The Significance of p16INK4a in Cell Defences Against Transformation

Human cells, including fibroblast strains that have been immortalized by telomerase, are much more resistant to transformation than rodent cells. Most of the experimental evidence suggests that transformation of human fibroblasts requires inactivation of both the retinoblastoma (pRb) and p53 tumor suppressors as well as the addition of one or more dominant oncogenes. By starting with strains of primary fibroblast (Leiden and Q34 cells) that are genetically deficient for p16INK4a, we have been able to generate anchorage independent colonies simply by addition of telomerase (hTERT) and either Ras or Myc. Importantly, the transformed cells appear to retain pRb and p53 functions and are essentially diploid. Whereas Leiden cells expressing the individual oncogenes did not form tumors in mice, the combination of hTERT, Myc and Ras enabled them to become tumorigenic, albeit at a frequency suggestive of an additional genetic event. Significantly, we have obtained karyotypically stable tumors without the need to use DNA tumor virus oncoproteins and without deliberate ablation of p53.     

The significance of p16INK4a in cell defenses against transformation

Human cells, including fibroblast strains that have been immortalized by telomerase, are much more resistant to transformation than rodent cells. Most of the experimental evidence suggests that transformation of human fibroblasts requires inactivation of both the retinoblastoma (pRb) and p53 tumor suppressors as well as the addition of one or more dominant oncogenes. By starting with strains of primary fibroblast (Leiden and Q34 cells) that are genetically deficient for p16INK4a, we have been able to generate anchorage independent colonies simply by addition of telomerase (hTERT) and either Ras or Myc. Importantly, the transformed cells appear to retain pRb and p53 functions and are essentially diploid. Whereas Leiden cells expressing the individual oncogenes did not form tumors in mice, the combination of hTERT, Myc and Ras enabled them to become tumorigenic, albeit at a frequency suggestive of an additional genetic event. Significantly, we have obtained karyotypically stable tumors without the need to use DNA tumor virus oncoproteins and without deliberate ablation of p53.     

Cooperation of simian virus 40 large and small T antigens in metabolic stabilization of tumor suppressor p53 during cellular transformation.

Metabolic stabilization of the tumor suppressor p53 is a key event in cellular transformation by simian virus 40 (SV40). Expression of the SV40 large tumor antigen (large T) is necessary but not sufficient for this process, as metabolic stabilization of p53 complexed to large T in abortively SV40-infected cells strictly depends on the cellular systems analyzed (F. Tiemann and W. Deppert, J. Virol. 68:2869-2878, 1994). Comparative analyses of various cells differing in metabolic stabilization of p53 upon abortive infection with SV40 revealed that metabolic stabilization of p53 closely correlated with expression of the SV40 small t antigen (small t) in these cells: 3T3 cells do not express small t and do not stabilize p53 upon infection with wild-type SV40. However, ectopic expression of small t in 3T3 cells provided these cells with the capacity to stabilize p53 upon SV40 infection. Conversely, precrisis mouse embryo cells express small t and mediate metabolic stabilization of p53 upon infection with wild-type SV40. Infection of these cells with an SV40 small-t deletion mutant did not lead to metabolic stabilization of p53. Small-t expression and metabolic stabilization of p53 correlated with an enhanced transformation efficiency by SV40, supporting the conclusion that at least part of the documented helper effect of small t in SV40 transformation is its ability to promote metabolic stabilization of p53 complexed to large T.     

The retinoblastoma protein is required for Ras-induced oncogenic transformation

Most human cancers involve either mutational activation of the Ras oncogenic pathway and/or inactivation of the retinoblastoma tumor suppressor (RB) pathway. Paradoxically, tumors that harbor Ras mutations almost invariably retain expression of a wild-type pRB protein. We explain this phenomenon by demonstrating that Ras-induced oncogenic transformation surprisingly depends on functional pRB protein. Cells lacking pRB are less susceptible to the oncogenic actions of H-RasV12 than wild-type cells and activated Ras has an inhibitory effect on the proliferation of pRB-deficient human tumor cells. In addition, depletion of pRB from Ras-transformed murine cells or human tumor cells that harbor Ras pathway mutations inhibits their proliferation and anchorage-independent growth. In sharp contrast to pRB-/- 3T3 cells, fibroblasts deficient in other pRB family members (p107 and p130) are more susceptible to Ras-mediated transformation than wild-type 3T3 cells. Moreover, loss of pRB in tumor cells harboring a Ras mutation results in increased expression of p107, and overexpression of p107 but not pRB strongly inhibits proliferation of these tumor cells. Together, these findings suggest that pRB and p107 have distinct roles in Ras-mediated transformation and suggest a novel tumor-suppressive role for p107 in the context of activated Ras.     

