Microtubule treadmilling in vitro investigated by fluorescence speckle and confocal microscopy.

Whether polarized treadmilling is an intrinsic property of microtubules assembled from pure tubulin has been controversial. We have tested this possibility by imaging the polymerization dynamics of individual microtubules in samples assembled to steady-state in vitro from porcine brain tubulin, using a 2% glycerol buffer to reduce dynamic instability. Fluorescence speckled microtubules were bound to the cover-glass surface by kinesin motors, and the assembly dynamics of plus and minus ends were recorded with a spinning-disk confocal fluorescence microscopy system. At steady-state assembly, 19% of the observed microtubules (n = 89) achieved treadmilling in a plus-to-minus direction, 34% in a minus-to-plus direction, 37% grew at both ends, and 10% just shortened. For the population of measured microtubules, the distribution of lengths remained unchanged while a 20% loss of original and 27% gain of new polymer occurred over the 20-min period of observation. The lack of polarity in the observed treadmilling indicates that stochastic differences in dynamic instability between plus and minus ends are responsible for polymer turnover at steady-state assembly, not unidirectional treadmilling. A Monte Carlo simulation of plus and minus end dynamics using measured dynamic instability parameters reproduces our experimental results and the amount of steady-state polymer turnover reported by previous biochemical assays.     

Dynamic features of microtubules as visualized by dark-field microscopy

We have reviewed recent progress in the dynamic features of microtubules in vitro as visualized by dark-field light microscopy using high intensity illumination. Observations of individual microtubules in real-time have made it possible to analyze the unique characteristics of microtubules exactly. The following three topics have been discussed: (1) treadmilling, i.e., the simultaneous assembly of tubulin at one end and disassembly at the other end on a single microtubule at a steady state. (2) Dynamic instability, i.e., the very unusual phenomenon in which two populations of microtubules coexist: those in one population elongating while those in the other shortening in the absence of MAPs. Both ends of the microtubules exist either in the growing or the shortening phase, and alternate between the two phases in a stochastic manner. (3) Morphogenesis of liposomes by microtubule growth. Tubulin is encapsulated into model membrane vesicles, liposomes. Polymerization of the encapsulated tubulin causes a change in shape of the spherical liposomes to form bipolar or multipolar vesicles, suggesting that microtubules have an active function in the morphogenesis of membranous organelles and cells.     

Phase dynamics at microtubule ends: the coexistence of microtubule length changes and treadmilling

The length dynamics both of microtubule-associated protein (MAP)-rich and MAP-depleted bovine brain microtubules were examined at polymer mass steady state. In both preparations, the microtubules exhibited length redistributions shortly after polymer mass steady state was attained. With time, however, both populations relaxed to a state in which no further changes in length distributions could be detected. Shearing the microtubules or diluting the microtubule suspensions transiently increased the extent to which microtubule length redistributions occurred, but again the microtubules relaxed to a state in which changes in the polymer length distributions were not detected. Under steady-state conditions of constant polymer mass and stable microtubule length distribution, both MAP-rich and MAP-depleted microtubules exhibited behavior consistent with treadmilling. MAPs strongly suppressed the magnitude of length redistributions and the steady-state treadmilling rates. These data indicate that the inherent tendency of microtubules in vitro is to relax to a steady state in which net changes in the microtubule length distributions are zero. If the basis of the observed length redistributions is the spontaneous loss and regain of GTP-tubulin ("GTP caps") at microtubule ends, then in order to account for stable length distributions the microtubule ends must reside in the capped state far longer than in the uncapped state, and uncapped microtubule ends must be rapidly recapped. The data suggest that microtubules in cells may have an inherent tendency to remain in the polymerized state, and that microtubule disassembly must be induced actively.     

Microtubule dynamics and the regulation by microtubule-associated proteins (MAPs).

