Prenatal screening for hemoglobinopathies. II. Evaluation of counseling.

Learning during genetic counseling is often below expectations, especially in the context of genetic screening. In this report we describe learning as a result of genetic counseling of 298 pregnant women identified as hemoglobinopathy carriers, 234 with sickle cell trait and 64 with beta-thalassemia trait. Counseling was designed to provide the information needed in a simple, clear, and nondirective manner. A special videotape produced for this purpose provided dramatization and a role model illustrating an appropriate response. After viewing the videotape the counselee had an opportunity to question the counselor and to have any misconceptions corrected. Questionnaires revealed significantly increased knowledge as a result of counseling in each of the three hemoglobinopathy subject areas tested-namely, clinical manifestations, genetics, and prenatal diagnosis. Five factors correlated with higher knowledge scores after counseling-namely, a younger patient age, more years of education, knowledge of having trait before this identification, knowledge of the baby's father having trait before counseling, and having no prior children.     

Genetic screening and genetic counseling: Knowledge,attitudes, and practices in two groups of family planning professionals

Abstract

Genetic counseling has evolved from a eugenic orientation to an orientation concerned with the physical and mental well‐being of counselees. This change in genetic counseling, which has received formal recognition in a new definition of genetic counseling, requires collateral development of the processes and evaluation of the outcomes of counseling. This paper offers a theory of genetic counseling which interrelates genetic information, psychological responses, learning theory, and decision‐making. The theory presented for genetic counseling is based on the more general theories of learning, decision‐making, and adaptation to psychological stress. This theory is extended into a practical model that provides a comprehensive explanation of the relationships between the activities of genetic counseling and informed decision‐making, which is assumed to be a major element of healthy counselee adjustment. Implications of this theory for the genetic counselor, the counselee, and the assessment of clinical and program success are discussed.     

The health orientation scale: A measure of feelings about sickle cell trait

Abstract

The Health Orientation Scale (HOS), a written self‐report instrument, was developed to objectively appraise the psychological implications of identification as a sickle cell gene carrier (AS). The HOS uses the semantic differential technique and consists, of nine situations thought to be of importance in identification as a carrier. The instrument was completed by respondents during the various phases of the screening and counseling process. Discussion will focus on a comparison of carrier and noncarrier (AA) reactions to situations which involve the diagnoses of sickle cell trait (AS), sickle cell disease (SS), cancer, and hypertension along with a comparison of feelings before and after counseling. Results suggest that noncarriers have more negative feelings about sickle cell than carriers. Further, counseling, as it is currently practiced, does not contribute to any significant differences in feelings about sickle cell for either carriers or noncarriers. The attitudes and feelings of noncarriers toward sickle cell trait and disease suggest that carrier identification is a stigma.     

Genetic counseling as an occupational specialty: A sociological perspective

Abstract

Observations of client‐counselor interaction during genetic counseling sessions at a metropolitan hospital on the West Coast identified five major problems with which genetic counselors had to deal. Their clients needed: (1) a diagnosis of the disease condition; (2) an evaluation of the genetic nature of the condition; (3) to be taught biomedical information; (4) assistance in coping with psychological stress; and (5) information on available community resources and social service support. The genetic counselors under observation tended to satisfy the clients’ first two needs, the need for a diagnosis and for a genetic evaluation, but they tended not to satisfy the clients’ needs in the areas of education and psychosocial counseling. Genetic counseling appears to demand a synthesis of five different professional skills, those of the medical doctor, the geneticist, the educator, the psychotherapist, and the social worker. These findings are discussed in terms of their relevance for creating programs for training genetic counselors.     

