Roles of colchicine rings B and C in the binding process to tubulin

The interactions of tubulin with colchicine analogues in which the tropolone methyl ether ring had been transformed into a p-carbomethoxybenzene have been characterized. The analogues were allocolchicine (ALLO) and 2,3,4-trimethoxy-4'-carbomethoxy-1,1'-biphenyl (TCB), the first being transformed colchicine and the second transformed colchicine with ring B eliminated. The binding of both analogues has been shown to be specific for the colchicine binding site on tubulin by competition with colchicine and podophyllotoxin. Both analogues bind reversibly to tubulin with the generation of ligand fluorescence. The binding of ALLO is slow, the fluorescence reaching a steady state in the same time span as colchicine; that of TCB is rapid. The displacement of ALLO by podophyllotoxin proceeds with a half-life of ca. 40 min. Binding isotherms generated from gel filtration and fluorescence measurements have shown that both analogues bind to tubulin with a stoichiometry of 1 mol of analogue/mol of alpha-beta tubulin. The equilibrium binding constants at 25 degrees C have been found to be (9.2 +/- 2.5) x 10(5) M-1 for ALLO and (1.0 +/- 0.2) X 10(5) M-1 for TCB. Binding of both analogues was accompanied by quenching of protein fluorescence, perturbation of the far-ultraviolet circular dichroism of tubulin, and induction of the tubulin GTPase activity, similarly to colchicine binding. Both inhibited microtubule assembly in vitro, ALLO substoichiometrically, and both induced the abnormal cooperative polymerization of tubulin, which is characteristic of the tubulin-colchicine complex. Analysis in terms of the simple bifunctional ligand binding mechanism developed for colchicine [Andreu, J.M., & Timasheff, S.N. (1982) Biochemistry 21, 534-543] and comparison with the binding of the colchicine two-ring analogue, 2-methoxy-5-(2,3,4-trimethoxyphenyl)-2,4,6-cycloheptatrien-1-one [Andreu, J. M., Gorbunoff, M. J., Lee, J. C., & Timasheff, S. N. (1984) Biochemistry 23, 1742-1752], have shown that transformation of the tropolone methyl ether part of colchicine into p-carbomethoxybenzene weakens the standard free energy of binding to tubulin by 1.4 +/- 0.1 kcal/mol, while elimination of ring B weakens it by 1.0 +/- 0.1 kcal/mol. The roles of rings C and B of colchicine in the thermodynamic and kinetic mechanisms of binding to tubulin were analyzed in terms of these findings.     

Aging of tubulin at neutral pH: stabilization by colchicine and its analogues.

The effect of colchicine and its analogues, allocolchicine, 2,3,4-trimethoxy-4'-carbomethoxy-1,1'biphenyl, 2,3,4,4'-tetramethoxy-1,1'-biphenyl, 2,3,4-trimethoxy-4'-acetyl-1,1'-biphenyl, and tropolone methyl ether, on the aging process of tubulin has been examined. In contrast to the vinca alkaloid drugs which accelerate the formation of the paucidisperse 9 S polymers by a factor of 3.5, the colchicine class of ligands stabilize alpha,beta-tubulin. Less than 10% of the protein is transformed into the aggregates after 50 h of incubation in the presence of 1 x 10(-3) M colchicine, as compared to nearly 70-75% transformation in its absence. These results are supported by fluorescence examination of the retention of colchicine binding ability, as well as circular dichroism spectroscopy. In the presence of colchicine, the rate determining step is a conformational change, just as in its absence. The colchicine analogues which bind to tubulin in a rapidly reversible equilibrium were almost as effective in tubulin stabilization. Addition of vincristine to the system reduced the stability of the tubulin-colchicine complex. Furthermore, vincristine was found to have the same effects on the fresh complex as it does on pure tubulin; i.e., it induced the isodesmic linear polymerization and inhibited assembly into the microtubule-mimicking large polymers. This inhibition, however, was stoichiometric, whereas it is substoichiometric in the case of microtubules.     