Individual microtubules (MTs) repeat alternating phases of polymerization and depolymerization, a process known as "dynamic instability." The dynamic instability is regulated by various protein factors according to the requirement of cellular conditions. Heat-stable MAPs regulate the dynamic instability by increasing the rescue frequency. To explore the influence of MAP2, a heat-stable MAPs abundant in neuron, on in vitro MT dynamics, the distribution of MAP2 on individual MTs was correlated with the dynamic phase changes of the same MTs by optical microscopy. MAP2 distributed inhomogeneously along the length of MTs by forming high-density regions, clusters. Stops of depolymerization were always found to occur only at the cluster sites. Every cluster did not stop depolymerization, but depolymerization did always stop at a cluster site. We suggest that mode of distribution along MT is an important factor of the function of heat-stable MAPs.     

Taxol stabilization of microtubules in vitro: dynamics of tubulin addition and loss at opposite microtubule ends

We have investigated the effects of taxol on steady-state tubulin flux and on the apparent molecular rate constants for tubulin addition and loss at the two ends of bovine brain microtubules in vitro. These microtubules, which consist of a mixture of 70% tubulin and 30% microtubule-associated proteins (MAPs), undergo a net addition of tubulin at one end of each microtubule (A end) and a precisely balanced net loss of tubulin at the opposite end (D end) at steady state in vitro. They do not exhibit to a detectable extent the "dynamic instability" behavior described recently for MAP-free microtubules, which would be evident as an increase in the mean microtubule length and a decrease in the number of microtubules in the suspensions [Mitchison, T., & Kirschner, M. (1984) Nature (London) 312, 237-242]. We used a double-label procedure in which microtubules were labeled with tritium and carbon-14 at A ends and carbon-14 at D ends to distinguish the two ends, combined with a microtubule collection procedure that permitted rapid and accurate analysis of retention of the two labels in the microtubules. We found that taxol slowed the flux of tubulin in a concentration-dependent manner, with 50% inhibition occurring between 5 and 7 microM drug. The effects of taxol on the apparent molecular rate constants for tubulin addition and loss at the two microtubule ends were determined by dilution analysis at an intermediate taxol concentration. The results indicated that taxol decreased the magnitudes of the dissociation rate constants at the two ends to similar extents, while exerting little effect on the association rate constants.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Suppression of microtubule dynamic instability and treadmilling by deuterium oxide

Deuterium oxide (D(2)O) is known to promote the assembly of tubulin into microtubules in vitro, to increase the volume of mitotic spindles and the number and length of spindle microtubules, and to inhibit mitosis. Reasoning that its actions on cellular microtubules could be due to modulation of microtubule dynamics, we examined the effects of replacing H(2)O with D(2)O on microtubule dynamic instability, treadmilling, and steady-state GTPase activity. We found that replacing 50% or more of the H(2)O with D(2)O promoted microtubule polymerization and stabilized microtubules against dilution-induced disassembly. Using steady-state axoneme-seeded microtubules composed of pure tubulin and video microscopy, we found that 84% D(2)O decreased the catastrophe frequency by 89%, the shortening rate by 80%, the growing rate by 50%, and the dynamicity by 93%. Sixty percent D(2)O decreased the treadmilling rate of microtubules composed of tubulin and microtubule-associated proteins by 42%, and 89% D(2)O decreased the steady-state GTP hydrolysis rate by 90%. The mechanism responsible for the ability of D(2)O to stabilize microtubule dynamics may involve enhancement of hydrophobic interactions in the microtubule lattice and/or the substitution of deuterium bonds for hydrogen bonds.     

Towards an understanding of microtubule function and cell organization: an overview.

Microtubules exhibit dynamic instability, converting abruptly between assembly and disassembly with continued growth dependent on the presence of a tubulin-GTP cap at the plus end of the organelle. Tubulin, the main structural protein of microtubules, is a heterodimer composed of related polypeptides termed alpha-tubulin and beta-tubulin. Most eukaryotic cells possess several isoforms of the alpha- and beta-tubulins, as well as gamma-tubulin, an isoform restricted to the centrosome. The isoforms of tubulin arise either as the products of different genes or by posttranslational processes and their synthesis is subject to regulation. Tubulin isoforms coassemble with one another and isoform composition does not appear to determine whether a microtubule is able to carry out one particular activity or another. However, the posttranslational modification of polymerized tubulin may provide chemical signals which designate microtubules for a certain function. Microtubules interact with proteins called microtubule-associated proteins (MAPs) and they can be divided into two groups. The structural MAPs stimulate tubulin assembly, enhance microtubule stability, and influence the spatial distribution of microtubules within cells. The dynamic MAPs take advantage of microtubule polarity and organization to vectorially translocate cellular components. The interactions between microtubules and MAPs contribute to the structural-functional integration that characterizes eukaryotic cells.     