Utility and efficiency of linked marker genes for genetic counseling. II. Identification of linkage phase by offspring phenotypes

For a linked marker locus to be useful for genetic counseling, the counselee must be heterozygous for both disease and marker loci and his or her linkage phase must be known. It is shown that when the phenotypes of the counselee's previous children for the disease and marker loci are known, the linkage phase can often be inferred with a high probability, and thus it is possible to conduct genetic counseling. To evaluate the utility of linked marker genes for genetic counseling, the accuracy of prediction of the risk for a prospective child with a given marker gene to develop the genetic disease and the proportion of families in which a particular marker locus can be used for genetic counseling are studied for X-linked recessive, autosomal dominant, and autosomal recessive diseases. In the case of X-linked genetic diseases, information from children is very useful for determining the linkage phase of the counselee and predicting the genetic disease. In the case of autosomal dominant diseases, not all children are informative, but if the number of children is large, the phenotypes of children are often more informative than the information from grandparents. In the case of autosomal recessive diseases, information from grandparents is usually useless, since they show a normal phenotype for the disease locus. If we use information on the phenotypes of children, however, the linkage phase of the counselee and the risk of a prospective child can be inferred with a high probability. The proportion of informative families depends on the dominance relationship and frequencies of marker alleles, and the number of children. In general, codominant markers are more useful than are dominant markers, and a locus with high heterozygosity is more useful than is a locus with low heterozygosity.     

Prevalence of beta-thalassaemia and sickle cell traits in premarital screening in Al-Qassim, Saudi Arabia

To study the prevalence of beta-thalassaemia and sickle cell traits in the Al-Qassim region, Saudi Arabia. The Ministry of Health of Saudi Arabia launched a countrywide programme in February 2004 to allow all Saudis planning marriage to screen their carrier status for beta-thalassaemia and sickle cell traits. This population survey of mandatory premarital screening for beta-thalassaemia and sickle cell heterozygotes provided an opportunity to estimate the prevalence of these traits in the Al-Qassim region. From February 2004 to October 2006 all individuals attending for premarital screening in that region were screened. For each subject, venous blood was taken to determine complete blood count, red cell indices and hemoglobin electrophoresis. Subjects were considered to have beta-thalassaemia trait if mean corpuscular volume was <79 fl, mean corpuscular haemoglobin <27 pg and haemoglobin A2 level >3.5%; and sickle cell trait if sickle cell haemoglobin amounted to 35 to 45% and sickling test was positive. Totally 38,153 individuals were screened during the study period. The prevalence rates of beta-thalassaemia and sickle cell traits were 0.165% (63/38,153) and 0.252% (96/38,153) respectively. Compared with results of previous studies carried out in this region on the same issue, the prevalence of sickle cell heterozygotes seems to be the same but the frequency of beta-thalassaemia carriers is substantially higher. Screening for carriers both of beta-thalassaemia and sickle cell traits is important to prevent at risk marriages through genetic counseling.     

What's new and what's true of what's new in dermatology

Within the past few years it has been noted that abnormal types of hemoglobin found in certain persons are associated with definite clinical disorders. At least four different varieties of sickle cell anemia are now recognized, three of them being heterozygous and one homozygous. When the gene for sickling is represented once, the person is asymptomatic and is said to have "sickle cell trait." However, when the sickle cell trait is present in combination with certain other hemoglobin abnormalities such as hemoglobin C or D or with thalassemia trait, symptomatic clinical disease results. The homozygous condition, in which two genes for hemoglobin C are present in the same person, has been observed in a few instances. A similar condition as regards hemoglobin D has not as yet been recognized.     

Evaluation of a Well-Established Task-Shifting Initiative: The Lay Counselor Cadre in Botswana

Background

Evidence supports the implementation of task shifting to address health worker shortages that are common in resource-limited settings. However, there is need to learn from established programs to identify ways to achieve the strongest, most sustainable impact. This study examined the Botswana lay counselor cadre, a task shifting initiative, to explore effectiveness and contribution to the health workforce.

Methods

This evaluation used multiple methods, including a desk review, a national lay counselor survey (n = 385; response = 94%), in-depth interviews (n = 79), lay counselors focus group discussions (n = 7), lay counselors observations (n = 25), and client exit interviews (n = 47).