A thermodynamic study of the interaction of tubulin with colchicine site ligands

The bicyclic colchicine analogue 2-methoxy-5-(2',3',4'-trimethoxyphenyl)-2,4,6-cycloheptatrien-1-on e (MTC) has been used to study the thermodynamics of specific ligand binding to the colchicine site of tubulin, employing isothermal reaction microcalorimetry. The binding of MTC to purified calf brain tubulin, in 10 mM sodium phosphate buffer, pH 7.0, is characterized by delta H degree = -19 +/- 1 kJ.mol-1, delta G degree = -31.8 +/- 0.6 kJ.mol-1, and delta S degree = 43 +/- 5 J.mol-1.K-1 at 298 K, with a slight variation in the temperature range from 283 to 308 K. The binding thermodynamics of colchicine and allocolchicine are similar to MTC under the conditions examined, suggesting related molecular interactions of the three ligands with the protein binding site. The standard enthalpy changes of binding of colchicine and MTC at 308 K coincide within experimental error. Therefore the more favorable free energy change of binding of colchicine must come from a larger binding entropy change (by about 20 J.mol-1.K-1). This difference could be attributed to the presence of the middle ring of colchicine, which is absent in MTC. Consistently, a similar entropy change is observed by the comparison of allocolchicine to MTC binding at several temperatures. In addition, allocolchicine binding is about 6 kJ.mol-1 less exothermic than MTC binding, which could be attributed to the presence in allocolchicine of a substituted phenyl ring instead of the colchicine-MTC tropolone ring. The present results and analysis are fully compatible with the previously proposed bifunctional binding of colchicine and MTC (through their trimethoxybenzene and tropolone moieties) to a bifocal protein binding site, and also with a partial immobilization of intramolecular rotation of MTC upon binding, which in colchicine is already constrained by its middle ring (Andreu, J. M., Gorbunoff, M. J., Lee, J. C., and Timasheff, S. (1984) Biochemistry 23, 1742-1752).     

Interaction of tubulin with bifunctional colchicine analogues: an equilibrium study

The interaction of tubulin with simple analogues of colchicine that contain both its tropolone and trimethoxyphenyl rings has been characterized, and the results were analyzed in terms of the simple bifunctional ligand model developed for the binding of colchicine [ Andreu , J. M., & Timasheff , S. N. (1982) Biochemistry 21, 534-543] on the basis of interactions of tubulin with single-ring analogues. The compound 2-methoxy-5-(2,3,4-trimethoxyphenyl)-2,4,6- cycloheptatrien -1-one has been found to bind reversibly to 0.86 +/- 0.06 site of purified calf brain tubulin with an equilibrium constant of (4.9 +/- 0.3) X 10(5) M-1 (25 degrees C), delta H degrees app = -1.6 +/- 0.7 kcal mol-1, and delta S degrees app = 20.5 +/- 2.5 eu. The binding appears specific for the colchicine site. The closely related compound 2-methoxy-5-[[3-(3,4,5-trimethoxyphenyl)-propionyl]amino] -2,4,6- cycloheptatrien -1-one interacts weakly with tubulin. Binding of the first analogue is accompanied by ligand fluorescence appearance, quenching of protein fluorescence, perturbation of the far-ultraviolet circular dichroism of tubulin, and induction of the tubulin GTPase activity, similarly to colchicine binding. Substoichiometric concentrations of the analogue inhibit microtubule assembly in vitro. Excess analogue concentration under microtubule-promoting conditions induces an abnormal cooperative polymerization of tubulin, similar to that of the tubulin-colchicine complex.     

Structure-activity relationships of phenylcyclohexene and biphenyl antitubulin compounds against plant and mammalian cells

Phenylcyclohexenes (PCHs) [e.g., trans-4-nitro-5-(2,3,4-trimethoxyphenyl)cyclohexene, 2d] were found to bind weakly to the colchicine site of bovine tubulin, but are the first mimics of colchicine found to have high activity towards plant cells. Structure-activity relationships for PCHs and biphenyl AC-ring analogues of colchicine (e.g., 2,3,4,4'-tetramethoxy-2'-methyl-1,1'-biphenyl, 3e) are discussed.     

