Habitat selection as a hierarchy: the spatial scales of winter foraging by muskoxen

We studied the winter resource selection of muskoxen Ovibos moschatus in the High Arctic using a nested hierarchy of spatial scales 1) population range, 2) travel routes, 3) feeding sites (l e clusters of feeding craters), 4) feeding craters, and 5) diet (I e plant species) We found that, generally, patterns of selection remained consistent across all levels At successively smaller scales, muskoxen selected for higher graminoid abundance and particularly for thinner, softer snow cover, although we did not reject the hypothesis of random travel route selection Muskoxen uncovered forages from beneath the snow cover, by cratering, near the flonstic and nival extremes of availability Selection was consistently biased toward use of water sedge, Carex aquatilis As scale changed, however, muskoxen showed reversals of preference for some other forage species Diet was dominated by C aquatilis and cotton sedge, Eriophorum angustifolium , species characteristic of lowland meadows During spring melt, muskoxen moved to snow-free uplands to feed Dietary quality, as revealed by fecal nitrogen, increased at this time The consistency of the results across scales implied that these local levels of habitat selection occurred within one scaling domain     

The importance of scale of patchiness for selectivity in grazing herbivores

The notion that spatial scale is an important determinant of foraging selectivity and habitat utilization has only recently been recognized. We predicted and tested the effects of scale of patchiness on movements and selectivity of a large grazer in a controlled field experiment. We created random mosaics of short/high-quality and tall/low-quality grass patches in equal proportion at grid sizes of 2×2 m and 5×5 m. Subsequently, we monitored the foraging behaviour of four steers in 16 20×40 m plots over 30-min periods. As predicted on the basis of nutrient intake maximization, the animals selected the short patches, both by walking in a non-random manner and by additional selectivity for feeding stations. The tortuosity of foraging paths was similar at both scales of patchiness but selectivity was more pronounced in large patches than in small ones. In contrast, the number of bites per feeding station was not affected by patch size, suggesting that selection between and within feeding stations are essentially different processes. Mean residence time at individual feeding stations could not be successfully predicted on the basis of the marginal-value theorem: the animals stayed longer than expected, especially in the less profitable patch type. The distribution of the number of bites per feeding station suggests a constant probability to stay to feed or to move on to the next feeding station. This implies that the animals do not treat larger patches as discrete feeding stations but rather as a continuous resource. Our results have important implications for the application of optimal foraging theory in patchy environments. We conclude that selectivity in grazers is facilitated by large-scale heterogeneity, particularly by enhancing discrimination between feeding stations and larger selection units. Received: 1 March 1999 / Accepted: 14 July 1999     

Foraging dynamics of muskoxen in Peary Land, northern Greenland

Muskoxen Ovibos moschatus in northern Greenland (79-83°N) are at the northern limit of their distribution and exist under seasonal extremes dominated by nearly 10 months of winter, much of which is without sunlight. The period of summer vegetative growth is less than two months. In the Kap København area (82°30'N), diversity of plant species is low (76 species of vascular plants) and forage biomass in major vegetation types in summer varies from over 40 g m^-2 in sedge-dominated fens to ≤5 g m^-2 in polar barrens. Nonetheless, 90-95% of the ice-free area consists of barren ground or sparcely vegetated polar desert. During summer, muskoxen apparently foraged opportunistically to maximize intake, with sedges the major food item in fens while willows were the major dietary component when on willow-dominated slopes. Quality of summer forage was high during its early phenological stages, with 21-28% crude protein and 60-75% in vitro digestibility. Microhistological analysis of winter feces indicated dominance by graminoids. Muskoxen spent > 50% of their daily activity feeding, which fits a cline of increasing feeding time with increasing latitude in summer. Increased feeding times at high latitudes appears to be a function of both reduced forage biomass and need to maximize forage intake during the brief summer period when forage quality is high. Movement rates in summer while foraging were inversely related to available forage biomass. Seasonal activity of muskoxen peaks during the rutting period (July-September) and then declines gradually through early winter to a low in late winter (March-April).     

