Contribution of leucine 85 to the structure and function of Saccharomyces cerevisiae iso-1 cytochrome c.

Cytochrome c is a small electron-transport protein whose major role is to transfer electrons between complex III (cytochrome reductase) and complex IV (cytochrome c oxidase) in the inner mitochondrial membrane of eukaryotes. Cytochrome c is used as a model for the examination of protein folding and structure and for the study of biological electron-transport processes. Amongst 96 cytochrome c sequences, residue 85 is generally conserved as either isoleucine or leucine. Spatially, the side chain is associated closely with that of the invariant residue Phe82, and this interaction may be important for optimal cytochrome c activity. The functional role of residue 85 has been examined using six site-directed mutants of Saccharomyces cerevisiae iso-1 cytochrome c, including, for the first time, kinetic data for electron transfer with the principle physiological partners. Results indicate two likely roles for the residue: first, heme crevice resistance to ligand exchange, sensitive to both the hydrophobicity and volume of the side chain; second, modulation of electron-transport activity through maintenance of the hydrophobic character of the protein in the vicinity of Phe82 and the exposed heme edge, and possibly of the ability of this region to facilitate redox-linked conformational change.     

X-ray crystallography, CD and kinetic studies revealed the essence of the abnormal behaviors of the cytochrome b5 Phe35-->Tyr mutant.

Conserved phenylalanine 35 is one of the hydrophobic patch residues on the surface of cytochrome b5 (cyt b5). This patch is partially exposed on the surface of cyt b5 while its buried face is in direct van der Waals' contact with heme b. Residues Phe35 and Phe/Tyr74 also form an aromatic channel with His39, which is one of the axial ligands of heme b. By site-directed mutagenesis we have produced three mutants of cyt b5: Phe35-->Tyr, Phe35-->Leu, and Phe35-->His. We found that of these three mutants, the Phe35-->Tyr mutant displays abnormal properties. The redox potential of the Phe35-->Tyr mutant is 66 mV more negative than that of the wild-type cyt b5 and the oxidized Phe35-->Tyr mutant is more stable towards thermal and chemical denaturation than wild-type cyt b5. In this study we studied the most interesting mutant, Phe35-->Tyr, by X-ray crystallography, thermal denaturation, CD and kinetic studies of heme dissociation to explore the origin of its unusual behaviors. Analysis of crystal structure of the Phe35-->Tyr mutant shows that the overall structure of the mutant is basically the same as that of the wild-type protein. However, the introduction of a hydroxyl group in the heme pocket, and the increased van der Waals' and electrostatic interactions between the side chain of Tyr35 and the heme probably result in enhancement of stability of the Phe35-->Tyr mutant. The kinetic difference of the heme trapped by the heme pocket also supports this conclusion. The detailed conformational changes of the proteins in response to heat have been studied by CD for the first time, revealing the existence of the folding intermediate.     

A single mutation induces molten globule formation and a drastic destabilization of wild-type cytochrome c at pH 6.0

Amino acid sequences of seven subfamilies of cytochromes c show that other than heme binding residues there are only four positions which are conserved in all subfamilies: Gly/Ala6, Phe/Tyr10, Leu/Val/Phe94, and Tyr/Trp/Phe97. These residues are 90% conserved in all sequences reported and are also considered to be involved in a common folding nucleus. To determine the importance of conserved interactions offered by the side chain of Leu94, we made an L94G mutant of horse cytochrome c. Characterization of this mutant by the far-UV, near-UV, and Soret circular dichroism, intrinsic and 1-Anilino-8-naphthalene sulfonate fluorescence, and dynamic light scattering measurements led to the conclusion that the L94G mutant has all the common structural characteristics of a molten globule at pH 6.0 and 25 °C. NaCl induces a cooperative transition between the acid-denatured state and a state of L94G having all the common structural characteristics of a pre-molten-globule state at pH 2 and 25 °C. Thermal denaturation studies showed that the midpoint of denaturation of the mutant is 28 °C less than that of the wild-type protein. Interestingly, the structure analysis using the coordinates given in the Protein Data Bank (1hrc) also suggested that the L94G mutant would be less stable than the wild-type protein.     

