Standardization of biological dyes and stains: pitfalls and possibilities.

The present paper gives a review of the actual state of standardization of biological dyes and stains. In a first part general information is given on practical problems encountered by the routine user of dyes with special emphasis on dye contamination. Some theoretical aspects of standardization are discussed. The second part of the paper gives more detailed information on commercial batches of hematoxylin-eosin-, Giemsa- and Papanicolaou-stains and on their standardization. Special problems arising with the application of image analysis techniques are briefly mentioned. User-oriented specifications for the standardization of dyes, stains and staining procedures are given. Fluorescent dyes and dyes used in chromogenic reagents such as the Feulgen-Schiff reaction are not included in this review.     

Standardization of biological dyes and stains: pitfalls and possibilities

Summary The present paper gives a review of the actual state of standardization of biological dyes and stains. In a first part general information is given on practical problems encountered by the routine user of dyes with special emphasis on dye contamination. Some theoretical aspects of standardization are discussed. The second part of the paper gives more detailed information on commercial batches of hematoxylin-eosin-, Giemsa- and Papanicolaou-stains and on their standardization. Special problems arising with the application of image analysis techniques are briefly mentioned. User-oriented specifications for the standardization of dyes, stains and staining procedures are given. Fluorescent dyes and dyes used in chromogenic reagents such as the Feulgen-Schiff reaction are not included in this review.This paper is dedicated to my academic teacher, Prof. Dr. D.H. Wittekind, on the occasion of his 70th birthday     

Improving Biological Dyes and Stains: Quality Testing Versus Standardization

This paper discusses the impact of both standardization and quality testing of dyes and stains in biology and medicine. After a brief review of why standardized dyes and stains are not presently available commercially, two types of testing and ways of improving dye quality are described. National or international organizations could be established to define standardization of dyes and stains. Standardization would be specifically defined as a list of physico-chemical parameters such as elaborated in this paper. Commercial batches of comparable quality may be labeled by the supplier as “standard dye.” a procedure currently performed by the European Council for Clinical and Laboratory Standardization (ECCLS). Also recommended to improve dye quality is commercial dye testing by independent laboratories with subsequent certification for use. This sort of quality control is currently carried out in the United States by the Biological Stain Commission (BSC). The advantages and disadvantages of both techniques and the use of image analysis for the definition of standards are discussed. A combination of both the BSC testing protocols and the ECCLS standards should be established for extended quality control of biological dyes and stains.     

Standardization of the Romanowsky staining procedure: an overview

Commerically available Romanowsky blood stains are variable mixtures of thiazein dyes and brominated fluorescein derivatives with varying degrees of metallic salt contamination in a number of different solvent systems. There is a need for standardized Romanowsky stains of constant composition, which, when used in conjunction with a carefully controlled specimen preparation technique, should give consistent performance. Such a preparation system would be of great value to hematologists in general and would be essential to the validity of data obtained by the digital processing of blood cell images. It is possible to prepare standardized Romanowsky stains as mixtures of two or three dye components, namely, eosin Y, azure B and methylene blue, although azure B has only recently become commercially available at an acceptable degree of purity. The logistic problems of stain standardization are discussed.     

Quantitative proteomics: assessing the spectrum of in-gel protein detection methods

Proteomics research relies heavily on visualization methods for detection of proteins separated by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Commonly used staining approaches involve colorimetric dyes such as Coomassie Brilliant Blue, fluorescent dyes including Sypro Ruby, newly developed reactive fluorophores, as well as a plethora of others. The most desired characteristic in selecting one stain over another is sensitivity, but this is far from the only important parameter. This review evaluates protein detection methods in terms of their quantitative attributes, including limit of detection (i.e., sensitivity), linear dynamic range, inter-protein variability, capacity for spot detection after 2D gel electrophoresis, and compatibility with subsequent mass spectrometric analyses. Unfortunately, many of these quantitative criteria are not routinely or consistently addressed by most of the studies published to date. We would urge more rigorous routine characterization of stains and detection methodologies as a critical approach to systematically improving these critically important tools for quantitative proteomics. In addition, substantial improvements in detection technology, particularly over the last decade or so, emphasize the need to consider renewed characterization of existing stains; the quantitative stains we need, or at least the chemistries required for their future development, may well already exist.     

