T helper cell lines that augment in vivo cytotoxic T-cell responses to minor alloantigens

We have investigated the ability of long-term cultured T helper (Th) cell lines to help an in vivo cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) response to non-H-2 alloantigens (minor antigens). Th cell lines specific for various single or undefined minor antigens were selected by regular restimulation with antigen in vitro. They were antigen specific and H-2 restricted in proliferation assays and were found to be able to help primary CTL responses to multiple minor antigens and secondary CTL responses to single minor antigens. Although the Th were antigen specific they did not determine the specificity of the CTL. Th cells were both necessary and limiting for an effective CTL response indicating that "helper-independent" CTL are not in themselves sufficient to generate a strong in vivo response. Under conditions where a CTL response was clearly H-2 restricted, Th cells were not. Thus, the Th cells appeared to be activated by reprocessed antigen rather than antigen on the surface of the injected antigenic cells even though the CTL themselves reacted directly to the injected antigen.     

Modeling of SEB-induced host gene expression to correlate in vitro to in vivo responses

Detection of exposure to biological threat agents has relied on ever more sensitive methods for pathogen identification, but that usually requires pathogen proliferation to dangerous, near untreatable levels. Recent events have demonstrated that assessing exposure to a biological threat agent well in advance of onset of illness or at various stages post-exposure is invaluable among the diagnostic options. There is an urgent need for better diagnostic tools that will be sensitive, rapid, and unambiguous. Since human clinical cases of illness induced by biothreat agents are, fortunately, rare, use of animal models that closely mimic the human illness is the only in vivo option. Such studies can be very difficult and expensive; therefore, maximizing the information obtained from in vitro exposures to peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) provide an opportunity to investigate dose/time variability in host responses. In our quest to study staphylococcal enterotoxin B (SEB) induced host gene expression patterns, we addressed two core issues using microarray analysis and predictive modeling. Our first objective was to determine gene expression patterns in human PBMCs exposed to SEB in vitro. Second, we compared the in vitro data with host responses gene expression patterns in vivo using PBMCs from an animal model of SEB intoxication that closely replicates the progression of illness in humans. We used cDNA microarrays to study global gene expression patterns in piglets intoxicated with SEB. We applied a supervised learning method for class prediction based on the k-nearest neighbor algorithm for the data obtained in piglets exposed to SEB in vivo against a training data set. This data set included gene expression profiles derived from in vitro exposures to eight different pathogens (Bacillus anthracis, Yersinia pestis, Brucella melitensis, SEB, cholera toxin, Clostridium botulinum toxin A, Venezuelan equine encephalitis, and Dengue-2) in PBMCs. We found that despite differences in gene expression profiles between in vitro and in vivo systems, there exists a subset of genes that show correlations between in vitro and in vivo exposures, which can be used as a predictor of exposure to SEB in vivo.     

T cell responses to alloantigens. I. Studies of in vivo and in vitro immunologic memory and suppression by limit dilution analysis

A limit dilution technique was used to study the frequency of cytotoxic T cell precursors (f pre Tc) in the peripheral blood lymphocytes (pbl) of naive and alloimunized mice. It was found that alloimmune mice showed a 2- to 5-fold specific increase in the f pre Tc reactive to the immunizing alloantigens. This technique was further adapted for use as a sensitive in vitro assay for alloantigen-specific suppressor T cells. It was found that nonimmunosuppressed B6AF1 mice bearing surviving B10.BR cardiac allografts had circulating alloantigen-specific suppressor cells. In vitro it was shown that the culture of heat-inactivated B10.D2 spleen cells with B6AF1 spleen cells gave rise to alloantigen-specific B6AF1 suppressor cells.     