Could a big gut be too costly for muskoxen (Ovibos moschatus) in their first winter?

Young mammalian herbivores are more vulnerable to harsh winter conditions than adults, especially among large circumpolar species like the muskox (Ovibos moschatus). We compared feeding responses of muskox calves (body mass 95 kg) with those of mature, non-reproductive females (body mass 227 kg) in mid-winter when air temperatures fell to -40 degrees C. Food intakes (1.8-2.2 kg digestible dry matter (DM)d(-1)), digesta fill (27-32 kg wet mass) and digestibility of hay (52-58% of DM; 49-55% of gross energy) were similar between age groups even though calves were much smaller than adults. Calves fed more frequently (12 vs. 8 feeding bouts per day) and thus spent more time feeding each day than adults (387 vs. 343 min per day). High mass-specific food intakes of calves indicate higher requirements for maintenance of body tissue than adults, which could be related to a larger intestinal tract in young muskoxen. Notably, cows and calves maintained a constant body mass throughout, indicating that they were feeding at maintenance levels and that the relatively higher intakes of calves were not related to growth. Together, these data suggest that limited food availability due to snow cover or high animal density may reduce the survival of muskoxen in their first winter.     

Seasonal and interannual variations in feeding station behavior of cattle: effects of sward and meteorological conditions

A feeding station is the area of forage a grazing animal can reach without moving its forefeet. Grazing behavior can be divided into residence within feeding stations (with bites as benefits) and movement between feeding stations (with steps as costs). However, relatively little information has been reported on how grazing animals modify their feeding station behavior seasonally and interannually in response to varying environmental conditions. The feeding station behavior of beef cows (Japanese Black) stocked on a tropical grass pasture (bahiagrass dominant) was monitored for 4 years (2010 to 2013) in order to investigate the association of feeding station behavior with meteorological and sward conditions across the seasons and years. Mean air temperature during stocking often exceeded 30°C during summer months. A severe summer drought in 2013 decreased herbage mass and sward height of the pasture and increased nitrogen concentration of herbage from summer to autumn. A markedly high feeding station number per unit foraging time, low bite numbers per feeding station and a low bite rate were observed in summer 2013 compared with the other seasons and years. Bite number per feeding station was explained by a multiple regression equation, where sward height and dry matter digestibility of herbage had a positive effect, whereas air temperature during stocking had a negative effect (R²=0.658, P<0.01). Feeding station number per minute was negatively correlated with bite number per feeding station (r=–0.838, P<0.001). It was interpreted that cows modified bite number per feeding station in response to the sward and meteorological conditions, and this largely determined the number of feeding stations the animals visited per minute. The results indicate potential value of bite number per feeding station as an indicator of daily intake in grazing animals, and an opportunity for livestock and pasture managers to control feeding station behavior of animals through managements (e.g. fertilizer application, manipulation of stocking intensity and stocking time within the day).     

Optimal grazing of wapiti (Cervus elaphus) on grassland: Patch and feeding station departure rules

Summary We studied factors which may shape giving-up decisions of wapiti grazing grassland patches (area where a wapiti initiates and terminates a feeding sequence) and feeding stations (area within a patch that a wapiti can reach without moving its forelegs). In grassland patches, cropping rate decreased after a critical period, whereas at feeding stations cropping rate increased with cumulative bites consumed. The number of feeding stations grazed, number of bites taken and grazing time did not dictate the termination of grazing in a patch. Wapiti gave up a patch only after the cropping rate at a feeding station dropped below the seasonal expectation during trials on lush pasture in May, but gave up after the cropping rate dropped below the seasonal expectation at two consecutive feeding stations in March/April and August when foraging conditions were less favourable. This confirmed a prediction of the marginal value theorem. Wapiti did not give up a feeding station according to bites taken, grazing time or cropping rate, but they left feeding stations when their lateral neck angle reached a critical point suggesting a biokinetic explanation. Leaving feeding stations when ungrazed forage can no longer be reached and patches when intake rate drops both appeared to be rules used by wapiti grazing grasslands of the boreal mixed wood forest.     