How Romanowsky stains work and why they remain valuable — including a proposed universal Romanowsky staining mechanism and a rational troubleshooting scheme

Abstract

An introduction to the nomenclature and concept of “Romanowsky stains” is followed by a brief account of the dyes involved and especially the crucial role of azure B and of the impurity of most commercial dye lots. Technical features of standardized and traditional Romanowsky stains are outlined, e.g., number and ratio of the acidic and basic dyes used, solvent effects, staining times, and fixation effects. The peculiar advantages of Romanowsky staining are noted, namely, the polychromasia achieved in a technically simple manner with the potential for stain intensification of “the color purple.” Accounts are provided of a variety of physicochemically relevant topics, namely, acidic and basic dyeing, peculiarities of acidic and basic dye mixtures, consequences of differential staining rates of different cell and tissue components and of different dyes, the chemical significance of “the color purple,” the substrate selectivity for purple color formation and its intensification in situ due to a template effect, effects of resin embedding and prior fixation. Based on these physicochemical phenomena, mechanisms for the various Romanowsky staining applications are outlined including for blood, marrow and cytological smears; G-bands of chromosomes; microorganisms and other single-cell entities; and paraffin and resin tissue sections. The common factors involved in these specific mechanisms are pulled together to generate a “universal” generic mechanism for these stains. Certain generic problems of Romanowsky stains are discussed including the instability of solutions of acidic dye–basic dye mixtures, the inherent heterogeneity of polychrome methylene blue, and the resulting problems of standardization. Finally, a rational trouble-shooting scheme is appended.     

The History of Staining Logwood Dyes

Except for the cochineal derivatives, logwood extract was the first of the important modern stains to be employed in histology. Certain other natural dyes, such as madder and indigo, had been used earlier, but they are of little significance in discussing the history of staining, because none of them nor even alizarin, the derivative of madder, are of any appreciable significance in these days of synthetic dyes. Hematoxylin, on the other hand, still continues a very important stain, and it has played an interesting part in the history of staining.     

The History of Staining Logwood Dyes

Except for the cochineal derivatives, logwood extract was the first of the important modern stains to be employed in histology. Certain other natural dyes, such as madder and indigo, had been used earlier, but they are of little significance in discussing the history of staining, because none of them nor even alizarin, the derivative of madder, are of any appreciable significance in these days of synthetic dyes. Hematoxylin, on the other hand, still continues a very important stain, and it has played an interesting part in the history of staining.     

Electron densitometry of stained virus particles

Methods are described for determining the relative mass of particles in electron microscope specimens through the measurement of photographic densities in recorded images. These methods were applied to a quantitative study of the amounts of electron stains that could be associated with the particles of tomato bushy stunt virus (BSV) and tobacco mosaic virus (TMV). In the pH range above 2 where the viruses are stable, the amount of stain absorbed is too small to produce adequate contrast in the electron microscope. Maximum stain absorption was achieved at pH about 1 where with several reagents and combinations of reagents the mass of BSV could be increased to about four times that of the unstained particles. Optimum results were obtained with phosphotungstic acid alone or in combination with Pt, Th, or La ions. Since the pH conditions for high stain absorption are normally destructive, morphology is satisfactorily preserved only when the phosphotungstic acid is applied in concentrations of 10 per cent or greater or when the use of destructive reagents is preceded by a preliminary fixation under mild conditions. Maximum staining of TMV increased the mass of the particles to about two times that of the unstained. Estimates of the mass of heavily stained BSV particles indicate that their density is 3.3 gm./cm.(3) The high internal hydration of BSV probably accounts for the greater stain absorption and penetration compared to those of TMV which has very low or zero internal hydration. Anomalous images resulting from the use of electron stains are shown and discussed.     

