The crystal lattice of Paramecium trichocysts before and after exocytosis by X-ray diffraction and freeze-fracture electron microscopy

Paramecium trichocysts are unusual secretory organelles in that: (a) their crystalline contents are built up from a family of low molecular mass acidic proteins; (b) they have a precise, genetically determined shape; and (c) the crystalline trichocyst contents expand rapidly upon exocytosis to give a second, extracellular form which is also an ordered array. We report here the first step of our study of trichocyst structure. We have used a combination of x-ray powder diffraction, freeze-etching, and freeze-fracture electron microscopy of isolated, untreated trichocysts, and density measurements to show that trichocyst contents are indeed protein crystals and to determine the elementary unit cell of both the compact intracellular and the extended extracellular form.     

A large multigene family codes for the polypeptides of the crystalline trichocyst matrix in Paramecium.

The secretory granules (trichocysts) of Paramecium are characterized by a highly constrained shape that reflects the crystalline organization of their protein contents. Yet the crystalline trichocyst content is composed not of a single protein but of a family of related polypeptides that derive from a family of precursors by protein processing. In this paper we show that a multigene family, of unusually large size for a unicellular organism, codes for these proteins. The family is organized in subfamilies; each subfamily codes for proteins with different primary structures, but within the subfamilies several genes code for nearly identical proteins. For one subfamily, we have obtained direct evidence that the different members are coexpressed. The three subfamilies we have characterized are located on different macronuclear chromosomes. Typical 23-29 nucleotide Paramecium introns are found in one of the regions studied and the intron sequences are more variable than the surrounding coding sequences, providing gene-specific markers. We suggest that this multigene family may have evolved to assure a microheterogeneity of structural proteins necessary for morphogenesis of a complex secretory granule core with a constrained shape and dynamic properties: genetic analysis has shown that correct assembly of the crystalline core is necessary for trichocyst function.     

Evidence for defects in membrane traffic in Paramecium secretory mutants unable to produce functional storage granules

The ciliated protozoan Paramecium has a regulated secretory system amenable to genetic analysis. The secretory storage granules, known as trichocysts, enclose a crystalline matrix with a genetically determined shape whose biogenesis involves proteolytic maturation of a family of precursor molecules into a heterogeneous set of small acidic polypeptides that crystallize within the maturing vesicles. We have developed an original pulse-chase protocol for monoxenic Paramecium cultures using radiolabeled bacteria to study the processing of trichocyst matrix proteins in wild-type and mutant cells. In wild-type cells, proteolytic processing is blocked in the presence of monensin and otherwise rapidly completed after approximately 20 min of chase, suggesting that the conversion occurs in the trans-Golgi and/or in small vesicles soon after sorting to the regulated pathway, probably before crystallization begins. In trichless mutant cells, which contain no visible trichocysts, secretory proteins are synthesized but not processed and we report constitutive secretion of the uncleaved precursor molecules. The mutation thus appears to affect sorting to the regulated pathway and should prove useful for analysis of the sorting machinery and of the relationship between sorting and proteolytic processing of secretory proteins. In mutants bearing misshapen trichocysts with poorly crystallized contents (tam33, tam38, stubbyA), the proteolytic processing of the trichocyst matrix proteins appears to be normal, while both pulse-chase and morphological data indicate that intracellular transport is perturbed, probably between ER and Golgi. Precursor molecules are present in the mutant trichocysts but not in wild-type trichocysts and may account for the defective crystallization. Our analysis of these mutants suggests that the temporal coordination of intracellular traffic plays a regulatory role in granule maturation.     

Control of exocytotic processes: cytological and physiological studies of trichocyst mutants in Paramecium tetraurelia