Foraging across a variable landscape: behavioral decisions made by woodland caribou at multiple spatial scales

We examined the foraging behavior of woodland caribou (Rangifer tarandus caribou) relative to the spatial and temporal heterogeneity of their environment. We assessed (1) whether caribou altered their behavior over time while making trade-offs between forage abundance and accessibility; and (2) whether foraging decisions were consistent across spatial scales (i.e., as scale increased, similar decision criteria were used at each scale). We discuss whether caribou adjusted their behavior to take advantage of changing forage availability through time and space. At the scale of the feeding site (as revealed by discriminant function analyses), caribou in both forested and alpine (above tree-line) environments selected sites where the biomass of particular lichen species was greatest and snow the least deep. Caribou did not select those species with the highest nutritional value (i.e., digestible protein and energy) in either area. Where snow depth, density, and hardness limited access to terrestrial lichens in the forest, caribou foraged instead at those trees with the greatest amount of arboreal lichen. Selection of lichen species and the influence of snow differed across time, indicating that in this system the abundance or accessibility of forage temporally influenced foraging behavior. A path analysis of forest data and multiple regression analysis of alpine data were used to test the hypothesis that variables important at the scale of the feeding site explained foraging effort at the scale of the patch. For forest patches, our hypothesized model reliably explained foraging effort, but not all variables that were statistically important at the scale of the feeding site were significant predictors at the scale of the patch. For alpine patches, our hypothesized model did not explain a statistically significant portion of the variation in the number of feeding sites within the patch, and none of the individual variables from the feeding site remained statistically significant at the patch scale. The incongruity between those variables important at the scale of the feeding site and those important at the patch showed that spatial scale affects the foraging decisions of woodland caribou. At the scale of the landscape, there was a trade-off between forage abundance and accessibility. Relative to the alpine environment, caribou in the forest foraged at feeding sites and patches with greater amounts of less variably distributed lichen, but deeper less variable snow depths. Considering the behavioral plasticity of woodland caribou, there may be no distinct advantage to foraging in one landscape over the other.     

Ecology of muskoxen in Jameson Land, northeast Greenland

Muskoxen Ovibos moschatus in Jameson Land exist at a density of somewhat more than 1 km⁻² of useable habitat and select moist meadows and snow bed vegetation for summer grazing and wind-exposed, dry dwarf shrub heath vegetation in winter. Graminoids dominate the winter diet and willows are the main component of the summer diet. Quality of the winter diet, as measured by the protein to fiber ratio is about one fourth that of the summer diet. During summer muskoxen supplement dietary sodium by using mineral licks. Muskoxen, especially females, retain considerable unused fat reserves through the winter and these are drawn upon during the post-calving period of lactation. Alternate year breeding is a common occurrence. Calves are frequently not weaned before the end of their first winter. Mean calf mortality is relatively low in the absence of significant predation and annual removal by hunting Inuits approaches the annual increment.     

Surface enlargement in the rumen of free-ranging muskoxen (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Ovibos moschatus</Emphasis>)

The intraruminal papillation pattern indicates the degree of rumen contents stratification and is related to the feeding niche of a ruminant. Muskoxen (Ovibos moschatus) display a variety of morphophysiological adaptations typical for grazers. We investigated the intraruminal papillation of 22 free-ranging muskoxen from five different months by comparing the surface enlargement factor both between seasons and between individual rumen regions. The seasonal pattern of rumen papillation indicated a distinct seasonality in food quality. The intraruminal papillation indicated a moderate degree of rumen contents stratification typical for intermediate feeders. The nutritional ecology of muskoxen is characterised by specific morphophysiological adaptations to a grass-dominated diet that nevertheless allow extensive seasonal use of browse forage.     

