Variations of chloroplast DNAs in the genus Pelargonium and their biparental inheritance

Summary The comparison of EcoRI patterns of chloroplast DNAs (ctDNAs) from five species of the genus Pelargonium and from 16 cultivars and varieties of Pelargonium zonale hort. demonstrates a remarkable inter- and intraspecific ctDNA (plastome) variation. The plastome of the P. zonale varieties could be differentiated into groups I, II and III. Reasons for this variation seem to be: occurrence of numerous spontaneous plastome mutations, intense hybridisation by gardeners and breeders, and biparental plastid inheritance.Crosses of P. zonale varieties with different ctDNA types lead to the direct evidence on the molecular level of biparental plastid inheritance and plastid sorting-out in F₁-hybrids.     

Cytological evidence of biparental inheritance of plastids and mitochondria inPelargonium

Summary Based on the organelle differences between egg and sperm cells inPelargonium hortorum, the zygote, proembryo, and endosperm were examined under the transmission electron microscope. Plastids and mitochondria in the egg cell are significantly different from those of the sperm cell. Egg plastids are starch-containing and less electron dense. They appear circular, elliptical irregular elongate in sections. Sperm cell plastids are relatively electrondense, mostly cup-shaped or dumbbell and devoid of starch granules. Mitochondria of the egg cell are giant and mostly cup-shaped while sperm mitochondria are smaller and usually circular in section. Double fertilization is completed by 24 h after pollination and the pollen tube can be seen in the degenerated synergid. In the zygote, plastids and mitochondria from male and female gametes can be distinguished by their characteristic differences. Moreover, paternal and maternal organelles appear to be distributed at random in the zygote. Aside from the pollen tube and its released starch granules, there is no enucleated cytoplasmic body in the degenerated synergid. Two days after pollination, the zygote undergoes one transverse division to form a 2-celled proembryo which consists of one larger vacuolated basal cell and one smaller densely cytoplasmic apical cell. Paternal and maternal organelles can be detected in both cells of the proembryo and also in the endosperm at this stage. From these results, it can be concluded that plastids and mitochondria from both male and female gametes have been transmitted into the apical cell of the proembryo and most probably to the following generation.Abbreviations TEM transmission electron microscope - DAPI 4,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole - RFLP restriction fragment length polymorphism     

Quantitative,three-dimensional analysis of alfalfa egg cells in two genotypes: Implications for biparental plastid inheritance

In alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.), plastids are inherited biparentally. Patterns of plastid transmission vary according to the genotypes involved, but there is a strong bias in favor of male plastid transmission. Previous cytological studies on the male gametophyte of this species have not provided an adequate explanation for the differences in plastid transmission frequencies among genotypes. In the present study, we compared egg cells from genotypes classified as strong or weak plastid transmitters to determine whether plastid transmission strength is correlated with egg cell structure before fertilization. We found that plastids in the mature egg cells of the strong female (genotype 6–4) are significantly larger than in mature eggs of the weak female (genotype CUF-B), and that significantly more plastids are positioned in the apical portion of the mature egg cell of genotype 6–4 than in CUF-B. Immature eggs in the two genotypes show the same pattern as mature eggs with regard to plastid number and polarization. Since only the apical portion of the egg cell/zygote gives rise to the functional embryo, these results indicate that the potential input of female plastids, in terms of plastid size and number, may be an important factor in determining the inheritance patterns of these organelles in alfalfa.Support for this work by the United States Department of Agriculture under grant 88-37234-3876, the National Science Foundation under grant DCB-9103658, the Organized Research Fund of Northern Arizona University, and the Arizona Agricultural Experiment Station is gratefully acknowledged. We are indebted to Dr. Craig Caldwell, Northern Arizona University Computer Visualization Laboratory, for his expert help with the computer graphics.     