The trichocysts of Paramecium tetraurelia constitute a favorable system for studying secretory process because of the numerous available mutations that block, at various stages, the development of these secretory vesicles, their migration towards and interaction with the cell surface, and their exocytosis. Previous studies of several mutants provided information (a) on the assembly and function of the intramembranous particles arrays in the plasma membrane at trichocyst attachment sites, (b) on the autonomous motility of trichocysts, required for attachment to the cortex, and (c) on a diffusible cytoplasmic factor whose interaction with both trichocyst and plasma membrane is required for exocytosis to take place. We describe here the properties of four more mutants deficient in exocytosis ability, nd6, nd7, tam38, and tam6, which were analyzed by freeze-fracture, microinjection of trichocysts, and assay for repair of the mutational defect through cell-cell interaction during conjugation with wild-type cells. As well as providing confirmation of previous conclusions, our observations show that the mutations nd6 and tam6 (which display striking abnormalities in their plasma membrane particle arrays and are reparable through cell-cell contact but not by microinjection of cytoplasm) affect two distinct properties of the plasma membrane, whereas the other two mutations affect different properties of the trichocysts. Altogether, the mutants so far analyzed now provide a rather comprehensive view of the steps and functions involved in secretory processes in Paramecium and demonstrate that two steps of these processes, trichocyst attachment to the plasma membrane and exocytosis, depend upon specific properties of both the secretory vesicle and the plasma membrane.     

Cytoskeleton-secretory vesicle interactions during the docking of secretory vesicles at the cell membrane in Paramecium tetraurelia cells

Stationary-phase cells of Paramecium tetraurelia have most of their many secretory vesicles ("trichocysts") attached to the cell surface. Log-phase cells contain numerous unoccupied potential docking sites for trichocysts and many free trichocysts in the cytoplasm. To study the possible involvement of cytoskeletal elements, notably of microtubules, in the process of positioning of trichocysts at the cell surface, we took advantage of these stages. Cells were stained with tannic acid and subsequently analyzed by electron microscopy. Semithin sections allowed the determination of structural connections over a range of up to 10 micrometer. Microtubules emanating from ciliary basal bodies are seen in contact with free trichocysts, which appear to be transported, with their tip first, to the cell surface. (This can account for the saltatory movement reported by others). It is noteworthy that the "rails" represented by the microtubules do not directly determine the final attachment site of a trichocyst. Unoccupied attachment sites are characterized by a "plug" of electron-dense material just below the plasma membrane; the "plug" seems to act as a recognition or anchoring site; this material is squeezed out all around the trichocyst attachment zone, once a trichocyst is inserted (Westphal and Plattner, in press. [53]). Slightly below this "plug" we observed fasciae of microfilaments (identified by immunocytochemistry using peroxidase labeled F(ab) fragments against P. tetraurelia actin). Their arrangement is not altered when a trichocyst is docked. These fasciae seem to form a loophole for the insertion of a trichocyst. Trichocyst remain attached to the microtubules originating from the ciliary basal bodies--at least for some time--even after they are firmly installed in the preformed attachment sites. Evidently, the regular arrangement of exocytotic organelles is controlled on three levels: one operating over a long distance from the exocytosis site proper (microtubules), one over a short distance (microfilament bundles), and one directly on the exocytosis site ("plug").     

Genetic analysis of membrane differentiation in Paramecium. Freeze- fracture study of the trichocyst cycle in wild-type and mutant strains

Using a series of mutants of Paramecium tetraurelia, we demonstrate, for the first time, changes in the internal structure of the cell membrane, as revealed by freeze-fracture, that correspond to specific single gene mutations. On the plasma membrane of Paramecium circular arrays of particles mark the sites of attachment of the tips of the intracellular secretory organelles-trichocysts. In wild-type paramecia, where attached trichocysts can be expelled by exocytosis under various stimuli, the plasma membrane array is composed of a double outer ring of particles (300 nm in diameter) and inside the ring a central rosette (fusion rosette) of particles (76 nm in diameter). Mutant nd9, characterized by a thermosensitive ability to discharge trichocysts, shows the same organization in cells grown at the permissive temperature (18 degrees C), while in cells grown at the nonpermissive temperature (27 degrees C) the rosette is missing. In mutant tam 8, characterized by normal but unattached trichocysts, and in mutant tl, completely devoid of trichocysts, no rosette is formed and the outer rings always show a modified configuration called "parentheses", also found in wild-type and in nd9 (18 degrees C) cells. From this comparison between wild type and mutants, we conclude: (a) that the formation of parentheses is a primary differentiation of the plasma membrane, independent of the presence of trichocysts, while the secondary transformation of parentheses into circular arrays and the formation of the rosette are triggered by interaction between trichocysts and plasma membranes; and (b) that the formation of the rosette is a prerequisite for trichocyst exocytosis.     

