The pea (Pisum sativum L.) genes sym33 and sym40 control infection thread formation and root nodule function

Two novel non-allelic mutants that were unable to fix nitrogen (Fix^?) were obtained after EMS (ethyl methyl sulfonate) mutagenesis of pea (Pisum sativum L.). Both mutants, SGEFix^?–1 and SGEFix^?–2, form two types of nodules: SGEFix^?–1 forms numerous white and some pink nodules, while mutant SGEFix^?–2 forms white nodules with a dark pit at the distal end and also some pinkish nodules. Both mutations are monogenic and recessive. In both lines the manifestation of the mutant phenotype is associated with the root genotype. White nodules of SGEFix^?–1 are characterised by hypertrophied infection threads and infection droplets, mass endocytosis of bacteria, abnormal morphological differentiation of bacteroids, and premature degradation of nodule symbiotic structures. The structure of the pink nodules of SGEFix^?–1 does not differ from that of the parental line, SGE. White nodules of SGEFix^?–2 are characterised by “locked” infection threads surrounded with abnormally thick plant cell walls. In these nodules there is no endocytosis of bacteria into host-cell cytoplasm. The pinkish nodules of SGEFix^?–2 are characterised by virtually undifferentiated bacteroids and premature degradation of nodule tissues. Thus, the novel pea symbiotic genes, sym40 and sym33, identified after complementation analysis in SGEFix^?–1 and SGEFix^?–2 lines, respectively, control early nodule developmental stages connected with infection thread formation and function.     

Rhizobium fix genes mediate at least two communication steps in symbiotic nodule development

To identify bacterial genes involved in symbiotic nodule development, ineffective nodules of alfalfa (Medicago sativa) induced by 64 different Fix-mutants of Rhizobium meliloti were characterized by assaying for symbiotic gene expression and by morphological studies. The expression of leghemoglobin and nodulin-25 genes from alfalfa and of the nifHD genes from R. meliloti were monitored by hybridizing the appropriate DNA probes to RNA samples prepared from nodules. The mutants were accordingly divided into three groups. In group I none of the genes were expressed, in group II only the plant genes were expressed and in group III all three genes were transcribed. Light and electron microscopical analysis of nodules revealed that nodule development was halted at different stages in nodules induced by different group I mutants. In most cases nodules were empty lacking infection threads and bacteroids or nodules contained infection threads and a few released bacteroids. In nodules induced by a third mutant class bacteria were released into the host cells, however the formation of the peribacteroid membrane was not normal. On this basis we suggest that peribacteroid membrane formation precedes leghemoglobin and nodulin-25 induction, moreover, after induction of nodulation by the nod genes at least two communication steps between the bacteria and the host plants are necessary for the development of the mature nodule. By complementing each mutant of group I with a genomic R. meliloti library made in pLAFRl, four new fix loci were identified, indicating that several bacterial genes are involved in late nodule development.     

Distribution of legume arabinogalactan protein-extensin (AGPE) glycoproteins in symbiotically defective pea mutants with abnormal infection threads

The interface between the host cell and the microsymbiont is an important zone for development and differentiation during consecutive stages of Rhizobium-legume symbiosis. Legume root nodule extensins, otherwise known as arabinogalactan protein-extensins (AGPEs) are abundant components of infection thread matrix. We have characterized the origin and distribution of these glycoproteins at the symbiotic interface of root nodules of symbiotically defective mutants of pea (Pisum sativum L.) by using immunogold localization with MAC265 an anti-AGPE monoclonal antibody. For mutants with defective growth of infection threads, the AGPE epitope was abundant in the extracellular matrix surrounding infected host cells in the central infected tissue of the nodule, as well as in the lumen of Rhizobiuminduced infection threads. This seems to indicate a mistargeting of AGPE as a consequence of abnormal growth of the infection threads. Furthermore, mutants in the gene sym33 showed reduced labeling with MAC265 and, in some infection threads and droplets, the label was completely absent, a phenomenon that is not observed in wild-type nodules. This suggests an alteration in the composition of the infection thread matrix for sym33 mutants, which may be correlated to the absence of endocytosis of rhizobia into the host cytoplasm.     

