Effect of anti-beta2-microglobulin on antigen and allogeneic lymphocyte-induced proliferation of human lymphocytes.

The effect of anti-beta2-microglobulin (beta2m) on the mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR), and an antigen-induced proliferative response was studied. Anti-beta2m IgG and Fab' fragments completely inhibited the MLR. Preincubation of stimulator or responder cells with anti-beta2m suggested that the major effect of anti-beta2m may be on the responder cell population. A clear-cut effect on responder cells was demonstrated by showing that anti-beta2m completely inhibited a MLR in which the stimulator population was a beta2m negative lymphoblastoid cell line. Anti-beta2m also inhibited PPD-induced proliferation of sensitized lymphocytes. The kinetics of this inhibition indicated that anti-beta2m added within the first 18 hr of stimulation was effective in inhibiting the proliferative response. These data are discussed in light of the hypothesis that beta2m may be a subunit of an antigen receptor on T cells.     

Specific inhibition of human lymphocyte responses by primed autologous lymphocytes. I. Evaluation of MLR inhibition as a model for suppression.

Human lymphocytes from person A, primed for 10 to 14 days in MLC against lymphocytes from person B, inhibit specifically the proliferative response to B by fresh (i.e., unprimed) lymphocytes of A. Gamma-irradiated (2000 R) primed lymphocytes likewise inhibit specifically, although less strongly. Cells of A, primed with cells of B and then irradiated, usually can inhibit the response of A to cells of any individual sharing HLA-D antigens with B, and the effect tends to be independent of the number of stimulating cells. We also often see inhibition of responses to cells sharing HLA-A and -B antigens with person B, but this effect tends to be lost when the number of stimulating cells is increased. Similarly, at low doses, cells primed for HLA-D antigen a appear not to inhibit the response to an irrelevant HLA-D antigen b on the same stimulating cell. At higher doses of primed cells, even the response to the irrelevant antigen is inhibited. These data suggest to us that at least two mechnaisms may be involved: one directed at the stimulating cell (most likely cell-mediated cytolysis), and predominant at high ratios of primed cells to stimulating cells; the other directed at specific clones of responding cells, and predominant at low ratios.     

Activation of human B lymphocytes. V. Kinetics and mechanisms of suppression of plaque-forming cell responses by concanavalin A-generated suppressor cells.

The kinetics and mechanisms of suppression of the PWM-induced PFC response of human PB lymphocytes by Con A-activated suppressor cells were investigated. It was necessary that Con A suppressor cells be present early in the process of activation of human B cells toward antibody syntheses, but maximal suppression of the PFC response occurred later in the culture period. In addition, Con A-activated cells, although suppressing the PFC response to PWM greater that 90% of control, did not significantly suppress the blastogenic response to PWM after 3 or 5 days in culture. On the contrary, after 3 days in culture, background tritiated thymidine incorporation as well as tritiated thymidine incorporation to PWM stimulation was increased when Con A suppressor cells are added to fresh autologous peripheral blood lymphocytes. This increased blastogenic response after three days most likely represented an autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) or Con A suppressor cells against fresh autologous non-T cells. The induction of autoreactive cells may be one of several modes of suppression of PFC responses by Con A activated suppressor cells.     

Effect of glucocorticoids on the development of suppressive activity in human lymphocyte response to a polysaccharide purified from Candida albicans

The action of glucocorticoids on the proliferative response of human lymphocytes stimulated in vitro by MPPS has been investigated. The effect of Dex was dependent on the time of steroid addition to the cultures. Dex added at the beginning of the culture period inhibited, cell proliferation and IL 1/IL 2 synthesis, although not completely. However, a delayed addition of 24 to 48 hr resulted in an enhancing effect on cell proliferative responses that was maximal at day 4. The effect of Dex on T suppressor cell activity was then investigated. Dex added 1 day before the appearance of suppressor cells resulted in a marked decrease or disappearance of the suppressive activity. Moreover, primed T lymphocytes treated with Dex in the presence of exogenous IL 2 enhanced the proliferative responses of fresh autologous PBMC stimulated by MPPS. Taken together, our data suggest that glucocorticoids inhibit the differentiation of T suppressor cells and that IL 2 is unable to reverse this inhibitory effect.     