p16(Ink4a) interferes with Abelson virus transformation by enhancing apoptosis

Pre-B-cell transformation by Abelson virus (Ab-MLV) is a multistep process in which primary transformants are stimulated to proliferate but subsequently undergo crisis, a period of erratic growth marked by high levels of apoptosis. Inactivation of the p53 tumor suppressor pathway is an important step in this process and can be accomplished by mutation of p53 or down-modulation of p19(Arf), a p53 regulatory protein. Consistent with these data, pre-B cells from either p53 or Ink4a/Arf null mice bypass crisis. However, the Ink4a/Arf locus encodes both p19(Arf) and a second tumor suppressor, p16(Ink4a), that blocks cell cycle progression by inhibiting Cdk4/6. To determine if p16(Ink4a) plays a role in Ab-MLV transformation, primary transformants derived from Arf(-/-) and p16(Ink4a(-/-)) mice were compared. A fraction of those derived from Arf(-/-) animals underwent crisis, and even though all p16(Ink4a(-/-)) primary transformants experienced crisis, these cells became established more readily than cells derived from +/+ mice. Analyses of Ink4a/Arf(-/-) cells infected with a virus that expresses both v-Abl and p16(Ink4a) revealed that p16(Ink4a) expression does not alter cell cycle profiles but does increase the level of apoptosis in primary transformants. These results indicate that both products of the Ink4a/Arf locus influence Ab-MLV transformation and reveal that in addition to its well-recognized effects on the cell cycle, p16(Ink4a) can suppress transformation by inducing apoptosis.     

Dissecting the contribution of p16(INK4A) and the Rb family to the Ras transformed phenotype

Although oncogenic Ras commonly contributes to the development of cancer, in normal primary cells it induces cell cycle arrest rather than transformation. Here we analyze the additional genetic changes required for Ras to promote cell cycle progression rather than arrest. We show that loss of p53 is sufficient for oncogenic Ras to stimulate proliferation in the absence of extrinsic mitogens in attached cells. However, surprisingly, we find that p53 loss is not sufficient for Ras to overcome anchorage dependence or contact inhibition. In contrast, expression of simian virus 40 (SV40) large T antigen (LT) allows Ras to overcome these additional cell cycle controls. Mutational analysis of SV40 LT shows that this action of SV40 LT depends on its ability to inactivate the retinoblastoma (Rb) family of proteins, in concert with the loss of p53. Importantly, we show that inactivation of the Rb family of proteins can be mimicked by loss of the cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor p16(INK4A). p16(INK4A) is commonly lost in human tumors, but its contribution to the transformed phenotype is unknown. We demonstrate here a role for p16(INK4A) in the loss of cell cycle controls required for tumorigenesis and show how accumulating genetic changes cooperate and contribute to the transformed phenotype.     

Recombinant retroviruses encoding simian virus 40 large T antigen and polyomavirus large and middle T antigens.

We used a murine retrovirus shuttle vector system to construct recombinants capable of constitutively expressing the simian virus 40 (SV40) large T antigen and the polyomavirus large and middle T antigens as well as resistance to G418. Subsequently, these recombinants were used to generate cell lines that produced defective helper-free retroviruses carrying each of the viral oncogenes. These recombinant retroviruses were used to analyze the role of the viral genes in transformation of rat F111 cells. Expression of the polyomavirus middle T antigen alone resulted in cell lines that were highly tumorigenic, whereas expression of the polyomavirus large T resulted in cell lines that were highly tumorigenic, whereas expression of the polyomavirus large T resulted in cell lines that were unaltered by the criteria of morphology, anchorage-independent growth, and tumorigenicity. More surprisingly, SV40 large T-expressing cell lines were not tumorigenic despite the fact that they contained elevated levels of cellular p53 and had a high plating efficiency in soft agar. These results suggest that the SV40 large T antigen is not an acute transforming gene like the polyomavirus middle T antigen but is similar to the establishment genes such as myc and adenovirus EIa.     

The transforming proteins of simian virus 40

Simian virus 40 (SV40) is a small DNA tumor virus whose early gene products, large T and small t antigens, efficiently immortalize and transform primary rodent cells, transform rodent cell lines and extend the lifespan of primary human cells. Mutational analysis has revealed that the transforming and lifespan extension properties of large T antigen correlate with binding to and disruption of the normal functions of the human tumor suppressor proteins pRb and p53. Small t antigen contributes to cell proliferation through inactivation of protein phosphatase 2A and subsequent activation of the MAP kinase pathway. By disrupting key cell growth control mechanisms, SV40 transforming proteins provide a valuable system for analysis of cellular growth control mechanisms.     

Modulation of p53 protein expression during cellular transformation with simian virus 40.