The pea ( Pisum sativum L.) genes sym33 and sym40 control infection thread formation and root nodule function

Two novel non-allelic mutants that were unable to fix nitrogen (Fix⁻) were obtained after EMS (ethyl methyl sulfonate) mutagenesis of pea (Pisum sativum L.). Both mutants, SGEFix⁻–1 and SGEFix⁻–2, form two types of nodules: SGEFix⁻–1 forms numerous white and some pink nodules, while mutant SGEFix⁻–2 forms white nodules with a dark pit at the distal end and also some pinkish nodules. Both mutations are monogenic and recessive. In both lines the manifestation of the mutant phenotype is associated with the root genotype. White nodules of SGEFix⁻–1 are characterised by hypertrophied infection threads and infection droplets, mass endocytosis of bacteria, abnormal morphological differentiation of bacteroids, and premature degradation of nodule symbiotic structures. The structure of the pink nodules of SGEFix⁻–1 does not differ from that of the parental line, SGE. White nodules of SGEFix⁻–2 are characterised by “locked” infection threads surrounded with abnormally thick plant cell walls. In these nodules there is no endocytosis of bacteria into host-cell cytoplasm. The pinkish nodules of SGEFix⁻–2 are characterised by virtually undifferentiated bacteroids and premature degradation of nodule tissues. Thus, the novel pea symbiotic genes, sym40 and sym33, identified after complementation analysis in SGEFix⁻–1 and SGEFix⁻–2 lines, respectively, control early nodule developmental stages connected with infection thread formation and function. Received: 12 June 1998 / Accepted: 25 June 1998     

The Auxin Transport Inhibitor N-(1-Naphthyl)phthalamic Acid Elicits Pseudonodules on Nonnodulating Mutants of White Sweetclover

The collection of symbiotic (sym) mutants of white sweetclover (Melilotus alba Desr.) provides a developmental sequence of mutants blocked early in infection or nodule organogenesis. Mutant phenotypes include non-nodulating mutants that exhibit root-hair deformations in response to Rhizobium meliloti, mutants that form ineffective nodules lacking infection threads, and mutants that form infection threads and ineffective nodules. Mutant alleles from both the sym-1 and the sym-3 loci exhibited a non-nodulating phenotype in response to R. meliloti, although one allele in the sym-1 locus formed ineffective nodules at a low frequency. Spot-inoculation experiments on a non-nodulating allele in the sym-3 locus indicated that this mutant lacked cortical cell divisions following inoculation with R. meliloti. The auxin transport inhibitor N-(1-naphthyl)phthalamic acid elicited development of pseudonodules at a high frequency on all of the sweetclover sym mutants, including the non-nodulating mutants, in which the early nodulin ENOD2 was expressed. This suggests that N-(1-naphthyl)phthalamic acid activates cortical cell divisions by circumventing a secondary signal transduction event that is lacking in the non-nodulating sweetclover mutants. The sym-3 locus and possibly the sym-1 locus appear to be essential to early host plant responses essential to nodule organogenesis.     

Sequential expression of two late nodulin genes in the infected cells of alfalfa root nodules.

The Nms-22 and leghemoglobin (Lb) genes are expressed exclusively in the infected cells of alfalfa root nodules. Expression of these two late nodulin genes originated at distinct cellular boundaries within the symbiotic region of the nodule. The Nms-22 gene was expressed in all infected cells, including those just adjacent to the meristematic region. Lb gene expression was induced in older infected cells and was most prominent in the mature region of the nodule. Despite this temporal separation of gene expression, both the Nms-22 and Lb genes were expressed in nodules elicited by bacA mutants in which bacteroid development has been blocked just after release from the infection thread.     

nip, a symbiotic Medicago truncatula mutant that forms root nodules with aberrant infection threads and plant defense-like response

To investigate the legume-Rhizobium symbiosis, we isolated and studied a novel symbiotic mutant of the model legume Medicago truncatula, designated nip (numerous infections and polyphenolics). When grown on nitrogen-free media in the presence of the compatible bacterium Sinorhizobium meliloti, the nip mutant showed nitrogen deficiency symptoms. The mutant failed to form pink nitrogen-fixing nodules that occur in the wild-type symbiosis, but instead developed small bump-like nodules on its roots that were blocked at an early stage of development. Examination of the nip nodules by light microscopy after staining with X-Gal for S. meliloti expressing a constitutive GUS gene, by confocal microscopy following staining with SYTO-13, and by electron microscopy revealed that nip initiated symbiotic interactions and formed nodule primordia and infection threads. The infection threads in nip proliferated abnormally and very rarely deposited rhizobia into plant host cells; rhizobia failed to differentiate further in these cases. nip nodules contained autofluorescent cells and accumulated a brown pigment. Histochemical staining of nip nodules revealed this pigment to be polyphenolic accumulation. RNA blot analyses demonstrated that nip nodules expressed only a subset of genes associated with nodule organogenesis, as well as elevated expression of a host defense-associated phenylalanine ammonia lyase gene. nip plants were observed to have abnormal lateral roots. nip plant root growth and nodulation responded normally to ethylene inhibitors and precursors. Allelism tests showed that nip complements 14 other M. truncatula nodulation mutants but not latd, a mutant with a more severe nodulation phenotype as well as primary and lateral root defects. Thus, the nip mutant defines a new locus, NIP, required for appropriate infection thread development during invasion of the nascent nodule by rhizobia, normal lateral root elongation, and normal regulation of host defense-like responses during symbiotic interactions.     