Secretory organelle docking at the cell membrane of Paramecium cells: dedocking and synchronized redocking of trichocysts

We present the first evidence that secretory organelle docking at the cell membrane can be reversed in vivo. In nondischarge (nd) mutants of Paramecium tetraurelia all trichocysts can be detached from the cell surface within 2-3 h by different means, including cytochalasin B (but not D), high cell density, or Ca2+ ionophores. Considering the well-established ultrastructural differences between nd and wild-type (wt) cells, one can conclude that trichocyst docking at the cell periphery involves two docking sites (I, II): Site I ties the organelles to the epiplasm, and site II is the connection to the cell membrane at the fusogenic zone (expressed only in wt cells); both sites are close to the cell surface and only 150 nm apart. When the trigger for detachment of cortically docked trichocysts (high cell density, cytochalasin B) is relieved, trichocysts are synchronously reattached at the cell membrane, within 40-50 min, with a rate of 20-40 organelles/min, which far exceeds spontaneous docking rates. This is therefore also the first report on synchronization of secretory organelle docking. It is shown by radioactive leucine labeling that the same organelles are redocked, because trichocyst biogenesis is minimal under the conditions of de/redocking used. Surprisingly not only redocking but also detachment of trichocysts from the cell surface can be abolished by inhibitors of protein synthesis. Since Ca2+ ionophores mimic the effects of other conditions sufficient to detach trichocysts from the cell surface, we assume that a protein-dependent mechanism sensitive to Ca2+ (or other ions in exchange) may operate in trichocyst detachment. The precise mechanism involved in attachment or detachment of trichocysts remains to be elucidated.     

Secretory organelle docking at the cell membrane of Paramecium cells: Dedocking and synchronized redocking of trichocysts

We present the first evidence that secretory organelle docking at the cell membrane can be reversed in vivo. In nondischarge (nd) mutants of Paramecium tetraurelia all trichocysts can be detached from the cell surface within 2–3 h by different means, including cytochalasin B (but not D), high cell density, or Ca²⁺ ionophores. Considering the well-established ultrastructural differences between nd and wild-type (wt) cells, one can conclude that trichocyst docking at the cell periphery involves two docking sites (I, II): Site I ties the organelles to the epiplasm, and site II is the connection to the cell membrane at the fusogenic zone (expressed only in wt cells); both sites are close to the cell surface and only 150 nm apart. When the trigger for detachment of cortically docked trichocysts (high cell density, cytochalasin B) is relieved, trichocysts are synchronously reattached at the cell membrane, within 40–50 min, with a rate of 20–40 organelles/min, which far exceeds spontaneous docking rates. This is therefore also the first report on synchronization of secretory organelle docking. It is shown by radioactive leucine labeling that the same organelles are redocked, because trichocyst biogenesis is minimal under the conditions of de/redocking used. Surprisingly not only redocking but also detachment of trichocysts from the cell surface can be abolished by inhibitors of protein synthesis. Since Ca²⁺ ionophores mimic the effects of other conditions sufficient to detach trichocysts from the cell surface, we assume that a protein-dependent mechanism sensitive to Ca²⁺ (or other ions in exchange) may operate in trichocyst detachment. The precise mechanism involved in attachment or detachment of trichocysts remains to be elucidated.     

Small GTP-binding Proteins Associated with Secretory Vesicles of Paramecium

GTP-binding proteins act as molecular switches in a variety of membrane-associated processes, including secretion. One group of GTP-binding proteins, 20–30 kDa, is related to the product of the ras proto-oncogene. In Saccharomyces cerevisiae, ras -like GTP-binding proteins regulate vesicular traffic in secretion. The ciliate protist Paramecium tetraurelia contains secretory vesicles (trichocysts) whose protein contents are released by regulated exocytosis. Using [α-³²P]GTP and an on-blot assay for GTP-binding, we detected at least seven GTP-binding proteins of low molecular mass (22–31 kDa) in extracts of Paramecium tetraurelia. Subcellular fractions contained characteristic subsets of these seven; cilia were enriched for the smallest (22 kDa). The pattern of GTP-binding proteins was altered in two mutants defective in the formation or discharge of trichocysts. Trichocysts isolated with their surrounding membranes intact contained two minor GTP-binding proteins (23.5 and 29 kDa) and one major GTP-binding protein (23 kDa) that were absent from demembranated trichocysts. This differential localization of GTP-binding proteins suggests functional specialization of specific GTP-binding proteins in ciliary motility and exocytosis.     