The zygote and proembryo of alfalfa: quantitative,three-dimensional analysis and implications for biparental plastid inheritance

Summary Genetic studies have demonstrated biparental inheritance of plastids in alfalfa. The ratio of paternal to maternal plastids in the progeny varies according to the genotypes of the parents, which can be classified as strong or weak transmitters of plastids. Previous cytological investigations of generative cells and male gametes have provided no consistent explanation for plastid inheritance patterns among genotypes. However, plastids in the mature egg cells of a strong female genotype (6–4) were found to be more numerous and larger than in mature eggs of a weak female genotype (CUF-B), and the plastids in 6–4 eggs are positioned equally around the nucleus. In CUF-B, the majority of plastids are positioned below (toward the micropyle) the mid level of the nucleus, which is the future division plane of the zygote. Since only the apical portion of the zygote produces the embryo proper, plastids in the basal portion were predicted to become included in the suspensor cells and not be inherited. In the present study, we examined zygotes and a two-celled proembryo from a cross between CUF-B and a strong male genotype (301), a cross that results in over 90% of the progeny possessing paternal plastids only. Our results indicate that the distribution of plastids observed in the CUF-B egg cell is maintained through the first division of the zygote. Further, paternal plastids are similarly distributed; however, within the apical portion of the zygote and in the apical cell of the two-celled proembryo, the number of paternal plastids is typically much greater than the number of maternal plastids. These findings suggest that maternal and paternal plastid distribution within the zygote is a significant factor determining the inheritance of maternal and paternal plastids in alfalfa.     

The mechanism of the mixed inheritance of chloroplast genes in Pelargonium

Summary The distributions are given of gene frequencies among embryos after G X W and W X G plastid crosses within and between eight Pelargonium cultivars and some of their inbred or hybrid derivatives.Two distinct segregation patterns are recognized. Homozygous type I female parents (Pr₁Pr₁) have a high frequency of progeny with only maternal alleles, are intermediate for biparental and low for paternal offspring. Heterozygous type II female plants (Pr₁Pr₂) have an equally high frequency of maternal and paternal offspring and a generally low biparental frequency. These correspond to L-shaped and U-shaped gene frequency distributions respectively in which the only modes are at 0 per cent (maternal embryos) and 100 per cent (paternal embryos), with no mode corresponding to the population mean and no sign of a Gaussian distribution.The extremely variable plastid gene frequencies are strongly influenced by the maternal nuclear genotype and by the plastid genotype in which the wild-type allele is always more successful than the mutant in strict comparisons.The relative frequencies of maternal and paternal zygotes, and the mean gene frequency among all the zygotes in a cross, are explicable in terms of the input frequencies of genes from the two parents, their degree of mixing, and by some form of selective replication of plastids. This selection is controlled by nuclear and plastid genotypes which may act in the same direction, to increase the frequency of either the maternal or the paternal alleles, or in opposition. But selection alone is inadequate to explain the shapes of the gene frequency distributions. Instead, a model is proposed in which the segregation or replication of plastids appears to have a strong random element, which results in random drift of gene frequencies within a heteroplasmic zygote or embryo.     

Cytoplasmic DNA apportionment and plastid differentiation during male gametophyte development in Pelargonium zonale

In the male gametophyte of Pelargonium zonale, generative and sperm cells contain cytoplasmic DNA in high density compared to vegetative cells. Cytoplasmic DNA was examined using the DNA fluorochrome DAPI (4'6-diamidino-2-phenylindole) and observed with epifluorescence and electron microscopy. The microspore cell contains a prominent central vacuole before mitosis; mitochondria and plastids are randomly distributed throughout the cytoplasm. Following the first pollen grain mitosis, neither the vegetative cell nor the early generative cell display a distributional difference in cytoplasmic DNA, nor is there in organelle content at this stage. During the maturation of the male gametophyte, however, a significant discrepancy in plastid abundance develops. Plastids in the generative cell return to proplastids and do not contain large starch grains, while those in the vegetative cell develop starch grains and differentiate into large amyloplasts. Plastid nucleoids in generative and sperm cells in a mature male gametophyte are easily discriminated after DAPI staining due to their compactness, while those in vegetative cells stained only weakly. The utility of the hydrophilic, non-autofluorescent resin Technovit 7100 in observing DAPI fluorescence is also demonstrated.     