Crystal structures of leucyl/phenylalanyl-tRNA-protein transferase and its complex with an aminoacyl-tRNA analog

Eubacterial leucyl/phenylalanyl-tRNA protein transferase (L/F-transferase), encoded by the aat gene, conjugates leucine or phenylalanine to the N-terminal Arg or Lys residue of proteins, using Leu-tRNA(Leu) or Phe-tRNA(Phe) as a substrate. The resulting N-terminal Leu or Phe acts as a degradation signal for the ClpS-ClpAP-mediated N-end rule protein degradation pathway. Here, we present the crystal structures of Escherichia coli L/F-transferase and its complex with an aminoacyl-tRNA analog, puromycin. The C-terminal domain of L/F-transferase consists of the GCN5-related N-acetyltransferase fold, commonly observed in the acetyltransferase superfamily. The p-methoxybenzyl group of puromycin, corresponding to the side chain of Leu or Phe of Leu-tRNA(Leu) or Phe-tRNA(Phe), is accommodated in a highly hydrophobic pocket, with a shape and size suitable for hydrophobic amino-acid residues lacking a branched beta-carbon, such as leucine and phenylalanine. Structure-based mutagenesis of L/F-transferase revealed its substrate specificity. Furthermore, we present a model of the L/F-transferase complex with tRNA and substrate proteins bearing an N-terminal Arg or Lys.     

Structural basis of neurophysin hormone specificity: Geometry, polarity, and polarizability in aromatic ring interactions

The structural origins of the specificity of the neurophysin hormone-binding site for an aromatic residue in peptide position 2 were explored by analyzing the binding of a series of peptides in the context of the crystal structure of liganded neurophysin. A new modeling method for describing the van der Waals surface of binding sites assisted in the analysis. Particular attention was paid to the unusually large (5 kcal/mol) difference in binding free energy between Phe and Leu in position 2, a value representing more than three times the maximum expected based on hydrophobicity alone, and additionally remarkable since modeling indicated that the Leu side chain was readily accommodated by the binding pocket. Although evidence was obtained of a weak thermodynamic linkage between the binding interactions of the residue 2 side chain and of the peptide alpha-amino group, two factors are considered central. (1) The bound Leu side chain can establish only one-third of the van der Waals contacts available to a Phe side chain. (2) The bound Phe side chain appears to be additionally stabilized relative to Leu by more favorable dipole and induced dipole interactions with nonaromatic polar and sulfur ligands in the binding pocket, as evidenced by examination of its interactions in the pocket, analysis of the detailed energetics of transfer of Phe and Leu side chains from water to other phases, and comparison with thermodynamic and structural data for the binding of residue 1 side chains in this system. While such polar interactions of aromatic rings have been previously observed, the present results suggest their potential for significant thermodynamic contributions to protein structure and ligand recognition.     

On the unyielding hydrophobic core of villin headpiece

Villin headpiece (HP67) is a small, autonomously-folding domain that has become a model system for understanding the fundamental tenets governing protein folding. In this communication, we explore the role that Leu61 plays in the structure and stability of the construct. Deletion of Leu61 results in a completely unfolded protein that cannot be expressed in Escherichia coli. Omission of only the aliphatic leucine side chain (HP67 L61G) perturbed neither the backbone conformation nor the orientation of local hydrophobic side chains. As a result, a large, solvent-exposed hydrophobic pocket, a negative replica of the leucine side-chain, was created on the surface. The loss of the hydrophobic interface between leucine 61 and the hydrophobic pocket destabilized the construct by ~3.3 kcal/mol. Insertion of a single glycine residue immediately before Leu61 (HP67 L61[GL]) was also highly destabilizing and had the effect of altering the backbone conformation (α-helix to π-helix) in order to precisely preserve the wild-type position and conformation of all hydrophobic residues, including Leu61. In addition to demonstrating that the hydrophobic side-chain of Leu61 is critically important for the stability of villin headpiece, our results are consistent with the notion that the precise interactions present within the hydrophobic core, rather than the hydrogen bonds that define the secondary structure, specify a protein's fold.     