Influence of size and density of browse patches on intake rates and foraging decisions of young moose and white-tailed deer

We examined the functional response and foraging behavior of young moose (Alces alces) and white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus) relative to animal size and the size and distribution of browse patches. The animals were offered one, three, or nine stems of dormant red maple (Acer rubrum) in hand-assembled patches spaced 2.33, 7, 14, or 21 m apart along a runway. Moose took larger twig diameters and bites and had greater dry matter and digestible energy intake rates than did deer, but had lower cropping rates. Moose and deer travelled at similar velocities between patches and took similar numbers of bites per stem. We found that a model of intake rate, based on the mechanics of cropping, chewing, and encountering bites, effectively described the intake rate of moose and deer feeding in heterogeneous distributions of browses. As patch size and density declined, the animals walked faster between patches, cropped larger bites, and cropped more bites per stem, and hence, dry matter intake rates remained relatively constant. As is characteristic of many hardwood browse stems, however, potential digestible energy concentration of the red maple stems declined as the size and number of bites removed (i.e., stem diameter at point of clipping) by the animals increased. Therefore, the digestible energy content of the diet declined with decreasing patch size and density. Time spent foraging within a patch increased as patch size increased and as distance between patches increased, which qualitatively supported the marginal-value theorem. However, actual patch residence times for deer and moose exceeded those predicted by the marginal-value theorem (MVT) by approximately 250%. The difference between actual and predicted residence time may have been a result of (1) an unknown or complex gain function, (2) the artificial conditions of the experiments, or (3) assumptions of MVT that do not apply to herbivores.     

Taste agents as modulators of the feeding behaviour of grazing yaks in alpine meadows

Feeding behaviour plays a significant role in promoting good animal health and welfare. It is also reflective of the quality and quantity of available feed. In fact, grazing livestock do not select their feed randomly, rather their behaviour is influenced by the texture, taste, and smell of each pasture species. Although taste agents are often used to modify feed intake for captive livestock, the effect on the feeding behaviour of grazing livestock has not yet been extensively evaluated in native grasslands. To address this gap in knowledge, herein, we sprayed three types of taste agents—salty (SA), sweet (SW), and bitter (BT)—on alpine meadows to investigate their effect on the grazing behaviour of yaks (Bos Grunniens) on the Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau (QTP). Behavioural observations showed that grazing was concentrated primarily in the morning and afternoon, while ruminating/resting peaked at noon; however, the diurnal behavioural patterns of grazing yaks were not affected by the taste agents. Application of the SA agent significantly increased the yaks’ grazing time, bites per minute, bites per step, time per feeding station, and steps per feeding station, while significantly reducing walking time, steps per minute, and number of feeding stations per minute. Meanwhile, application of the SW agent significantly increased the yaks’ time per feeding station, however, significantly reduced the steps per minute and number of feeding stations per minute. In contrast, the BT agent significantly increased the yaks’ walking time, steps per minute, and number of feeding stations per minute, while significantly reducing grazing time, bites per minute, bites per step, and time per feeding station. Application of the SA agent also significantly increased the intake of favoured, edible, and inedible forage, while the SW agent improved inedible forage intake, however, had a more subtle effect on favoured and edible forage intake. Meanwhile, the BT agent had an inhibitory effect on grazing intake. Hence, the structural equation model suggested that taste agents may directly or indirectly influence grazing behaviour by regulating feeding behaviour. Our findings provide a theoretical basis for using taste agents in grasslands to control the grazing behaviour of livestock and provide a method to promote the stability of grassland communities, while mitigating the degradation of grasslands in the QTP.     

Optimal trade-offs between competing behavioural demands in the great tit

We present a dynamic optimal control model to show how territorial male great tits (Parus major L.) should combine territorial vigilance with foraging. In the model, territory owners allocate time either to feeding in patches or travelling between them. Travelling is compatible with territorial vigilance, while feeding is not. Owners are assumed to adjust their patch residence and travel times in order to minimize the costs accruing from intruders on their territories, while at the same time reducing their hunger. The relation between patch residence and travel time matches that of Charnov's (1976) marginal value theorem while hunger is high, but as hunger is reduced the dynamic model predicts shorter patch residence times for any observed travel time. We present supporting evidence from an experimental test with captive male great tits.     

