Photo-ionization spectroscopy and mass spectrometry of some molecular and supramolecular asymmetric systems in the isolated state

Asymmetric molecular and supramolecular systems are characterized by: i. the circular dicroism in the angular distribution of valence photoelectrons emitted from randomly oriented chiral molecules by their interaction with circularly polarized VUV light; ii. the different stability and reactivity of diastereomeric aggregates. Both these aspects may have some relationship with the "chiral enrichment mechanism" of chirogenesis, based on the preferential destruction of one enantiomer of a racemate by interaction with a chiral agent, whether a massive species or a circularly polarized photon. The most recent spectroscopic and mass spectrometric studies on this topic are reported in the present mini-review.     

Enantiodiscrimination of chiral alpha-aminophosphonic acids by mass spectrometry.

Diastereomeric clusters between first-group metal ions (M(+)) and chiral alpha-aminophosphonic acids (A and B) have been readily generated in the gas phase by electrospray ionization (ESI) and their fragmentation investigated by mass spectrometry. The complexes studied had the general formula [MA(S)B(2)](+) and [MA(R)B(2)](+), where M = H, Li, Na, or K, A(S) and A(R) are the two enantiomers of a given acid A, and B is a reference alpha-aminophosphonic acid of defined configuration. Collision-induced decomposition (CID) of [MA(S)B(2)](+) and [MA(R)B(2)](+) leads to fragmentation patterns characterized by [MAB](+)/[MB(2)] abundance ratios which depend on the configuration of ligand A. These different spectral features were correlated to the different stability of the diastereomeric [MA(S)B(2)](+) and [MA(R)B(2)](+) complexes in the gas phase. The results have been discussed in the light of MM2 Molecular Mechanics Force Field calculations.     

Resolution of sertraline with (R)-mandelic acid: chiral discrimination mechanism study

The chiral discrimination mechanism in the resolution of sertraline with mandelic acid was investigated by examining the weak intermolecular interactions (such as hydrogen bond, CH/π, and van der Waals interactions) and molecular packing difference in crystal structures of the resulting diastereomeric salts. A new one-dimensional chain-like hydrogen-bonding network and unique supramolecular packing mode are disclosed. The investigation demonstrated that stable hydrogen-bonding pattern, herringbone-like arrangement of aromatic rings, and planar boundary surface in the hydrophobic region are the three most important structural characteristics expected in less soluble diastereomeric salts. The existence and magnitude of hydrogen bond, CH/π interaction, and van der Waals interaction related to three characteristic structures, determine the stability of diastereomeric salt. The hydrogen bond is not necessarily the dominant factor while the synergy and optimization of all weak intermolecular interactions attribute to the chiral recognition.     

Gas-phase enantioselective reactions in noncovalent ion-molecule complexes

Noncovalent diastereomeric ion-molecule complexes are produced in the gas phase and are ideal for the study of chiral recognition in the absence of complicating solvent and counterion effects. This review article describes the state-of-art in this field with special emphasis on the most recent mass spectrometric studies of the structure, dynamics, and reactivity of diastereomeric ion/molecule aggregates.     

First direct discrimination of chiral phosphorus thionate (P=S) derivatives by multinuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy in the presence of a chiral dirhodium complex

Enantiomeric ratios of compounds with P=S functionalities can be determined by 1H, 13C, and 31P NMR spectroscopic inspection of their diastereomeric complexes with (R)-Rh2(MTPA)4 (MTPA-H identical with methoxytrifluoromethylphenylacetic acid; Mosher's acid). This is the first facile and rapid spectroscopic method for chiral recognition in this class of compounds. Whereas complexation shifts Deltadelta are moderate or even negligible, significant signal dispersions Delta(nu) can be observed. Some rationalization about the complexation mode is presented. The NMR spectral characteristics of the free P=S compounds 1-9 are described in detail.     