Effects of brain microtubule-associated proteins on microtubule dynamics and the nucleating activity of centrosomes

In this paper, we report on the effect of brain microtubule-associated proteins (MAPs) on the dynamic instability of microtubules as well as on the nucleation activity of purified centrosomes. Under our experimental conditions, tau and MAP2 have similar effects on microtubule nucleation and dynamic instability. Tau increases the apparent elongation rate of microtubules in proportion to its molar ratio to tubulin, and we present evidence indicating that this is due to a reduction of microtubule instability rather than to an increase of the on rate of tubulin subunits at the end of growing microtubules. Increasing the molar ratio of tau over tubulin leads also to an increase in the average number of microtubules nucleated per centrosome. This number remains constant with time. This suggests that the number of centrosome-nucleated microtubules at steady state can be determined by factors that are not necessarily irreversibly bound to centrosomes but, rather, affect the dynamic properties of microtubules.     

Dynamics of microtubules from erythrocyte marginal bands.

Microtubules can adjust their length by the mechanism of dynamic instability, that is by switching between phases of growth and shrinkage. Thus far this phenomenon has been studied with microtubules that contain several components, that is, a mixture of tubulin isoforms, with or without a mixture of microtubule-associated proteins (MAPs), which can act as regulators of dynamic instability. Here we concentrate on the influence of the tubulin component. We have studied MAP-free microtubules from the marginal band of avian erythrocytes and compared them with mammalian brain microtubules. The erythrocyte system was selected because it represents a naturally stable aggregate of microtubules; second, the tubulin is largely homogeneous, in contrast to brain tubulin. Qualitatively, erythrocyte microtubules show similar features as brain microtubules, but they were found to be much less dynamic. The critical concentration of elongation, and the rates of association and dissociation of tubulin are all lower than with brain microtubules. Catastrophes are rare, rescues frequent, and shrinkage slow. This means that dynamic instability can be controlled by the tubulin isotype, independently of MAPs. Moreover, the extent of dynamic behavior is highly dependent on buffer conditions. In particular, dynamic instability is strongly enhanced in phosphate buffer, both for erythrocyte marginal band and brain microtubules. The lower stability in phosphate buffer argues against the hypothesis that a cap of tubulin.GDP.Pi subunits stabilizes microtubules. The difference in dynamics between tubulin isotypes and between the two ends of microtubules is preserved in the different buffer systems.     

Modulation of microtubule dynamics by drugs: a paradigm for the actions of cellular regulators

Microtubules are intrinsically dynamic polymers. Two kinds of dynamic behaviors, dynamic instability and treadmilling, are important for microtubule function in cells. Both dynamic behaviors appear to be tightly regulated, but the cellular molecules and the mechanisms responsible for the regulation remain largely unexplored. While microtubule dynamics can be modulated transiently by the interaction of regulatory molecules with soluble tubulin, the microtubule itself is likely to be the primary target of cellular molecules that regulate microtubule dynamics. The antimitotic drugs that modulate microtubule dynamics serve as excellent models for such cellular molecules. Our laboratory has been investigating the interactions of small drug molecules and stabilizing microtubule-associated proteins (MAPs) with microtubule surfaces and ends. We find that drugs such as colchicine, vinblastine, and taxol, and stabilizing MAPs such as tau, strongly modulate microtubule dynamics at extremely low concentrations under conditions in which the microtubule polymer mass is minimally affected. The powerful modulation of the dynamics is brought about by the binding of only a few drug or MAP molecules to distinct binding sites at the microtubule surface or end. Based upon our understanding of the well-studied drugs and stabilizing MAPs, it is clear that molecules that regulate dynamics such as Kin 1 and stathmin could bind to a large number of distinct tubulin sites on microtubules and employ an array of mechanisms to selectively and powerfully regulate microtubule dynamics and dynamics-dependent cellular functions.     