Evidence for the presence of suppressor T lymphocytes in animals treated with cyclosporin A

Mice sensitized with alloantigens and treated with cyclosporin A (CsA) were incapable of generating antigen-specific cytolytic lymphocytes (CL). Lymphocytes from these CsA-treated animals could not be reactivated upon exposure to the same alloantigens in mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC), whereas their response to a third-party antigen remained intact, suggesting a long-lasting and specific effect of CsA. After being irradiated, these lymphocytes from CsA-treated animals were added to normal MLC and were shown to prevent normal lymphocytes from becoming cytolytic in a dose-dependent and antigen-nonspecific fashion. These suppressor cells were not detected in mice receiving CsA only, indicating that CsA did not induce but rather permitted the expression of suppressor cells possibly generated by allosensitization. The suppressor cells appeared to be T lymphocytes, because treatment with anti-Thy-1.2 antibody and C abrogated their suppressive activity. The present results suggest that activation and/or sparing of suppressor cells by CsA may account for the long-lasting unresponsiveness seen in CsA-treated animals.     

Activation of human B lymphocytes by a particulate antigen

A specific IgM antibody response toward the trinitrophenol (TNP) hapten can be induced in mononuclear blood cell suspensions upon culture with a particulate antigen: polyacrylamide beads conjugated with the TNP hapten (TNP-PAA). The response, and its specificity, are demonstrated by an increase in the number of TNP binding B lymphocytes (specific rosette forming cells), by the appearance of cells producing anti-TNP antibody at a high rate (haemolytic plaques), (ELISA test). The anti-TNP response requires monocytes, the role of which is to produce interleukin-1 (IL-1) and T lymphocytes (belonging to the T4 helper subset) the role of which is to produce interleukins (the characterization of which is under study). We propose a model or B cell activation based on the following signals: an early specific signal, provided by the particulate antigen; several non specific signals, provided by T derived interleukins. The anti-TNP response is negatively regulated by monocytes, the functional states of which can be modified in certain situations (autoimmunity, aging) or influenced by glucocorticoids. Suppressor T lymphocytes of this response (not exclusively of the T8 phenotype) can be induced and this can allow the evaluation of T suppressor cell function. This was used in adult idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura treated with high doses of intra-venous gammaglobulins.     

Specific absorption of T lymphocytes committed to soluble protein antigens by incubation on antigen-pulsed macrophage monolayers.

Monolayers of macrophages (Mphi) pulsed with antigen were used as immunosorbents for T lymphocytes from guinea pigs primed to soluble protein antigens. T lymphocytes were cultured on the Mphi monolayers for 4 hr, then aspirated and reincubated on a fresh monolayer pulsed with the same antigen for a second and a third step. T lymphocytes so treated were selectively deprived of cells responding in assay for antigen-dependent proliferation against the antigen used for pulsing the absorbing monolayer, but maintained their response to other antigens. The lymphocytes adhering to the Mphi of the absorbing monolayer were capable of giving a full response to the antigen used for pulsing the Mphi of the monolyers. The proliferative response of F1 T lymphocytes to antigen in association with Mphi of either parental strain could be absorbed leaving the response to antigen in association with Mphi of the other parental strain. The absorption of the proliferative response was not inhibited by addition of excess soluble antigen to the medium of the absorption culture. Our results indicate that specific guinea pig T lymphocytes responding by proliferation to soluble protein antigens recognize and bind specifically to a complex of Ia antigen and protein antigen at the surface of the Mphi.     

Histamine-induced suppressor factor (HSF): effect on migration inhibitory factor (MIF) production and proliferation.

