Interpreting the role of phosphorus and growth rate in enhanced fungal induction of sesquiterpenes from Hyoscyamus muticus root cultures

The effect of thiamine limitation in combination with fungal elicitation on sesquiterpene (solavetivone) production was studied in Agrobacterium-transformed hairy-root cultures of Hyoscyamus muticus as a potential means of manipulating the growth rate independent of phosphorus availability. Limiting the initial supply of thiamine did not affect the growth of these cultures compared to growth at the control level of thiamine (0.01 g/l). There was also no enhancement in sesquiterpene production when thiamine supply was limited. Serial culturing in thiamine-free media suggests that these root cultures are not strictly auxotrophic for thiamine, in contrast to previously published results for untransformed root culture. The effect of phosphate limitation combined with elicitation on the production of solavetivone was examined at constant media volume to provide a constant elicitor concentration and to eliminate feedback-inhibition effects. Limiting the initial supply of phosphate to elicited cultures resulted in a twofold increase in solavetivone production as compared to the elicitation at control media phosphate levels (1.1mm). Because growth was attenuated, production per unit cell mass increased 11-fold compared to the control. The effect of phosphate limitation on solavetivone production at constant cell mass and elicitor per root mass was studied. Limiting the initial supply of phosphate to elicited cultures under these conditions did not result in enhanced production of solavetivone. The initially observed enhanced production of solavetivone at limiting initial phosphate concentrations is therefore due to factors other than the growth rate or phosphate involvement in secondary metabolism. Correspondence to: W. R. Curtis     

Enhanced anthraquinones production from adsorbent-treated Morinda elliptica cell suspension cultures in production medium strategy

Continuous removal of anthraquinones (AQ) by Amberlite polymeric adsorbents (XAD-4, XAD-7 and XAD-16) through in situ adsorption in Morinda elliptica cell suspension cultures is studied for product recovery and improvement of the overall titre. Ethanol was the best eluting solvent for effective recovery of AQ from all adsorbents. Pre-treatment of XAD-4 with sodium acetate not only enhanced intracellular AQ, but also AQ release and subsequent recovery from the adsorbent. The addition of sodium acetate pretreated XAD-4 on day 18 for 6-day contact period, achieved comparable cell growth to control (41 g/L), but with 1.3-fold higher intracellular AQ (124 mg/g DW) and two-fold increase in extracellular AQ (14.3 mg/L). High amount of adsorbent and longer contact period for the cultures entering stationary growth phase, stimulated AQ release and recovery but at the expense of cell growth. With 5–8.3 g XAD-4 adsorbent per litre M. elliptica culture in production (P) medium, between 60 and 90% AQ was recovered from extracellular AQ after 24–26 days of culture period.     

Fed-batch hairy root cultures within situ separation

Fed-batch cultures ofL. erythrorhizon hairy root were carried out by controlling sucrose concentration and media conductivity in a shake flask and a modified stirred tank reactor. For the efficient product recovery from the culture,in situ adsorption by XAD-2 was also conducted. When sucrose was used as a carbon source, the highest shikonin production and hairy root growth were obtained. When glucose or fructose was used instead, the growth was severely inhibited. In addition, it was found that alternating feeding of sucrose could be used as an effective strategy for enhancing the productivity of shikonin derivatives., As the XAD-2 amount was increased up to 1.5 g/L, shikonin production was enhanced by removing shikonin produced and other products which might be inhibitory to cell growth. Most amount of shikonin produced was successfully recovered in XAD-2 (Over 99%). Using hairy root culture in a modified stirred tank reactor, the shikonin productivity and hairy root growth rate on the average were 9.34 mg/L day and 0.49 g DCW/L · day, respectively.     