The model plant Medicago truncatula exhibits biparental plastid inheritance

The plastid, which originated from the endosymbiosis of a cyanobacterium, contains its own plastid DNA (ptDNA) that exhibits a unique mode of inheritance. Approximately 80% of angiosperms show maternal inheritance, whereas the remainder exhibit biparental inheritance of ptDNA. Here we studied ptDNA inheritance in the model legume, Medicago truncatula. Cytological analysis of mature pollen with DNA-specific fluorescent dyes suggested that M. truncatula is one of the few model plants potentially showing biparental inheritance of ptDNA. We further examined pollen by electron microscopy and revealed that the generative cell (a mother of sperm cells) indeed has many DNA-containing plastids. To confirm biparental inheritance genetically, we crossed two ecotypes (Jemalong A17 and A20), and the transmission mode of ptDNA was investigated by a PCR-assisted polymorphism. Consistent with the cytological observations, the majority of F(1) plants possessed ptDNAs from both parents. Interestingly, cotyledons of F(1) plants tended to retain a biparental ptDNA population, while later emergent leaves tended to be uniparental with either one of the parental plastid genotypes. Biparental transmission was obvious in the F(2) population, in which all plants showed homoplasmy with either a paternal or a maternal plastid genotype. Collectively, these data demonstrated that M. truncatula is biparental for ptDNA transmission and thus can be an excellent model to study plastid genetics in angiosperms.     

Paternal inheritance of plastids in Medicago sativa

Summary Plastids are plant cellular organelles that are generally inherited from the maternal parent in the angiosperms. Many species exhibit biparental inheritance of plastids, but usually with a predominantly maternal influence. In contrast to this, we report strong paternal inheritance of plastids in reciprocal crosses of alfalfa, Medicago sativa, by following restriction fragment length polymorphisms for plastid DNA in two normal green plastids. Mitochondrial inheritance remained exclusively maternal.     

Quantitative cytology of the alfalfa generative cell and its relation to male plastid inheritance patterns in three genotypes

Summary Studies utilizing restriction analysis of plastid DNA, as well as those employing chlorophyll-deficient mutants, have shown a high frequency of paternal plastid transmission in alfalfa. Recent research has also shown that plastid inheritance patterns among alfalfa genotypes and are under genetic control. In a previous study we were unable to detect any correlations between qualitative, three-dimensional ultrastructure of generative cells and male plastid transmission strength in certain genotypes. In the present study we used serial ultrathin sectioning, computerized reconstruction and quantitation, and stereology to further analyze generative cells within mature pollen. Measurements included volumes and surface areas of cells, nuclei, and organelles, as well as organelle number and distribution. Three genotypes were investigated, one that is a strong transmitter of male plastids (genotype 301), one that is a weaker transmitter of male plastids (genotype 7W), and a third that is an even weaker male plastid transmitter (genotype MS-5). Our results show that genotype MS-5 has significantly fewer plastids/generative cell than either of the other genotypes, which may account for it being a relatively poor transmitter of male plastids. However, plastid number does not explain known differences in male plastid inheritance between genotypes 301 and 7W, since plastid number does not differ significantly between these two genotypes. Regarding the other features of generative cells measured in this study, no consistent correlations were found that might account for differences in male plastid inheritance patterns between genotypes. Plastid distribution is equal in each end of the spindle-shaped generative cell in all genotypes studied. Similar relative results were found with regard to mitochondria within generative cells; however, comparative genetic data are not available on mitochondrial transmission patterns in alfalfa genotypes.     

Presence of plastid and absence of mitochondrial DNA in male reproductive cells as evidence for cytoplasmic inheritance in Turnera ulmifolia and Zantedeschia aethiopica

Summary. Epifluorescence microscopy of mature pollen grains of Turnera ulmifolia and Zantedeschia aethiopica stained with 4,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole demonstrated the presence of fluorescent cytoplasmic DNA aggregates in the male reproductive cells of both species. Double staining of the cells with 4,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole and 3,3-dihexyloxacarbocyanine iodide in Technovit resin sections showed that the mitochondria of these cells did not correspond to the fluorescent cytoplasmic DNA aggregates. Electron microscopy studies revealed both plastids and mitochondria in the cells of these species. In addition, immunoelectron microscopy using an anti-DNA monoclonal antibody showed clear labeling of plastids but not mitochondria. These data provide cytological evidence for biparental plastid inheritance and maternal mitochondrial inheritance in these species.Correspondence and reprints: College of Life Sciences, Peking University, Beijing 100871, Peoples Republic of China.     

Irregular segregation at the Pr locus controlling plastid inheritance in Pelargonium: gametophytic lethal or incompatibility system?