Histamine added in vitro to cultures of sensitized lymphocytes suppresses antigen-induced production of migration inhibitory factor (MIF) and proliferation by these cells. Recent studies have suggested that lymphocytes bearing histamine type-2 receptors play a regulatory role in these in vitro responses. The present studies were undertaken to determine if suppressor function by cells having histamine receptors was mediated through a soluble product. It was found that lymph node cells from nonimmune or immune strain 2 guinea pigs elaborate a nondialyzable factor into the culture supernatant when incubated with 10(-3) to 10(-5) M histamine (histamine-induced suppressor factor of HSF). HSF, when cocultured with sensitized lymphocytes, suppressed their MIF and proliferative responses to antigen. HSF was made by lymphocytes but not macrophages. Its production could be blocked by an H2 receptor antagonist (burimamide) but not an H1 receptor antagonist (chlorpheniramine). Furthermore, the inhibitory effect of HSF was reversible as lymphocytes washed free of the factor after 24 hr and recultured with fresh medium and antigen were able to produce MIF. Gel filtration by Sephadex G-100 chromatography indicated that HSF had an approximate m.w. of 23,000 to 40,000. These results suggest that the release of histamine at the sites of immediate hypersensitivity reactions, possibly by generating HSF activity, may play a regulatory role in the subsequent development of cellular-immune reactions at the same site.     

Role of nominal antigen and Ia antigen in the binding of antigen-specific T lymphocytes to macrophages.

We have previously demonstrated that when primed T lymphocytes were repeatedly incubated on monolayers of antigen-pulsed macrophages (M phi), the cells that failed to adhere to the monolayer demonstrated a marked depletion of their proliferative response that was specific both for the antigen used for pulsing the M phi and for Ia determinants on the M phi. In order to further analyze the contribution of the nominal antigen and Ia antigens to the physical binding of T lymphocytes to M phi, we have attempted to block the absorption of T lymphocytes to M phi with a large excess of soluble antigen and with anti-Ia sera. Our results demonstrate that anti-Ia sera inhibit but that soluble antigen augments the binding of specific T lymphocytes to M phi. The implications of these findings for "dual recognition" and "linked recognition" models of T lymphocyte receptors are discussed.     

T-T interactions in the induction of antigen-specific human suppressor T lymphocytes in vitro.

We intended to investigate whether the suppression of antigen-induced antibody responses in vitro in man by T suppressor cells required contact of T suppressor cells with target cells or whether this effect was mediated by factors released by T suppressor cells. To this end supernatants of antigen-induced T suppressor cells were tested (by a plaque forming cell assay) for their capacity to suppress antibody responses of autologous and allogeneic human peripheral blood lymphocytes. We have shown that supernatants of antigen-specific T suppressor cells, designated as TsF24: a) can suppress an antibody response of autologous but not allogeneic lymphocytes to the inducing antigen; b) are antigen-specific in their effect; and 3) are produced by radiosensitive T cells. Furthermore, the target of the factor is a radiosensitive T cell. These findings taken together indicate that, in the generation of T-effector suppressor cells in man, T-T interactions occur, and in addition, that cellfree factors may be involved in these interactions.     

Effects of concanavalin A-induced cells on the proliferative response of T cells. Concanavalin A-induced suppressor and amplifier cells to the proliferative response of human T cells to trinitrophenyl-modified autologous lymphocytes.

Effects of Con A-induced human mononuclear cells on the proliferative response of peripheral T cells were examined by using TNP-modified autologous lymphocytes as stimulator cells. Cells induced by incubation with Con A contained both suppressor cells and amplifier cells. The former were induced from nylon wool-nonadherent T cells and these precursor cells were sensitive to mitomycin treatment. On the other hand, amplifier precursor cells were nylon wool-nonadherent T cells and were resistant to mitomycin treatment. Cell proliferation was required for the induction of suppressor cells but not for the induction of amplifier cells. Con A-induced suppressor effector cells were both nylon wool-adherent and nonadherent cells, on the contrary, Con A-induced amplifier effector cells were nonadherent cells. A small number of macrophages enhanced the suppressive activity of nonadherent T cells when added at the induction phase of suppressor T cells.     