Regulation of isoflavone production in hydroponically grown Pueraria montana (kudzu) by cork pieces, XAD-4, and methyl jasmonate

A mini-hydroponic growing system was employed for seedlings of kudzu vine (Pueraria montana) and contents of isoflavones (daidzein, genistein, daidzin, genistin, and puerarin) from shoot and root parts of seedlings were analyzed quantitatively. In addition, exogenous cork pieces, polymeric adsorbent, XAD-4, and universal elicitor, methyl jasmonate (MeJA), were used to regulate the production of these isoflavones. It was shown that cork pieces up-regulate the production of daidzein and genistein up to seven- and eight-fold greater than the levels obtained for control roots. In contrast, levels of glucosyl conjugates, daidzin and genistin, decrease up to five- and eight-fold, respectively. Cork treatment also induces the excretion of the root isoflavone constituents into the growth medium. Minimal levels of isoflavones are absorbed by the cork pieces. XAD-4 stimulates the production of glucosyl conjugates, daidzin and genistin, in root parts about 1.5-fold greater than that obtained in control roots. These are the highest amounts of daidzin and genistin that are observed (5.101 and 6.759 mg g⁻¹ dry weight, respectively). In contrast to these two adsorbents, MeJA increases the accumulation of isoflavones in shoot rather than in root parts of seedlings, about three- to four-fold over control levels, with the exception of genistein. These studies reveal new observations on the regulation of isoflavone production in hydroponically grown Pueraria montana plants by two adsorbents (cork pieces and XAD-4) and MeJA elicitor.     

In situ and Ex situ adsorption and recovery of betalains from hairy root cultures of Beta vulgaris

Various adsorbents were screened for in situ recovery of betalain pigments effluxed from hairy root cultures of red beet, Beta vulgaris. Alumina/silica (1:1) appeared ideal, showing in situ adsorption of 97% in a unit time of 30 min accounting for in situ recovery of 71.39% of the total betalaine effluxed. Other adsorbents such as Amberlite series (XAD-2 and -4), cyclodextrin, maltodextrin, dextrin white, and starches such as wheat starch and corn starch exhibited very poor in situ adsorption properties. Pretreatment of adsorbents with methanol significantly improved the adsorption capacities of some of the adsorbents, with a highest adsorption of 97.2% for alumina followed by alumina/silica (1:1) and higher adsorption by XAD-2 and -4. Complete in situ adsorption equilibrium was reached in 20 min for a solution containing 2.5 mg mL(-)(1) of betalain in adsorbents alumina, silica, and a mixture of alumina and silica. In situ betalain adsorption parameters for alumina/silica were determined using the Langmuir isotherm model where the adsorption capacity was found to be 0.174 mg g(-)(1) and the adsorption energy was 0.9 at pH 5.5 and 25 degrees C. Desorption of pigments from the adsorbents was invariably highest in poor adsorbents, indicating their poor adsorption energy for betalaines. Similarly, recovery by desorption was low in those adsorbents having high adsorption capacity, indicating that adsorbents such as activated ones with highest adsorption capacity with zero desorption property were unsuitable for the recovery of effluxed pigments. Ex situ recovery of betalain done using various combinations of alumina/silica and processed sand and different column geometries indicated that alumina with processed sand at a 2:1 ratio (w/w) and a minimum column material of 2 cm height and 2 cm diameter was good enough to cause 97% pigment adsorption from a solution containing 1.6 mg mL(-)(1). Desorption and recovery of pigments ex situ from columns were affected by various elution mixtures, where a gradient elution with ascending levels of HCl/ethanol in water resulted in 100% recovery of adsorbed pigments in a significantly lesser volume of eluent in a short period of 1 h. Different pigment flow rates of 0.2, 0.3, and 3.1 mL s(-)(1) through a column of alumina/processed sand indicated that a pigment equilibrium concentration of 0.18 mg mL(-)(1) at flow rates of 0.02 and 0.3 mL s(-)(1) resulted in a breakthrough at 110 and 14 min adsorbing 16.9 and 16.91 mg g(-)(1) betalain, respectively. From the breakthrough curves, the column capacities for respective flow rates were calculated as 8.86 and 9.6 mg g(-)(1), and the higher flow rates resulted in earlier breakthrough with lower capacity. Observations made in the present study are useful to develop a process for the on-line recovery of betalains effluxed from hairy roots.     