Results

Interview and focus group data indicate that lay counselors contribute to essentially all HIV-related programs in Botswana and they conduct the majority of HIV tests and related counseling at public health facilities throughout the country. Interviews showed that the lay counselor cadre is making the workload of more skilled health workers more manageable and increasing HIV acceptance in communities. The average score on a work-related knowledge test was 74.5%. However for 3 questions, less than half answered correctly. During observations, lay counselors demonstrated average competence for most skills assessed and clients (97.9%) were satisfied with services received. From the survey, lay counselors generally reported being comfortable with their duties; however, some reported clinical duties that extended beyond their training and mandate. Multiple factors affecting the performance of the lay counselors were identified, including insufficient resources, such as private counseling space and HIV test kits; and technical, administrative, and supervisory support.

Conclusion

Lay counselors are fulfilling an important role in Botswana''s healthcare system, serving as the entry point into HIV care, support, and treatment services.

Recommendation

For this and other similar task shifting initiatives, it is important that lay counselors'' responsibilities are clear and that training and support are adequate to optimize their effectiveness.     

Prenatal genetic counseling for hemoglobinopathy carriers: a comparison of primary providers of prenatal care and professional genetic counselors.

Health personnel trained in medical genetics are insufficient to meet the demand for genetic services. Methods must be found to enable primary care providers to offer commonly needed genetic services themselves. In our recently reported community-wide prenatal screening program for hemoglobinopathies, 36% of women detected to have a hemoglobinopathy did not come to a tertiary center for counseling and thus may have not benefited from testing. To determine whether the efficiency of the program could be increased if counseling were provided by the prenatal care provider (obstetrician or family practitioner), we developed a pilot training program on the basis of our experience in offering such services and enlisted 68% of regional prenatal care providers to participate. The proportion of patients detected to have a hemoglobinopathy who received counseling was similar in the primary and tertiary provider groups: 59% versus 50%, respectively, for sickle trait, and 69% versus 66%, respectively, for beta-thalassemia trait. Knowledge after counseling was also similar for the primary and tertiary provider groups: 64% versus 66% (mean % correct), respectively, for sickle trait, and 79% versus 78%, respectively, for beta-thalassemia trait. However, the two provider groups significantly differed with regard to whether or not the patient had her partner tested. For sickle trait, it was 25% for the primary providers but 49% for the tertiary providers (P < .001). For beta-thalassemia trait, it was 47% for the primary providers but 78% for the tertiary providers (P < .001).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Validation of a Low-Cost Paper-Based Screening Test for Sickle Cell Anemia

Background

The high childhood mortality and life-long complications associated with sickle cell anemia (SCA) in developing countries could be significantly reduced with effective prophylaxis and education if SCA is diagnosed early in life. However, conventional laboratory methods used for diagnosing SCA remain prohibitively expensive and impractical in this setting. This study describes the clinical validation of a low-cost paper-based test for SCA that can accurately identify sickle trait carriers (HbAS) and individuals with SCA (HbSS) among adults and children over 1 year of age.

Methods and Findings

In a population of healthy volunteers and SCA patients in the United States (n = 55) the test identified individuals whose blood contained any HbS (HbAS and HbSS) with 100% sensitivity and 100% specificity for both visual evaluation and automated analysis, and detected SCA (HbSS) with 93% sensitivity and 94% specificity for visual evaluation and 100% sensitivity and 97% specificity for automated analysis. In a population of post-partum women (with a previously unknown SCA status) at a primary obstetric hospital in Cabinda, Angola (n = 226) the test identified sickle cell trait carriers with 94% sensitivity and 97% specificity using visual evaluation (none of the women had SCA). Notably, our test permits instrument- and electricity-free visual diagnostics, requires minimal training to be performed, can be completed within 30 minutes, and costs about $0.07 in test-specific consumable materials.

Conclusions

Our results validate the paper-based SCA test as a useful low-cost tool for screening adults and children for sickle trait and disease and demonstrate its practicality in resource-limited clinical settings.     

Prenatal screening for hemoglobinopathies. III. Applicability of the health belief model.