Suppressor T cell recognition of major and minor histocompatibility alloantigens: selected suppression of MHC-directed responses by minor alloantigen Ts

The induction of suppression by i.v. administered alloantigens in the murine host was analyzed as a model of the possible effects of blood transfusion on transplant survival. The results indicated that suppressor T cells (Ts) specific for minor histocompatibility alloantigens could be readily induced by the i.v. presentation of minor alloantigen-disparate spleen cells. In contrast, similar priming with cells differing solely at the H-2 major histocompatibility complex stimulated only positive T cell immunity, with no evidence of suppression. The induction of H-2 directed Ts activity could be accomplished only by i.v. priming with major plus minor incompatible donor cells, suggesting that suppressor cell recognition of minor alloantigens may have facilitated the generation of Ts against H-2-encoded major transplantation antigens. A role for minor histocompatibility antigens in the regulation of H-2-specific immunity at the effector level was also indicated. Ts induced by i.v. pretreatment with minor antigen-disparate donor cells not only suppressed the delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) response to the relevant minor alloantigens, but also inhibited DTH against unrelated H-2 alloantigens introduced during subsequent intradermal immunization. Suppression of H-2-directed T cell reactivity was specific in that the presence of the Ts-inducing minor alloantigens was also required and occurred only when the minor and unrelated major alloantigens were presented within the same inoculum, if not on the same cell surface. The capacity of Lyt-2+Ts or Ts-derived suppressive factors specific for one set of cell surface molecules to modulate responses to an unrelated group of surface antigens does not appear to represent a general phenomenon, because similar suppression of immunity to unrelated tumor-specific transplantation antigens by minor-specific Ts was not observed. These results are discussed with respect to the possible mechanism of H-2-directed suppression and the role of the I region in Ts recognition of antigen.     

Defects in tumor cell immunogenicity: lymphokine signals in in vitro cytolytic responses to tumor alloantigens

The B16 melanoma of C57BL/6 mice illustrates a deficiency in immunostimulation which may be important in some host-tumor relationships. B16 immunizes very poorly, even against its own major histocompatibility complex (MHC) antigens. We have compared the anti-MHC cytolytic response induced in vitro by B16 and by other tumors of both lymphoid and nonlymphoid origin. We have also studied the role of indomethacin and exogenous lymphokines in facilitating these responses and examined the relationship of specific and nonspecific effector cells induced. In contrast to normal lymphoid cells and two lymphoid tumor cells (EL4 and WEHI-265), the three nonlymphoid tumors, B16, Lewis lung tumor (3LL), and MC-2 fibrosarcoma, failed to induce primary cytolytic responses by themselves. MC-2 and B16 represented two different defects in immunogenicity. MC-2, which we have shown previously to induce an in vivo cytolytic response, could also immunize in vitro provided that prostaglandin production was blocked with indomethacin. In contrast B16, which is poorly immunogenic in vivo, immunized in vitro only if a concanavalin A-induced lymphokine supernatant (CS) was added as an exogenous source of "signal 2." High concentrations of the interleukin 2-containing Con A-induced spleen cell culture supernatant-induced non-H-2b-specific lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells in the absence of B16 stimulator cells. However, lymphokine concentrations too low to induce LAK cells enabled the otherwise nonimmunogenic B16 cells to induce specific cytolytic activity.     

Differential resistance to growth of a tumor expressing incompatible minor alloantigens reflects regulatory influences rather than differences in anti-minor-CTL-P frequencies

In previous studies it was found that BALB/c (H-2d) was more susceptible than (BALB/c X A)F1 (H-2d X H-2a) to a tumor bearing multiple mismatched minor histocompatibility antigens, the DBA/2 (H-2d) mastocytoma P815, and that this resistance was H-2 linked. In the present studies the immunologic basis of this effect was examined by comparing the cytotoxic-T-lymphocyte (CTL) responses of BALB/c with those of (BALB/c X A)F1. Despite the BALB/c X A)F1's 34-fold greater resistance to P815 in vivo, the numbers of effector cell precursors were found to be similar in the two hosts as shown by (a) similar anti-P815 CTL responses in vitro with T-cell growth factor, (b) similar secondary anti-DBA/2 MiHA responses after in vivo priming with irradiated P815, and (c) similar frequencies of anti-DBA/2 CTL precursors by limiting-dilution analysis. However, priming with proliferating P815 in vivo revealed a defect in the BALB/c animals: Spleen cells from such animals were unable to control the growth of contaminating P815 cells in vitro or to mount strong secondary CTL responses to DBA/2 antigens. The defective priming of BALB/c could be corrected when DBA/2 spleen cells were added to the P815 inoculum. This impaired priming by living tumor cells was not seen in (BALB/c X A)F1. It is concluded that the use of living P815 tumor cells revealed a defect in immunoregulation in BALB/c mice, which rendered them susceptible to tumor growth in spite of apparently adequate numbers of anti-minor-CTL precursors. How the additional H-2 products expressed in the (BALB/c X A)F1 might correct this defect is discussed.     