Orientation of paramecium swimming in a DC magnetic field

We found that a ciliated protozoan, Paramecium, swam perpendicular to a static (DC) magnetic field (0.68 T). The swimming orientation was similar even when the ionic current through the cell membrane disappeared after saponin treatment. To determine the diamagnetic anisotropy of intracellular organs, macronuclei, cilia, and secretory vesicles, trichocysts, were selectively isolated. Both cilia and trichocysts tended to align their long axis parallel to the magnetic field (0.78 T). Paramecium mutants that lack trichocysts also swam perpendicular to the magnetic field, although the proportion fraction was smaller than the normal population. Since large numbers of cilia and trichocysts are arranged at right angles to the long axis of the cell, the diamagnetic anisotropies of cilia and trichocysts cause the long axis of the cell to align perpendicular to the magnetic field. In contrast to the DC magnetic field, an alternative (AC) magnetic field (60 Hz, 0.65 T) had almost no effect on the swimming orientation of Paramecium.     

Small GTP-binding proteins associated with secretory vesicles of Paramecium

GTP-binding proteins act as molecular switches in a variety of membrane-associated processes, including secretion. One group of GTP-binding proteins, 20-30 kDa, is related to the product of the ras proto-oncogene. In Saccharomyces cerevisiae, ras-like GTP-binding proteins regulate vesicular traffic in secretion. The ciliate protist Paramecium tetraurelia contains secretory vesicles (trichocysts) whose protein contents are released by regulated exocytosis. Using [alpha-32P]GTP and an on-blot assay for GTP-binding, we detected at least seven GTP-binding proteins of low molecular mass (22-31 kDa) in extracts of Paramecium tetraurelia. Subcellular fractions contained characteristic subsets of these seven; cilia were enriched for the smallest (22 kDa). The pattern of GTP-binding proteins was altered in two mutants defective in the formation or discharge of trichocysts. Trichocysts isolated with their surrounding membranes intact contained two minor GTP-binding proteins (23.5 and 29 kDa) and one major GTP-binding protein (23 kDa) that were absent from demembranated trichocysts. This differential localization of GTP-binding proteins suggests functional specialization of specific GTP-binding proteins in ciliary motility and exocytosis.     

Secretory organelles of Paramecium cells (trichocysts) are not remarkably acidic compartments.

Acridine orange (AO) trapping in conjunction with fluorescence microscopy was applied to Paramecium cells. Trichocysts were not labeled when analyzed with an image intensification system (as opposed to a lysosomal population). Only with increasing intensity of ultraviolet light (UV) did trichocysts (and to some extent the cytosol) exhibit orange fluorescence, both effects being paralleled by increasing cell damage. Therefore, in comparison with the reported cytosolic pH (6.8), trichocysts cannot be considered as essentially acidic compartments. This is supported by experiments in vitro, using isolated cortex fragments or isolated fractions of membrane-bounded trichocysts (greater than or equal to 90% non-leaky). Again, during UV illumination orange fluorescence was observed even in the absence of ATP and Mg2+. Furthermore, this AO fluorescence and the condensation state of trichocyst contents were not affected by NH3 or by any of the widely differing ion- and H(+)-exchange inhibitors or ionophores tested. Decondensation of trichocyst contents occurred only when Ca2+ ionophore A23187 or X537A was incorporated into trichocyst membranes and when Ca2+ was then added. In this case all trichocysts partially decondensed within their intact membranes. We conclude that AO might be trapped in trichocysts by the abundant acidic secretory components during observation with UV light, rather than by acidic luminal pH.     

Chromogranin A-like proteins in the secretory granules of a protozoan, Paramecium tetraurelia

The ciliate protozoan Paramecium tetraurelia produces secretory granules (trichocysts) which release needle-like structures composed of small, acidic proteins. Using antibodies against isolated chromogranin A (CGA) and against trichocyst proteins, we found cross-reactive proteins in chromaffin granules and trichocysts. Four independently derived sera against isolated CGA stained bands of the Mr 15,000-25,000 family of trichocyst proteins on immunoblots. A positive response was also obtained with antiserum against chemically synthesized peptides (PL26 and GE25) corresponding to defined regions of the CGA amino acid sequence. In extracts of whole Paramecium, larger proteins (Mr 53,000 and 49,000) also reacted with antibodies against CGA and the related synthetic peptides. These larger proteins may represent unprocessed precursors to the smaller proteins of mature trichocysts. Antiserum to trichocysts recognized CGA in chromaffin granule lysates. Further evidence of a Paramecium protein related to CGA was provided by hybridization of Paramecium mRNA with cloned cDNA for bovine CGA. Our results suggest striking conservation in evolution of CGA-like proteins that may play some role, as yet unknown, in secretion.     