Spectroscopic and kinetic features of allocolchicine binding to tubulin

Allocolchicine is a structural isomer of colchicine in which colchicine's tropone C ring is replaced with an aromatic ester. In spite of the structural differences between the two ligands, the association parameters for both molecules binding to tubulin are quite similar. The association constant for allocolchicine binding to tubulin was determined by fluorescence titration to be 6.1 x 10(5) M-1 at 37 degrees C, which is about a factor of 5 less than that of the colchicine-tubulin association. In particular, analysis of the kinetics of the association of allocolchicine with tubulin yielded nearly equivalent activation parameters for the two ligands. The activation energy of the allocolchicine binding reaction was found to be 18.4 +/- 1.5 kcal/mol, which is only slightly less than the activation energy for colchicine binding to tubulin. This finding argues against conformational flexibility of the C ring as the structural feature of colchicine responsible for the slow kinetics of colchicinoid-tubulin binding reactions. Tubulin binding promote a dramatic enhancement of allocolchicine fluorescence. Unlike colchicine, the emission energy and intensity of the tubulin-bound allocolchicine fluorescence can be mimicked by solvent, and a general hydrophobic environment for the ligand binding site is indicated. The excitation spectrum of the protein-bound species, however, is shown to possess two bands which center at higher and lower energy than the energy maximum of the spectrum of the ligand in apolar solvents, indicating that properties of the colchicine binding site in addition to a low dielectric constant contribute to the fluorescence of the bound species.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Mechanism of colchicine binding to tubulin. Tolerance of substituents in ring C' of biphenyl analogues

The limits of structural variation of the substituent in position 4' of ring C' of biphenyl colchicine analogues (ring C in colchicine) were probed by the synthesis of a number of analogues and the examination of their binding to tubulin and its consequences. Binding was found to require the location in three-dimensional space of the oxygen in the 4'-substituent at a locus not far distant from those of the colchicine ring C oxygens. All those analogues that bind to the colchicine site of tubulin induced the GTPase activity and inhibited microtubule assembly, those containing a carbonyl group substoichiometrically and the others stoichiometrically. A similar relation was found for the induction of the abnormal polymerization of the colchicine analogue-tubulin complex, with methoxy-containing compounds requiring a higher temperature to induce the polymerization. A concerted analysis of the binding thermodynamics of colchicine and its various analogues has shown full consistency with the previously proposed two-step binding pathway that involves two nonidentical binding moieties in the ligand [Andreu, J. M., & Timasheff, S. N. (1982) Biochemistry 21, 534-543]. Comparison of the binding parameters of colchicine, its des(ring B) analogue (MTC), and ring A and C compounds individually with the thermodynamic parameters deduced for the first steps of the bindings of colchicine and MTC [Engelborghs, Y., & Fitzgerald, T. J. (1987) J. Biol. Chem. 262, 5204-5209] have led to the conclusion that binding can occur by two pathways leading to the identical product. In the first pathway, ring A binds first; this is followed by a rate-determining thermodynamically indifferent reaction (protein conformation change), and finally a rapid binding of ring C. In the second pathway, the events are the same except that the order of binding of the rings is reversed. Colchicine, due to the steric hindrance of ring B, can follow only the second pathway. For MTC, both kinetic pathways are open and binding may be initiated by random first contact of either ring A or ring C.     

Podophyllotoxin as a probe for the colchicine binding site of tubulin.

The binding of [3H]podophyllotoxin to tubulin, measured by a DEAE-cellulose filter paper method, occurs with an affinity constant of 1.8 X 10(6) M-1 (37 degrees at pH 6.7). Like colchicine, approximately 0.8 mol of podophyllotixin are bound per mol of tubulin dimer, and the reaction is entropy-driven (43 cal deg-1 mol-1). At 37 degrees the association rate constant for podophyllotoxin binding is 3.8 X 10(6) M-1 h-1, approximtaely 10 times higher than for colchicine; this is reflected in the activation energies for binding which are 14.7 kcal/mol for podophyllotoxin and 20.3 kcal/mol for colchicine. The dissociation rate constant for the tubulin-podophyllotoxin complex is 1.9 h-1, and the affinity constant calculated from the ratio of the rates is close to that obtained by equilibrium measurements. Podophyllotxin and colchicine are mutually competitive inhibitors. This can be ascribed to the fact that both compounds have a trimethoxyphenyl ring and analogues of either compound with bulky substituents in their trimethoxyphenyl moiety are unable to inhibit the the binding of either of the two ligands. Tropolone, which inhibits colchicine binding competitively, has no effect on the podophyllotoxin/tubulin reaction. Conversely, podophyllotoxin does not influence tropolone binding. Moreover, the tropolone binding site of tubulin does not show the temperature and pH lability of the colchicine and podophyllotoxin domains, hence this lability can be ascribed to the trimethoxyphenyl binding region of tubulin. Since podophyllotoxin analogues with a modified B ring do not bind, it is concluded that both podophyllotoxin and colchicine each have at least two points of attachment to tubulin and that they share one of them, the binding region of the trimethoxyphenyl moiety.     