Efficient resolution of venlafaxine and mechanism study via X‐ray crystallography

Numbers of resolving factors were investigated to improve resolution of venlafaxine 1 . An effective resolving agent, O,O′‐di‐p‐toluoyl‐(R, R)‐tartaric acid 2 , was screened using similar method of ‘Dutch resolution’ from tartaric acid derivatives. The resolution efficiency was up to 88.4%, when the ratio of rac‐ 1 and 2 was 1:0.8 in THF with little water (10:1 v/v). Enantiomerically pure venlafaxine was prepared with 99.1% ee in 82.2% yield. The chiral resolution mechanism was first explained through X‐ray crystallographic study. One diastereomeric salt with well solubility forms a columnar supramolecular structure as the acidic salt (R)‐ 1 · 2 , while the other diastereomeric salt with less solubility forms a multilayered sandwich supramolecular structure by enantio‐differentiation self‐assembly as the neutral salt 2(S)‐ 1 · 2 . The water molecules play a key role in the optical resolution, as indicated by the special structures of the diastereomeric salts.     

Electrostatic chiral distinction: Tetrahedral model dimers

Although chiral distinction plays a pervasive role in chemistry, a complete understanding of how this takes place is still lacking. In this work, we expand the earlier described minimal requirement of so called four‐point interactions (vide infra). We focus on chiral point charge model systems as a means to aid in the dissection of the underlying, operative principles. We also construct models with defined symmetry characteristics. By considering extensive constellations of diastereomeric complexes, we are able to identify emerging principles for chiral distinction. As previously postulated, all the diastereomeric complexes, regardless of their nominal contact‐points, possess a chiral distinction energy. In the comparison of complexes, we find that, contrary to chemical intuition, the magnitude of chiral distinction does not correlate with the stability of the complexes, i.e., consideration of low energy complexes may not be an effective way to evaluate chiral distinction. Similarly, we do not find a correlation between the number of contact‐points and chiral distinction. Moreover, favorable interactions and facile chiral distinction appear to be unrelated. We also see some tendency for greater chiral distinction in less symmetric systems, although this may not be general. These studies can now form the basis to fold in higher levels of complexity into the models so as to gain further insights into the nature of chiral distinction. Chirality, 2010. © 2009 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Chiral discrimination by ligand-exchange chromatography: A comparison between phenylalaninamide-based stationary and mobile phases

The copper(II) complexes of two new diastereomeric ligands, N²-(R)- and N²-(S)-2′-hydroxypropyl-(S)-phenylalaninamide [(R, S)-1 and (S, S)-1], have been used as additives to the eluent in high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) reversed phase for the chiral separation of DNS-amino acids. The aim was that of comparing the separation process obtained by the chiral eluent with that obtained by an analogous bonded stationary phase containing (S)-phenylalaninamide, previously studied [CSP-(S)-Phe-NH₂]. The affinity of the ternary complexes for the C₁₈ column was determined by adsorption experiments in HPLC. It was shown that the two systems (chiral eluent, chiral stationary phase) work according to different mechanisms. Ternary complex formation in solution was studied by fluorescence spectroscopy. It was shown that chiral separation with the Cu(II) complexes added to the eluent was determined by the relative affinities of the ternary complexes for the column-stationary phase rather than by their stabilities in solution. With CSP-(S)-Phe-NH₂ the separation is accounted for by the relative stabilities of the ternary complexes, which depends mainly on the “allowed” geometry of the complex and on the steric repulsion of the amino acid side chain with the spacer. © 1996 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Chiral recognition of ethers by NMR spectroscopy

Enantiomers of chiral ethers and acetals are notoriously difficult to differentiate because their reactivity is low and they are poor donors to any Lewis acid or metal ion. As an exception, epoxides are somewhat better donors. This review describes the properties of ethers, explains NMR methods for their chiral recognition and describes successful examples of ether differentiation. The majority of literature reports deals with chiral lanthanide shift reagents and dirhodium tetracarboxylate complexes, which were used as enantiopure auxiliaries to create diastereomeric adducts with dispersed (1)H and (13)C NMR signals. The various methods are compared as to which is best suited for which purpose.     