Interaction of methyl jasmonate, wounding and fungal elicitation during sesquiterpene induction in Hyoscyamus muticus in root cultures

The ability of methyl jasmonate (MeJa) to induce sesquiterpene production in root cultures of Hyoscyamus muticus has been studied. Although MeJa alone could not induce sesquiterpene in unwounded culture, MeJa added in the presence of wounding displayed a dose-dependent response, saturating at 50 μM. The ability to respond to MeJa declined with an increase in time between MeJa contact and wounding; however, responsiveness could be recovered by re-wounding of tissue prior to MeJa contact, suggesting that additional signaling related to wounding is required for sesquiterpene pathway induction. The saturation level of sesquiterpene induction with fungal elicitor was four times higher than the saturation level achieved by MeJa, with clear differences in sesquiterpene composition. Fungal elicitation results in a higher level of lubimin and a lower level of solavetivone production; whereas, methyl jasmonate induces predominantly solavetivone and little or no lubimin production. This suggests that fungal elicitation induces enzymes further down the sesquiterpene pathway which are not affected by MeJa. The induction of roots in contact with subsaturated levels of elicitor can be enhanced to saturation production levels by the addition of small amounts of MeJa (5–10 μmoles/l). In these studies, MeJa was consistently found to favor the earlier metabolite (solavetivone), while fungal elicitation promoted conversion to subsequent metabolites in the pathway (lubimin). The interactive role of MeJa in signal transduction for secondary metabolic production is discussed. Received: 8 June 1997 / Revision received: 13 August 1997 / Accepted: 13 September 1997     

The effect of ajmalicine spiking and resin addition timing on the production of indole alkaloids from Catharanthus roseus cell cultures

The potential for the feedback inhibition of indole alkaloid synthesis was investigated by spiking suspension cultures of Catharanthus roseus with 0, 9, or 18 mg/L ajmalicine on day 0. The production of ajmalicine, catharanthine, and serpentine were inhibited in a dose-dependent manner. The inhibition was transient as the exogenous ajmalicine was ultimately either metabolized in the medium or within the cell. The addition of neutral resin has previously been shown to enhance ajmalicine production. To minimize product inhibition and product metabolism, Amberlite XAD-7 resin was added to immobilized cultures of C. roseus starting on either day 0, 5, or 15, and fresh resin was exchanged for spent resin every 5 days. The addition of resin did not decrease the viability of the culture. Growth was reduced only in cultures with resin added on day 0. Alkaloid production was enhanced to different extents by the timing of resin addition, suggesting that feedback inhibition or product metabolism was present throughout the culture period. Ajmalicine recovery was nearly 100% when the resin was added initially either on day 0 or day 5. Ajmalicine recovery was reduced to 55% when the resin was added later in the culture period starting on day 15, presumably because of resin saturation or the inaccessibility of alkaloids trapped in the vacuole. Delaying the addition of XAD-7 resin until 5 days after the start of the culture resulted in the highest improvement in ajmalicine production, i.e approximately 70% and also resulted in the complete recovery of ajmalicine from the cell.     

Biotransformation of the potato stress metabolite,solavetivone, by cell suspension cultures of two solanaceous and three non-solanaceous species

Cell suspension cultures of several plant species which were exogenously supplied solavetivone accumulated four hydroxylated derivatives. Only solanaceous cell cultures converted exogenously supplied solavetivone to sesquiterpenoid compounds identified with the plant response to biotic stress. Failure of potato cell cultures to make these compounds under biotic stress may be linked to their inability to produce adequate levels of solavetivone.Abbreviations MS Murashige and Skoog (1962) - 2,4-D 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid - TMV Tobacco Mosaic Virus - NAA 1-naphthaleneacetic acid - TLC thin layer chromatography - GC gas chromatography - GC/MS gas chromotography/mass spectrometry - NMR nuclear magnetic resonance     

Autointoxication in residues ofAsparagus officinalis L.

