Effects of butyrate precursors on electron relocation when methanogenesis is inhibited in ruminal mixed cultures

AIMS: Inhibition of ruminal methanogenesis often causes accumulation of H(2), formate and ethanol, which are not energy substrates for ruminants. It was hypothesized that the addition of butyrate precursors would avoid the formation of these products and relocate electrons into butyrate. METHODS AND RESULTS: In four ruminal 24-h incubations, two inhibitors of methanogenesis, each at three different initial concentrations (0, 2 or 4 mmol l(-1) for propynoic acid, and 0, 4 or 8 mmol l(-1) for ethyl 2-butynoate), were combined with two butyrate precursors at two different initial concentrations (0 or 4 mmol l(-1) for crotonic acid or 3-butenoic acid). Ground lucerne hay was the substrate. Propynoic acid at 4 mmol l(-1) decreased CH(4) formation by more than two-thirds. Ethyl 2-butynoate at 8 mmol l(-1) suppressed methanogenesis by more than 90%. Butyrate precursors generally did not decrease the accumulation of H(2) and formate or ethanol production. CONCLUSIONS: Butyrate precursors were ineffective as electron acceptors because they were not completely converted to butyrate and were also metabolized through other pathways. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: Effectiveness of butyrate precursors may be improved by adding them to the fermentation continuously or by enhancing the kinetics of their conversion into butyrate.     

Use of some novel alternative electron sinks to inhibit ruminal methanogenesis

Several compounds were evaluated in vitro as alternative electron sinks to ruminal methanogenesis. They were incubated with ruminal fluid, buffer mixture, and finely ground alfalfa hay for 24 h, at 0, 6, 12, and 18 mM initial concentrations. The propionate enhancer oxaloacetic acid, the butyrate enhancer beta-hydroxybutyrate, and the butyrate unsaturated analog 3-butenoic acid were ineffective in decreasing methanogenesis. Nevertheless, beta-hydroxybutyrate increased apparent fermentation of the alfalfa hay substrate from 58.0 to 63.4%, and 3-butenoic acid seemed to increase it from 62.0 to 73.7%. Almost all of added oxaloacetic acid disappeared during the incubation, while only between 30.3 and 53.4% of beta-hydroxybutyrate disappeared. The butyrate enhancers acetoacetate and crotonic acid, and the butyrate unsaturated analog 2-butynoic acid, decreased methanogenesis by a maximum of 18,9 and 9%, respectively. Crotonic acid at 18 mM initial concentration seemed to increase the substrate apparent fermentation from 57.0 to 68.2%. Between 78.6 and 100% of acetoacetate disappeared during the incubation. The propionate unsaturated analog propynoic acid, and the unsaturated ester ethyl 2-butynoate, decreased methanogenesis by a maximum of 76 and 79%, respectively. Less than 5% of propynoic acid disappeared. The substrate apparent fermentation was decreased by propynoic acid from 62.0 to 57.4%, and seemed to have been decreased by ethyl 2-butynoate from 62.0 to 29.3%. More accurate measurements of the disappearance of some of the compounds studied are needed to better understand how they are metabolized and how they affect fermentation.     

Effects of several inhibitors on pure cultures of ruminal methanogens

AIMS: To examine the effects of five inhibitors of methanogenesis, 2-bromoethanesulphonate (BES), 3-bromopropanesulphonate (BPS), lumazine, propynoic acid and ethyl 2-butynoate, on CH4 production of the ruminal methanogens Methanobrevibacter ruminantium, Methanosarcina mazei and Methanomicrobium mobile. METHODS AND RESULTS: Methanogens were grown in MS medium including 25% (v/v) clarified ruminal fluid. Methane production was measured after 4 and 6 days of incubation. Methanobrevibacter ruminantium was the most sensitive species to BES, propynoic acid and ethyl 2-butynoate. Methanosarcina mazei was the least sensitive species to those chemical additives, and Mm. mobile was intermediate. BPS failed to inhibit any of the methanogens. All three species were almost completely inhibited by 50- and 100%-lumazine saturated media, but the inhibition was somewhat lower with a 25%-lumazine saturated media. CONCLUSIONS: There were important differences among species of methanogens regarding their sensitivity to the different inhibitors. In general, Ms. mazei was the most resistant to inhibitors, Mb. ruminantium the least resistant, and Mm. mobile was intermediate. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: Differences among methanogens regarding their resistance to chemical inhibitors should be considered when designing strategies of inhibition of ruminal methanogenesis, as selection of resistant species may result.     