Genetic dissection of the initiation of the infection process and nodule tissue development in the Rhizobium-pea (Pisum sativum L.) symbiosis

Twelve non-nodulating pea (Pisum sativum L.) mutants were studied to identify the blocks in nodule tissue development. In nine, the reason for the lack of infection thread (IT) development was studied; this had been characterized previously in the other three mutants. With respect to IT development, mutants in gene sym7 are interrupted at the stage of colonization of the pocket in the curled root hair (Crh- phenotype), mutants in genes sym37 and sym38 are blocked at the stage of IT growth in the root hair cell (Ith- phenotype) and mutants in gene sym34 at the stage of IT growth inside root cortex cells (Itr- phenotype). With respect to nodule tissue development, mutants in genes sym7, sym14 and sym35 were shown to be blocked at the stage of cortical cell divisions (Ccd- phenotype), mutants in gene sym34 are halted at the stage of nodule primordium (NP) development (Npd- phenotype) and mutants in genes sym37 and sym38 are arrested at the stage of nodule meristem development (Nmd- phenotype). Thus, the sequential functioning of the genes Sym37, Sym38 and the gene Sym34 apparently differs in the infection process and during nodule tissue development. Based on these data, a scheme is suggested for the sequential functioning of early pea symbiotic genes in the two developmental processes: infection and nodule tissue formation.     

Development of ectopic roots from abortive nodule primordia

The symbiotic phenotype of five Tn5-induced mutants of Rhizobium etli affected in different anabolic pathways (namely, gluconeogenesis and biosynthesis of lysine, purine, or pyrimidine) was analyzed. These mutants induced, on the root of Phaseolus vulgaris, a normal early sequence of morphogenetics events, including root hair deformation and development of nodule primordia. Later on, however, from the resulting root outgrowths, instead of nodules, one or more ectopic roots (spaced closely related and agravitropic) emerged. Therefore, this group of mutant was collectively called "root inducer" (RIND). It was observed that the RIND-induced infection threads aborted early inside the invaded root hair, and that the resulting abortive nodules lack induction of late nodulin genes. Moreover, experiments performed using a conditional mutant (a methionine-requiring invader) revealed that bacterial invasion plays a key role in the maintenance of the program of nodule development and, in particular, in the differentiation of the most specific symbiotic tissue of globose nodules, the central tissue. These data indicate that, in P. vulgaris, the nodule primordium is a root-specified pro-meristematic tissue.     

crinkle,a novel symbiotic mutant that affects the infection thread growth and alters the root hair,trichome, and seed development in Lotus japonicus

To elucidate the mechanisms involved in Rhizobium-legume symbiosis, we examined a novel symbiotic mutant, crinkle (Ljsym79), from the model legume Lotus japonicus. On nitrogen-starved medium, crinkle mutants inoculated with the symbiont bacterium Mesorhizobium loti MAFF 303099 showed severe nitrogen deficiency symptoms. This mutant was characterized by the production of many bumps and small, white, uninfected nodule-like structures. Few nodules were pale-pink and irregularly shaped with nitrogen-fixing bacteroids and expressing leghemoglobin mRNA. Morphological analysis of infected roots showed that nodulation in crinkle mutants is blocked at the stage of the infection process. Confocal microscopy and histological examination of crinkle nodules revealed that infection threads were arrested upon penetrating the epidermal cells. Starch accumulation in uninfected cells and undeveloped vascular bundles were also noted in crinkle nodules. Results suggest that the Crinkle gene controls the infection process that is crucial during the early stage of nodule organogenesis. Aside from the symbiotic phenotypes, crinkle mutants also developed morphological alterations, such as crinkly or wavy trichomes, short seedpods with aborted embryos, and swollen root hairs. crinkle is therefore required for symbiotic nodule development and for other aspects of plant development.     