Inhibition of murine suppressor cell function by progesterone

The effects of progesterone on murine suppressor cell function generated in allogeneic MLCs were investigated. BALB/c splenic lymphocytes stimulated in vitro with C3H/He cells significantly suppressed the proliferative response of BALB/c lymphocytes in a secondary MLC. This suppression was highly specific for the sensitizing alloantigens since the suppressor cells had no effect on the proliferative response of BALB/c lymphocytes to third-party alloantigens. In addition, BALB/c lymphocytes stimulated with syngeneic cells were observed to nonspecifically suppress the MLC response to a lesser extent. One to 10 micrograms/ml progesterone added at initiation to suppressor cell generating cultures diminished the ability of both alloantigen specific and nonspecific suppressor cell populations to suppress the proliferative response of homologous lymphocytes to alloantigens. Experiments with pyrilamine, an antihistamine, which blocks cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) generation, suggests that progesterone has a direct inhibitory effect on suppressor cell function independent of its ability to block CTL induction. The effects of progesterone on suppressor cells were not due to shifts in peak response time in MLC or induction of radiosensitive cells in progesterone-treated cultures. Estradiol at doses between 5 and 10 micrograms/ml, and cortisol at dose of 1 microgram/ml, also significantly inhibited suppressor cell function. These results suggest that the steroid hormone milieu within the placenta may effect the activity of allogeneic or nonspecific suppressor cell activity.     

Suppression of the responsiveness of lymphocytes from cancer patients triggered by co-culture with autologous tumor-derived cells

The question as to whether or not cancer patients have "tumor antigen"-induced suppressor T cells is of considerable interest and importance. As an approach to that question, the effect of addition of autologous irradiated tumor-derived cells (TDC) on the mixed lymphocyte response (MLR) of patients' lymphocytes (Ly) and of healthy donor Ly was tested. The rationale for these experiments was based on the fact that circulating antigen-responsive blood lymphocytes can be reactivated in vitro by exposure to the appropriate antigen. Thus, if there are circulating tumor "antigen"-reactive suppressor Ly, exposure to TDC as a source of the antigen should reactivate those cells. Reactivation of suppressor cells might result in diminished responsiveness to other stimuli such as alloantigens in the mixed leukocyte culture. We found that the addition of TDC to Ly cultures produced four distinct patterns of reaction. In 26 of the 74 different patient-tumor assays, the addition of autologous TDC to the patient cultures inhibited MLR, but the addition of the same TDC to cultures of Ly from healthy donors had no effect or increased their responsiveness (Specific Suppression). In 21 cases, the addition of autologous TDC to the patient cultures suppressed the MLR and the addition of the same TDC to control cultures suppressed the response of some but not all the healthy donors (Selective Suppression). In four cases, the addition of TDC to the cultures suppressed the MLR of the patients and all of the control donors (Nonspecific Suppression). In 23 cases, the addition of autologous TDC resulted in no suppression of the patient MLR or of any of the simultaneously tested normal donors (No Suppression). When TDC of patients with noninvasive bladder cancer were added to their own Ly cultures, only four of 11 produced specific or selective suppression compared to 11 of 12 when TDC came from patients with superficially invasive cancer. These data provide indirect evidence to support the hypothesis that human tumors induce circulating suppressor cells that may be reactivated in vitro by co-culture with TDC.     

Cell-mediated destruction of human leukemic cells by MHC identical lymphocytes: requirement for a proliferative trigger in vitro.