Trichocysts—Paramecium's Projectile‐like Secretory Organelles

This review summarizes biogenesis, composition, intracellular transport, and possible functions of trichocysts. Trichocyst release by Paramecium is the fastest dense core‐secretory vesicle exocytosis known. This is enabled by the crystalline nature of the trichocyst “body” whose matrix proteins (tmp), upon contact with extracellular Ca²⁺, undergo explosive recrystallization that propagates cooperatively throughout the organelle. Membrane fusion during stimulated trichocyst exocytosis involves Ca²⁺ mobilization from alveolar sacs and tightly coupled store‐operated Ca²⁺‐influx, initiated by activation of ryanodine receptor‐like Ca²⁺‐release channels. Particularly, aminoethyldextran perfectly mimics a physiological function of trichocysts, i.e. defense against predators, by vigorous, local trichocyst discharge. The tmp's contained in the main “body” of a trichocyst are arranged in a defined pattern, resulting in crossstriation, whose period expands upon expulsion. The second part of a trichocyst, the “tip”, contains secretory lectins which diffuse upon discharge. Repulsion from predators may not be the only function of trichocysts. We consider ciliary reversal accompanying stimulated trichocyst exocytosis (also in mutants devoid of depolarization‐activated Ca²⁺ channels) a second, automatically superimposed defense mechanism. A third defensive mechanism may be effectuated by the secretory lectins of the trichocyst tip; they may inhibit toxicyst exocytosis in Dileptus by crosslinking surface proteins (an effect mimicked in Paramecium by antibodies against cell surface components). Some of the proteins, body and tip, are glycosylated as visualized by binding of exogenous lectins. This reflects the biogenetic pathway, from the endoplasmic reticulum via the Golgi apparatus, which is also supported by details from molecular biology. There are fragile links connecting the matrix of a trichocyst with its membrane; these may signal the filling state, full or empty, before and after tmp release upon exocytosis, respectively. This is supported by experimentally produced “frustrated exocytosis”, i.e. membrane fusion without contents release, followed by membrane resealing and entry in a new cycle of reattachment for stimulated exocytosis. There are some more puzzles to be solved: Considering the absence of any detectable Ca²⁺ and of acidity in the organelle, what causes the striking effects of silencing the genes of some specific Ca²⁺‐release channels and of subunits of the H⁺‐ATPase? What determines the inherent polarity of a trichocyst? What precisely causes the inability of trichocyst mutants to dock at the cell membrane? Many details now call for further experimental work to unravel more secrets about these fascinating organelles.     

Endogenous signal peptides efficiently mediate the secretion of recombinant proteins in Pichia pastoris

By predicting the potential signal peptides from proteins that are naturally secreted by Pichia pastoris, we identified three possible endogenous signal peptides: Scw, Dse and Exg. We compared their capability to mediate the secretion of enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP) and Candida antarctica lipase B (CALB) with that of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae α-factor prepro-signal. EGFP entered the secretory pathway of P. pastoris and was efficiently secreted into the culture medium by all three endogenous peptides. Further, these three putative endogenous signal peptides were also effective in secreting CALB. These endogenous signal peptides thus have the potential to mediate the efficient secretion of heterologous proteins in P. pastoris.     

Molecular genetics of regulated secretion in paramecium

Paramecium is a unicell in which cellular processes are amenable to genetic dissection. Regulated secretion, which designates a secretory pathway where secretory products are first stored in intracellular granules and then released by exocytotic membrane fusion upon external trigger, is an important function in Paramecium, involved in defensive response through the release of organelles called trichocysts. In this review, we focus on recent advances in the molecular genetics of two major aspects of the regulated pathway in Paramecium, the biogenesis of the secretory organelles and their exocytosis.     