We analyzed the relation of metabolic stabilization of the p53 protein during cellular transformation by simian virus 40 (SV40) to (i) expression of the transformed phenotype and (ii) expression of the large tumor antigen (large T). Analysis of SV40-tsA28-mutant-transformed rat cells (tsA28.3 cells) showed that both p53 complexed to large T and free p53 (W. Deppert and M. Haug, Mol. Cell. Biol. 6:2233-2240, 1986) were metabolically stable when the cells were cultured at 32 degrees C and expressed large T and the transformed phenotype. At the nonpermissive temperature (39 degrees C), large-T expression is shut off in these cells and they revert to the normal phenotype. In such cells, p53 was metabolically unstable, like p53 in untransformed cells. To determine whether metabolic stabilization of p53 is directly controlled by large T, we next analyzed the metabolic stability of complexed and free p53 in SV40 abortively infected normal BALB/c mouse 3T3 cells. We found that neither p53 in complex with large T nor free p53 was metabolically stable. However, both forms of p53 were stabilized in SV40-transformed cells which had been developed in parallel from SV40 abortively infected cultures. Our results indicate that neither formation of a complex of p53 with large T nor large-T expression as such is sufficient for a significant metabolic stabilization of p53. Therefore, we suggest that metabolic stabilization of p53 during cellular transformation with SV40 is mediated by a cellular process and probably is the consequence of the large-T-induced transformed phenotype.     

Dual growth arrest pathways in astrocytes and astrocytic tumors in response to Raf-1 activation

Normal human fibroblasts have been shown to undergo a p16(Ink4a)-associated senescence-like growth arrest in response to sustained activation of the Ras/Raf/MEK/ERK pathway. We noted a similar p16(Ink4a)-associated, senescence-like arrest in normal human astrocytes in response to expression of a conditional form of Raf-1. While HPV16 E7-mediated functional inactivation of the p16(Ink4a)/pRb pathway in astrocytes blocked the p16(Ink4a)-associated growth arrest in response to activation of Raf-1, it also revealed a second p21(Cip1)-associated, senescence-associated, beta-galactosidase-independent growth arrest pathway. Importantly, the p21(Cip1)-associated pathway was present not only in normal astrocytes but also in p53-, p14(ARF)-, and p16(Ink4a)/pRb-deficient high grade glioma cells that lacked the p16(Ink4a)-dependent arrest mechanism. These results suggest that normal human cells have redundant arrest pathways, which can be activated by Raf-1, and that even tumors that have dismantled p16(Ink4a)-dependent growth arrest pathways are potentially regulated by a second p21(Cip1)-dependent growth arrest pathway.     

Tumorigenicity of fibroblast lines expressing the adenovirus E1a, cellular p53, or normal c-myc genes.

Cellular and viral oncogenes have been linked to the transformation of established cell lines in vitro, to the induction of tumors in vivo, and to the partial transformation or immortalization of primary cells. Based on the ability to cooperate with mutated ras oncogenes in the transformation of primary cells, the adenovirus E1a and cellular p53 genes have been assigned an immortalizing activity. It is demonstrated in this paper that the adenovirus type 5 E1a gene and simian virus 40 promoter-linked p53 cDNA are able to transform previously immortalized cells to a tumorigenic phenotype without a significant change in cell morphology. It is also shown that, when linked to a constitutive promoter, the normal mouse and human c-myc genes have the same transforming activity. Cells transformed by each of these oncogenes have an increased capacity to grow in the absence of growth factors and a limited anchorage-independent growth capability.     

Enumeration of the simian virus 40 early region elements necessary for human cell transformation

While it is clear that cancer arises from the accumulation of genetic mutations that endow the malignant cell with the properties of uncontrolled growth and proliferation, the precise combinations of mutations that program human tumor cell growth remain unknown. The study of the transforming proteins derived from DNA tumor viruses in experimental models of transformation has provided fundamental insights into the process of cell transformation. We recently reported that coexpression of the simian virus 40 (SV40) early region (ER), the gene encoding the telomerase catalytic subunit (hTERT), and an oncogenic allele of the H-ras gene in normal human fibroblast, kidney epithelial, and mammary epithelial cells converted these cells to a tumorigenic state. Here we show that the SV40 ER contributes to tumorigenic transformation in the presence of hTERT and oncogenic H-ras by perturbing three intracellular pathways through the actions of the SV40 large T antigen (LT) and the SV40 small t antigen (ST). LT simultaneously disables the retinoblastoma (pRB) and p53 tumor suppressor pathways; however, complete transformation of human cells requires the additional perturbation of protein phosphatase 2A by ST. Expression of ST in this setting stimulates cell proliferation, permits anchorage-independent growth, and confers increased resistance to nutrient deprivation. Taken together, these observations define the elements of the SV40 ER required for the transformation of human cells and begin to delineate a set of intracellular pathways whose disruption, in aggregate, appears to be necessary to generate tumorigenic human cells.     

