing the NC4 domain of the type IX collagen alpha1 chain at days 12 and 16. A novel peptide antibody against a near N-terminal epitope of the NC4 domain confirmed the finding and indicated the presence of one of the fragments already at day 9. Mass spectrometric analysis of the two most abundant fragments revealed that the smallest one contained almost the entire NC4 domain cleaved between arginine 258 and isoleucine 259 in the sequence -ETCNELPAR258-COOH NH2-ITP-. A larger fragment contained the NC4 domain and the major part of the COL3 domain with a cleavage site between glycine 400 and threonine 401 in COL3 (-RGPPGPPGPPGPSG400-COOH NH2-TIG-). The presence of multiple collagen alpha1 (IX) N-terminal sequences demonstrates that the released molecules were cleaved at sites very close to the original N terminus either prior to or due to IL-1 treatment. Matrix metalloproteinase 13 (MMP-13) is active and cleaves fibromodulin in the time interval studied. Cartilage explants treated with MMP-13 were shown to release collagen alpha1 (IX) fragments with the same sizes and with the same cleavage sites as those obtained upon IL-1 treatment. These data describe cleavage by an MMP-13 activity toward non-collagenous and triple helix domains. These potentially important degradation events precede the major loss of type II collagen.     

Isolation and sequence analysis of the glycosaminoglycan attachment site of type IX collagen

Type IX collagen from chick embryonic cartilage is unique among the collagens in that it contains chondroitin sulfate covalently linked to the alpha 2(IX) polypeptide chain. We have isolated and sequenced the glycosaminoglycan-containing peptide released by collagenase digestion from type IX collagen, labeled biosynthetically with [35SO4] and 3H-aminoacids. This peptide was purified by gel filtration and, following chondroitinase ABC digestion, by reverse-phase high performance liquid chromatography. The amino acid sequence obtained for this peptide has 23 residues, beginning and ending with a collagenous sequence, indicating that it spans an internal noncollagenous domain. Comparison of this sequence with the one predicted from cDNA clone pYN 1738 for the alpha 1(IX)chain and pYN 1731 and pDM 222 for the alpha 2(IX)chain revealed the peptide to be the noncollagenous NC3 domain of alpha 2(IX). The glycosylated sequence Val-Glu-Gly-Ser*-Ala-Asp- of type IX collagen does not have the Ser-Gly normally functioning as the attachment sequence but does have an acidic residue preceding the serine which should improve the acceptability of this sequence for the xylosyltransferase. That it is an adequate acceptor can be inferred from the observation that type IX collagen carries a glycosaminoglycan chain on over 70% of the molecules isolated.     

Molecular cloning of rat and human type IX collagen cDNA and localization of the alpha 1(IX) gene on the human chromosome 6

Type IX collagen is found in hyaline cartilage, where it is associated with type II collagen in quarter-staggered collagen fibrils. Chicken type IX collagen has been extensively characterized and shown to contain molecules with three triple-helical domains, interspersed with non-triple-helical sequences. The molecule contains three, genetically distinct, subunits and one of these subunits carries a covalently bound glycosaminoglycan side chain. In the present report, we describe for the first time the primary structure of mammalian type IX collagen chains, based on cloning and sequencing of cDNA from rat and human cDNA libraries. The results suggest that mammalian alpha 1(IX) chains have the same multi-domain structure as the avian protein. We also demonstrate, by in situ hybridization of chromosome spreads, that the human alpha 1(IX) collagen gene is located on the long arm of chromosome 6. The cloning of human type IX collagen cDNA provides a probe for molecular studies of human chondrodysplasias that may involve abnormalities in this extracellular collagen-proteoglycan.     

Collagen type IX: Evidence for covalent linkages to type II collagen in cartilage

A major site of pyridinoline cross-linking in bovine type IX collagen was traced to a tryptic peptide derived from one of the molecule's HMW chains. This peptide gave two amino acid sequences (in 2/1 ratio) consistent with it being a three-chained structure. The major sequence matched exactly that of the C-telopeptide of type II collagen from the same tissue. A second HMW chain that contained pyridinoline cross-links also gave two amino-terminal sequences, one from its own amino terminus, the other matching exactly the N-telopeptide cross-linking sequence of type II collagen. We conclude that type IX collagen molecules are covalently cross-linked in cartilage to molecules of type II collagen, probably at fibril surfaces.     