Natural regulatory cells in murine bone marrow: inhibition of in vitro proliferative and cytotoxic responses to alloantigens

A lymphocyte-enriched fraction of murine bone marrow (BML), obtained by sucrose density fractionation, contains natural regulatory cells that can profoundly suppress the proliferative and cytotoxic response of syngeneic lymph node cells to irradiated alloantigens in a mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC). A close correlation exists between the inhibition of alloantigen-induced proliferation and the generation of cytotoxic effectors. The suppression of proliferation is dependent on the dose of BML added to the cultures but is not due to cell crowding, since red blood cells, thymocytes, and irradiated splenocytes, all syngeneic to the lymph node responders, do not inhibit proliferation to the degree observed with BML. The addition of BML to cultures does not cause the maximum proliferative response to change from the usual day 5 peak, indicating that there is no change in culture kinetics. The release of nonradioactive thymidine by BML cannot explain the suppression. The target of suppression is maximally affected during the first 24 hr of culture, since adding BML to MLC later than this resulted in negligible inhibition of proliferation. Thus, the natural regulatory cell-mediated suppression reflects inhibition of "early" events in the proliferative response to alloantigens.     

Differential expression of alloantigens of the major histocompatibility complex on unfertilized and fertilized mouse eggs

Mouse oocytes at the dictyate and metaphase II stages as well as fertilized eggs have been studied by indirect immunofluorescence for the expression of H-2 histocompatibility antigens on surface membranes. Serologically specific reactivity to H-2 antibody was observed as patchy fluorescence distributed over the surface of the oocyte membrane. In contrast, one-cell zygotes exhibited variable reactivity, and early two-cell stages were negative. Absorption studies confirmed the serologic specificity of the reactivity on oocytes, which could be shown to be due to H-2 antibody. The results suggest that fertilization results in altered expression of major histocompatibility complex surface antigens, and confirms earlier studies that cleavage stage mouse embryos are not reactive with H-2 antibody.     

Differential expression of 240 kDa ConA-binding glycoprotein in vitro and in vivo detected by immunochemical methods

The expression of the 240 ConA-binding glycoprotein (240 kDa), a marker of synaptic junctions isolated from the rat cerebellum, was studied by immunocytochemical techniques in forebrain and cerebellum from rat and chicken, and in chick dorsal root ganglia. Parallel studies were carried out either on tissue sections or in dissociated cell cultures. In all cases non neuronal cells were not immunostained. The tissue sections of cerebellum from rat and chick exhibited 240 kDa glycoprotein immunoreactivity, especially in the molecular layer, while the forebrain sections from rat and chick did not show any significant immunostaining. In contrast, in dissociated forebrain cell cultures, all neuronal cells expressed 240 kDa glycoprotein immunoreactivity, while glial cells remained totally unlabelled. In tissue sections of dorsal root ganglion (DRG), sensory neurons expressed the 240 kDa only after the embryonic day (E 10). A large number of small neurons in the dorsomedial part of DRG were immunostained with 240 kDa glycoprotein antiserum, whereas only a small number of neurons in the ventrolateral part of the ganglia displayed 240 kDa immunoreactivity. In dissociated DRG cells cultures (mixed or neuron-enriched DRG cell cultures) all the neuronal perikarya but not their processes were stained. These studies indicate that 240 kDa glycoprotein expression is completely modified in cultures of neurons of CNS or PNS since the antigen becomes synthetized in high amount by all cells independent of synapse formation. This demonstrates that the expression of 240 kDa is controlled by the cell environment.     