These experiments have investigated cellular mechanisms involved in the generation of cellular immune responses to human acute leukemic blasts. Because normal human lymphocytes are not able to recognize immunologically, in vitro, lymphocytes from MHC identical siblings, the present studies have examined the in vitro proliferative and cytotoxic responses of normal lymphocytes to MHC identical AML and ALL blasts. In those cases where acute leukemic cells were unable to induce a proliferative response by MHC identical lymphocytes, the generation of effective anti-leukemic cytotoxicity required the addition of unrelated stimulating cells to the sensitization culture. In contrast, leukemic blasts that induced a proliferative response by MHC identical lymphocytes were also able to stimulate anti-leukemic cytotoxicity. This could be augmented by the addition of unrelated stimulating cells to the sensitization culture. The specificity of anti-leukemic cell cytotoxicity was demonstrated in all instances by simultaneous testing of putative killer cells on 51Cr leukemic blasts as well as 51Cr-labeled MHC identical phytohemagglutinin blasts or normal lymphocytes. Simultaneous sensitization to MHC identical leukemic blasts and unrelated stimulating lymphocytes did not invariably generate anti-leukemic cytotoxicity even when allogeneic cytotoxicity was observed; the absence of demonstrable suppressor activity in these nonreactive combinations suggested that some individuals may be specifically immunoincompetent, and thereby unable to generate effective anti-leukemic CML.     

Studies on the mechanism of suppression by T cells in an adoptive secondary response.

Suppression of antibody synthesis by lymphocytes was studied using an adoptive secondary response model in which human serum albumin (HSA)-primed lymphocytes (memory cells) from the thoracic ducts of inbred rats were inhibited in irradiated recipients by nonimmune lymphocytes after mixed cell transfer. This investigation extended earlier work and formally showed that the suppressor cells were peripheral thymus-derived lymphocytes, which could rapidly recirculate from the blood to lymph, were present in spleen but not in bone marrow, and that primed T cells lacked this property to inhibit. The suppressive effect was independent of antigen dose but was markedly influenced by the form of antigen used for challenge in that suppression was significantly abrogated with aggregated HSA or with soluble HSA in the presence of specific antibody. Suppressor cells were found to exert their effect maximally at the time of antigen injection, but became ineffective by 40 hr following challenge. The results are considered within a larger framework of cellular regulation of antibody synthesis.     

T cells from naive mice suppress the in vitro cytotoxic response against endogenous Gross virus-induced tumor cells

Syngeneic normal lymphoid cells added in co-culture of immune lymphocytes and tumor cells reveal a suppressive activity inhibiting the generation of cytolytic T lymphocytes. The suppression was specific for the response directed against endogenous virus-induced or x-ray-induced tumor cells expressing endogenous C type virus antigens. Thymocytes, spleen cells, or lymph node cells from naive mice were able to express this suppressive activity. The same cells displayed no suppressive activity on killer cells directed against exogenous C type virus-induced tumor cells. The suppressor cells were Thy-1+, Lyt-1- 2+. Our results strongly suggested that the spontaneous suppressor cells exert their activity by interacting with an early step on the CTL response, probably at the level of the helper T cell function. The suppressive activity was mediated by soluble factor(s) that were antigen specific and possibly H-2 restricted. The possible implications of these spontaneous suppressor T lymphocytes in the development of endogenous virus-induced tumors and their possible implications in tolerance to self antigens are discussed.     

A low level of macrophages enhances anti-TNP plaque-forming cell generation by human lymphocytes against TNP-Brucella abortus, a T-independent antigen

Making use of trinitrophenyl-Brucella abortus (TNP-Ba), a T-independent antigen, the mechanism of antibody production in vitro by human lymphocytes was studied, focusing on the accessory role played by macrophages (m phi). Human tonsillar cells and peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL), and their fractions which were depleted of T cells, M phi, or both by rosetting with sheep erythrocytes and glass adherence plus passage through a Sephadex G-10 column, were stimulated in vitro with TNP-Ba under optimal culture conditions. Substantial antibody response against the antigen was induced in the whole tonsillar cells, while no appreciable level of response was induced in the whole PBL. The level of response observed after T-cell depletion was not different from that of the whole cells. In contrast, the response was significantly enhanced both in tonsillar cells and in PBL by depleting M phi to a low level, such as 1-2% of the cultured cells. It was further shown that a small amount of M phi added back to the M phi-depleted fraction activity suppressed the response again to the level seen in the whole cells. If allogenic M phi were substituted for autologous ones, the same degree of suppressor function was observed irrespective of the difference seen in the HLA types.     

Inhibition of macrophage-lymphocyte interaction by cytochalasin B during antigen recognition by T lymphocytes.