Chemical inhibitors of methanogenesis and putative applications

This mini-review summarizes the category, characteristics, and the application fields of the chemical methanogenic inhibitors. Usually, the chemical methanogenic inhibitors can be divided into “specific” and nonspecific inhibitors. The former group includes the structural analogs of coenzyme M and HMG-CoA inhibitors. The nonspecific group includes many chemicals which can inhibit the activity of both methanogens and non-methanogens. The chemical inhibitors of methanogenesis have been widely used in the fields of understanding methane production and consumption in pure culture or in complex natural environment, production of value-added substances, such as volatile fatty acids and hydrogen, and reduction of energy loss and improvement of the efficiency of ruminal energetic transformations. Finally, with an increasing understanding of the mechanistic effects of the chemical inhibitors of methanogenesis, it is possible that some could be used to develop into promising feed additives to reduce losses associated with enteric methane production or as useful tools to screen microbial consortia from various biotechnological applications to enhance hydrogen and acid production.     

Studies on potential effects of fumaric acid on rumen microbial fermentation,methane production and microbial community

The greenhouse gas methane (CH₄) contributes substantially to global climate change. As a potential approach to decrease ruminal methanogenesis, the effects of different dosages of fumaric acid (FA) on ruminal microbial metabolism and on the microbial community (archaea, bacteria) were studied using a rumen simulation technique (RUSITEC). FA acts as alternative hydrogen acceptor diverting 2H from methanogenesis of archaea towards propionate formation of bacteria. Three identical trials were conducted with 12 fermentation vessels over a period of 14 days. In each trial, four fermentation vessels were assigned to one of the three treatment groups differing in FA dosage: low fumaric acid (LFA), high fumaric acid (HFA) and without FA (control). FA was continuously infused with the buffer. Grass silage and concentrate served as substrate. FA led to decreases in pH and to higher production rates of total short chain fatty acids (SCFA) mediated by increases in propionate for LFA of 1.69 mmol d^?1 and in propionate and acetate production for HFA of 4.49 and 1.10 mmol d^?1, respectively. Concentrations of NH₃-N, microbial crude protein synthesis, their efficiency, degradation of crude nutrients and detergent fibre fraction were unchanged. Total gas and CH₄ production were not affected by FA. Effects of FA on structure of microbial community by means of single strand conformation polymorphism (SSCP) analyses could not be detected. Given the observed increase in propionate production and the unaffected CH₄ production it can be supposed that the availability of reduction equivalents like 2H was not limited by the addition of FA in this study. It has to be concluded from the present study that the application of FA is not an appropriate approach to decrease the ruminal CH₄ production.     

溶菌酶对瘤胃体外发酵、甲烷生成及微生物菌群结构的影响

【目的】通过体外静态模拟瘤胃发酵法研究溶菌酶对瘤胃发酵、甲烷生成及微生物菌群结构的影响。【方法】采用单因素多水平试验设计,溶菌酶添加水平分别为0(L-0,对照组)、0.1 mg/100 m L(L-0.1)、1 mg/100 m L(L-1)、10 mg/100 m L(L-10)和100 mg/100 m L(L-100),定时测定产气量和甲烷产量,培养24 h后,发酵液用于发酵参数和微生物菌群数量的q PCR测定,其中L-0、L-1和L-100三个组发酵液同时进行16S r RNA基因Illumina高通量测序。【结果】与对照组相比,低剂量溶菌酶添加(L-0.1组)不影响甲烷产量、氨氮浓度、干物质消失率、有机物消失率和总挥发性脂肪酸等瘤胃发酵参数(P0.05);随着剂量提高,L-1处理组甲烷产量、氨氮浓度显著降低(P0.05),丙酸浓度显著增加(P0.05),并且干物质消失率、有机物消失率和总挥发性脂肪酸不受影响(P0.05);而较高剂量组(L-10和L-100组)虽然甲烷产量显著降低,丙酸浓度显著增加(P0.05),但干物质消失率和有机物消失率也显著降低(P0.05)。q PCR结果显示高剂量组(L-100组)总菌、原虫、甲烷菌数量与对照组相比显著降低(P0.05),而L-0.1、L-1和L-10组总菌、真菌和原虫数量与对照组相比均无显著变化(P0.05)。高通量测序主成分分析(PCA)显示对照组与溶菌酶添加组间瘤胃细菌组成的明显区分,说明添加溶菌酶显著改变了瘤胃细菌菌群结构。溶菌酶通过增加月形单胞菌和琥珀酸弧菌等丙酸生成菌的相对丰度,使更多的氢被用于生成丙酸,导致甲烷产量降低;溶菌酶可抑制普雷沃氏菌和拟杆菌属等蛋白降解菌的生长,进而减少蛋白质过度降解,降低氨氮浓度。【结论】添加适宜浓度(1 mg/100 m L)的溶菌酶可通过调控瘤胃微生态改变瘤胃发酵模式,降低瘤胃甲烷和氨的生成,短期内并不影响饲料消化。     