Genetic Analysis of the Relationships between the Cell Surface and the Nuclei in PARAMECIUM TETRAURELIA

In Paramecium tetraurelia, a number of mutations have been shown to affect simultaneously cortical organization (attachment of trichocysts to the cortex) and nuclear division (Ruiz et al. 1976). In order to analyze the genetic and physiological basis of this correlation, we have isolated new mutations affecting the properties of the trichocysts and studied their genetic relationships with other previously known mutations. Of 24 to 28 loci controlling the biogenesis and properties of the trichocysts, mutations only in the 16 to 20 loci that control trichocyst attachment to the cortex result in nuclear defects. Cytological observations show that all of these mutants display the same set of nuclear abnormalities: in particular, rounded shape of the resting macronucleus, mispositioning and defective elongation of the dividing macronucleus and unequal repartition of the macro- and micronuclei. This common syndrome is independent of both the mutagenic origin and the mutated locus. Furthermore, by microinjection, it is possible to localize the site of action of the mutations in either the trichocyst compartment or the nontrichocyst compartment. It was found by this technique that the nuclear syndrome is also independent of the site of action of the mutation. All the genetic and physiological data support the conclusion that the nuclear defects are the consequence of the lack of trichocyst attachment to the cortex: in wild-type cells, trichocyst attachment would induce a membranar or perimembranar state necessary for correct nuclear positioning during cell division. In the absence of trichocyst attachment, the cortical control of nuclear division would be abolished. The possible involvement of cytoskeletal links between surface and nuclei is discussed.     

Secretory protein decondensation as a distinct, Ca2+-mediated event during the final steps of exocytosis in Paramecium cells

The contents of secretory vesicles ("trichocysts") were isolated in the condensed state from Paramecium cells. It is well known that the majority portion of trichocysts perform a rapid decondensation process during exocytosis, which is visible in the light microscope. We have analyzed this condensed leads to decondensed transition in vitro and determined some relevant parameters. In the condensed state, free phosphate (and possibly magnesium) ions screen local surplus charges. This is supported by x-ray spectra recorded from individual trichocysts (prepared by physical methods) in a scanning transmission electron microscope. Calcium, as well as other ions that eliminate phosphate by precipitation, produces decondensation in vitro. Under in vivo conditions, Ca2+ enters the vesicle lumen from the outside medium, once an exocytic opening has been formed. Consequently, within the intact cell, membrane fusion and protein decondensation take place with optimal timing. Ca2+ might then trigger decondensation in the same way by precipitating phosphate ions (as it does in vitro) and, indeed, such precipitates (again yielding Ca and P signals in x-ray spectra) can be recognized in situ under trigger conditions. As decondensation is a unidirectional, rapid process in Paramecium cells, it would contribute to drive the discharge of the secretory contents to the outside. Further implications on the energetics of exocytosis are discussed.     

Immunological Characterization of Trichocyst Proteins In the Ciliate Pseudomicrothorax Dubius

ABSTRACT. Ejectable trichocysts were isolated from the ciliate Pseudomicrothorax dubius. Polyclonal antibodies were raised against three groups of trichocyst proteins: G1 (30-31 kDa), G2 (26-27 kDa) and G3 (15-20 kDa). By indirect immunofluorescence, the three antisera strongly label the shafts of ejected trichocysts and the proximal ends of condensed trichocysts within the cells. By immunogold labeling for electron microscopy, the three sera specifically recognize the shafts of both extended and condensed trichocysts and shaft precursors in pretrichocysts as well. On one-dimensional immunoblots of isolated trichocysts, anti-G1 serum recognizes the G1 proteins, anti-G2 serum detects G2 proteins and some G1 proteins, and anti-G3 serum reacts with 15 bands, mainly the G3 and (30-41)-kDa proteins. In cells with and without trichocysts, the sera recognize non-ejectable trichocyst proteins at 41-42 kDa and 47 kDa. On two-dimensional immunoblots of isolated trichocysts, anti-G1 serum labels proteins with a pI of 4.75-5.7, anti-G2 serum labels proteins with a pI of 4.75-6.25 and anti-G3 serum labels proteins with a pI of 4.7-6.6. Analyses of cells with and without trichocysts allow identification of possible precursors between 41 and 47 kDa. Some are in the same pI range as their putative products, but others, labeled by anti-G3 serum, are less acidic than most of their mature products.