The effects of cytochalasin B on functional and physical macrophage-lymphocyte interaction have been examined. Cytochalasin B, an inhibitor of a variety of membrane activities blocks antigen-dependent bindings of immune lymphocytes to macrophages and antigen-triggered lymphocytes proliferation if added at the initiation of culture. Cytochalasin B becomes progressively less inhibitory if addition is delayed by increasing intervals from the onset of culture. Under these conditions neither antigen handling by macrophages nor the proliferative response of lymphocytes to PHA is inhibited by cytochalasin B. These data are interpreted to suggest that cytochalasin B inhibits antigen-specific macrophage-lymphocyte interaction either by inhibition of an initial antigen-independent phase of macrophage-lymphocyte interaction or by interfering with a lymphocyte membrane event necessary for the interaction of the antigen-specific lymphocyte receptor with the macrophage-bound antigenic signal.     

Separation of a population of human T lymphocytes that bind prostaglandin E2 and exert a suppressor activity

Prostaglandin E2 (PGE2) is a potent inhibitor of immune functions. Two possible mechanisms of PGE2-mediated suppression have been proposed: one is a direct inhibitory effect exerted on interleukin 2-producing T cells; the second is mediated by the activation of nonspecific suppressor T lymphocytes. We previously showed that PGE2 can directly activate human T lymphocytes to suppress lymphocyte proliferation and B lymphocyte maturation. Herein is described the binding of 10 to 30% of human peripheral blood T lymphocytes to insolubilized PGE2 coated to albumin-Sepharose. The T lymphocytes that bound PGE2 (PGE2(+] could be eluted by the addition of serum and gentle shaking of the beads. The following data indicated the specificity of the binding: i) T lymphocytes after an overnight incubation, a condition known to abolish sensitivity to PGE2, lost their affinity for PGE2; ii) preincubation of T lymphocytes with PGE2 blocked the binding; iii) PGE2(+) T cells bound PGE after a 24-hr incubation, whereas PGE2(-) T cells did not. Few T cells bound albumin, and only a small percentage (7 to 9%) bound 6-keto-prostaglandin F1 alpha-coated beads. Among PGE2(+) T cells, there was a slight increase in the percentage of OKT8+ cells. Although T cells that had no affinity for PGE2 (PGE2(-] proliferated as well as unseparated T lymphocytes when stimulated with mitogens or antigens, the proliferative response of the PGE2(+) subset was poor. Moreover, PGE2(+) T lymphocytes did exert a strong suppressor activity on mitogen- or allogeneic cell-induced lymphocyte proliferation as well as on pokeweed mitogen-driven B cell maturation into Ig-containing cells. PGE2(-) T lymphocytes were shown not to exert a significant suppressor activity in these assays. The PGE2(+) subset-mediated suppression was not secondary to a carry-over of PGE2 released from the beads, because its suppressor activity was not altered by the addition of an anti-PGE2 serum. Moreover, PGE2(-) T lymphocytes were not sensitive to the inhibitory activity on cell proliferation of PGE2. These results indicate that a given functional subset of peripheral blood T lymphocytes binds PGE2, and that at least some of them are activated into suppressor T cells. The relationship between the PGE2-activatable T suppressor subset and other functionally defined suppressor T cells remains to be clarified; it is suggested, however, that PGE2 can act as an immunoregulator through the activation of identifiable suppressor T cells.     

Human suppressor lymphocytes: I. Induction and characterization

Human peripheral blood lymphocytes were induced to become suppressor cells by exposure to Concanavalin A or Phytohemagglutinin. These cells were able to suppress the cytotoxic responses but not the proliferative responses of alloantigen activated human lymphocytes. Suppressor cells were non-specific in their activity, suppressing both allogeneic and syngeneic responders. They were labile in short-term tissue culture and required a proliferative phase for full induction of suppressor activity. Removal of macrophages prior to mitogen exposure resulted in a small loss of suppressor activity. Suppression was not the result of too much help since enhancement could not be demonstrated upon the addition of small numbers of suppressor cells to MLC.