Construction and Systematical Symmetric Studies of a Series of Supramolecular Clusters with Binary or Ternary Ammonium Triphenylacetates

Functions of clusters in nano or sub-nano scale significantly depend on not only kinds of their components but also arrangements, or symmetry, of their components. Therefore, the arrangements in the clusters have been precisely characterized, especially for metal complexes. Contrary to this, characterizations of molecular arrangements in supramolecular clusters composed of organic molecules are limited to a few cases. This is because construction of the supramolecular clusters, especially obtaining a series of the supramolecular clusters, is difficult due to low stability of non-covalent bonds compare to covalent bonds. From this viewpoint, utilization of organic salts is one of the most useful strategies. A series of the supramolecules could be constructed by combinations of a specific organic molecule with various counter ions. Especially, primary ammonium carboxylates are suitable as typical examples of supramolecules because various kinds of carboxylic acids and primary amines are commercially available, and it is easy to change their combinations. Previously, it was demonstrated that primary ammonium triphenylacetates using various kinds of primary amines specifically construct supramolecular clusters, which are composed of four ammoniums and four triphenylacetates assembled by charge-assisted hydrogen bonds, in crystals obtained from non-polar solvents. This study demonstrates an application of the specific construction of the supramolecular clusters as a strategy to conduct systematical symmetric study for clarification of correlations between molecular arrangements in supramolecules and kinds and numbers of their components. In the same way with binary salts composed of triphenylacetates and one kind of primary ammoniums, ternary organic salts composed of triphenylacetates and two kinds of ammoniums construct the supramolecular clusters, affording a series of the supramolecular clusters with various kinds and numbers of the components.     

Resolution of 2-chloromandelic acid with (R)-(+)-N-benzyl-1-phenylethylamine: chiral discrimination mechanism

During the resolution of 2-chloromandelic acid with (R)-(+)-N-benzyl-1-phenylethylamine, the crystals of the less soluble salt were grown, and their structure were determined and presented. The chiral discrimination mechanism was investigated by examining the weak intermolecular interactions (such as hydrogen bond, CH/π, and van der Waals interactions) and molecular packing mode in crystal structure of the less soluble diastereomeric salt. A one-dimensional double-chain hydrogen-bonding network and a "lock-and-key" supramolecular packing mode are disclosed. The investigation demonstrates that hydrophobic layers with corrugated surfaces can fit into the grooves of one another to realize a compact packing, when the molecular structure of resolving agent is much larger than that of the racemate. This "lock-and-key" assembly is recognized to be another characteristic of molecular packing contributing to the chiral discrimination, in addition to the well-known sandwich-like packing by hydrophobic layers with planar boundary surfaces.     

First direct discrimination of chiral phosphine selenide (P=Se) derivatives by multinuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy in the presence of a chiral dirhodium complex

Enantiomeric ratios of compounds with P=Se functionalities (phosphine selenides) can easily be determined by (1)H, (13)C, (31)P, and (77)Se NMR spectroscopic inspection of their diastereomeric complexes with (R)-Rh(2)(MTPA)(4) (MTPA-H identical with methoxytrifluoromethylphenylacetic acid; Mosher's acid). This is the first facile and rapid spectroscopic method for chiral recognition in this class of compounds. Whereas most complexation shifts Delta(delta) are moderate or even negligible, significant signal dispersions Delta(nu) can be observed. Some rationalization for the adduct formation mode is presented. NMR spectral characteristics of the free P=Se compounds 1-5 are described.     

R2PI Study of intermolecular hydrogen bond in solvent-free chiral complexes.