Mechanism of binding of the new antimitotic drug MDL 27048 to the colchicine site of tubulin: equilibrium studies.

MDL 27048 [trans-1-(2,5-dimethoxyphenyl)-3-[4-(dimethylamino)phenyl]-2- methyl-2-propen-1-one] fluoresces when bound to tubulin but not in solution. This effect has been investigated and found to be mimicked by viscous solvents. Therefore, MDL 27048 appears to be a fluorescent compound whose intramolecular rotational relaxation varies as a function of microenvironment viscosity. The binding parameters of MDL 27048 to tubulin have been firmly established by fluorescence of the ligand, quenching of the protein fluorescence, and gel equilibrium chromatography. The apparent binding equilibrium constant was (2.75 +/- 0.45) x 10(6)M-1, and the binding site number was 0.81 +/- 0.12 (10 mM sodium phosphate-0.1 mM GTP, pH 7.0, at 25 degrees C). The binding is exothermic. The binding of MDL 27048 overlaps the colchicine and podophyllotoxin binding sites. Binding of MDL 27048 to the colchicine site was also measured by competition with MTC [2-methoxy-5-(2,3,4-trimethoxyphenyl)-2,4,6-cycloheptatrien-1-one] , a well-characterized reversibly binding probe of the colchicine site [Andreu et al. (1984) Biochemistry 23, 1742-1752; Bane et al., (1984) J. Biol. Chem. 259, 7391-7398]. In contrast with close analogues of colchicine, MDL 27048 and podophyllotoxin neither affected the far-ultraviolet circular dichroism spectrum of tubulin, within experimental error, nor induced tubulin GTPase activity. Like podophyllotoxin, an excess of MDL 27048 over tubulin induced no abnormal cooperative polymerization of tubulin, which is characteristic of colchicine binding.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

N-acetylcolchinol O-methyl ether and thiocolchicine, potent analogs of colchicine modified in the C ring. Evaluation of the mechanistic basis for their enhanced biological properties

Two colchicine analogs with modifications only in the C ring are better inhibitors than colchicine of cell growth and tubulin polymerization. Radiolabeled thiocolchicine (with a thiomethyl instead of a methoxy group at position C-10) and N-acetylcolchinol O-methyl ether (NCME) (with a methoxy-substituted benzenoid instead of the methoxy-substituted tropone C ring) were prepared for comparison with colchicine. Scatchard analysis indicated a single binding site with KD values of 1.0-2.3 microM. Thiocolchicine was bound 2-4 times as rapidly as colchicine, but the activation energies of the reactions were nearly identical (18 kcal/mol for colchicine, 20 kcal/mol for thiocolchicine). NCME bound to tubulin in a biphasic reaction. The faster phase was 60 times as fast as colchicine binding at 37 degrees C, and a substantial reaction occurred at 0 degrees C. The rate of the faster phase of NCME binding changed relatively little as a function of temperature, so the activation energy was only 7.0 kcal/mol. Dissociation reactions were also evaluated, and at 37 degrees C the half-lives of the tubulin-drug complexes were 11 min for NCME, 24 h for thiocolchicine, and 27 h for colchicine. Relative dissociation rates as a function of temperature varied little among the drug complexes. Activation energies for the dissociation reactions were 30 kcal/mol for thiocolchicine, 27 kcal/mol for NCME, and 24 kcal/mol for colchicine. Comparison of the activation energies of association and dissociation yielded free energies for the binding reactions of -20 kcal/mol for NCME, -10 kcal/mol for thiocolchicine, and -6 kcal/mol for colchicine. The greater effectiveness of NCME and thiocolchicine as compared with colchicine in biological assays probably derives from their more rapid binding to tubulin and the lower free energies of their binding reactions.     