A cooperative oxygen binding hemoglobin from Mycobacterium tuberculosis. Stabilization of heme ligands by a distal tyrosine residue

The homodimeric hemoglobin (HbN) from Mycobacterium tuberculosis displays an extremely high oxygen binding affinity and cooperativity. Sequence alignment with other hemoglobins suggests that the proximal F8 ligand is histidine, the distal E7 residue is leucine, and the B10 position is occupied by tyrosine. To determine how these heme pocket residues regulate the ligand binding affinities and physiological functions of HbN, we have measured the resonance Raman spectra of the O(2), CO, and OH(-) derivatives of the wild type protein and the B10 Tyr --> Leu and Phe mutants. Taken together these data demonstrate a unique distal environment in which the heme bound ligands strongly interact with the B10 tyrosine residue. The implications of these data on the physiological functions of HbN and another heme-containing protein, cytochrome c oxidase, are considered.     

The structure and function of omega loop A replacements in cytochrome c.

The structural and functional consequences of replacing omega-loop A (residues 18-32) in yeast iso-1-cytochrome c with the corresponding loop of Rhodospirillum rubrum cytochrome c2 have been examined. The three-dimensional structure of this loop replacement mutant RepA2 cytochrome c, and a second mutant RepA2(Val 20) cytochrome c in which residue 20 was back substituted to valine, were determined using X-ray diffraction techniques. A change in the molecular packing is evident in the RepA2 mutant protein, which has a phenylalanine at position 20, a residue considerably larger than the valine found in wild-type yeast iso-1-cytochrome c. The side chain of Phe 20 is redirected toward the molecular surface, altering the packing of this region of omega-loop A with the hydrophobic core of the protein. In the RepA2(Val 20) structure, omega-loop A contains a valine at position 20, which restores the original wild-type packing arrangement of the hydrophobic core. Also, as a result of omega-loop A replacement, residue 26 is changed from a histidine to asparagine, which results in displacements of the main-chain atoms near residue 44 to which residue 26 is hydrogen bonded. In vivo studies of the growth rate of the mutant strains on nonfermentable media indicate that the RepA2(Val 20) cytochrome c behaves much like the wild-type yeast iso-1 protein, whereas the stability and function of the RepA2 cytochrome c showed a temperature dependence. The midpoint reduction potential measured by cyclic voltammetry of the RepA2 mutant is 271 mV at 25 degrees C. This is 19 mV less than the wild-type and RepA2(Val 20) proteins (290 mV) and may result from disruption of the hydrophobic packing in the heme pocket and increased mobility of omega-loop A in RepA2 cytochrome c. The temperature dependence of the reduction potential is also greatly enhanced in the RepA2 protein.     

Waterproofing the heme pocket. Role of proximal amino acid side chains in preventing hemin loss from myoglobin

The ability of myoglobin to bind oxygen reversibly depends critically on retention of the heme prosthetic group. Globin side chains at the Leu(89)(F4), His(97)(FG3), Ile(99)(FG5), and Leu(104)(G5) positions on the proximal side of the heme pocket strongly influence heme affinity. The roles of these amino acids in preventing heme loss have been examined by determining high resolution structures of 14 different mutants at these positions using x-ray crystallography. Leu(89) and His(97) are important surface amino acids that interact either sterically or electrostatically with the edges of the porphyrin ring. Ile(99) and Leu(104) are located in the interior region of the proximal pocket beneath ring C of the heme prosthetic group. The apolar amino acids Leu(89), Ile(99), and Leu(104) "waterproof" the heme pocket by forming a barrier to solvent penetration, minimizing the size of the proximal cavity, and maintaining a hydrophobic environment. Substitutions with smaller or polar side chains at these positions result in exposure of the heme to solvent, the appearance of crystallographically defined water molecules in or near the proximal pocket, and large increases in the rate of hemin loss. Thus, the naturally occurring amino acid side chains at these positions serve to prevent hydration of the His(93)-Fe(III) bond and are highly conserved in all known myoglobins and hemoglobins.     