Traces of brain microtubule-associated proteins affect dynamic properties of microtubules

A method is described for measuring the quantities of stable and dynamic microtubules in a population in vitro. The method exploits the tendency of dynamic microtubules to depolymerize rapidly after being sheared. Stable microtubules, such as those protected by microtubule-associated proteins (MAPs), are broken to a smaller size by shearing, but do not depolymerize into subunits. The usual difficulty with this procedure is that the tubulin released from the dynamic microtubules rapidly repolymerizes before the end point of depolymerization can be measured. This has been overcome by including a small quantity of tubulin-colchicine complex in the mixture to block the repolymerization. For a total of 24 microM tubulin in a polymerization mixture, 10 microM of the sample polymerized originally under the conditions used. When 1.05 microM tubulin-colchicine complex was added at the time of shearing, the dynamic microtubules depolymerized, but the tubulin was released was unable to repolymerize and a small fraction of stable microtubules that resisted shear-induced depolymerization could then be detected. When traces of MAPs (0.23-2.8% by mass) were included in the tubulin mixture, the fraction of stable microtubules increased from 5% in the absence of added MAPs to 41% in the presence of 2.8% MAPs. All the MAPs in the mixture were found in the stable fraction and this stable fraction forms early during microtubule assembly. Calculations on the extent of enrichment of MAPs in the stable fraction indicated that as little as 4% MAPs in a microtubule protected it from shear-induced disassembly. The results suggest that low levels of MAPs may distribute nonrandomly in the microtubule population.     

Direct observation of steady-state microtubule dynamics

Different types of unusual dynamic behavior have been reported for steady-state microtubules. While almost all earlier reports relied on kinetic measurements of bulk polymerization, we have directly visualized the steady-state addition of subunits to individual microtubules through the use of tubulin derivitized with biotin. Biotinylated tubulin was used both as an internal "seed" for polymerization and as a marker for assembly onto the ends of microtubules composed of purified tubulin. Biotinylated segments were distinguished from unmodified tubulin by double-label immunofluorescence. Microtubule lengths, number concentrations, and segment lengths have been monitored with time at steady state under two buffer conditions. The results indicate that the microtubule steady state under these conditions is a balance between a majority of slowly growing microtubules and a minority of rapidly depolymerizing ones as described by the "dynamic instability" model (Mitchison T., and M. Kirschner, 1984, Nature (Lond.)., 312:232-242). Microtubules show no evidence of treadmilling; instead most show progressive growth off both ends at steady state. Although solvent conditions markedly influence the growth rates, qualitatively the behavior is unchanged.     

Real-time observation of microtubules attached to microtubule organizing centers in vitro*

Summary— The dynamics and organization of microtubules associated with axonemes and kinetochores in vitro were visualized using video microscopy techniques. Microtubules attached either at the ends of axonemes or to mitotic chromosomes behave accordining to dynamic instability in our conditions. Microtubules attached to kinetochores showed lower rates of elongation and shortening than those nucleated by axonemes in the same conditions. In addition, elementary bundles of microtubules appeared spontaneously in association with kinetochores, with microtubules elongating along previously attached microtubules at even lower rates. Such side interactions, either spontaneous or stabilized by factors such as MAPs, might affect microtubule dynamics directly.     

Structural plugs at microtubule ends may regulate polymer dynamics in vitro

Microtubules contain in their lumens distinct structures (plugs) that influence their dynamic behavior in vitro. As observed by electron microscopy, plugs are stain-occluding structures 10-30 nm in length that occur along the lengths and at the ends of microtubules. Plugs occur at a frequency of 20-40% at the ends of microtubules assembled from cycled microtubule protein containing MAPs. While the composition of plugs is not known, preliminary evidence suggests that they are accretions of tubulin, that they are labile, and that they are more common in preparations containing MAPs. When polymers are induced to depolymerize by endwise subunit dissociation, the frequency of plugged microtubule ends increases transiently, suggesting that plugs temporarily stabilize microtubules. The functional significance of plugs may be that they prevent the sudden complete loss of microtubules through catastrophic disassembly. It is possible that plugs, by slowing the rate of disassembly, enable a polymer to add GTP-tubulin subunits, thereby forming a stabilizing GTP-cap. These observations suggest that plugs may stabilize polymers and account for the frequent transitions from shortening to growing phases that characterize dynamic instability.     