MHC alloantigens elicit secondary,but not primary,indirect in vitro proliferative responses

The relative contributions of direct and indirect pathways of allorecognition to graft rejection remain controversial. Recent reports suggest that the indirect pathway may play a prominent role in both acute and chronic allograft rejection. Such studies suggest that MHC-derived allopeptides are more immunogenic than those derived from minor histocompatibility or other nominal Ags. The aim of this study was to characterize the immunogenicity of MHC alloantigens in MHC-defined miniature swine via primary and secondary MLR culture assays. APCs were selectively depleted from either responder or stimulator cell populations to specifically analyze direct and indirect proliferative responses, respectively. Radio-resistant cytokine secretion and subsequent backstimulation of responder cells was eliminated by using stimulators that were either lysed or unresponsive to the responder MHC haplotypes. When the effect of backstimulation was eliminated from MLR culture assays, indirect proliferative responses were not observed among naive responders. Only after in vivo priming of responder animals could indirect proliferation be detected. These data do not refute the potential importance of indirect allorecognition in graft rejection. However, they suggest that MHC-derived alloantigens behave similarly in vitro to minor histocompatibility Ags, with comparable immunogenicity. These data also suggest that the MLR culture assay does not accurately reflect the importance of indirect mechanisms that have previously been reported in experimental models of graft rejection. A greater understanding of the indirect pathway and the associated immunogenicity of MHC allopeptides has the potential benefit of enabling the development of therapeutic interventions to prevent or halt allograft rejection.     

Cell-mediated immune responses in vitro. II. Simultaneous generation of cytotoxic lymphocyte responses to two sets of alloantigens of limited cross-reactivity.

The conditions for generation of simultaneous and independent cytotoxic lymphocyte (CL) responses to each of two sets of alloantigens of limited cross-reactivity by mouse spleen cells in vitro have been investigated. Responder spleen cells were incubated with mitomycin C-treated C57BL/6 (H-2b) or DBA/2 (H-2d) stimulator spleen cells and day 5 CL responses were assayed with 51Cr-labeled EL-4 leukemia (H-2b) and P815 mastocytoma (H-2d) as target cells. Spleen cells from mice of the various H-2 haplotypes tested differed greatly in their ability to develop specific CL responses against alloantigens on the stimulator spleen cells and in the degree of cross-reactive cytotoxic activity against target cells bearing alloantigens not present on the stimulator spleen cells. In contrast to the other strains examined, DBA/1 (H-2q) spleen cells developed specific CL responses to either H-2b or H-2d alloantigens without exhibiting significant cross-reactive activity on the inappropriate target cell. The CL responses to H-2b and H-2d alloantigens by DBA/1 spleen cells were comparable in magnitude and had similar stimulator cell-dose requirements. Further, DBA/1 spleen cells developed CL responses of normal magnitude simultaneously against both target cells when incubated with both mitomycin C-treated C57BL/6 and DBA/2 stimulator cells.     

Phagocytic cell responses to in vivo and in vitro exposure to the Lyme disease spirochete.

An experimental skin lesion induced in rabbits by the bite of infected adult Ixodes dammini showed dense dermal interstitial inflammatory cell infiltrates composed of mononuclear cells (histiocytes and lymphocytes) and granulocytes. The prevalence of phagocytic cells in this experimental lesion motivated a study on the interactions of macrophages and neutrophils with Lyme disease spirochetes. Interactions as measured by uptake of radiolabeled spirochetes and by indirect immunofluorescence were enhanced by opsonization of spirochetes with immune serum and not significantly decreased by heat inactivation of the same. Phagocytosis was inhibited by treatment of cells with Cytochalasin B. Adherence of opsonized spirochetes to neutrophils was decreased by blocking Fc receptors with heat-aggregated IgG, suggesting an important role for this receptor.     

Regulation of cytotoxic responses to alloantigens by Ia+ cells

Pretreatment of responder spleen cells with anti-Ia plus complement led to an enhancement of cytotoxic responses to alloantigens as well as to TNP-modified self antigens. This observation confirms previous reports that cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) and their precursors (CLP) are Ia^?. Furthermore, it suggests that the CTL responses to alloantigens or TNP-modified self-antigens are regulated by an Ia⁺ suppressor cell. Absorption studies and studies with anti-Ia sera specific for either the entire I region or the I-E/C subregions suggest that the regulatory cell certainly expresses I-E/C-coded determinants although the possibility that it also expresses I-A/B/J-coded determinats cannot be ruled out. Cell-mixing studies suggest that the regulatory cell is Thy-1^? and requires cell division before it can suppress. A clonal assay for CLP was used to show that the enhancement of the CTL response to alloantigens cannot be accounted for on the basis of an increase in the number of CLP in the anti-Ia + C-treated group.