Symbiotic mutants deficient in nodule establishment identified after T-DNA transformation of Lotus japonicus

Nitrogen-fixing root nodules develop on legumes as a result of an interaction between host plants and soil bacteria collectively referred to as rhizobia. The organogenic process resulting in nodule development is triggered by the bacterial microsymbiont, but genetically controlled by the host plant genome. Using T-DNA insertion as a tool to identify novel plant genes that regulate nodule ontogeny, we have identified two putatively tagged symbiotic loci, Ljsym8 and Ljsym13, in the diploid legume Lotus japonicus. The sym8 mutants are arrested during infection by the bacteria early in the developmental process. The sym13 mutants are arrested in the final stages of infection, and ineffective nodules are formed. These two plant mutant lines were identified in progeny from 1112 primary transformants obtained after Agrobacterium tumefaciens T-DNA-mediated transformation of L. japonicus and subsequent screening for defects in the symbiosis with Mesorhizobium loti. Additional nontagged mutants arrested at different developmental stages were also identified and genetic complementation tests assigned all the mutations to 16 monogenic symbiotic loci segregating recessive mutant alleles. In the screen reported here independent symbiotic loci thus appeared with a frequency of ～1.5%, suggesting that a relatively large set of genes is required for the symbiotic interaction.     

Effect of mutations in the pea genes <Emphasis Type="Italic">Sym33</Emphasis> and <Emphasis Type="Italic">Sym40</Emphasis>

Two symbiotic pea (Pisum sativum L.) mutants SGEFix(-)-1 (sym40) and SGEFix(-)-2 (sym33) with abnormalities in infection thread formation in symbiotic root nodules were characterised with respect to dynamics of arbuscule development at 15 degrees C and 24 degrees C. Mutation of sym33 decreased mycorrhiza colonisation at both temperatures and delayed arbuscule development at 15 degrees C, whereas mutation of sym40 accelerated mycorrhiza colonisation and arbuscule senescence at 24 degrees C. The differences between the mutants and the wild-type were more pronounced at 24 degrees C, a temperature close to the optimum for pea growth. The results demonstrate that both pea genes are important in the control of arbuscular mycorrhiza development and can be considered necessary for the tripartite symbiosis in pea.     

CERBERUS, a novel U-box protein containing WD-40 repeats, is required for formation of the infection thread and nodule development in the legume–Rhizobium symbiosis

Endosymbiotic infection of legume plants by Rhizobium bacteria is initiated through infection threads (ITs) which are initiated within and penetrate from root hairs and deliver the endosymbionts into nodule cells. Despite recent progress in understanding the mutual recognition and early symbiotic signaling cascades in host legumes, the molecular mechanisms underlying bacterial infection processes and successive nodule organogenesis are still poorly understood. We isolated a novel symbiotic mutant of Lotus japonicus , cerberus , which shows defects in IT formation and nodule organogenesis. Map-based cloning of the causal gene allowed us to identify the CERBERUS gene, which encodes a novel protein containing a U-box domain and WD-40 repeats. CERBERUS expression was detected in the roots and nodules, and was enhanced after inoculation of Mesorhizobium loti . Strong expression was detected in developing nodule primordia and the infected zone of mature nodules. In cerberus mutants, Rhizobium colonized curled root hair tips, but hardly penetrated into root hair cells. The occasional ITs that were formed inside the root hair cells were mostly arrested within the epidermal cell layer. Nodule organogenesis was aborted prematurely, resulting in the formation of a large number of small bumps which contained no endosymbiotic bacteria. These phenotypic and genetic analyses, together with comparisons with other legume mutants with defects in IT formation, indicate that CERBERUS plays a critical role in the very early steps of IT formation as well as in growth and differentiation of nodules.     

Symbiotic mutants deficient in nodule establishment identified after T-DNA transformation of Lotus japonicus

Nitrogen-fixing root nodules develop on legumes as a result of an interaction between host plants and soil bacteria collectively referred to as rhizobia. The organogenic process resulting in nodule development is triggered by the bacterial microsymbiont, but genetically controlled by the host plant genome. Using T-DNA insertion as a tool to identify novel plant genes that regulate nodule ontogeny, we have identified two putatively tagged symbiotic loci, Ljsym8 and Ljsym13, in the diploid legume Lotus japonicus. The sym8 mutants are arrested during infection by the bacteria early in the developmental process. The sym13 mutants are arrested in the final stages of infection, and ineffective nodules are formed. These two plant mutant lines were identified in progeny from 1112 primary transformants obtained after Agrobacterium tumefaciens T-DNA-mediated transformation of L. japonicus and subsequent screening for defects in the symbiosis with Mesorhizobium loti. Additional nontagged mutants arrested at different developmental stages were also identified and genetic complementation tests assigned all the mutations to 16 monogenic symbiotic loci segregating recessive mutant alleles. In the screen reported here independent symbiotic loci thus appeared with a frequency of ∼1.5%, suggesting that a relatively large set of genes is required for the symbiotic interaction. Received: 12 May 1998 / Accepted: 24 June 1998     

Rhizobium meliloti nodulation genes allow Agrobacterium tumefaciens and Escherichia coli to form pseudonodules on alfalfa.