Summary Two distinct segregation patterns are recognized after G X W plastid crosses in Pelargonium. Type I parents produce offspring in which maternal zygotes are frequent, biparental intermediate, and paternal zygotes rare (MZ>BPZ>PZ), as defined by the presence or absence of green or white plastids in the young embryos into which the zygotes develop. Type II parents produce offspring in which maternal and paternal zygotes are frequent with biparental zygotes the least frequent class (MZ>BPZPr ₁ Pr ₁. Type II plants, which do not breed true, are regarded as heterozygotes — Pr ₁ Pr ₂. The nuclear gene is symbolized as Pr as it is presumed to control alternative patterns of plastid segregation through an effect on plastid replication.Selfs and intercrosses of heterozygous plants segregate in an unexpected 1:1 ratio and not the expected 3:1 (1:2:1). The alternative homozygote — Pr ₂ Pr ₂ — could not be detected. Reciprocal crosses between heterozygotes (Pr ₁ Pr ₂) and homozygotes (Pr ₁ Pr ₁) give the expected 1:1 ratio when the Pr ₂ allele is derived from the male, whereas there is often, but not always, a highly significant deviation from 1:1 when the Pr ₂ allele is derived from the female.A simple explanation, which is not wholly satisfactory, is to assume that Pr ₂ is a gametophytic lethal on the female side. An alternative, or additional, explanation is that an incompatibility mechanism is involved in which Pr ₁ is a self-compatible allele, Pr ₂ a self-incompatible allele, and Pr ₁-Pr ₂ cross-compatible alleles. Successful fertilization is then determined by sporophytic control on the male side and gametophytic control on the female side.     

Multiple gene control of plastome-genome incompatibility and plastid DNA inheritance in interspecific hybrids of Zantedeschia

From interspecific hybridisation in the genus Zantedeschia, we have previously produced albino, variegated and virescent hybrids. The inhibition of chloroplast development in these hybrids is due to plastome-genome incompatibility. The albino hybrids did not develop prolamellar bodies in their etioplasts in darkness and formed only distended membranes, but no grana in light. This indicates that the block to chloroplast development occurs before or during the development of etioplasts. In albino leaf sectors of variegated hybrids, chlorophyll and carotenoid contents were only 2–4% of those in green plants. The mRNA levels for five plastid-development-related genes were also severely reduced, but they were still readily detectable using Northern hybridisation techniques. In the green sectors of variegated hybrids, chlorophyll content and mRNA levels of the fives genes were slightly reduced. We have earlier shown that F₁ hybrids between Z. aethiopica and Z. odorata were albino when Z. odorata plastids were present but virescent when Z. aethiopica plastids were present. When the F₁ hybrids with Z. aethiopica plastids were backcrossed to Z. odorata, the progeny were albino, virescent or green. Z. odorata plastids were inherited only from maternal parents in the F₁ progenies but inherited from either maternal or paternal parents in the backcross. The increased compatibility with, and inheritance of Z. odorata plastids in the backcross suggests that multiple genes play a major role in the plastome-genome incompatibility. An increase in the number of genes from the parent contributing the plastids improves chloroplast development in the hybrids of the genus Zantedeschia. Received: 29 November 1999 / Accepted: 2 December 1999     

Populations of plastids and mitochondria during male reproductive cell maturation in Nicotiana tabacum L.: A cytological basis for occasional biparental inheritance

The dynamics of plastid and mitochondrial populations in male reproductive cells of tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.) were examined during development using serial ultrathin sections and transmission electron microscopy to reconstruct 58 generative cells and 31 sperm cells at selected stages of maturation from generative cell formation through gametic fusion. The first haploid mitosis resulted in incomplete exclusion of plastids providing an average of 2.81 plastids and 82.7 mitochondria for each newly formed generative cell. During generative-cell maturation, plastid content decreased to an average of 0.48 plastids/generative cell at anthesis owing to autophagy of organelles. Plastids were present in low frequency within generative and sperm cells in the pollen tube and appeared to be transmitted, according to observations immediately prior to fertilization. This forms a cytological basis for genetic reports of occasional biparental plastid inheritance. In contrast, mitochondria were transmitted in larger numbers, and approximately 80 mitochondria per generative cell or sperm cell pair were retained throughout development. This provides a potentially stable source for the transmission of male mitochondrial DNA, if present at fertilization.Abbreviations GC generative cell - SC sperm cell We thank Dr. Frank J. Sonleitner, for helpful suggestions on the statistical calculations and Dr. Bing-Quan Huang for technical assistance in the preparation of embryo sacs during fertilization. This research was supported in part by U.S. Department of Agriculture grant 91-37304-6471. We gratefully acknowledge use of the Samuel Roberts Noble Electron Microscopy Laboratory of the University of Oklahoma.     