A comprehensive prenatal hemoglobinopathy screening program in Rochester, NY, has been described in a preceding paper in this issue of the Journal. A woman identified as a carrier may face three decisions. The first is whether to accept the offer of counseling. The second is whether to have her partner tested. If her partner also tests positive, then the third decision is whether to accept the offer of prenatal diagnosis. This report analyzes factors affecting her decision, with special attention being given to factors invoked by the Health Belief Model. Factors predicting that a patient who we identified as a carrier would come for counseling included the following: patient had no prior knowledge that she is a carrier (P less than .001), a gestational age less than 18 wk (P less than .01), and Caucasian race (P less than .05). For sickle cell trait counselees and beta-thalassamia trait counselees, factors found to predict patient's intent to have partner tested were the following: a greater postcounseling knowledge of the disease (P less than .009), a lesser perceived burden of intervention (P less than .011), and belief that the partner is also a carrier (P less than .008). Also for sickle cell trait counselees and beta-thalassemia trait counselees, factors predicting that the partner actually will be tested were the following: living with the partner (P less than .001), gestational age at identification less than or equal to 18 wk (P less than .001), a lesser perceived burden of intervention (P less than .002), and a greater perceived seriousness of the disease (P less than .05).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Efficacy of and patient preference for three counseling formats

Three methods of conveying genetics-related information to parents with children who have isolated cleft lip and palate (CL/P) were evaluated for efficacy and patient preference. The methods were slide-tape, group counseling, and individual (or parental couple) counseling formats. Sixty-one subjects were assigned at random to one of the three formats and then quizzed about their pre- and postcounseling knowledge and attitudes on CL/P. Long-term retention of information was measured by administering a third quiz 6 months after the initial counseling session. Comparisons of the mean scores for the three formats within each questionnaire revealed no significant differences among them. Based on this study, the following conclusions were drawn: Genetic counseling significantly improves one's knowledge base about CL/P; no counseling method is detectably better or worse than the others in conveying genetic information to counselees; group or audiovisual counseling is accepted by counselees as well as or better than individual counseling; the audiovisual format presents the same information as a counselor in half the time; and genetic counseling for CL/P is an underprovided service by San Antonio's CL/P treatment teams.     

Association of duffy blood groups with the suckle cell trait

Summary Among a small group of Saudi Arabs the Duffy blood group (Fy(a-b-)) was found to be associated with the sickle cell trait more often than could be explained by random gene combination thus supporting the concept that African gene flow brought the sickle cell trait to the Arabian peninsula. Based on recent observations concerning the possible role of Fy(a-b-) as a resistance factor againstvivax malaria, it is proposed that the gene combination AS FyFy is likely to be selected in areas wherefalciparum andvivax infections are endemic and mixed infections occur frequently.     

Dactylitis in a child with sickle cell trait

Dactylitis commonly occurs in patients with homozygous hemoglobin S disease (sickle cell anemia), sickle cell-hemoglobin C disease or sickle cell-β-thalassemia. A case is reported of dactylitis associated with sickle cell trait, a very rare occurrence. It may be that in this patient the disorder was secondary to severe diarrhea and dehydration.     

Utility and efficiency of linked marker genes for genetic counseling. III. Proportion of informative families under linkage disequilibrium.

A marker locus closely linked to a disease locus is often useful for genetic counseling provided that a counselee is heterozygous at both disease and marker loci. Furthermore, the linkage phase of these genes in the counselee must be known. When the linkage between the disease and marker loci is very close, one often finds linkage disequilibrium between the loci. To evaluate the effect of such nonrandom associations on the utility of linked marker genes for genetic counseling, the proportion of informative families is studied for X-linked recessive and autosomal dominant diseases. This proportion is higher for X-linked genes than for autosomal genes, if other factors are the same. In general, codominant markers are more useful than dominant markers. Also, under appropriate conditions, the proportion of informative families is higher when linkage disequilibrium is present. The results obtained in this paper are useful for evaluating the utility of polymorphic restriction endonuclease cleavage sites as markers in genetic counseling.     

Sickle cell trait human erythrocytes are significantly stiffer than normal

Atomic force microscopy (AFM) allows for high-resolution topography studies of biological cells and measurement of their mechanical properties in physiological conditions. In this work, AFM was employed to measure the stiffness of abnormal human red blood cells from human subjects with the genotype for sickle cell trait. The determined Young's modulus was compared with that obtained from measurements of erythrocytes from healthy subjects. The results showed that Young's modulus of pathological erythrocytes was approximately three times higher than in normal cells. Observed differences indicate the effect of the polymerization of sickle hemoglobin as well as possible changes in the organization of the cell cytoskeleton associated with the sickle cell trait.     