The Mechanism of the Gram Reaction. III. Solubilities of Dye-Iodine Precipitates and Further Studies of Primary Dye Substitutes

Solubilities of dye-iodine precipitates in alcohol and in aqueous safranin solution were determined by direct solubility methods and by photocolorimetric methods. It was found that, increasing precipitate solubility in alcohol or safranin solution gave decreasing differentiation between Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria. Dyes which did not stain the cells well as a primary stain did not give good Gram stains, regardless of the solubilities of their precipitates. Some dyes (typified by methylene blue) which gave relatively alcohol-insoluble iodine precipitates gave inferior Gram differentiation because these precipitates were readily soluble in the safranin counterstain.

Solubilities of precipitates of crystal violet and various iodine substitutes were determined photocolorimetrically. The ability of a substance to replace iodine in the Gram stain correlated with its ability to give a precipitate which was only slightly soluble in alcohol and relatively insoluble in aqueous safranin solution.

It was concluded that the usual Gram reagents are not truly specific for the differentiation. Any dye and mordant could be used if the dye was deeply colored, stained the cells well, and if the precipitate of dye and mordant was only slightly soluble in alcohol and relatively insoluble in the counterstain. These factors, combined with those influencing differences in cell membrane permeability, constitute the most important factors in the Gram stain differentiation.

Studies were made concerning the ability of dyes to substitute for crystal violet in the Gram procedure. Of 29 dye samples reported on here for the first time none proved to be good substitutes for crystal violet.     

Influence of staining on fast automated cell segmentation, feature extraction and cell image analysis

FAZYTAN, a system for fast automated cell segmentation, cell image analysis and extraction of nuclear features, was used to analyze cervical cell images variously stained by the conventional Papanicolaou stain, the new Papanicolaou stain and hematoxylin and thionin only; the last two dyes are used as the nuclear stains in the two versions of the Papanicolaou stain. Other dyes were also tried in cell classification experiments. All cell images in the variously stained samples could be described by the same nuclear features as had been adapted for the discrimination of conventional-Papanicolaou-stained cells. Variances were lower for thionin-stained cells as compared with hematoxylin-stained cells. By application of spectrophotometry, it was confirmed that the spectra of the cytoplasmic counterstains are superimposed on those of the nuclear stains. It appears that a variety of dyes are suitable as cytologic stains for cell classification by the FAZYTAN system, provided that they achieve sufficiently strong nuclear-cytoplasmic contrast by precisely delineating the chromatin texture.     

Prediction of in situ fluorescence of histochemical reagents using a structure-staining correlation procedure

Summary A total of ninety acid, basic, and non-ionic dyes were screened for fluorescent staining of various Carnoy fixed rat tissues. It was found that the fluorescence/nonfluorescence of a dye could be predicted using a conjugated bond number (CBN) cut-off value. Thus 90% of dyes with CBNs of 29 or less were fluorescent; whilst 70% of dyes whose CBNs exceeded 30 were nonfluorescent. The cut-off value was not significantly influenced by the charge, or the hydrophobic-hydrophilic character of the dye; though fluorescence was greatly influenced by the mode of fixation. The CBN cut-off value proved surprisingly robust. Thus most fluorochromes found in the histochemical literature have small conjugated systems, with CBNs less than the cut-off value. This includes labels of immunoglobulins, vital stains of neurones, and fluorescent Schiff reagents. Conversely several dyes used to quench background autofluorescence have large conjugated systems, with CBNs substantially above the cut-off value.In honour of Prof. P. van Duijn     

Prediction of in situ fluorescence of histochemical reagents using a structure-staining correlation procedure

A total of ninety acid, basic, and non-ionic dyes were screened for fluorescent staining of various Carnoy fixed rat tissues. It was found that the fluorescence/non-fluorescence of a dye could be predicted using a conjugated bond number (CBN) cut-off value. Thus 90% of dyes with CBNs of 29 or less were fluorescent; whilst 70% of dyes whose CBNs exceeded 30 were nonfluorescent. The cut-off value was not significantly influenced by the charge, or the hydrophobic-hydrophilic character of the dye; though fluorescence was greatly influenced by the mode of fixation. The CBN cut-off value proved surprisingly robust. Thus most fluorochromes found in the histochemical literature have small conjugated systems, with CBNs less than the cut-off value. This includes labels of immunoglobulins, vital stains of neurones, and fluorescent Schiff reagents. Conversely several dyes used to quench background autofluorescence have large conjugated systems, with CBNs substantially above the cut-off value.     