One- and two-color, mass selected R2PI spectra of the S(1)<--S(0) transitions in the bare (+)-(R)-1-phenyl-1-ethanol (E(R)) and its complexes with different solvent molecules (solv) (-)-(R)-2-butanol (B(R)) or (+)-(S)-2-butanol (B(S)) and (-)-(R)-2-butylamine (A(R)) or (+)-(S)-2-butylamine (A(S)), have been recorded after a supersonic molecular beam expansion. The one-color R2PI excitation spectra of the diastereomeric complexes are characterized by significant shifts of their band origin relative to that of bare E(R). The extent and the direction of these spectral shifts are found to depend on the structure and the configuration of solv and are attributed to different short-range interactions in the ground and excited states of the complexes. In analogy with other diastereomeric complexes, the phenomenological binding energy of the homochiral cluster is found to be greater than that of the heterochiral one.     

Chiral recognition phenomena probed by steady-state luminescence measurements: Stern-Volmer analysis of chiral discriminatory behavior

The chiral recognition phenomenon observed in enantioselective excited-state energy transfer processes currently requires the use of chiroptical spectroscopic techniques to probe the magnitude and sense of the discriminatory interactions. The use of chiroptical spectroscopic techniques limits the study of chiral recognition to those molecular species with strong absorption or emission dissymmetry factors. This study presents the theoretical and experimental methodology to determine the magnitude of chiral discriminatory interactions with unpolarized, steady-state luminescence measurements. Based on bimolecular luminescence quenching kinetics for a system containing chiral molecules, the Stern-Volmer equation is derived and contains a chiral discriminatory term for a system containing a chiral but racemic luminophore and an enantiomerically resolved quencher species. The utility of this methodology is confirmed by examining the enantioselective excited-state quenching between several Ln(dpa)(3)(3-) complexes (where Ln = Eu(3+), Tb(3+), or Dy(3+) and dpa = pyridine-2,6-dicarboxylate) acting as the energy donor and either racemic or enantiomerically resolved [Co(dach)(3)](3+) (where dach = trans-1R,2R (or 1S,2S)-diaminocyclohexane) acting as the energy acceptor in an aqueous solution. The results of this study confirm the utility of unpolarized, steady-state luminescence measurements as a probe of chiral discriminatory behavior.     

Chiral recognition via helical sense and phase in a crystalline supramolecular array of intermeshed triple-helices

Hexatertiary butyl-substituted D(3)-symmetrical cage ligands composed of octahedral bidentate complexes of Ni(II) or Cu(II) ligated on either side to triskelion arrangements of three salicyl rings bound to a central nitrogen hub atom exhibit triple-helical conformations. Maximization of intermolecular aromatic-aromatic interactions between these complexes promote extended tongue and groove interleaving and affords a supramolecular array of diastereomeric intermeshed C(3)-symmetrical triple-helices perpetuating sideways throughout alternating enantiomeric layer stacks in the entire P-3 space group crystal lattice. Chiral recognition within these supramolecular ensembles is based upon the principles of helical sense and phase. A discussion of the symmetry, mechanical and chemical factors, and constraints influencing the formation of these self-assembled crystalline supramolecular ensembles will be presented.     

Molecular modeling of chiral-modified zeolite HY employed in enantioselective separation

Insight into enantioselective separation utilizing chiral-modified zeolite HY could be useful in designing a chiral stationary phase for resolving pharmaceutical compounds. A model was employed to better understand the enantioseparation of valinol in zeolite HY that contains (+)-(1R;2R)-hydrobenzoin as a chiral modifier. This model incorporates the zeolite support and accounts for the flexible change. Results from grand canonical Monte Carlo and molecular dynamics simulations indicate that the associated diastereomeric complex consists of a single (+)-(1R;2R)-hydrobenzoin and a single valinol molecules located in the zeolite HY supercage. Supercage-based docking simulation predicted an enantioselectivity of 2.6 compared with that of 1.4 measured experimentally. Also, the supercage-based docking simulation demonstrated a single binding motif in the S complex, and two binding motifs in the R complex. The multiple binding modes in the R complex resulted in its lower stability. This is hypothesized to be the origin of the weaker binding between (-)-(R)-valinol and the chiral modifier, and explains why (+)-(R)-valinol is retained more in the chiral-modified zeolite system studied.     

