Somatic cell variants express altered H-2Kb allodeterminants recognized by cytolytic T cell clones

The present studies have made use of in vitro derived H-2Kb mutants to analyze the fine specificity of alloreactive cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL). The variants were derived by negatively selecting mutagenized tumor cells with a monoclonal anti-H-2Kb antibody and positively selecting for residual cells expressing serologically altered H-2Kb molecules. Details of this procedure are described in the companion paper. Selected populations of bulk alloreactive and cloned CTL were examined for recognition of the variants. In contrast to the serologic findings presented in the companion paper, there does not appear to be a correlation between the monoclonal antibody used to select the R8 variant and the CTL specificities recognized. In several instances, CTL clones could discriminate between variants having identical serologic profiles. Therefore, it would appear that the CTL have a large repertoire of allorecognition, even when generated across a mutant anti-Kb combination reflecting only a few amino acid differences. In addition, a diverse set of epitopes can be recognized on the Kb molecule. Finally, in some instances a change in what would appear to be a single amino acid resulted in a profound alteration of CTL recognition even though the Kb mutant molecule expressed limited serologic changes. These results support the idea that small changes in the H-2Kb molecule can have dramatic effects on CTL even though there are relatively little effects on serologic recognition of the target molecule.     

Cytotoxic T lymphocyte recognition of class I H-2 antigens after DNA-mediated gene transfer

Cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) recognition sites on class I major histocompatibility complex molecules have been investigated by several laboratories by using cloned genes expressed on mouse L cells by DNA-mediated gene transfer. Recombinant genes, constructed by restriction endonuclease treatment of cloned H-2Dd and Ld genes and exchange of the N and C1 exons (exon shuffling) have provided an additional tool. These hybrid H-2 molecules expressed on L cells have been used as targets to achieve more precise localization of site(s) recognized by allospecific and virus-specific CTLs. CTL systems were chosen that limit recognition to either the Dd or Ld alloantigen or to virus and Dd or Ld complexes. Using this approach, we were able to map essential restricting site(s) to the N and/or C1 domains. Additional evidence is presented that the cytoplasmic tail of H-2 may be involved in interactions with some viral antigens and effect the formation of an immunogenic complex.     

Clonal analysis of H-2Kb + TNP recognition by T cells with the use of H-2Kbm mutants and H-2Kb-specific monoclonal antibodies

Eleven long-term cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) clones derived from C57BL/10 T cells sensitized in vivo and in vitro with trinitrobenzene sulfonate- (TNBS) treated syngeneic cells were all restricted to the K end of H-2b. The fine specificity of these CTL clones was analyzed by using H-2Kbm mutant target cells and H-2Kb-specific monoclonal antibodies (mAb). Seven distinct patterns of reactivity of the T cell clones could be observed with the use of six H-2Kbm mutant target cells. Further heterogeneity could be detected in terms of the ability of anti-Lyt-2 mAb to inhibit CTL activity. Cross-reactivity between H-2Kb + TNP and H-2Kbm + TNP was observed for all clones tested for bm5 and bm6, but less frequently for bm3 (8/11), bm8 (7/10), bm4 (4/11), and bm1 (3/11). It was further observed that amino acid substitutions located in the first domain only (one clone), or in the second domain only (six clones), or in either the first or the second domain (three clones) of the H-2Kb molecule could affect target cell recognition by a given T cell clone. the latter type of reactivity suggested that some clones recognized "conformational" determinants of the H-2 molecule, or that amino acid substitutions in one domain might influence the structure of the next domain. One H-2Kb + TNP-reactive clone exhibited a heteroclitic behavior with decreasing avidities for target cells expressing H-2Kbm8 + TNP, H-2Kb + TNP, and H-2Kbm8, which further extends the various patterns of T cell cross-reactions observed within a given class of MHC products. The use of H-2Kb-specific mAb in blocking studies as an attempt to define further the H-2Kb epitopes recognized by CTL clones indicated that: a) TNBS treatment may affect the antigenicity of the H-2Kb molecule as assessed by some mAb; and b) that the T cell clone-target cell interaction may or may not be inhibited by a given mAb, depending on structural variations of the H-2Kb molecule (use of H-2Kbm mutants) that do not affect the interaction itself. These results indicate that this type of analysis does not permit correlation of serologic- and T cell-defined epitopes.     