ELECTRON DENSITOMETRY OF STAINED VIRUS PARTICLES

Methods are described for determining the relative mass of particles in electron microscope specimens through the measurement of photographic densities in recorded images. These methods were applied to a quantitative study of the amounts of electron stains that could be associated with the particles of tomato bushy stunt virus (BSV) and tobacco mosaic virus (TMV). In the pH range above 2 where the viruses are stable, the amount of stain absorbed is too small to produce adequate contrast in the electron microscope. Maximum stain absorption was achieved at pH about 1 where with several reagents and combinations of reagents the mass of BSV could be increased to about four times that of the unstained particles. Optimum results were obtained with phosphotungstic acid alone or in combination with Pt, Th, or La ions. Since the pH conditions for high stain absorption are normally destructive, morphology is satisfactorily preserved only when the phosphotungstic acid is applied in concentrations of 10 per cent or greater or when the use of destructive reagents is preceded by a preliminary fixation under mild conditions. Maximum staining of TMV increased the mass of the particles to about two times that of the unstained. Estimates of the mass of heavily stained BSV particles indicate that their density is 3.3 gm./cm.³ The high internal hydration of BSV probably accounts for the greater stain absorption and penetration compared to those of TMV which has very low or zero internal hydration. Anomalous images resulting from the use of electron stains are shown and discussed.     

The analysis of some commercial dyes and Romamowsky stains by high-performance liquid chromatography.

High-performance liquid chromatography has been used to quantitate batch variations in commericial samples of thiazine dyes, thiazine eosinates, and Romanowsky-type blood stains. It has been observed that all the dyes and eosinates examined, only methylene blue chloride and thionin were reasonably free of their methylated, demethylated, or oxidized homologs. Large variations in composition were observed between most of the samples of each type examined. In several instances the labeled compound was a minority species. In one instance a dye was apparently mislabeled. Large compositional variation was found between various batches of Wright and Giemsa stains, whereas significant differences between the thiazine composition of these two stain types were minor. Very little compositional variation was observed between the lots of LARC stain examined. The thiazine composition of Ames stain was similar for the three lots examined. Ames stain, however, was found to contain several components of unknown composition which have been linked to degradation products formed when stains are aged in methanolic solution.     

Standardization in Biological Staining. The Influence of Dye Manufacturing

The purpose of biological staining is to obtain specimens of biological material that can be assessed in the microscope. These specimens are influenced by all processes from removal from the intact organism to mounting on the microscopic slide. To achieve comparable results with various techniques for biological staining, standardization of all procedures and reagents is mandatory. In this paper, I focus particularly on dyes and consider the possibilities for obtaining standardized dyes. In general practice, most biological staining takes place with available commercial dyes. These dyes may or may not have been subjected to quality assessment either internally by the producer or vendor or externally by independent investigators or organizations such as the Biological Stain Commission. Concerted attempts at standardization in Europe are discussed. The latest results of this work, the European standard EN 12376, is presented. This standard is concerned with information supplied by the manufacturer with in vitro diagnostic reagents for biological staining. The standard has been prepared by a Working Group on Staining in Biology under Technical Committee 140, In Vitro Medical Devices, of the European committee for standardization, CEN.     

Standardization in biological staining. The influence of dye manufacturing.

The purpose of biological staining is to obtain specimens of biological material that can be assessed in the microscope. These specimens are influenced by all processes from removal from the intact organism to mounting on the microscopic slide. To achieve comparable results with various techniques for biological staining, standardization of all procedures and reagents is mandatory. In this paper, I focus particularly on dyes and consider the possibilities for obtaining standardized dyes. In general practice, most biological staining takes place with available commercial dyes. These dyes may or may not have been subjected to quality assessment either internally by the producer or vendor or externally by independent investigators or organizations such as the Biological Stain Commission. Concerted attempts at standardization in Europe are discussed. The latest results of this work, the European standard EN 12376, is presented. This standard is concerned with information supplied by the manufacturer with in vitro diagnostic reagents for biological staining. The standard has been prepared by a Working Group on Staining in Biology under Technical Committee 140, In Vitro Medical Devices, of the European committee for standardization, CEN.