Dynamic instability of native microtubules from squid axons is rare and independent of gliding and vesicle transport

Dynamic instability characterizes the steady-state behavior of microtubules in vitro whereby polymer mass remains constant, while individual microtubules in the population may either grow or shrink. Video-enhanced contrast light microscopy was used to directly observe dynamic length changes in native, MAP-containing microtubules from squid axoplasm. We wanted to determine whether dynamic instability characterizes the steady-state behavior of axoplasmic microtubules in vitro. The lengths of a representative population of over 400 microtubules were analyzed. "Dynamic" microtubules were found to represent about 2% of the population. This observation is different from that described for cultured cells or microtubules assembled from PC-purified tubulin where most microtubules were either growing or shrinking.     

Intrinsically slow dynamic instability of HeLa cell microtubules in vitro

The dynamic behavior of mammalian microtubules has been extensively studied, both in living cells and with microtubules assembled from purified brain tubulin. To understand the intrinsic dynamic behavior of mammalian nonneural microtubules, we purified tubulin from cultured HeLa cells. We find that HeLa cell microtubules exhibit remarkably slow dynamic instability, spending most of their time in an attenuated state. The tempered dynamics contrast sharply with the dynamics of microtubules prepared from purified bovine brain tubulin under similar conditions. In accord with their minimal dynamic instability, assembled HeLa cell microtubules displayed a slow treadmilling rate and a low guanosine-5'-triphosphate hydrolysis rate at steady state. We find that unlike brain tubulin, which consists of a heterogeneous mixture of beta-tubulin isotypes (beta(II), beta(III), and beta(IV) and a low level of beta(I)), HeLa cell tubulin consists of beta(I) tubulin ( approximately 80%) and a minor amount of beta(IV) tubulin ( approximately 20%). The slow dynamic behavior of HeLa cell microtubules in vitro differs strikingly from the dynamic behavior of microtubules in living cultured mammalian cells, supporting the idea that accessory factors create the robust dynamics that occur in cells.     

Dynamic instability of individual microtubules analyzed by video light microscopy: rate constants and transition frequencies

We have developed video microscopy methods to visualize the assembly and disassembly of individual microtubules at 33-ms intervals. Porcine brain tubulin, free of microtubule-associated proteins, was assembled onto axoneme fragments at 37 degrees C, and the dynamic behavior of the plus and minus ends of microtubules was analyzed for tubulin concentrations between 7 and 15.5 microM. Elongation and rapid shortening were distinctly different phases. At each end, the elongation phase was characterized by a second order association and a substantial first order dissociation reaction. Association rate constants were 8.9 and 4.3 microM-1 s-1 for the plus and minus ends, respectively; and the corresponding dissociation rate constants were 44 and 23 s-1. For both ends, the rate of tubulin dissociation equaled the rate of tubulin association at 5 microM. The rate of rapid shortening was similar at the two ends (plus = 733 s-1; minus = 915 s-1), and did not vary with tubulin concentration. Transitions between phases were abrupt and stochastic. As the tubulin concentration was increased, catastrophe frequency decreased at both ends, and rescue frequency increased dramatically at the minus end. This resulted in fewer rapid shortening phases at higher tubulin concentrations for both ends and shorter rapid shortening phases at the minus end. At each concentration, the frequency of catastrophe was slightly greater at the plus end, and the frequency of rescue was greater at the minus end. Our data demonstrate that microtubules assembled from pure tubulin undergo dynamic instability over a twofold range of tubulin concentrations, and that the dynamic instability of the plus and minus ends of microtubules can be significantly different. Our analysis indicates that this difference could produce treadmilling, and establishes general limits on the effectiveness of length redistribution as a measure of dynamic instability. Our results are consistent with the existence of a GTP cap during elongation, but are not consistent with existing GTP cap models.     