Regions of the Rhizobium meliloti symbiotic plasmid (20 to 40 kilobase pairs long) containing nodulation (nod) genes were transferred to Agrobacterium tumefaciens or Escherichia coli by conjugation. The A. tumefaciens and E. coli transconjugants elicited root hair curling and the formation of ineffective pseudonodules on inoculated alfalfa plants. A tumefaciens elicited pseudonodules formed at a variable frequency, ranging from 15 to 45%, irrespective of the presence of the Ti plasmid. These pseudonodules developed characteristic nodule meristems, and in some nodules, infection threads were found within the interior of nodules. Infrequently, infection threads penetrated deformed root hairs, but these threads were found only in a minority of nodules. There was no evidence of bacterial release from the infection threads. In addition to being found within threads, agrobacteria were also found in intercellular spaces and within nodule cells that had senesced . In the latter case, the bacteria appeared to invade the nodule cells independently of infection threads and degenerated at the same time as the senescing host cells. No peribacteroid membranes enclosed any agrobacteria , and no bacteroid differentiation was observed. In contrast to the A. tumefaciens-induced pseudonodules , the E. coli-induced pseudonodules were completely devoid of bacteria; infection threads were not found to penetrate root hairs or within nodules. Our results suggest that relatively few Rhizobium genes are involved in the earliest stages of nodulation, and that curling of root hairs and penetration of bacteria via root hair infection threads are not prerequisites for nodule meristem formation in alfalfa.     

Expression of the Medicago truncatula DM12 gene suggests roles of the symbiotic nodulation receptor kinase in nodules and during early nodule development

The Medicago truncatula DMI2 gene encodes a receptorlike kinase required for establishing root endosymbioses. The DMI2 gene was shown to be expressed much more highly in roots and nodules than in leaves and stems. In roots, its expression was not altered by nitrogen starvation or treatment with lipochitooligosaccharidic Nod factors. Moreover, the DMI2 mRNA abundance in roots of the nfp, dmil, dmi3, nsp1, nsp2, and hcl symbiotic mutants was similar to the wild type, whereas lower levels in some dmi2 mutants could be explained by regulation by the nonsense-mediated decay, RNA surveillance mechanism. Using pDMI2::GUS fusions, the expression of DMI2 in roots appeared to be localized primarily in the cortical and epidermal cells of the younger, lateral roots and was not observed in the root apices. Following inoculation with Sinorhizobium meliloti, the DMI2 gene was induced in the nodule primordia, before penetration by the infection threads. No increased expression was seen in lateral-root primordia. In nodules, expression was observed primarily in a few cell layers of the pre-infection zone. These results are consistent with the DMI2 gene mediating Nod factor perception and transduction leading to rhizobial infection, not only in root epidermal cells but also during nodule development.     

The relationship between nodulin gene expression and the Rhizobium nod genes in Vicia sativa root nodule development

The role of the Rhizobium nod genes in the induction of nodulin gene expression was examined by analyzing nodules formed on vetch roots by bacterial strains containing only the nod region. Introduction of an 11-kb cloned nod region of the R. leguminosarum sym plasmid pRL1JI into sym plasmid-cured rhizobia conferred on the recipient strains the ability to induce nodules in which all nodulin genes were expressed. This proves that from the sym plasmid only the nod region is involved in the induction of nodulin gene expression. A transconjugant of Agrobacterium carrying the same nod region induces nodules in which only early nodulin gene expression is detected. Thus, the nod region is essential for the induction of early nodulin gene expression. In this case, nodule cytology may indicate that a defense response of the plant interferes with the induction of late nodulin gene expression. Indirect evidence is presented that indeed the Rhizobium nod genes are also in some way involved in the induction of the expression of late noduling genes. The combination between histological data and pattern of nodulin gene expression furthermore reveals a correlation between nodule structure and nodulin gene expression. This correlation may aid in speculations about the functions of nodulins.