A polypeptide chain-refolding event occurs in the Gly82 variant of yeast iso-1-cytochrome c

The replacement of Phe82 in yeast iso-1-cytochrome c by a glycine residue substantially alters both the tertiary structure and electron transfer properties of this protein. The largest structural change involves a polypeptide chain refolding of residues 79 through 85. Refolding places glycines 82, 83 and 84 immediately adjacent to the plane of the heme group in a spatial positioning comparable to that of the phenyl ring of Phe82 in the wild-type protein. Despite this perturbation in structure, solvent accessibility computations show that heme solvent exposure has not increased in the Gly82 variant protein. However, refolding does result in the introduction of a number of polar groups into the hydrophobic heme pocket. This appears to be responsible for the decreased reduction potential of the heme in this protein. The present study, along with that of the Ser82 variant protein (Louie et al., 1988b), clearly establishes the link between dielectric constant within the heme crevice and reduction potential. The further anomalously low electron transfer activity of the Gly82 variant protein would appear to arise from two factors. First, the polypeptide chain medium now adjacent to the heme is unable to facilitate electron transfer in a manner similar to that of the aromatic side-chain of Phe82. Second, polypeptide chain refolding significantly alters the surface contour of the Gly82 protein rendering it less suitable to interact with the corresponding complementary surfaces of redox partners. Our data support the conclusion that Phe82 plays a number of roles in the electron transfer process mediated by yeast iso-1-cytochrome c. These include the maintenance of the heme environment, provision of an optimal medium along the path of electron transfer and formation of interactions at the contact interface in complexes with redox partners.     

Reactivity of manganese peroxidase: site-directed mutagenesis of residues in proximity to the porphyrin ring

The purpose of this study was to determine the effect of heme pocket hydrophobicity on the reactivity of manganese peroxidase. Residues within 5 A of the heme active site were identified. From this group, Leu169 and Ser172 were selected and mutated to Phe and Ala, respectively. The mutant proteins were then characterized by steady-state kinetics. Whereas the Leu169Phe mutation had little, if any, effect on activity, the Ser172Ala mutation decreased kcat and also the specificity constant (kcat/Km) for Mn2+, but not H2O2. Transient-state studies indicated that the mutation affected only the reactions of compound II. These results indicate that compound II is the most sensitive to changes in the heme environment.     

Thermophilic cytochrome P450 (CYP119) from Sulfolobus solfataricus: high resolution structure and functional properties

Crystal structures of a thermostable cytochrome P450 (CYP119) and a site-directed mutant, (Phe24Leu), from the acidothermophilic archaea Sulfolobus solfataricus were determined at 1.5-2.0 A resolution. We identify important crystallographic waters in the ferric heme pocket, observe protein conformational changes upon inhibitor binding, and detect a unique distribution of surface charge not found in other P450s. An analysis of factors contributing to thermostability of CYP119 of these high resolution structures shows an apparent increase in clustering of aromatic residues and optimum stacking. The contribution of aromatic stacking was investigated further with the mutant crystal structure and differential scanning calorimetry.     