Summary In a greenhouse experiment the growth of asparagus seedlings was retarded by the residue treatments in both vermiculite and sand cultures. In general, the retardation of asparagus root by residues was slightly greater than the retardation of shoot in both cultures. The retardation of the growth of asparagus seedlings by root and stem treatments was usually higher than that by old root litter. Root and stem extracts strongly inhibited the development of asparagus seedlings in the seed bioassay. The inhibition of extracts to the growth of shoot was greater than that to the growth of root. The quantities in the total phenolics and catachol type phenolics from root, stem and old root litter extracts corresponded to the autotoxicity in the seed bioassay. The soil extracts obtained from using acetone, methanol, and XAD-4 extractions strongly inhibited the shoot and root development of asparagus seedlings in the bioassay. The efficiency of phenolics extraction by the XAD-4 method was significantly higher than that by acetone and methanol extractions. The results obtained in the greenhouse experiment and bioassay revealed that phytotoxic substances present in the residues and the soil of asparagus and may be partially responsible for the asparagus replanting problems.     

Increased anthraquinone production in Galium vernum cell cultures induced by polymeric adsorbents

Anthraquinones produced by suspension cultures of Galium vernum are completely retained intracellularly. Surprisingly, in the presence of some polymeric adsorbents anthraquinones are partially released into the culture medium. The secretion and in situ removal stimulates anthraquinone production in cell cultures of Galium vernum. Best results were obtained with Wofatit ES and Amberlite XAD-2.Abbreviations DW dry weight - MS Murashige & Skoog[7]medium - NAA 1-naphthaleneacetic acid     

Shikonin production and secretion by hairy root cultures of Lithospermum erythrorhizon

Summary Hairy root cultures of Lithospermum erythrorhizon were established by transformation of in vitro grown shoots with Agrobacterium rhizogenes 15834. Hairy roots cultured on Murashige and Skoog solid medium did not produce any red pigments. However, the hairy roots cultured in Root Culture solid or liquid media produced a large amount of red pigments, which were released to the medium. The addition of adsorbents to the culture medium stimulated shikonin production by ca. 3-fold. Using this method an air-lift fermenter system was established, equipped with a XAD-2 column, which continuously produced ca. 5 mg/day of shikonin during a period of more than 220 days.     

Product enhancement and recovery from transformed root cultures of Nicotiana glauca

Transformed roots of Nicotiana glauce synthesize the alkaloids nicotine and anabasine at levels reflecting the parent plants. Media composition, strength, and pH were evaluated with respect to biomass yield and productivity. Full-strength Gamborg's B5 medium proved the best for biomass yield while half-strength, or low-salt, medium enhanced alkaloid accumulation. A detailed investigation of media nitrate levels demonstrated how these may be manipulated to promote growth and intracellular or extracellular alkaloid levels. High nitrate concentrations were found to significantly enhance media alkaloid levels at the end of the growth phase. Media pH is also important, although transformed roots will grow in Gamborg's B5 medium between pH 3 and 9, root biomass is favored by an increase in medium alkalinity, while alkaloid release is encouraged by mildly acidic pH.Transformed roots release a proportion of their secondary metabolites into the growth medium. By continually removing root products, any feedback inhibition on enzymatic reactions is reduced, as are the toxic effects resulting from product accumulation. In this article we describe the use of Amberlite resins (XAD-2 and XAD-4) to enhance alkaloid levels (nicotine and anabasine) of hairy root cultures of Nicotiana glauca by a factor of 10 with no adverse effect on root growth. The performance of the Amberlite columns was subsequently investigated with respect to alkaloid adsorption and desorption, including an evaluation of the effects of pH and loading capacity. The resins also adsorb media constituents which are identified and quantified as part of this work. Resulting nutritional stresses are thought to be partly responsible for enhancing secondary metabolism at the expense of biomass yield. However, the net effects of using Amberlite resins as a means of product removal significantly increases the overall product yield and the extent to which products are released into the growth medium.     

The stimulation of anthraquinone production by Cinchona ledgeriana cultures with polymeric adsorbents

Summary Anthraquinones produced by suspension cultures of Cinchona ledgeriana are released into the medium, which becomes saturated with products late in the growth cycle. When a high affinity polymeric adsorbent, such as the macro-reticular Amberlite XAD-7, is added to the culture the concentration of anthraquinone in the medium is maintained at a low level and production may be stimulated 15-fold, yielding up to 20 mg/1/day. More than 90% of the product is released from the cells. For maximal yields it is shown that both the amount of adsorbent used and the time after sub-culture at which it is added to the system are critical. The value of such a method for product recovery from immobilised cells is discussed.     