Effects of methanogenic inhibitors on methane production and abundances of methanogens and cellulolytic bacteria in in vitro ruminal cultures

The objective of this study was to systematically evaluate and compare the effects of select antimethanogen compounds on methane production, feed digestion and fermentation, and populations of ruminal bacteria and methanogens using in vitro cultures. Seven compounds, including 2-bromoethanesulphonate (BES), propynoic acid (PA), nitroethane (NE), ethyl trans-2-butenoate (ETB), 2-nitroethanol (2NEOH), sodium nitrate (SN), and ethyl-2-butynote (EB), were tested at a final concentration of 12 mM. Ground alfalfa hay was included as the only substrate to simulate daily forage intake. Compared to no-inhibitor controls, PA, 2NEOH, and SN greatly reduced the production of methane (70 to 99%), volatile fatty acids (VFAs; 46 to 66%), acetate (30 to 60%), and propionate (79 to 82%), with 2NEOH reducing the most. EB reduced methane production by 23% without a significant effect on total VFAs, acetate, or propionate. BES significantly reduced the propionate concentration but not the production of methane, total VFAs, or acetate. ETB or NE had no significant effect on any of the above-mentioned measurements. Specific quantitative-PCR (qPCR) assays showed that none of the inhibitors significantly affected total bacterial populations but that they did reduce the Fibrobacter succinogenes population. SN reduced the Ruminococcus albus population, while PA and 2NEOH increased the populations of both R. albus and Ruminococcus flavefaciens. Archaeon-specific PCR-denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) showed that all the inhibitors affected the methanogen population structure, while archaeon-specific qPCR revealed a significant decrease in methanogen population in all treatments. These results showed that EB, ETB, NE, and BES can effectively reduce the total population of methanogens but that they reduce methane production to a lesser extent. The results may guide future in vivo studies to develop effective mitigation of methane emission from ruminants.     

The effect of pH on ruminal methanogenesis

Abstract: When a fistulated cow was fed an all forage diet, ruminal pH remained more or less constant (6.7 to 6.9). The ruminal pH of a concentrate-fed cow decreased dramatically in the period soon after feeding, and the pH was as low as 5.45. Mixed ruminal bacteria from the forage-fed cow converted CO₂ and H₂ to methane, but the ruminal fluid from the concentrate-fed cow did not produce methane. When the pH of the ruminal fluid from the concentrate-fed cow was adjusted to pH 7.0, methane was eventually detected, and the absolute rate constant of methane production was as high as the one observed with ruminal fluid from the forage fed cow (0.32 h⁻¹). Based on the zero-time intercepts of methane production, it appeared that the concentrate-fed cow had fewer methanogens than the forage-fed cow. When the mixed ruminal bacteria were incubated in a basal medium containing 100 mM acetate, methanogenesis was pH-dependent, and no methane was detected at pH values less than 6.0. Because the removal of acetic acid completely reversed the inhibition of methanogenesis, it appeared that volatile fatty acids were causing the pH-dependent inhibition. Based on these results, concentrate diets that lower ruminal pH may provide a practical means of decreasing ruminal methane production.     