Roles of the heme proximal side residues tryptophan409 and tryptophan421 of neuronal nitric oxide synthase in the electron transfer reaction

Nitric oxide synthase (NOS) has an oxygenase domain with a thiol-coordinated heme active side similar to cytochrome P450. In contrast to cytochrome P450, however, conserved aromatic amino acids are situated in the heme proximal side of NOS. For example, in endothelial NOS (eNOS), the indole-ring nitrogen of Trp180 hydrogen-binds to the thiol of Cys186, the internal axial ligand to the heme. And, the aromatic side chain of Trp192 forms a bridge between this residue and the protein. Trp180 and Trp192 of eNOS correspond to Trp409 and Trp421 of neuronal NOS (nNOS), respectively. In order to understand the roles of the aromatic amino acids in catalysis, we generated Trp409His, Trp409Leu, Trp421His and Trp421Leu mutants of nNOS and determined their catalytic parameters. The Trp409Leu mutant was very poorly expressed in E. coli and was easily denatured during purification procedures. The NO formation activities of the Trp409His and Trp421Leu mutants were 11 and 25 micromol/min per micromol heme, respectively, and are lower than that (44 micromol/min per micromol heme) of the wild type. The activity (46 micromol/min per micromol heme) of the Trp421His mutant was comparable to that of the wild-type enzyme. However, NADPH oxidation rates of Trp421His (230 micromol/min per micromol heme) and Trp421Leu (104 micromol/min per microol heme) in the presence of L-Arg were much larger than those observed for the wild type (65 micromol/min per micromol heme) and the Trp409His mutant (43 micromol/min per micromol heme). The cytochrome c reduction rate of the Trp421His mutant was 6-fold larger than that of the wild type. The heme reduction rate with NADPH for the Trp421His mutant (0.09 min(-1)) was much lower than that (1.0 min(-1)) of the wild type. Taken together, it appears that Trp421 may be involved in inter-domain/inter-subunit electron transfer reactions.     

The loss in hydrophobic surface area resulting from a Leu to Val mutation at the N-terminus of the aldehyde dehydrogenase presequence prevents import of the protein into mitochondria

An apparent conservative mutation, Leu to Val, at the second residue of the rat liver mitochondrial aldehyde dehydrogenase (ALDH) presequence resulted in a precursor protein that was not imported into mitochondria. Additional mutants were made to substitute various amino acids with nonpolar side chains for Leu2. The Ile, Phe, and Trp mutants were imported to an extent similar to that of the native precursor, but the Ala mutant was imported only about one-fourth as well. It was shown that the N-terminal methionine was removed from the L2V mutant in a reaction catalyzed by methionine aminopeptidase. The N-terminal methionine of native pALDH and the other mutant presequences was blocked, presumably by acetylation. Because of the difference in co-translational modification, the L2V mutant sustained a significant loss in the available hydrophobic surface of the presequence. Import competence was restored to the L2V mutant when it was translated using a system that did not remove Met1. The removal of an Arg-Gly-Pro helix linker segment (residues 11-14) from the L2V mutant, which shifted three leucine residues toward the N-terminus, also restored import competence. These results lead to the conclusion that a minimum amount of hydrophobic surface area near the N-termini of mitochondrial presequences is an essential property to determine their ability to be imported. As a result, both electrostatic and hydrophobic components must be considered when trying to understand the interactions between precursor proteins and proteins of the mitochondrial import apparatus.     

Substituting leucine for alanine-86 in the tether region of the iron-sulfur protein of the cytochrome bc1 complex affects the mobility of the [2Fe2S] domain

Mutating three conserved alanine residues in the tether region of the iron-sulfur protein of the yeast cytochrome bc(1) complex resulted in 22-56% decreases in enzymatic activity [Obungu et al. (2000) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1457, 36-44]. The activity of the cytochrome bc(1) complex isolated from A86L was decreased 60% compared to the wild-type without loss of heme or protein and without changes in the 2Fe2S cluster or proton-pumping ability. The activity of the bc(1) complex from mutant A92R was identical to the wild-type, while loss of both heme and activity was observed in the bc(1) complex isolated from mutant A90I. Computer simulations indicated that neither mutation A86L nor mutation A92R affects the alpha-helical backbone in the tether region; however, the side chain of the leucine substituted for Ala-86 interacts with the side chain of Leu-89. The Arrhenius plot for mutant A86L was apparently biphasic with a transition observed at 17-19 degrees C and an activation energy of 279.9 kJ/mol below 17 degrees C and 125.1 kJ/mol above 17 degrees C. The initial rate of cytochrome c(1) reduction was lowered 33% in mutant A86L; however, the initial rate of cytochrome b reduction was unaffected, suggesting that movement of the tether region of the iron-sulfur protein is necessary for maximum rates of enzymatic activity. Substituting a leucine for Ala-86 impedes the unwinding of the alpha-helix and hence movement of the tether.     