Matrix deposition of tryptophan-containing allelic variants of type IX collagen in developing human cartilage.

Genetic polymorphisms that encode a tryptophan (Trp) residue in the triple-helical domain of the alpha2 (Trp2) or alpha3 chain (Trp3) of human type IX collagen have been linked to risk of degenerative intervertebral disc disease. To determine whether these two allelic variants express protein that may affect the extracellular matrix of cartilage in vivo, we examined the properties of resident type IX collagen in an anonymous collection of embryonic and fetal human cartilage samples screened for Trp genotypes. No difference was found in the yield and electrophoretic properties of pepsin-solubilized type IX collagen between Trp2, Trp3 and non-Trp cartilage samples. On Western blot analysis, a polyclonal antiserum raised against a synthetic peptide matching the immediate Trp-containing sequence of the Trp3 allele reacted specifically with the alpha3(IX) chain prepared from Trp3 cartilage samples. Two-dimensional peptide mapping of type IX collagen in CNBr-digests of whole tissue gave indistinguishable fingerprints for Trp2, Trp3 and control tissues, including the yield of cross-linked peptides. Analysis of one cartilage sample that was homozygous for the Trp2 allele also gave a normal yield of collagen IX, including its alpha2 chain and a normal profile of cross-linked peptides. Together, the findings indicate that both Trp2 and Trp3 allelic products are incorporated into the cross-linked fibrillar network of developing human cartilage apparently normally. Any pathological consequences are likely, therefore, to be long-term and indirect rather than from overt misassembly of matrix.     

D-periodic distribution of collagen type IX along cartilage fibrils

It has recently become apparent that collagen fibrils may be composed of more than one kind of macromolecule. To explore this possibility, we developed a procedure to purify fibril fragments from 17-d embryonic chicken sternal cartilage. The fibril population obtained shows, after negative staining, a uniformity in the banding pattern and diameter similar to the fibrils in situ. Pepsin digestion of this fibril preparation releases collagen types II, IX, and XI in the proportion of 8:1:1. Rotary shadowing of the fibrils reveals a d-periodic distribution of 35-40-nm long projections, each capped with a globular domain, which resemble in form and dimensions the aminoterminal globular and collagenous domains, NC4 and COL3, of type IX collagen. The monoclonal antibody (4D6) specific for an epitope close to the amino terminal of the COL3 domain of type IX collagen bound to these projections, thus confirming their identity. Type IX collagen is therefore distributed in a regular d-periodic arrangement along cartilage fibrils, with the chondroitin sulfate chain of type IX collagen in intimate contact with the fibril.     

Two-dimensional peptide mapping of cross-linked type IX collagen in human cartilage

Type IX collagen is a quantitatively minor component of hyaline cartilage that is essential for the normal structural integrity of the tissue. Purification and analysis are difficult because the mature protein is insoluble as a cross-linked integral component of the fibrillar matrix. In order to view a peptide map of the total pool of type IX collagen in a cartilage sample, a selective method based on Western blot analysis was developed for displaying collagen IX peptides in a cyanogen bromide digest of tissue. Digests were partially resolved by reverse-phase HPLC, individual fractions were run on SDS-PAGE and then transblotted to membrane, and the collagen IX fragments were revealed using an anti-collagen IX rabbit antiserum. All major CB-peptides from alpha1(IX), alpha2(IX), and alpha3(IX) chains in the resulting two-dimensional display were identified by amino-terminal sequence analysis. Cross-linked peptides originating from sites of covalent interaction between collagen types IX and II and between IX and IX were also defined. By comparison with an analysis of soluble type IX collagen from chondrocyte culture medium, the results showed that the pool of type IX collagen molecules in fetal and adult human cartilage is extensively cross-linked intermolecularly at sites previously revealed by other methods using purified protein. This sensitive, direct method has the potential to screen for abnormalities in the content and properties of type IX collagen in tissue samples, for example, in the study of heritable chondrodysplasia syndromes and the pathogenesis of cartilage destruction in osteoarthritis.     