Elucidation of the chromatographic enantiomer elution order for praziquantel: An experimental and theoretical assessment

In this work, we have studied both experimentally and theoretically the praziquantel (PZQ) chiral discrimination. According to the main results, the enantioseparation of PZQ was efficiently optimized by HPLC on the reverse phase from the Chiralpak IB column, which has cellulose tris (3,5-dimethylphenylcarbamate) (CDMPC) as a chiral selector. The thermodynamic and structural parameters obtained via density functional theory (DFT) calculations pointed out the chiral discrimination as well as the enantiomeric elution order of PZQ, thus elucidating the experimental data and validating our proposed method. Finally, the hydrogen bonds and π-π stacking interactions played a key role in the discrimination between the PZQ diastereomeric complexes formed.     

Supramolecular exciton chirality of carotenoid aggregates

The conventional organic chemistry concept of chirality relates to single molecules. This article deals with cases in which exciton chirality is generated by the interaction of associated carotenoids. The handed property responsible for exciton signals in these systems is due to the alignment of neighboring molecules held together by secondary chemical forces. Their mutual positions are characterized by the overlay angle. Experimental manifestation is obtained by spectroscopic studies on carotenoid aggregates. Compared to molecular spectra, both UV/visible and circular dichroism spectroscopic observations reveal modified absorption bands and induced Cotton effects of opposite sign (exciton couplets), respectively. A new term, "supramolecular exciton chirality," is suggested for these phenomena, allowing the detection of weak chemical interactions not readily accessible for experimental studies, although highly important in the mechanism of biological processes.     

NMR studies of chiral discrimination relevant to the enantioseparation of N-acylarylalkylamines by an (R)-phenylglycinol-derived chiral selector

Recently, it was reported that the chiral recognition ability of (R)-N-3,5-dinitrobenzoyl phenylglycinol derivative was examined as a new HPLC chiral stationary phase (CSP 1) for the resolution of racemic N-acylnaphthylalkylamines. However, the mechanism of chiral discrimination on the CSP remained elusive until now. In this study, a spectroscopic investigation of the chiral discrimination mechanism of CSP 1 was undertaken using mixtures of (R)-N-3,5-dinitrobenzoyl phenylglycinol-derived chiral selector (2) and each of the enantiomers of N-acylnaphthylalkylamines (3) by NMR study. First, the differences in free energy changes (DeltaDeltaG) upon diastereomeric complexation in solution between the complex of each isomer with chiral selector 2 by NMR titration were calculated. The values were then compared with those estimated by chiral HPLC. The chemical shift changes of each proton on the chiral selector and analytes were also checked and it was found that the chemical shift changes decreased continuously as the acyl group on analytes increased in length. This observation was consistent with the HPLC data. From these experimental results, the interaction mechanism of chiral discrimination between the chiral selector and the analytes is more precisely explained.     

The chirality selectivity in the uptake of platinum (II) complexes with 1,2-cyclohexanediamine isomers as carrier ligand by human erythrocytes

The uptake kinetics of cisplatin analogs of 1,2-cyclohexanediamine(dach) isomers with various leaving groups, by human erythrocytes in plasma isotonic buffer, were studied. The experimental results showed that the uptake rate constants (k values) decrease with the change of leaving group in the sequence: chloride (Cl) > squaric acid (SA) > oxalate (OX) > demethylcantharic acid (DA), with the same dach isomer as carrier group. It is noteworthy that for the platinum (II) complexes with the same leaving group, the k values always reduce as: 1R, 2R-dach > 1R, 2S-dach > 1S, 2S-dach. This result reflects the chirality selectivity. No differences in reactivity to protein thiols and effects on membrane permeability were found for the R,R-, R,S-, S,S-isomeric complexes. It is proposed that the chirality selectivity in uptake is due to the recognition of the chirality of the platinum complexes by the erythrocyte membrane. The interactions between the chiral platinum complexes and the head groups of the membrane phospholipid molecules are probably involved.