Identification of the ligands to the ferric heme of Chlamydomonas chloroplast hemoglobin: evidence for ligation of tyrosine-63 (B10) to the heme

We have studied the unusual heme ligand structure of the ferric forms of a recombinant Chlamydomonas chloroplast hemoglobin and its several single-amino acid mutants by EPR, optical absorbance, and resonance Raman spectroscopy. The helical positions of glutamine-84, tyrosine-63, and lysine-87 are suggested to correspond to E7, B10, and E10, respectively, in the distal heme pocket on the basis of amino acid sequence comparison of mammalian globins. The protein undergoes a transition with a pK of 6.3 from a six-coordinate high-spin aquomet form at acidic pH to a six-coordinate low-spin form. The EPR signal of the low-spin form for the wild-type protein is absent for the Tyr63Leu mutant, suggesting that the B10 tyrosine in the wild-type protein ligates to the heme as tyrosinate. For the Tyr63Leu mutant, a new low-spin signal resembling that of alkaline cytochrome c (a His-heme-Lys species) is resolved, suggesting that the E10 lysine now coordinates to the heme. In the wild-type protein, the oxygen of the tyrosine-63 side chain is likely to share a proton with the side chain of lysine-87, suggested by the observation of a H/D sensitive resonance Raman line at 502 cm(-)(1) that is tentatively assigned as a vibrational mode of the Fe-O bond between the iron and the tyrosinate. We propose that the transition from the high-spin to the low-spin form of the protein occurs by deprotonation and ligation to the heme of the B10 tyrosine oxygen, facilitated by strong interaction with the E10 lysine side chain.     

Fine-tuning of the binding and dissociation of CO by the amino acids of the heme pocket of Coprinus cinereus peroxidase

Resonance Raman and infrared spectra and the CO dissociation rates (k(off)) were measured in Coprinus cinereus peroxidase (CIP) and several mutants in the heme binding pocket. These mutants included the Asp245Asn, Arg51Leu, Arg51Gln, Arg51Asn, Arg51Lys, Phe54Trp, and Phe54Val mutants. Binding of CO to CIP produced different CO adducts at pH 6 and 10. At pH 6, the bound CO is H-bonded to the protonated distal His55 residue, whereas at alkaline pH, the vibrational signatures and the rate of CO dissociation indicate a distal side which is more open or flexible than in other plant peroxidases. The distal Arg51 residue is important in determining the rate of dissociation in the acid form, increasing by 8-17-fold in the Arg51 mutants compared to that for the wild-type protein. Replacement of the distal Phe with Trp created a new acid form characterized by vibrational frequencies and k(off) values very similar to those of cytochrome c peroxidase.     

Hydrophobic core repacking and aromatic-aromatic interaction in the thermostable mutant of T4 lysozyme Ser 117-->Phe.