Absence of p53 complements defects in Abelson murine leukemia virus signaling

The v-Abl protein encoded by Abelson murine leukemia virus (Ab-MLV) induces transformation of pre-B cells via a two-stage process. An initial proliferative phase during which cells with limited tumorigenic potential expand is followed by a crisis period marked by high levels of apoptosis and erratic growth. Transformants that survive this phase emerge as fully malignant cells and usually contain mutations that disable the p53 tumor suppressor pathway. Consistent with the importance of p53 in this process, pre-B cells from p53 null animals bypass crisis. Thus, the transformation process reflects a balance between signals from the v-Abl protein that drive transformation and those coming from the cellular response to inappropriate growth. One prediction of this hypothesis is that Ab-MLV mutants that are compromised in their ability to transform cells may be less equipped to overcome the effects of p53. To test this idea, we examined the ability of the P120/R273K mutant to transform pre-B cells from wild-type, p53 null, and Ink4a/Arf null mice. The SH2 domain of the v-Abl protein encoded by this mutant contains a substitution that affects the phosphotyrosine-binding pocket, and this mutant is compromised in its ability to transform NIH 3T3 and pre-B cells, especially at 39.5 degrees C. Our data reveal that loss of p53 or Ink4a/Arf locus products complements the transforming defect of the P120/R273K mutant, but it does not completely restore wild-type function. These results indicate that one important transforming function of v-Abl proteins is overcoming the effects of a functional p53 pathway.     

Binding of p300/CBP co-activators by polyoma large T antigen.

Small DNA tumor viruses such as simian virus 40 (SV40) and polyomavirus (Py) take advantage of host cell proteins to transcribe and replicate their DNA. Interactions between the viral T antigens and host proteins result in cell transformation and tumor induction. Large T antigen of SV40 interacts with p53, pRb/p107/p130 family members, and the cyclic AMP-responsive element-binding protein (CREB)-binding protein (CBP)/p300. Py large T antigen is known to interact only with pRb and p300 among these proteins. Here we report that Py large T binds to CBP in vivo and in vitro. In co-transfection assays, Py large T inhibits the co-activation functions of CBP/p300 in CREB-mediated transactivation but not in NF-kappa B-mediated transactivation. p53 appears not to be involved in the functions of CREB-mediated transactivation and is not essential for large T:CBP interaction. Mutations introduced into a region of Py large T with homology to adenovirus E1A and SV40 large T prevent binding to the co-activators. These mutant large T antigens fail to inhibit CREB-mediated transactivation. The CBP/p300-binding Py mutants are able to transform established rat embryo fibroblasts but are restricted in their ability to induce tumors in the newborn mouse, indicating that interaction of large T with the co-activators may be essential for virus replication and spread in the intact host.     

Kaposi's sarcoma-associated herpesvirus latency-associated nuclear antigen prolongs the life span of primary human umbilical vein endothelial cells

Tumor spindle cells in all clinical types of Kaposi's sarcoma (KS) are infected with Kaposi's sarcoma-associated herpesvirus (KSHV). Although KSHV contains more than 80 genes, only a few are expressed in tumor spindle cells, including latency-associated nuclear antigen (LANA) and k-cyclin (kCYC). To assess the oncogenic potential of LANA and kCYC, primary human umbilical vein endothelial cells (HUVEC) and murine NIH 3T3 cells were stably transduced by using recombinant retroviruses expressing these genes or the known viral oncogene simian virus 40 large T antigen (LTAg). Interestingly, LANA-transduced HUVEC proliferated faster and demonstrated a greatly prolonged life span (mean +/- standard deviation, 38.3 +/- 11.0 passages) than untransduced cells and vector-transduced cells (<20 passages). By contrast, kCYC-transduced HUVEC did not proliferate faster or live longer than control cells. LANA- and kCYC-transduced HUVEC, but not LTAg-transduced HUVEC, retained the ability to form normal vessel-like structures in an in vitro model of angiogenesis. In cellular assays of transformation, LANA- and kCYC-transduced NIH 3T3 cells demonstrated minimal or no anchorage-independent growth in soft agar and no tumorigenicity when injected into nude mice, unlike LTAg-transduced NIH 3T3 cells. Lastly, gene expression profiling revealed down-regulation, or silencing, of a number of genes within LANA-transduced HUVEC. Taken together, these results suggest that KSHV LANA is capable of inducing prolonged life span, but not transformation, in primary human cells. These findings may explain why LANA-expressing spindle cells proliferate within KS tumors, yet most often do not demonstrate biologic characteristics of transformation or true malignant conversion.