Potential for biparental cytoplasmic inheritance in Jasminum officinale and Jasminum nudiflorum

 Mature Jasminum officinale and J. nudiflorum pollen grains were stained with 4′,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole (DAPI) and examined by epifluorescence microscopy. The pollen grains were found to be trinucleate, and the sperm cells in both species contained a large number of epifluorescent spots that corresponded to cytoplasmic DNA aggregates (nucleoids). The nucleoids of J. nudiflorum were observed to be dimorphic under the epifluorescence microscope, indicating that the sperm cells might contain both plastid and mitochondrial DNA. The nucleoids of J. officinale presented a similar appearance when stained with DAPI, but electron microscopic examination of the sperm cells revealed that they contained both plastids and mitochondria. When analyzed by DNA immunogold electron microscopy, gold particles were detected on both plastids and mitochondria. These findings demonstrated the preservation of plastid and mitochondrial DNA in mature sperm cells and thus the potential for biparental cytoplasmic inheritance in J. officinale and J. nudiflorum. Received: 8 August 1997 / Revision accepted: 25 February 1998     

Paternal inheritance of plastids in the genus Daucus

Summary The plastid DNAs of the species Daucus carota (ssp. sativus, libanotifolia, gingidium), D. maximus and D. muricatus were compared by restriction enzyme analysis. A number of restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs) were observed. As expected from taxonomic data the degree of plastid DNA homology between D. carota and D. maximus is significantly higher (97%) than between D. carota and D. muricatus (70%). On the basis of RFLPs of plastid DNA the mode of plastid inheritance in interspecific crosses between D. muricatus and D. c. sativus was analysed. The results clearly indicate paternal plastid inheritance. Thus Daucus is the second genus among angiosperms transmitting predominantly male plastids.     

A rapid PCR based method to establish the potential for paternal inheritance of chloroplasts inPelargonium

A simple procedure for the amplification of chloroplast DNA from pollen is described. This allows the potential for biparental or paternal inheritance of chloroplasts in angiosperms to be established rapidly and reliably. Such information is important when chloroplast DNA, which is generally assumed to be inherited maternally, is used to study gene flow or reconstruct phylogenies. The technique could also prove valuable in assessing the risks of transgene escape via pollen of genetically modified plants, in which the chloroplast genome rather than the nucleus has been transformed.     

The role of plastid competition in the control of plastid inheritance in the zonal Pelargonium

The inheritance pattern of mutant white plastids was studied in W × W crosses, in which one mutant was highly stable (W^s) and the other unstable (W^u) owing to the spontaneous restitution (mutation) of white plastids to a new green form. Thirty-six selfs and crosses were made within and between three nuclear type I cultivars, transmitting the unstable plastids, and three nuclear type II cultivars, transmitting the stable plastids. The allelic frequencies of the restituted plastids among the progeny were subjected to an analysis of variance which showed that within each nuclear type the three cultivars were rather similar except for some heterogeneity after W^s × W^u plastid crosses. The relative average transmission of the two mutant plastids in these W × W crosses was estimated and compared with their individual transmission in reciprocal crosses in which one parent contained green plastids. In the latter crosses, the green plastids were superior to the mutant plastids and the unstable plastid mutant was only slightly more successful than the stable mutant. But when the mutant plastids competed against each other, the unstable mutant became greatly superior to the stable mutant and comparable to a green normal plastid. A model to explain these results is discussed.     

Shoot regeneration of hybrid seed geranium (Pelargonium x hortorum) and regal geranium (Pelargonium x domesticum) from primary callus cultures

Procedures have been developed that increase the rate of shoot regeneration of hybrid seed geranium from month-old primary callus cultures. Hybrid geranium callus tissue covered with green nodular structures was initiated by placing shoot tip explants on solidified Murashige & Skoog medium (MS) supplemented with 2.0 mgl^-1 zeatin and 1.9 mgl^-1 indoleacetic acid. Hybrids Red Orbit, White Orbit and Scarlet Orbit were shown to produce 5–50 shoot primordia per explant when callus was initiated on this medium. Regal geranium callus was initiated by placing leaf explants on MS medium supplemented with 2.0 mgl^-1 6-benzylaminopurine and 2.0 mgl^-1 naphthaleneacetic acid. Regal geranium cultivars Tiny Tot and Lavender Grand Slam were shown to produce between 2–50 shoot primordia per explant when initiated on the same medium.