The T4 lysozyme mutant Ser 117-->Phe was isolated fortuitously and found to be more thermostable than wild-type by 1.1-1.4 kcal/mol. In the wild-type structure, the side chain of Ser 117 is in a sterically restricted region near the protein surface and forms a short hydrogen bond with Asn 132. The crystal structure of the S117F mutant shows that the introduced Phe side chain rotates by about 150 degrees about the C alpha-C beta bond relative to wild type and is buried in the hydrophobic core of the protein. Burial of Phe 117 is accommodated by rearrangements of the surrounding side chains of Leu 121, Leu 133, and Phe 153 and by main-chain shifts, which result in a minimal increase in packing density. The benzyl rings of Phe 117 and Phe 153 form a near-optimal edge-face interaction in the mutant structure. This aromatic-aromatic interaction, as well as increased hydrophobic stabilization and elimination of a close contact in the wild-type protein, apparently compensate for the loss of a hydrogen bond and the possible cost of structural rearrangements in the mutant. The structure illustrates the ability of a protein to accommodate a surprisingly large structural change in a manner that actually increases thermal stability. The mutant has activity about 10% that of wild-type, supportive of the prior hypothesis (Grütter, M.G. & Matthews, B.W., 1982, J. Mol. Biol. 154, 525-535) that the peptidoglycan substrate of T4 lysozyme makes extended contacts with the C-terminal domain in the vicinity of Ser 117.     

Resilience of Rhodobacter sphaeroides cytochrome bc1 to heme c1 ligation changes

Typically, c hemes are bound to the protein through two thioether bonds to cysteines and two axial ligands to the heme iron. In high-potential class I c-type cytochromes, these axial ligands are commonly His-Met. A change in this methionine axial ligand is often correlated with a dramatic drop in the heme redox potential and loss of function. Here we describe a bacterial cytochrome c with an unusual tolerance to the alternations in the heme ligation pattern. Substitution of the heme ligating methionine (M185) in cytochrome c1 of the Rhodobacter sphaeroides cytochrome bc1 complex with Lys and Leu lowers the redox midpoint potential but not enough to prevent physiologically competent electron transfer in these fully functional variants. Only when Met-185 is replaced with His is the drop in the redox potential sufficiently large to cause cytochrome bc1 electron transfer chain failure. Functional mutants preserve the structural integrity of the heme crevice: only the nonfunctional His variant allows carbon monoxide to bind to reduced heme, indicating a significant opening of the heme environment. This range of cytochrome c1 ligand mutants exposes both the relative resilience to sixth axial ligand change and the ultimate thermodynamic limits of operation of the cofactor chains in cytochrome bc1.     

Residue F4 plays a key role in modulating oxygen affinity and cooperativity in Scapharca dimeric hemoglobin

Residue F4 (Phe 97) undergoes the most dramatic ligand-linked transition in Scapharca dimeric hemoglobin, with its packing in the heme pocket in the unliganded (T) state suggested to be a primary determinant of its low affinity. Mutation of Phe 97 to Leu (previously reported), Val, and Tyr increases oxygen affinity from 8- to 100-fold over that of the wild type. The crystal structures of F97L and F97V show side chain packing in the heme pocket for both R and T state structures. In contrast, in the highest-affinity mutation, F97Y, the tyrosine side chain remains in the interface (high-affinity conformation) even in the unliganded state. Comparison of these mutations reveals a correlation between side chain packing in the heme pocket and oxygen affinity, indicating that greater mass in the heme pocket lowers oxygen affinity due to impaired movement of the heme iron into the heme plane. The results indicate that a key hydrogen bond, previously hypothesized to have a central role in regulation of oxygen affinity, plays at most only a small role in dictating ligand affinity. Equivalent mutations in sperm whale myoglobin alter ligand affinity by only 5-fold. The dramatically different responses to mutations at the F4 position result from subtle, but functionally critical, stereochemical differences. In myoglobin, an eclipsed orientation of the proximal His relative to the A and C pyrrole nitrogen atoms provides a significant barrier for high-affinity ligand binding. In contrast, the staggered orientation of the proximal histidine found in liganded HbI renders its ligand affinity much more susceptible to packing contacts between F4 and the heme group. These results highlight very different strategies used by cooperative hemoglobins in molluscs and mammals to control ligand affinity by modulation of the stereochemistry on the proximal side of the heme.