Cytotoxic T lymphocyte response to minor H-43a alloantigen in H-43b mice. Privileged H-2Kb restriction to the response is not due to immunodominance or epistatic effect but due to Ir gene function of H-2Kb itself

Previous study demonstrated that anti-H-43a cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) response of H-43b CWB (H-2b) stain carrying non-major histocompatability complex (MHC) genes of C3H and F1 strains raised by crossing CWB with various H-43b strains was restricted exclusively by self H-2Kb (Kb). In the present study, newly produced C3W strain (H-2k, H-43b), which is H-43-congenic to C3H/HeN (H-2k, H-43a), was used as H-43b mice, and possibility of immunodominance of Kb was examined. No anti-H-43a CTL response could be induced in C3W strain and F1 strains raised by crossing C3W with other H-43b strains not carrying Kb. Thus, the possibility of immunodominance of Kb over the other MHC class I alleles could not be supported. We also examined possibility of epistatic effect of I region genes and non-MHC genes on the Kb restriction. (C3W x C57BL/6)F1(I-Ak/b) and (C3W x B6.CH-2bm12)F1(I-Ak/bm12)mice showed equally anti-H-43a CTL response restricted exclusively by self Kb, and (C3W x B10.MBR)F1(Ik/k) mice also showed anti-H-43a CTL response restricted solely by self Kb. Cold target competition experiments demonstrated that H-43b C57BL/10 or A.BY mice, which do not have non-MHC genes of C3H mounted anti-H-43a CTL response restricted solely by self Kb. Thus, no relation of I region genes or non-MHC genes to the Kb restriction was shown. All the results indicate that H-43b mouse strains, including F1, can not achieve anti-H-43a CTL response unless they carry Kb allele. Notably, (C3W x C57BL/6)F1 mice mounted self Kb-restricted anti-H-43a CTL response, whereas (C3W x B6.CH-2bm1)F1 mice carrying mutated Kb could not mount anti-H-43a CTL response at all. These findings indicate strongly that Kb itself is classical Ir gene of anti-H-43a CTL response and directs self Kb restriction of the response.     

Differential allo-response of murine thymocytes to H- 2 K region different recombinants and to H-2Kb mutants

Thymocytes used as responding cells in a mixed leukocyte culture with x-irradiated splenic stimulating cells generate highly significant proliferative and cytotoxic responses when responding and stimulating cells differ by the entire H-2 complex. On the other hand, when the genetic difference between responding and stimulating cells is only a K region, very little, if any, proliferative response is detectable and no cytotoxic response is found. In contrast, when responding and stimulating cell donors differ by a spontaneous mutation in the K region of the H-2 complex, as found in B6.C-H-2ba, B6-H-2bd and B6.C-H-2bf, highly significant proliferative and cytotoxic responses can be obtained. These results, thus, argue that the H-2 mutants cannot, with regard to their relationship to the parental strain, be readily equated with a K region difference as defined in the recombinant inbred strains.     

Cytotoxic T lymphocyte recognition of secreted HLA class I molecules

The cytolytic responses of DBA/2 mice against syngeneic transfected P815 mastocytoma cells expressing either membrane-associated (HLA-Cw3) or -secreted hybrid (HLA-Cw3 x H-2 Q10b) molecules were compared. In spite of the absence of serologically detectable hybrid molecules on their plasma membrane, cells secreting these molecules elicited a CTL response similar to that of cells expressing the membrane associated HLA-Cw3 molecules, in terms of both MHC-restriction and peptide specificity. Together with the observation that syngeneic mice were capable of rejecting the injected secreting cells, these results imply that secreted HLA class I molecules can function as minor histocompatibility Ag and suggest that processing of both the membrane-bound and the -secreted forms of a protein may follow common or overlapping pathways.     