The effect of depletion and predictability of distinct food patches on the timing of aggression in red deer stags

For group-foraging ungulates, forage is generally widely and relatively evenly dispersed. However, for free-ranging red deer Cervus elaphus supplementary winter feeding provides distinct patches of predictable food. These patches differ in size, but also in temporal distribution and depletion rate. Interference competition is known to increase with increasing spatial clumping (decreasing patch size), but the influence of temporal clumping and the predictability of food occurrence has received much less attention. Therefore in this study we investigated the effects of different degrees of spatial and temporal clumping of food on interference competition during feeding. Patch size was the main parameter influencing participation in feeding as well as interference competition during feeding on the respective patch. Temporal dispersion and the predictability of food occurrence were however, important parameters for the timing of aggressive interactions. Generally, aggression occurs during feeding and increases with decreasing patch size. But when depletion rate was high food availability was predictably short and the patch occurred predictably (such as hay), middle ranking stags increased aggression already prior to feeding at the respective patch. We suggest that in this way they confirmed hierarchy outside feeding on the quickly depleted patch and as a result gained actual feeding time when feeding on the respective patch. With the patch occurring predictably but varying in size the number of participating subordinates varied concomitantly with variation in patch size. Subordinates assessed patch profitability and left without having fed when patch size was too small for an efficient participation. When patch size was predictably small enough to be defended exclusively (feed blocks), subordinate stags did not assess profitability each time but did not participate at all in feeding at the respective patch. The relative importance of these various food-related parameters (patch size depletion rate, predictability) influencing feeding competition and the timing of aggression will vary with group size, rank, alternative food sources, physical characteristics of the food as well as different hierarchy systems of the feeding animals.     

Effects of demographic parameters on metapopulation size and persistence: an analytical stochastic model

An analytical stochastic metapopulation model is developed. It describes how individuals will be distributed among patches as a function of density-dependent birth, death and emigration rates, and the probability of successful dispersal. The model includes demographic stochasticity, but not catastrophes, environmental stochasticity or variation in patch size and suitability. All patches are equally likely to be colonized by migrants. The model predicts: (a) mean and variance of the number of individuals per patch; (b) probability distribution of individuals per patch; (c) mean number of individuals in transit; and (d) turn-over rate and expected persistence time of a single patch. The model shows that (a) dispersal rates must be intermediate in order to ensure metapopulation persistence; (b) the mean number of individuals per patch is often well below the carrying capacity; (c) long transit times and/or high mortality during dispersal reduce the mean number of individuals per patch; (d) density-dependent emigration responses will usually increase metapopulation size and persistence compared with density-independent dispersal; (e) an increase in the per capita net growth rate can both increase and decrease metapopulation size and persistence depending on whether dispersal rates are high or low; (f) density-independent birth, death, and emigration rates lead to a spatial pattern described by the negative binomial distribution.     

Low genetic variation in muskoxen (Ovibos moschatus) from western Greenland using microsatellites

Muskoxen are large herbivores living in Arctic environments. Lack of genetic variation in allozymes has made it difficult to study the social and genetic structure of this species. In this study, we have tried to find polymorphic microsatellite loci using both cattle-derived microsatellite primers and primers developed from a genomic plasmid library of muskoxen. Only limited variation was found for both sets of microsatellite loci. We conclude that this consistent low genetic variation is probably due to demographic features of the muskoxen populations rather than to methodological constraints caused by the transfer of microsatellites between species.     

Quantification of biogenic 3-D structures in marine sediments

Burrow and tube structures of marine infauna were quantified in sediments from cores obtained at 3 depths (75, 95 and 118 m) at 3 occasions over a 1-year period. The benthic communities at the two deeper stations were re-establishing subsequent to re-oxygenation after hypoxic conditions; the shallow station was a reference station unaffected by hypoxia. The benthic macrofauna was simultaneously quantified from sieved grab samples. The sediment cores were frozen and later sliced with a plane in horizontal layers. Biogenic structures in these sections were digitally analysed for numbers, area and volume. Number of tubes and burrows showed a general decline with depth in the sediment. The biogenic structures in the sediment at the reference station increased the sediment-water interface about 1.5 times compared to the surface area. The surface areas of burrows and tubes were 2 to 3 times larger at the reference station than at the deeper stations. The benthic fauna at the 95-m and 118-m stations showed a temporal increase in density and number of species. In contrast, development of biogenic surface areas in the sediment at these stations showed no significant temporal trend during the benthic faunal succession. Relic tubes of Melinna cristata were found throughout the sampling period at the 118-m station. The ecological importance of bioirrigation for biogeochemical processes is discussed.     