Adsorbent polystyrene as an aid in plant enzyme isolation

Porous polystyrene (Amberlite XAD-4) adsorbs hydrophobic and surface-active materials from plant extracts and homogenates. With conventional extraction techniques, these materials tend to bind to proteins by hydrophobic interactions. In some cases covalent modification of protein also occurs. Interfering compounds include phenolics, quinones, terpenes and organic isothiocyanates. Polystyrene complements insoluble polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVPP, Polyclar AT), and the combination of these two adsorbents produced superior enzyme extracts from the several plant tissues that were tested. Tested procedures are described, and suggestions are given for adapting the procedures to new plant systems with contaminating natural products varying in quantity and in chemical nature.     

Permeabilization and in situ adsorption studies during growth and coumarin production in hairy root cultures of Cichorium intybus L

Effect of addition of a permeabilizing agent dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) and a solid adsorbent, XAD -7, on growth and coumarin production in hairy root cultures of C. intybus was studied. Continuous permeabilization of the hairy root cultures of C. intybus with DMSO has been shown to be an effective strategy for enhanced release of coumarins while preserving the root viability. DMSO at 0.2% (v/v) level showed the maximum growth and coumarin production but was less as compared to control on day 28. Treatment of cells with increasing concentrations of DMSO (0.3 - 0.6 % v/v) to hairy root cultures of C. intybus, showed an inverse relationship with growth and coumarin production. Growth and production of coumarins increased with 1% media filtrate (MF) of cultures of Phytopthora parasitica var. nicotiana treatment. It was observed that treatment with DMSO (0.2% v/v) and 1% MF of P. parasitica showed the better growth and coumarin production with an increased release of coumarins as compared to the control and other treatments. It was observed that treatment of hairy root cultures with XAD-7 resulted in lesser growth and coumarin production as compared to control during the culture period. Addition of XAD-7 along with 1% MF of P. parasitica showed enhanced growth, coumarin production and increased adsorption as compared to control and lone XAD-7 treatment. Combined addition of DMSO/XAD-7 with fungal elicitor showed synergistic response in terms of biomass and coumarin production. Excretion of coumarins in both the cases was dependent on the presence of DMSO/XAD-7. These results showed that continuous permeabilization of hairy root cultures of C. intybus by using DMSO at 0.2% (v/v) level coupled with 1% MF of P. parasitica maintained viability of tissues and produced coumarins at higher level.     

Selective adsorption of plant products

The results from this study demonstrate that neutral resins can selectively concentrate specific indole alkaloids from dilute aqueous mixtures. Adsorption was observed to provide a one to two order of magnitude improvement in concentrating these alkaloids, as compared to an equivalent single-staged extraction. Since the sorption correlates with the concentration of the neutral form of the dissolved alkaloid, the adsorption is dependent on both the pH of the medium and the pKa of the alkaloids. Also, adsorption is dependent on specific sorbent-sorbate characteristics. In this study, by exploiting differences in the acid-base properties and the sorption characteristics of specific indole alkaloids, separation factors of 20-30 were observed. Although this behavior is valuable for analytical separations, the present study considers the application to the primary recovery of alkaloids from plant cell processes. Throughout this study it was also observed that the polycarboxylic ester resin (XAD-7) behaved quite differently from the styrene divinylbenzene resin (XAD-4). Despite a lower capacity, the XAD-7 resin was considerably more selective in adsorbing indole alkaloids than the XAD-4 resin. These alkaloids could also be desorbed from the XAD-7 resin by acidifying the liquid, while organic solvents were required to desorb these compounds from the XAD-4 resin.     

Nicotine production by “hairy root” cultures of Nicotiana rustica: Fermentation and product recovery

The production of nicotine by cultures ofNicotiana rustica transformed withAgrobacterium rhizogenes has been examined in a packed bed fermenter as a two-stage batch/continuous-flow system. A substantial proportion of the nicotine synthesised in the batch phase may be subsequently harvested from the medium. The possibility of improving product recovery using macroreticular adsorbents is considered.     