Cytotoxic T lymphocyte responses to minor H-43 alloantigens in H-43a and H-43b mice. Both anti-H-43b and anti-H-43a CTL activities are generated exclusively in the context of the same H-2Kb restriction element

We have previously demonstrated that anti-H-43a CTL response of H-43b responder mice was exclusively restricted by self H-2Kb (Kb) but not by the other nine self MHC class I alleles from independent origins, i.e., Kbml,d,k,s and Db,d,k,q,s. In the present study, we verified that Kf,q,r and Df,r alleles could also not serve as restricting class I elements in the CTL response to H-43a alloantigen. Another notable observation made in the earlier study was the fact that, in H-43 incompatibility of the alternative combination, H-43a mice were incapable of generating CTL activity against H-43b alloantigen. However, by means of employing new in vivo immunization procedures, we discovered that some but not all genetically identical H-43a responder mice could mount anti-H-43b CTL response restricted by self Kb. Again, no anti-H-43b CTL activity could be generated in the context of self Kk, Kj, Db or Dk molecules. Although the number of class I alleles we examined is still limited, these results indicate that antigenic fragments derived from the processed H-43a and H-43b alloantigens possess an indistinguishable epitope (agretope), and that such agretope either interacts only with the privileged Kb molecules or allows to bestow the immunogenic conformation of allodeterminants on the fragments solely in the context of the restricting Kb element.     

Cross-reactivity patterns of influenza-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes from H-2Kb mutant mice

Limit dilution cultures were used to test for influenza immune T cell populations from bm1 and bm3 mutant mice that were not lytic for virus-infected targets expressing the Kb and Db major histocompatibility complex glycoproteins. Both Kbm3- and Kbm1-restricted cytotoxic T cells were detected. Such effectors showed minimal cross-recognition of influenza on other mutant targets, except for the case of bm1 and bm10 targets. This is dissimilar to previous findings concerning vaccinia presentation in which bm3+bm11, bm1+bm9, and bm3+bm9 pairs each showed high cross-reactivity. These differences illustrate the role of the H-2K glycoprotein in immune responsiveness. Not only are multiple determinants on each H-2K glycoprotein involved in antigen presentation, they appear to play differential roles in the presentation of different viral antigens.     

Cross-reactive recognition of mouse cells expressing the bm3 and bm11 mutations within H-2Kb by H-2Kb-restricted herpes simplex virus-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes

Cytotoxic T lymphocytes, generated in C57BL/6 mice in response to herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV) and known to be restricted in their recognition of HSV-encoded antigen(s) in association with the class I H-2Kb gene product, were consistently found to contain a subpopulation that recognized and lysed uninfected, SV40-transformed cells that expressed the H-2Kbm3 and H-2Kbm11 mutant class I gene products on their cell surface. The mutant cell lines, designated Lgbm3SV and Kbm11SV, share a common amino acid substitution at position 77, with the bm3 mutation having an additional amino acid substitution at position 89. Cross-reactive lysis was observed only after in vivo priming with HSV, suggesting an important role for an antigen-dependent driving step in the expansion of these cross-reactive CTL. The phenotype of the cross-reactive effector population was further confirmed as a T lymphocyte by negative-selection techniques. Limiting dilution analysis of the frequency of cross-reactive CTL precursors suggested that cross-reactivity was mediated by a subpopulation of HSV-specific CTL, and this was confirmed by clonal analysis of the reactivity patterns of short-term, HSV-specific CTL clones. However, analysis of the specificity of the cross-reactive CTL population by cold-target inhibition of bulk culture-derived CTL, or by Spearman ranking analysis of limiting dilution-derived CTL, indicated that the specificity of the cross-reactive population for HSV-infected H-2b target cells and for uninfected bm3 or bm11 target cells was quite distinct. These findings suggested that the cross-reactive CTL population played little, if any, role in the HSV-specific CTL response as measured in vitro. The findings also suggested that the HSV-specific CTL clones able to mediate cross-reactive recognition of the bm3 and bm11 targets had a higher intrinsic avidity for the foreign target than for the inducing antigen.     