Effect of select nitrocompounds on ruminal fermentation; an initial look at their potential to reduce economic and environmental costs associated with ruminal methanogenesis

Methane production by ruminal microbes during the digestion of feedstuffs is an inefficient process resulting in losses of 2-12% of the gross energy consumed by ruminants. Presently, we report the effect of three inhibitors on ruminal methane production in vitro. Mixed populations of ruminal microbes collected from cannulated cows maintained on an alfalfa hay:corn diet (50:50) were incubated at 39 degrees C for 24 h under a 100% carbon dioxide gas phase in closed tubes with 72 mM added sodium formate. Cultures were supplemented with 12 mM 2-nitropropanol, nitroethane or nitroethanol (experiment 1) or with 2, 12 or 24 mM nitroethane or a combination of 12 mM nitroethane and 4 mM nitroethanol (experiment 2). Control cultures containing no added nitrocompound were incubated simultaneously with treated incubations. Methane concentrations were reduced (P<0.05) from those measured in control incubations (27.6 +/- 2.1 and 17.7 +/- 0.8 micromol/ml; mean +/- SD for experiments 1 and 2, respectively) by at least 57% and as much as 94% in the nitrocompound supplemented incubations. By comparison, the widely fed methane inhibitor, monensin, typically reduces ruminal methane production by about 33%. Concentrations of volatile fatty acids and ammonia that accumulated in the nitrocompound supplemented incubations were not markedly affected compared to those produced by control cultures despite the reductions in methane produced. Hydrogen accumulated only slightly in cultures supplemented with the nitrocompounds. These results demonstrate that 2-nitropropanol, nitroethane and nitroethanol inhibit ruminal methane production. Further research is warranted to determine the mechanisms responsible for this inhibition and to see if these inhibitors can be used in practical application to reduce economic and environmental costs associated with ruminal methanogenesis.     

Effects of volatile fatty acids,ammonium and agitation on thermophilic methane production from biogas plant sludge in lab-scale experiments

The effects of different volatile fatty acids (VFA, formate, acetate, propionate and butyrate), ammonium (NH (4) (+)) and agitation on methane (CH(4)) production were determined in 120-mL serum bottles. We showed that the addition of formate did not lead to an inhibition of methanogenesis until a concentration of 120 mmol/L. A complete inhibition of methanogenesis was detected in variants containing 360 mmol/L formate or propionate until day 3 but the production started afterwards within next 2 days. This might indicate a kind of adaptation to the higher volatile fatty acid concentrations. Increasing NH (4) (+) concentrations led to higher initial CH(4) production, with an optimum at 120 mmol/L. The addition of 720 mmol/L NH (4) (+) led to a complete inhibition until day 3; subsequently, CH(4) production started again on day 5 though it was still significantly lower compared to the other variants. Finally, also the speed of agitation showed significant effects on methanogenesis. The CH(4) production from complex carbon sources was most favourable at a moderate agitation of 150 rpm of the lab-scale serum bottles. A lower or higher speed brought about a distinct reduction of CH(4) production.     

Changes in microbial community structure, methanogenesis and rumen fermentation in response to saponin-rich fractions from different plant materials

Aims:  Investigation of the effects of saponin-rich fractions on rumen fermentation, methane production and the microbial community.
Methods and Results:  Saponins were extracted from Carduus , Sesbania and Knautia leaves and fenugreek seeds. Two levels of saponin-rich fractions with a substrate were incubated using the Hohenheim gas method. Methane was measured using an infrared-based methane analyser and microbial communities using quantitative PCR. On addition of saponin-rich fractions, methane and short-chain fatty acid production was not affected. The protozoal counts decreased by 10–39%. Sesbania saponins decreased methanogen population by 78%. Decrease in ruminal fungal population (20–60%) and increase in Fibrobacter succinogenes (21–45%) and Ruminococcus flavefaciens (23–40%) were observed.
Conclusions:  The saponins evaluated possessed anti-protozoal activity; however, this activity did not lead to methane reduction. Fenugreek saponins seemed to have potential for increasing rumen efficiency. The saponins altered the microbial community towards proliferation of fibre-degrading bacteria and inhibition of fungal population.
Significance and Impact of the Study:  The uni-directional relationship between protozoal numbers and methanogenesis, as affected by saponins, is not obligatory. All saponins might not hold promise for decreasing methane production from ruminants.     