Antimitotic natural products combretastatin A-4 and combretastatin A-2: studies on the mechanism of their inhibition of the binding of colchicine to tubulin

Combretastatin A-4 (CS-A4), 3,4,5-trimethoxy-3'-hydroxy-4'-methoxy-(Z)-stilbene, and combretastatin A-2 (CS-A2), 3,4-(methylenedioxy)-5-methoxy-3'-hydroxy-4'-methoxy-(Z)-stilbene, are structurally simple natural products isolated from the South African tree Combretum caffrum. They inhibit mitosis and microtubule assembly and are competitive inhibitors of the binding of colchicine to tubulin [Lin et al. (1988) Mol. Pharmacol. 34, 200-208]. In contrast to colchicine, drug effects on tubulin were not enhanced by preincubating CS-A4 or CS-A2 with the protein. The mechanism of their binding to tubulin was examined indirectly by evaluating their effects on the binding of radiolabeled colchicine to the protein. These studies demonstrated rapid binding of both compounds to tubulin even at 0 degrees C (binding was complete at the earliest times examined), in contrast to the relatively slow and temperature-dependent binding of colchicine. Although the binding of the C. caffrum compounds to tubulin was quite tight, permitting ready isolation of near-stoichiometric amounts of drug-tubulin complex even in the absence of free drug, both CS-A4 and CS-A2 dissociated rapidly from tubulin in the presence of high concentrations of radiolabeled colchicine. Apparent rate constants for drug dissociation from tubulin at 37 degrees C were 3.2 x 10(-3) s-1 for CS-A4, 4.8 x 10(-3) s-1 for CS-A2, and 2.9 x 10(-5) s-1 for colchicine (half-lives of 3.6, 2.4, and 405 min, respectively). Thus, the effectiveness of the C. caffrum compounds as antimitotic agents appears to derive primarily from the rapidity of their binding to tubulin.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Binding to tubulin of the colchicine analog 2-methoxy-5-(2', 3', 4'-trimethoxyphenyl)tropone. Thermodynamic and kinetic aspects

The thermodynamics and kinetics of the binding to tubulin of the colchicine analog 2-methoxy-5-(2', 3', 4'-trimethoxyphenyl) tropone (termed AC because it lacks the B-ring of colchicine) have been characterized by fluorescence techniques. The fluorescence of AC is weak in aqueous solution and is enhanced 250-fold upon binding to tubulin. The following thermodynamic values were obtained for the interaction at 37 degrees C: K = 3.5 X 10(5) M-1; delta G0 = -7.9 kcal/mol; delta H0 = -6.8 kcal/mol; delta S0 = 3.6 entropy units. The AC-tubulin complex is 1-2 kcal/mol less stable than the colchicine-tubulin complex. The change in fluorescence of AC was employed to measure the kinetics of the association process, and quenching of protein fluorescence was used to measure both association and dissociation. The association process, like that of colchicine, could be resolved into a major fast phase and a minor slow phase. The apparent second order rate constant for the fast phase was found to be 5.2 X 10(4) M-1 S-1 at 37 degrees C, and the activation energy was 13 kcal/mol. This activation energy is 7-11 kcal/mol less than that for the binding of colchicine to tubulin. The difference in activation energies can most easily be rationalized by a mechanism involving a tubulin-induced conformational change in the ligand ( Detrich , H. W., III, Williams, R. C., Jr., Macdonald, T. L., Wilson, L., and Puett , D. (1981) Biochemistry 20, 5999-6005). Such a change would be expected to have a small activation energy in AC because it possesses a freely rotating single bond in place of the B-ring of colchicine.     