The role of H-2 in T cell recognition of Mls

The role of H-2 was evaluated in T cell recognition of Mls-encoded antigens during primary mixed lymphocyte responses (MLR). Mlsc was used as a stimulating determinant in MLR and its recognition by T cells was assessed by linear regression analysis under culture conditions in which (A x B)F1 responder cell number was the factor limiting total response. Results of such experiments indicated the presence of distinct (A x B)F1 responder T cell subpopulations capable of differentially recognizing the foreign Mls antigen in association with one or the other parental H-2 haplotype. These findings demonstrate that T cells do not recognize Mlsc products in isolation, but rather are restricted to recognition of Mlsc in the context of "self" H-2 determinants.     

Cytotoxic T cell recognition of the influenza nucleoprotein and hemagglutinin expressed in transfected mouse L cells

L cells expressing either the A/NT/60/68 nucleoprotein or the A/PR/8/34 (H1) hemagglutinin by DNA mediated gene transfer were used to investigate recognition by influenza A specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL). A subpopulation of CTL that recognized the H1 hemagglutinin was detected in mice primed with either A/PR/8/34 (H1N1) or A/JAP/305/57 (H2N2) influenza viruses. However, neither CTL from mice primed with A/NT/60/68 (H3N2) nor the recombinant virus X31 (H3N2) showed any activity on L cells expressing H1. These results showed that the majority of fully crossreactive CTL do not recognize the hemagglutinin molecule. A comparison between nucleoprotein and hemagglutinin transfected L cells reveals the nucleoprotein as the major target for CTL that are crossreactive on the three pandemic strains of human influenza A virus.     

T cell recognition of nonpolymorphic determinants on H-2 class I molecules

Recognition of polymorphic determinants on class I or class II MHC Ag is required for T lymphocyte responses. Using cell-size artificial membranes (pseudocytes) bearing H-2 class I Ag it is demonstrated that T cells can, in addition, recognize nonpolymorphic determinants on class I proteins. Pseudocytes bearing class I alloantigen stimulate in vitro generation of secondary allogeneic CTL responses. At a suboptimal alloantigen surface density, incorporation of class I molecules identical to those of the responder cells (self-H-2) or from third-party cells resulted in dramatically enhanced responses, whereas incorporation of class II proteins had no effect. The receptor that mediates recognition of conserved class I determinants has not been identified, but results of antibody blocking studies are consistent with the Lyt-2/3 complex of CTL having this role. Thus, class I proteins on Ag-bearing cells can have two distinct roles in T cell activation, one involving recognition of polymorphic determinants by the Ag-specific receptor and the other involving recognition of conserved determinants.     

Cytotoxic T-lymphocyte tolerance to minor H-43a alloantigen is induced exclusively in the context of the self major histocompatibility complex class I H-2Kb molecules

We elucidated previously that cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursors (CTLp) against H-43a allo-antigen, which we had discovered as a new mouse minor H antigen, were primed in H-43b mice only in the context of self H-2Kb restriction element, and that anti-H-43a CTLp tolerance was induced in H-43b mice by injection with H-43a spleen cells (SC) from H-43 congenic mice, i.e., under the condition of disparity at only the H-43 locus. The present study attempted to determine whether the H-2Kb restriction element for anti-H-43a CTLp priming is also implicated in the induction of anti-H-43a CTLp tolerance. For this purpose, we used a newly established H-43b C3W (H-2k) strain which is H-43 congenic to H-43a C3H/HeN. When (C3W X B10.MBR)F1 (H-43b, H-2Kk/b, Ik/k, Dk/q) mice were injected with H-43a-bearing (C3H/HeN X B10.AKM)F1 (H-43a/b;H-2Kk/k,Ik/k,Dk/q)SC, their selfH-2Kb-restricted anti-H-43a CTLp were were primed (cross-priming). By contrast, injection of H-43a-bearing (C3H/HeN X B10.MBR)F1 (H-43a/b; H-2Kk/b,Ik/k, Dk/q)SC, which differ from (C3H/HeN x B10.AKM) F1 SC solely at H-2K and possess H-2Kb molecules, did not prime but specifically inactivated the anti-H-43a CTLp of (C3W x B10.MBR)F1 mice. These results indicate clearly that anti-H-43a CTLp tolerance is induced exclusively in the context of the H-2Kb element expressed on the antigenic H-43a SC.