Crotonic acid as a bioactive factor in carrot seeds (Daucus carota L.)

Water extracts from the carrot seed (Daucus carota L.) var. Perfekcja exhibit plant growth inhibitory properties against cress, cucumber, onion and carrot in a dose-dependant manner. This property results from the action of low-and high-molecular components of the extract. The low-molecular component was identified as crotonic acid ((E)-2-butenoic acid). Its presence was also confirmed in other late varieties of carrot. The determined strong herbicidal properties of crotonic acid and its availability after release to soil combined with its high level in seeds suggest that it might be considered as an allelopathic and autotoxic factor in the seeds.     

The effect of pectin, corn and wheat starch, inulin and pH on in vitro production of methane, short chain fatty acids and on the microbial community composition in rumen fluid

Methane emission from livestock, ruminants in particular, contributes to the build up of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere. Therefore the focus on methane emission from ruminants has increased. The objective of this study was to investigate mechanisms for methanogenesis in a rumen fluid-based in vitro fermentation system as a consequence of carbohydrate source (pectin, wheat and corn starch and inulin) and pH (ranging from 5.5 to 7.0). Effects were evaluated with respect to methane and short chain fatty acid (SCFA) production, and changes in the microbial community in the ruminal fluid as assessed by terminal-restriction fragment length polymorphism (T-RFLP) analysis. Fermentation of pectin resulted in significantly lower methane production rates during the first 10 h of fermentation compared to the other substrates (P = 0.001), although total methane production was unaffected by carbohydrate source (P = 0.531). Total acetic acid production was highest for pectin and lowest for inulin (P < 0.001) and vice versa for butyric acid production from pectin and inulin (P < 0.001). Total propionic acid production was unaffected by the carbohydrate source (P = 0.791). Methane production rates were significantly lower for fermentations at pH 5.5 and 7.0 (P = 0.005), sustained as a trend after 48 h (P = 0.059), indicating that there was a general optimum for methanogenic activity in the pH range from 6.0 to 6.5. Decreasing pH from 7.0 to 5.5 significantly favored total butyric acid production (P < 0.001). Principle component analysis of T-RFLP patterns revealed that both pectin and pH 5.5 resulted in pronounced changes in the microbial community composition. This study demonstrates that both carbohydrate source and pH affect methane and SCFA production patterns, and the microbial community composition in rumen fluid.     

Inhibitory effects of nitrogen oxides on a mixed methanogenic culture

The effect of nitrate, nitrite, nitric oxide (NO), and nitrous oxide on a mixed, mesophilic (35 degrees C) methanogenic culture was investigated. Short-term inhibition assays were conducted at a concentration range of 10-350 mg N/L nitrate, 17-500 mg N/L nitrite, 0.02-0.8 mg N/L aqueous NO, and 19-191 mg N/L aqueous nitrous oxide. Simultaneous methane production and N-oxide reduction was observed in 10 and 30 mg N/L nitrate and 0.02 mg N/L aqueous NO-amended cultures. However, addition of N-oxide resulted in immediate cessation of methanogenesis in all other cultures. Methanogenesis completely recovered subsequent to the complete reduction of N-oxides to nitrogen gas in all N-oxide-amended cultures, with the exception of the 500 mg N/L nitrite- and 0.8 mg N/L aqueous NO-amended cultures. Partial recovery of methanogenesis was observed in the 500 mg N/L nitrite-amended culture in contrast to complete inhibition of methanogenesis in the 0.8 mg N/L aqueous NO-amended culture. Accumulation of volatile fatty acids was observed in both cultures at the end of the incubation period. Among all N-oxides, NO exerted the most and nitrate exerted the least inhibitory effect on the fermentative/methanogenic consortia. The effect of multiple additions of nitrate (300 mg N/L) on the same methanogenic culture was also investigated. Long-term exposure of the methanogenic culture to nitrate resulted in an increase of N-oxide reduction rates and decrease of methane production rates, which was attributed to changes in the microbial community structure due to nitrate addition.     