Oxalone and lactone moieties of podophyllotoxin exhibit properties of both the B and C rings of colchicine in its binding with tubulin

Thermodynamics of podophyllotoxin binding to tubulin and its multiple points of attachment with tubulin has been studied in detail using isothermal titration calorimetry. The calorimetric enthalpy of the association of podophyllotoxin with tubulin is negative and occurs with a negative heat capacity change (DeltaC(p) = -2.47 kJ mol(-)(1) K(-)(1)). The binding is unique with a simultaneous participation of both hydrophobic and hydrogen-bonding forces with unfavorable negative entropic contribution at higher temperature, favored with an enthalpy-entropy compensation. Interestingly, the binding of 2-methoxy-5-(2',3',4'-trimethoxyphenyl)tropone (AC, a colchicine analogue without the B ring) with tubulin is enthalpy-favored. However, the podophyllotoxin-tubulin association depending upon the temperature of the reaction has a favorable entropic and enthalpic component, which resembles both B- and C-ring properties of colchicine. On the basis of the crystal structure of the podophyllotoxin-tubulin complex, distance calculations have indicated a possible interaction between threonine 179 of alpha-tubulin and the hydroxy group on the D ring of podophyllotoxin. To confirm the involvement of the oxalone moiety as well as the lactone ring of podophyllotoxin in tubulin binding, analogues of podophyllotoxin are synthesized with methoxy substitution at the 4' position of ring D along with its isomer and another analogue epimerized at ring E. From these results, involvement of oxalone as well as the lactone ring of the drug in a specific orientation inclusive of ring A is indicated for podophyllotoxin-tubulin binding. Therefore, podophyllotoxin, like colchicine, behaves as a bifunctional ligand having properties of both the B and C rings of colchicine by making more than one point of attachment with the protein tubulin.     

Energy-transfer studies of the distance between the high-affinity metal binding site and the colchicine and 8-anilino-1-naphthalenesulfonic acid binding sites on calf brain tubulin

The high-affinity metal divalent cation Mg2+, associated with the exchangeable guanosine 5'-triphosphate (GTP) binding site (E site) on purified tubulin, has been replaced by the transition metal ion Co2+ on tubulin as well as on the tubulin-colchicine, tubulin-allocolchicine and tubulin-8-anilino-1-naphthalenesulfonic acid (tubulin-ANS) complexes. While pure native tubulin readily incorporated 0.8 atom of Co2+ per tubulin alpha-beta dimer, incorporation was reduced to 0.4 atom of Co2+ per mole of tubulin when it was complexed with colchicine, indicating that the conformational change induced in tubulin by the binding of colchicine leads to a reduced accessibility of the divalent cation binding site linked to the E site without necessarily changing the intrinsic binding constant. The fluorescence emission spectra of tubulin-bound colchicine, allocolchicine, and ANS displayed a strong overlap with the Co2+ absorption spectrum, identifying these as adequate donor-acceptor pairs. Fluorescence energy-transfer measurements were carried out between tubulin-bound colchicine (or allocolchicine) and ANS as donors and tubulin-complexed Co2+ as acceptor. It was found that the distance between the ANS and the high-affinity divalent cation binding sites is greater than 28 A, while that between the colchicine and the divalent cation binding sites is greater than 24 A.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Binding to tubulin of an allocolchicine spin probe: interaction with the essential SH groups and other active sites

EPR titration of tubulin with an allocolchicine spin probe showed more than one binding site: one high-affinity binding site (Kd = 8 microM), consistent with the Ki found for competition with colchicine, and one or more low-affinity site(s) (Kd higher than 50 microM). No disturbance of the EPR signal of the tubulin-bound allocolchicine spin probe could be observed at room temperature in the presence of other paramagnetic probes: Mn(II) for the binding site of Mg(II), Co(II) for the Zn(II) binding site and Cr(III)GTP for the binding site of the exchangeable GTP. Labelling of tubulin with both the allocolchicine and a SH-group spin probe also showed lack of interaction. The colchicine-binding site is thus sterically isolated from the binding sites for GTP, Mg(II), Zn(II) and the two essential SH-groups. In the tubulin-colchicin complex, all SH-groups could still be labelled with an excess of the SH-reagent, N-ethylmaleimide. Furthermore, colchicine binding was only minimally influenced by the blocking of the two essential SH-groups. However, the rate constant of the reaction of two equivalents of the SH-reagent, a maleimide spin probe, with the tubulin-colchicine complex was only 50% of the rate constant found with uncomplexed tubulin. As direct steric interaction of the essential SH-groups with the colchicine-binding site can be excluded, we can now definitively decide that binding of colchicine to tubulin induces a conformational change, which affects the accessibility of the most reactive SH-groups.     