Temporal resource variability and the habitat-matching rule

Summary The ideal free distribution of competitors in a heterogeneous environment often predicts habitat matching, where the equilibrium number of consumers in a patch is proportional to resource abundance in that patch. We model the interaction between habitat matching and temporal variation in resource abundance. In one patch the rate of resource input follows a Markov chain; a second patch does not vary temporally. We predict patch use by scaling transition rates in the variable patch to the time that consumers require to respond to changes in rates of resource input. If consumers respond very quickly, habitat matching tracks temporal variability. If resource input fluctuates faster than consumers respond, habitat matching averages over the equilibrium of the Markov chain. Tracking and averaging produce the same mean resource consumption for individuals, but long-term mean occupation of the patches differs. When habitat matching tracks temporal variability in resources, consumer density in the variable patch has a lower mean and a higher variance than when habitat matching reflects only average rates of resource input.We tested our model by feeding free-living mallard ducks (Anas platyrynchos) at two artificial patches. The foragers' behavior satisfied the quantitative predictions of the model in each of two experiments.     

Patch Time Allocation by a Parasitoid: The Influence of Con-specifics,Host Abundance and Distance to the Patch

Patch residence time is at the core of models of decision making by foragers living in patchy environments. We studied patch residence time (PRT) of Ibalia leucospoides, a parasitoid of the woodwasp Sirex noctilio, as assigned to 4 treatments (recent feeding and/or oviposition experience) foraging in an array of host-infested pine logs. We tested the effects of distance from release point, host abundance, and the number of con-specifics at the time of arrival, on patch (pine log) residence time. PRT depended on a combination of patch quality (number of hosts in a log) and distance from the release point. Neither the presence of con-specifics on the patch, prior exposure to hosts, nor feeding prior to the experiment affected the time spent on a patch. We conclude that PRT in I. leucospoides meets Marginal Value Theorem predictions qualitatively, overruling the effects recent oviposition experience, access to food and contact with conspecifics. These findings are in line with the reported pro-ovigeny in I. leucospoides as well as the strong spatial aggregation of hosts in the field.     

Feeder design and available feeding space influence the feeding behaviour of hens

This paper describes a study of the influences of feeder design and available feeding space on the feeding behaviour of laying hens.When feeders were partitioned, feeding rates and the number of feeding bouts were higher than when the feeders were unpartitioned, but feed consumption was lower and the duration of feeding was shorter. Increased feeding space led to longer feeding times with fewer but longer feeding bouts. These results are discussed in relation to animal welfare, with particular reference to feather-pecking.     

Long-term responses in arctic ungulate dynamics to changes in climatic and trophic processes

 Following predictions from climatic general circulation models, the effects of perturbations in global climate are expected to be most pronounced in the Northern Hemisphere. Elaborating on a recently developed plant–herbivore–climate model, we explore statistically how different winter climate regimes and density-dependent processes during the past century have affected population dynamics of two arctic ungulate species. Our analyses were performed on the dynamics of six muskox and six caribou populations. In muskoxen, variation in winter climate, mediated through the North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO), explained up to 24% of the variation in interannual abundance, whereas in caribou up to 16% was explained by the NAO. Muskoxen responded negatively following warm and snowy winters, whereas caribou responded negatively to dry winters. Direct and delayed density dependence was recorded in most populations and explained up to 32% and 90% of variations in abundance of muskoxen and caribou, respectively. Received: November 19, 2001 / Accepted: May 28, 2002