Stathmin strongly increases the minus end catastrophe frequency and induces rapid treadmilling of bovine brain microtubules at steady state in vitro

Stathmin is a ubiquitous microtubule destabilizing protein that is believed to play an important role linking cell signaling to the regulation of microtubule dynamics. Here we show that stathmin strongly destabilizes microtubule minus ends in vitro at steady state, conditions in which the soluble tubulin and microtubule levels remain constant. Stathmin increased the minus end catastrophe frequency approximately 13-fold at a stathmin:tubulin molar ratio of 1:5. Stathmin steady-state catastrophe-promoting activity was considerably stronger at the minus ends than at the plus ends. Consistent with its ability to destabilize minus ends, stathmin strongly increased the treadmilling rate of bovine brain microtubules. By immunofluorescence microscopy, we also found that stathmin binds to purified microtubules along their lengths in vitro. Co-sedimentation of purified microtubules polymerized in the presence of a 1:5 initial molar ratio of stathmin to tubulin yielded a binding stoichiometry of 1 mol of stathmin per approximately 14.7 mol of tubulin in the microtubules. The results firmly establish that stathmin can increase the steady-state catastrophe frequency by a direct action on microtubules, and furthermore, they indicate that an important regulatory action of stathmin in cells may be to destabilize microtubule minus ends.     

Dynamics of Antarctic fish microtubules at low temperatures

The tubulins of Antarctic fishes, purified from brain tissue and depleted of microtubule-associated proteins (MAPs), polymerized efficiently in vitro to yield microtubules at near-physiological and supraphysiological temperatures (5, 10, and 20 degrees C). The dynamics of the microtubules at these temperatures were examined through the use of labeled guanosine 5'-triphosphate (GTP) as a marker for the incorporation, retention, and loss of tubulin dimers. Following attainment of a steady state in microtubule mass at 20 degrees C, the rate of incorporation of [3H]GTP (i.e., tubulin dimers) during pulses of constant duration decreased asymptotically toward a constant, nonzero value as the interval prior to label addition to the microtubule solution increased. Concomitant with the decreasing rate of label incorporation, the average length of the microtubules increased, and the number concentration of microtubules decreased. Thus, redistribution of microtubule lengths (probably via dynamic instability and/or microtubule annealing) appears to be responsible for the time-dependent decrease in the rate of tubulin uptake. When the microtubules had attained both a steady state in mass and a constant length distribution, linear incorporation of labeled tubulin dimers over time occurred at rates of 1.45 s-1 at 5 degrees C, 0.48 s-1 at 10 degrees C, and 0.18 s-1 at 20 degrees C. Thus, the microtubules displayed greater rates of subunit flux, or treadmilling, at lower, near-physiological temperatures. At each temperature, most of the incorporated label was retained by the microtubules during a subsequent chase with excess unlabeled GTP.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Generation of microtubule stability subclasses by microtubule- associated proteins: implications for the microtubule "dynamic instability" model

We have developed a method to distinguish microtubule associated protein (MAP)-containing regions from MAP-free regions within a microtubule, or within microtubule sub-populations. In this method, we measure the MAP-dependent stabilization of microtubule regions to dilution-induced disassembly of the polymer. The appropriate microtubule regions are identified by assembly in the presence of [3H]GTP, and assayed by filter trapping and quantitation of microtubule regions that contain label. We find that MAPs bind very rapidly to polymer binding sites and that they do not exchange from these sites measurably once bound. Also, very low concentrations of MAPs yield measurable stabilization of local microtubule regions. Unlike the stable tubule only polypeptide (STOP) proteins, MAPs do not exhibit any sliding behavior under our assay conditions. These results predict the presence of different stability subclasses of microtubules when MAPs are present in less than saturating amounts. The data can readily account for the observed "dynamic instability" of microtubules through unequal MAP distributions. Further, we report that MAP dependent stabilization is quantitatively reversed by MAP phosphorylation, but that calmodulin, in large excess, has no specific influence on MAP protein activity when MAPs are on microtubules.