Prevalence of diabetes mellitus in individuals heterozygous and homozygous for sickle cell anemia

Colorimetric determinations of glycosylated Hb were carried out in a sample (n = 97) of sickle cell anemia patients, and in an age- and sex-matched group of individuals (n = 45) heterozygous for sickle cell anemia, from the Eastern Province of Saudi Arabia. A statistically significant increase in the value of glycosylated Hb was found in sickle cell trait (HbAS) group, when compared with those of sickle cell anemia (HbSS) and normal (HbAA) groups. Since glycosylated Hb is considered a valid indicator of long-term blood glucose, and assuming normal red blood cell survival in HbAS carriers, the increased value of glycosylated Hb may suggest that there exists a higher incidence of undiagnosed diabetes mellitus in individuals with heterozygous inheritance for sickle cell hemoglobin than homozygous sickle cell patients and normal individuals. The mechanism underlying this observation remains to be defined.     

alpha-thalassemia in Bantu population from Congo-Brazzaville: its interaction with sickle cell anemia

Deletional alpha(+)-thalassemia (-alpha(3.7)) was investigated in four groups of unrelated individuals from the Bantu population (newborns, normal adults, sickle cells trait carriers, sickle cell anemia patients) of Brazzaville, Congo. The frequency of the (-alpha(3.7)) chromosome was similar between newborns (f = 0.40) and adult subjects (f = 0.36), and between sicklers and nonsickler subjects. The frequency of the (-alpha(3.7)) chromosome in sickle cell anemia patients (SS patients) did not change when age was stratified. The hematological characteristics of SS patients with (-alpha/alphaalpha, -alpha/-alpha) and without (alphaalpha/alphaalpha) alpha(+)-thalassemia were similar to those reported in Jamaican and US sickle cell anemia patients. alpha(+)-Thalassemia had an effect on the percentage of hemoglobin S in sickle cell trait carriers. Thus, the high frequency of alpha(+)-thalassemia in the Congolese population presumably results from this disorder having a selective advantage favoring survival. However, the frequency of alpha(+)-thalassemia was not affected by age. Although in this selective tropical environment, alpha(+)-thalassemia as elsewhere markedly affects the hematological characteristics of sickle cell anemia patients, however our data provide no evidence that alpha(+)-thalassemia increases survival of SS patients.     

Prenatal screening for hemoglobinopathies. I. A prospective regional trial.

Prenatal hemoglobinopathy screening was chosen as a model system for the study of patient receptivity to unsolicited genetic information. Providers of prenatal care in Rochester, NY, were offered free testing of all their prenatal patients and genetic counseling of women found positive. The 18,907 prenatal samples tested in a 5-year period represented 35.1% of the pregnancies in the Rochester metropolitan region. A hemoglobinopathy was found in 810 pregnancies (4.3%). Of the 21 different types of hemoglobinopathies detected, the most common were sickle cell trait (59%), hemoglobin C trait (19%), beta-thalassemia trait (11%), and hemoglobin E trait (5%). At the time of phlebotomy, 75% of the pregnancies were of less than 18 wk duration. Sixty-six percent of the pregnancies occurred in patients unaware of their diagnosis, and 80% occurred in patients unaware that they might be at risk for a child with a serious blood disorder. Of the 810 positive pregnancies, 551 (68%) occurred in patients who came for counseling. Of 453 women counseled during their first screened pregnancy, 390 (86%) said they wanted their partners tested and 254 (55%) had their partner tested. In the 77 pregnancies thus found to be at risk, the couple was too late for prenatal diagnosis in 12 cases, and the condition for which the fetus was at risk was too mild in 12 cases. Prenatal diagnosis was offered in the remaining 53 pregnancies and was accepted by 25 couples (47%). These results indicate that unselected patients in the primary care setting in this region, even though pregnant, are receptive to and utilize genetic information.