Biotechnology and the improvement of silage (tropical and temperate) rumen digestion: a mini-review

Summary As with forage diets in general, ensiled tropical residue feeds and temperate grass and legume herbage tend to have lower fibre digestibility, ruminal biomass production and feed bypass, resulting in limited protein nutrition and intake in the animal. Various modified (recombinant and mutated) microbial inculants might be used mainly to: (1) boost lactic acid production in temperate silage to stabilize against further clostridial protein breakdown during the ensiling process and effect silage fibre (lignin, cellulose, and hemicellulose) digestion to increase digestibility and (2) increase microbial digestion of fibre along with boosting microbial protein synthesis to increase microbial biomass production in the rumen.     

Fermentation of methanol in the sheep rumen

Sheep fed a hay-concentrate diet were adapted to pectin administration and ruminal infusion of methanol. Both treatments resulted in a strong increase in the rate of methanogenesis from methanol. Quantitative data show that methanol was exclusively converted into methane. Treatments did not influence ruminal volatile fatty acid percentages.     

瘤胃甲烷菌及甲烷生成的调控

甲烷菌属于古细菌 ,参与有机物的厌氧降解 ,生成甲烷。反刍动物瘤胃内甲烷的生成损耗 2 %～ 12 %的饲料能量 ,并且通过嗳气排入大气。甲烷不仅是温室气体之一 ,而且还会破坏大气臭氧层。每年全球反刍动物排放大量的甲烷 ,减少瘤胃内甲烷的生成对提高饲料能量利用率和改善环境具有重要意义。近年来 ,有关瘤胃甲烷菌及甲烷生成调控的报道日益增多。概述甲烷菌的特性以及瘤胃内甲烷生成的途径 ,综述甲烷生成的调控手段 ,主要包括去原虫、日粮配合、添加电子受体、增加乙酸生成菌等方法     

Fermentation of methanol in the sheep rumen.

Sheep fed a hay-concentrate diet were adapted to pectin administration and ruminal infusion of methanol. Both treatments resulted in a strong increase in the rate of methanogenesis from methanol. Quantitative data show that methanol was exclusively converted into methane. Treatments did not influence ruminal volatile fatty acid percentages.     

The pterin lumazine inhibits growth of methanogens and methane formation

The pterin compound lumazine [2, 4-(1H, 3H)-pteridinedione] inhibited the growth of several methanogenic archaea completely at a concentration of ≤ 0.6 mM and was bacteriocidal for Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum strain Marburg. In contrast, growth of two non-methanogenic archaea, several eubacteria, and one eukaryote was not strongly affected at much higher concentrations. In washed-cell suspensions, methanogenesis from H₂ and CO₂ by Mb. thermoautotrophicum or from H₂ and methanol by Methanosarcina barkeri was inhibited by addition of lumazine. In cell-free extracts of Mb. thermoautotrophicum, H₂-driven methane production from CO₂ or CH₃-S-CoM was completely inhibited by 0.6 mM lumazine. The results suggest that the compound may be useful in probing the methanogenesis pathway or in selecting against methanogens. Received: 30 January 1996 / Accepted 15 May 1996     

瘤胃甲烷调控方法评述

反刍动物释放的甲烷不仅消耗6％～10％的能量摄入,而且是重要的温室效应气体。过去20多年以来,研究人员围绕瘤胃甲烷生成及其调控展开了大量的研究,目前采取的主要措施包括：（1）提供电子释放新途径;（2）利用疫苗、生物控制剂（噬菌体和细菌素）以及化学抑制剂等抑制产甲烷菌,以及（3）去原虫、添加植物提取物或有机酸等促进产乙酸菌增加,降低产甲烷菌可利用的氢。瘤胃生态系统是一个复杂的生态系统,能够将复杂碳水化合物转化成为挥发性脂肪酸,这个过程部分依赖于甲烷的生成和氢的消耗。因此,虽然各种调控措施能够在短期内抑制甲烷生成,但瘤胃微生态系统能够恢复原有的甲烷生成水平,这表明我们对瘤胃中氢代谢仍然认识不足。进一步提高对瘤胃内氢和甲烷生成的微生物生化机制的了解,有助于我们找到有效的甲烷调控措施。