Anion-induced increases in the affinity of colcemid binding to tubulin

Colcemid binds tubulin rapidly and reversibly in contrast to colchicine which binds tubulin relatively slowly and essentially irreversibly. At 37 degrees C the association rate constant for colcemid binding is 1.88 X 10(6) M-1 h-1, about 10 times higher than that for colchicine; this is reflected in the activation energies for binding which are 51.4 kJ/mol for colcemid and 84.8 kJ/mol for colchicine. Scatchard analysis indicates two binding sites on tubulin having different affinities for colcemid. The high-affinity site (Ka = 0.7 X 10(5) M-1 at 37 degrees C) is sensitive to temperature and binds both colchicine and colcemid and hence they are mutually competitive inhibitors. The low-affinity site (Kb = 1.2 X 10(4) M-1) is rather insensitive to temperature and binds only colcemid. Like colchicine, 0.6 mol of colcemid are bound/mol of tubulin dimer (at the high-affinity site) and the reaction is entropy driven (163 J K-1 mol-1). Similar to colchicine, colcemid binding to tubulin is stimulated by certain anions (viz. sulfate and tartrate) but by a different mechanism. Colcemid binding affinity at the lower-affinity site of tubulin is increased in the presence of ammonium sulfate. Interestingly, the lower-affinity site on tubulin for colcemid, even when converted to higher affinity in presence of ammonium sulfate, is not recognized by colchicine. We conclude that tubulin possesses two binding sites, one of which specifically recognized the groups present on the B-ring of colchicine molecule and is effected by the ammonium sulfate, whereas the higher-affinity site, which could accommodate both colchicine and colcemid, possibly recognized the A and C ring of colchicine.     

Association of thiocolchicine with tubulin

Thiocolchicine, a colchicine analog in which the C-10 methoxy is replaced with a thiomethyl moiety, was shown to bind with high affinity to the colchicine site on tubulin (Ka = 1.07 +/- 0.14 x 10(6) M-1 at 23 degrees C). Like colchicine, the association kinetics were biphasic, and the rate constants of both phases were temperature dependent. The rate constant of the fast phase of the association was 4 times greater than the rate constant for colchicine binding, and the activation energy was lower (19.1 +/- 1.8 kcal/mol). X-ray crystallographic analysis shows that thiocolchicine displays greater puckering of the tropone C ring than colchicine (Koerntgen, C. and Margulis, T. N. (1977) J. Pharm. Sci. 66, 1127-1131.). These results indicate that the conformation of the C ring may have little effect on the energetics of colchicinoids binding to tubulin.     

-NH-dansyl isocolchicine exhibits a significantly improved tubulin-binding affinity and microtubule inhibition in comparison to isocolchicine by binding tubulin through its A and B rings

Structure-activity relationship studies have established that the A and C rings of colchicine comprise the minimum structural feature necessary for high affinity drug-tubulin binding. Thus, colchicine acts as a bifunctional ligand by making two points of attachment to the protein. Furthermore, analogues belonging to the iso series of colchicine are virtually inactive in binding to tubulin and inhibiting microtubule assembly. In the present study, we found that the substitution of a hydrophobic dansyl group on the B-ring side chain (C7 position) of isocolchicine reverses the structural alterations at the C ring and the newly synthesized -NH-dansyl isocolchicine restores the lost biological activity of the compound. It inhibits microtubule assembly efficiently with an IC(50) value of 10 microM and competes with [(3)H]colchicine for binding to tubulin. Moreover, although -NH-dansyl colchicine binding to tubulin involves two steps, the -NH-dansyl isocolchicine-tubulin interaction has been found to occur via a one-step process. Also, the affinity constant of the -NH-dansyl isocolchicine-tubulin interaction is roughly only 3 times lower than that of the -NH-dansyl colchicine-tubulin interaction. These results suggest that the enhanced microtubule inhibitory ability of -NH-dansyl isocolchicine is therefore related to the affinity of the drug-tubulin interaction and not to any conformational changes upon binding tubulin. We also observed that the competition of -NH-dansyl isocolchicine with [(3)H]colchicine for binding to tubulin was dependent on the tubulin concentration. In conclusion, this paper for the first time indicates that a biologically active bifuntional colchicine analogue can be designed where the drug binds tubulin through its A and B rings, while the C ring remains inactive.     