Trimerization of collagen IX alpha-chains does not require the presence of the COL1 and NC1 domains

Collagen IX is a heterotrimer of three alpha-chains, which consists of three COL domains (collagenous domains) (COL1-COL3) and four NC domains (non-collagenous domains) (NC1-NC4), numbered from the C-terminus. Although collagen IX chains have been shown to associate via their C-terminal NC1 domains and form a triple helix starting from the COL1 domain, it is not known whether chain association can occur at other sites and whether other collagenous and non-collagenous regions are involved. To address this question, we prepared five constructs, two long variants (beginning at the NC4 domain) and three short variants (beginning at the COL2 domain), all ending at the NC2 domain (or NC2 replaced by NC1), to study association and selection of collagen IX alpha-chains. Both long variants were able to associate with NC1 or NC2 at the C-terminus and form various disulfide-bonded trimers, but the specificity of chain selection was diminished compared with full-length chains. Trimers of the long variant ending at NC2 were shown to be triple helical by CD. Short variants were not able to assemble into disulfide-bonded trimers even in the presence of both conserved cysteine residues from the COL1-NC1 junction. Our results demonstrate that collagen IX alpha-chains can associate in the absence of COL1 and NC1 domains to form a triple helix, but the COL2-NC2 region alone is not sufficient for trimerization. The results suggest that folding of collagen IX is a co-operative process involving multiple COL and NC domains and that the COL1-NC1 region is important for chain specificity.     

Isolation and primary structure of PARP, a 24-kDa proline- and arginine-rich protein from bovine cartilage closely related to the NH2-terminal domain in collagen alpha 1 (XI)

A protein rich in proline and arginine (proline/arginine-rich protein (PARP] has been isolated from dissociative extracts of bovine nasal and articular cartilage, and its primary structure has been determined. The protein has 218 amino acids, giving a calculated protein Mr of 24,075. In nasal cartilage, this protein is in molar concentrations equivalent to 1/20-1/10 that of the link protein of cartilage proteoglycan aggregates. PARP has also been isolated from bovine articular cartilage, bovine fetal epiphysis, and nonossified human tarsal bones. PARP is similar to various collagen NH2-terminal domains. It is 49% identical to the NH2-terminal end of collagen alpha 1 (XI), 17% identical to the NC4 domain of collagen alpha 1 (IX), and 14% identical to the NC3 domain of collagen alpha 1 (XII). Four cysteines are conserved between type XI collagen and PARP, and these form two disulfide bonds. Two of the cysteines are also conserved between PARP and collagens IX and XII. The homology between the collagens and PARP makes it possible to speculate on the likely disulfide bond pattern in the collagen NH2-terminal domains. It is probable that PARP is a collagen fragment removed during processing in a manner analogous to chondrocalcin (the C-terminal propeptide of type II collagen).     

Complete sequence of the 23-kilobase human COL9A3 gene. Detection of Gly-X-Y triplet deletions that represent neutral variants.

We report the complete sequence of the human COL9A3 gene that encodes the alpha3 chain of heterotrimeric type IX collagen, a member of the fibril-associated collagens with interrupted triple helices family of collagenous proteins. Nucleotide sequencing defined over 23,000 base pairs (bp) of the gene and about 3000 bp of the 5'-flanking sequences. The gene contains 32 exons. The domain and exon organization of the gene is almost identical to a related gene, the human COL9A2 gene. However, exon 2 of the COL9A3 gene codes for one -Gly-X-Y- triplet less than exon 2 of the COL9A2 gene. The difference is compensated by an insertion of 9 bp coding for an additional triplet in exon 4 of the COL9A3 gene. As a result, the number of -Gly-X-Y- repeats in the third collagenous domain remains the same in both genes and ensures the formation of an in-register triple helix. In the course of screening this gene for mutations, heterozygosity for separate 9-bp deletions within the COL1 domain were identified in two kindreds. In both instances, the deletions did not co-segregate with any disease phenotype, suggesting that they were neutral variants. In contrast, similar deletions in triple helical domain of type I collagen are lethal. To study whether alpha3(IX) chains with the deletion will participate in the formation of correctly folded heterotrimeric type IX collagen, we expressed mutant alpha3 chains together with normal alpha1 and alpha2 chains in insect cells. We show here that despite the deletion, mutant alpha3 chains were secreted as heterotrimeric, triple helical molecules consisting of three alpha chains in a 1:1:1 ratio. The results suggest that the next noncollagenous domain (NC2) is capable of correcting the alignment of the alpha chains, and this ensures the formation of an in-register triple helix.