Continuous production of scopolamine by a culture of Duboisia leichhardtii hairy root clone in a bioreactor system

The scopolamine-releasing hairy root clone DL47-1 of Duboisia leichhardtii was cultured in an Amberlite XAD-2 column-combined bioreactor system for continuous production of scopolamine. The medium used was continuously exchanged during culture to maintain the electrical conductivity of the medium constant. After culturing the hairy roots in the system for 11 weeks, 0.5 g/l of scopolamine was obtained in the column. When the roots were cultures in the reactor system containing polyurethane foam or stainless-steel mesh to support the hairy roots, scopolamine recovery was increased. Thereafter, a two-stage culture, the first stage in the medium for hairy root growth and the second stage in the medium for scopolamine release, was carried out in this system by using a turbine-blade reactor with stainless-steel mesh as a support. Under these conditions, 1.3 g/l of scopolamine was recovered during 11 weeks of culture in the medium for scopolamine release. This bioreactor system seems applicable for the production of various plant metabolites by cultures of hairy roots. Correspondence to: T. Muranaka     

原位吸附和茉莉酸甲酯联合使用显著提高中国红豆杉细胞云南紫杉烷c的生产

本实验所用的中国红豆杉细胞悬浮培养体系中,云南紫杉烷c(Tc)是主要的次生代谢产物,该化合物有类神经生长因子活性,提高其产量是进一步规模化生产的前提。本研究考察了原位吸附和茉莉酸甲酯(MJA)联合调控提高Tc产量的可能性。在培养的第7天加入浓度为100μmol/L的MJA虽然会使细胞的生物量下降10%～30%,但是单位细胞内Tc含量和Tc产量均有显著提高,分别是对照的3.6和3.3倍。吸附剂XAD-7在不同时间加入对Tc的合成影响显著。在培养的第7天同时加入100μmol/L的MJA和100g/L的XAD-7会使细胞生物量增加,Tc产量显著提高。培养到第21天,Tc产量达477.4mg/L,为对照的6.3倍,为只加MJA的1.9倍,其中94%的Tc被树脂吸附。实验结果表明,在MJA诱导高表达的过程中,吸附剂XAD-7的加入使细胞内代谢产物外泌,浓度降低,减轻产物反馈抑制现象,从而大幅度提高代谢物产量,有较好的生产前景。     

Effect of elicitation on growth, respiration, and nutrient uptake of root and cell suspension cultures of Hyoscyamus muticus

The elicitation of Hyoscyamus muticus root and cell suspension cultures by fungal elicitor from Rhizoctonia solani causes dramatic changes in respiration, nutrient yields, and growth. Cells and mature root tissues have similar specific oxygen uptake rates (SOUR) before and after the onset of the elicitation process. Cell suspension SOUR were 11 and 18 micromol O2/g FW x h for non-elicited control and elicited cultures, respectively. Mature root SOUR were 11 and 24 micromol O2/g FW x h for control and elicited tissue, respectively. Tissue growth is significantly reduced upon the addition of elicitor to these cultures. Inorganic yield remains fairly constant, whereas yield on sugar is reduced from 0.532 to 0.352 g dry biomass per g sugar for roots and 0.614 to 0.440 g dry biomass per g sugar for cells. This reduction in yield results from increased energy requirements for the defense response. Growth reduction is reflected in a reduction in root meristem (tip) SOUR, which decreased from 189 to 70 micromol O2/g FW x h upon elicitation. Therefore, despite the increase in total respiration, the maximum local oxygen fluxes are reduced as a result of the reduction in metabolic activity at the meristem. This distribution of oxygen uptake throughout the mature tissue could reduce mass transfer requirements during elicited production. However, this was not found to be the case for sesquiterpene elicitation, where production of lubimin and solavetivone were found to increase linearly up to oxygen partial pressures of 40% O2 in air. SOUR is shown to similarly increase in both bubble column and tubular reactors despite severe mass transfer limitations, suggesting the possibility of metabolically induced increases in tissue convective transport during elicitation.