Novel Analogue of Colchicine Induces Selective Pro-Death Autophagy and Necrosis in Human Cancer Cells

Colchicine, a natural product of Colchicum autumnae currently used for gout treatment, is a tubulin targeting compound which inhibits microtubule formation by targeting fast dividing cells. This tubulin-targeting property has lead researchers to investigate the potential of colchicine and analogs as possible cancer therapies. One major study conducted on an analogue of allocolchicine, ZD 6126, was halted in phase 2 clinical trials due to severe cardio-toxicity associated with treatment. This study involves the development and testing of novel allocolchicine analogues that hold non-toxic anti-cancer properties. Currently we have synthesized and evaluated the anti-cancer activities of two analogues; N-acetyl-O-methylcolchinol (NSC 51046 or NCME), which is structurally similar to ZD 6126, and (S)-3,8,9,10-tetramethoxyallocolchicine (Green 1), which is a novel derivative of allocolchicine that is isomeric in the A ring. NSC 51046 was found to be non-selective as it induced apoptosis in both BxPC-3 and PANC-1 pancreatic cancer cells and in normal human fibroblasts. Interestingly, we found that Green 1 was able to modestly induce pro-death autophagy in these pancreatic cancer cells and E6-1 leukemia cells but not in normal human fibroblasts. Unlike colchicine and NSC 51046, Green 1 does not appear to affect tubulin polymerization indicating that it has a different molecular target. Green 1 also caused increased reactive oxygen species (ROS) production in mitochondria isolated from pancreatic cancer cells. Furthermore, in vivo studies revealed that Green 1 was well tolerated in mice. Our findings suggest that a small change in the structure of colchicine has apparently changed the mechanism of action and lead to improved selectivity. This may lead to better selective treatments in cancer therapy.     

The effects of colchicine analogues on the reaction of tubulin with iodo[14C]acetamide and N,N'-ethylenebis(iodoacetamide)

We have previously found (Ludue?a, R. F., and Roach, M. C. (1981b) Biochemistry 20, 4444-4450) that colchicine and podophyllotoxin inhibit the alkylation of tubulin by iodo[14C]acetamide and the formation of an intrachain cross-link in the beta-tubulin subunit by N,N'-ethylenebis(iodoacetamide) (EBI). It was not clear whether these effects were due to conformational changes in tubulin induced by drugs or to direct steric blockage of the sulfhydryl groups involved. In an effort to characterize further these phenomena, we have examined the effects of single-ring and bicyclic analogues of colchicine on the reaction of tubulin with iodo[14C]acetamide and EBI. We have found that neither the A-ring analogues, 3,4,5-trimethoxybenzyl alcohol, 3,4,5-trimethoxybenzaldehyde, 2,3,4-trimethoxybenzaldehyde, and benzaldehyde, nor the C-ring analogues, tropolone and tropolone methyl ether, inhibited alkylation. In contrast, colchicine, podophyllotoxin, and nocodazole and the bicyclic analogues, 5-(2',3',4'-trimethoxyphenyl)-2-methoxytropone and combretastatin, inhibited tubulin alkylation. Since the presence of a bond joining the A and C rings seems to be the determining factor in the suppression of alkylation, it is likely that inhibition by colchicine of the reaction with iodo[14C] acetamide is due largely to a conformational change induced by colchicine. A different pattern was obtained when the effects on cross-link formation by EBI were examined. Here, all the A-ring analogues, the bicyclic analogues, and colchicine, podophyllotoxin, and nocodazole all inhibited formation of the cross-link, whereas the C-ring analogue tropolone methyl ether did not inhibit cross-link formation. Since compounds whose effect on alkylation is markedly different have the same effect on cross-link formation, it is possible that this effect is a steric one and that perhaps the A-ring of colchicine binds to tubulin very close to one of the sulfhydryls involved in the intrachain cross-link formed by EBI in beta-tubulin.